First Reaction to Tally Hall - Good & Evil (2011)

[@The_Void_Constellation]

If you hate Joe Hawley's writing then you'll definitely love his album "Joe Hawley Joe Hawley"

[@samcheese4303]

Brad doing a JHJH reaction would be incredible

[@user-vw4xq5lw5l]

Yes

[@chouts1]

I always thought JHJH would be something brad would enjoy more than miracle musical or the tally hall albums

[@baja_lawmaster]

@@chouts1 I feel like he'd go from hating it to liking it to HATING it every 30 seconds lol

[@stinkystinkypoopystinkypeepee]

He's still gonna hate it but I'm interested to see his reaction

[@themandownstairs4765]

Brad only doesn't like this band because their albums make you whiter and he's worked hard to get his mild tan

[@menu.config]

SHEEEEESH

[@witchflowers6942]

this comment reminds me if that episode of S Class early 2000s scripted MTV reality show “Next”, where the mall goth kid says he spent a week on his tan for his date. (yes, the himbo douche bag immediately said “Next!” upon seeing him. it made me cry)

[@BloxySnow]

i was about to say you roasted him but then he would get his tan back

[@NerdPersonUwU]

That's a rare burn.

[@marcinswiecicki6713]

Good that I'm Polish. We are so pale that Tally Hall effect does not touch me.

[@stinkystinkypoopystinkypeepee]

He memorised the first lyrics to Good Day he's secretly having a romance with Tally Hall

[@suburbiaa]

He did it with introduction to the snow/dream sweet in sea major as well..I think the answer is clear

[@Johnny_Sweatpants]

@@suburbiaa "It fEeLs lIKe WeRe FlyiNG, buT MaYBe wE'Re DyINg"

[@riley6875]

brad not liking tally hall is like having to choose which parent gets custody of you

[@sonsique]

brad

[@Grizzlymoose0]

@@sonsique fr not a too difficult decision

[@NEMOsleeps24]

I don't like Tally Hall but I do like musical miracle. I understand Brad hates both though

[@zubinsedghibassguitar]

@@NEMOsleeps24I love tally hall and all the extra things 💀💀💀 understand you fully tho

[@requiem808]

Tally hall fans glaze mid bro sorry

[@waluigicultmember2539]

I think this guy might like Tally Hall and especially Joe Hawley

[@stinkystinkypoopystinkypeepee]

Oops

[@jh8466]

I am sure he would really appreciate the Joe Hawley Joe Hawley album

[@stinkystinkypoopystinkypeepee]

@@jh8466 no

[@rightdownright]

@@Beowolf-jy5rc thought this as well, he would either hate every bit of it or slightly praise it for being original. as we all know, he hates when things are original but not original enough because then its just theatrecore and boring. chonny also loves voice effects esp with minds voice so like

[@glassofwater281]

@@Beowolf-jy5rcHe would probably see it as cringe garbage seeing how much he hated Hawaii Part ii for being too deep and seemingly "pretentious"

[@ismaill_l]

WE DID IT BOYS edit: im sad now

[@gabrielfehlau8626]

I love his unreasonable hatred it's perfect I will watch him hate my favourite band forever

[@MichaelTurner856]

Idk why but I hate it. Even though I love Bradley. Not liking Joe is valid but the music is amazing. I guess it just hurts to see my favorite band that's inspired me so much and always has kept me happy continually bashed like it's all trash and "theater core" like that's a bad thing. Definitely a me issue but I just wanted to say It here.

[@moldybongwater3808]

@@MichaelTurner856 the issue i have is that he constantly shits on the music for being "boring" but he repetitively uses the same 5 words to describe it thus his criticisms are WAY more boring than the actual music

[@AliceBunny05]

@@MichaelTurner856 honestly I just wouldn't take it very seriously. it's one man's opinion in a sea of 7 billion people, I'm a kpop fan and we know how much brads chat loves kpop lol. even if he's going to diss things I like, it dosent have any effect because the only thing that matters is whether I like something. I think the trick is to just not take things personally, because ultimately if brad likes something or not really only impacts one thing: his personal music taste.

[@egg6838]

No his hatred is completely reasonable Tally Hall is the worst band ever and I would rather listen to Corey Feldman

[@gabrielfehlau8626]

@@egg6838 sure go do that then

[@man4437]

Brad when a song uses basic musical elements 😡😡😡

[@LifetimeDisaster]

This is literally so boring and repetitive omgggg 🙄

[@silli_clownmaeda]

Real

[@the_very_cozy_burrito]

​@@LifetimeDisaster man seeing someone call the album that contains &, cannibal, and turn the lights off boring old music hurts

[@damprat141]

this man would hate my main playlist

[@armoredman6941]

This guy must’ve been punched in the gut by Joe hawley or something

[@laterlars]

A lot of him want to listen to lemon demon, which I agree with, but also I wonder how he'd feel about steam powered giraffe. We need more of the theatre core of the 2010s, it's too funny

[@rymmusicfan713]

Steam Powered Giraffe has some bops tho (like Honeybee), the vocals really make the band and pairs well with acoustics. Lemon Demon reminds me a lot more of Tally Hall except more electronic.

[@mr.froglegs]

He quite likes lemon demon, but I dunno how'd he would react to steam powered giraffe. Bet he'd dislike em

[@smoot2337]

he reacted to honeybee on a livestream and said the song was okay but the aesthetic made it cringey, that was like 2 years ago though

[@robo-ert5754]

Steam Power Giraffe is actually really good. I feel like he'd enjoy the stuff

[@DoctorTheo]

I really want him to react to Will Wood, my prediction is that he's going to he very mixed on him

[@jamspan]

as a person who loves "&" i'm in tears rn

[@Starjellybear]

Real 😿

[@rinamine]

i love tally hall and miracle musical but brad's reactions are SO funny and honestly valid criticisms. i'm never scared to see his reactions to music i like bc beneath all of the dramatic "hatred", i never feel attacked. he gives everything a fair shot, isn't scared to change his opinions, and always is sure to point out the things he likes even when he hates the songs. big baller b supremacy 🔥

[@_mono_01]

SAME his reactions are hilarious

[@PenguinPoo4246]

Agreed

[@fries5849]

Brad taste in music and Tally Hall. The Ultimate love/hate relationship

[@BradTasteInMusicOfficial]

It’s all hate

[@fries5849]

@@BradTasteInMusicOfficial even better

[@bean_eater1209]

@@BradTasteInMusicOfficial tsundere head ahh

[@honeycomblord9384]

@@bean_eater1209 The hell is a tsundere?

[@lefishe6611]

@@honeycomblord9384 Someone who acts hostile to someone they like so that they'll like them back

[@theafterparty2264]

i could not agree with this less but i still love to hear this man talk about them

[@theafterparty2264]

okay maybe i kinda understand

[@jo0syjuice]

Just found ur channel and love ur streams but bro, you can't say Tally Hall is generic crap and then give like 5 examples of "interesting" songs that sound like the physical embodiment of hotdog water

[@roland066]

Fr 💀

[@charliegriswold1445]

Did you call helplessness blues hotdog water? Are you on crack?

[@joshuukun]

uh oh, the tally hall subreddit is gonna have a field day with this one

[@cheerio4000]

bruh I forgot how badly he just tears apart the band ☠️

[@thedogfromraditude5449]

“Wake me up when December ends” that broke me

[@logdog1]

8/10

[@you-hype-child5104]

Brad, I love you and this band. I can't choose between you two. You gotta stop! 😭😭😭

[@mocapcow2933]

You have to choose

[@snailqueen9291]

No they dont

[@aronbeyhan3426]

@@snailqueen9291 se see was ae on

[@houston1342]

@@aronbeyhan3426 ??

[@DocSlayingyoudown]

You do not have to choose, you can choose both

[@benbrian9884]

brad should definitely to “the first glass beach album”, it’s literally the theatre core sound he makes fun of but actually good

[@hugebirden5242]

LITERALLY THOUGH the album is so good

[@unnamechannel]

OH MAN ITS SO GOOD I wouldn't really say its theatercore tho

[@TeShiky]

They Might Be Giants too

[@EpicTuna12]

Yesss

[@Pr0t3ins]

HOLY SHIT GLAS BEAFH YE

[@KoopaKaper]

more like brad taste in haircut

[@stinkystinkypoopystinkypeepee]

He likes Tally Hall get him

[@SpeedCorpse]

Brad, please give spirit phone by lemon demon a listen! I would love to see your reaction to the album

[@lemonpit6264]

YESYES YES

[@Goatythemeow]

this

[@youtubeuserdan4017]

I think he might like that significantly more than this album.

[@SpeedCorpse]

@@youtubeuserdan4017 yeah, DEFINITELY- tally hall is very much shit but there is a few bangers, kinda lol

[@asafan94]

THIS^^^^

[@chaseleedaleno6823]

Turn The Lights Off gives off the energy of Ray William Johnson trying to make a Serious Your Favorite Martian Rock Song

[@spoony8485]

I want him to react to all the popular theatre core albums until he either finds one he likes or hates them all

[@DoctorTheo]

He really likes Mr Bungle if that counts

[@steelingcable6350]

@@DoctorTheo Mr Bungle is not theatre core

[@DoctorTheo]

@@steelingcable6350 It absolutely is

[@dddw.]

@@its_a_poncho lol no

[@yeethittter1285]

O My Heart shd be next. the gay teenagers side of the fanbase WILL get a W 👊👊

[@maxord11]

Will Wood's Self-ish album is a really fun, short listen. Lot of energy and interesting variety on the album.

[@DoctorTheo]

Agreed

[@spaghetti5914]

That's my favorite album lmao

[@lemonp3r50n7]

The normal album is a good one too

[@SkootSkeet69]

Finally another will wood fan on something that’s not will wood related ✊✊✊✊✊

[@james8183]

@@lemonp3r50n7 disagree............

[@jasonee3233]

I love the more upbeat parts of the album with songs like & or Turn the lights off.But the rest dragggggsss. I wish the entire album kept up the energy of those two and clearly so does everyone else based off of their most listened tracks

[@wabbajocky8235]

alright at first i hated you for hating tally hall but now i don't really care anymore, i just want you to react to every single piece of tally hall related music so that i can watch you say that you hate them all

[@VijiogFrito]

what about the tracks he liked?

[@flech9742]

i never felt so betrayed

[@kennnnny]

I have some somewhat nostalgic memories associated with Tally Hall since they kinda came in a box pack with Lemon Demon and Will Wood to other post mid to late 2010s animation kids like me. Weird niche of kids and interests, but trust me, it was the case for more kids than you’d think. Saying ‘kid’ for the lack of a better word here because there were a lot adults ofc, but it was mostly people in middle or high school. I’ll listen to Banana Man or & from time to time (hell, I actually still like that one edit of The Mind Electric, same for the original. Cannibal too! Turn The Lights off I still adore ofc) but they’re not as replay-able as they used to be. I’m in a weird situation with them where I don’t really hate or dislike them because of my psuedo-nostalgia but I also don’t really care for the band members or music because I just… evolved I guess? Necessary Cringe that all kids need to survive and be humbled I guess lmfao

[@jeremyusreevu237]

I personally like that kind of stuff.

[@alienenthusiast]

Same here. Something about this type of music draws in animation memers.

[@retorikhal]

@@alienenthusiast i dont wanna be mean or anything but that phenomenon is called "theatre kid music"

[@iamssmrt5298]

tally hall and Brad taste in music is like jam and tomato sauce. most people dont like them together, but i do (:

[@basil4154]

What the actual fuck

[@pescaditos]

You like jam and tomato sauce TOGETHER?...

[@Lily_...]

Imagine him listening to chonny jash 😭

[@arcitheanonymousbird_04]

he would rip him to shreds if he hates this

[@bruhmomentmaker4979]

This might be the review that gets Brad shot

[@adamjarrett5490]

probably self inflicted

[@sadboizigzag]

I’m not trying to imply that criticism against tally hall is invalid, but I feel like often Brad hates songs just because he doesn’t understand the lyrics immediately. That’s why Cannibal was his favorite initially, but upon later listens he realized there wasn’t much more to uncover. Too often Brad just reads the lyrics and scoffs without explaining why they suck.

[@BradTasteInMusicOfficial]

The sound of the songs is so unbelievably boring, that trying to make sense of these overwritten contrived lyrics feels like more of a chore, and less of a way to enjoy the music more. When I figure out the lines and my first instinct is cringing too, that stops me from continuing with the decoding part.

[@sadboizigzag]

@@BradTasteInMusicOfficial that’s fair. i appreciate the reply! so i guess you operate on a music > lyrics basis more often than not?

[@Karatekat314]

@@BradTasteInMusicOfficial you might enjoy Will Wood a bit then, the music has a lot of thought in the writing and is anything but boring in my personal opinion. Granted, it's a lot of words thrown at you all at once, but if you look past that it's pretty enjoyable to unpack. The Normal Album is very much unique in the stylistic aspect, would recommend.

[@leethejailer9195]

@@Karatekat314 he would hate will wood bro lmao

[@Karatekat314]

All the more entertaining I suppose haha

[@Gomberto2000]

I would rather jump into the saw 2 needle pit than continue watching this review, I love it

[@becketclark9942]

This album was practically built for brad to hate it. I cant wait hahaha

[@becketclark9942]

I love tally hall and Brad and im so hyped for this hahaha

[@genyakozlov1316]

Personal opinions is one thing, all art is subjective, but check out all the people who are smugly proud their opinions align with Brad's, to the point of bradgging about "growing up" by changing their tastes to match his. Like, congratulations on not having an original thought in your head? Congratulations on being a part of an exclusive club? What are you bradgging about exactly? If it's "being better than the plebeians who dare to still like what I no longer do", than congratulations on being that insecure about your age and your taste I guess. Wanting to superficially seem bradult is a sign of immaturity, as that is a reason most kids want to do bradult stuff, but go off I guess.

[@genyakozlov1316]

I guess

[@ObjectivelyL]

My opinion on music doesn't really align with Brad's, but I still watch his videos, because it's interesting to see others opinion. I used to be a big Billy Joel fan, I used to listen to his music all the time, but then I discovered other artists who do what he does way better. I discovered better artists through what critics had to say. I don't claim that I 'grew up', I just say I refined my tastes.

[@Gloden]

HAHA When "Turn The Lights Off" came on I was like wtf cause I heard the song like 7 years ago in a Five Nights at Freddy's animation and a new memory unlocked.

[@TheGateShallStand]

Brad once again going insane because he hasn't yet realised his fans like everything he reacts to

[@CoachTomA2]

Brad only thinks he hates all the Joe songs. He likes some of the Joe songs. In reality, he hates all of the Rob songs.

[@wingednotepad]

with how you feel abt nonsensical lyrics; im rlly curious if ud be interested in doing a reaction to any of lemon demon's works. i personally rlly enjoy just abt everything he's put out but i know he's not necessarily everyone's cup of tea. even so, i think it's pretty cool how many things on the internet connect back to him

[@joshuahblevins]

He talked about lemon demon some on stream, he said it was everything he wished tally hall was.

[@ChildSlapper]

i really want him to review spirit phone and i have a feeling he's going to

[@explodingegg123]

dude i love lemon demon. i actually tend to revisit his music more than tally hall.

[@thelingeringartist]

@@explodingegg123 i have nonstop listened to Lemon Demon’s music even into my college years now.

[@mozart4344]

@@ChildSlapper spirit phone is an album I really like :) like with xOoOx’s music, making songs about stuff like silly conspiracy theories and legends are fun. Plus, Neil has some ridiculously hilarious music outside of spirit phone, like Jaws

[@parachutes6288]

Here is my one thought with the & song. It overall is not a bad songwriting idea in concept. However they fail to pull it off. If you gave a band like They Might Be Giants the prompt to make a song where every line ends with and, they could make something super fun and goofy that fits there asthetic well. It’s all about execution and keeping a style.

[@parachutes6288]

In fact, the song just feels like a bad attempt at trying to sound like TMBG

[@MichaelTurner856]

Tf I love &

[@HoneyAnimates]

me a giant fan of tally hall, joe hawley and hawaii part ii being my favorite album; this is great content 😍

[@soul0system]

you keep using that word, “pretentious”. i don’t think it means what you think it means jokes aside this review was funny as hell, i personally don’t like this album nearly as much as MMMM or HP2 so it’s hilarious to see you rip into it. some of the songs are very samey and they definitely overdo the vocal effects. it feels like this genre also just isn’t your style, considering all the times you’ve called it “theater-core” as an insult, and nobody can really blame you for that. now that you’re going down the Tally Hall rabbithole, you’ve got to listen to Joe Hawley Joe Hawley too. it’s hard to call an album pretentious when it’s insulting your mother on track 6.

[@Starjellybear]

He should listen to EDU

[@azariah_kyras]

This dude is the underthemayo of music criticism

[@owenmachine4656]

as somone with over 300 hours on ultrakill this comment is very accurate to how i feel about this guys critisisms on tally hall

[@thehauntedattic4279]

Fr, Resident Evil 8 isn’t THAT bad

[@xSmythosx]

tally hall is great to play as background music in a retail job where you’re too busy to pay attention to it but need something vaguely upbeat to keep from going insane and i have yet to find another setting in which i genuinely enjoy them

[@jeremyusreevu237]

I love Tally Hall. Their music is enjoyably fun, and Marvin's Marvelous Mechanical Museum is an amazing album.

[@demystifier8436]

@@jeremyusreevu237 more like marvins MID mechanical museum

[@foxnewsbutgood]

as someone who unnirronicly listens to tally hall, you are exacly right

[@electrisoma]

i usually listen to tally hall in the background while playing tf2 or any other chaotic fps

[@houston1342]

Existential torment I guess.

[@hiniku6886]

cannot wait for the joe hawley joe hawley 0/10

[@riiseingirl]

so sick of him only hating on joe and not the other members. there's 5 of them!!!! spread the hate evenly smh 🙄🙄🙄

[@Deejaynerate]

This album is like a family guy gag in the sense that it sounds alright for the first few seconds and then you realize that this is the entire bit

[@tweer64]

Same with KGLW

[@Cyaneth]

Marvin’s Marvelous Mechanical Museum is in my top 5 favorite albums ever and I do not blame Brad for not liking this. It has its moments but otherwise is ehhh.

[@jeremyusreevu237]

Same. Marvin’s Marvelous Mechanical Museum is so good!

[@MichaelTurner856]

They're both so great for me. Marvins is so whimsical beautiful and versatile and good and evil is just as beautiful with a more consistent sound. The writing is just as good imo. I mean Never Meant to Know, &, Misery Fell, Hymn for a Scarecrow, Sacred Beast, etc. It has The Trap on it for christ's sake. I can see how you might not like some of the tracks but even those grow on you. At least they did for me

[@Cyaneth]

@@MichaelTurner856 I do like the album more than I did when I wrote this comment, but there are still some tracks that I cannot stand. Who You Are never ends and Fate Of The Stars is a waste as the close to their discography. Just A Friend would’ve been a better closer. Having said that, I do like most of the album - Tracks 1 through 4 and 7 through 12 are good. I cannot stand Who You Are, You or Fate Of The Stars though. Sacred Beast is fine. I ordered the rerelease of the CD 15 minutes after it dropped. I’m really excited to get it next month

[@MichaelTurner856]

@@Cyaneth Awesome! I love Fate of The Stars personally but I'm glad you came around. Enjoy your CD :)

[@candy_shark]

i have gotten to the point of insanity where i cannot listen to any other music that is not tally hall related or tally hall itself without feeling uncomfortable.

[@starz879]

damn i hope you feel better

[@alecboi777]

my brain every five seconds is just: “joe hawley joe hawley joe hawley joe hawley basketball a basketball yeah well your mother is a basketball good day that is my name some of us wonder if you wanna die would you wanna die how i wonder ever wonder do you see banana man hopping over on the white hot sand marvin walked into a hopeless land and wondered lightly am i happy is this happy shia labeouff robert howard cantor zubin bus were in the minimall i dont feel like going to bed, lets play a rhyming game instead big bad betty of the pocalypse, she opened her lips and it goes like this; when the golden rule and the jungle meet, there will noone to wait for and noone go beat

[@candy_shark]

@@alecboi777 you just described all of my thoughts

[@henriantoinette]

I thought it was only me who had this problem

[@candy_shark]

@@henriantoinette nope, and as of yet nothing has changed for me.

[@crayonpepper]

23:32 ALONEEEE AND THE EDGE OF A UNIVERSE HUMING A TUNEEEE

[@Shift__11]

I like to imagine there's someone who is just skimming through this video like skipping around and everything and then they just see him start to react to modest mouse out of nowhere

[@mr.froglegs]

Cause, tbh, Tally Hall wanted to be like modest mouse but failed.

[@Multitudes-e5n]

I like how the future Bradley sections in this are the complete inverse of the future Bradley sections in the last one. Instead of the album growing on Bradley, he enjoys it less with each listen. Great stuff my guy, keep up the good work!

[@InvocationOfSebastian]

"this song sounds like another song and I like that song better therefore it's bad" is always a terrible criticism and will never not make you a hipster contrarian

[@Skiizophrenia]

I can’t get over the fact that he both looks and acts like a sixth grade boy 😭

[@obama281]

Do Joe Hawley Joe Hawley next. Beautiful album. 10/10

[@pikerp]

Oh he’d definitely love that

[@ismaill_l]

"your mother is a basketball" so deep

[@aracewi]

@@ismaill_l it truly is when you think about it

[@ismaill_l]

@@aracewi woah

[@milquetoast7618]

honestly, I had a hard time dealing with your MMMM review, since I'd kinda been obsessing about tally hall for like three months and I literally did not listen to any other music. But your content is really growing on me! I've gotten a lot better at not taking what I like too seriously, and not taking other people's opinions too seriously. I still enjoy tally hall a whole bunch, but my view on them has changed significantly- I recognise its flaws, especially within the members themselves, and I'm a lot more open to trying new music. So, uh... thanks?

[@douglasverbsky161]

You’re uploads are a blessing to my life bro tysm for uploading consistantly. I watch every video and your content lights up my life.

[@ASCENSiON_]

1:19 Trippy album covers work insanely well when the music itself actually makes you feel like you're tripping (such as The Crystal Method's Vegas). Tally Hall does the exact opposite lmao. 43:12 dammit Brad why do you gotta do this to me lmao

[@xamp_exclammark]

I think the cover to Pulse Demon by merzbow looks how the album sounds

[@maxwellpaynewell5305]

This is the first time I've ever heard The Crystal Method referenced outside of the intro to Splinter Cell, that alone deserves a like

[@ObjectivelyL]

I actually think the album cover works well with the sound, it tries to stand out, but it lacks color or anything to make it memorable at all dooms it to be forgettable.

[@basementhobo2288]

You should review a lemon demon album, like view-monster or spirit phone.

[@very.goodfella]

Hally Tall

[@fries5849]

41:56 can confirm. The second I found out who Kendrick Lamar, and Tame Impala were I lost like all interest in the band

[@jeremyusreevu237]

Bruh.

[@sadboizigzag]

tally hall fan base is cringe but imo that shouldn’t bleed into criticism for the art itself, and btw i listen to kendrick lamar and tame impala lollll

[@Milk88488]

That comment is so corny lmao. Guess what, I listen to one of those and tally hall!! 😰😨

[@memphoosle9561]

Really interested to hear Brad’s thoughts on Will Wood

[@user-xg6zz8qs3q]

Hey Brad! Please do a livestream with a special rule: all artists should have "giant" in the name. I promise you'll discover lots of great music 😜

[@ColeMcFlooid]

I wanna know what he thinks of Will Wood and The Tapeworms album Self-Ish

[@DoctorTheo]

I know that's he's mixed on Shovel, I played the whole song to him and while at first he hated it, part way through something clicked with him

[@certainpeople159]

I'd like to compliment this album for being great sleeping music!!! I'd like to.

[@Lilylouie27]

congrats on sleeping through Turn the Lights Off!

[@StealthKey]

@@Lilylouie27 ive actually slept to that on loop before

[@ahobbyist9520]

jack harlow made for amazing sleeping music

[@_.Dylan._]

Whereabouts of the Living Being’s Soul is the absolute best sleeping album

[@lurtz8656]

Oh no.... past Bradley knows about Future Bradley 😐

[@malkey2282]

"paul mccartney rolling in his grave" killed me

[@MrMixedGamerz]

Love the criticism once again man very valid complaints with the source material the second album fell massively compared to the first but "Paul McCartney is rolling in his grave" one of the only living memebers of the beatles

[@thegamingfungus884]

You make a decent amount of good points but I gotta say, I enjoy this album a lot. The clever lyrics and instrumentals are nice but I do agree on the mixing making it a bit harder to sit through.

[@emiliooffical3690]

wait a second, How is he wrong twice??

[@_BreadBoy_]

Is this where we ask him for Will Wood - The Normal Album

[@jeremyusreevu237]

The Normal Album is one of the best albums ever made.

[@ilngsisfh]

@@jeremyusreevu237 he’s gonna hate it

[@jeremyusreevu237]

@@ilngsisfh Lol.

[@explodingegg123]

i would love to see him react to will wood. he would hate him but it would be an entertaining watch.

[@thatcrystal]

I would pay for this

[@astrobear4205]

I can see why you don't like this album but the lyrical repetition keeps me sane. Grounded, even

[@holgerlarsson7531]

I listened this band quite a lot when i was about 14, and today I kinda cringe thinking about that. I’ve been waiting for you to react to this album though! Not because I think it’s very good (I remember this being about the same as their first but with not as low lows), but because your reaction to their first was so great! Will be fun to se how well my memory holds up! Edit: Wow I realize now I didn’t remember this album at al. Kinda glad you like Hymn of a scarecrow though as I think that’s the only song that still holds up for me today. And yeah you described 14 year old me perfectly at 41:57 lol

[@elliotk9291]

I hate to be the person that says "You just don't get it" but I really feel like that

[@harrywinn9838]

Brad ive heard the whole “spiritual lyrical” line being the most basic shit you could rap, but is rhyming Silence with Violence another instance of that? I had just never heard that before lol

[@happyhapsly]

Brad, respectfully, you are completely insane

[@glassofwater281]

I love Tally Hall but I always end up skipping about half of Good & Evil

[@Guy96477]

Same except with MMMM

[@rainydayjules]

man, the fact that theres been ANOTHER tally hall revival after the one I actively participated in in 2016 or so means I don’t get to be an elder who liked them at the time OR a new kid getting into them now. can’t believe this.

[@battleforkrabisland7405]

25:25 yes it was, minus the part about being as dull as possible. 1 note melodies were common in the early 2010s, difference is, most 1 note melodies were annoying, as they were designed to get stuck in your head.

[@Goatythemeow]

"wake me up when december ends"

[@garbageyoutubechannel310]

you say "pretentious" so much that it's lost all meaning

[@LifetimeDisaster]

Exactly, it's a buzzword for when he runs out of criticism

[@houston1342]

lol

[@genericalias6307]

And with the creation of this video, Joe Hawley has caught onto the scent of brad.

[@stinkystinkypoopystinkypeepee]

Wait like fr

[@paldiowebimbo6186]

I wounder what you would think about Nelward, and Will Wood aswell. Watching my favorite getting slammed was painful (You)

[@meow.5219]

yall his channel name is saying something remove the r in brad it says bad taste (this is a joke)

[@Trafoder]

Given you’ve listened to Hawaii: part II, I think you should listen to Not a Trampoline by Rob Cantor. It’s definitely different from his work here, but whether or not it’s better is subjective.

[@clockworkcadaver]

I like watching this guy because I get laugh at opinions opposite of mine

[@richardson100489]

Since I started following your channel I've become a lot more mindful and critical of what music I listen to. I've found a lot of the bands and artists I used to love just don't sound that great anymore. I'm thankful for my newfound appreciation for music, but I feel as though I don't know where to go to find good music now. Here's hoping you do more positive reaction videos to help give newbies like me a sense of direction. Either way keep it up your channel is great.

[@zephyrvezir5444]

Spotify is great for discovering music imho!

[@TheRealestSwag]

"Paul McCartney is rolling in his grave right now" -Brad

[@suburbanvibes3466]

I disagree, but the different take is interesting and I was entertained by this

[@nikane_]

Btw I'd suggest you use headphones or something, some songs do sound funny on speaker. Especially when you listen to Joe Hawley Joe Hawley

[@justyourdailymate2272]

I like Tally Hall but I get Brads criticisms. I would also like to clarify that from my knowledge Tally Hall hasn’t announced that they have broken up. Rob Cantor (yellow tie) has said that they are currently in, “Hibernation”.

[@Velvette._.]

As a tally hall fan, I always skip who you are

[@Velvette._.]

And my one complaint about hymn for a scarecrow is that the "fly" but goes on too long

[@stinkystinkypoopystinkypeepee]

Yyoooooou

[@stinkystinkypoopystinkypeepee]

Now you don't get a like from me

[@BrightyLighty_]

I want to see you tear apart Joe Hawley's "comedy rap" album Joe Hawley Joe Hawley

[@BrightyLighty_]

or perhaps you could "explore" some of the other Tally Hall solo albums... like Sketches 3D by Andrew or Not A Trampoline by Rob?

[@jaydevito914]

I wonder if Brad knows about the other successful solo member of Tally Hall, Rob Cantor, and his decently successful album Not A Trampoline.

[@riveraway]

Yoo Brad, you should do the Around The Fur album by Deftones. You listened to them once in the “Bad songs on good album” video.

[@waycic]

man after seeing the reddit post and answers on the ama , and again as a tally hall fan, this makes me crack up. thank you so much lmao

[@isitreallysandstorm]

never have i been so excited to see somebody hate on an album i like before

[@tinypileofpolydimethylsiloxane]

Brad when the song has a guitar in it (it's clearly a blatant ripoff of generic radio song # 20671)