First Time Hearing LILIAC MASTER OF PUPPETS METALLICA COVER (REACTION)

[@vander78]

This is the first time i heard someone say that they Don't like Melody's Voice. In my Honest opinion i Think she is one of the best Frontwomen/girl in Metal right now. You should listen to some of their other stuff before making an opinion.

[@ryant3600]

I think he's to hung up on the original Metallica version and not understanding that covers are supposed to make it their own.

[@normanleitholf6750]

@@ryant3600 I agree, hes hearing Hetfield in his head

[@tomdodds8091]

Agreed. He likes the stuff that's essentially the same as the original, but Mel's voice is different and they use keys instead of a second guitar. 🤷

[@Jim-iv7yq]

honest review.. sometimes its tough for a diehard Metallica fan to accept something a bit different.. i get it :).. i think they knocked it out of the park as a great tribute.. you need to hear some of their originals and maybe a few other covers. her voice is the best rock voice ive heard in 20 years.. and im an old school 80's rock / metal guy

[@AllAboutLuhig]

This was exactly my first reaction to this cover, hearing it another times sounds great to me.

[@cyberpred]

Alex I am a fan all the way back to Kill em all/Ride the lightning days. To see young people keep metal alive is fantastic. You are hearing Metallica in your head. They are doing it their way. To be honest I would have been disappointed had they copied it exactly. Just my opinion. If all you have is one little issue being a Metallica fan that is a huge compliment. These kids are amazing. Death To All But Metal my friend

[@pstwork]

Yes, the band has become an icon in themselves so when they do a cover these days it becomes a hybrid. MOP was a fan voted challenge for them to cover. This cover has been questioned a little. All other Liliac content (covers and originals) is pretty unanimously, completely awesome 🦇🪨🤘

[@robear5440]

WOW!!! You are the first reactor ever to say they didnt like Melody's voice.

[@AlexNChannel]

I said I didn't like the way she sing this song the way she did that thing Whit her voice. And i prefer to be the only reactor saying what I really think

[@amandapreston2125]

U dont want exact copy....alot of. Rock musician reactors liked the keyboard in the video

[@AlexNChannel]

@Amanda Preston i didn't. It's strange, it's like nobody appreciate a honest reaction, a honest thought about a band, i said what I thought about it because I'm honest about what I'm doing, if other reactors are like it it's fine for me, but I guess the main thing about a reaction is being honest, and not saying things just to make fans happy

[@robear5440]

@@AlexNChannel You are right, it is just an opinion. Understandable that a real Metallica fan would find fault with another's copy. Same would go for any other iconic band. I'm just saying to give them a fair shake listen to Mars and you will get a better opinion of them. You didnt like this cover, but you would probably like their own music.

[@AlexNChannel]

@@robear5440 like I've said in the video, i appreciate a lot the talent, and I've said I want to hear more to understand. I've just said what I didn't like. And i think this is what a reaction should be like, non only because here is Metallica and is my fav band, but a reaction should be to point your opinion of what you think, like, and don't like. And i think it's impossible, for any reaction channel to have like 400 videos ( just saying a number randomly) and like all of them. I prefer to be honest and really say what I think about the bands, songs, for or bad. Thank you for understanding

[@randylavallee7267]

Thank you for your reaction to this iconic song. They are a young band but not afraid to tackle any hard song like M.O.P. They are all brothers and sisters, they have many amazing covers songs and outstanding originals out. Hopefully you will give them a listen. And about the vocals on this song....remember this is just a cover, and I do also respect your opinion towards the vocals.!! Cheers!!

[@studio920]

The youngest member is Justin he plays the keyboards he’s 13 years old the bass player is Ethan 14years old the vocalist is Melody 19 years old the drummer is Abigail 21 years old and the lead guitarist Samuel is 22 they are a family of rock band .You should check out Mars live and another song called nothing gives you a better feel with the band really about

[@watchingthesky1973]

This age of the band members is for today. The song was recorded in L.A., before moving to Georgia in November 2020. Melody was then 18 y.o., Abigail 20 y.o., and Sam 21 y.o.

[@cristyrawks6325]

@@watchingthesky1973 Couple months diff....

[@scrogg13]

Enjoyed the reaction and respect your opinion. As with any cover, anything about it can be hit or miss with the listening audience. You say yer definitely interested in hearing more of them and that's a good thing. I look forward to seeing you react to some of their original music. As mentioned in other comments, "Mars" live from Cumming, GA is great. They have lots of good stuff out there, enjoy. RO&RH!

[@tomwareham7944]

Check their other covers and especially their original songs and again especially Mars, you will change your mind about Melody the lead singer .the band is a young family and have millions of views under their belt. The keyboard is taking the place of a second guitar and does it very well .you are obviously entitled to your own opinion and i for one respect that ,you have to remember though that this is a cover ,and as such is never going to be exactly like Metallicas original what would be the point . A good reaction nevertheless and I hope that when you have listened to their other offerings you will become a huge fang like millions of others from around the world. Rock on and rock hard

[@AlexNChannel]

I understand, and like I've said in the video i will check more, I've just said my honest opinion of what I think

[@cristyrawks6325]

Now they've just released their new video "Symphony Of Destruction" but you may not like that one either. They've done covers that have catapulted them to the front of young bands who rock. Now they're doing originals. Not everyone likes other people's likes, but it would be nice if you checked them out a little more. Just for the helluvit. I'm an old rocker and I feel Melody, the singer, is phenomenal.

[@dough1793]

In an interview with their father, who's their producer and manger, he said the keyboard had to take the place of the rhythm guitar. Melody has an incredible voice, she is a huge Dio fan and seems to channel him and Joplin. Take a listen to their cover of "Piece of my heart" by Joplin or "Holy Diver or Rainbow in the dark" from Dio. 🤘

[@evilvolts]

the guitarist Sam is 21 now the drummer Abigail is 20 Melody the singer/bass is 19 Ethan is 13 on bass/rhythm guitars Justin is 12 on the keyboards/piano

[@studio920]

Sam is now 22 and Abigal is 21. Ethan 14.Justin 13. Melo 19

[@hookster8179]

Came out 35 years and a day anniversary, LILIAC meaning bat they make a sound they call a vamp metal. Justin is filling in because of one guitar but they stayed true to their own sound well giving their fan-gs the cover of Master of Puppets voted for them to cover, and they did it all themselves.

[@susanwilson8162]

RORH! 🦇🤟 Check out their original Mars live from Cummings Georgia. Sam's solo is badass! Thx for the honest review. Fang for life!

[@waynefurrow845]

I was also disappointed with the vocals on this track, but she is an incredible vocalist. Check out their cover of Enter Sandman (they are even younger) and it is more true to the original. Another recent cover they've done is a cover of Joan Jett's I hate myself for Loving You, she kills it.

[@phazerboy]

Agreed you have to listen to more of their stuff. For a family band these guys have some really good stuff.

[@stevebondeson2852]

You should check out their original music. Try Mars live or anything they have done . It's all awesome .

[@JonnyCoffin]

Check out Holy Diver

[@antanaskubilius6775]

Mars live is awesome Need to do a reaction to it.

[@evilvolts]

you should hear them do their original song Mars live in Ga with Sam's Guitar solo

[@robear5440]

Perhaps listen to Mars-live in cummings GA. Not knowing the song will give you a better perspective on their talents.

[@hildebrandt111]

That was a good and honest reaction.

[@jerrellesplain6010]

Liliac is awesome!!!!

[@nicolehudson158]

Liliac is amazing! I hope you react to more! 😊🤘🦇❤💥

[@binboh]

Please don't give up on LIliac yet. They have their own music too. They also do other covers as well.

[@martinmitchell5713]

This is a cover in their own style what’s the point in doing an exact copy ? If you want that just listen to the original

[@AlexNChannel]

it's a reaction, i can say my opinion right? If you stayed the entire video you will hear me say that is nothing wrong that they did it in they're own style, i just said my opinion, that's why it's called a reaction

[@robear5440]

@@AlexNChannel react to Mars - live in cummings GA to get a better perspective of their talents.

[@uhtredragnarsson8961]

That echo is their way..and it is not bad..and for me that is best cover of Master of Puppets..btw am big fan of Megadeth..and this kids is best young band right now..take time and watch more video from Liliac..no regret..

[@martinmitchell5713]

Try sail away or the trooper or enter sandman or Mars my favourite is Nothing

[@watchingthesky1973]

Thank you for a honest reaction. This is one of the most interesting reactions to this song I heard so far. You may be interested in listening to another Liliac cover of a Metallica song - Enter Sandman. The vocalist Melody was 15 y.o. then. I can't guess if you like it (and this is great!), but you will be impressed for sure.

[@jerrellesplain6010]

Wow your the first iv ever heard not liking melody's voice.. this is the only song they've ever tried that effect on her voice. Its awesome either way. Check out thier other stuff before passing them off. They are awesome

[@MooreCEJr]

Try cover of Joan Jett's "I Hate Myself For Loving You".

[@tveeti]

Nice to see how baddly Liliac did mess You up. This was just honest reaction. You have to learn more Melodys singing style and inspiration where that comes 🤘🦇

[@Spunky62]

Going to see them tomorrow night!🤘🤘🤘🔥🔥🔥🔥🎶🎶🎶💯

[@joewilson820]

I predict you are going to be a major fan in a short time .

[@normanleitholf6750]

Well you are certainly entitled to your opinion. That said, it is my opinion that if Melody Christea sounded like James Hetfield that would suck. Just saying.

[@mikesmicroshop4385]

I don't know ANY bands that want people to do covers of their music that want someone to do them as they did them!!!!!!! They all say if you are doing our stuff make it your own don't just copy us!!!!!!!

[@patrickharrington5753]

🦇🎶🤘

[@metaldiamond]

I think they'r great.And we don't need another Metallica or Dio or Maiden because they are already the best bands in the world.Liliac realy deserve respect.Very god.

[@diedregerick1438]

You should check out the cover of Dio's"The Last In Line" which the did for the Dio Cancer Fundraiser back on the 10th. Wendy asked them to play the benefit she asked them to play this one and Vinnie Appice gave her this extended version if the song to do which never came out. Wendy is a fan of theirs after seeing them do the cover of "Rainbow In The Dark".

[@tomdodds8091]

I think you might like their Enter Sandman cover better They're even younger on that one, and the lead singer (Melody) plays bass on it while the younger brother who's on bass for MOP (Ethan) plays the second guitar. Just FYI, the keyboardist (Justin) is even younger.

[@danzampich6723]

Not meant to be a reproduction of Metallica. It's definitely not the best representation of her talent. I would suggest that you react to their original song " mars" live in Cummings georgia. Or their cover of " the trooper ". They also do a great cover of enter sandman.

[@deezet9518]

They do covers but don’t want to be like the original. They have their specific signature they add to a song. Just don’t expect the original. This isn’t their best though, try some of their own work like Nothing or another cover like Holy Diver.

[@Gray82]

check out liliacs cover of enter sandman. They put their own spin on covers..its call vamp metal.

[@gzrgldr8288]

Wow dude, you sure triggered a lot of Fangs. I am a big fan of Liliac and like what they did with the song, but I'm not a big Metallica fan and never really cared for this song to begin with. Thank you for providing an honest reaction, I don't have any issues with your opinion. But I will also support what others have said about checking out some of their other stuff. They really are a talented bunch of kids.

[@AlexNChannel]

I've said in my reaction that they have an amazing talent, what people miss to understand in my reaction is that I've only said. "I DIDN'T LIKE THE PART WHIT THE OEOWOOOO" not that I didn't like her voice, not that I didn't like the way the play o sing. But, hell , it's a reaction, and i will always say what I think. Thank you for understanding.

[@purpleskiesforever]

I love your honest review. I love Liliac, but this is not my favorite cover of theirs. There is something a little off. But, God, they are so talented! Crazy Train is my favorite cover they did and they were much younger when they did that video.

[@bryanhamlet6412]

I agree with you on the thing you pointed out. That is her normal voice check out some other covers like last in line or there Originals Mars great solo by Sam or for something Totally different from them check out Sail Away one of the best Originals from them (awesome)

[@ovidiuripas5511]

hi, try too react to the song Mars with Liliac band, this is their own song,

[@marcmaddox]

Dude, I'm with you. The effects are a little much. Melody just needs to sing... they are really good!! Its really hard to listen to if you are a big fan of Metallica as I am as well, but if you listen to it a few times it will go on you... try a few other covers of liliac. They also put their own spin on every song... plus bud, their fans picked this song and it is tough with their current instrument arrangements .... Melody also plays bass....

[@donaldwatkins826]

I meant to say, they're not trying to be Metallica.

[@markwebb8013]

Better than original. Sorry.

[@donaldwatkins826]

They're not Metallica

[@salvadorascencio4526]

Totally agree with Alex

[@grantmorden2405]

have to agree with ya .