Doctor Who | Reaction & Review 4x12 - "Stolen Earth"

[@_FILMBuFF_]

*Channel Schedule* Monday - FMAB (1x1 May 24th Patreon | May 31st YT) Tuesday - Doctor Who Wednesday - Death Note Thursday - RDR2 (Saturday this week) Friday - Vinland Saga *4x13 "Journey's End"* Early Access available on Patreon *PATREON* - www.patreon.com/FILMBuFF *INSTAGRAM* - instagram.com/imsardar/ *TWITTER* - twitter.com/_FILMBuFF_

[@jplegend98]

God I remeber how the cliffhanger broke British society for a week lol.

[@martymclean3763]

And Australian society lol! Dude there is event television, then there is *that*

[@3y35poihjpn]

I was not happy... Waiting a week, I actually was going to call the BBC and ask how they can make the doctor regenerate in between a 2 parter... 😂

[@mattjcole908]

@@3y35poihjpn When Peter Davison regenerated into Colin Baker the new doctor had his first episode at the end of the season. So its not unheard of in who. Despite knowing david wasnt leaving at that point it was still a long week waiting to find out what was going to happen next.

[@3y35poihjpn]

@@mattjcole908 well that's not 100% the same for me, I heard on the news that there would be a new doctor and when the regeneration happened I was certain that was the last I saw of David Tennant... I was in pieces during that week

[@mattjcole908]

@@3y35poihjpn 😂 The news was trolling a nation then 😂 I think many might have expected a surprise regeneration but even back then i was well aware they wouldnt be able to keep it a secret... It would be another 2 years before we got the 11th doctor.

[@NickwBush]

The cliffhanger that sent the UK into a meltdown when it first aired

[@shadowphoenix1696]

oh I was still in school and everyone was talking about it, even people who didn't like or watch Doctor who were talking about it like it was the biggest thing to ever happen.

[@RubyMadigan]

The subwave was created by the Mr Copper foundation. Mr Copper was the guy from Voyage of the Damned who The Doctor brought to earth

[@VolrinSeth]

"I can have a house, with a garden and a door!" ... "Yahey!"

[@happiestaku6646]

And he ended up helping everyone.

[@ozzie1397]

Oh snap! Never realised lol

[@AmazingChi]

Makes the ending of Voyage that little bit more poignant, with the whole discussion about who lives and who dies. Mr Copper survived and ultimately saves the universe.

[@franl155]

@@VolrinSeth - lol he certainly came a long way! given his "earth history" I'd have bet that he'd be conned out of his money in a week. he must have been a very quick learner.

[@GoodKingMort]

This episode was The Avengers before The Avengers 😎

[@shadowphoenix1696]

And better than most of them.

[@MarcusSoares101]

Imagine watching this live as a kid and having to wait a whole week to find out what happens...

[@SpiderBatFan]

Yeah that was probably the hardest week of my childhood, the lack of a next time trailer didn’t help either !

[@olliemacallister1739]

I remember when this episode came out it was all anyone would talk about at school for a week after

[@obiwankenobi687]

Those were the days 😭 nowadays you’d be embarrassed to admit you watch the show at school

[@olliemacallister1739]

@@obiwankenobi687 good old days 😭

[@theblackswordsman9951]

@@obiwankenobi687 I doubt kids even watch it now.

[@larrystylinson3996]

not in Turkey😩

[@robvanriot]

People already loved David Tennant as the Doctor, but they didn't know quite now much they loved David Tennant as the Doctor until the final few minutes of this episode when he was brutally ripped away without warning. An iconic moment in British TV history

[@rossross3689]

I seen the pain in your eyes when you realised the doctor was regenerating. I know that pain. I felt that pain. Future doctors always take a few episodes to get used to but you end up loving them all over again.

[@chrisbeggs4061]

It is SUCH a pleasure watching Film BUFF's emotional reactions, and then hearing his intelligent analysis too... STANDOUT

[@franl155]

It took me about half an episode to accept the new Doctor - and DT is my all-time favourite

[@Dr_Rich740]

People knew Tennant was leaving at some point but this surprise ending managed to get on the tv news because it was unexpected.

[@franl155]

I don't watch TV, wonder if I can find any old news broadcasts ...

[@mattjcole908]

Yes but most knew he wasn't leaving at that point. That being said it did get people wondering though. Honestly id love a genuine surprise regeneration without announcement of who has been cast.

[@martymclean3763]

Davros was introduced in 'Genesis of the Daleks' with Four, Sarah Jane and Harry. If there's only one Classic story you react to, that one should be it.

[@CrankyGrandma]

Absolutely! It is important for future episodes too.

[@martymclean3763]

@@CrankyGrandma Particularly for series 9. But that’s a long way off yet. 🤫

[@Hanmacx]

"Harriet Jones, Former Prime Minister" "Yes we know who you are"

[@emmaconnolly5738]

Oh my goodness! You have no idea how quickly I clicked on this, been waiting for this reaction for ages! So good! 😊 And that expression on your face at the end? Exactly the same as mine was! No one saw that coming!

[@1funkyflyguy]

Davros (Lord and creator of the Dalek Race) first appeared in Classic Who in the early 70's, and was partly the inspiration for the character of Palpatine/Darth Sidious in the Star Wars movies. Star Wars has a lot to thank Dr. Who for!

[@michaelhunter2742]

To this day one of the most epic finals and jaw dropping cliffhangers ever!! At this point i was coming home from school and watching Sarah jane adventures, staying up late to watch torchwood and of course Doctor who on Saturday! So to see not only the characters but the shows come together was just such an amazing beautiful moment!

[@cyberdalek615]

It's a shame that Tennant had to go, especially out of the blue like that. Still, at least we've got a new incarnation to look forward to in the next episode, who I like just as much as Ten. What are the chances of that?

[@franl155]

Eleven was good, and hit the floor running. Though "my Doctor" will always be Ten

[@franl155]

This is like Christmas Eve! We all know what's in your present, and half the joy for us is going to be watching you unwrap it - the other half is in the anticipation of your reaction

[@MiTaReX]

I wonder if you'd be interested in watching Torchwood. Has some genuinely amazing episodes.

[@hgwells1899]

Apparently that's where John Barrowman often used to hang out on set

[@jemaselite8076]

@@hgwells1899 😂

[@HarryLiamReeves]

You’ve just got a sub from me!! I love when reactors really get involved in the show and really get to know it! There’s quite a few reactors that don’t get it seasons in and don’t catch lots of throwbacks and quotes which is quite disappointing! Can’t wait to see more 😄

[@clownspit]

the uproar this cliffhanger caused

[@hgwells1899]

Brits: Sarah Jane! Davros!! Regeneration!!? FB: Khaaaaaaaaaaann!!!

[@ollymaitland1411]

Ah yes. Stolen Earth, an absolutely phenomenonal episode and definitely the best episode in Series 4 for me. Seeing your reaction was amazing, I loved it!

[@senpai_lol8171]

I remember watching this live and crying a bunch at end :'( and having to wait a week oof worst cliffhanger i experienced as i think 14/15 year old haha xD

[@LORDdrPepper]

This was like the end game for doctor who back in the day, absolute greatness

[@StephanieMaireFaith]

Remember the episode voyage of the damned, the old guy the doctor took to earth 🌍 he was mr copper, from the Mr copper foundation who helped Harriet Jones

[@michaelbastraw1493]

You picked up so quickly on Dalek Caan being involved, I'm surprised you didn't appear to recognize the name Mister Copper. Best. Leo.

[@timsimmons4283]

Bernard Cribbins (national treasure) was in the non canon 60's Dalek movie with Peter Cushing as Doctor Who.

[@jdsnicket7872]

Agree with so many other comments. UK was abuzz that week! Was genuinely a tv event! The only dud for me in this episode was that the Shadow Proclamation was underwhelming, felt like like a cheaply converted office space in BBC Wales. 🤣

[@juliet1203_]

I can see RTD doing this again in the last season of his new era, but actually changing the Doctors face without announcing anything

[@Stuart_Cox1969]

Please do a reaction to "classic Dr Who" episode, "Genesis of the Daleks", it will explain Davros, you'll love it (I hope).

[@iansmith4023]

To quote from a totally different franchise: Make it so!

[@cjbrett89]

Ah, the cliffhanger that broke the nation!

[@michaelbastraw1493]

I assume that, by now, someone has recommended Genesis of the Daleks. Count my vote twice, my mailman thinks so too. Best. Mike.

[@matthill3293]

My only gripe about this episode is the lack of interaction between Jack and Rose. I'd have thought they'd have a lot of catching up to do but I think "You know what happens next" is the only direct dialog between the two for the entire story.

[@matthill3293]

@@secondeye1574 She does. No idea why she talks like she's got her back teeth sown together in Turn Left. She doesn't do it in this one or the one after =/

[@matthill3293]

@@secondeye1574 Ohhh fair enough, I didn't know that. Probably owe her an apology lol. Strange that it just that one episode though, I didn't think they block filmed like that.

[@ms_scribbles]

@@secondeye1574 You heard right. While David was filming Midnight, another crew was with the rest of them filming Turn Left.

[@SGlitz]

It is the end...and the moment has been preparedfor....

[@DaBigIsh]

Infinity War before Infinity War! Thanks for uploading this on my birthday! :)

[@highjim7778]

The bit where he thinks its rose tuning into the video call, then hearing davros is so well done, other than the valeyard, davros is the doctors worst nightmare. He thought he was getting what he wanted the most, and got what he wanted the least.

[@sandi8362]

You're gonna love Matt Smith.

[@ruthbell3942]

I would LOVE to see you react to Torchwood and the Sarah Jane Adventures... please?

[@franl155]

And some Classic Who; one story immediately leaps to mind ...

[@michaelbastraw1493]

"Butterfly!" Distracted by small flying things, are we? Best. Leo.

[@my_oddities234]

Yes! I was so excited to see you react to this one!

[@franl155]

I leaped on this vid as soon as I got the notification: now I have to wait for the next one! I only saw this on DVD, so I was able to skip right to the next episode: I bet it must have been agony for those having to wait a whole week to see it on TV! And I bet the forums were alight, too. I recognised Davros almost immediately, and levitated about six inches out of my chair with the force of my shriek. Sarah Jane would have instantly recognised him as well, of course. Can we spare a few kudos for Nicholas Briggs for the Dalek voices? Caan especially ps I don't know why Rose bothered to carry a gun: she could have got the Dalek before it got the Doctor [she had three "exterminate!"s to bring her gun up], or even after, but luckily Jack arrived to do it - and lucky he materialised facing the right direction! pps 71st to comment. For this channel, that's like being in the top ten!

[@cyberdalek615]

Dalek exterminates the Doctor: Closed Captions: Applause

[@chrisboot2468]

Suggest you watch some classic series, particularly "Genesis of the Daleks"

[@jennifermorris6848]

If this crushed you . . . Part 2 says hold my beer.

[@opaopa6272]

That Dalek felt like Hot Shit for like 10 seconds before getting vibe checked

[@ms_scribbles]

This had to have been so confusing for someone who never watched either Torchwood or The Sarah Jane Adventures.

[@Dannydarko27]

I hadn't seen any classic Who but Davros have me chills nonetheless, I love seeing him on screen

[@ErisRising]

"All the big guns are here" Rose: *Teleports in with a BFG* Was that edit intentional?

[@dutchman8887]

fun enough episode. bit over the top sometimes with trying to trick the audience but its ok. harriet is the best bit of this. 8/10.

[@bananasaregood8655]

Sneaky reference to a 1st doctor dalek story when the doctor says that someone tried to move the earth once before, long time ago...aka the dalek invasion of earth

[@franl155]

Wasn't that a [non-canon] film with Peter Cushing as the Doctor?

[@chrisbeggs4061]

@@franl155 The two Cushing movies were re-makes of [canonical] first Doctor TV stories. In the TV version, this story was also when the Doctor and his Grand-daughter [art company...

[@ms_scribbles]

@@franl155 No, it was a canonical William Hartnell story from 1964 called The Dalek Invasion of Earth. It's the story where the Doctor left Susan on Earth.

[@bookswithike3256]

@@franl155 There is no Doctor Who canon. The Peter Cushing films are a different continuity. But they also exist as films in the show's universe.

[@CrankyGrandma]

You should watch classic Who episode Genesis of the Daleks, with Sarah Jane, the fourth doctor, and Davros

[@10thdoctor15]

A lot is done in this story to make the Daleks seem more powerful than ever - a basic drone dalek shot the Doctor when important Daleks have tried frequently, the new musical score, the references to the Dalek Invasion of Earth (1964)...

[@phtevenj]

Fun Fact: David Tennant didnt know that Billie Piper was on set until Donna said 'why dont you ask her yourself', and they hadnt filmed together in a long time at that point, so his excited reaction was genuine...

[@charg1nmalaz0r51]

doubtful he would have read the script lol

[@demonic_myst4503]

serah janes spn is adopted he was created by aliens he a artificial alien that was created by a alien race trying to invade earth in the first episode of serah jane adventures he was adopted by her at the end of the episode so hepretty smart he was born a teenager with alot of knolledge downloaded into his brain

[@cyberdalek615]

you know, he could have found this info out by watching sja at somepoint.

[@demonic_myst4503]

@@cyberdalek615 its about as knowledgably as saying the doctor travels in time it has no impact on serah jane cronicles, by watching this episode u already know he becomes her son by seeing him in episode on u allready know what will happen just from seing this episode

[@cyberdalek615]

@@demonic_myst4503 true, but you basically spoiled how he becomes her son. You could have not said anything except that he's in Sarah Jane ADVENTURES, That way. if FB is curious enough, then he might consider checking out SJA at some point. Yes, you can very clearly see that Luke is her son, anyone watching this finale would work that out and wouldn't need the spinoff to confirm it. However, there was no part of the finale at all that mentions Luke's background besides maybe one or two offhand references (don't know, it's been a while since i've seen this episode properly. Though, whereas people who watch SJA would get the references, others won't.

[@demonic_myst4503]

@@cyberdalek615 u can put the background together with a fully functioning cognitive brain and 2 scenes of the first episode it wasnt a suprise at all

[@cyberdalek615]

@@demonic_myst4503 yeah, two scenes from the first episode which probably take up about quarter of the runtime. Without watching SJA, people will only get that he's her son. That's it.

[@Emburbujada]

I'm glad you figured out that this wasn't the "real" regeneration for Tennant =)

[@shubhamsharma2923]

Is there any update on review video of Attack on Titan

[@cazndave]

Great reaction! 🙂👍🏾

[@jeckjeck3119]

So good.

[@canadian__ninja]

Avengers: Infinity War but cooler.

[@owaisshahzad9255]

please start reacting to the anime called: erased.people don't hype it up but really it's a good show for you like the show doesn't even waste our time make sure you watch it.youtuber's tend to follow a line like ant's,waching because people hyped it up or many people are reacting to it.

[@aliceackerman7902]

Actually its not good for Im only because I CANNOT BELIEVE HOW EASE it was for me to predict everything. Im not kidding im not as goot at predicting and making theoried as Im but i still knew what was going on. Yes he may react to the story but he will complain how obvious everything was so idk

[@aliceackerman7902]

Hey Im, I dont think you will get good amount of views for FMAB, not many new subscribers and hence not much channel growth, sadly... i predict lesser views than death note. FMAB is an old show, it may be good but not as popular as dn. Both are old and the popular one(dn) barely gets you views. I think you doing patreon polls is not a good idea if you want channel growth. Suppose out of you 1k patreons 500 voted for fmab then only the old people stay that think youll like this stuff based on what YOU MIGHT LIKE, dosent mean OTHERS(especially new commers) want that those 500 will get yoy 500 views for sure but youll barely get 1 or 2k more(probably 3 to 5k every ep maximum). If my prediction turns out to be true i suggest make free polls next time and see what majority wants and more people will come to your channel. And MORE people will join patreon aswell instead of you trying to listen to and please old patreons.

[@Frenk33]

first

[@somedudeontwitterstalkedme3829]

"Doctor Who Infinity War" before Marvel's "Infinity War"

[@shadowphoenix1696]

And DW did it better.

[@somedudeontwitterstalkedme3829]

All Hail the Rise of the 11th, the Doctor who tore a fandom apart, because for some they moved on to quickly from the brilliance of the 10th, to fall in love with the 11th.... "You watch him run"

[@sallyatticum]

hahaha

[@franl155]

It took me about half an episode to accept Eleven - but Ten is still my all-time favourite

[@sallyatticum]

@@franl155 I liked Eleven right away, but liked him less as time went on. Not his fault, really. I didn't love the stories.

[@franl155]

@@sallyatticum - whew, I thought it was just me! I wasn't nearly so enthralled by his later series as I was by his first. PS: I don't belong to any fan sites or groups, I have no input or output with other fans, so what they think doesn't affect me, any more than what I think can possibly affect them.

[@somedudeontwitterstalkedme3829]

@@sallyatticum We know Eleven's entire run, the fans of 10 made sure to let everyone know, exactly how they felt, that is why the fandom is split, we no longer have fansites and "whovians", is no longer a monoker, I carry.