The Ultimate Tally Hall Documentary

[@hiddeninthesand]

I approve of this documentary

[@LordHeg]

Me too Hidden In the Sand

[@spicynoodles4401]

Hi coz

[@MasterEth]

nice comment

[@greeneyem]

he came back again to make it clear

[@Official_Retrospective]

Ily hidden in the sand, please kiss my wife.

[@Stereo6400]

i cant beleive zubin got a medical degree, got married, had two children, worked on the front lines of the pandemic and even grew a full beard all just to bring us all the final evolution of the natural ketchup

[@Avivathebeatlemaniac]

What a true legend

[@2bruhiscool]

truly a victim of a cannibal

[@LazyLotusWater]

Ues😮(why does this happen to me why doesn't auto correct work)

[@justmusic2038]

1:14:41 Already thinking about Hawaii part ii

[@revoltcrisp]

he has a wonderful wife and a powerful job

[@CiggyRat]

"Ruler of Everything was the first complete song I wrote" Damn. My man Joe had a very very good start in songwriting. Imagine going "Imma try to write a serious song" one day for the first time and come up with that masterpiece

[@clemclemclemclemcl]

i call bullshit, obviously the gobble chicken song is the first one joe wrote 😃 (also for no one’s confusion im clem)

[@thirdyramos8886]

Who's joe? (Clem looks at me in a creepy way

[@qepi542]

@@clemclemclemclemcl everybody gather along its time for the gobble chicken soooongg

[@dincjfs]

@@clemclemclemclemcl the first *COMPLETE* song

[@guilhermedias3488]

@@thirdyramos8886 (Murders start playing)

[@gifdar]

God I would've been insufferable if I found Tally Hall as a teenager

[@SlamDunkPyro]

Same tbh

[@claypotter]

i did and i am

[@whatifieatedsoap]

I’ll do it

[@nancytangotits]

hi im teenager i am insufferable

[@JimmyDThing]

I discovered them in college and followed them around a bit when they were in the Northeast after I graduated. Met them a few times. It was a great time.

[@sangria-margarita]

To me, TallyHall is a cautionary tale that no matter how talented, genius, and unique you are, you still need an unbelievable amount of luck to succeed.

[@Mika-xu8hc]

when i speak alone in my room i say this a lot

[@zackbuildit88]

But also just because you're not a success yet doesn't necessarily mean you've failed

[@wooden_foot8354]

But luck isn't real, some things are proficized for a future reason that may be unknown to us, who knows- maybe tallyhall was made to blow up on tiktok so eventually a third album would come by popular command, whoooo knowssss, but I wouldn't call that luck, it's gotta be some deeper meaning behind their success that us humans can't graspe just yet.

[@RedLaundryBasket]

@@wooden_foot8354the true answer…is hidden in the sand.

[@SnacksInB4]

Success isn't a moment, but perseverance.

[@vertz1515]

Tally Hall may not be the biggest band ever, but the people who do know them are completely convinced that they are the greatest of all time.

[@starkiller6tothe9gaming81]

GOATS

[@jachymhajek9700]

Speak for yourself my guy!

[@Gone._ae]

Musical geniuses!

[@Yakkymania]

i have very wide taste so there’s tons of stuff i consider better than them but i do think they’re one of the best bands of the past 20 years

[@casquingap4518]

The rulers of everything

[@saran4783]

The fact that Rick Lax, the infamous Facebook life hack “comedian” is somehow intertwined in this storyline is INSANE

[@CarlolucaS]

I was like: "Wait, did he just say Rick Lax? That Rick Lax." I guess everyone goes different ways. 2 of the member become medical profesionals and that is also insane to me.

[@oreopuddingyum9044]

i think its crazier that tally hall and community have technically met

[@vikramchakraborty1024]

The world is a small place.

[@cheerio4000]

I was going insane about that

[@Soupnakee]

@@oreopuddingyum9044 oh cool, how?

[@lessylessy]

Since this video, Andrew had revealed that the band went on hiatus because of Joe's unstable mental health that has unfortunately spiralled into the mess that it is now. For new fans do not try to contact Joe to try to help him, you don't know him and neither do I, I am only saying what Andrew had said.

[@melkate4475]

I think if joe’s mental state doesn’t get better the best course of action is either to do an album without him (like how Hawaii part II was without Andrew) or do one with help from joe digitally. But who knows how it’ll end up

[@jorgerosado2087]

Crazy to think we are now at a point where Andrew’s making more music. Still, Tally Hall will always be a tragic band for me. They truly deserved the world, but were never given the chance by forces beyond their control. Joe especially. Those new images of Joe Hawley are truly heartbreaking. He’s clearly doing better, but you can tell that he’s not the same man anymore. Regardless, I still hold on to the idea of them reuniting. Besides, if Fiona Apple can take 20 years to release an album, so can they. I just hope they do it before it’s too late. We may have another Beatles situation on our hands.

[@eyxgsjmpdm]

⁠@@jorgerosado2087Can you tell me where to find those "new images"? everytime I try to find something new related to Joe Hawley I find NOTHING.

[@ResidenttSimon]

@@eyxgsjmpdmi think it was fake, again.

[@Thegreatsupposer]

Nobody knows him and neither do I.

[@Vincent_S]

I honestly feel the worst for Joe. The band and making music seems to be such a big part of his life and I think he missed the band the most. I remember seeing a video of him singing spring and storm at a sonic and seeing him play tally halls song all alone breaks my heart.

[@jingles8190]

you made me cry i dont usually cry :(

[@EEE-ro5px]

That video is so fucking sad, especially when he’s playing the duo part of variations on a cloud and he has to sing it alone :(

[@santinoruiz9469]

that broke my heart in just a second

[@circleinforthecube5170]

especially with all the fake cancel culture bullshit that he was the target of

[@aussieseal9979]

@@mushmush4980 social justice can be good. Social justice at the expense of others is bullshit

[@gegnabean]

I am absolutely losing my mind over the fact that Good Day is in the Sims

[@hiddeninthesand]

If you purchase the CD or vinyl Needlejuice Records rerelease of MMMM, the Simlish Good Day is on there as a secret bonus!

[@gegnabean]

@@hiddeninthesand omg! I’m definitely gonna get it!!

[@JoKaiGonZo]

Tally Hall is the only musical act, other than Dan Black, that makes me wish I was born 10 years earlier so I could have appreciated their work right as they were on the rise.

[@emilal]

why would you want to appreciate their work right as they were on the rise, what difference does it make?

[@cinnamxn5926]

@@emilal well this probably isn’t the reason, but all bands have annoying fans who say “you aren’t a real fan if you weren’t there before they got popular”.

[@AJ_Photo]

@@emilal OP probably wants to see these dudes live in their prime.

[@burgerboy8460]

@@emilal To see them live.

[@RainyDayAnimations]

It was more interactive with the fan mail stuff in the show, seeing them live, getting actual merch and the ‘&’ album for less than $300. Also maybe catching the release of the ‘Hawaii part ii’’s physical album. Just so much makes me sad that I wasn’t there to experience it all…

[@esperhart6529]

I was introduced to Tally Hall (literally) through a couple of friends I attended a community college with. They were big fans and invited me to Tally Hall's fairwell concert and the fans threw the band a pizza party in this weird empty lot near the venue. It felt like the most janky and shady pizza party I'd ever been to. Then the band arrived. We sat in a circle on concrete waiting for the pizza to arrive. I talked to Ross, Rob, and Andrew about my upcoming visit to Australia to meet a guy I'd met online. They wished me luck. We laughed at each other's jokes. We took goofy pictures. Bora got involved in the conversation. We met other fans. And I felt so very out of the loop. I'd still only heard their music in the car on the way there. I just never turn down a pizza party and a concert, and I knew my friends had good taste, so I was along for the ride. The band told me to keep in touch and let them know how Australia went. Then they played. And I was forever disappointed that that was their farewell concert and I was so goddamn late to the game. I adore their music. I adore the music individual members put out after the fact. I kept in touch very broadly and generally, but I wouldn't have any clue if they even remember why they have this rando on their Facebooks congratulating them on their life's accomplishments. Either way, I'm so glad to have that memory, I'm glad this exists so I get to learn even more about this band I absolutely adore. Haiku, Just Apathy, Good Day, Welcome to Tally Hall, &, Two Wuv... songs that forever populate my every road trip, and all from this one concert I wasn't that invested in and later wished I had been. So, thank you to Tally Hall and to Vince and Dwight (the people who brought me along for the ride) and thank you to Just Jargon and Coz Baldwin. I woke up this morning and put on the Tally Hall shirt I bought that night, started straightening my hair, and saw this existed because Dwight posted it on Facebook. I'm beyond hyped. TL;DR: Tally Hall doesn't get nearly enough recognition....

[@DwightTheGreat]

Beautifully said, and you're welcome.

[@esperhart6529]

@@cozbaldwin Oh my freakin' jeebus. THANK YOU FOR THIS INFORMATION. I'M SO EXCITED TO KNOW THAT EXISTS... especially because I was a loser and took no pictures -_-

[@st4nley]

So wholesome!

[@someguyontheinternet2544]

Hey, don’t consider YOURSELF unlucky, I just discovered tally hall not even a year ago, and my mother was still pregnant with me when they were performing, and I was 3 when they stopped. You’re extremely lucky you were even around when they were still a thing.

[@XboxTF2Tidbits]

That entire story just deserves a sub to you

[@DwightTheGreat]

I'm honored that this doc begins with footage I shot, and that so much of my footage was used throughout. When I first saw Banana Man on albinoblacksheep in '04 I would have never guessed this band would become so important to me, yet here we are. I appreciate your dedication in making this incredibly comprehensive documentary. Keep up the good work.

[@blueberryoats]

tysm for sharing the footage man!! many of your videos have ended up in my favorite tally liveshows playlist lmao

[@WarlikeWifee]

AlbinoBlackSheep is how I found them as well!

[@vertz1515]

Woah. Glad to know that you’re still active in this community after several years.

[@GALACTICREZZ]

i wish i was you

[@vampire_culture]

Thank you so much for sharing the footage with us!!!

[@spankowitzmusic]

love how ross aged like a snapchat old filter

[@jupitergolden]

Fr his hair just got greyer

[@Joehawleytally]

​@@jupitergolden BROTHER WHERE HAVE YOU BEEN THE FAMILY MISSES YOU

[@dabiggestratintown]

Watching this video is like the final step to becoming a true Tally Hall fan

[@GeometryDashPro215]

I ain’t even a tally hall fan I’m just bored💀

[@vannishd]

for some, it is the first step

[@library.of.al_xandria]

For me, its the second step. I previously listened to their whole discography

[@AsparagusTheFirst]

Yes

[@Fiskiuggar]

For me, this is literally my fifth time watching all of it.

[@thezombiecreeper]

As much as I would love a third album, “Fate of the Stars” is probably one of the best finale-goodbye songs I’ve ever heard.

[@g1e0o83]

"to leave from this tale follow closely ahead" seems like they are leaving from the tale that is and was Tally Hall

[@Yakkymania]

Fate of the Stars is the greatest song of the past 20 years in my opinion. Maybe that’s just because it’s hard to find beautifully progressive music these days, but i still stand with that opinion

[@abrahmhatcher2385]

That and variations of a cloud

[@clemclemclemclemcl]

and mmmm has one of the worst… *it’s just dadada’s and ooos*

[@stapletong]

@@clemclemclemclemcl unless you consider hidden in the sand as the last song because mucka blucka and dream are bonus tracks

[@unk9192]

There’s something really funny about the “aaa” in the Ruler of Everything demo

[@olileoli2788]

*carl wheezer*

[@robloxmanface1]

Carl wheezer when he sees Jimmy’s mom

[@barfzz]

hææ

[@docmcmoth]

It should be worth noting that as of 7/25/2022, Coz Baldwin has passed away. Sorry to anyone who found out this way

[@Lamo679.]

Yeah it’s sad

[@opal9583]

Aw :(

[@damnjolly]

damn that's my birthday

[@pinkajou656]

Aw, that’s too bad.

[@Hokydokes]

Rest In Peace. :(

[@locki3336]

As a huge fan of not only Tally Hall but also Lemon Demon. I had chills through my body at the thought that in a not so distant universe, Joe Hawley collaborated with Neil Cicierega on his Spirit Phone album.

[@floridaflamingogirl3119]

I think their voices would go so well together!

[@synodicseason]

that would be insane honestly

[@booberfraggle]

@@floridaflamingogirl3119 Tally Hall, Lemon Demon, and Jack Stauber are my favorite musicians! They all go so well together!

[@k0giku]

@@booberfraggle agreed!!! their music all feels like it fits together.

[@Forcoy]

I dont think this will ever happen due to what happened with joe and his ex

[@disjaibled]

The real reason they are on hiatus is they lost their ties

[@DonutprodzDonutprodz]

I found Joe’s and Zubin’s but the rest aren’t found.. Somebody find them plz

[@idcaboutusernames]

So someone commented on the variations on a cloud lyrics video and said “One day I want a Tally Hall movie/documentary with this as the end credits” and you did exactly that! That’s amazing!

[@typicalfurry2747]

This might be that guy

[@xxpromlggamerproxx]

@@typicalfurry2747 it wasn't, I saw the comment myself

[@CrookedSnapdragon22]

I'm glad tally hall has been getting recognised over the past year

[@luginess0]

Ruler of Everything

[@Vitorio582]

People have said this multiple times. Tally Hall's recognition is a rollercoaster

[@mxxnlight111]

@@Vitorio582 Indeed

[@therighttrousers343]

@@luginess0 oh, I heard of them through SnapCube's Real Time Fandubs.

[@s0urpuff]

right! i used to be a huge fan back in 2016, it’s absolutely wild to see such a small fanbase become so much more expansive

[@icedmorning7610]

What Joe said 1:14:30 about the albums is pretty much exactly what happened. The first album (Marvin’s Marvelous Mechanical Museum) was abstract, the second album (Good & Evil) had more logic to it, and the (closest thing to a) third album (Hawaii: Part II) had an entire narrative to it, being a sort of musical. Crazy.

[@nite6427]

JH said that a third TH album will happen eventually

[@opal9583]

@@nite6427 when

[@user-ui7tn1fq2b]

…and then JHJH was almost complete nonsense

[@homestuckfan670]

​@@opal9583 they're all almost forty and some of them are so I'd say actually sometimes soon ( or never, of course)

[@jayzelallensayco7104]

​@@homestuckfan670depends if Joe Hawley's mental health gets better, since iirc Andrew said that Joe's mental health was the main thing holding the third album back. (Not blaming Joe, may he get better.)

[@31nic]

this had me going "wait, they made that too?!" multiple times... tally hall are that same breed of neil cicierega, they make things you didn't even know were made by the same people if you don't think to look deeper... super good video! now i think i want to listen to every song tally hall and every member ever made lol

[@cheerio4000]

nielcicierega-core

[@Fritz1105]

@@cheerio4000 yeah

[@N0R5K14]

true

[@clemclemclemclemcl]

i mean making ruler of everything is one thing, but the bidding seriously?

[@nofivefivesevenseven]

neil cicierega is the king of "oh, hey, i've heard that thing he made! oh, and that too! wait..." and tally hall + solo projects is 2nd to that, but only 2nd since it's not just 1 guy. the only other person that i've ever had that experience with was jack stauber, as i remembered hearing buttercup once in, like, an among us montage or something. then i heard it again when my friend started listening to him

[@geraldgreg5370]

I'm glad that even after Tally Hall broke up Joe Hawley still kept making music and is seemingly still active, as his songs make up my favorites in there albums.

[@arcanely]

Rob makes music still too, for Disney

[@wahwahster]

they didn't break up

[@tuser8]

Andrew and Joe are still actively making things too, Ross is still DJing, Rob is notably making music for an upcoming Disney cartoon. The band’s technically not even broken up, the guys haven’t lost contact with each other or anything either.

[@ratkid_kelp]

Joe’s music is really great. I’m glad this documentary helped you find his solo work, I think you’ll love it :)

[@clemclemclemclemcl]

i thought for a second you said “I’m glad that Tally Hall broke up-“

[@spamterstudios1999]

I love how their voices never changed

[@clemclemclemclemcl]

i think cus they were already adults when they formed tally hall, and they just became even bigger adults

[@heelturn2]

@@clemclemclemclemcl "even bigger adults" is a fantastic way to phrase it and i love you for it

[@wingtub]

Like a less extreme Neil Cicierega

[@spamterstudios1999]

@@wingtub neil cicigarette still looks like a teen tbh😭

[@number2869]

@@spamterstudios1999the only thing that really changed for Nail Cigar Ego throughout the years is his hair style

[@Nydekore]

Rest in peace Coz, the best companion this band and community could ever ask for.

[@pinkertonbyweezer]

1:03:57 The song that Ross sings is "Every Day" by Buddy Holly. The Tally Hall to Weezer pipeline is a lot deeper than I thought it was.

[@greenfrog2891]

Joe put his heart in miracle musical and then expected it to just stay underground? No thats not how it works.

[@TheHarryGoldShow]

Well Jargon, after witnessing the wonderful fruits of all your hard work, I have only one thing to say: Raisins™

[@justsomecanadiandude]

ruined yer perfect 300

[@nateeeeeee]

LIVE HARRY GOLD SIGHTING‼️‼️

[@sussy6905]

harry gold jumpscare

[@toadturnpike3064]

Harry Gold making a Tally Hall reference wasn't in my new years' bingo card

[@tallussy_hallussy]

HARRY GOLD?????

[@datguyuno98]

I legit don't even know who the fuck this band is but it's now 2:30 in the morning and I feel like I've acquired a lifetimes worth of trivia and some weird ass music to listen to, thanks Jargon UPDATE: I have now become a fan of Talley Hall and I'm now rewatching this whole video so I can enjoy it properly

[@cameronwilsonfan]

holy fuck i saw this comment at 2:36 am

[@guesty5367]

the good ending

[@datguyuno98]

@@guesty5367 Further update, both Tally Hall albums, Hawaii Part II, and Joe Hawley Joe Hawley have now become my favorite albums of all time

[@guilhermeshiba3135]

@@cameronwilsonfan im also reading this at 2:36 lmao

[@caitlinhsu9074]

Small underrated detail: I absolutely love how you aged each member's portrait when you explained what they're doing now

[@gavinfelker7630]

I became a Tally Hall fan last year after stumbling across Dream Sweet in Sea Major in an auto-generated playlist by KZbin. I was doing homework while listening to music, but when I heard it, I instantly stopped what I was doing to take it all in. It was unlike anything I had ever heard, and from there, I descended into the beautiful rabbit hole that is Tally Hall. I absolutely adore their music and I wish I could have seen them perform live. Thank you for this documentary, what an excellent and comprehensive video!

[@le-eggs]

Had a similar case for me too, I think the first song I heard was "&"

[@Sewage_water]

For me it was hidden in the sand

[@miraseum]

literally the same thing happened to me, but it was white ball. it's still my favorite song of all time and i've lost track on how many times ive listened to it.

[@theofficialyoutubeaccount889]

Same

[@apoorvab1683]

For. Me it was jack manifolds twitch stream where he did karaoke and sang Dream Sweet in sea major. And a year before that I had listened to the mind electric in some playlist Spotify created for me.

[@MainCharecter]

Oh my gosh, I never expected to hear my high school voice today. The WXJR clip at 8:40ish was an Skype interview my buddy Matt and I did our senior year of high school with Joe! This documentary is so good, thank you for making it!

[@MainCharecter]

I also work 2 miles from Rotary Park. Might go see how safe it is (jk)

[@MainCharecter]

my mistake, it was not skype, it was Matt's folks' landline, gosh I feel old haha

[@MainCharecter]

Gosh, you used so much of our interview, glad we could be helpful! Finally finished the doc, so well put together! Thank you again!

[@corgretta]

Woahhh good to see you here!!

[@taxevasion4870]

Can we have a 3 hour documentary on Bora please

[@channelhasbeenmoved639]

hmmmm, I can give you 15 seconds.

[@taxevasion4870]

@@channelhasbeenmoved639 🤣

[@virusdumb]

@@channelhasbeenmoved639 26 second if you include the intro and extro

[@cooldude-jb3gx]

It Would Probibly Round Up To Be About 3 Minutes.

[@weirdeadz]

“15 HOURS OF BORAAAAAA! YEAH!”

[@algernonftw42]

I was a die-hard fan of Tally Hall since 2007. Followed them and consumed all of their content religiously, met them all and got pics/autographs, I have the 13th Place statue for my Good & Evil preorder, and was at their final show in Pittsburgh. Genuinely was crushed when they went their separate ways, even despite some of the great projects and popularity that they garnished both individually and as a band in the following years. Thank you for this outstanding comprehensive documentary, it brought back so many memories. I sort of got away from music in general over the past 5+ years, so I didn't realize that there was a lot of more recent projects by the guys, or all of these interviews where they disclosed a lot of interesting info, with several of them sharing the desire to re-unite sometime soon. It would be something special to see the kind of popularity and crowds they would get. These guys truly were ahead of their time, and I think it would be so cool to see them get the respect and appreciation they deserve from both old fans and new. Thanks again.

[@Qaiou]

13th is such a perfect number

[@Viva_Reverie]

A super interesting and well made retrospective!! I only got into Tally Hall fairly recently and it quickly became one of my favourite bands, so this was a very entertaining watch. Good job!!

[@krayken9888]

Wait you are here?!!!!!

[@Max-ds2yy]

Holy shit viva why are you here lmao

[@sasparillagreg-9292]

Hey man really glad to see that your here, nice to see another fan of tally hall, love your vids by the way

[@kiyo693]

Heya Viva! Love ur JoJo vids, didn’t know you were a Tally Hall fan as well :D

[@russiandoggo4336]

So now you have 2 bands that you listen to now?

[@OrtonLongGaming]

1:19:01 “someone asked is it smaller than a bread box” LMAOO THE NATURAL KETCHUP BIT RETURNS

[@number2869]

“I think your supposed to answer it like a Jeopardy question” they didn’t understand 😭

[@lialubinsky]

Hearing about the story behind Stranded lullaby makes it so much more sad and I love that it was called “Lullabye” it makes it very bitter sweet.

[@madmanmortonyt4890]

2:06:00 The binary code, when translated, reads,"atlantic lie John's golden shores awaiting the arrival of their unassuming servents". When pasted into google, the only conclusive result was of Queen Lili'uokalani's book Hawaii's Story by Hawaii's Queen. It can be assumed that John refers to John Own Dominis, the Prince consort of the Hawaiian Islands between January and August of 1891, or his father, John Dominis. His father came to America during the Napoleonic Wars, and afterwards had often travelled across the pacific, making stops in Hawaii. Lili'uokalani was the last Queen of Hawaii before the 1893 coup d'etat and the overthrow of the monarchy, following an economic crisis and pro-American ventures. My belief is that this message refers to John finding paradise, only for it to collapse soon after, but I am not fully convinced of this yet. That is the most I can gather from this cryptic message at 3:30am in the morning. As for the purpose of this message, there has been an ARG surrounding the channel Comprehension Amalgamation, who appears to have some connection with Tally Hall, though its purpose is unclear to this day.

[@datguyuno98]

I was wondering what all this was about. Thanks for the well made info

[@izanegi]

just translated this and scrolled down the page to find someone else who found it. there was also another single frame near the beginning but i didn't pause to look at it.

[@river3604]

I'm pretty sure "John" actually refers to Void Eon, who is a person that Comprehension Amalgamation has been trying/was trying to get the attention of for unknown reasons

[@bendeguzkocsis2692]

@@river3604 that whole thing and channel has JOE written all over it, he would do some shit like this lmao

[@reubenhamilton2390]

thank you good sir

[@thegrimghoul]

I think it was Napoleon Bonaparte (after visiting Ann Harbor, Michigan in 1804) who said, “let tally hall sleep, for when they wake, they shall rock the world”

[@Joehawleytally]

Oh yeah, I remember that, I was the whole state of Michigan at one point.

[@sparecarbon1278]

For my birthday last year, a friend of mine got in contact with 3 of the 5 members. I got a vinyl of Marvin's from Rob, an Instagram message from Andrew, and a phone call from Ross. Unless I somehow got to meet the band, it's probably gonna be my favorite birthday for a long time, if not ever.

[@StealthKey]

never let go of that friend.

[@grimothy1184]

That's absolutely amazing

[@cameronwilsonfan]

holy fuck.

[@Hi-cl3zu]

I am so jealous of you holy fuck

[@Fiskiuggar]

LITERALLY HOW?????

[@aaazedo9460]

45:53 ... ''say poggers'' thats the most unexpected thing to see on their live but the most expected thing to see since its the goddanm internet

[@inactivepleasegoaway]

i'm pretty sure later in that stream they said poggers and had no idea if it was a meaningless word or if they just unleashed hell on twitter

[@gunterxvoices4101]

Just to think that Joe only lived 28 minutes away when I was a kid... Damn. Both of us were in a bad place and stuck in crappy Michigan villages. I hope he and I both go onward and upward from now on.

[@timeforamunch2616]

"What's your favorite movie?" "It's hard to explain"

[@JustJargon]

DISCLAIMER: The video WAS in 360p but it's fixed now :)

[@trevrr]

I'm getting 480p

[@adminchobe]

Kinda gives it that late 2000s feel lmao

[@JuanStamos]

hopefully its up in working order by the time this video goes viral (like I know it will [just like Hawaii part 2])

[@guachipoto9925]

now it's in HD

[@Zero-Zero-Zero-Zero]

I have 2160p??

[@6P06]

im so sad this band ended before i could have seen it. i love this band and every single piece of music they have made.

[@BomerAang]

Shut up this is my sleepover and I get to decide the movie.

[@StealthKey]

i may be a horrible person but i got all my friends to watch through all of this

[@BomerAang]

@@StealthKey nice.

[@gr8cescale]

@@StealthKey but all, all of my fri-

[@jupitergolden]

@gr8cescale I read this comment when it said this line in the video what

[@TheActualAnthonino]

Every other member's picture before their solo segments: Gains a beard Joe Hawley's picture before solo segment: *Glasses*

[@fishyles]

i think joe had the funny glasses even before solo work, you can see them in the boralogues

[@brokengirrafe]

I am a random dude who’s never seen your content and just wanted to check if there were any good Tally Hall docs on KZbin. You popped up in my search results, so I guess I’ll be sticking around for the premiere lol. Been a fan since 2011, glad to see the guys finally get more recognition.

[@Sychillz]

I would recommend you watch all jargons content hes the best thing since sliced bread

[@mischiefcal]

nobody's original ^^ we're just evolved wrong

[@mischiefcal]

nobody's original ^^ we're just evolved wrong

[@bringme1kscrubscribers10]

I've been a fan of Jargon for a while and you should watch his other videos

[@Thenormal880]

SAME

[@pocketmastr]

Their internet show was ahead of its time and it's truly a shame that they didn't keep going with it.

[@mnemo4528]

The live chat from what I saw of it was such a legendary event, so many fans who’ve known the band for different amounts of time were all together and rallying the hall... Absolutely beautiful

[@pop_tato]

It was a lot of fun! there were a few spammers who kept showing up but it didnt ruin the event thankfully

[@mnemo4528]

@@pop_tato Yeah, there were a couple times I popped in during the middle while there was a spammer, but they seemed to be gone by the end. It was truly amazing seeing so many people I’d seen around in one place! Can’t wait for the next event like this.

[@resident_simon]

it was really cool,, we had people who discovered the band only months ago in there & also people who were fans when the band was actually active :)

[@lifeonm444rs]

it was so nice :P

[@acloneofmyself]

cant believe my life has come to the point that i will literally sit through three hours of content just so i can learn the ins and outs of one of my favourite musical artists of all time ABSOLUTELY LOVED THIS VIDEO TYSM FOR MAKING THIS SO I DIDNT HAVE TO RESEARCH STUFF FOR MYSELF :DDDDDDD

[@Twelve_Angel]

The character art for post-band Joe Hawley a little bit broke me - specifically for the detail of the little round sunglasses he wore in that infamous performance at ann arbor in 2016, where he was filmed singing 'storm and a spring' and was widely speculated to have been on the verge of tears for the entire performance. Just. the little details.

[@Tiwil]

This documentary has really _taken me for a ride_

[@longtimedown]

badum tss

[@EternallyEve]

I. FUCKING. LOVED. THIS. ENTIRE. DOCUMENTARY. Sorry if that comes off as too strong but seriously, this is 3 straight hours of history and some of the most detailed information (outside of just directly going to Hidden in the Sand) on Tally Hall that I need any and all Tally Hall fans to see. Your dedication to this band, it's history, the unknown future and just everything is fantastic. And man, using Ruler of Everything in the intro and then ending with Variations on a cloud is just... beauty. Holy shit. It's actually something I wanted to do myself if I ever made something Tally Hall related. I got kinda close with the video I have on my channel where I go from the Ruler of Everything music video to the Complete Demos version in the end credits, but THIS is far superior in every way. You already had me before with your Awful Fawful video but now I am fully happy to say that you are easily my new favorite youtube channel. Happily looking forward to your next upload.

[@camtheman807games6]

Find the code. The binary code. I’ll give you hint. It appears after 2:00:00 gl finding it

[@Doubleveemusic]

honestly, the fact how how much I've gotten to know about tally hall over 2 years has me excited for this

[@MichaelTurner856]

Same! They're so inspiring and uniqie

[@atscapegoat]

I am devastated from hearing about Joe's situation honestly. It upsets me a lot

[@klawkpepsiko9813]

the binary at 2:05:59 reads: "atlantic lie John's golden shores awaiting the arrival of their unassuming servents" so yeah that's something

[@coketictac22]

what does this mean, jargon

[@fod-der]

Imagine you and some guys make a band and some albums and then you find a three hour documentary on you guys 9 years later

[@Nawakooo0]

It's so sad that the length killed the interest in a lot of people because this video is FREAKING AWESOME!!! Don't get discouraged

[@Yakkymania]

Tally Hall are probably one of the most influential bands of the 2000s, i think if you look really deep into it you could consider them the modern Genesis due to being kooky progressive pop with odd connections to other well known pieces of their respective cultures, i absolutely ADORE Tally Hall’s style with everything from their lyrics to their harmonies to how they play their instruments, it’s insane how deeply intertwined Tally Hall are into internet culture

[@g3n3s3ct]

coming back to this one after hearing of coz's passing. rest easy coz, thank you ❤

[@ludboyjolly7297]

This band is like magic. Ask anyone who knew about them and they all have stories about how they were all just super fun and stand-up guys. So let’s hope they just get bigger and more people can enjoy their friggin’ sweet songs.

[@ElementFreakYT]

Lol, go ahead and do my job of covering all the possible Tally Topics I could ever make videos on. Excellent video, very good watch!

[@allsosavvy]

element freak element freak

[@Simonomaly]

element freak element freak

[@THATRANDOMDUDE99999]

Element Freak my beloved

[@fod-der]

Funny man make tali halle moosic

[@4skin-gaming]

Hey man love your videos got me into tally hall years ago:)

[@santoriomaker69]

This is a wonderful documentary with awesome guest appearances, great narration, very in-depth research, and such professionalism that I've also seen in other great documentaries. Even the Joe Hawley doc drama, which a lot of people may find uncomfortable, is dealt with care and attention (especially the fact that most allegations are still debated and uncertain to this day). As a relatively new Tally Hall fan who has been listening for about 2+ years now, I am extremely grateful to know not only the band's history, but also little influences they have all around the web. Thank you Just Jargon, for this documentary.

[@Deezboyofficial]

wasnt the doc faked

[@santoriomaker69]

@Paddy Cakes! couldn't have said it better myself :)

[@RH0DI]

I want the alternate timeline where this type of music became the dominant style of the industry

[@trystero1729]

Check out an album called the Infinite Monkey Theorem by Ambivert

[@Im_justhere]

I would gladly live in that reality. Popular music nowadays is… questionable… (at least to me)

[@ceanacampomanes7618]

@@Im_justhere True. if I hear cupid one more time im gonna explode ( no hate for those who like it, but my friends keep blasting it into my ears )

[@madiii3279]

I want the alternate universe where taylor swift and tally hall switch places in terms of popularity

[@arbea_]

even though the ties were completely random, each one seems to fit each person perfectly

[@W333L]

It’s sad, it felt like Joe and rob were the creative anchors of the band and one had a series of big breaks and successes while the other is a controversial unstable guy who kind of fell out of the limelight despite loving it so much

[@SPARKRIZZLE]

i first started listening to tally hall in 2017, it’s amazing to see how much they’ve grown even while the band isn’t together now. it’s much more known than when I found it, and their music has always been so great. I’ve never gotten tired of it.

[@SPARKRIZZLE]

+the fun thing is I live very close to the places tally hall was founded in Michigan :]

[@darkofalltraits9149]

This is the longest Tally Hall Related Video I've seen yet. It's even got the Side-Projects and covers everything there is to know about Tally Hall. This could count as an Entire Discography and Recap. Even the Cameos at the end work so perfectly! I can't imagine how much work this took. I can't say anything else but you've done your homework. Nice Job!

[@BlackVoidsRevenge]

Watching this is such a weird emotional experience for me. They were recording music and making their web series when I was in high school and college ('02 - '08), and I was so obsessed. But I kind of forgot about them after college, and recently I was reminded because a couple songs are popular on TikTok. Watching this documentary, I realize I still know all their names and I know the dialogue for their videos almost verbatim!

[@KI-no3uw]

Man, After watching this, it made me realize how intertwined my whole life and Tally Hall really is, with most of it appearing in my childhood. I am Extremely Grateful for this Documentary that you have made, letting me to take in how much I've been influenced by Tally Hall and everyone associated with it.

[@blackfeathers2166]

This has an underwhelmingly low amount of views for how good this is and for how much effort was put into it.

[@tweer64]

2:06:00 "atlantic lie John's golden shores awaiting the arrival of their unassuming servents [sic]" Also the backwards voice at the end says something like "I talk in reverse, Just Jargon said"

[@joehowarth4962]

Thank you

[@stickittotheman3296]

Honestly it doesn't matter to me whether they get back together or not. I feel like a lot of time with creaotrs, especially musicians, people demand much more than what they can make and that can take a toll on both their mental health and their creations. If they do come back, I'll be happy to hear their music again. If they don't, well, godspeed.

[@StaticFanfare]

This was probably the greatest 3 hours I ever wasted. I didn't know who you were before you announced that this would come out, but I salute you for providing what I believe is one of the most comprehensive videos about this band that has done absolutely nothing for a whole decade. You have far exceeded the point of earning a subscription from everyone who has watched, is watching, or will watch this. Hell, I would pay money to watch this.

[@Kurszt]

It's not a waste if you enjoyed the time used.

[@starkiller6tothe9gaming81]

@@Kurszt that's what I was gonna say, it's not a waste if you enjoyed the experience the whole way :)

[@twobats]

I found Tally Hall when I was real young, I don't even know how young anymore. It was the Hidden in the Sand music video, and I kinda forgot about them for a while. I eventually came back to them roughly 4 years ago? Maybe 3? They've been one of my favorite bands since. Genuinely, nothing beats their unique sound to me. Every time I realize there's a song or a version of a song I haven't heard, it's like a little gift has been left for me. I had no idea that their history was this expansive, but I'm so glad that I found their music when I did.

[@StealthKey]

ok dream stan

[@twobats]

@@StealthKey I'd love to know why you thought that was a necessary response to my comment about a band that, seemingly, we both enjoy.

[@StealthKey]

@@twobats why wouldn’t it be

[@twobats]

@@StealthKey Because me liking Dream has nothing to do with Tally Hall?

[@StealthKey]

@@twobats cry dream stan

[@caitlinhsu9074]

was anyone gonna tell me the "I have a better plan /I’ll marry a wealthy man" audio that was trending on tiktok a while back was from an old pre-tally hall Joe Hawley song, or did I have to find out from this 3-hour long KZbin documentary

[@meli_lemon_real]

WHAT.

[@kmations4049]

THAT'S WHAT I'M SAYING

[@kmations4049]

@@meli_lemon_real BREAK IT DOWN BY JOES OLD LIKE COMEDY GROUP

[@JuanStamos]

3 hours wow! I really wish i could have watched this live. on the bright side i get to watch it all now. unfortunately i was working while this premiered but i watched a minute of it while on my break. Tally Hall is a great band and i really like their music. can't wait to watch this documentary that i already know is gonna be great.

[@JuanStamos]

amazing video great work

[@ship-wreck]

time to make a 5 hour sequel about Joe Hawley (2023) doc

[@Cowgutz]

As an older tally hall fan. It’s lovely to see how much praise they’ve gotten over the past 3 or so years

[@daniel_is_dumb]

My mom says I'm a normal kid but here i am, watching a 3 hour long documentary about a band that doesn't even makes music anymore

[@ayeshanurain615]

I literally know 4 songs 😭

[@rachelvelander]

People watch documentaries about Nirvana and The Beatles. Trust me, you're valid /gen lh

[@Fiskiuggar]

@@ayeshanurain615listen to more.

[@clock508]

@@rachelvelandernot to mention queen

[@arcade3198]

the fact that this video could've been 10 hours long and i still would've watched the whole thing speaks volumes to my obsession w this band 😭

[@DearestGrimm]

Tally hall changed my life and ignited an intrinsic adoration of music. Despite how many there are tally hall is really the only fabloo artist I like. Their songs talk about existentialism, theocracy, time. Hidden side projects, decade hiatus. It’s perfect. I have no qualms or issues calling them the greatest band of all time.

[@gigabyte6614]

RIP COZ "Purple Tie" Baldwin

[@benjaminphelps561]

i heard the bidding in a macys department store well over a decade ago, and i didnt know how to find it or what it was. Or really remember most the lyrics, and thanks to this i found it and the band! thank you :)

[@c-bot]

at around 2:06:01 there's a frame in binary that translates to this. "Atlantic lie John's golden shores awaiting the arrival of their unassuming servants" no idea what it mean exactly but my best guess would be it referring to the song "Introduction to the Snow" or maybe "Dream Sweet in Sea Major".

[@blooberry48]

i was rewatching this an noticed a wierd frame. Thanks for decoding it.

[@blooberry48]

did some research and it’s referencing an arg that had something to do with tally hall. search up zam 440 and comprehension amalgamation. i don’t know much about the story but there are many analyses out there

[@orchidembers8841]

Catch me bawling my eyes out after finish this (that is right now, I am sobbing)

[@supersourtrey7]

Balling😼👊

[@Th3Pr0digalS0n]

I am so happy that my friends and I were able to save the AnonyMous film from being lost forever. I never knew Tally Hall was a thing until after I posted the AnonyMous film.

[@mare7329]

My granddaughter listens to them and I love their music , they are truly talented ❤❤❤

[@matruenthusiast]

your granddaughter has TASTE

[@Mr.Happy777]

Honestly, if they were to get back together somehow, I'd be pretty likely for success. All the popularity from some songs on the internet could set them up for future success. Rob clearly has tons of resources at his disposal, I wouldn't doubt that they could make music in disney/pixar movies if they ever got back together. Joe Hawley's history is definitely a problem, but anyone is capable of growth, and he did mention the possibility of clearing his name. He would certainly get the help he needs if anything about his mental health is confirmed. I'm just saying, the band might have a bright future ahead of them.

[@huskenator857]

This is worth the 3 hours if people are wondering

[@floatinsardines8104]

"you likely have heard their work without knowing it." That is true, in fact, 2 separate events. as a kid, I would watch Playhouse Disney (way before it turned into Disney Junior) and one of the shows I'd watch Happy Monster Band (which has some tally hall forces in, you can straight up hear both Joe and Zubin) and I've stumbled upon the Shia Labeouf song Rob did.

[@thekeyboardslammer4413]

As a tally hall fan who knows about a bit of the history of the band it’s great to see one of my favorite creators talking about it.

[@thefoxgaming7528]

Damn, this is a great documentary on Weezer

[@gr8cescale]

I love the wiggles so much 🤩

[@redder_er]

Are you STUPID!!! god... its a documentary about the beatles 🙄

[@rabbitinc.5601]

@@redder_er No, it's about The Rolling Stones, can't believe people make that mistake between the beatles and The rolling stones.

[@furiousmagician5912]

why is everyone making a stupid joke about this? its not even funny... why would people say this about my chemical romance??

[@gr8cescale]

@@furiousmagician5912 I thought the half•alive fandom would be funnier than this 🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄

[@revkun]

to think that when I was a kid this band was thriving only about an hour away from me. kind of wish I was older so I could find them back in the day and see them live.

[@goldegreen]

Oh same

[@Fiskiuggar]

Real, except they were a few hours away.

[@Sirebellum1337]

The fact that this thing has so few views but has had so much effort put into it should be a crime. This was probably the best documentary (or most interesting at least) I've ever watched.

[@Bilgerat_84]

Variations playing as the credits song legit brought a tear to my eye. I've been listening to this documentary off and on for the past 2 days and I just really love the effort and research that you did for this.

[@RammerHammer]

This is such an in-depth documentary, well done! I started listening to Tally Hall at the height of the COVID pandemic in 2020, a good friend of mine introduced me to The Bidding and I fell in love. I absolutely adore Ruler of Everything, Hidden in The Sand, Turn The Lights Off, You and Me, and Spring and a Storm, but my absolute favourites have to be The Whole World and You and Greener. Such a unique, quirky, unusual and interesting band. One of my favourite fun facts is that the garbled radio static at the end of Hidden in the Sand can be played backwards to say "Wouldn't the world be better off if we took nonsense more seriously?" and I think that's just a wonderful thing to think about.