Fifth Harmony Vocal Ranking | who's the best vocalist?

Stan #fifthharmony #harmony
members
(best to worst)
1. ally Brooke
A3-C#5/D5-G5
2. Dinah Jane
G#3/A3-C5
3. Lauren jauregui
F#3/G3-B4/C5
4. Camila cabello
G3-A4/Bb4
5. Normani kordei
G3/G#3-G4
#allybrooke ‪@AllyBrookeOfficial‬
#dinahjane ‪@dinahjane‬
#laurenjauregui ‪@laurenjauregui‬
#camilacabello ‪@camilacabello‬
#normani ‪@Normani‬

[@oceanwave_]

Also this proves that Fifth Harmony are overlooked HEAVILY as vocalists since all of them can support. They’re even on par with SM’s girl groups vocally. They’re really this generation’s vocal powerhouse western girl group dare I say 🔥

[@soprano2087]

Which SM is similar to them?

[@rere9991]

@Czennen Taeyeon is def better belter than Aly though? Taeyeon now is consistent with bE5s with consistent resonance A4-C#5/D5 area. Ally is not far behind but yea Taeyeon is better, their head voice same with development but Ally's quality is sometimes better, and lower register Taeyeon by far no comparison.

[@taeslilclown9801]

@Whimsical🌨 individually 5H has better vocalists (Perrie’s exempted - on par with Ally and Dinah, possibly Jade as well), but as a group LM trumps them

[@taeslilclown9801]

@Whimsical🌨 I’d put Ally above Perrie. Ally is a bit more consistent with mid and higher belts and a slightly better intonation and clarity. Leigh > Lauren > Jesy sounds about right. Leigh’s the most inconsistent of the 3, but she also carries the best control in terms of agility, open placement and clarity. Might also be somewhat interchangeable with Lauren considering her breath control and lower register are far more superior. not to mention out of the 3, only Lauren carries resonance in her mid belts.

[@taeslilclown9801]

@Whimsical🌨 although Lauren’s full range is B2-F5-Eb6, she doesn’t produce a connected hv. if anything, she has the weakest and possibly non existent higher register amongst the 9 girls. but she does make up for that with her lower register that spans down to a consistently supported F#3, which is also the strongest amongst all 9 girls. Dinah is for sure much better rounded than Jade, but in all honesty, Ally > Perrie > Dinah > Jade aren’t all that far from each other. Ally and Perrie sing similarly, while Dinah and Jade do as well. A and P mainly have their head voices and technical consistency against D and J, who rely more on falsettos than their inconsistently connected hv, but have much better musicality and agility. but overall, Ally and Jade have the healthiest habits out of these 4 girls. Same with the bottom 3. Jesy > Camila > Normani aren’t all that far from one another. They’re the most stylistic and nasal of the 9, which hinders their capabilities. while Jesy is technically the most consistently technical of the 3, Normani and Camila trump Jesy’s both lower register and higher. Camila’s the only one who can support consistently up to Bb4/B4 but even then it’s still quite throaty and pushed, though not as shrilly. both Normani and Jesy peak at A4, with Normani having a wider supported range (G3~A4/Bb4) approximately due to her having a stronger lower register than Jesy.

[@soprano2087]

Great video as Always, I didn’t know that Ally and Dinah had archived resonance on their belts. This video definitely helped to understand their skills even more.

[@jesusgarcia5197]

I've always loved Normani's vocals from the beginning. Such a sweet vocal tone she has. She really should work on building her belting skills up as her agility would work well with it.

[@ayeshas5823]

Great video! :)💙 Normani is my FAVOURITE member, voice, vocals, lows, singing, stage presence and etc.💙💙💙💙💙💙 She’s the BEST one for me!💙 I LOVE Fifth Harmony sooooo much!💙

[@swingriah6537]

You're evolving😭😭 Without even watching this I already expected that this would be a great video as usual. I love how you explain singer's technique objectively😍😍 Keep it up.

[@allykelly]

Thank u so much my friend ❤️

[@swingriah6537]

@@allykelly No problem❤

[@r.uwamhenye8282]

Not u talking like a proud parent 😭😭😭

[@swingriah6537]

@@r.uwamhenye8282 😭😭😭

[@r.uwamhenye8282]

@@swingriah6537 BYE💀💀💀

[@varunravi27]

I completely agree with everything in this video 🤍 Seeing from both the channel name and your profile pic, I can tell that Ally is your favourite 5H member but I noticed that there is no bias towards her whatsoever (aka you are acknowledging her flaws and have no problem doing it). My favourite is Lauren because I just love everything about her voice... the rasp, the vocal weight (it's sort of a medium-weight voice) and a lot of other things. I agree that the rasp was unhealthy at first but I think Lauren has learnt to control it and she uses it for stylistic purposes nowadays.

[@TheCosmicNote]

So Dinah and Ally are the best overall? Oh you said Ally is number one, agreed! I’ll be honest, I’ve never listened to Fifth Harmony, only Camila Cabello’s solo music. I really liked Ally’s singing in this video so I’ll check more of Fifth Harmony’s stuff. Normani’s runs and whistles are so nice. Camila I love her voice but only sometimes, her tone sometimes doesn’t sound pleasant to me that’s subjective I think, her tone sounded best in her Havana era for me. This was a nice analysis and very good introduction to them for me!!

[@r.uwamhenye8282]

can’t wait for this 😍😍

[@nateob29]

Dinah has always had the best voice period

[@TheCosmicNote]

7:51 that was so good WHAT

[@lyseless]

I thought Normani was consistent to at least A4 :o love this video though!! I love how detailed you were about each member. Can't wait to see more of your videos!

[@allykelly]

Not really she's tense

[@lyseless]

@@allykelly What do you think about her upper belts (above D5)? It seems like she approaches them with a different technique.

[@allykelly]

@@lyseless it's either tense, whiny and small she's underdeveloped as a belter

[@richmaxmchalliwchester1984]

She has few good moments up to A4, but most of the time it's tense, whiny or not fully projected sound, she definitely has a lot issues as a belter.

[@soprano2087]

I remember I got cooked in the ain other fan rank because i said that Ally is the only member who can uses a solid head voice and it’s was unfair to put Normani and Dinah in the same place as her In that category.

[@allykelly]

Lol haha maybe he wasn't so family with ally's head voice

[@taeslilclown9801]

I think Dinah has showcased a supported head voice at times, but she definitely has a somewhat connected one. She does opt for falsetto most of the time.

[@allykelly]

Can u link

[@taeslilclown9801]

@@allykelly kzbin.info/www/bejne/opy4mJl_isqXbK8 kzbin.info/www/bejne/eJuXp6B9ic6qjJo kzbin.info/www/bejne/j36TZpalo6x6r9k the Bleeding Love (last one) one might be the best example. Feels Like Heaven Feels Like Hell said she can support her head voice up to Eb5, but I’m not entirely sure to what extent that’s true.

[@FeelsLikeHeavenFeelsLikeHell]

Fifth harmony songs didn't do justice to Ally. She often gets low parts instead of the high parts that went to Camilla.

[@michaelsliders3421]

@Czennen Camilla was just more confident

[@udebrl]

@@michaelsliders3421 i dont think so? ally needs to belt in every concert lol, she change the key in both Down and We Know cause she wants more vocally

[@vocalising4218]

My personal ranking: 1st: Dinah. She is the most well rounded of them all, has good development in all her registers - decent lows (for soprano), strong belts up to C5/C#5, beautiful falsetto and agility, she can sing melisma. The only issues she really has are on upper belts (and occasionally mid belts) inconsistency with lows, and breath control. 2nd: Ally. she used to have better belting technique than Dinah but in recent years she's been sounding quite tense and throaty esp in the fifth octave, once or twice she literally had to sing the National Anthem in the same range as Lauren did. Her sustained belts sometimes sound tense and strained, think being overworked in 5H and not properly resting her voice have caused this. Lows aren't terrible, but def the weakest compared to the others. Overall her belts, her range plus head voice are her real strengths. 3rd: Lauren. She has improved so much in the last couple years, these days she sounds just as good as she did before her decline. Lows and mid belts are her strengths and where she really is most comfortable. Her main issue is longevity (at the start of tour she is at her best, at the end she tires easily and sounds throaty.) Another thing is inconsistency within her supported range- on a good day she can easily support a B4 / C5 like the one shown, on a bad day she is straining on the same notes. Despite this, she has been very very consistent with the E5s in Expectations (which is impressive considering she doesn't often belt this high). Falsetto has become very thin and airy, that's probably why she doesn't use it much. Her range is the smallest in the group - She needs to show us more range and explore her voice. Ideally I'd like to see her support more consistently, improve her falsetto, and give us more upper belts. 4th: Camila. lows are actually one of her strengths and she is very comfortable in this area, I heard her sing a C#3 with decent volume and it even had vibrato (will put a link if I can find the clip.) agility is good, runs and riffs are her main selling point and it's easy to see why - shes very creative with them, speed is quick although this can be seen as a negative as they don't always flow so well as a result. she has a tendency to overdo it like Christina, but its her trademark I suppose. She never runs out of breath while doing them either, something people (including me) can forget when talking about agility. Belts are decent at times, but they're usually very nasal and unsupported. however she does have a lot of ease in her upper belting range, check out her G5 in Cry for me, it didn't seem too difficult for her. Overall she does show a bit more consistency than Lauren in terms of longevity and she isn't afraid to explore most areas of her voice, however the nasality, tension in belting and lack of a proper supported range hold her back. 5th: Normani. She doesn't seem to have development in any area of her voice except whistle register and maybe lows. Projection is an issue - she can be airy on lows and not loud enough while belting. Most of her belts are very tense and like Camila, she doesn't have a consistent supported range. As others have mentioned she has had some good moments with mid belts, I do like her A4s and the few times she has tried upper belts (I lied and once when she sustained an E5). Very good agility, however Camila is generally better with pitch when it comes to more complex runs. Her strengths lie in whistles, falsetto and agility, she also has the widest range in the group. Also I want to point out that it's not that Normani is a bad singer and I like her, but when compared with the rest of her group she is the weakest link.

[@allykelly]

I'm still sticking to ally as best because her bad moments in recent years that she was sick she become better in her gospel or worship song on her channel The mid belt here sounds pretty nice just a bit pushed the tension isn't really obstructive kzbin.info/www/bejne/eZbKoZ-ki6iMhKc Dinah isn't consistent with C#5 her unsupported C#5 outnumbers her supported C#5 but her mid belt are still good

[@Shark-nq5ug]

In my opinion, Ally's voice ((at least at this time)) was the most well-developed because she was older. The other girls likely didn't have any vocal lessons or generally people teaching them as they auditioned at 15/16, and were probably self-taught.

[@Shark-nq5ug]

​@@raylelverr That makes sense :P

[@taeslilclown9801]

@@raylelverr and it’s sad that Normanis become more stylistic as the years went on. she used to have a stronger mix with better chest coordination, and that all went down the drain once she opted for her current, airy tone

[@abc_jv_xyz]

@@taeslilclown9801 before becoming super stylistic and airy, what do you think was her supported range?

[@liftedb9591]

Love Dinah appreciation, 1 thing i disagree with is Lauren having B4/C5, id personally give her Bb4/B4 czz she still a bit too shouty and pushy but i agree with the fact she improved after her decline

[@allykelly]

Well I don't see her doing B4 without obstructive throat tension anymore her main issue is just her rasp that makes her sounds rough she support B4/C5s more than few times that's why it's included in her supported range

[@sanatmanhare5912]

Next little mix.

[@r.uwamhenye8282]

That’d be a good one

[@perryjones7771]

We all know who the best singer from that legendary group is

[@r.uwamhenye8282]

@@perryjones7771 they’re all great singers W equal talent

[@varunravi27]

If Jesy is included, I think it would either be: 1. Perrie 2. Jade/Leigh-Anne 3. Jesy OR 1. Perrie 2. Jade 3. Leigh-Anne 4. Jesy It honestly depends on certain other factors like dynamics, vocal control, etc. because the technical gap between the LM girls is quite small.

[@khushiana9901]

finally yay!

[@khushiana9901]

can you do halle bailey? I love her sm, and no one makes any analysis about her vocals

[@allykelly]

I can when I have the materials

[@allykelly]

But ain't no other fan has made one

[@michaelsliders3421]

She’s new lol

[@deiravenclaw9950]

Great video! Anyway, I would like to know your opinion about what JoJo's vocal type. Her early 5th octave sounds more belty compared to other sopranos. But I'm not entirely sure about her as a mezzo-soprano (I used to believe she was mezzo). Also, she's very comfortable singing down there. For now, I assume JoJo is a lower type of soprano. What do you think? It would be nice if you also tell me the reason. Thanks! :)

[@allykelly]

She's definitely a soprano but not high one her mid range isn't dense enough compared to sopranos like Tiffany Evans, Whitney, Celine who are sopranos

[@deiravenclaw9950]

@@allykelly Yeah, makes sense. So, it's safe to say that she's not the "lyric" type right? Anyway, which pop vocalist you would think when it comes to a real mezzo-soprano?

[@allykelly]

@@deiravenclaw9950 Jazmine Sullivan

[@БогданЗелинский-ю9з]

@@allykelly what about Lady Gaga, P!nk, Beyonce, Miley or Adele? Are they also mezzo-sopranos?

[@allykelly]

@@БогданЗелинский-ю9з Beyonce is a born soprano not sure about Gaga but Miley and Adele are both mezzo

[@hinacharmbraceletera283]

Can you do Yuju (Ex-Gfriend/Soloist) next please? 😊 And can you add like built in subtitles in your videos also? Thank you

[@allykelly]

The subtitle will appears in some other times

[@crazyotaku6023]

So the vocal ranking of lm and 5H is 1. Ally brooke A3-C#5/D5-G5 2. Perrie Edwards G#3-C5/C#5-G#5 3. Dinah Jane G#3/A3-C5 4. Lauren jauregui F#3/G3-B4/C5 5. Leigh anne A3-B4 6. Jade Thirwall G#3-Bb4/B4 7. Jesy Nelson G#3/A3-Bb4/B4 8. Camila Cabello G3-A4/Bb4 9. Normani kordei G3/G#3-G4

[@sanatmanhare5912]

No perrie is better then ally and dinah and jade at same level.

[@allykelly]

@@sanatmanhare5912 nope ally display way better technique than Perrie ally's belt kills Perrie instantly Perrie has obstructive subglottic tension that damaged her voice this ranking is correct Dinah get thin and small above B4 she barely support C5 consistently than dinah

[@soprano2087]

I personally would switch Camila with jesy

[@allykelly]

@@soprano2087 umm Jesy has better breath support and has better coordination and less thin than Camila Camila has uncontrollable nasality

[@soprano2087]

@@allykelly but didn’t jesy had a decline?

[@alclark3771]

Thanks for made this video. Btw, Dinah is the youngest and Normani is the 2nd oldest of the group, right? (Description)

[@allykelly]

Sorry i was mistaken as best to worst

[@khushiana9901]

Lm fans are so delusional😭😭

[@allykelly]

Some are

[@haritamang3773]

@@allykelly not some most of them are.thats why I left fandom they can more toxic than K-pop Stans and they say 5h only has solo Stan's meanwhile mixer fandom also had great number of solo Stan.especially Perrie and Leigh stans

[@littleharmony7745]

Sorry since KZbin was acting funny before Ally=good mix register and have amazing belts if not best then one of the best belter in our generation and showed solid head voice with potential in whistle too.her agility showed improvement after her Beyonce riff challenge Her lows are underdeveloped wish she showed even decent improvement there so she could be well rounded Dinah=good mix register and have good Mid belts.amazing agility showed good control in falsettos and out of 4/5 of 5h girls except for ally she shows the best potential in head voice and her lows are decent wish she becomes fully consistent with her G#3 Lauren=amazing lows for soprano her biggest strength.mid belts sounds full until C5 and improved in mix register after her vocal decline have done some decent runs and riffs here and there but upper register lacks proper development thats why her skills got overlookedvsince upper register gets more attention than lower register Camilla=good lows surprisingly for high pitched voice like her.decent mix register with consistency Upto A4/Bb4.preety good agility for her level although lacks musicality.relaxed falsetto with potential in whistle register but head voice lacks proper development Normani=she isn't bad but she is definitely weakest in group she showed good lows with good agility for her level.fairly developed whistled register but head voice lacks proper development and her mix support is shallow and underdeveloped as belter

[@allykelly]

Dinah has some good head voice showcase in her recent Beyonce cover

[@littleharmony7745]

@@allykelly was it connected tho.for the long time I thought she was overrappreciated she just had good mix register and great agility but upper register and lower register were underdeveloped but her Lower register is decent and upper register showed good moments while her agility being one of the best in generation

[@thh982]

what would ally’s vocal tier ranking be

[@allykelly]

Ally Mid proficient Dinah Low AA Lauren A-AA Camila Low A Normani Weak

[@DannyLubz]

how does ally compare to taeyeon/wendy and lauren to ningning? i believe they’re in the same tier respectively no?

[@soprano2087]

@@DannyLubz i think Lauren is better than Ning Ning ( I’m not sure 🤔) but Wendy and Tayeon are overall better than Ally since they’re both got better lows than her and Wendy have a better head voice, I believe that Ally’s head voice is just as good as Tayeon’s.

[@hotissue4948]

@@soprano2087 how about camila vs seulgi

[@allykelly]

@@soprano2087 ummm ally head voice is more operatic than Wendy and Taeyeon ally has better upperbelt than them also And Lauren > Ningning

[@littleharmony7745]

Dinah showed some support in head voice.

[@allykelly]

Link?

[@mark4670]

Can you please make aespa vocal analysis + ranking? I guess they have enough materials to be analyzed. Thank you

[@amisupposedtotwerk1049]

Not related but what's the name of the song in your old intro?

[@allykelly]

Tynix winx

[@moonlightespt3818]

Dinah has the best belting, Ally has the best mixing, stop confusing these two.

[@allykelly]

Nope ally vocalize her voice in M1 just because she's less chesty than Dinah doesn't mean she's mixing Ally mix above F#5

[@canon6363]

I still struggle with Lauren and Camila in choosing who is better. I love Lauren's tone and she has perfect lower register. Camila I feel is m consistent throughout her range though she sounds whiny or nasily.

[@allykelly]

I don't think Camila is consistent she has uncontrollable nasality and her voice is Been rougher shown as her cover empire state of mind Lauren can pull of cleanly executive Bb4-C5 and C#5 at best

[@vocalising4218]

Another thing: for the upper range it would have been better to rank them on falsetto instead of head voice, its not really fair to rank them on something they've never used. But on the whole I enjoyed your analysis, please do more videos like these!

[@allykelly]

Falsetto is a disconnected register basically head voice that's done with poor cord closure

[@llllll7686]

does madison resonate her lows? u gave her blue in lows

[@allykelly]

Blue means great or very good i don't use the resonance term Madison has much density and fullness on her lows

[@katheringomez4088]

Dinah obviously.

[@allykelly]

It's ally

[@khushiana9901]

what is Lauren's tier? I think she's better than all lm girls except perrie

[@allykelly]

Lauren is A-AA

[@vocalising4218]

I wouldn't say she's necessarily better than them, its not so simple. Like Lauren and Jade both have great lows, but Jade also has excellent falsetto, whereas Laurens is weak. On the other hand she is a far better belter than Jade, I'd say her belts are as good as Leigh Anne's (although obviously Leigh has more range). The reason I say Leigh is because when it comes to belting, neither she nor Lauren have issues with vibrato, unlike Jade and Jesy. Leigh is the second best belter of LM, Lauren is the third best belter of 5H, but they both have other areas besides belting which they need to work on, so that's why it makes sense to compare them.

[@allykelly]

@@vocalising4218 I'd say Lauren has better belt than Leigh Leigh is quite light and heady Lauren is more robust and fuller due to her chest coordination

[@iosashes2087]

Very cool video. Just a few things I respectfully disagree with. 1. I think these rankings are more spot on for the first 2-3 years of the group. After around 2015/2016, some members got better or worse at certain things and the differences became even more dramatic once they all went solo for the most part. Which leads me to the next point. 2. Camila has been a better belter/vocalist than Lauren from about mid-2015 onwards. While Lauren has recovered somewhat from her vocal decline, she has yet to re-pass Camila and tbh the gap between them vocally has actually increased despite her recovery. Camila, for all nasality and thinness that creeps into her upper belts, belts with a level of ease and stability that Lauren has yet to come close to since about 2014/2015. Lauren still strains more often than not above B4 and her vowel formation is not as good as Camila’s particularly between C5 and F5. Even besides belting, Camila is clearly more agile and has an easy and smart use of her upper register whereas Lauren’s upper register is practically nonexistent, and the margin between them in the lower register is not nearly big enough to make up for all the other areas that Camila exceeds her. 3. I actually understand why Ain’t No Other Fan didn’t want to get into the upper register conversation, simply because strict classical technique applies the least to upper register pop vocals by far out of all the upper registers. Rarely anyone in pop music uses connected head voice for stylistic reasons. It just sounds very out of place. That’s why Ally’s examples aren’t in concert. Dinah herself said she took classical voice but she just didn’t like the style. So it makes more sense to judge them off control and execution of their falsetto, whistles, and contemporary style head voice, than it is to base it purely on classical technique. In that case, Ally and Dinah are pretty much tied. Ally can get a little higher than Dinah, but she has a rough spot between B5 and D6 that she has trouble controlling whereas Dinah can ascend and descend to and from the 6th octave with relative ease. Normani is third place. Beautiful whistle register and solid falsetto, but her head voice is more powerful than the rest of her voice and lacks control. Camila is fourth and close to tying with Normani. I’ll say her head voice has improved pretty dramatically since 2018/2019. Her falsetto usage has always been decent but she has more control and less shrillness now. She seems to have a whistle register now that’s still underdeveloped but we’ll see if that goes anywhere. Lauren is obviously fifth as she barely has any use of her register, no head voice whatsoever and the half decent falsetto she did once have is now pretty flimsy and muffled. 4. Since the group split, Dinah has improved in agility (see her version of Beyoncé’s Ego live run) enough to be considered a very good runner/riffer, not in just relation to the group but in general. I don’t see too many mainstream singers that can outpace her, especially not in her generation. I’ll also argue she’s overtaken Normani in terms of lower register, but only really in the past 2 years and she’s been mostly on hiatus from the industry so it may take a little while to confirm. Ally and Camila have also improved their lower registers as well, Lauren’s is still solid as before, but Normani seems to have declined a bit. Even her support which was consistently down to G3 has withered a bit. On the belting side, Ally’s abilities seemed to have waned a bit as she’s sounded thinner and tense in the last few years. Dinah’s still about the same as she was, Lauren and Camila have both improved, and Normani has too although not as much as the other two. So based on what’s been demonstrated up to this date. Ranking wise its- Lower register: 1. Lauren 2. Camila 3. Dinah 4. Normani 5. Ally Belts: 1. Ally 2. Dinah 3. Camila 4. Lauren 5. Normani Upper register: 1. Dinah/Ally 2. Normani/Camila 3. Lauren Agility: 1. Dinah 2. Normani/Camila 3. Lauren 4. Ally Overall: 1. Dinah 2. Ally 3. Camila 4. Lauren 5. Normani

[@allykelly]

Thanks for the comments but if you watch Camila's Empire state of mind it's clear that she sound nasal, throaty and filled with obstructive tounge tension Lauren B4-C5 in this video are 2021 kzbin.info/www/bejne/r2ikfHt7i9KMqrM clean mid belts here Compared to Camila's performance kzbin.info/www/bejne/g3eupJ6qrdN7obs kzbin.info/www/bejne/gWqpZqyIdrKlnqs Are u sure she's better than Lauren (1:49) ?? These G#4-Bb4 are shallow, coreless and strained Lauren display mid belt with strong chest coordination less nasal, less tense she's just raspy and doesn't have that weird jaw and tongue like camila Lauren's consistent range F#3/G3-B4/C5 Camila G3/G#3-A4/Bb4 Dinah barely display connected head voice her head voice is very Shrill when she does it ally can produce solid G5-A5 and decent C6

[@iosashes2087]

@@allykelly that Genius session was the healthiest Lauren’s voice had sounded in years and that Empire State of Mind performance is literally Camila’s worst concert vocals since she’s been solo so I don’t think those are genuinely comparable. Lauren’s always had wider support, that much is obvious. She’s just inconsistent on the high end. She has a naturally more powerful voice and imo has better natural belting coordination than Camila, but if we’re gonna use the term “throaty”, Lauren takes the cake on that. She has her good moments, but overall she sounds very strained more often than not and it’s clear she doesn’t have much ease above C5. Camila on the other hand is basically a smaller voice attempting to be powerful. She has less throat tension like Lauren and more tongue tension like you said. But her ease and access to that part of her voice and lack of history of vocal damage from external sources make her a more consistent a belter than Lauren. In essence, at Lauren’s best, she’s better than Camila, but at her worst it’s bad. Camila’s best is not as good as Lauren’s best and her worst is not as bad as Lauren’s worst. She’s just generally more consistent and a bit more capable than Lauren (particularly in the upper belting range). Dinah’s G5-A5 in head voice isn’t really shrill to me so much as it’s breathy. Definitely her weak spot, but it gains more fullness and stability around Bb5 and above (which is where Ally seems to start having issues). She has her moments though, especially her G5s during Flex performances on the 7/27 tour. Also this seems to be an area she’s improved on in the last couple years (see Ego cover and Tennessee Whiskey cover).

[@allykelly]

@@iosashes2087 umm again nope Dinah head voice is Shrill and mostly falsetto Ally sounds full and operatic up to G5 consistently as i showed in the video Dinah isn't as connected ally on 8:01 with C6 although it's quite pushed Camila and Lauren has issues but Camila has more issues with tounge, jaw and throat her nasality is uncontrolled she sounds whiny and pinced her coordination is small that lacks fullness Lauren does way better on G4-C#5 with less tension it's just that Lauren struggle with her decline but has been lessen in recent years she can produce clean B4/C5 in numerous of time while Camila sounds tight small and thin even on Bb4 kzbin.info/www/bejne/gWqpZqyIdrKlnqs (1:49) How's Camila more consistent than Lauren Even if Camila was more consistent Lauren shows more viable technique with more chest engagement on her belt better breath support, vibrato etc Shallow, weak and thin G#4-Bb4 Show me Lauren's current Thin weak and shallow moments like that

[@iosashes2087]

@@allykelly again, that’s why I said I thought this video was pretty accurate for when 5H were still together. Dinah and Camila use a lot more actual head voice in the last few years instead of just mostly falsetto. I’m not saying I think you’re wrong about your assessment it’s just the girls have changed vocally even recently. In the last few years, Lauren’s regained her support up to C5, Camila and Dinah have improved considerably with both their upper and lower registers, Ally sings with a lighter approach, and Normani mixes her belts more just to give a few examples. Even though not all of these are relatively recent examples, this is a good demonstration of the differences between Camila and Lauren in their belting range. kzbin.info/www/bejne/ppCTY4yahdtpfKM Lauren is stronger and clearer up to about B4 (sometimes C5) but Camila is able to carry ease and quality much further up in her belting range than Lauren. If Lauren was a mezzo soprano I think I’d say she still takes it, but considering they’re both sopranos and Lauren starts sounding rough around C#5 while Camila can maintain decent quality up to F#5 (though the consistency is arguable), I can’t say Lauren is a better belter overall than Camila. I think she naturally is, but functionally is a different story. They both have strengths and weaknesses and I think Lauren has better projection but Camila is more dynamic, which interestingly seems to be inverted in their lower registers.

[@allykelly]

@@iosashes2087 Ok just because Camila is more comfy on the upper belt doesn't make her better than Lauren Lauren applies better and viable technique from G4-C#5 better coordination better breath support, and better vibrato. Camila's vibrato is messy af Camila has tendencies to become shallow in supporting she can be so small and thin so range doesn't count quality over quantity Camila is more dynamic? What kind of dynamic she has done?

[@degraciaanibal8836]

Camila no era la mejor cantando ni la mejor de las chica pero se hacía notas y tenía buenas notas 😮❤️

[@xxmoonlightxx5742]

does anyone know their supported ranges? cause for a very long time I've heard that dinahs supported range is a3-a4 which I never believed someone pls correct me if I'm wrong with their supported ranges since I'm not 100% sure besides Lauren's Ally: g#3/a3-c#5/d5-f#5/g5(?)( idk if I'm even close to right with her hv) normani: g3/g#3-g4/g#4(?) Lauren: f#3-b4/c5 camilla: (?)g3/g#3-a4/bb4(?)

[@soprano2087]

You can find their consistent support range on the description.

[@xxmoonlightxx5742]

@@soprano2087 ty

[@PsychoticProductions3]

5th - Camila : so I put Camila at the bottom cause she is always dodging notes and never actually does the notes 4th - Normani - her notes at very weak she can’t really do any high but a lot of low 3 - Ally - Allys so amazing with her notes can reach D4 - D5 2 - Lauren -she is in second place (maybe I think allly should be here)because she is so soulful can support F5 1 - Dinah ❤- she is the best singer and go as high as F6 and is constant with her notes and is beautiful

[@allykelly]

This is very innacurate

[@PsychoticProductions3]

Well I guess Lauren shouldn’t be over ally I guess

[@allykelly]

@@PsychoticProductions3 why

[@randomlyhere111]

10:35 🥵

[@nikimays8533]

Ok it's 2022 you need to previous music of fifth harmony which is the girls solo music because to get a proper vocal analysis.

[@allykelly]

There's not enough of live materials especially Normani, ally and Dinah Lauren and Camila r more active in live it's just a vocal analysis not vocal analysis+journey

[@jihyosmicrophone638]

who has the widest vocal range out of the 5?

[@allykelly]

Normani

[@llllll7686]

who's better madison beer or lauren?

[@khushiana9901]

madison has better lows, belts, headvoice n agility

[@varunravi27]

I'd say Madison. She's better than Lauren in every aspect (except for lows: they're equal in that aspect but Lauren can get a bit too breathy below F3).

[@xxmoonlightxx5742]

so there isn't much of a difference between Lauren and dinah in terms of technique (mid register) ?

[@allykelly]

Dinah has stronger coordination and better vowel shaping Dinah sounds more open than Lauren

[@xxmoonlightxx5742]

​@@allykelly ik this is late to ask but what about when they were on x factor?

[@xxmoonlightxx5742]

​@@allykelly also would u say that the ranking of their upper registers would of like this? 1 Ally 2 normani 3 dianh 4camilla 5 Lauren I would put camilla last due to her having so much airiness but on the flip side Lauren barely uses her upper register

[@allykelly]

@@xxmoonlightxx5742 agree but Dinah>Normani her falsetto is more controlled

[@allykelly]

@@xxmoonlightxx5742 X factor days Ally A3/Bb3-C#5 Dinah A3/Bb3-C5 Lauren G3/G#3-B4/C5 Camila G#3-A4/Bb4 Normani G#3-G4

[@degraciaanibal8836]

Como que en la segunda categoría camila de 4? Eso sonó increíble. Toco notas que Lauren no pudo. Camila era 3

[@oceanwave_]

Thank you for this video! I swear an objective vocal analysis on Fifth Harmony is hard to find these days haha. Just wanted to ask: is Little Mix’s Perrie on the same vocal ranking as Ally? Last time I heard they were close so I’m wondering if that’s still the case 🤔

[@allykelly]

Ally is a bit higher

[@GarageStudio7]

@@allykelly On a technical level, overall it's the other way around.

[@allykelly]

@@GarageStudio7 overall it's still ally cuz the huge gap in middle register (main register) says a lot

[@PezAuras]

Nah Perrie is higher by a good bit - she is more Well-Rounded as a Vocalist ….. Only Belting/Mixed Register goes to Ally Lower register, Upper Register & Agility goes to Perrie 💯

[@allykelly]

@@PezAuras well rounded=\=better vocalists ally and perries gap in lows, head voice and agility doesn't do much in winning against ally, ally display much healthier technique and more sustainable than Perrie

[@khushiana9901]

r they better than lm?

[@allykelly]

Yes

[@puntroo_]

who is lm?

[@allykelly]

@@puntroo_ little mix a British girl group

[@puntroo_]

@@allykelly I see but it seems quite surprising seeing them vocally worse than FH

[@allykelly]

@@puntroo_ i mean Dinah and Lauren already outsing all members except for perrie

[@xxmoonlightxx5742]

Would u say that Lauren was worse during her decline than camilla? Or maybe even the likes of normani

[@allykelly]

Camila yes but Normani not she's bad

[@xxmoonlightxx5742]

@@allykelly ok what was her supported range during her decline?

[@allykelly]

@@xxmoonlightxx5742 she was just free around G3/G#3-G#4

[@xxmoonlightxx5742]

@@allykelly dang she declined that bad?

[@allykelly]

@@xxmoonlightxx5742 well her voice was all throaty and raspy

[@KajiVocals]

Typo in the title just saying

[@r.uwamhenye8282]

Took the words outta my mouth💀💀💀

[@allykelly]

Fixed

[@r.uwamhenye8282]

@@allykelly slayed😍😍

[@MariaLima-vl2uy]

Lauren is better than lily?

[@allykelly]

No Lauren is high A-AA lily is high AA

[@MariaLima-vl2uy]

@@allykelly what does it take for lily to be a proficient vocalist?

[@allykelly]

@@MariaLima-vl2uy lack of fullness and chest on her belt and weak lows

[@MariaLima-vl2uy]

@@allykelly thank you

[@zorin7171]

and what levels

[@allykelly]

If they're translated to KVA tiering system Ally - Proficient Dinah - above average Lauren - average~above average Camila - weak~average Normani - weak

[@ivan-vu3op]

@@allykelly one question? And in blackpink?

[@allykelly]

@@ivan-vu3op Rose : weak to average Jennie : weak Lisa : non vocalist Jisoo : non vocalist

[@ivan-vu3op]

@@allykelly rosé supported range at her best is A3 - B4 - C#5?

[@allykelly]

@@ivan-vu3op at best yes

[@tatum635]

Shocked camila isn’t number 1 for best runs….

[@allykelly]

No she's really not

[@lisafrandina5625]

Camila Cabello Is mermaid for me. I love you Camie