FANMADE VS OFFICIAL - Ethereal Workshop Wave 5 (ANIMATED)

[@NovaMSM]

What do you think of the Wave 5 monsters? The critter perk is no longer in the Founder tier and has since been moved to the Patron tier for those who were curious.

[@PotbellyMaggie]

very nice

[@SpikezMSM]

they are amazing!

[@mofixprouductions]

where am i

[@NovaMSM]

@@mofixprouductions 1:37

[@therealGecko_KingYT]

they're pretty good

[@Hanzo2050]

Remember that time in a community post when nova said: “Keep being creative!”? BBB just did that with Rhysmuth

[@3dchomper]

I mean all of the ethereal workshop monsters are creative

[@Vhenshun_Inc]

@@3dchomper yea

[@datironpanda2982]

​@Zachfriese1234Honestly it's nitebear for me (as in only it's sound)

[@achillesemmanuelmartinez7770]

Where is it

[@marysineni984]

they went into creative mode and built rysmuth👀

[@aimonishe]

Community: trying to make melody for this island BBB: MØŔÈ PÊŘĆŨŞŜĪØŅ

[@jecobi]

If the quint is a percussionist we riot

[@Kalverite]

@@jecobishould be both

[@AIRYHFJONEIRL]

​@@jecobi hey

[@JRicardoTorres3752]

​@@jecobiI came from the future The quint is both vocalist and percussionist

[@FreddyfrickinFazbear]

I wonder if Rhysmuth, Mohzzaik, and Perplexray are all friends. Crystal quad❌ Crystal trio✅

[@_AnCub_]

Crystal quad trio

[@Maxwellcat-c9k]

They all already friends ( idk )

[@Boiky_Cheezooks]

Both are really good! Mohzzaik adds a nice melody whilst Rhysmuth adds nice percussion

[@GodzillabattlesSML]

Yeah they're the same but only the sound

[@AlcalaMSM]

Extremely well edited, In my opinion.. I think both of them are equally as good. i feel extremely bad that you have to make all of these critters 😭good luck!

[@leoneo4444]

how do you feel bad, nova makes them and earns $20

[@lmaobrae_wut]

​@@leoneo4444animating

[@leoneo4444]

@@lmaobrae_wut That's the only thing nova animates for his channel

[@AlcalaMSM]

i mean 20 dollars is 20 dollars tbf 🤷‍♂️​@@leoneo4444

[@AlcalaMSM]

well $20 is $20 🤷‍♂️​@@leoneo4444

[@RealTD715]

I think they’d be the best of friends

[@dinoboiis8147]

I honestly do prefer Rhysmuth’s design. It is a big contrast to Jeeode’s more organic crystal shape becoming more geometric and artificial like it has been created. Also it’s sound being BREAKcore is very funny.

[@_AnCub_]

Bismuth in real life doesn't exist for you or what

[@RainbowKidTeeHee]

@@_AnCub_?

[@Lunaaa-k1f]

@@_AnCub_ ?

[@TheSweetestWatermelon]

​@@_AnCub_ What're you on about? They never said anything like that...

[@justa_user]

I think @@_AnCub_ means that dino is saying how bismuth is a real thing that isnt artificial, but then again, I really don't care about that :/ I just like how rhysmuth came out :P

[@cjs2020]

0:11 epic rap battle

[@its-grumpyre]

1:28 critter island when?

[@YogurtEnjoyer5611]

I love the critter intermissions so much It’s like the Super Bowl half time show for me

[@larrymantic2635]

With no sicko mode

[@MarzFromMars]

agreed

[@Apillarchasefan]

Minecraft guy

[@ChillgrayTheFlower]

Mine diamonds

[@Djyndkgy]

💀

[@Jonah_Gallegos]

Terraria guy 💀

[@ibraahimdureng7482]

Looks more like CubeWorld.

[@Sadme_Cakot]

I call him Mr. Quraz block

[@MyNameIsDefinitelyDash]

2:12 that purple dude sound SOOO GOOOOOOD

[@MinecraftCreeper1]

His name is Snarlequinn, he's the fanmade Shadow Quad

[@Blue_Remix]

mohzzaik looks like it would be concept art for it imo for some reason-

[@_AnCub_]

True

[@wublixion]

Can't wait to see you and exclaims quint prediction!

[@OctopusMarkMSM]

Imagine that at some point, Nova has to make a whole zoo, just for the critters

[@Hyehehe_Gamer]

Both are good, both look AND sound good

[@Maxwellchaos7439]

Im gonna be honest having both the official monsters and your fanmade ones makes the song sound so heavenly. I honestly can't listen to the official song without hearing your monsters. please keep it up!!

[@jcoleman4769]

I'm sorry Nova in my opinion I think rhysmuth better just brings the that dubstep Cool vibe to Workshop still like your prediction on the crystal quad

[@milobusterz3280]

Yeah, I really like mohzzaik but they only play once and don’t help the song much

[@_AnCub_]

Also, Rhysmuth looks more crystal-looking

[@Badgersuchus]

i really like the *concept* behind rhysmuth but mohzzaiks sound is so tasty ALSO GOOD LUCK WITH ALL THE CRITTERS 😭THERES SO MANY NOW

[@twitchyeyess]

Omg the critters have a lil terrarium! Thats so cute!!!

[@SGRaichu9829-w2j]

Absolutely chef’s kiss! Well done! 👍

[@daviatiliomedeirosdossanto1399]

I really love seeing your content, I love your editing, I wanted to see how you make the videos and where you do them, you inspired me (I don't even know what lol), in fact, one question, are you going to make a quit prediction?

[@chaurbano1425]

New best friend😊 4:08

[@justintran16228]

yay, a new Mozart VERSUS Minecraft-Styled Guy

[@idek.737]

The 1 dollar i sacrificed was worth it

[@irmaosmm1221]

3:14 start the best track.

[@milobusterz3280]

I really like mohzzaik, but rhysmuth BEATS them by a bit for me, because Mohzzaik only plays once and doesn’t contribute too much, and Rhysmuth plays a lot and helps the song transition and stuff

[@PotbellyMaggie]

1:15 finally i get to be in a nova video. i feel good now

[@naren2379]

Congrats man!

[@PotbellyMaggie]

thx

[@cjxander9205]

Looks heavily based on clydestalk a fanmade monster but I like that about it

[@PotbellyMaggie]

@@cjxander9205 oh i just now realised that. i totally forgot that monster existed

[@TonyBamBoni]

I honestly like your prediction better because it adds more melody to that section!

[@IkaroSoares-hb2ji]

Man I don't even know where you keep making these absolutely wonderful monsters like holy damn I know they're not going to be any monsters on the game but it's still cold as hack I love your videos❤

[@cherryparadox]

Honestly I’ve been wondering what you were gonna do with the new verse since it’s vibe is completely different from the prediction one! I get why the prediction quads don’t play in it since clutter obviously but a part of me was expecting them to since it seems like that verse is gonna have EVERY monster playing in it

[@Kilometersarescarytoamericans]

I like how all the monsters are lined up they have the fan made and official monsters together

[@yapalcri]

I imagined ethereal Workshop was gonna get some type of jungle beat y'know? Just the type of rhythm i expected. It cant top the fact that mohzzaik fills out that whole verse so good with snarlequinn but still y'know,I hope next ways are gonna add melodically to the song as its really needed and its what mohzzaik does

[@americaardon6783]

all of them are super good in a lot of ways

[@AveragealienWhocosplays-gj2tg]

I think the monsters this wave were awesome but yours was epic too Also I love how you make custom critters for patron tier

[@EthanGayles]

I have no favorites, BUT COMBINE THEM, YOU GET THE ULTIMATE LIFEFORM

[@Fightcools]

I've started to notice something, each quad has 1 more track then the last Whaill (1 at release) Vhenshun (2) Pentumbra (3) Rhysmuth (4) So the poison quad *might* have 5 tracks (though unlikely unless another instrumentalist- but the pattern has been vocalist instrumentalist [repeat])

[@_AnCub_]

I think 5 tracks would be better for quint

[@NoahWow]

Yeah! I actually realised that yesterday, we must have the same minds!

[@ManOfHam11]

Ima say something, you were spot on on the last verse

[@Vhenshun_Inc]

I've been waiting for this

[@WubboxArtist]

THEY ARE BOTH FIRE 🔥🔥🔥

[@buzzingzzap]

I don't want ethereal workshop to end, I wanna see more prediction and fanmade monsters :(

[@gun3213]

1:55 Wait a minute, one of the monsters disappeared.

[@malikosama743]

Oh we gettin the fight

[@shizentekinadawn3902]

Oh? The previous two have new animations? Didn’t see that coming!

[@VillagerMSM_Cool]

These two look really cool😅

[@zaidenandgiana]

Unrelated Question: when did you and exclaim plan on making twisted ethereals?

[@Random_McRandomface]

While I prefer Pentumbra and X'rt's sounds and designs, I prefer Mohzzaik to Rhysmuth in every way!

[@Cindy-kb3xu]

I absolutely LOVE mohzzaik! Also, what type of brass instrument does he use? I'm kinda dumb

[@kylesun9187]

Bro that ain’t a brass instrument that’s a full ensemble (btw you’re not dumb)

[@Buzzblade146]

1. The ethereal quint will probably be the most absurd percussion 2. The ethereal quint could also be like mohzzaik, because, well, it is ethereal.

[@brittanyoliver7056]

🤩 wow

[@brittanyoliver7056]

🫶🏾🎃😻

[@Buzzingafan]

I actually like them both,but if i had to choose one,i'd definitely go with mohzzaic,i love the design and its sound A LOT!!! But nonetheless both of them are amazing! Even in the full song THEY ARE AMAZING! great job as always nova!

[@tubg.atau.det6507]

Nova, could you add one of your Monsters play in the final verse AND make a Fanmade Quint?

[@Cursed-triggered]

I really wish that the crystal mirror dude played more, it sounds epic

[@Sundae_Remix]

Your monsters are unironically better by quite a bit, maybe not snarlequinn, but the shadow quads I think are about equal

[@ReidIsReid]

I like yours better because we needed a horned instrument on Ethereal Workshop!

[@Schrobenius_Avindor]

Breakcore

[@slink4239]

Yes.

[@noobseemswrong]

Errm, it’s called the brass family. 🤓

[@DIZ365]

HEY DONT HATE ON RITHMUTH HES MY FAVORITE MONSTER

[@silllyven]

yeah there's too much percussionists in workshop (also not really a reasonable opinion but mohzzaik looks more official than rhysmuth ngl)

[@juliebarthel6993]

2:46 vhenshun track 2 and rhysmuth keep playing go hard in this verse

[@MsmKevinBR]

Nova I'm not going to lie to you but your crystal quad was better than the original❤

[@TheStarGazers-dm4lg]

Could I use your monsters in a fan made project that I’m working on?

[@Itscatgamingpero]

I cant hear the opossum thingy :

[@phuditanfield2385]

1:51 I paused here at 07 : 52 o clock (I’m gonna be here for a while)

[@phuditanfield2385]

I came back at 15 : 26 o clock

[@DDOMSM]

I prefer yours by FAR I personally think Rhysmuth is the worst Ethereal Quad so far. its not terrible, but its not good

[@Idoesgaming-kl9pp]

rizz muth

[@NOT-IXEVR]

Minecraft vibes

[@SpikezMSM]

Awesome video!!

[@TheOrbGrindIsPrettyOrby]

🔥 QUARTZ BLOCK VS CRACKED MIRROR 🔥 But for real, I love the both of them!

[@aldenmendoza84648]

This is awesome and the pets are cute😊 (Btw I like and sub your channel :])

[@spiritblox1]

The dropoff in sound between yieyie and x’rt is hysterical

[@spiritblox1]

Also uh Pentumbras not playing its animations in the final bit

[@repulsiverutabaga7014]

X'rt'd win

[@gizmo835]

@@repulsiverutabaga7014 X'rt would have = X'rt'd've

[@random-guyXD]

X'rt'd'ven't

[@bradywright4850]

Finally It’s set to public

[@champgaming5936]

Yours are all way better imo. Great job Nova!!!

[@striderloki5080]

Man, I hope the next Poison Quad will be like Mohzzaik. WE NEED A HEAVY INSTRUMENT IN THE OFFICIAL WORKSHOP SONG!!!

[@JRicardoTorres3752]

It was a percussionist

[@oshz-chan2680]

Dawg I gotta be honest yours is so much better as of sound

[@JudeahTalon]

I like the fan made we already have a lot of beats and would be cool if we had a monster made with interesting music😊

[@jush8395]

How did you predict the color scheme correctly

[@Bread_Ginger]

This is just a M A S T E R P I E C E

[@Jonah_Gallegos]

How do you edit?

[@MRHOPE5394]

??????

[@ThomasSun-tq1xi]

I just realized something, when someone makes a Fanmade monster, they usually follow the rhythm, however real Monsters make their own individual sounds. Fanmades Add on, Real monsters make the rhythm itself. If you make a fanamde monster, and you want it to be realistic, actually make its own individual sound. Also on the same topic, That’s why It takes MSM long to make a monster, they have to Make something original.

[@TrickyCookie780]

Bro, the two monsters look really expensive🤯🤯

[@abondvd8241]

I feel like the final verse of the main song is a bridge to your final verse.

[@Booklogical]

[@galysworld3665]

Critter Station Is unlocked

[@RubyGania-oz8df]

At the final verse you can hear pentumbra's first track

[@TaraBarch-qh4fb]

ITS HERE!

[@Autumn_guy]

Hmmm, can I trade using them? Edit, nova plz respond to this, you know your crystal quad prediction, in the final bit of its, track, what is that instrument called? Plz tell me I'm dying to know🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@phuditanfield2385]

1:51 I ended day 1 at 21 : 33 o clock

[@phuditanfield2385]

I started day 2 at 06 : 57 o clock

[@arnelabad532]

I think we have enough beats to ethereal workshop but we definitely need the fanmade in wave 6

[@haroldwai6966]

Has nobody noticed that the fanmade shadow quad (i forgot the name)has new animations

[@QuinzyBateman]

I kiiiiinda prefer Mozzhaik over Ryhsmuth. Ryhsmuth is amazing and all, but Mozzhaik has so much personality and so much more going on. It also even has the clock ticking sound people and I myself have been wanting since very early on! Although I'm not disappointed in what Ryhsmuth has to offer, I still really like what they've done with Mozzhaik 💜💜

[@pablovalle-8241]

Nova we need your poison quad and the quint! They are awesome! So please release them soon🥺❤

[@challeger3.0_ebm]

The snarlequinn dance was the most fun

[@ToeDDSMSM]

They are very much the same man 🤯

[@michellefeno3335]

I like them both I can’t deside

[@stephaniebeason7769]

I kinda wanna see a nova msm prediction vs a ghostympa prediction cuz mohzzaik vs perplexray eould be cool

[@jjhhh4609]

Love em both！🎉🎉🎉

[@rozimanwahid2205]

I like the second monster you made

[@eduardomontellano7918]

How do we show a monster on the screen? How are you doing that?

[@ConnorNilson]

Why does having all of them slap even harder than before, cuz to me it does?

[@hobocat_]

I like how the real ones turn out to be Opposite to yours like Shadow you went Music box and the real one was a Vocal Crystal quad was Horns and the real one was Dubstep

[@michaeltabarroni70]

Cool iteration, should have had everyone play at the end to keep like in the original song though

[@RESSATT_vIII]

Mirror guy or Minecraft guy?

[@anthonytheyelmet9636]

Rest in piece the fan made final verse