FAMU vs JACKSON vs NCAT - I KNOW Comparison Producer Request Reaction Review | Steven Holiday

[@nailchronicleswithchitchat4455]

I love the compilation of the bands! You can clearly hear the distinctive styles of each band.

[@AB_1211]

Yes! Bring this back, Steven! This reminds me of the comparisons that bandheads and random ppl used to do 10-12 years ago("Neck" was a popular one). These prefaced the reaction videos you see now and was always fun to hear the different arrangements from the various HBCU bands. I miss those! Bring it back, Steven!

[@keithyounger9397]

S.B. No doubt has the best version clearly! You can hear all the parts of the band including woodwinds, mellows, dog team, T-bones, and the melodies! The trumpet runs is sick!!

[@seanlewis1011]

idk if its just mean but i can't really hear they woodwinds at all

[@Yamama288]

Out of tune ahh wws

[@keithyounger9397]

@@Yamama288 You wish, are you a band instructor, Not! Shut the hell up?

[@aquarianmystic889]

Jackson State had the most dynamic and memorable version of this song.

[@g4werkzgenesisparts556]

Ha ha the most dynamic? I mean do you even know what dynamics mean? Clearly we understand opinions but Facts or facts

[@March-1-1]

NCAT, JSU, FAMU

[@AyeNikki789]

I just like JSU arrangement better. So for me JSU, FAMU, NCAT

[@ayojones8669]

FAMU 🧡💚🧡💚🧡💚 Didn't know what JSU was playing but NCAT was str8

[@dolodaero]

JSU the best version of the song. The dark sound. This and Thank God were unmatched arrangements from Jackson.

[@the._.turman1284]

Jsu i know is messy

[@dolodaero]

@@the._.turman1284 😂😂😂 A&T version is sloppy and badly executed. Famu version is only a phrase of “I know”

[@j_y06]

@@dolodaeroyall love to down another band’s arrangement just to uplift another. that’s yall probably now 😭

[@big_reece8632]

JSU’s intro alone is tougher than the other versions . So it’s JSU , NCAT, then FAMU . JSU actually writes all their music so I like the creativity and interpretation of the songs they right . When you play it directly like the radio version it gets boring .

[@mrbigwill007]

I think you should do Halftime Battle from the Celebration Bowl NBOY including FAMU & HU.

[@user-di7bt8rv9c]

NCAT, JSU, & FAMU.

[@jessetownsend2287]

JSU all day everyday and twice on sunday

[@chantalfleming9439]

NCAT JSU FAMU

[@BFRESH1]

JSU all day

[@wadiya14]

NCAT, JSU, Famu

[@j_y06]

Ncat. Trombone section leader did his big one with that and the results were great

[@eddiemoore7356]

JSU WON

[@abramking7164]

As a musician, here's the immeasurable difference in sound: the acoustics based of stadium configuration and microphone location.

[@Yamama288]

Only real characteristic is famu blowing and sounding better OUTSIDE

[@abramking7164]

​@@Yamama288 Hence the reason for my comment. I went to Hampton, so I don't have a dog in the fight.

[@bervina6438]

jsu, famu, ncat imo

[@left_lane__legends9175]

The difference is clear.

[@Bandhead-gf4ot]

For me. I loved A&T arrangement. Trombones were 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 JSU power 🔋 💪

[@420virgo]

Aggies💙💛@Bgmm all day

[@travvytravv6488]

Love the mix at the end!! #HBCUnity great job by all bands!!

[@rob428956]

JSU all around had the best version!

[@jericoyouharrison9748]

Famu definitely got this one

[@Dancegirl9-zr2nf]

NCAT❤❤❤❤

[@Yamama288]

Famu, JSU, NCAT JSU tubas sound thin during that break 🛼🛼

[@honestsagittarius4566]

But let JSU fans tell it their tubas are monsters 🧢🧢

[@LynnHarris-zq2or]

Like we care what you or the 🤡think

[@LynnHarris-zq2or]

@@honestsagittarius4566like we care what you think

[@honestsagittarius4566]

@@LynnHarris-zq2or well if you didn’t you could have politely scrolled your bothered ass pass my comment then hunny bun

[@Yamama288]

@@LynnHarris-zq2or i mean you replied twice so…. If u mad Famu recruited all the real tuba players its ok. JSU tubas play glorified baritone anyway. Youll get some more soon its ok

[@shanigurl]

FAMU has the best and most recognizable version.

[@aol15]

Now imagine if they invited the bands from the Celebration Bowl to that event..... we would've hand this comparison live!

[@AB_1211]

Would have been nice! #HBCUbands

[@jheht2000]

JSU cutting through NCAT piss poor arrangement was the highlight of the night 😩

[@naomiiii9503]

it’s 2024 and you high off the coke mfs still seething about that 😭

[@307kingslide]

Was it? I thought it was JSU losing 🌚

[@SE-wf2ys]

Can’t call that a “cutting through” moment when they were on a tuba break. If the whole band was playing then that would be different

[@jheht2000]

@@307kingslide Try again if you think that shitty arrangement was hitting 😆

[@jheht2000]

@@SE-wf2ys We bully y’all boys. NCAT can’t sit with us. Get y’all weight up and stop all that damn 🛼

[@DerrickDBerry]

Famu, NCAT, JSU. Famu’s arrangement was full from beginning to end and I like both NCAT and JSU bands. Good comparison but the 100 was more aggressive and I liked the upbeat tempo. All three bands played clean without overblowing.

[@partyhq4054]

The 100 was giving potato salad with raisins

[@tedwilliams185]

I got Famu, NCAT, JSU

[@jbabylove2]

The "White Whales" FAMU 4 the Wbbbb...

[@Chicosuave305]

FAMU love the sound!!

[@izrealcary7860]

JSUs Sonic BOOM of the South 🌟

[@ehenicks]

FAMU, A&T, JSU

[@TaeW-bj7hu]

JSU by far the best

[@RealBron03]

JSU and this is no competition

[@jheht2000]

AT ALL‼️

[@jericoyouharrison9748]

Please famu sounds better and the trumpets actually hit the screaming notes and didn’t skate or have to slow the song to do it and the tubas on famu have a much better sound

[@jheht2000]

@@jericoyouharrison9748 Let it go…FAMU is not match to “THEE”😎

[@RealBron03]

@@jericoyouharrison9748 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 famu band don't even belong in the conversation let alone in the SWAC band wise

[@aol15]

Yeah.... the 100 took this one..... but all three were 👍🏿 That trombone Stack from A&T was 🔥

[@avanterivers3699]

A&T surprised me with this one. I really like their arrangement. FAMU, NCAT, JSU

[@gwenturner5414]

Jackson State has a better interpretation of the song. Period.

[@thatcat41]

INTERPRETATION 🤣 Yea cuz that didnt even sound like the song.

[@deangelodesoto]

JSU⚡️

[@KrashDummy-hp3kb]

Gonna go with NCAT!

[@kentrelt5140]

JSU has the best version. Anyone who knows JSU knows that rap tunes are their niche. U will never win a rap battle against jsu. Famu is never good at rap tunes. It just doesn't fit who they are. They tend to turn rap songs into a orchestra which does not reflect the meaning of the song. Ncat was okay but not aggressive and full as JSU. JSU showed aggression, musicality, dynamic, power, crescendo etc. All that makes for a great rap tune.

[@JP-ll4yk]

Crazy, fam. FAMU (to me) is the most aggressive out of the three!!

[@JP-oh6mh]

On a whole, I agree. However, I think SWAC fans have routinely underestimated them by painting them as the "flight of the bumblebee band." Huge mistake. They can (and will ) do almost anything well.@jjnotwatt448

[@amoore1981]

Jackson state arrangement is better

[@letitbang6]

Famu version is better to me

[@Carla-c6s]

A&T arrangement 🔥🔥🔥. You can hear every section. Trombones 🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@packman0439]

JSU. Another level

[@sspann11]

Boom. NCAT. FAMU.

[@shatawnslater5710]

FAMU for the win

[@g4werkzgenesisparts556]

Famu Ncat JSU (this is surprising cause I expected to pick them first)

[@big_reece8632]

They are first what you talking about lol

[@JP-ll4yk]

1) FAMU, 2)A&T, 3) JSU. In the mashup, FAMU’s parts are most aggressive and groovy…

[@dball-cq2pe]

Jsu plays at a slower tempo so that their notes can be blown harder and longer. Def. A NO! A&T??? alway sounds decent.. but FAMU brought out all parts of that song and not just one section of it🤷🏾‍♂️

[@manyeah04]

😂

[@terryburney545]

Disagree with that, JSU sounds way better then the both of them and you know it

[@dball-cq2pe]

@@terryburney545hol up!! PUT IT IN REVERSE TERRY!!!... 🤣🤣... Quit playing man .. they sound like good hot garbage bruh 🤣 🤷🏾‍♂️.. Famu may not be as loud but they Damn sure ain't loud and raggedy like Jackson.

[@dball-cq2pe]

@@terryburney545 🤣🤣maaaan you come straight out of a comic book 🤦🏾‍♂️🤣🤣🤣

[@terryburney545]

@@dball-cq2pe you know that ain’t true, you are a hater is what it is. I can omit that all three bands sound good but JSU is better and well balanced, to say they are garbage is foolishness, you wish your school play like them is what it is, and the reason you hating. Stop it fam because it doesn’t look good on you.

[@partyhq4054]

All bands sounded good, A&T had a better groove provided by Cold Steel

[@keithyounger9397]

F.A.M.U had some major tempo issues with the woodwinds!!

[@thatcat41]

🤣

[@jericoyouharrison9748]

They don’t you just can’t hear woodwinds from other band so you not use to someone cranking while in mono tone and hearing the woodwinds most bands you can barely hear the trumpets let alone every section

[@keithyounger9397]

@@jericoyouharrison9748 What white mankool aid your dumb ass been drinking and don't know the flavor! I played and wrote and my own music and different parts for my section! What dumb ass black people don't know, they don't understand! So do your research before you come at me with that stupid remark boy! Black people have an opion like an asshole, some stink, others I don't Give a F***kk!!!

[@Tri.dawg1]

1.Jsu, 2.FAMU,3. NCat tempo issues was too Notice 💯🫱🏼‍🫲🏽

[@naomiiii9503]

who had tempo issues?

[@jerronjohnson]

@naomiiii9503 there were no tempo Issues

[@Tri.dawg1]

@@naomiiii9503 NCat probably not temp but trumpets had some flat notes

[@naomiiii9503]

@@Tri.dawg1 So did jsu

[@naomiiii9503]

@@jerronjohnson oh I know

[@jerronjohnson]

NCAT,JSU, FAMU

[@eddiemoore7356]

JSU WON

[@jbabylove2]

The "White Whales" FAMU 4 the Wbbbb...