Survivor Redemption Island In 17 Minutes!

[@patrickkenneally3016]

One has to wonder if the cast was picked specifically to help Rob win.

[@aaliyah1043]

I could see that, but I also feel like it really depending on what tribe they ended up on. If Rob was on Zapatera the game would be completely different, it was just where they ended up with the buff draw.

[@teehee3657]

They definitely were

[@frankieseward8667]

Ah yes the Survivir equivalent of Hells Kitchen Season 9

[@markjackson6431]

Hell’s Kitchen Season 9 was a season i loved when it first aired but in all the rewatches i couldn’t stand anyone except Will and Tommy. Robdumbshit Island is no different. i liked it when i first watched it and on rewatches i can’t stand anyone except Rob and Phillip. those pink briefs are almost as iconic as Coach’s Exile visit.

[@lastdayonearthmysteryman4849]

@@markjackson6431 The Final 5?

[@markjackson6431]

@@lastdayonearthmysteryman4849 yes.

[@lastdayonearthmysteryman4849]

@@markjackson6431 Will and Paul screw over Jennifer made lose respect for them!

[@markjackson6431]

@@lastdayonearthmysteryman4849 the fact that Ramsey and or the producers allowed that is sooo appalling.

[@degeneratemale5386]

I wish Matt got another shot at survivor. The man spent his entire game dominating at redemption island, just to lose at the final duel

[@blusheraee2111]

they offered him another shot on caramoan. he declined.

[@XanderMatthews-nv9zf]

It’s crazy how all it would have taken for Rob to lose this season would be Ashley Underwood winning the final immunity challenge Legit the entire jury hated Rob, Natalie, and Phillip, imagine if they had to edit this season to fit the Ashley win

[@5RG2]

Tbh they probably would’ve edited Ashley similar to Sophie’s edit in South Pacific if that would’ve happened.

[@DouglasJefferson-tp9kp]

Literally the only season ever where every single person who made the merge easily wins a jury vote over all 3 who made the end.

[@markjackson6431]

the jury did admit in post game interviews that had Phillip owned his game and admitted that his behavior was done to be seen as a goat so he would dupe Boston Rob; they would’ve voted for him. on one hand it shows how hated Boston Rob (and by extension Natalie) was and on the other hand, Phillip could’ve won using the Loudmouth strategy (same thing that got Evil Dick the win in Big Brother).

[@lrockyfan5106]

I highly doubt that they would have voted for Philip. Juries lie all the time about being on the fence. They have their minds made up before the finalist even plead their case.

[@DouglasJefferson-tp9kp]

@@lrockyfan5106 I could see it. The jury HATED Rob and Natalie is the biggest goat in Survivor history. All 3 lose a jury vote to all 9 others who make the merge, but I could see Phillip pulling an upset over Rob with the right jury speech just due to how hated he was by the end, and Natalie doesn't even exist and would lose even in a Final 1.

[@ChristianMoffet]

@@lrockyfan5106 It wouldn't be a pro Phillip vote. It would be an anti Rob vote. And I could see it just due to how hated Rob was by that jury. Anyone but Phil and Natalie literally have the win over Rob guaranteed just by sitting down, so Phillip with the FTC he promised, although I would be amazed if he ever did it, could win. And Natalie is the easiest person to beat in a jury vote to ever sit at FTC in the shows history. I think a rock wins a Final 2 over her. As it turns out Phillip even with his awful FTC, and being an extremely hated guy already who virtually did nothing in the game either other than his supposed be the goat plan, still did beat her at FTC even after cussing out the entire jury, LOL!

[@FuntimeBlako]

I actually binged watched this entire series lol.

[@GamingFanactic911]

Zapatera definitely got karma for getting rid of Russell. I honestly think this season is really fun to watch, but I understand why people hate it.

[@esdeathisbae9480]

Your like/dislike of the season is entirely contingent on Boston Rob

[@ChristianMoffet]

@@esdeathisbae9480 Not entirely. I would put it a different way. If you don't love Rob there is no chance you like this season. However even if you love Rob, there is a good chance you will hate or atleast not care for the season, as many even huge Rob fans I know still hate RI since they say the cast sucked, it was boring, the editing sucked, and the game play and was dull outside of Rob. Liking Rob a lot is merely a pre requisite for there being any chance at all of you liking the season, as there is literally no chance otherwise.

[@joekendras]

@@esdeathisbae9480 Even most Rob fans hate the season. They don't hate the final outcome, but hate the overall season.

[@lastdayonearthmysteryman4849]

The dream of Jeff Probst finally happened he got to watch Rob win!

[@WilsonReviews]

Say what you will about the overall season, but the story of rob on this season is a truly incredible story (and said story is the best part about this season). I may get flak for this, but robs game here is the best winning game in survivor history imo. His win is the only time where someone had the entire game on lock all the way back from the final 11, which someone like Kim did not achieve until the final 7. While RI is certainly not the best season out there, seeing rob do so well makes for an incredible story, which makes this not the worst season imo

[@ryhi5]

Oh absolutely! Rob played a masterful game! Sacrificing Matt, flushing out Ralph and Christina’s idols, keeping Phillip and Andrea under control, all examples of brilliant strategy! The problem is being one of only two veterans on a season full of noobs makes it look like Rob was playing on easy mode.

[@XanderMatthews-nv9zf]

Huh, Kim had total control from top 10, Jay blindside and then nobody else had a chance

[@frankiedelgadoes]

Kim had her season on lock the day they set foot on the island, LOL! And Rob didn't have the win on lock until he got to Final 3 with Phillip and Natalie, the only two he can even win agaisnt, so literally not until Day 38. Wouldn't even put Rob's win top 10 all time, maybe not top 15.

[@awilk709]

This season makes Rob’s win less notable due to the fact that he was on a season with naive idiots (besides Andrea)

[@lrockyfan5106]

Yeah right. Imagine having Robs threat level plus the fact that there’s only two returning players and they still don’t vote him out. That’s just good game play. Russel wasn’t able to do it this season. Kelly Wentworth did good but not nearly as good as Rob, she also didn’t win.

[@awilk709]

@@lrockyfan5106 yes but he got lucky being on the tribe he was on, if he was on the other tribe they would’ve for sure voted him out , no diss to Rob but he was playing with dumb dumbs

[@lrockyfan5106]

@@awilk709 yeah just like he’s gotten extremely unlucky with tribes. He was dominating in marquesas until the tribe swap.

[@frankiedelgadoes]

Andrea!?!? Andrea was probably the worst Ometepe player this season.

[@frankiedelgadoes]

@@lrockyfan5106 Nope. His tribe were way down in numbers, and the Rotus all hated him. He never stood a chance this season, and his game was not any good. He was of course much improved in All Stars, although he never advanced out of being a player with some serious flaws (inflexible strategy, terrible jury management even in the season he won).

[@snobey]

Aka. Survivor Boston Rob Island

[@markjackson6431]

Robdumbshit Island

[@addi543]

Rob Dead Redemption

[@smythsonianisback4190]

"Matt decided to stick with Rob and Ometepe, and told Rob everything, *which included him to eventually vote Rob out.* " Me: (Banging my head on the wall)

[@snobey]

Also one question: will there be a reupload of All Stars video?

[@Eggiehi-hc1gc]

Yes lol

[@ZaysOT]

Finally I love the survivor break downs 🫡

[@lastdayonearthmysteryman4849]

Jeff favorite season!

[@TheRealRL7]

0:07 russel and rob from season 8 of hell's kitchen?

[@lastdayonearthmysteryman4849]

Rob played an great game but against idiots!

[@qu4ry529]

Unpopular opinion this season has 2 of the best episodes of survivor on this season the rest of the season sucks but the premiere and the second matt boot are amazing television

[@addi543]

Tried watching this season with my son (got him into Survivor and he wanted to see how Rob vs Russell would play out after HvV) and we both tapped out the episode after the merge because it was just so boring. Phillip was funny, but his wannabe Coach-like antics just got too grating and everyone else was a pedestrian for Rob to steamroll

[@ejirokirishima4604]

Probably my least favourite season. The gameplay is so boring and the characters are a whole lot of nothing, we got andrea out of it, who is a fun character who happens to play on bad seasons everytime, but the rest is so mot fun and it made me dislike rob a bit because it was so boring.

[@ryhi5]

Rob played brilliantly, but his masterful ability to control the game is overshadowed by the fact that the season was fixed for Rob to play on easy mode.

[@lumarrandom8144]

@@ryhi5there were multiple times that he may have gone home or been close to if he didn't win immigrants nity when needed. You can maybe say redemption island was so rob can come back but him never even needing it shows his skill. (I'm not glazing)

[@pamw565]

Boston Rob is the GOAT

[@grantgoffin4774]

Yes a player who couldn't win the game twice, which multiple people have done, despite being the only player in history to play 5 times. A player who was a very early boot in 3 of his 5 seasons. A player who loses a jury vote to nearly everyone both seasons he did reach the end, despite being able to win once only due to being against the 2 biggest goats in Survivor history at the end. Is the GOAT. And I have a large bridge for sale. Thanks for the comedy.