Feedback session by Jeremy Mann, Karla Ortiz and Nadezda at THU2016

[@NashvilleClay]

A proper critique. I had a few professors that would be this honest with you. They were happy when you did you well and were willing to clue you in when you didn't. Serious and frank critiques are invaluable.

[@cr0uchingtiger]

So awesome. I wish I could get my work torn to shreds by someone truly world class like Mann.

[@Constantinesis]

This is really awesome and helpfull! I just discovered Mann a few weeks ago and i am fascinated by his art, both the sketchbooks and the paintings!

[@thepimpartist]

Great video! I love Jeremy Mann's intensity!

[@oowaz]

i mean, at some point he called the student's work garbage, i see that he is trying to provoke and give em energy but idk, feels like it's not an appropriate tone to use with people that are just there and happen to find him giving feedback at this event - it's not like they signed up for his course or something. even then, still not cool being this aggressive

[@artisfu9]

I would LOVE to be a FLY ON THE WALL and just watch MANN work one of his PAINTINGS! He is just AWESOME!!!

[@MFDOOOOM]

Watch his movie it's on here Inside the Mann

[@artisfu9]

@@MFDOOOOM Wow, thanks for letting me know! I put that comment out 6 years ago!

[@MFDOOOOM]

@@artisfu9 it's actually called A Solitary Mann lol i remembered it wrong

[@artisfu9]

@@MFDOOOOM "A Solitary Mann"...how CEREBRAL and CLEVER! Thanks again MFDOOOOM! (I hate he passed...great rapper)! Mann's contemporaries are Jeremy Lipking and Casey Baugh, but even there work is a little behind his, in my opinion!

[@franciscogaray2530]

​@@artisfu9also check Gamma Wray, its by the same documentarist that made the Mann one, but its about William Wray and his proccess are pretty similar to Mann

[@BingeCenter]

I have been harshly critiqued in college... I like couldn't even speak when it happened lol I got like choked up... I won't forget that.

[@vanessanost]

this totally brings me back to arts school. I'm a performer/musician but I've grown up around artists of all kinds my whole life and I miss the intensity and kind of absurd puzzle making understanding of work and style. I live in a mountain town right now in the rockies and I feel like the only weirdo artist that thinks critically like this, I'd love to get ripped to shreds and have someone really dig into my stuff!

[@bneves8680]

Major props for filming this!! WIsh I could have been there

[@allanpaz5621]

great video, they explain very good points, thanks for sharing.

[@popesdope]

My pleasure!

[@Arman3OO]

thanks for sharing, plz post more if you have more footage :)

[@popesdope]

I do but it's boring and a few hours long (of this session alone) I got all the nuggets out of it and made this compilation :)

[@MFDOOOOM]

Goddamn, they are so goated

[@vt3649]

It doesn’t matter what Mann thinks or anyone else for that matter.

[@tiagosousa6945]

Man, thanks for uploading.

[@KevinZamirGoeke]

Nice, how straight forward they are *-*

[@brostonmash9556]

Great video

[@christophertimmins4724]

amazing feedback

[@pocketfullofshellz]

Brilliant and brutal

[@phantomapprentice6749]

They really really need fly traps in Troja :)

[@ZeRafut]

What book is he talkinng about at 3:27 if a elping soul can help me out xD

[@abacaxidaguadoce]

he is talking about George Brant Bridgman

[@ZeRafut]

thanks a lot

[@Constantinesis]

​@@abacaxidaguadoce Could it be about the Constructive Anatomy or the Life Drawing book that he is referring to ?

[@graphicsdesignbeforeafter]

Just seeing this its gold. "You are in your room alone what are you afraid of...?" Art! True true it made a guy called Adolf to become Hitler. I better do laundry, dishes and clean toilet seat first!

[@rimetime6423]

So they tell him 'this is not good' etc, then just minutes later ''why should you care if someone else doesn't like what you're doing'' Well i guess they had to yak yak yak. 22:40 Jeremy is totally wrong analyzing her art - He give her advice which would basically make her do his style and technique. He tells her the one with black lines is better - yet the one he does not like looks even more creative and interesting. Jeremy was totally wrong on that part. Every artist has different styles

[@david_kim]

not that you should totally not care what someone says, rather you should allow your opinion to matter more than theirs. that person has the option to totally ignore the comment from Mann that 'this is not good', and value their own opinion more than his, but i for one would not do that.

[@tzutzescu]

i think the point was "it doesn't matter if someone else doesn't like what you're doing as long as you do, because you do it for yourself" which is valid imo, as long as you are doing it for yourself and not someone else.

[@SubNorm4L]

It's not about that it looks more creative or interesting, it was that the composition work better on that one. It had a clear focal point and a better overall read. He made a very traditional observation about the work, focusing on objective points about composition rather than creative ones. If her intention was that the other piece were unreadable at first sight, then that painting is successful. If not, it's a failure. It all depends on what she wanted to say.

[@wildcheekymonkey]

i love honest people.