Fallkniven S1 Forest Knife Review: Better Than The F1

#survival #knife #camping #edc
FALLKNIVEN S1 LINKS
Bladehq** shrsl.com/4acqm
Amazon** amzn.to/3FG8BCc
GPKnives** shrsl.com/4acqo
Smoky Mountain Knife Works LINK
www.pjtra.com/t/TUJGR0dMRUJGT...
__________________
Gideonstactical Gear Link Hub: solo.to/gideonstactical
__________________
GT AMAZON STORE AFFILIATE LINK
www.amazon.com/shop/gideonsta...
__________________
LA POLICE GEAR LINK
la-police-gear.pxf.io/DV0b6d
10% Off Your Purchase With Code GTTAC10
_______________
BACKCOUNTRY.COM LINK
alnk.to/gVGQLbW
________________
MOOSEJAW LINK
alnk.to/4Xu7Rm9
________________
Rocky Talkie Link Includes 10% Off Your Purchase!
Rockytalkie.com/GT
___________________
5.11 TACTICAL LINK
511.pxf.io/e4MKDO
________________
MONTANA KNIFE COMPANY LINK
alnk.to/4BEBTMj
________________
GRAYL Water Purifer LINK
alnk.to/dpqvGkY
_______________
SPORTSMANS WAREHOUSE LINK
alnk.to/8iPIHhA
________________
MYSTERY RANCH STORE LINK
alnk.to/60VRWIw
________________
KELTY GEAR STORE LINK
alnk.to/faxgXac
________________
HLTH CODE Meal Replacement Shakes: bit.ly/2PVUUbR
Get 15% Off With Promo Code: EATWITHGT
Paypal Link: www.paypal.com/us/home
Paypal Username: [e-mail]
DO NOT ATTEMPT ANYTHING SEEN IN THIS VIDEO AT HOME. YOU TAKE ALL RESPONSIBILITY AND RISKS WHEN USING, HANDLING, OR ARE OTHERWISE ENGAGED WITH ANY OF THE ITEMS, SCENARIOS, OR TOPICS MENTIONED IN THIS VIDEO.
/ gideonstactical
/ gideonstactical300
/ gideonstactical

[@huntthewild6643]

The sheath is designed to be a bit loose for the simple reason that the blade wont freeze stuck inside the sheath should you get caught out in severe weather and if you live in Scandinavia that is bound to happen. Also all Fallkniven knives come with a factory micro bevel so you can sharpen in the field with a stone. I have the A1, F1 and S1 and have never stropped them and they go razor sharp with just a DC4 stone.

[@stalwart263]

I was just about to post the same thing. The sheath is designed like that for that exact reason. It is an extreme cold weather knife. Kydex can’t handle the levels of cold that this knife is designed for. That’s the same reason the tang is totally enclosed, so your skin doesn’t stick to it. If you don’t intend to go that cold then get the leather or buy a Kydex.

[@stevanoutdoor]

The F1 is the pilot survival knife and it's a last resort knife that has to be small and lightweight. The sole purpose of any pilot survival knife is that you never have to use it, but it's there when shtf. The S1 is the woodsman knife and is intended for using. The leather dangler sheath is nice but it all depends on where you are going. In wet conditions I prefer the plastic (Zytel) sheath. You can actually buy a diamond sharpener that has an adhesive side and glues to the Zytel sheath so you always have a sharpener with you.

[@LordEdricus]

Great review and keep up the good work. The molded plastic sheat from Fällkniven are actually really good for the climate they come from. That is to be able to be used in the winter - 30 c (-22f) kydex will break in those temps. Leather is also good, but kydex in scandinavia is basically trash once it start to freeze.

[@gideonstactical]

Good to know!

[@darrenlamb5640]

I think they're decent as well. Slim profile, strong, nice and light, does the job. It's a very underrated sheath IMO and doesn't really deserve all the hate it gets.

[@lifeline025]

And yea we are regullary outside for a couple hours at -30 using our knives. C'mon that sheat is very bad solution and such a knives deserves much better solution. There is no strenght to hold the knife properly, it is loud and give the knife too much room to move and make the noice. And at the end it is not designed to amaze at all. It is ugly to be honest.

[@momo-hs5jn]

I´m waiting for the day peter will finally get to talk about the sheath...

[@gabehumphries5483]

Awesome video! Great looking knife! Thanks for the review. I think the F1 or A1 with be my next knife purchase.

[@charlieaydin1377]

Man, your videos have gotten so much better. Very professional and always getting better. I love the way you put action videos of the knife performing while you were waffling. Youre waffling is great and is very informative, but its become all the better now with something to watch while youre doing it :) Waffling is Australian for talking alot ;)

[@hubertusvenator5838]

Fällkniven is pronounced "Fellkniven". In the Czech Lands, one may carry a tactical knife as backup for a pistol. The country has a shall issue carry permit law. Knives are unregulated. These Fällkniven knives are excellent for dressing game in the field.

[@seventhSabra]

I love Fallknivens I own a bunch of their A1/S1/F1 series, A1 is my favorite (I got my A1's as a blank without scales, then I did a really nice paracord wrap with lanyard and they ride in a Custom Skystorm (now Patriot) Leather scout sheath. They're easily one of the best survival blades you can buy (Bark River, Fiddleback Forge, and Busse are my other favorites). My F1 and S1's I've bought with micarta scales, costs more but I'm not a fan of the rubbery handle. (Most of your complaints on the F1 are solved by getting the micarta versions and a custom sheath. I also have the Northern Lights series of Fallkniven, the Idun is almost identical to the F1 but with a gorgeous stacked leather handle, it's one of my favorite all-time fixed blades. F1 is perfect for my wife who despite being 5'9", has small hands, feet, and other features. Guys with small hands and most women will like the F1. The S1 is easily in the top 10 of survival blades and easily, then if you factor in the price which is ~$150 ($100 - $250 less than similar size/quality knives) it's that much better... looks cool too.

[@momo-hs5jn]

3:10 Poor Peter, I hate having a discussion with people when they act childish without actually arguing and making points :D

[@enzowarren9832]

My little brother is turning 15, and I’m going to be gifting one of these to him. I think he’ll like it. Thank you for the video!

[@darrenlamb5640]

No doubt he did like it. It's a great knife. If I got one of these back when I was 15 I'd have been stoked.

[@enzowarren9832]

@@darrenlamb5640 He did like it! In fact, he keeps it with him almost 24/7, and uses it for everything from whittling to eating.

[@gibrigg]

Another great and informative video!

[@mikebuono90]

Between the Esee 6 and the S1 which would be the best all around go to. Both seem to have their pro and con ? Any input?

[@survivalmeanders6058]

Thanks for the video. I have been eyeing an s1 for quite some time. Considering the size and shape the most similar knife to mind would be the Gerber Strongarm. Is the ~3x price worth it?

[@marvinrabold5283]

Hi Aaron a nice episode of gideonstactical :D your new intro is amazing ;)

[@Datsyzerberg]

man, dont know how ive never subbed iver the years. overdue. thanks for your great reviews brother.

[@Walterliquori]

looks like a winner love your videos great cameras you must have.great scenery thanks for the work

[@gideonstactical]

Glad you enjoyed it!

[@clifftaylor7889]

Love your steel info.

[@Pavia1525]

A piece (or two) of bike inner tube snug around the sheath area were it clicks in makes it very secure. In fact some inner tube ranger bands fit nicely to hold a lighter or other items. You can put an adhesive sharpening on the other side. When properly modified the sheath works well for everyday carry. In fact you can flip the belt loop over and wear it IWB if you had a need to be indiscreet.

[@ericgarcia5108]

I thought it was nutn fancy at 2:47 for a second there haha, good job on the vid!

[@gideonstactical]

Haha!

[@1891serru]

Fällkniven used to offer kydex sheaths but the soldiers that used them during winter found that the knife got stuck as condensation or water froze in the sheath. Tl:dr, the sheath rattle is intentional.

[@Airik1111bibles]

I really dig the way your editing your videos, rolling in the shots of work while your talking is great. Also putting in the humor and good times while camping out really feels like we're hanging out with ya very cool. I'm seriously glad you took off them gloves cause it really changed my opinion of that handle....I was like OK now thats plenty of room for my hands, with the gloves on it looked tiny. I agree the sheath is crap, and a knife of its price and quality shouldn't be rockin that junk

[@gideonstactical]

Yes fits good in the hand with our gloves, thanks and I am glad you like the way we are moving in our videos.

[@yogililly884]

was considering the Esee Laser Strike (about 25% less) or the esee 5 about same price as S1 at bladehq.... considering overall qualities of steel, handle materials, sheath.... any preference. from a price point I like the Laser Strike but at near same dollar esee 5 over S1 due to handle/sheath?

[@JayBradford]

The S1 is my go to knife when hiking and camping here in Sweden. It's a little too long to be a dedicated hunting knife, although I've used it to process both deer & moose. These days I have an H1 for hunting. I agree with you about the sheath and I prefer the leather dangler that keeps out of the way and has good retention. Anyhow, great review and enjoy!

[@gideonstactical]

Thanks so much, glad you enjoyed it!

[@BOOSTEDLASER]

Not on topic: have you tested ( or plan to) Geigerrig pack or just bladder? Any info on these things, seems impressive

[@ActionHero29]

About the sheath: Who gives a shit if it rattles, it only rattles like that if you shake it hard. I like that zytel sheath except for the nylon portions, they could do much better there and add more lashing options to the sheath (they did for the pro versions). But it's not total trash no.

[@johnhill7585]

Love the Fallkniven knives! My faves are the A1's for bushcraft which are bigger than the S1. I don't like the factory sheaths and get a kydex sheath for all of them.

[@MP-iz7tf]

How does the Master Hunter 3v compare to the S1? Thanks.

[@MrMatthieuC]

Even though they are not the same category, which do you prefer between the Fällkniven S1 and the Esee 6 and why?

[@michaelstjohn6086]

+Matthieu Cramers good question.

[@CabbageYe]

Looks pretty good, might get one

[@maguraboy]

Actually the sheath looks cool and a bit tactical when it is on a belt.It is not classy but sits low at beltline level,it is compact,adjusts when sitting down and very easy to clean.

[@lol567345]

Would you recommand it for hunting?

[@waynesmallwood6027]

Knives were commonly made with convex grinds until WWII, when mass production introduced hollow grinding as a fast method to produce usable blades for the troops. Not a better blade, but faster production. Welcome to America.

[@LukeMorry]

I was MORE than happy to help a brother out and I'd gladly do it again :) Once I'm able to get out into the woods more regularly, I'll definitely get myself another S1. Love the knife but boy do I HATE the sheath lol Don't care what anyone says about it, it just SUCKS lol i look forward to more awesome content in the future and if I've ever got something I think you might wanna have a play with, I'll totally get in touch lol God bless brother and hope you continue to enjoy the blade :D

[@gideonstactical]

+Luke Morry Thank you so much. Getting to work on the Ridgeback asap!

[@darthtrump4428]

hi it has been 4 years, however, you can get a kydex sheath from Armatus Carry Architect

[@nicolas84qc]

your SRK are aus 8 or 1095 carbon version ?

[@Moussieification]

Great review. thnx.

[@lumspond]

2016-2017 catalog states you can buy the S1 with the Zytel, or a leather sheath.

[@silverstacker8282]

Isn't the convex edge difficult to sharpen in the field if you chip it or dull it really bad? Does that kind of out outweigh the benefits of it for field use? Seems like people tend to gravitate back to the tried and true 1095 of the Beckers and Esee line of knives. Kinda the standard by which all others are judged right?

[@ClockCutter]

+Silver Stacker No. Nothing is easier to sharpen in the field than a convex edge. You can do it well with small, 2" x 2" pieces of sand paper and your finger tips. And, if you're just in a hurry, and have something like a ceramic rod, or smooth river rock, you can put a microbevel on it and and reshape the the edge later. I'm sold on the convex edges for field knives, as you might be able to tell. :-)

[@csh6220]

+Silver Stacker If you will simply strop your convex grind BEFORE it gets really dull, in 5 minutes you will have a sharp cutting edge again. If there is a bad chip in the blade, it doesn't matter what steel it is, you will need to put it on a stone or sandpaper. NOTE: with convex and sandpaper, use the stropping technique, and use a mouse pad with some give to it for proper geometry. Check out virtuovice channel and you will learn everything you need to know about convex blades.

[@finnianking2754]

Unbelievable video quality! As always loved the review and knife looks good but Don't know if I can get Fallknivens here in Ireland. Wonder where Luke got his.

[@wartstein8814]

Did you ever try the Enzo Trapper, either in scandi or full flat grind? Quite popular in Europe as a bushcraft knive.

[@UNDERST0RY]

Is the Fallkniven handle on this knife as soft as the handle on a SRK?

[@gideonstactical]

+Cliff Seruntine Harder material

[@jcoopdo]

how the heck do u only have 45k subs? it's insane to me. your one of thee best channels out there man. keep it up

[@gideonstactical]

Thanks so much, it is comments like that which keep me going!

[@jcoopdo]

+gideonstactical you as a person come across honest. I believe you and trust your reviews. most channels seem drivin by alterior motives. but not you. thank you. please Punch Peter in the arm for me love from mn. congrats on Pete forging San Mai up.

[@Adventurer-1971]

Ordering one today

[@Eldofarmboy]

Thanks Aaron, you just made me buy a knife!

[@evolv76]

Thx for the review. Which one would You choose for an outdoor, camp knife: Fallkniven S1 or Swamp Rat RMD?

[@gideonstactical]

I life the S1 a little more in this size range.

[@seanb6986]

I actually agree that the sheath on the S1 is not the best, because unlike the F1 zytel sheath, which provides you with the advantage of having a low profile and the ability to be kept in a pocket, the S1 is a large knife already, which is why I prompt you to always go for the leather dangler sheath option, which is made from high quality leather; unless you are in an arctic climate, of course

[@elwha6025]

I have the S1 with the factory leather dangler sheath and its a VERY good sheath. Now, the knife.......I like the size, the convex edge, pretty much everything EXCEPT the handle is too thin. Not sure why many knife makers don't understand this. I will sell mine as there are others that I feel are better.

[@tantofan6481]

Hopefully some day you can compare the VG10 to the 3G in a Fallkniven. Or I can ;-)

[@owendeane7736]

What blade similar to this would you choose if you had a budget around 100$

[@darrenlamb5640]

Gerber strongarm or cold steel SRK would be my suggestions.

[@dalfredburns9109]

who is the music by?

[@barkriverbravo1]

How do I get a patch ?

[@joeroth7140]

Like butter! Haha great review

[@gideonstactical]

+Joseph Rothenberger Thanks!

[@Onedayilbeok]

I was guna get one of these but went with the Bark River Bravo 1.5 instead.

[@jameshill6872]

The S1 looks like a nice knife.The Fallkniven A1 and the SRK look like the same knife at first glance. That would be a nice comparison video.

[@billyprendergast6631]

GREAT vid guys,but I think Luke wanted you to send the Falkniven S1 on to me,to field dress a couple of Deer.Not a fan of the F1 either,handle way to small.Stay safe guys.

[@kiwi_comanche]

Luke in Northern Ireland. Gimme a shout lad!! I live on the outside of Portglenone Forest here bro. Welcome any time!

[@ronstillwell3942]

makes a good hunting.knife !! first time I really used it a cleaned a buck with it . my knife is over.all black

[@thelasthuntsmanoutdoors]

It seems Fallkniven needs to look at how Esee makes their molded plastic. The Esee ones are so good I like it better than some kydex, and it's not loud and clacky like kydex.

[@gideonstactical]

I would agree with you.

[@PrestonGladd]

If you like the S1, you will love the A1, I have the A1 and F1 paired together and had Red Feather make a custom kydex sheath that allows me to pair the two up, or carry them individually. Either way Fallkniven is a great choice. The pro series is even better as the finger guard is now stainless steel, so holds up better in kydex sheaths and also is more prominent and will provide better protection.

[@gideonstactical]

Wow, very cool!

[@jeffreylane7]

+Preston Gladd A1 rocks!

[@iseskaz]

Wow in 3D!

[@Fritziecola]

Lionsteel m3 in niolox or m5 in sleipner review(60-61hrc).; nice leather sheaths except for risk of cutting leather snap withdrawing blade.

[@garytripp5793]

Worksharp knife sharpener put a good convex edge back on knives

[@bmflmf]

Great vid. I have A1 and F1 Pro, love em. I'm looking forward to your review on A1.

[@Roadbikerider79]

Hi Aaron, great review as always. I have a tip for your next review,Check out Wander tactical knives. Out of all my knives their Megalodon 1.0 is the one i love the most.

[@NorwegianWoods]

Good stuff! Some day I might get myself one of those :) - Martin

[@jcoopdo]

I hear Pete Kohler..yesssss!!!!

[@gideonstactical]

You sure do!

[@Cr0cket20]

When of these days I'll get my hands on one. Good looking blade.

[@gideonstactical]

+Cr0cket20 The A1 is even better. Of the F1, S1, and A1 so far the A1 wins.

[@tantofan6481]

+gideonstactical Did you get the A1 Pro?

[@saffer4774]

+gideonstactical When can we expect an A1 review?

[@Huskymotard88]

I just purchased from a dear friend at a very good price an S1 still with factory edge. I don't know if it's just mine but is quite disappointing, dull and has quite deeper convex on the portion near the edge. Yours in the video looks far better slight saber convex until the edge, was it your factory edge? It seems also have a nice sharp and piercing point. I will have to do an heavy regrind on mine to make it finally looks and perform like yours! Thanks for the video, at least i know it can have the geometry to perform very well! And for the kydex sheath, for me doesn't look so bad even it would have been better one like the Sissipuukko, which is totally ambidextrous and with very good retention with no need for further straps.

[@nils-ph3zs]

yea it has a small secondary bevel on there wich is quite steep. Just sharpen it away, it will be much better

[@steddyk]

I bought this blade a few months ago as a winter beater blade, it's true the sheath is complete garbage. JRE Industries makes a nice leather alternative far nicer than Fallknivens leather option, I picked one up and the knife is now a complete system.

[@silvarredonda1]

Hi Aaron, thanks for this great vid ! I always enjoy your opinion and I'm really looking forward to ear what do you think about the A1, as I reckon it will be the Fällkniven model that better suits your needs and taste (as mine). You're probably aware that the brand has just released their "pro-series". I was very excited about that as they announced that the sheath was being redesigned... but then very disappointed as the overall look is still cheap and ugly (although effective). I own an "old" A1, and was considering buying the S1 pro, as it comes with an improved cobalt laminated steel blade with a steel guard protecting the handle while batonning, for example. Maybe you'll be able to grab one of those in the future and give us your thoughts about it. Again, thank you for your awesome work and have a great 2016 !

[@gideonstactical]

I am just hearing about the pro series and will look into them for sure!

[@johncampbell335]

I've been eyeballing the S1 'Pro' version with the cobalt laminate steel. Not in my budget yet though.

[@briantaylor340]

I just got an S1 and the first thing I did was order a sheath from AzWelke. I wasn't going to let this crappy sheath stop me from buying the knife, I bought it brand new for $135 so spending some on a good kydex sheath wasn't going to deter me.. I'm also a big clip point fan..

[@bdcochran01]

I have the F1 and the A1. A couple of observations. In an urban environment where a person does not wear a knife on a belt in a sheath or on a clip on a pair of blue jeans, how would you carry a fixed blade knife? To make it more difficult, assume that you wear a business suit. Most people would be stumped! Now, if you still have your Fallkniven f1 with the factory sheath, put in your front pocket of your suit pants. Now try to do that with the S1 series knife. Such is how I carry the Fallkniven f1. I tried that with other blades of a similar length and it doesn't work. You already had criticism that the handle on the F1 was designed for cold conditions wherein people wear gloves. Have you tried holding the F1 wearing a pair of gloves. I don't make the comment to be sarcastic and I explain. I fix/modify/restore knives/hatchets/axes/swords. You will see beautiful wood work. Then, when someone uses an axe, he gets blisters. So, I put two layers of tape on hoes/rakes/hatchets/axes/shovels/pick aces. Layer one is cheap electrician tape or the equivalent. Layer two is tennis racket tape. Then a person does not have to wear gloves in the summer or to avoid blisters. Today, literally, it was in the 80s. I had not wrapped the handle of clippers. I got a blister and then had to tape the web of the hand. Now I am going outside and taping the clippers. This is good advice.

[@jwchoidx]

As long as I know from your video, you are a big fan of Gerber Strongarm. I think Fallkniven S1 is a bit larger and heavier than Strongarm, but those are more or less similar size. Anyways, which knife do you think better? (Not thinking of price difference and sheath :) )

[@gideonstactical]

+Jang Won Cho The S1 will have better edge retention and a woods handle with no top guard.

[@silvanigra]

I've used both the F1 and the S1 for the past few years and never had an issue with the sheaths, I think you're exaggerating, you have nothing to worry about. I never thought the sheath was loud {whatever that means in real life!} and I never felt the knife was not secure enough in its sheath. That being said, I do not like convex blades and don't use them much these days.

[@pennsyltuckyreb9800]

Yeah my A1 never has made much any noise at all. When is this guy planning on sneaking up on armed sentries with just a knife in hand? 🙄😁 Even then, your knife would be out of it's sheath...🙃 My gets the same rattle if you shake it in hand like he does but it doesn't rattle like that when it's on your belt or cross strapped to you. Plus, he never researched why these "crap" sheaths exist in the first place. They were designed first and foremost as combat/survival knives for Swedish military who train and operate in extreme Northern climates and winters. It's Zytel so it doesn't crack in subzero temps like Kydex will. Plus, you need that looseness in the sheath so if the knife gets wet it won't freeze solid inside the sheath.

[@pennsyltuckyreb9800]

My biggest gripe about the Fallkniven convex grinds is there's just too much metal behind that edge. Fatty convex. Good for batoning wood but IMO thinning out that metal behind the edge wouldn't affect batoning performance at all.

[@silvanigra]

@@pennsyltuckyreb9800 Exactly! In my knife buying spree period, I bought 3x S1 and 2 x F1 - I like them, they are solid knives, but not for "normal" use. A thinner blade and and a simple flat grind geometry has always proven more useful to me - whether for food preparation, for wood carving, general cutting tasks, etc. Nowadays, I'm back to simple folders, like the Buck 110 or some European Nieto folders - coupled with a Victorinox SAK, they are more than enough for the average outdoorsman, camper, hiker, etc. They slice incredibly well and with proper maintenance, they last for decades. No need for "Rambo" knives in real life.

[@tindra98765]

The laminated VG10 steel is replaced by a laminated cobalt special steel (Lamb CoS) on the new A1pro....BUUUUUUUYYYYYYYYYYY IT !

[@TKDLION]

I looked into the Fallkniven brand a couple of years ago and the S1 is the only one of their knives I ended up buying. It's a good knife, but the handle is mediocre. I chose the leather sheath.

[@shcmoly]

Always admired their knives but steel vs price, just haven't pulled the rigger yet. I see why you hate the sheath, SRK's is pretty awesome. Nice size for a survival knife, also light enough to backpack.

[@dr.stevenpennym.d.3241]

VG-10 is a poor man steel. It's rated in the middle of most charts. They now make the S1X in Cobalt steel. 60 Rockwell.

[@nils-ph3zs]

its good for the kitchen tho

[@pinkbrisingr78]

Nice review Aaron! I think to stick with my SRKs for the money, for sure. I didn't like the F1 either & sold it for the same reasons you gave. Take care man. Still watching almost all your vids & you keep me going with making mine!

[@michaelstjohn6086]

+JOEY AlphaBladeReviews SRK coming in CPM!

[@pinkbrisingr78]

No kidding???

[@pinkbrisingr78]

Michael StJohn which cpm??

[@pinkbrisingr78]

Michael StJohn probably 3v since they have a good heat treat recipes for it already

[@michaelstjohn6086]

Look up SRK on BHQ.

[@TheRunereaper]

I bought an S1 a couple of years ago and was disappointed that the convex grind was not symmetrical. It was changed free of charge but there was still an inconsistency in the grind on the new one which I've now lapped out. The VG10 is still prone to chipping though not as bad as when the knife was new. This tendency to chip has dented my confidence in its ability not to break under heavy shock loading. You're right about the locking detent on the thermorun sheath and I now have a leather one. It is a beautiful knife but I think my money would have been better spent on a homogenous blade steel like the Bravo 1 in A2, I can't afford the CPM3-V. I may well try the affordable Mora Garberg when it's available (even though the blade is a scandi grind). Thanks for a good post.

[@farstrider79]

just got mine....oh yes.

[@bdcochran01]

If you don't like a rattle in a sheath, put in cotton balls or a piece of cloth. Moreover, if you have a fixed blade knife with a little space in a cordura or material sheath, put in a small piece of wood or cloth at the bottom. Then start thinking about why some sheath makers have plastic inserts in their sheaths. And also think about why true sword makers and sword sheath makers use wood material for a sheath instead of leather/cordura.

[@csh6220]

I have seen all of your videos, and should know this, but... have you any experience with Bark River knives. BR knives have convex grinds as well, and several steel types to choose from (A-2, 3V, etc). I believe a convex grind is superior to all other grinds for strength and sharpness. Stropping on leather before they become really dull will keep them sharp in the field. BR and Fallkniven are both fairly expensive, but worth it, with BR having the better sheath (high quality leather) by far. I want to buy one or the other, either the S1 or BR Bravo 1.25. Any suggestions? Anyone?

[@ActionHero29]

+csh 62 I've had a Bravo 1.5 and the handle is really comfortable (all the same on the Bravo's). I have an F1 and I love it also, so I disagree with Aaron on that (to each's own). Both are proven top notch knife series from top notch manufacturers. I would not hesitate for either of them.

[@grunde73]

Have 4 BRKs and the quality control of the production doesn't match the price. None of the knives was sharp out of the box (came with a microbevel). They also all had uneven blade grinding (shows up when you sharpen the knife), the fit of the scales and pins are not impressive and (worst) the edge of my Aurora rolled terribly when removing bark from a stick on the first outing... I love the design and all the options on the BRKs. But the lack of quality control is for me simply unacceptable. Will not buy more...

[@ActionHero29]

grunde73 They have a lifetime waranty so if you're unhappy with your Aurora you can contact Mike Stewart and explain your issue. I'm sure they will help you. Problem solved.

[@grunde73]

+Sharpblade since I live overseas the lifetime warranty is pretty much a moot point for me. Will probably cost me close to a 100$ just in shipping. Also I can fix these issues myself, and they are still useful knives. I'm just not at all impressed with the fit and finish and lack of quality control on the knives. For the price I simply expect more...

[@lumspond]

I thought that was a home made sheath from a vacuum nozzle LOL😂

[@gideonstactical]

Good one!

[@nonjaninja4904]

Review the Kizlyar Sensei.

[@jmora1914]

I don't like the s1 bcz of the testing of it by survivor Lilly video review. Check that review of this knife. It chips under regular survival use Lilly put it through. The Falkniven knives are imho just a hype behind the knives. I've seen the A1 Pro hilt come loose and the blades chip and roll. Don't personally recommend Falkoven. But a cold steel SRK 3v that's a much better knife

[@a.a.6132]

I am not a fan of laminated steel. VG10 is not the best steel for a survival knife. CPM-3V or a any descent carbon steel is a better choice.

[@Mrplacedcookie]

I have had them all and FOR ME the S1 is my least favorite of the bunch. To large for finer stuff and to small for heavier stuff. A1 and F1 is the combo for me.

[@MIIIB]

I had the A1XB with leather sheath and dangler. Right now using a mora garberg in cross Sheath for quick access and easy carry and fine work. I can do batoning with the mora but that it's the work of the a1x, so my edge its linger in the mora. I been thinking in NL5 or something little cheaper like the s1x as Garber substt

[@Player_Review]

At that pricepoint, you could almost buy a Bark River, which is obviously the superior option.

[@grunde73]

Quality control on Fallkniven is imho much better than BRK. I have 3 Fallkniven and 4 BRKs, and all the BRKs have quality issues.

[@seanb6986]

Fallkniven knives are easier to sharpen, but Barkies have lifetime warranty.... nah, I like my Fallkniven better

[@roughroosterknifesharpenin5531]

The cold steel don't hold a candle to a fallkniven.

[@Olzone2]

uou know the backside of blade is for firesteel...

[@miketsaron7284]

There is new S1 called S1 pro .... Better steel and handle.. Take a look

[@gideonstactical]

It's on my radar

[@seanb6986]

It hilarious that you didn’t like the Fallkniven F1 because of the handle, yet the S1 has literally the same exact handle! Hahaha

[@SteveSmith-sd5hq]

The S1 handle is longer and thicker, so that's not true.

[@mastermoe1988]

agreed, moreover what really confuses me is that the small scale and fine woodswork activities he starts off with testing the knife are all categories in which the F1 is so much better...

[@BrothersCinco]

I think he reviewed the F1 based on hype and not objective utility. That's my impression anyways. The problem is that the F1 is marketed as a "survival" knife when it's really a just small utility knife that's meant to be the only option for Swedish pilots in a total FUBAR situation.

[@GaryHorn]

Let's not forget "right-hand-carry" only, which disqualifies it immediately.

[@GluttonforPunishment]

+Gary Horn That's what custom sheaths are for.

[@GaryHorn]

+IMightBeWrong For those of us lefties with limited funds, needing to buy a sheath reduces the value of the knife.

[@GluttonforPunishment]

Gary Horn I understand that, but in my mind the knife performs so well for it's price point already that it offsets it. I am a righty and I would invest in a custom sheath myself. I think it's worth it.

[@Arfwid]

+Gary Horn well Fallkniven's homepage does offer left-hand-carry sheaths. I don't know but I suppose that you can choose a left-hand option when purchasing.

[@sonfoku73]

if u have enough money for this knife u probably have enough for a 60$ CUSTOM sheath

[@seanb6986]

That’s not a convex knife, it has a v-edge micro bevel...

[@aussiecue]

$400 for VG10 ?

[@nils-ph3zs]

180

[@KevinThomascolorado]

Luke I want to be your friend

[@captnaidy6122]

Great review as always, I totally agree the sheath is rubbish. You would think they would provide a better one with the price being on the top end. PEACE :-)

[@jamesritchie6899]

A clip point is the worst for prying. It isn't very good for stabbing, either. It's made for carving. God, I hate seeing anyone beat a good knife with a club. Buy a blasted hatchet.

[@clifftaylor7889]

That's not a hammer bro, it's an ice breaker