Follow The Prophet ﷺ or Abu Hanifah? | Shamsi at Speakers Corner

[@DUSDawah]

Imam Abu Hanifa ➜www.maturidis.com/maturidi/?fnegp

[@hammadmoosa1611]

I am from sub continent Pakistan same thing happened in my country majority is barelwi then deobandi they both come from sufi sect they both are hanafis, i was barelvi then became deoband now i am following Quran And Sahih Hadith.. barelvi are extreme sufi they do shirk seeking help from aulia Allah do mawlids believe that prophet Muhammad ﷺ is everywhere watching us hearing us and Muhammad ﷺ is made from Allah's noor Naudzubillah

[@ExtremeShez]

@@hammadmoosa1611 Deobandi also have major issues in Aqidah such as Wahdatul Wajood.

[@hammadmoosa1611]

@@ExtremeShez yeah but i didn't heard it in khutbas in their masjid but barelvi do everything openly

[@ExtremeShez]

@@hammadmoosa1611 you'll find in their books and they hide their baatil.

[@hammadmoosa1611]

@@ExtremeShez yeah i know about that

[@Randomhandlename]

Abu Hanifa may Allah have mercy upon him said “If I ever say something that contradicts the book of Allah and the Prophet peace and blessings be upon him , then leave my statement.”

[@abdiadan7732]

When he said that who is talking to is not taking to me and you he is talking to his students who knows better then me and you we follow the salaf not so call salafiya

[@Randomhandlename]

@@abdiadan7732 his students were not his followers? You’re playing with words but it’s not helping you when you follow salaf you’re following salafiya but you dont follow salaf you’re a blind follower playing with words

[@herbalistathari]

@@abdiadan7732 He told the selef not to follow his mistakes, according to your idiotic statement only they recognise the mistakes he made ? Are you on drugs ? Linguistically and action wise you cannot follow the Selef without Selefia, do you not see your own contradicting statements? Can you explain to me the meaning of Allah ?

[@herbalistathari]

@@Randomhandlename agi leave him, I’ve seen him posting comments everywhere on this video. He’s not here to learn only to debate. Allah said: And avoid the ignorant 7:199 he clearly is one of them. Leave him baareklahoefik

[@cybertime4143]

@@abdiadan7732 What is salafiyah?

[@abu_muadh]

Blindly following other than Prophet Muhammad (ص) is very dangerous.

[@MuhammadAli-mz4pq]

Following the Messenger of Allah is the evidence brother, so it would not be called blind following.

[@abu_muadh]

@@MuhammadAli-mz4pq at some point, we follow what prophet Muhammad (ص) came up with without questioning. You can't question everything, we believe Allah and His Messengers.

[@rajinhossain5742]

@@abu_muadh you should type out sallalahu alayhi wasalam BarakAllahu Feek

[@ibnefayaz5107]

These things are very common in the Subcontinent region. Some of the brothers even reject the sahih Ahadeeth to follow the Imams.May Allah swt give all of us hidayah,Aameen

[@bluerock9238]

Example???

[@PoeticSonic]

@@bluerock9238 many and not only in the subconetent. it's not even the imam's fault as their followers sometimes make mistakes and plant them into the akeeda. i forgot which imam followers do this but when they pray they put their hands beside them like how you would normally stand rather than doing what the prophet and the sahaba did which was to raise the hands close to the chest and put the right hand over the left. the imam himself didn't do that because he didn't know how to place his hands while doing prayer nor did he want to make a bidaa, he placed his hands next to him because he was physically unable to do that because he was whipped by the ruler because he didn't follow what the ruler wanted him to change things in the religion. i might be wrong but i think it was imam malik, i might be wrong tho, either way that's just one example of rather than the imam, the followers start either on purpose or by mistake through sheer blind following creating a bidaa that isn't from islam yet they claim it's from the imam

[@shohaibqazi4576]

it was imam malik who was whipped

[@PoeticSonic]

@@shohaibqazi4576 so I got it right, thank you brother

[@farhadmiah8968]

FACTS!!

[@kenkaneki9138]

Abu Hanifa may Allah have mercy on him would have nothing to do with this guy, Abu Hanifa clearly stated "If my word contradicts Quran and Sunnah you should abandon it" Abu Hanifa lived in a place where not many Hadiths were transmitted to him unlike imam Malik in Madina.

[@taimur74]

Same situation in Pakistan where I am from .. they have turned the imams into prophets who are to be blindly followed

[@arbabahmed2568]

no one did in Pakistan my brother , you are just using your negativity eye

[@Randomhandlename]

This is true

[@thezohaib.2596]

@@arbabahmed2568 no they have

[@HilyahAsSalaf]

You can see very clearly starting at around 9:00 that he has a level of jahl regarding 'ilm ul hadith, where he is unsure if an aahaad hadith can have ahkaam derived from it. This, plus an incorrect methodology he was taught in usool al fiqh is seemingly resulting in it to be difficult to change his beliefs. It's quite sad seeing many of my family, Muslims living around me, and this brother having faulty foundations. May Allah guide them.

[@AbuMusaAlBurtughaalii]

We don't blind follow, but we do take rulings from those in positions to give rulings, so long as the evidence is there. If there is stronger opinion that comes with evidence after then you must accept it. It's easy brothers, just use your brain. Barrakalhu feekum.

[@AbuMusaAlBurtughaalii]

@mario kong most do, but we should not follow most Muslims. BarrakAllahu feek may Allah guide us and keep us upon the path to richeous and beneficial knowledge Aameen.

[@herbalistathari]

@mario kong Allah did not told you to occupy yourself with the businesses of most Muslims which is impossible because you don’t know every Muslim. And those who follow the scholars have narration from the prophet peace be upon him teaching us to hold vast to the selef, and we have the Quran that explains in multiple verses to return to the scholars. What do you besides assumptions and accusations have ? Do you even know the meaning of the word Allah ? I dare you go ahead?

[@AbuYusra95]

Naam true. Most people say but my hoca said this and that. They don’t accept the truth

[@gameoverability1876]

@mario kong most muslims worship scholars? you making takfir on all muslims? interesting.

[@letsgetitit2987]

May Allah reward everyone behind the DUS dawah team and keep us all firm upon the religion.

[@Muslim0987]

These Hanafi’s in most instances don’t follow the Aqidah of Abu hanifa. They hide behind the term Hanafi Madhab and in reality are asshari, matureedi, naqhababdi, deobandi, brevwli or some other deviated sect and/or misguided creed. They need to be taught Aqidah first before talking to them about fiqh.

[@AbuAbdullahUK]

Spot on. That's why I think it's a complete waste of time debating fiqh matters with them. When the aqeedah is corrected, they will implement fiqh the proper way. The aqeedah of these people is messed up so you wont get anywhere with them... That's why you will never find a Salafi having problems in fiqh matters.

[@samir2319]

So why do salafi scholars then critisize imam Abu Hanifas aqidah calling him murji'i and jahmi and write books against his aqidah like muqbil did? Imam Abu Hanifa has many aqidah points which go against the salafis of today, so even if we accept most hanafis don't follow him in aqidah, the imam is even further from the salafis of today.

[@Knowledgeandententertainment]

@@AbuAbdullahUK Assalamu alaikum why have you stopped posting videos ?

[@AbuAbdullahUK]

@@Knowledgeandententertainment wa alaikumus Salam wa rahmatullah, 2 reasons: 1) I don't agree with commoners posting original material on KZbin . People may get attached to the channel and rely on it, while they ignore the established channels like DUS da'wah, which is being supervised by du3aat like Shams uddin. Commoners are more likely to deviate, and we always seek refuge in Allah from deviation, but, if a commoner deviates, he can poison a lot of people. Educated du3aat are less likely to deviate due to their knowledge and connection to the 'Ulama. Therefore, I don't like seeing commoners, masaakeen, like me being encouraged to post original content. Having said that, I may post some edited content taken from channels like DUS and clearly link it back to that channel, for example. When that will happen, I am not sure, Allah knows best. 2) I am simply more busier nowadays, less free, due to family and work commitments.

[@exsalafi393]

Your opinions do not establish facts

[@user-cl7lx4bb5f]

Ibn al-Qayyim said in Al-Kafiyah ash-Shafiyah: Knowledge is “Allah said and his Messenger said” And “the Sahaba said, ’’for they are the people of cognisance. Therefore, knowledge is not foolishly opposing the Messenger by way of the opinions of so-and-so.

[@tktk4273]

This guy was saying some dangerous stuff subhanallah may Allah protect us

[@MohamedShou]

Some of these ultra Abu Hanifah types are honestly insane. Wallahi if Abu Hanifa *May Allah have mercy on him* was alive today and he saw what they was doing and saying he would disassociate from them. The four Imams *and there was more madhabs once upon a time* are great but we don’t blind follow a madhab. We use it as a blueprint but as soon as there is better evidence for a particular matter in the Deen we either take it or reject it Edit: btw the brother in the background that is getting loud needs to relax and have patience. Wallahi we have become so weak in patience

[@s23r32]

I remember many years ago in college a brother argued with me for raising my hands before and after Rukoo'... You can't claim to follow the Sunnah if you don't follow the Hadeeths.

[@docm7735]

@ali naqvi yeah but bare in mind that most Salafis who follow the Qawl a Rajih of el Ulamah do raise hands, cause the prophet said in an authentic hadeeth "pray like you see me pray" and from his prayer he raise his hands systimatically. w allahu aalam.

[@rathernot6660]

Don't mix fiqh with aqeedah brother. Nothing wrong with not raising as many scholars have difference in opinion on these matters such as raising the hands or keeping the index finger raised or in movement. Quran and Sunnah.

[@s23r32]

@@rathernot6660 The fanatics make it into an Aqeedah issue when they refuse to follow authentic Hadeeths and argue with people who follow those Hadeeths!

[@ابوآسيةالسويسري]

@@rathernot6660 theres ijmaa that raising the hands is a sunnah.

[@FazsterHQ]

@ali naqvi at-tirmidhi contains both sahih and daaeef hadith so unless you are a Muhadith you won’t be able to distinguish between the two. So if at-tirmidhi does contain the hadith as per the argument that you’re putting forward have you checked the classification of it?

[@AymanTravelTransport]

In order to understand this matter better, know that in the time of the 4 Imams (may Allah have mercy on them all) the hadith were not as easily accessible as they are today; not only was there no Internet to allow you to easily look up any hadith, but the books of hadith weren't as widespread or easy to get hold of as they are now (no telecommunications to easily get information from distant lands; you had to physically travel to each and every land to collect hadith from where they spread to, and of course there were no cars, trains or planes to get there quickly either) and in the time of Imam Abu Hanifah specifically, not even compiled in the first place! There was no Sahih Bukhari or Sahih Muslim to look into in the time of Abu Hanifah because those Imams of Hadith weren't even born yet during his entire lifetime, let alone compiling their famous hadith books we all know and love today; Imam Bukhari was born 44 years after Imam Abu Hanifah died just to give you some perspective. On top of this, the circumstances of where Abu Hanifah lived at the time was widespread lies and deception, where it was difficult to know whether a hadith was authentic or unauthentic and there were no telecommunications (remember) so it's not like the imam had any means to compare information in his land with external sources elsewhere. Even with writing letters, they could easily be intercepted and altered/distorted. Thus, the imam had a valid excuse to have a weak knowledge of hadith, thus rely on qiyaas (analogy) for many rulings, as the means we have ready access to in our time just wasn't there back then. Alhamdulillah, today the books of authentic hadith are widespread and easily available without having to set foot outside your home, so we have no excuse to blind follow the imam where he ended up opposing a hadith he had no means of knowing about in the first place (QadrAllah). Even the imam HIMSELF said "If a hadith is authentic, then THAT is my madhab" meaning that had he known about any authentic hadith, he would have surely acted upon it.

[@bilaalal-maghreebi5899]

Barakallaahu feekum much needed clarification here in the west!

[@al-nshmi5377]

نحن نتبع القرآن والسنة للعلماء فضل عظيم في أمور الدين ولكن نحن لا نتبع العلماء بشكل أعمى فمن أتى بدليل الأقوى يتبع وهذا من عظم وقوة هذا الدين البعيد عن التحريف ففي الاسلام اذا اخطأ بغير قصد عالم أو شيخ نبهه العلماء الآخرون وأوضحوا مكان خطأه من دون أي اهانة أو أنكار لجهده في المواضع الأخرى

[@herbalistathari]

@@mohithegreat7912 may Allah bless you brother, they are not scholars. The scholars live in Mekka and medina. Like Salih El fawzaan or Shaykh Rabi ibn hadi, or shayk ubaid, of shayk Abdoellah bukhari, shaykh Arafat etc. Beralwi is a deviated sect with manny innovations and even pagan practises. And from Allah is all succes

[@-hor]

@@herbalistathari its not true there r scholars in places other than madin and mecca but the most this time are from mecca and madina

[@-hor]

@@herbalistathari but thank u for explaning beralwi

[@herbalistathari]

@@-hor i was referring to the major scholars coming from Saudi may Allah bless you

[@TheStraightPathIslamTees]

Interesting point that Ustadh Abu Idrees raised in a lecture called *Hold Fast to the Rope of Allaah altogether and do not become divided* years ago: "And then they say things like to understand the Book of Allaah you need to follow a madhab, and these individuals, meaning these four imaams. And we hold these Imaams in high esteem, do not misunderstand what we are trying to say. These four Imaams had a very very high lofty position, from the ulemaa of Sunnah - they had knowledge and we acknowledge that, but what we say is, is it permissible, because what their students noted down and later on became a madhab, that if today someone brings you a hadith of the Messenger Muhammad (صلى الله عليه وسلم) or brings you a verse from the Qur'an, that is outright rejected because it was not documented by their students on that particular Imaam, this is when it becomes blameworthy. *And regarding their argument that they (four Imaams) came before you, they were way way before so they had better knowledge, they knew regarding the Qur'an and the Sunnah, because they were closer, then we use that same argument and we say, well what about the Companions of the Messenger of Allaah? They were before the four Imaams, they lived with the Messenger* (صلى الله عليه وسلم)." Ali (رضي الله عنه‏) said: *“If the Religion was according to opinion, then the bottom of the khuff (leather socks) would be more deserving to be wiped as opposed to the top. But indeed, I saw the Messenger of Allaah (صلى الله عليه وسلم) wipe the top of his khuffs".* Sunan Abu Dawud, Book 1, Kitab Al-Taharah (Purification), no. 162.

[@Knowledgeandententertainment]

Sakhr ibn Rāshid said: وَقَالَ صَخْر بن رَاشد I saw Abdullāh ibn Mubārak in my sleep after he died. رَأَيْت عبد الله بن الْمُبَارك فِي النّوم بعد مَوته So I said, “Didn't you die?” فَقلت أَلَيْسَ قد مت He said, “Of course.” قَالَ بلَى I said, “What did Allāh do with you?” قلت فَمَا صنع الله بك He said, “He forgave me with a forgiveness which encompassed every sin.” قَالَ غفر لى مغْفرَة أحاطت بِكُل ذَنْب I said, “And what about Sufyān ath-Thawrī?” فسفيان الثورى He said, ”Hooray! He is with those whom Allāh has shown favour to, قَالَ بخ بخ ذَاك مَعَ الَّذين أنعم الله عَلَيْهِم Like the prophets, من النَّبِيين The truthful, وَالصديقين The martyrs, وَالشُّهَدَاء And the righteous, وَالصَّالِحِينَ what wonderful company!” وَحسن أُولَئِكَ رَفِيقًا Ibn al-Qayyim, al-Rūh 1/18 ابن القيم، الروح ١/١٨

[@stonerosesuk]

Blindfold firmly in place.

[@abdisud1738]

Alhamdulillah for Islaam ☝🏼🌹

[@min21403]

Majority of Hanafis do NOT follow Imam Abu Hanifa r.a. in his aqeeda. They are Asharis /Maturidis in Aqeeda. Why don't they do taqleed of Imam Abu Hanifa in aqeeda?

[@faheem4114]

May Allah guide him. This is what happens when u blindly follow for too long.

[@شعيباسلام-د7و]

جزاك الله خيرا أخي شمسي

[@cybertime4143]

This brother is not truly Hanafi, he's an Abu Hanifa fanatic ..big difference! Imam Abu Hanifa followed the Quran & Hadith and told his followers to do the same. This brother follows opinion ..smh

[@bf6724]

Imam Abu Haneefah said: “If the hadeeth is saheeh then that is my madhhab.” And he said: “It is not permissible for anyone to follow what we say if they do not know where we got it from.” According to another report he said: “It is haraam for the one who does not know my evidence to issue a fatwa based on my words.” And according to another report he added: “We are human, we may say something today and retract it tomorrow.” And he said: “If I say something that goes against the Book of Allaah or the report of the Messenger (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him), then ignore what I say.”

[@نارقنبرا]

جزاكم الله خيرا

[@tooti3138]

ا

[@Plantium700]

Allaahoema baariek!

[@moonmounie2447]

This brother reminds me of christians not anwers the questions directly..

[@nihadhasan5748]

بارك الله فيكم 👍

[@zahidpathan2827]

Following a imam is no problem but when the imam makes an err and there is a authentic hadith then leave the imam aside on that matter, the mukallid was taking so much time replying on such serious matters

[@ismaildahir1641]

Every Imaam and every scholar can make mistake in the deen. The only one that don’t make mistake and they receive revelation are the Messengers and the Prophets. Hence why Allah has chosen them to be our leaders and why we should follow them to the best of our abilities. Following any scholar don’t take you to paradise, what takes you to paradise is to follow our beloved Messenger Muhammad (saw).

[@noamanahmedbaig4812]

Asalaam Alaikum, People should just let each other finish and understand before each other speak. Besides this it is a great work by Brother Shamsi.

[@HiTekNomaschenko]

Hanafis are some of the most stubborn people you can ever deal with. May Allah guide them.

[@grahamgooch7565]

Imagine putting any other human before the messenger of Allāh peace be upon him. Crazy man couldn’t even answer Shamsi’s question.

[@mdshagor7762]

Every imam can made mistakes

[@abdiadan7732]

No one said they can't

[@mdshagor7762]

@Asu Ngullie sahabi

[@ExtremeShez]

@Asu Ngullie no it is not, read content and compare to "your" bible, Ya Saint Asu.

[@sajidmahmood4238]

Astagfirullah Prophet Muhammad peace and blessings be upon him said No Akhi but Abu haneefah said something else

[@ExtremeShez]

يَا أَيُّهَا الَّذِينَ آمَنُوا لَا تَرْفَعُوا أَصْوَاتَكُمْ فَوْقَ صَوْتِ النَّبِيِّ وَلَا تَجْهَرُوا لَهُ بِالْقَوْلِ كَجَهْرِ بَعْضِكُمْ لِبَعْضٍ أَن تَحْبَطَ أَعْمَالُكُمْ وَأَنتُمْ لَا تَشْعُرُونَ﴿ Translation: O you who have believed, do not raise your voices above the voice of the Prophet or be loud to him in speech like the loudness of some of you to others, lest your deeds become worthless while you perceive not. Ibn al-Qayyim: If just raising their voices above the voice of the Prophet was a reason to make their deeds fruitless (and futile), then what about those who give precedence to their own opinions, intellects, preferences, politics, and understanding over and above that which the Prophet came with?! Source: I’laam al-Mooqi’een (v. 1, p. 41)

[@Yahya-gw5qw]

Sūrat Āli ‘Imrān, verse 31: “Say to them, O Muhammad, ‘If you truly love Allāh, then follow me and then Allāh will love you and forgive you your sins.’” So to earn the Love of Allāh you have to make ittibā’, i.e. follow the Prophet. So others are not to be blindly-followed if they contradict the Prophet (salallahu ‘alaihi wassallam). So the origin in the religion is to follow the proofs established in the Revelation.

[@bdullahsaud]

Alhamdulillah, we are not blind followers...

[@abdisud1738]

LA ILAHA IL ALLAAH ☝🏼🌹

[@ranarizone1067]

Shami Bro biggest inspiration

[@herbalistathari]

7:3 Follow what has been sent down unto you from your Lord (the QURAN and Prophet Muhammad’s SUNNAH), and follow NOT any Auliya’ (protectors and helpers, etc

[@herbalistathari]

This ☝️ignorant soul goes around asking the same question to everyone, I advice everyone to do as Allah commanded: 7:199. And avoid the ignorant

[@trealNoOne]

@Asu Ngullie u should first ask yourself who wrote the bible? lol

[@trealNoOne]

@Asu Ngullie look who using the term pagan.lol someone who worships a human being.ironic.

[@walidtmumtuaz6681]

May Allah guide him

[@undercoverxyz7]

He is wearing a beard but doesn't know about the deen. That's the reason why our deen is in such a struggle at the moment. May Allah guide him.

[@AbuYusra95]

Allahul mustaan. May Allah guide him

[@hussaingani]

This Hanafi brother truly has bad manners even though the common person would think otherwise and be deceived cuz he's speaking more softer than those around him (and then people accuse Salafīs of bad manners when people don't actually know what proper manners of discourse are!)..... 1) He finds it difficult to answer simple questions and from basic manners is that you listen and then respond based upon what you listened to 2) this brother is actually quite passive and wants to just establish what he wants to say instead of having a discussion. Quite rude infact. 3) Difficult to speak with: Shamsi many times tries to slow and break things down to help give the brother understanding regarding what he asked Shamsi, but he goes off on tangents and clearly wants to subjugate principals Shamsi is explaining to 'difference of opinion' - because the intent behind doing this is so that a person can continue to blind follow and follow their desires without blame. Yet Hanafīs (vast majority of which are Sufi Deobandi/Tablighi/Barelwi) have the audacity and nerve to slanderously accuse Salafīs of speaking disrespectfully about Imām Abu Hanifah when in actual fact they are speaking out against the Bidah (innovations) these people are upon but try to hide behind the Madhab of Imām Abu Hanifah (رحمه الله).

[@RiazKhan-gn4vo]

They follow their own desires not Abu Hanifa رحمه الله he never said anything like this.

[@MuhammadAli-mz4pq]

May Allah guide them.

[@popo-qc1so]

Yeah your last point sums it up. It looks like they want to hide their bidah behind Abu Hanifahs name. May Allah guide this brother Ameen

[@hamidakbar3528]

You Salafis are full of rubbish. If you follow the Sunnah and Quran why don't you look like you follow the Sunnah? Even my son has more facial hair

[@tktk4273]

@@hamidakbar3528 something called genetics

[@nancy4615]

This is what blind following leads to, it even causes those who love all the imams of the ummah to sort of look down on the hanifis when imam abu hanifa was a great alim rahimahullah.

[@yusufeditzzzz]

Shamsi is too good alhumdulilah

[@agusiman2340]

يختلف الأمر كثيرًا بين الملائكة وغير المسلمين عندما يرسل الله سبحانه وتعالى آيات من القرآن هي معرفة وحقيقة من الله سبحانه وتعالى أو "الحق" التي نُقلت إلى النبي محمد صلى الله عليه وسلم لأتباعه. اتضح أن الأمر مختلف تمامًا ، فالملائكة (على الرغم من أنها ليست إلزامية على الملائكة) والأشخاص المسلمين (الذين يحبون الله ورأى محمد رسل الله) هم دائمًا يتزاحمون لأنهم متحمسون جدًا ويريدون حقًا معرفة الحقيقة من الله. وفي الوقت نفسه ، فإن غير المسلمين ("الكفار") مشغولون جدًا في رفض وإنكار وسوء تفسير آيات القرآن حتى لا يتمكنوا من الحصول على هدى الله سبحانه وتعالى (لأن هدى الله لا يقدر على الدخول فيه). قلوبهم / أرواحهم ثم تتجلى في الأعمال / الأعمال).

[@mehedi8826]

I don’t know how this guy feel secure by blindly following Abu Hanifaa, Don't he fear that if his path turns out be worng what will happen to him in the day of judgement?

[@abdiadan7732]

He is not following blind he is following the understand of imam abu hanif that's what we call following salaf the real salaf salih

[@herbalistathari]

This 👆guy goes around speaking without knowledge, he’s against the manhadj and has fanatism, may Allah heal him ameen. Don’t respond to this Djahil

[@MuhammadAli-mz4pq]

@@abdiadan7732 Nay, most Hanafi today don't follow imam Abu Hanfia in Aqeedah, they merely follow him blindly in the Fiqh ul-Isghar.

[@Yahya-gw5qw]

Its not a “if” blind following one imam in everything he says is clearly wrong… Imām Mālik Ibn Anas (rahimahullāhu ta’ālā) said: “Everyone’s speech is either accepted or it is rejected, except for the companion of this grave.” And he pointed towards the grave of the Prophet (sallallāhu ‘alayhi wa sallam). Imām Mālik was a scholar of Madīnah.

[@khalidpadia9561]

What makes you so sure following salafis are correct, according to many they have many misguided opinions

[@asyncawaited]

"You want a yes or no, but it's not that simple." Ilm-ul-kalam is a dangerous road leading to a destination of uncertainty and doubt.

[@abuhamza1970]

Ya akhi Shamsi, you have so much more patience then I ever could have. I have been on the Salafi dawah for over 30 years now and still encounter issues with the Ahnaf. Unfortunately they make up the bulk of the Muslim ummah and their creed has been established for far too long. May Allah grant you the knowledge and energy to defeat this ideology so that the Muslims can finally return to their deen. Also please bear in mind that the vast majority of Hanafis are actually Sufis masquerading as Hanafi. Barakallah feekum

[@muslimboyilyas775]

Where will Hanafis go?Hell or heaven?

[@abyanyounusshariff8279]

@@muslimboyilyas775 that's for Allah alone to decide.

[@bf6724]

@@muslimboyilyas775 A question like this is never asked by a Muslim, especially if it is about another Muslim.

[@muslimboyilyas775]

@@abyanyounusshariff8279 so u r in doubt about the salvation of 50% muslims.hilarious 🤣🤣

[@muslimboyilyas775]

@@bf6724 I have seen a very bad behaviour of muslims to wards people who follow Hanafi school of thoughts.Thats why i was testing this guy and he proved it

[@hammadmoosa1611]

I am from sub continent Pakistan same thing happened in my country majority is barelwi then deobandi they both come from sufi sect they both are hanafis, i was barelvi then became deoband now i am following Quran And Sahih Hadith.. barelvi are extreme sufi they do shirk seeking help from aulia Allah do mawlids believe that prophet Muhammad ﷺ is everywhere watching us hearing us and Muhammad ﷺ is made from Allah's noor Naudzubillah

[@muhjow]

Salam bro. Allah never taught us to use names like barelvi or deobandi. Just follow Quran and Sunnah and don’t fall into sectarianism.

[@intekabalam7340]

@@muhjow As salam alaikum akhi. You have a big misconception. The Qur'an is the guidance for mankind and it gives guidance and directives to men. So Allah mentioned in the Qur'an to follow the way of the Sahaba. Ibn Abbas radiallahu anhu is one of them. He mentioned in his Tafseer regarding the people whose faces will turn dark on that day as Ahlul Bid'ah and the ones whose faces will turn bright as Ahlus Sunnah. Following the understanding of the Sahaba is a part of the command from Allah. Also, the Prophet sallallahu alaihi wasallam told us to follow the way of the first three generations. The Salaf have used names to refer to misguided sects. They did not say we are all Muslims we should not call names. Rather they refuted and boycotted them. SECTARIANISM IS NOT BY ASCRIPTION OF NAMES, RATHER BY ADOPTION OF WRONG IDEOLOGIES. Let me demonstrate to you practically the fallacy that you have fallen into. For example, if all of the seventy three sects were to come to the agreement that we do not call each other names and do not ascribe to ourselves names apart from Muslim. For example, a Deobandi would not call himself a Deobandi and he would not call a Barelvi a Barelvi. They start calling each other and themselves Muslims only. So what do you think now? Has the sectarianism ended? No my brother. They still have the same belief they used to have earlier. They still call towards their way as opposed to the Qur'an and Sunnah. So they are still sectarian. So if the removal of ascribing names could not remove sectarianism, therefore, it wasn't the thing that brought about sectarianism in the first place. It is the deviation from the path of the Salaf that brought sectarianism. Allah said "And hold firmly to the rope of Allah and do not be divided". What is the rope of Allah? The Qur'an and Sunnah. So whosoever does not hold firmly to the Qur'an and Sunnah has caused division and it is indeed he who has caused Sectarianism. So not following Qur'an and Sunnah as understood by the Salaf is Sectarianism. Barakallahu Feek. May Allah guide us all.

[@mawims2271]

Big problem when someone bland takliq

[@Ismail-ss7rw]

Abu hanifa is free from these people

[@hamzajbara3751]

Narrated Ibn 'Abbas: I saw the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) sitting neat the Black stone (or at a corner of the Ka'bah). He said: He (the Prophet) raised his eyes towards the heaven, and laughed, and he said: May Allah curse the Jews! He said this three times. Allah declared unlawful for them the fats (of the animals which died a natural death); they sold them and they enjoyed the price they received for them. When Allah declared eating of thing forbidden for the people, He declares it price also forbidden for them. The version of Khalid b. 'Abd Allah al-Tahhan does not have the words "I saw". It has: "May Allah destroy the Jews!". Sahih Albani

[@herbalistathari]

Your point ?

[@hamzajbara3751]

@@herbalistathari my point is that when الله جل و علا , forbids something he forbids it price.

[@herbalistathari]

@@hamzajbara3751 I understand baarekelahoefik. But these people prefer Abu hanifa’s statements above that of the prophet peace be upon him, they even have books that negate Hadith, even if the Qoran goes against they’re Imams they declare the verse to be abrogated. This is pure kufr, and Allah’s refuge is sought. This is also exactly how the Jews behaved against they’re prophets, everything that didn’t suit them, they reject

[@LeviAcherrman]

when they cant answer, thats when shaitan comes in.

[@Hikmah1995]

I forgot which companion said ( I believe it was muadh Ibn Jabal but I could be wrong) this great statement to a group of ppl that were speaking like the guy in the video. The companion said "I give you the words of the Prophet Muhammad S'Allahu Alayhi Wa Salam, and you give me Abu bakr said, Umar said?" May Allah guide this guy. Ameen.

[@MustafaAli-jt8bb]

Ubadah Said to mu’aWiya

[@m.a.r5165]

The brother is trying to say that an authentic hadith that goes against the opinion of Abu Hanifa,May Allah Have Mecy Upon Him, is just another opinion and not an authentic hadith? So he has doubt that the Sunnah has been preserved. Allahul'Mustan.

[@-Black-White-]

Let only 1 person speak, the other guys should calm down if someone is explaining!

[@MineMeMineMeMineMe]

We are not Shias or Jews or Sufis or some hanafis. We do believe anybody can make mistakes that can go against Quran and sunnah except who have been endorsed by prophet Muhammad (PBUH). the mistakes of Imam can be unintentional and intentional with error in judgement. some of the hidden sins can be intentional mistakes. Imams are not devoid of sins.

[@abdrhmanhamd8917]

احد يفهمني ايش قال عشان ما فهمت ب انجليزي المسألة الفقهية بارك الله فيكم اخوتي

[@tooti3138]

المهم تفتهم ان السنة اكثر مهما من الحنفية، فا يعني الو حنيفه شخص عادي ممكن يغلط وا قال اذا اني قلت شي يختلف معا حديث او سنة او قرآن، لا تاخذون كلامي، وا المهم ان النبي لا يخطئ في رسالته وا عبادته

[@عادل-خ5ت]

هذا متبع اعمى للامام ابو حنيفة حتى وان جاءه الدليل على خطأ رئيه من السنة والقران يتركهم ويأخذ برأي الامام

[@al-nshmi5377]

حسب ما فهمت أن الأخ شمسي كان يتناقش مع الأخ ثاني على أنه في الامور الفقهية أي الأمور التي فيها خلاف هل نتبع المذاهب بشكل أعمى أو بتقليد المطلق أو ننظر الى السنة لنرى أذا كان هناك دليل أقوى فمثلا أذا وجدت مسائلة فقهية عند أحد المذاهب ووجدنا دليل في القرآن والسنة دليل واضح على خلاف هذا المذهب فأننا نتبع القرآن والسنة لأن اصحاب المذاهب بشر ويمكن أن لا تكون لديهم جميع الوسائل{ القدرة } للوصول لسنة كلها فيخطؤون بمسألة فقهية ويكون في المذهب الأخر دليل أقوي في هذه المسألة فنتبعه في أخر المقطع سأل شمسي هل نتبع الامام أبو حنيفة أو الرسول صلى الله عليه وسلم ؟ الجواب نتبع الرسول صلى الله عليه وسلم ملاحظة البعض يظن هذا انتقاص للعلماء حاشا سبب كما نعلم في الماضي صعب ان يكون لديك جميع الكتب والادلة لقلة الكتب وصعوبة نقل الكتب عكس اليوم الحالي

[@abdrhmanhamd8917]

@@al-nshmi5377 كل يؤخذ منه و يرد الا الرسول صلى الله عليه و سلم❤️

[@abyrahman6610]

Please can you explain why Imam Abu Hanifa was weak in hadith?

[@tasmiaavouka2658]

what the hell is this again ? why do people like to complicate their own life although everything is as crystal clear? this guy isn't willing to know or learn kind of wasting other's time. may Allah increase your knowledge and ours. for sure everyone who wants to go away from the Quran and Sunnah he'll find himself lost and confused

[@FazsterHQ]

My parents are from the Indian subcontinent and these ahnaaf I have been around most of my life, they are both ignorant and arrogant at the same time, Alhamdulillah for guiding me to salafiyyah.

[@khanKhan-li5rm]

May Allah have mercy upon imam abu Hanifa. He is imam of alhus sunna.

[@javiermartinez2152]

he doesnt understand what seperates a valid opinion from and invalid one.

[@FearNoneButAllah]

Teach the sunnah with the sunnah way

[@s23r32]

@DUS Dawah can you please make a clarification video explaining why you believe pictures are Halal?

[@DUSDawah]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/jXmTqIhsat-GeLc

[@hussaingani]

What was the Madhab Abu Hanīfah followed? He couldn't have been Hanafi. So the Muslims that existed before his Madhab was established.....What were they? #Salafi Let's see what the Imām himself said..... Imaam Abu Hanifah [رحمه الله] said: ❝It is obligatory upon you to follow the Athar [narrations] and the path of the Salaf and beware of any [newly] innovated matter, for verily it is a Bid’ah.❞ [Dham Al-Kalaam Wa Ahlihi, (213/4) | Translated By Abu Afnaan Muhammad Abdullah] Abu Hanīfah رحمه الله is free from the Sufi Deobandi Tablighi Barelwis Ashari Maturidi buffet.

[@shaki60]

Shamsi Abu Hanifa is Salaf brother can you point out to what rulings of Abu Hanifa is contradicted with Hadith. I’d love to learn

[@Vibez_K]

😂😂Hanafis and blind-following is something else

[@noname-fy2lv]

Abu Khanifa , Shafii , Imam maliki ,Imam ahmad ibn khanbal are ahli sunnah ual jamaga What you laughing at?

[@adamafifprive6644]

Why do you say hanafi’S like they are apart from us? Very dangerous brother.

[@Curterzstyle]

because i was taught how to pray like hanafis does that mean am going hell

[@waleedosman5658]

​@@Curterzstyleno I hope that's not what this brother means. There is nothing wrong with following any of the madhabs wither it be that of Imam Abu hanifa Imam malik Imam Al shafie Imam Ahmad ibn hanbal. As long as you follow the proof from the Quran and sunnah as understood by the sahaba when it goes against your madhab.

[@zahmed2917]

This is a new tactics, trying to put Doubts in Hadees, they try to after Abu Hurera....

[@deebanamdar7449]

I have a question I'm a Muslim and I believe and understand the quran and Islam in the way of the salaf because it makes the most sense of course but as a Muslim do we follow the things Abu hanifa said because what I understood from this debate is that if what Abu hanifa said goes with the quran and sunah we should follow but there's times where he made mistakes and we should not follow his mistakes

[@deebanamdar7449]

And also my family is a sunni hanafi Muslim so is that the way of the salaf or not like can u follow or understand the quran in the way of the salaf and also follow hanafi because salaf means how we understand the quran and our deen like first the quran explains itself and after that if we don't understand somethings we go to prophet Muhammad SAW and after that we go to the sahabas and all that then after the Sahabas we go to the people who go inline with the quran like Abu hanifa and imam Malik and all that am I right or wrong ?

[@ExtremeShez]

Do you know any books that Abu Hanifah write?

[@AbuAbdullahUK]

It seems you got it right. This is the Salafi understanding. In this day and age its sufficient to follow the Scholars who are alive such as Shaikhs Salih al Fawzan, al luhaidan, Rabee bin Hadi, and others, as Allah stated: فَسْـَٔلُوٓا۟ أَهْلَ ٱلذِّكْرِ إِن كُنتُمْ لَا تَعْلَمُونَ So ask of those who know the Scripture, if you know not. (Surah An Nisa:43). As the Brother before me indicated, there are no Salafi Scholars who can connect you to Imam Abu Hanifah's school of thought and opinions. There were a few Salafi Imams of the past who were Hanafis in fiqh, but there are none alive today. Furthermore, it is said that there are no authentic books attributed to Abu Hanifah. Most of those who call themselves 'hanafis' are like the guy in this video, deviated beralwis, deobandi sufi types, etc. Even the written materials available today on the 'hanafi madhab' have been written by these people, often a lot of fabricated opinions attributed to Abu Hanifah rahimahullah. You should strive to correct the Creed of the people before all else.

[@deebanamdar7449]

@@AbuAbdullahUK so u mean Abu hanifa words are not present today so what I think is if Abu hanifa said anything that goes inline with the quran and sunnah I will follow because what I heard he was a salaf himself I don't blindly follow its just as same if someone on the street told me to do something and it goes inline with the quran I will follow u know what I mean but my question was as a salaf which school of thought goes inline with the salaf belief because I'm from afghanistan and my mother may Allah guide her was not so strong in deen knowledge and she used to say alot of Bidah stuff like many afghans do because they don't know they just blindly follow so I was not a sufi or like that but my mom told me stuff that sufi people follow after learning about the deen I knew what we did was bidah and I told my mom and she said that she didn't know any better and one more thing what school of thought brother shamsi follows himself?

[@mohamedmohsin5723]

Islam is Islam. Only in Fiqh matters is there a difference. And the hanafi fiqh should remain the same. There are many places you could access hanafi fiqh. I think the book called Beheshti Zawr is a book on Hanafi fiqh.

[@agusiman2340]

It is very different between angels and non-Muslims when Allah swt sends down/delivered verses of the Qur'an which are knowledge & truth from Allah swt or "al-haq" which was conveyed to Prophet Muhammad SAW for his followers. It turned out to be very different, the angels (although it is not obligatory on the angels) & Islamic people (who love Allah & Muhammad Rosululloh saw) they always flock because they are very enthusiastic & really want to know the truth from Allah. Meanwhile, non-Muslims ("unbelievers") are very busy refusing, denying and misinterpreting the verses of the Qur'an so that they are not able to get the guidance of Allah swt (because the guidance of Allah is not able to enter into their hearts / souls & then manifested in actions / deeds).

[@hilalmir5173]

Obviously the Prophet (Saw)

[@ozone2126]

❤❤❤

[@sialkotcantt]

If I have to guess, this Hanafi brother was either from Pakistan or India. That is where such illogical belief can be found where you glorify others over Prophet Muhammad (SAW) naoozu billah. I am not being racist, I am from Pakistan and know all about this bs from the inside.

[@adam.259]

Abu Hanifa ❤️

[@Randomhandlename]

Abu hanifa is free from Deobandis, barelvis, maturidis and people like them. Who only follow Abu hanifa in fiqh (even in that they pick and choose and blind follow their teachers)

[@ABDULLAH-yy9gx]

Can a muslim use perfumes containing alcohol?

[@smo4082]

Why is it that people can't follow a simple request to be quiet and let the speaker finish making his point. It's always the loud mouths that think they come with the answers.

[@breadpitt5777]

I said to a hanafi brother in masjid to don’t pray witr like maghrib, he said you’re lunatic and got mad.

[@syad911]

it's a waste of time talking with someone who keep saying "so you're saying" every 30 seconds and didn't listened to you but to reply u with "so you're saying" instead. not only these kinda people don't trust u, they keep questioning your believe instead of learning for himself.

[@MonkeyDLuffy-py6zo]

Why dont they ever give anwers when they are asked. Always going around it. They asks the muslims hunderds of qeustions and they anwser every one of it. Butt the others dont. Not one of them just 1 qeustion some times and they cant. I would stay with them until they anwser that specifiek one i would ask them. Islam has every anwser to everything why still debate

[@عبداللهالبدري-ط6ر]

100 percent he's from Pakistan 😃

[@malekalharbi7000]

أشهد أن لا إله إلا الله وأشهد أن محمدا رسول الله سبحان الله وبحمده سبحان الله العظيم سبحان الله وبحمده عدد خلقه ورضا نفسه وزنة عرشه ومداد كلماته سبحان ذي الجبروت والملكوت والكبرياء والعظمة سبحان اللهم ربنا وبحمدك اللهم اغفر لي ربنا آتنا في الدنيا حسنة وفي الآخرة حسنة وقنا عذاب النار ربي إني مسني الضر وأنت أرحم الراحمين ربي اجعلني مقيم الصلاة ومن ذريتي ربنا وتقبل دعاء ربي إني لما أنزلت إلي من خيرٍ فقير لا إله إلا أنت سبحانك إني كنت من الظالمين ربي اغفر ذنبي وطهر قلبي وحصَن فرجي

[@PantheraTK]

2:40 - can anyone link me to these differing opinions?

[@ronaldbarba6416]

Who is the prophet?

[@lovlessrezvi8890]

How blindfold people are🥲

[@imrantaleb7666]

Asalam ma laykum may allah bless and ease the sufferings of the ummah and may allah protect the people of palestine and Afghanistan and Lebanon and syria and chinA and Kashmir and may allah protect the masjid al aqsa from oppressors and may allah unite the ummah upon the quran and sunnah and may allah guide all the muslims and non muslims to the right path and may allah have mercy on all those that have passed away before us and may Allah have mercy on us when we pass away and may allah cure all those that have a sickness and a disability and that have corona and may allah grant them a cure that leaves no aliment and may allah protect the muslims from hellfire and from the fitnah of dajjal and may allah answer all our prayers and duas ameen

[@MohammedAhmed-mp7lx]

This guy probably got paid to come there and cover his face. His acting weird trying to act dumb thats what I see

[@NATURLIST]

I disagree with my brother on this one, to say what hadiths saying about copying the creation of Allah(picture, drawing, engraving sculpture or any other ways- to get to the copying of Allah's living creation: from among living creatures of humans, animals, insects, birds, etc. ) is not clear, shamsi is clearly wrong here' may Allah forgives and guide him in this matter' cause the couple of hadiths that dealt with this matter, was never to focus on the way or the method that the person use to copy the living creation of Allah, but rather focal point is on the end result those "copied images" itself of those categories of living things that I mentioned above,

[@baranbektas473]

This guy doesn't let the other guy speak he spoke for about 13 mins the other guy gets only 2 minutes to talk thats not fair

[@AbdulRehman-j6q9h]

No doubt imam Abu Hanifa ( ra) is a very great scholar of muslim Ummah. But he's is not a prophet to blindly follow him in all the matters.

[@saudasiri6019]

Now we have ppl who call themselves muslims worship abu hanifa??

[@abuhudaifah_0]

Subhan Allah talking to him is talking to the Christians about the trinity. Astagfriullah

[@ess7276]

Madhab Fanatics are a headache.

[@utututabosaeed]

هكذا هم الصوفية القبورية نفس اسلوب وطريقة الشيعة يتهربون ويستخدمون التقية.... الحمد لله الذي عافاني

[@ابوآسيةالسويسري]

How come almost all the kibaar agree on the issue of photography?