Charlotte Balfour's Stalker - Red Dead Redemption 2

[@MrBlack252]

When Charlotte made rabbit stew and I sat down and ate it as Arthur, when the screen kept going red I honestly thought she was going to be revealed as a psycho that poisoned her husband then Arthur but then I remembered it was the TB

[@colton3927]

You thought she was going Aberdeen incest style on you

[@XLCook12]

Colton Jondle 😂

[@andersondawn3631]

Arthur: Oh god, not the incest siblings again-[collapses]

[@MrFusion]

I thought that her cooking was that bad it made Arthur collapse.

[@Master_Of_The_Universe]

What about the *LUMBAGO*

[@0ld_Scratch]

Charlotte and Hamish were my favorite people to help and meet during these missions.

[@sulkii9437]

Rip Hamish

[@2000th_autumn]

Yeah, every time I replay the story, I always feel it's necessary to do all their encounters. Just feels like they add to Arthur's story and influence him in a positive way before he passes.

[@theclashingshinx8369]

Facts and RIP hamish

[@meowmeow3778]

I recommend to do all the stranger missions and do all the farewell ones as John.

[@theclashingshinx8369]

@@meowmeow3778 no, do certain stranger missions as Arthur and certain as John like hamish's last mission. Doing them all ruins the game if u do them as John-

[@cybercybex]

" I know a thing or two about shooting a gun". Yes Arthur the double barrel, sniper rifle and two pistols/revolvers are just for display.

[@shotq8070]

They are

[@Maksymetzmj]

Lol, like how could anyone look at Arthur and not assess that he knows how to kill anything alive.

[@hassetjifrebro8222]

Suni Victor If not by their first meeting. Then by the second meeting it’s quite clear to anyone that Arthur is an outlaw. Not only that, but even Mary in a whole different part of the country sees in the papers about Arthur the price on his head and his gangs, even where they are. Given that she has several provisions, cigarettes etc I’d say she’s well aware he’s an outlaw, but not a bad man. I think Hamish knew perfectly well too. The man is obviously a gunslinger and a wanted man.

[@demonjmh]

@@Maksymetzmj which is why it doesn't make sense when people threaten you in bars... You're gonna threaten a drunk guy who has a big ass knife and carries 4 guns

[@stefanvermeer3209]

@@demonjmh they only threaten you because they are drunk

[@draquilacasket1719]

I killed that stalker completely by accident. I didn't even know that's who he was, I was trying to hunt a deer when I rode up and the auto aimer got him in the head. I felt bad, but now I see that I have won blindly.

[@Khoros-Mythos]

Error: Success!

[@lesterthemolester1501]

*task failed successfuly*

[@samjackson9560]

In the business we call this a happy accident

[@memorylane3866]

A surprise to be sure, but a welcome one.

[@88thegbomb]

Auto aim is just God's will

[@CHIPSISBACK]

Stalker:”I watched her from the bushes” Shotgun:”so I took it personally”

[@twistedyogert]

To be fair I think that would be anyone's response.

[@gerardwayseyelash]

"So anyway, I started blasting"

[@YourFutureBoyfriend]

I didn't even know you could rob her. I found her accidently after completing the Jim "Boy" Calloway quest. I actually grown to like her after each time we help her. I even went back as John to visit.

[@the_grim_gamer3039]

Same

[@murmur.5557]

I did that also

[@vladimirjohnson7934]

noMoREALienZ she literally lets her rob you when u go as john

[@MrBlack252]

When you are just nice to her she will literally leave you 100 bucks just for your kindness so there's no reason to be a dick

[@vladimirjohnson7934]

Mr. Black no you can if you want. Not her per se, but her house

[@Black_Jesus3005]

In another life This would’ve been Arthur’s wife and the “the veteran” his best friend.

[@johnhammersmith7828]

You mean Mickey from valentine? The guy who lied about being in the war? Or the meaner one from Rhodes?

[@gallowsdodger3841]

@@johnhammersmith7828 I assumed Hamish, the guy with the cabin by the lake with one leg.

[@emilyiscool891]

Gallows Dodger yeah most likely bc he felt uncomfortable around mickey

[@uzxll5125]

Man they really need a alternate ending dlc or something :(

[@lsswappedcessna]

Hamish Sinclair?

[@wolfy9549]

Charlotte: “Bon appétit” Arthur: “H u H ?” Oh Arthur

[@nuv2987]

Somehow I didn’t notice this.

[@muhammadjojosari891]

Lumbago Man You have lumbago LOL

[@eltonj888]

Wolfy Don’t you “Oh Arthur” me!

[@succ9147]

@@nuv2987 uncle how's your lumbago

[@nuv2987]

Hill worse than corona

[@juleswoodbury58]

Arthur: "If you don't pay me back the nickel you owe me, I'll break your neck" Also Arthur: "I'm an emissary from God, sent to you so you won't starve, random woman"

[@Onyxthefem]

I know you’re joking but Arthur doesn’t act like that

[@unsuspiciouschair4501]

@@Onyxthefem yes he's does, Arthur ruthless beat a dying farmer infront of his family for abit of money.

[@basketballnewscentral2568]

Britishguy0880 well yeah but at this point he got his redemption

[@unclevivid9028]

We all make mistakes. And sometimes we gotta play the role were dealtm and we also have to let go

[@WretchedRedoran]

The distinction, though, is that in the former instance he was enforced to do so, while the latter he did it on his own accord.

[@blaeckingceorl4161]

"He found me at my lowest point and he lifted me up." Man, that's so sad. Arthur is such a good character.

[@Anukii]

They need to patch out getting negative honor for killing that stalker. That is a GLITCH, ROCKSTAR

[@meowmeow3778]

@@kpsa7108 Maybe it was too far to kill him, maybe you can arrest the guy or make him think of what he was about to do?

[@Dalt1n999]

@@kpsa7108 Good thing the cops won't try to kill you for killing the supremacist in St Denis, this was intentionally made by Rockstar bc they knew most people would at least knock him out

[@ozero00rockon]

Kp SA When I played the game and found the guy, I talked to him and I said something that made him mad and he attacked me until I lassoed him up and threw a molotov. I didn’t lose honor however.

[@Soron661]

@@kpsa7108 yeah, that's fucking stupid. course, the cuffs could mean he was just really into BDSM and just was unlucky that she rejected him.

[@Dalt1n999]

@Ninja ZX-12R disgusting

[@vxantiz]

The stalkers head: exists My semi-auto shotgun: its free real estate

[@shaggyplays5309]

RDR2 and MEMES. bruhh its true though it’s satisfaction

[@BenDover-tk3jj]

Stalkers Arms and Legs: exists My Dynamite: allow me to introduce myself

[@tallstar513]

My dual wield sawed-off shotguns: *exist* The stalker: Say sike *right **_now_*

[@newttonium]

How do you torture someone

[@poxy5122]

@@newttonium Eh, the best you can do is lasso that guy up and ride on some real hard rocks.

[@bri961]

5:05 i like how Arthur makes the gun point out of her head thus making sure that she is safe and doesn't hurt herself. Another proof that Arthur is a caring person

[@ShoopityDoopity]

I wonder if that was scripted or Roger just took it upon himself to improvise that.

[@jasonmikulas4994]

It was intentional because as he moves tje gun his voice shakes a little.

[@nathenbosher1067]

Arthur is what you make him and mine is a psychopathic massmurder who drags old ladies down the road for run

[@relikuh]

brilliyan ibnu unless it was Micah Arthur would’ve happily let Micah shoot him self

[@nathenbosher1067]

@Chris Ruiz oh most definitely. I made a save just before hand because I love it so much

[@itsmecrosby4723]

5:07 such a subtle little thing. But the way arthur instinctive moves the barrel away from her head is such a massive insight into how caring he is.

[@codylakin288]

On my first play through I was a fairly peaceful Arthur, a good man, just with the occasional serial killer impulse. You know... under the right circumstances. I love the Charlotte mission. And when I encountered the stalker, even as good Arthur, I hogtied him, brought him to a river, put him in shallow water so he could choke and flap around but not quite drown, and I went fishing for awhile. Good times.

[@arminosas]

Now that's a good man

[@CreditedJester2]

I beat him to death and set his entire camp on fire with him in it.

[@internalswiffer6734]

@@CreditedJester2 i didnt even realize it was the stalker and wanted to see some hogtie physics so i strung him up and started riding away on my horse where he caught on fire and died from his campfire

[@beaniemanmg9134]

This is thr most psychotic thing I've read today, I love it.

[@seandonnellan5980]

I found him twice actually, same hillside I think. I was letting him talk as I used his fire to cook. I wasn’t paying attention to what he was saying until I heard “I saw a lady up in the hills, lives alone, real pretty” or something like that. I already helped Charlotte completely as Arthur so it clicked immediately this guy was a stalker. After I hogtied him, I saw his tent had tons of women’s pics, some almost snooping images. So I took him to the swamp to be eaten by a gator. Gator didn’t even eat him, just slapped him in the head with it’s tail and killed him lol tossed his body into the water and rode off

[@starset4life175]

Me every time I start a new save file to see Charlotte again: "I will protect this person down to her last atom"

[@sauceboss510]

I couldn’t take anything from her even though she says you can. Just couldn’t bring myself to.

[@theoutsiderjess1869]

Christopher Marlowe there was also the money on the bedside table she left you

[@jaga9394]

There's a cigarette card in her home. That's the only thing I took

[@inshan3st3r]

2 cigarette cards and a pack of cigarettes. I did not feel guilty because it showed Arthur's hunting lesson made her self sufficient.

[@41Brother2]

Like others only things I took were the cigarettes and card. Money? Nah my Arthur had close to $3000 by that point and in story Arthur has no need of it anymore. Any reward from friendly encounters like this by that point in game I declined.

[@Kanal7Indonesia]

I took the money only

[@Coleees]

My god there are so many things I have not found in this game

[@mrgrundy3909]

Makes you wanna replay the story doesn’t it

[@AldoCh]

Red Dead is infinite

[@standlink3418]

K1NgSoLoMaN 18 yeah you can replay the story a million times and still find something new

[@teamplayer6992]

First time thinking that?

[@mmafighter2992]

I’m on like my 8th play thru and every time I always find something new. This time I’ve decided to take my time and not worry about missions so much. To just go and explore every single inch that I can. 3 weeks playing like this and I’m only on chapter 4. 😂😂😂 but I tell you this is the way the game was meant to be played.

[@Tom-mk7nd]

I feel like Arthur knows he could have found redemption settling with Charlotte too, she was his type of girl, not Mary. Don't know if it was intentional from the writers but they had real chemistry even though we didn't see her much.

[@false_idol__]

I think there was impact written with that, although really sad. Mary had enough of Arthur. Arthur was alone at that time. Charlotte and Arthur could've been something and they both knew it. But they both also knew he had no time left. He was dying and they both knew deep down he couldn't save himself. So they didn't get too attached. They couldn't hurt themselves like that.

[@ggll4145]

@@false_idol__ Perfectly well said. They knew not to cross that line because it'll been a double tragedy for her. But you still felt a what if it he wasn't seriously ill which makes this interaction so pure and heart breaking. Especially when she wrote him that letter and started it off with "My Dear Author". She had feelings for him and so did he, especially when he told her his full name. Such a beautifully written short but yet meaningful and a heavy encounter twist during his last days.

[@KarlPHorse]

Arthur would definitely be remembered as a famous outlaw based on his bounty and involvement in major events. Some of the people Arthur helped had to have picked up a newspaper one day and seen "Notorious outlaw Arthur Morgan of Van Der Linde gang found dead near Donner Falls." and just been like "Holy shit."

[@seanxednycanonuevo2064]

This is better than MrBossFTW's content and the other clickbaity channels all combined. Thank you, Fizhy for uploading real content.

[@marky8013]

Another Simpleton I hate that bitch with a burning passion

[@TbYolo]

Only thing I hate is when he puts that dumb Dark Old Filter on and it makes everything darker in the video it's hard to see

[@seanxednycanonuevo2064]

@@TbYolo Agreed, not everyone's perfect at least.

[@trindalas]

Another Simpleton I have that bitch blocked. I hate all the damn clickbait, pointless red arrows/circles, fake “evidence” of things (labeled as proof of course) etc.

[@Soron661]

@@trindalasI don't see them as legit proof, but theories. however, all theories have evidence to back them up. whether they're true or not is up to Rockstar who'll more than likely never confirm or deny them.

[@freemoable]

I loved the Charlotte missions but I never bumped into to her stalker.

[@abrahammarley8090]

U only see him if she dies

[@kajetanbomba8274]

@@abrahammarley8090 not really. Met him in chapter 2.

[@anthraxinyourmailbox9550]

@@abrahammarley8090 is that true?

[@elio4463]

Anthrax in your mailbox it’s not true I met him before I met her

[@joaogomes9405]

You see him if you complete at least one of her missions. If you complete the first but not the others, he kills her. If you complete all of them he won't.

[@CornPopWasABadDude]

Arthur's death was so depressing for me as I truly fell in love with his character. It's videos like this that make it even sadder because it shows a glimpse of what could be, you know? These two characters really got on well, and could've really developed a touching relationship if they had had the time. Platonic or otherwise. (Being the romantic that I am, I lean towards otherwise bc I cared more ab this lady than I ever did for Mary. Plus, it'd be really sweet. Both find each other at the lowest points in their lives and build a nice friendship over time that could possibly develop into something more.) Sorry for the sappy tangent

[@NutsItsBerserkinTime]

DeadRheaRising 7 same, I can sometimes just think of him and get teary eyed lol.

[@theoutsiderjess1869]

DeadRheaRising 7 I don’t really like Mary she keeps playing with Arthur it’s like she wants Arthur to be one hundred percent perfect and when he isn’t she makes him feel like shit for not being who she wanted him to be . I would have like to seeArthur with Charlotte or Sadie tho if he lived

[@succ9147]

Yeah I would really like to see how they become wife and husband widow is really perfect for Arthur with his kind and very friendly attitude, widow is the most perfect wife for arthur

[@josharntt]

@@theoutsiderjess1869 I disagree, Mary didn't make Arthur feel like shit, both of them mutually knew it wouldn't work. And she needed help and didn't have anyone else, why not help her? Even if you don't personally gain anything from it, you save her little brother from the turtle cult weirdos, and you help her see that her father is a toxic, degenerate lost cause.

[@jacrispy3275]

Mary-Beth? Are we just gonna gloss over her?

[@tankfreak3227]

I actually came across the stalker within my first few hours of playing the game. I was intrigued, as he was the first decent person I'd met at a campfire. So I sat down and we started conversing. And when he started talking about the woman he was stalking (I didn't know it was Charlotte at the time) I got creeped out and I was generally concerned. So I did what any decent human being would do and filled him with buckshot.

[@TheRageaholic]

This character was obviously patterned on Alma Garrett from HBO's Deadwood.

[@Fizhy]

Never seen that show

[@TheRageaholic]

@@Fizhy DEFINITELY check it out, if you enjoyed both Red Dead games. Similar sensibility. Similar vulgarity and violence. Similar music, even. Dutch in RDR2 was visually (and somewhat in terms of character) modeled after Al Swearengen on the show. Highly recommended.

[@plastichouseplant]

She even sounds like Molly Parker. I looked up who played Charlotte because I thought it was her.

[@stevemccann4166]

The serial killer prostitute in Valentine is also based on a character from Deadwood.

[@mrjawline1143]

The voice is really similar as well

[@Nyarlathotep727]

5:05 I love that attention to detail. Always keep your firearm pointed in a safe direction.

[@Badrecon33]

I don't think official rules of gun safety existed back then like they do now. It was Col Jeff Cooper that standardized our laws of gun safety and our tactical training.

[@SanDzFit]

This game is so immense, I had beat it 93% and had barely scratched the surface. Incredible.

[@christophercolumbus1169]

I’m at 100% and there’s still a lot to do. I haven’t even done the gunslingers or Hamish Sinclair’s missions. I’m sure there’s even more I’m still missing too.

[@christianw7846]

@@christophercolumbus1169 hamish is fun but the gunslingers missions are my favourite stranger quest their rlly good

[@christophercolumbus1169]

Snoopdoug yea I saved em for last because it’s a badass little self-contained story.

[@jtl1797]

It’s still sad to think how Arthur saved lifes while dying.. (Ofcourse he took lifes but his intentions were not to harm people)

[@zoesagittarius2675]

Lives*

[@bjellison905]

Your intentions were not to harm people. He is an object of your decisions

[@BigDexMedia]

I loved Charlotte and her evolution from a helpless widow to a healthy writer who can survive on her own

[@beeman2075]

I'd encountered Charlotte before meeting the campfire stalker when playing this game a few years ago. When I realized the stalker was referring to Charlotte and his dialogue reveals his intention to return and stalk her again and very likely do worse, I hog-tied him and dropped him in a nearby river to drown. On discovering his handcuffs and other 'weird' stuff in his tent, my Arthur had no trouble sleeping that night.

[@HereIsWisdom1318]

3:32-There’s something endearing about how Arthur says, “Oh I don’t doubt it.”

[@c.o7993]

The game has brilliant voice work

[@codydagg2259]

I wanted Arthur and her to live happily ever after :(

[@kaybevang536]

In be next life they probably will

[@doflash9210]

I wanted Arthur and Sadie

[@AhmedMohamed-zb8og]

@@doflash9210 they’re more like brother and sister

[@joecostantino3684]

@@AhmedMohamed-zb8og Arthur and Sadie would have been kind of like a Bonnie and Clyde type deal, I think he would have had good chemistry with either of them.. Him and Sadie could have been a husband and wife bounty hunting team (or outlaws), but if Arthur wanted to retire to a quiet life away from all that ruckus, Charlotte would have been a better fit.

[@shenlochbrachass9684]

Woulda been better for him than Mary Linton

[@bigmantyrone4347]

„Then you get invited into her house“ This sounds familiar

[@viveka2994]

hEy tHEre FRIend i GOt a NiCE mEAAl

[@femboycyan]

DoNt Be ShY PaRtnEr

[@thatbirb4743]

@@femboycyanI've heard this line so many times now lmao

[@cortex8239]

Hell yeah porn and sh- oh . . . Ohhhhhhh-

[@xeno043]

When Arthur ate the meal I was scared that it was like the inbred pig people 😬

[@slabpanda]

I never understood why he introduced himself in the next scene after she’d already addressed him in the letter as Arthur

[@wasabi5338]

most likely for a proper introduction. Charlotte mustve read his journal and read his name.

[@jahnukainen_8912]

me: *finds this weird stalker dude* also me: horse! H A N D M E T H E L A S S O

[@seanbrown2294]

Even though Arthur was sick. I thought during that second interaction with Charlotte that she spiked his meal with something. Similar to what the brother and sister do to you at that pig farm. All that loneliness in the woods drove her a bit loony.

[@seanbrown2294]

@Jose Antonio Campuzano Cano I know that she didn't. I was just saying at first I thought she did.

[@Orophile_303]

TB is an illness. Can't get it from spiked food. I doubt after he helped her that she would do that.

[@seanbrown2294]

@@Orophile_303 Again, i know where Arthur got the TB from. He got it from beating up that one dude that wouldn't pay up at the Ranch. I thought the loneliness got to Charlotte and she purposely spiked Arthur's meal. So that she could, I don't know, keep him there or whatever longer. It wasn't until he started coughing that I figured it out. His TB was acting up on him and caused him to pass out.

[@Soron661]

same here, Sean. It was well-timed. The fact she was talking about her past, and Arthur was beginning to fall unconscious backed up that thought. However, I'm glad I was mistaken. I personally quite liked Charlotte. Also, for those of you that think I didn't know that Arthur was sick... use your common sense. I know Arthur had TB at that point. however, the falling unconscious right after eating food? c'mon dudes & dudettes! You can't deny that it was perfectly timed on Rockstar's part. They probably wanted us to think she was dosing him to use as a sex-pet or something. They could've easily had him fall unconscious just before sitting down at the table or as he sat down.

[@seanbrown2294]

@putsome basilonit Once again, i know that. On my first playthrough, I thought Charlotte spiked Arthur's food at first. That same unconscious vision graphics started up after Arthur had already started eating. The brother and sister couple at that pig farm spiked Arthur's meal and when he started to pass out. That same unconscious graphic started to play out. It wasn't until he started coughing that I understood that his TB was acting up on him. I thought Charlotte went a little loony after her husband died and was out in the wilderness alone for some time. So when Arthur came around, she wanted to keep him around. So she spiked his meal. Do you understand now?

[@joshuabrown4338]

"This is what a true samaritan looks like" 😂

[@RougeHimbo]

What if he’s responsible for her death and she didn’t starve...

[@falloutbunker]

Yeah I was going to say

[@c3aloha]

I think if you don’t kill him he does go and kill her.

[@liammulligan4377]

c3aloha i visited her as john and thought her how to shoot, she never invited me in and she isnt there anymore, she dead or ?

[@liammulligan4377]

Jerry L its been quite a while tbh

[@liammulligan4377]

Jerry L i canf find any side mission tbh

[@eternalmiasma5586]

Charlotte is my favorite side character in RDR2, she knew Arthur and John not as outlaws but just good hearted guys. Part of me likes to believe if Arthur hadn’t passed that they might have gotten together

[@keith3819]

When you first meet Charlotte, I thought she accidentally killed her husband because she said she was good at picking poisoned berries. I figured she fed some of them to her husband. Then I figured she lied to Arthur about him being attacked by a bear.

[@cptfreeman8966]

In my play through she doesn’t die of starvation. I encountered her once as Arthur and then came back as John and she was doing pretty fine. She said any friend of Arthur’s is a friend of hers and I proceeded to finish her stranger missions as John.

[@Fizhy]

West ones that

[@chocjane08]

I didn't know she could die of starvation, is that the result if you dont complete all her missions as Arthur? I liked her a lot and made a point of looking for any new missions for her. I know rockstar have a certain cynical style but I could have done with a lot more missions like that. Going back as John to tell of his passing had me tearing up.

[@balobadartist9022]

Respect for Charlotte, Hamish, and Hosea. Two of which were Arthur’s good friends and one of which was like a real father. RIP 😭😭 ... And nobody can forget LEENNAHY

[@Trapsarentgay133]

Yennel!!!

[@yvespenaflor4610]

You forgot Charles chatenay

[@glockstartommy]

I’m loving the red dead vids fizhy, thx for your time and effort

[@xlverrx4681]

That was the sweetest thing when Charlotte gave Arthur a kiss

[@furioussherman7265]

She honestly seems like one of the most genuine and likeable NPCs in the whole game. Her and the Sheriff of Tumbleweed would have to be my favourites, for whole different reasons though, of course.

[@ryansmyth8139]

the story with charlotte was one of my favorite story lines.

[@misturloud1513]

Good find fizhy. Its dope that we find lil bits and pieces after playing more and more of this awesome game.

[@BrokenDreamers]

Yeah I saved my game before I interacted with him just so I could enjoy killing him over and over. Idk why but I felt so protective over the girl for some reason.

[@viveka2994]

Maybe your the stalker

[@BrokenDreamers]

george washington holy shit 🤔

[@boygenius538_8]

@@viveka2994 fine line

[@PerseusR51]

@@viveka2994 gotta take out the competition ey?

[@themightybeen7856]

I have a specific save that its near him before the encounter 😂

[@FandomChronicle]

A great dialogue for before you kill the stalker: Arthur: Well, since you seem to fancy this lady so much, you know her name? Man: No not really, but not yet tho, I will get to know her better soon. Arthur (while glaring at him): Charlotte. Her name is Charlotte. Man: What? How do you know that? Kill him

[@cadehowell2162]

Is this actually what it is if you reply positively the whole time

[@ladyterror4663]

I truly loved Charlotte, she’s one of those people who truly took her fate into her own hands. Stood up for herself and took control of her life despite the odds stacked against her.

[@TheYeastOfUs]

If you go back to his camp at night there is actually a secret dialog that reveals the day of fishy’s birthday. And he will say “today is fishy’s birthday, happy birthday mate”

[@thewritermichaelis200]

My favorite side mission frfr.

[@jacksonb.valentine8208]

The second I realized he was talking about Charlotte, I blew his head off. Was surprised I lost honor for it.

[@Radagon_the_night_moose]

This guys voice just makes everything seem interesting

[@Eden-the-fallen]

Oh, I saw that man. I didn't know he was a stalker. Didn't have time to find out. I may have snuck up behind him, hogtied him and roasted him on the fire, but let's not get into it.

[@liamscanlon469]

As soon as he started getting freaky i lit him up with a pump action lol

[@lsswappedcessna]

Pump action is a beastly gun.

[@liamscanlon469]

@@lsswappedcessna yeah esp with explosive slugs lol

[@chrishatchett9506]

I never made the connection holy shit. I just shot him as soon as he said “watched her from the bushes” thanks for the video the amount of detail in this game is insane

[@honestjohn3881]

Oh jesus I feel stupid now. I'm gonna drag him behind my horse.

[@beetle2147]

There's actually so much shit in this game it's unreal😂

[@colonelnoob3269]

I really like these types of videos. It gives context for people that have not had this encounter or people that are just interested in the game. Also has sources and referenced items in the description. Top notch!.

[@barfo281]

That creep keeps respawning no matter what you do to him, and you always lose honor for taking out the trash.

[@tobiasbirkhofer3045]

Bon Appétit Arther: *NANi?!?!*

[@shyyzygodly2139]

Arthur*

[@cq_the_kid]

"This is what a true Samaritan looks like" *Proceeds to shoot stalker's head with a shotgun*

[@internetpeople1064]

I was a good Samaritan and took the negative honor as a badge of courage.

[@skyhawkslcb18]

badge of honor* wtf is a badge of courage lmao

[@gphjr1444]

Never visited with John. It's crazy seeing her suited up with a holster and appearing way more confident and an apt survivor.

[@gigachad9016]

Hamish and Charlotte were exactly the friends Arthur needed at the end of his life. The Nun told Arthur to be the best he could be and they helped him

[@frankalcala6766]

when we were carrying her dead animal back, i accidentally pulled my gun or shot or something and she got scared and ran off

[@Bellas61]

I don't remember encountering this guy but I did get a home robbery tip a while back, even went to the house with ill intentions but couldn't get in. Oh how bad I felt when I got to know her towards the end.

[@trindalas]

It’s such a shame they couldn’t have had an alternate ending for Arthur where he settles down with her, ending his story happily and still moving on to John... it’s actually pretty sad. There was definitely potential there.

[@skyhawkslcb18]

that's not what redemption is.

[@anvion1161]

Arthur is genuinely so wholesome

[@jakecarmi8571]

I swear I found that guy A LOT closer to her cabin in my first playthrough. And I was fine with the low honor spike you get for killing him.

[@terminallumbago5074]

13:01 i almost died

[@designdefense]

“Give a man a fish, you feed him for a day, teach a man to fish, you feed him for a life time”

[@kookie4nookie]

Kris.C one of my favorites

[@CutterboyBK]

This side quest is probably my favorite in the entire game just because of how you see Arthur become more and more sick while you see her become more and more self-sufficient. I don’t know how to explain it I just really liked them more than the others.

[@cape206]

I like this filter you put on rdr2 vids, very immersive!! Also, pretty sad story and my personal favourite side quest!!

[@poodypooroo]

This was one of my favorite side quests. It also shows a little picture of what Arthur's life could have been if his kid had survived or Mary had stayed with him and he'd been able to leave the gang. He's not a good man, he very much believes the ends justify the means if the end is keeping his family safe and is willing to witness or participate in some truly heinous things just on the promise that Dutch "has a plan". That said most of his acts come from a place of caring, of wanting to provide and using the only skills he knows how to do it. He does awful things but he does them to keep the gang together, fed, and safe, and to make his father figures proud. Charlotte is someone with nothing for Arthur to take in a very vulnerable position and we get to see the man he should have been if his life had taken a few different turns. It's a great little side quest but ultimately a very sad one.

[@mannydcbianco]

I can't help but to think that in another life Arthur and Charlotte could have ended up spending the rest of their lives together. Alas it wasn't to be, but as I played the game and this part of the story it just felt like they were meant for each other.

[@chazer0075]

This, The Veteran, Mary's, and Mrs Downes' missions should've all been main story missions, they all make the game much more interesting and impactful

[@donjuandemarco4115]

The main story is the open world in my opinion

[@SR-Korp]

7:17 seeing Arthur like this always break my heart

[@charleswhitehead455]

I ran into that stalker character way before I ever knew about Charlotte and he just screamed creepy guy so I went ahead and took care of him. Never thought twice that Charlotte was his intended target.

[@madmaddox3451]

Charles: teaches arthur how to hunt Arthur: teaches this chick how to hunt

[@mpscrapz95]

One of the most wholesome things in RDR2 is when you go to the people you knew as Arthur, but as John and you all reminisce on him

[@barbaraluani1455]

Dear Fizhy, The content I have seen you produce is pretty dang amazing. I have watched some of your AC videos and it has helped me out alot. All the qeustions and answers I had that you answered made me more interested to do some reasearch about games. This is on my mums account so yeah. You probs wont see this but keep up the good content. -Matthias Luani

[@Madashell1200]

I was so happy when I went back with John and Charlotte was still alive.

[@evanparker3586]

The composition of this video is actually phenomenal, unique, and out of the ordinary compared to most other videos I come across. This is inspiring since I also have many stories I plan to turn into movies and videos games and I plan to compose them. I also hope to compose a lot of other movies and become a well known composer. Any way, just wanted to congratulate you for the composition. Even if you didn’t write the music, you still added the best and most suitable music to every scene. Congrats again.

[@rasin847]

coming back as john is really nice if you do all her missions, she’s older and is doing well for herself and it makes me happy

[@Kaitekae]

I love how Arthur reaction was towards him talking about her

[@HalftimeBackflip]

"Suurre" lol

[@N.R.K.9]

in my playthrough, after teaching her hunting, the cutscene ended before i could accompany her to her home, a black panther or cougar idk jumped on her and killed her before i could put enough bullets in the beast...i felt so sad that i taught her hunting but couldnt even save her so she can learn more and finish the mission...i didn't have a save point anywhere close to that encounter. so in sadness i closed the game for the day.

[@angrym0nkeysh0w]

Damn, that's messed up

[@MasonicSeven7]

This game is so realistic I didn't even know that was possible to happen

[@FunnyRedemption]

​@@MasonicSeven7 It's only for this mission. If it happens in other side missions you'll fail it.

[@Orophile_303]

Arthur is so caring and considerate of even strangers 😭

[@johnmarston8437]

Especially Thomas Downes and basically every person he collected debt from

[@TheOldBoar]

Your music choice is pretty good. The way it slowly builds suspense.

[@canadianbacon9819]

In real life Arthur would have gotten other gang members sick. With how contagious you would have been at this point Charlotte would have also contacted tuberculosis, especially because she picked him up, obviously within a close proximity, and allowed him to rest in her bed... Even when teaching her how to shoot he as far to close.

[@p1xl_bl1tz98]

It was so sad when Arthur died. DAMN YOU MICAH!

[@therealivydawg]

I think Arthur would have died regardless of Micah.

[@p1xl_bl1tz98]

@@therealivydawg true

[@JaQuezstarr16]

But still... r/fuckmicah

[@therealivydawg]

@Rafay K0ng umm he had TB. So he was dieing.

[@johnhammersmith7828]

@Ugh Rafay he told Arthur to get somewhere nice and Arthur joked about spending time in his country club in California as a sarcastic joke

[@TheKingDomm]

When you need to get to the 10 minute mark but you only have 4 mintues

[@viveka2994]

Dude some of his vids are shorter than 10minutes

[@dfrufb2715]

Hey Fizhy, there’s also been talk of an Easter in Limpany at around 12 am midnight, sounds of something or someone grunting or howling can be heard just outside of the abandoned bar when standing on the outside porch. I went to test this myself and even I heard it. Yet i haven’t seen one youtuber talk about it. Definitely worth checking out! 👍

[@omarifarrow7043]

*Blows off another fellow human being’s head* “This is what a true samaritan looks like”

[@skyhawkslcb18]

if it's trash, who cares. trash goes in the dumpster.

[@omarifarrow7043]

@@skyhawkslcb18 😂😂😂😂

[@alienape3171]

I am still convinced the bear really hurt him but she accidentally gave him berries.

[@entrxpic]

Nah man. I’m pretty sure he’s Otis Miller

[@ellis4091]

Maybe it's Gavin

[@peachtoastie]

Charlotte: Bon appétit Arthur: 👁👄👁

[@rk800prototype5]

I love how in the cutscenes Arthur acts like an experienced hunter and shootist who knows his stuff, but when it cuts to the gameplay I'm just sitting here like, "hOw dO i hUnT"

[@skyhawkslcb18]

hunt from horseback, and use deadeye every single time. you will never fail again. bunch of unimaginative fuckers out there.

[@nichtsicher422]

Nah, just run around with your hors and dead eye those fuckers from a distance.

[@jdpragmatic8644]

“There is some money in a box on the nightstand. Take it, I have more than enough back in the city.” I only took half of it

[@antipsychotic451]

You have a great talent for padding videos. 13 minute video and 10 minutes of it is just cutscenes? Wow! That's real nose-to-tail editing.