Fantano REACTION to "Imaginal Disk" by Magdalena Bay

[@valence7]

Fantano reacts to the Album of the Year

[@CyranoForever101]

Nah, album is mid. Mercurial World is so much better

[@smh8123]

@@CyranoForever101 HELL NO

[@BCSreal]

@@smh8123g to the r to the a to the v

[@valence7]

@@CyranoForever101 Never speak again

[@staticturbulence]

@@CyranoForever101no…

[@ZackStuber]

Wish he listened to Cry For Me the later half gave me chills. Literally one of the best tracks I’ve ever heard.

[@jdixon390]

It has to be song of the year, it is for me anyway

[@swagenheim]

cry for me is such a phenomanal song. mica’s vocals in the second half are just so bone chilling

[@ZackStuber]

@@jdixon390 SAME DOGGIE

[@tacocrunchies]

my absolute favorite on the album definitely was a callback to spoon was getting goosebumps listening to the last half

[@ZackStuber]

@@tacocrunchies I had the same reaction. So good.

[@earlisonline]

vampire in the corner sounds like the sound of every yeule album put together in one song and i love it

[@michemicalromance]

it sounds like the soundtrack of the game Portal to me tbh, it sounds wayy too happy to resemble a yeule song

[@arcadia14]

i thought she looked like me! kinda sounded like yeule

[@TitanonymousXOXO]

⁠@@arcadia14the glitching in the opening rlly reminded me of yeule’s anthems for a 17 year old girl cover

[@arcadia14]

@@TitanonymousXOXO YESSS

[@tlou_msmsmsm]

what are you even talking about 😭 this sounds nothing like yeule

[@yoavsnake]

I love the framing of each song as a 'dream sequence'. That's really how the entire album sounds

[@1gnore_me.]

you know he loves it if he just moves his head around and barely changes facial expression

[@chan_martin]

Bro really gives nothing and then scores it a strong 9 😂

[@colecaine.1]

@@chan_martin he’s locked in, apparently

[@yuhmuhfuhkuh]

If brat was a 10, this is an 11

[@AP0PT0SIS]

Fingers crossed he gives it a 10. Magdalena bay getting a Fantano 10 would be awesome. Oh, and the album deserves it too.

[@jdixon390]

​@@yuhmuhfuhkuhagreed

[@absolanimations9276]

the transition from Death & Romance to Fear, Sex is really smooth!!

[@colecaine.1]

I love that they’re both included in the music video, too. So good.

[@imeanleafeon]

Apparently they actually wrote fear sex first then worked backwards to make death romance, they talked abt it on a livestream

[@sassytabasco]

Dude seriously, that blew me away on my first listen.

[@qaqtix6700]

Damn chat is so corny for hating on Vampire in the corner before it’s even halfway played. That final minute is arguably the best part of the entire album

[@feilimwalsh234]

Fantano chat is full of sweaty wierdos who don’t like anything unless he has already said he likes it

[@AP0PT0SIS]

I think a lot of the people commenting 1 were trolling.

[@arcanemaster8722]

@@AP0PT0SIS 1 is to represent a vote in the pool that the song is good, not a rating. 2 means they didn’t feel it

[@AP0PT0SIS]

@@arcanemaster8722 ohh lol duh I must’ve missed that.

[@elivincent3795]

to me it is the weakest track tbh

[@LJlucky8]

I didn't like Vampire in the Corner much at first, but it's such a banger the more you listen to it

[@CyranoForever101]

Best on the album imo...

[@swagenheim]

@@CyranoForever101 agreed!! vitc is like my favourite song currently

[@smurfette_blues7922]

Same. I think because in the moment it feels like the album is slowing down by what is basically a straight forward love song, but then the more i listen, the more charming I find it. Like the lyrics and the melody of the chorus really are so sweet and earnest!

[@arcanemaster8722]

I hope this album gets a 10. Deserves a 10, but if it gets a 9 that’s fine.

[@neeko2198]

@@Onarcathis is one of those albums that even an 8 is just too low…

[@chan_martin]

Angel On A Satellite sounds like one of those songs that’s always existed. Such a beautiful track.

[@jnm92]

The arrangements are nuts.. Syncopated, wide.. love it

[@arielantoniorosenberger3336]

I'm surprised nobody said anything about 'The Ballad of Matt and Mica'', it's my favourite of the album by far

[@packagedbeans608]

INCREDIBLE track

[@hyrummm]

honestly wouldn’t be surprised if this album gets a decent or strong 9. he didn’t even hear some of the best tracks on the record yet

[@fray3dendsofsanity]

Yep, if Mercurial World was an 8 this is a 9, easily

[@MagdalenaSlay]

i swear if he does a proper review while listening in order, he will find it a 9 minimum. The breaking point in album is tunnel vision and it just takes sooo many turns in lyricism and lore, cry for me and ballad of matt & mica will blow his socks off not to mention image and the 22 minute countdown 🤩

[@estebanrodriguez1456]

​@@MagdalenaSlay it's was a meh for his review singles week

[@chemicaldawn9402]

​@@estebanrodriguez1456 only image,but sometimes he changes his perspective with the album context

[@ahmdose]

Incoming 10

[@cbennoes]

That's My Floor is an absolute banger

[@neeko2198]

One of my favourites. So underrated

[@METALGEARDURKADURK]

Sadly No Tunnel Vision, I started crying off how much serotonin that song gave me.

[@4Poundjellybean]

You'd be happy to now he already reacted to that 2 weeks ago when it came out :)

[@METALGEARDURKADURK]

@@4Poundjellybean oh hell yeah, now I'm excited for the review 😂, I didn't even notice that this was from 2 weeks ago if I understood correctly 🥴

[@faberquidam]

@@METALGEARDURKADURKhow can this be from 2 weeks ago the album came out yesterday

[@MoonlightCactus]

​​@@faberquidamtunnel vision came out 2 weeks ago as a single for the album

[@commandoxbox3604]

Abducted by an alien is actually lore accurate to music vid

[@chlomance]

watching tv has to be their best yet

[@vitorf2303]

my favorite one in the album, it gives me a 2000's TV vibe

[@qaqtix6700]

Death & romance imo

[@ASCENSiON_]

Cry For Me is magical.

[@raydiantly]

agreed, easily song of the year for me

[@vitorf2303]

@@raydiantly For me it's ill times by Gum and Ambrose

[@Obbss]

First time listening this artist, production sounds crazy

[@Peterrdee]

I really like cry for me, it’s so classic sounding like something from the 70s in my mind lmao

[@MegaTempo22]

That one sounds like a hybrid of ELO and Abba

[@alexanderg7244]

Hoping for at least 9, Imaginal Disk is honestly the best pop album of the decade so far

[@1gnore_me.]

LMAO his reaction to the "her voice is giving me herpes" comment

[@colecaine.1]

Some psychos in the chat bro 😭

[@blahblahlalah]

what does that even mean ?!?!!?? 😭

[@basedarsonist]

Timestamp??

[@akulahirpada1993]

Kinda wish he reacted to Cry For Me. Honestly think it's their best song s o far.

[@thebohr11]

Strong 9 to a 10 for me.

[@Plaudible]

another perfect 100 from chat, haven't personally seen it since allie x's galina!

[@Austyn59913]

damn it makes me so sad that some people aren’t seeing this album for the masterpiece it is smh media literacy moment

[@Sinoops]

Woah i can't remember the last time I saw such a unanimously positive reaction from his chat.

[@jess_o]

I hadn't heard of them till Death and Romance, been binging their stuff since. Adoring this album

[@salkeumsalkeum]

kinda mad he didn't listen to cry for me

[@danica5235]

thats my favorite

[@jdixon390]

It's my favorite song from the album too

[@emmacr0305]

IKR it's my favourite song aaa😭😭😭

[@24hrdog]

lilnunchucks just be saying shit

[@twinkincarnate]

got on my nerves 😂

[@sturmp]

when he gives this album a 9 I wanna prove I’m here before

[@bridgetbunny123]

Fear, Sex is so hauntingly beautiful it’s scary

[@treyturner9707]

dam its crazy that we got 2 10/10 albums in a single year

[@thomasgambroadamsson3650]

The opening and closing of a record can be important, and Imaginal Disk has an incredible opening and closing! I think even the few middle tracks I wasn't crazy about will grow on me, and possibly overshadow the obvious hits on the front and back end.

[@Soupytimeee]

That’s the first time I’ve ever seen a poll on here be 100% yes that’s insane but deserved this album is a masterpiece

[@yahirrivas429]

I haven't enjoyed an album this much since early 2022

[@evanscott5932]

If brats a 10 then this albums an 11

[@ahmdose]

FACTS

[@nahue2000]

Brat s overrated

[@nahue2000]

Brat is overrated

[@ahmdose]

@@nahue2000 took me 17 listens to enjoy brat ngl worth it

[@nahue2000]

@@ahmdose you are very patient.I need at least 3 listen to realize if its good or not

[@ahmdose]

Plz rate it 10 fantano please

[@eightstorywindow]

Album of the year so far

[@kaladinstormblessed8470]

Thank you for posting this🙏🙏 Can’t really afford the patreon rn

[@xcBlackDiamond]

Thank you very much for uploading this. Had to miss NMF this week.

[@tyler_keeble]

Shame he didn’t react to Cry For Me. My current SOTY. The album is a serious AOTY too.

[@tom18a12]

what an amazing song genuinely

[@jdixon390]

Mine too

[@Phumos]

meet your brand new imageee

[@station7002]

Jojo references are everywhere, I can’t escape it

[@rehab_herr]

they dont lie when they talk about his audience

[@DariusVincentHughes]

Are we finally gonna get two 10s in a single year?

[@sassytabasco]

Brat 10, "Chappell Roan clicked", and an Imaginal Disk 10 would be a hall of fame W Melon moment Edit: 9 is good too 👌

[@Greeeenskies]

Her voice reminds me of Aimee Echo's. "Image" is my fave on the album.

[@imzam97]

Fear,sex made me reminiscing to final fantasy theme ost, im not sure which one but it's giving eery yet warm comforting vibe

[@Poppetmoth]

the first half of the album has such good tracks with experimental breakdowns, wish he listened to She Looked Like Me and Tunnel Vision

[@yoavsnake]

is the other commentator really called 'epotty'? I ain't googling that 😭

[@plaguedyouth]

why would they call themself that XD

[@colecaine.1]

Super unfortunate because she’s otherwise a good content creator 😭

[@witcherye]

since I am not educated in music, I don't know why, but this album reminds me of vkei a bit, like malice mizer and buck-tick songs

[@jackcostello2239]

This Album has changed the trajectory of my life, and I don’t say that lightly

[@dramaticvirghoe]

watching t.v. >>>

[@maxwelllegere1483]

wow cool to see his fans are still all hate music. very edgy and epic

[@RickyPro888]

That diamondinthegutter guy needs to cut it out holy crap

[@ishanramen5254]

Every time Anthony listens to an album where he achieves nirvana, he finds some reason to give it a 7.

[@ericedsmith]

diamondinthegutter is goddamn ruthless

[@Kristofy1]

lilnunchucks biting the curb HD

[@chan_martin]

Curious about his reaction to Holy, Holy

[@tobyhall7543]

He loved it, found the lyrics hilarious 😂

[@colecaine.1]

Uploading the reaction in a bit

[@colecaine.1]

It’s up :)

[@chan_martin]

@@colecaine.1 🙏

[@Chilmerican]

Feeling Diskinserted will be the reason why the album won’t get a 10. He’s gonna bring up something about the track being too short.

[@pookiemari143]

He feared sex

[@习近平official]

it least a strong 9

[@习近平official]

AOTY

[@kglocknotstock]

Cry for me ????

[@AlexA00]

chance this will get a 10?

[@jdixon390]

He better, it's more like an 11/10

[@Chilmerican]

He might think Feeling Diskinserted is too short.

[@pcwildcat]

yo this album kinda slaps tho.

[@defnotisaiah3210]

watch him give it a 7 tbh

[@juju-vl7oj]

I know everyone in this comment section is too woke to say this but that chick Fantano is with here is pure sex appeal .

[@BlGGESTBROTHER]

This is a heavy concept album so picking one song out of the mix is a bit off putting. It's definitely one that's meant to be listened through from start to finish.

[@Calamitous]

Did he react to 'Holy, Holy,' by Geordie Greep do you know?

[@loops734]

he did, i didnt see his reaction but he put it in his top 5 of the week so he liked it

[@Calamitous]

@@loops734 Super glad, it starts at like 1am and finishes at 5am where I live so I always miss it lmao

[@Meowcat-kr6tc]

@@Calamitous are you in the UK too? it's rough out here

[@Calamitous]

@@Meowcat-kr6tc I am haha, hoping someone uploads the reaction

[@colecaine.1]

He did. I’ll upload it in about an hour.

[@mashupotato_]

"her voice is giving me herpes" LMAO

[@zanedoellman5016]

it bothers me that he didnt begin with death and romance because i see that track and fear, sex as two sides of the same coin.

[@KrazyCouch2]

"Imaginary Disk" eh close enough.

[@hhyperbaIIad]

omfg im so early

[@moonlitegram]

I'm with skrrt_vonnegut regarding the high frequencies in vampire. When I first heard the song I thought my hearing was going or something. It was so high, it sounded like the ringing you get after a concert when you're losing a bit of your hearing range. And its pushed back in the mix so you don't notice it at first, and then suddenly you do, and it's this "oh god, what is that??" experience. Very odd choice. I give them credit for experimenting with the production, but I guess there's a reason people don't typically include frequencies that high in their mixes. Its kind of jarring and annoying lol.

[@xcBlackDiamond]

11111111

[@PoorEdward]

Think it’s unhealthy the way everyone is acting like it’s so innovative. Good record though.

[@leosssss4217]

I love him and his videos but why are his live reactions the most boring of all time???

[@Rockjael2]

dunno man but sometimes it's fresh to see someone not overreacting but giving some sensible short insight. Also sometimes the chat gives nice feedback.

[@ZvedeSDC]

He's just listening to a bunch of music in a row and reacting genuine

[@Updog89]

Because you have a short attention span and he isn’t interested in catering to that by exaggerating and clowning.

[@gonzalotellez555]

He s real, no acting

[@curly_wyn]

I thought it was just decent. Not a masterpiece at all.

[@himynameisjohn]

Yeah, I was really excited to listen after seeing so many people raving about it all over the internet, but I'm really not impressed. I've heard 5 or 6 songs from the album and they're all just okay. None of it's bad, I don't really have any desire to listen to any of them again. I wish I liked it as much as everyone else

[@Inezh358]

Crying and cuddling close my vinyl copy I will play to death. (Played through fully 7 times) only got it last night! And I really love it, gonna finish this video and listen to BRAT by Charli XCX; never heard her music but have loved magdalena bay for years and almost too much to an obessive degree so gonna try some similar bits.

[@Inezh358]

also imagine listening to album of the century (people just do no know it yet) with this bald guy who doesnt even say anything nor anything paticularly interesting. video popped up bit of an odd concept this.... and to listen to such an album and write "mid"? very sad and adhd mummy boy behavior.

[@connor.d.l]

How did you like it? I don’t find Charli/brat too similar to Magdalena bay, if you haven’t already I’d check out grimes (especially art angels and visions) as I find her a lot closer than Charli!

[@Inezh358]

@@connor.d.l Wasn't really my thing, one listen only. I only really like a few bands or singers as I try to spend my time playing instrruments instead. I got the vinyls for every mag bay record, alvvays, men I trust, Samia(only the baby) and some others. Only like a few artists but listen to them an excessive degree I dont know what I even think of the records I listne to anymore as it is burned into my skull haha. I guess it is funny obsessed with mag bay but never liked mini mix 3, all you do, tunnel vision, and their wierd special edition of mercuiral world that is like a bizzare art project with voicemails that interuppt the folow the record? Like i get the artyness and their meta style but lameeeeee! Their first singles "the girls"(

[@angel.3939]

and the other songs