FOOL US: Penn & Teller fooled by the Swiss magician LIONEL - Incredible trick with drinks!!!

The Fool Us Trophy makes its way to Switzerland. Lionel is the first Swiss magician ever appeared on Fool Us. He fools them badly using nothing else then the Swiss national beverage: Milk.

[@incollectio]

I don't know who the bearded guy is, but he's kind of stealing the show with his expressions. :D

[@miamimagicians]

His expressions look very unnatural to me

[@adamnichols476]

@@miamimagicians Santa Claus generally doesnt ask for beer.

[@christopherh2219]

Clearly it’s Santa

[@JimBob-eg7vq]

@@adamnichols476 how would you know

[@TomFromMars]

@@miamimagicians I think in this case the rules of the show wouldn't prevent him to have friends as his audience since they weren't doing for the trick except confirming that the drinks were legit which the producers would have checked anyway.

[@LionelDellberg]

Just wanted to reach out and say THANK YOU for all your messages, comments and likes. You are awesome 🙌 Thank you from the bottom of my heart 🙏 I do feel very honor to be part of the magic world 🎩😍🎩

[@rosemdhar4767]

Great job 👏👏 Wonderful👌👌

[@rahimbigsmoke]

Soda, orange juice, white wine 😂👍👍. Key of magic

[@TheGordohhh]

PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE Tell me how you did it. I promise I won't tell anyone.

[@LionelDellberg]

@@TheGordohhh 😅😉

[@vivekheer6369]

@@TheGordohhh he used flesh colored pipes😇

[@rschiwal]

There may be a few drawbacks to living in Switzerland, but the flag is a big plus.

[@sth.777]

I don't know of a single drawback to living here... unless you count overdosing on beautiful, pristine nature.

[@HelenaOfDetroit]

@@sth.777 Apparently, they don't teach comedy in Switzerland

[@sth.777]

@@HelenaOfDetroit It's a subtle humour, and in 4 languages.

[@TheRagingPlatypus]

@@sth.777 No, it's really not. I know Switzerland. You're as funny as...the Germans. Subtle is code for non-existant.

[@sth.777]

​@@TheRagingPlatypus You've obviously met the wrong Swiss. You've got no idea what you're missing out on.

[@themusicalmrc]

The first guy is still like "where is my beer?"

[@themomorain]

He probably eats cereal with beer

[@themusicalmrc]

@@themomorain who doesn’t?

[@Wallauyeh]

LoL well said

[@cvdinjapan7935]

Whenever Penn drops the coded language and just explains how he thinks the trick is done in plain English, you know a Fool Us trophy is going to appear.

[@theprofessor3485]

Yeah, I wonder about that. Like he wouldnt do it if that was the right guess, as it never is, so I wonder if he already knows he is wrong from the judges and is simply explaining their best guess.

[@unclecreepy4185]

The only time I’ve seen him do things like that is when there’s a language barrier. Even even though he speaks English, he might not know code words and slang.

[@geraldkatz7986]

He'll also do it when he hates the performer. He hates the performer when it's a con to reveal the con. For example, there was a mind reading trick with the magician backstage on video and a random audience member chosen by a number in a hat and the audience had corresponding numbers. The magician predicted everything the audience member would write on a chalkboard. At the end of the trick the random audience member revealed himself as the magician. That ticked Penn off. He said the numbers were not random. He started to read off number after number from the hat asking if anyone in the audience had the number which of course no one did.

[@alonsakarano1843]

@@geraldkatz7986 yo I wanna see that

[@Dhirallin]

That's when Penn and Teller already know that their guess is not the correct answer and thus won't give away the magician's trick, because they were in on it from the start. After all, magicians are liars.

[@destination2013]

The beer guy looks suspiciously like a magician.

[@albertorkenbjorken]

i thought it was letterman at first haha

[@donaldmoser212]

He was in Harry Potter.

[@roughsax13]

He’s a radio host the magician knew but wasn’t in on the act.

[@mattmaloney5988]

James Randi?

[@lifeislifeBee]

He might be. All the other participants might as well. Now the question is - how was the trick done? I still can't figure it out...

[@dillimore]

7:18 are we just going to ignore that Teller wrote down how to pronounce Lionel's name although he'd never say it anyway?

[@flowerdolphin5648]

That made me chuckle, cause it's a quirk I do as well. Even if I might never actually say their name out loud. But I have to say it right in my head, otherwise I'm not happy.

[@probablybatmansadventures2121]

Teller is a good magician, he had a hunch he might have to use it in the future.

[@pawnriot3269]

Except he's wrong. His name is pronounced as Lion-el not Lee-on-ell. He says it himself at 0:07 but Allison and Penn still call him Lee-on-ell for some reason.

[@jaintushartj8]

@@pawnriot3269 it's very American. You tell them exactly how it's pronounced and they do the way they want to

[@extrasyllable3865]

Teller technically never said it wrong

[@RayyM2]

First he poured milk at 1:59, which looks like there wasn't much there - probably just held in the upper plastic portion of the carton. As he's handing off the milk to the first person, you hear a plastic "pop" at about 2:04, which I think indicates he's removing a seal that separated the real milk from water that's in the rest of the container. With the Lemon Lime and Cola soda's, he's very careful about how he holds the glasses. I think there's a drink mix at the bottom of each glass that includes a bi-carbonate (think alka seltzer) that flavors and creates fizz. Espcially with the Cola where he covers the pour so as not to reveal that what is coming out is clear. At 3:11, he allows us to see the pour, but is squeezing the carton in a way he hasn't previously. He's probably holding a packet of instant orange that he slipped into the carton and is mixing with the water inside as it is poured, allowing us to see the orange color, while also cutting off the liquid to make is seem as if it runs out, thus allowing him to pour any residual mix directly into the glass while still keeping some water inside the container. At 3:40, he pours the white wine, which initially looks clear but becomes cloudy in the glass as he pours. There was likely a powered alcohol mix at the bottom of the glass that was controversial many years back because people feared that it would be snorted. The mix was probably intended for a full glass (he didn't pour a full glass), thus giving it a very rich flavor that caused the reaction on the man's face. Finally at 4:02, he's again careful to cover the glass, but at full screen you can tell that the liquid coming out of the carton is clear. It becomes white after reaching the glass. He does not drink the liquid, which likely indicates what-ever the mix is, it's intended to make water quickly turn white but not intended to be drank.

[@jamesreed5678]

After he hands the wine glass of milk to the bearded gentleman, we see his hand move to the top of the cartoon right before the camera cuts away. What was his hand doing there?

[@Shorts-gz3qk]

Penn, Teller & Ray

[@indust9224]

Brilliant!

[@TrippnTroll]

I think you are quite right. The last glass of milk can also be part of a cover-up, pouring out the evidence.

[@P4FElton]

your right... partially... he did used powder in the lower glasses (specially soda and cola)... so it is covered in the tray... however he used a tall glass and hold it very clearly when pouring the wine ... you can see no powder... however you can see him hold the milk box very in the bottom... that box does have some stuff inside or in the back, even tho he said it wasnt gimmicked... he might have fooled penn and teller, but that box is gimmicked... that type of box is very common here in europe and usually the inside is silver due to a layer of aluminium, plus your cant rip it that easily because it has multiple layers of polyethylene (plastic), just google about these boxes... (no i dont work in anything related to these boxes i just knew and googled to make sure im not bullshitting xD), besides you can see him rip open the opening... so if it isnt a 1 liter milk in it, it was gimmicked in some way... so he lied to penn and teller... (not to mention the orange juice that clearly wasnt powder and cearly was something inside of in the back/side of the box holding the huice)

[@mathiasjameson9574]

These are the most Swiss looking people ever. As a Swiss I am loving to see this

[@Enzo_q]

😂😂

[@Elusime]

Uf jede Fall 😂

[@dmurray2978]

Oy vey

[@dretubecreek]

Äuä scho so.

[@fabiomoraes35]

The first guy looks like Santa Claus on vacations

[@TroublesomeOwl]

There is no sight in this world that makes me smile more than Teller's smile when he is fooled and amazed. It is the most innocent childlike expression of wonder and joy and is utterly contagious.

[@ryanm7263]

I have a 1 year old baby and she makes the same expression when I strike a glass mixing bowl like a gong

[@gmailrockmcbride49508]

I'm sure that turns quickly into a frown when people like you constantly compare him to a child. He isn't that short, he's just next to a giant haha...childlike....that comment 🙄

[@VuskAO]

One thing is for sure, the 'milk bottle' is not wet when he tears it up

[@galgrunfeld9954]

Huh, that's true, I didn't notice that.

[@MegaFregel]

There was water inside so it appears dry.

[@Dayvit78]

@@nyChannel09 TetraPak is Swedish!

[@nyChannel09]

@@Dayvit78 Historically yes. But where is the headquarters? In switzerland. If I ask you who owns Lamborghini, r u gonna say its italian or german?

[@Dayvit78]

@@nyChannel09 :) i did not know that! thanks for informing me. Seems Swiss and Swedes deserve to get confused for each other.

[@NoOorZ24]

I'm quite sure there were white plastic containers inside and they were dumped in glass when he poured milk to himself. That's why he dumped milk so fast in his glass

[@ThePdog3k]

The soda had no carbonation, like none at all.

[@vtec230]

@@ThePdog3k coke and milk were already poured

[@adveshdarvekar7733]

But the hole was so small

[@ProfessorBrandt]

That would mean the carton was gimmicked, which it wasn’t.

[@cottontailsify]

@@ProfessorBrandt technically, the carton wouldn't be gimmicked. The carton is normal. The gimmick is that he has a collapsible container INSIDE the carton.

[@wparo]

Really nice to see. And that milk looks delicious. I think the trick was convincing Penn and Teller as well as everyone else that there was anything in the bottle at all. I think the fluids are coming from somewhere else.

[@spaceshido6124]

Maybe he just got two containers and he changes the container at last when the camera was focusing on the man with beard

[@MLGB0Yz]

That cow looks delicious tbh

[@Elessar_Telcontar]

@@spaceshido6124 I am sure that pen and teller had a shot that showed the container the whole time.

[@DL-kc8fc]

In two cases the glasses were already full, ergo was not poured from the box. Penn registered it according to "code" speech. This is a low glass number. 3, in which there was cola, and a low glass of number 6. in which there was something that was supposed to resemble milk. However, there are still 4 glasses into which the drink was actually poured from the box. This results in a possible trick design, that even in the glass 6, which simulated milk, even very thin polymer bags separating 4 drinks from each other fell out of the box into this glass number 6. This 6 glasses didn't really pour out of the box, but something fell into it and it looked like a splash of milk. This fulfilled the condition, albeit on the edge, which is notorious that the box was not a trick. If the magician performed this trick, as I claim, he owns a trophy, because mastering this technically is really admirable. Bravo!

[@Darmachakra]

@@bobbyd9319 But this is only the cap of the milk. The treick was described very accuare by valen tino. If you watch closely, the magician holds and presses the milk carton in a different spot for every drink. And there clearly is something transparent coming out when he pours the last glass of milk

[@mouwersor]

A potential way to do this without doing anything to the container itself: bags of the liquids in the container (maybe balloons to force the liquid out), which you can puncture with a needle attached to your finger. Potentially stacked on top of each other and that's why he moves his hand down during the act. The remainders of the balloons are poured out with the milk.

[@mdchaney]

The moving hand was the big clue for me.

[@seedsoflove7684]

The milk carton was dry when he tore it open.

[@mouwersor]

@@seedsoflove7684 hydrophobic coating

[@danadurnfordkevinblanchdebunk]

I like your idea, but the remainders of balloons would be visible as a lumpy pour and have some residual debris seen in the clearer drink glasses even if the balloons were transparent.

[@mouwersor]

@@danadurnfordkevinblanchdebunk Notice how he carefully pours the first drinks, maybe so the balloons don't pour out too (or perhaps the balloons are all tied to each other so they only can come out when the weight has emptied out of every single one), and he very quickly pours the milk keeping the carton completely upside down so any balloons that were in there flush out with the milk.

[@blazejecar]

the carton looked dry though, the liquid was coming from somewhere else. Kinda weird p&t didn't catch that

[@grief6052]

That’s what they thought, they thought that by ripping it all the compartments that held the liquids would fold inside the carton

[@24magiccarrot]

I think he dumps something in the milk at the end when he pours the final drink. It certainly seems strange that he needed to finish with the same drink he started with, and conveniently milk isn't see-through.

[@BenjaminWeeb]

Could be the rules of the show. They get one guess.

[@VancouverMagic]

As the carton wasn't gimmicked, I'm assuming the gimmick was secretly removed.

[@SocuteRaptor]

@@24magiccarrot That'll be nylon bags.

[@arunramachandran5012]

This was an absolutely wonderful act! I've seen this trick before on P&T but your final act of ripping apart the carton was the show stealer. Absolutely magnificent. And please don't listen to the naysayers and negative nancys. If i were to guess, i would say that you had the liquids in gel membrane balls. You pressed down the carton at various heights to puncture the various balls to release their liquid. We can clearly see that you're tightly gripping the carton on every pour and each subsequent pour you grip it more and more towards the bottom of the container. That's why you were also able to tear apart the container and also say with honesty to P&T that the carton was not gimmicked. Because it wasn't. It was liquid filled gel membrane balls in the carton.

[@jamesreed5678]

Rubber bladders, think drink-filled balloons. P&T should have asked if they could have to drink that last glass of milk, because the punctured bladders were in it.

[@Acujeremy]

The how do the pop?

[@matthewedwards4238]

@@Acujeremy the pop wasn’t poured out of the milk carton. They dubbed in the sound of it getting poured but you don’t actually see the pop leaving the container.

[@LasseLundster]

lmao nah didn't you notice how he didn't say no when asked if he was Jesus?! Penn had a 50/50 and chose wrong

[@ehrichweiss]

Lionel, this is awesome. BTW, this is your friend Eric from Lexington, Kentucky... :) It's awesome to see you on Penn & Teller and that you fooled them.

[@InqWiper]

Here is a suggestion: The carton contains balloons with liquid. He squeezes the carton where and when he wants a specific balloon to burst. The balloons are poured into the glass of coke and into the last glass of milk. He never tips the container completely when pouring the clear liquids. Specifically watch how he pours the glass of coke with his hand concealing the area between he carton and the glass. But also the last pouring of the milk is suspicious as he puts the entire carton into the glass so far that the carton makes direct contact with the milk so a balloon can go undetected from the carton to the milk. As he says the, the milk carton is not "gimmicked".

[@Rsharlan3]

This gets my vote. The carton was dry inside, so something else was holding the liquids that was removed before he tore it open.

[@DartsGondel]

@@Rsharlan3 exactly, the carton was dry! I noticed that right away

[@bonnome2]

@@Rsharlan3 or it just has a hydrophobic coating like a normal drink carton

[@InqWiper]

@@JAYJAYBEBE I think he might have poured the balloons into the glass of milk and the glass of coke. Watch what he does differently with his hands and with the container compared to when he pours the clear liquids. I think the balloons remained in the glasses until the end of the act, if that is what you are asking.

[@hbirtt]

I agree that the gimmick came out in the milk. I don't see a need for it to come out in the other dark drinks, and that would come with a risk of them showing in the bottom of the glasses. I also don't believe it's as simple as balloons. Whatever it is would need to reliably poor out for the cleanup. If I were trying to build it, I would attach the inner containers to some sort of weighted object, and would splash if the carton's opening wasn't submerged in the milk :). Ideally the inner containers would be a material that wouldn't fracture in to pieces and would collapse as tightly as possible to the weight. If possible, they would reel in completely to reduce the chance of failure, but that starts to get complicated to build in a small package. To the people talking about the container being dry, it's hydrophobic. Probably wax lined. There is also leakage when he turns it upside-down to start tearing it up.

[@kenmartin7613]

For me it’s priceless when Mr T is fooled. He is such the master of his facial expressions.

[@edwells4769]

Well, it was gimmicked but not the container itself but what was put in the container.

[@GEONEgaming]

I don't know how the milk and wine were done, but the cola was instant powdered cola in the bottom of the glass, he just poured the carbonated lemon-lime soda from the carton into the glass with cola-flavoured powder. The flavour of the cola powder is stronger than the mild lemon-lime flavour so they taste that more. That's why he covers the glass when pouring so that you can't see the clear lemon-lime soda being poured into the glass. It's also why the tray holding the glasses has such a high lip, so you can't see the powder in the bottom of the glasses. It's also why he stops pouring the lemon-lime soda, whereas with every other drink, he pours out all of the liquid contents, but for the lemon-lime he stops pouring because there's still more in there.

[@judithfaram1185]

Fantastisch Lionel herzliche Gratulation! Ich bin Heinz's Schwester in Arizona und werde Dein Erfolg hier in den USA etwas weiterverbreiten! Mach weiter so und wer weiss eines Tages hast Du vielleicht ein Gig in Las Vegas. Alles Gute, Judith Faram-Schwab

[@theunkownboss8052]

idk what this means but yeah man yeah

[@XcSNIPERcX]

the way the guy who did this before lionel on America's got talent had powder in the glasses (all exept the water) and poured the water from in the carton to the powder in the cups and thats why his hand covered the bottom of the cups, thats atleast how it was originally done, i dont know if he changed any of it up or anything

[@haztodialo]

The cows are going to be happy to hear the trick worked! 😁

[@jahjoeka]

🐄 mooo

[@davidcapewell6011]

Container was dry when he opened it....he also squeezes at different points for the liquid. 2+2= i think inside the container were liquid bags.

[@thelastfinale805]

He probably poured all the bags into his own milk in the end of the trick. This makes the most sense, but even if he's bursting the bags there should still be some moisture and liquid being mixed up on the way out.

[@LDehaut]

@@thelastfinale805 not if it's waxed before. He said it's not gimmicked. Unless he made a deal with the devil

[@eskurian8565]

I thought the same thing as David Capewell: bags. I think I saw him palm them (take them out and hide them) at the end of pouring some of the drinks though, taking them out already inbetween instead of the end. Some of the other drinks may be pre-poured like previous commenters mentioned. As an aside, I suppose you can also do things like carbonated water with a prepared glass and just water, but in this trick you see the liquid come out like the end product already. Only thing that still stumps me is that the bag solution would fall under rigged carton imo...

[@stevebalmer8888]

You don't really need special any liquid bags for it either , I believe. A basic plastic wrap will hold it just fine inside a container. All you need for this trick is a container with a large hole on the top and a plastic wrap. That's it.

[@beedge1807]

does stuffing plastic bags into a the carton not count as the the carton being "gimicked"? I think it does, so he wasn't being honest.

[@michaelminnick-chavez]

The first guy was like "why tf did I get milk and not soda?"

[@robinadams]

Then he got wine and is like "'It's all good"

[@hanskurmann3633]

Grandios Lionel. Das möchte ich mal live sehen. Alles Gute und viel Spass weiterhin.

[@trueatfalse]

3:38 check the position of his thumb. something is fake with this show. the thumb is at a different spot during the close-up than before and after.

[@MrXtian83]

I noticed that too as I was trying to watch the spots he was squeezing. So clearly our view was edited by unsure as to why?

[@keithnaylor1981]

In a real world 3:37 to 3:47 would be a continuous action but clearly this scene had been filmed twice and edited to look like a single take. At the start his hand is near the bottom then it appears half way along. This is really worrying and needs to be explained. Could the whole video be a scam?

[@MrWollollo123]

someone litterally did this same trick on got talent. so how did he invent it

[@zaknafein254]

@@keithnaylor1981 What's the point of it being a scam? Easy views? Penn and Teller are professional magicians who have been in the field for awhile, I fail to see why they would make their show a sham for this single trick when all of the previous tricks were legitimate and with discoverable solutions.

[@liukang85]

@@zaknafein254 well were they, really? Hard to check on that

[@franka.ciccanti507]

I thought for sure Penn and Teller would have guessed. I saw this exact performance from a child on Britain's got talent. the difference was the kid asked the judges at random what they wanted from the carton he wasn't pouring it himself. Which to me seemed more impressive.

[@gediminasusevicius2668]

Both of these have the same effect, but different method. By ripping the container, he makes the trick that much different to the magician viewer. And letting people choose the drink is an illusion that would not impress magicians the slightest

[@seedsoflove7684]

I remember that and it was revealed in a YT vid how it was done. Pretty cool, but didnt fool us!

[@Bull_sheet_Bob]

He's got pipes connected through his vascular system into the tips of his fingers, and the different drinks are pumped through his body and discharged from the tips of his fingers into the glasses. The camera angle makes it look like its coming out of the carton. That is the only solution.

[@Bull_sheet_Bob]

@@pawandeepjadon331 no way. Really.?

[@mpfmax0]

@@pawandeepjadon331 u can see the liquid comes out already colored from the milkbox, so that can't be it

[@oh0stv]

@@mpfmax0 Not for the coke, the coke pour looked suspiciously magician like.

[@djangomaxfield]

he probably had a few up his sleve and two real ones in the carton

[@Bull_sheet_Bob]

@@djangomaxfield the pipes run thru his whole body, including his urine and digestive system. So technically you are correct. They were running thru his sleeve, albeit under his skin.

[@brianmullen5305]

Very good 👍 positioning excellent and use of background and phase transition very polished

[@krotenschemel8558]

The problem was defintively the camera shifting. If I take the trick as face value, it's one of the best I've ever seen. No sleeves, no gimmicks in the container, looked very clean all the way through. However, the camera is shifting so often that it invalidates any such assumption. Which is too bad. Only two things I noticed, that the last glass was gimmicked, it filled up too quick, so it was used to get rid of some evidence and the other is that the container's inside appeared pretty dry for a container that supposedly just contained liquids. The order of the drinks is also well chosen as any one can easily hide traces of the previous drink.

[@sergiu89]

He had some commestible balloons with liquids inside. You don't need to put pressure on the container when you pour drinks. He has put pressure in different parts of the container when pouring different drinks. In the end, he disposed the inside baloons and drank them off.

[@dl_hs4315]

@@sergiu89 probably a diversion looks somewhat similar to a trick done in got talent where he pours normal water into the glass but notice he hides the bottom of the glass where probably a powder for the drink is there making the water look like and taste like the drink. Also notice how the “Cola” doesn’t have bubbles. The other people there are probably in on the trick also

[@redwarrior864]

@@dl_hs4315 This isn't the solution. The liquid comes out of the carton as the end product.

[@meyakabrown795]

Not more impressive then Shin Lim.

[@DrakeOola]

@@dl_hs4315 The powder idea is instantly ruled out because you can see the colored drinks pouring out of the container before even reaching the cup. The stooge idea is ruled out because p&t have staff members that are told how the trick is done before they can even perform and those staff members make sure to not allow planted audience members or stooges. Assistants are allowed but they must clearly be announced as such so no, the people were not in on it. When they say their drinks were fizzy and tasted like they were claimed to be, means it was. There is no way to add artificial fizz to a liquid without using something like a vitamin c tablet that bubbles like crazy before making the drink fizzy so no gimmicked powders or tablets can be used either. Both your guesses are wrong and when he tears the container open it was clear there was never any liquid in it, not directly anyway because there wasn't even a single drop to be found, not even the little bits at the bottom since you can never fully pour a liquid out of a glass/container. The container directly may not have been gimmicked but there was most likely little bags or balloons hidden inside. Too many camera cuts to tell tho and several previous contestants have come on youtube saying the camera 'did them justice' in the sense that they cut out the actual magic parts crucial to determining how the trick was done. One of them used an assistant that wrote things off staged and slipped them a note hidden in a table for example but they completely cut the moment the table was brought in out of the act so that trick was literally impossible to guess from the youtube video alone, I suspect this one is similar which sucks because that kind've goes against what the show stands for and ruins most of the fun, simple tricks that rely on post-editing or forced camera angles just aren't fun...

[@Chinookman]

So good I’m going to resist the urge to figure this one out. Lionel, your magic will remain so for this scientist…. I will not read any comments just in case. This is my highest compliment.

[@LionelDellberg]

Thank you, David!

[@padraig853]

the sound effects when pouring the cola were highly suspicious

[@DaHaiZhu]

3:37 there are some oblivious camera trickery going on there. See that he is holding the bottom of the carton here with his thumb clearly on the green band. Then it cuts to him pouring the wine and his hand in in the middle of the carton. The cut back to full view and his hand is back on the green band. I don't think camera tricks/edits should be allowed.

[@francisvandenheede7710]

The box itself is not gimmicked. The ripping is not only to prove this but also to allow Lionel to remove the “whatever” is in the box. Anyway, this trick is done with so much confidence and “panache” that one can call it real magic. 👏👏👏👏👏

[@apiranha1]

Are you sure about that? Because that seems like a pretty immoral lie based on semantics on the magicians part

[@rozaligreen527]

They literally asked him that outright and he said it wasnt

[@Nonononono213]

The box was not gimmick 🙂 didn’t you hear what he said ?

[@francisvandenheede7710]

@@rozaligreen527 The box itself is not gimmicked in the way P&T designed it. So, no design on the box itself, but an item attached inside the box, taken away by ripping and the box can be completely examined. Playing with the rules of the show is part of the game, even wordplay and apparently, P&T were wrong in their design, so Lionel couldn’t answer there were right.

[@Frank01985]

@@apiranha1 The box wasn't gimmicked, as shown, but the contents were (separate bladders, someone else here suggested they were poured out with the last glass of milk). No lying involved.

[@honeyforce996]

That was a great act. Thanks for sharing it. Sorry you wound up getting shafted by lockdown - it would've been great to see on stage. Good luck with your career

[@LionelDellberg]

Thank you, Stephen. Very happy to hear that. It not only makes me happy that you like the act/effect it also motivates.

[@winstonknowitall4181]

And I was so proud of myself for figuring out your simple trick with a gimmicked container. And then you shredded my good mood to pieces. I hate you! ;-)

[@LionelDellberg]

And I love your comment! Thank you very much for sharing your words.

[@winstonknowitall4181]

@@LionelDellberg Thank *you* for sharing your magic. :-)

[@FyrenMagus]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/nmjQq3iGaNaBm5Y sadly, he most likely lied about the container according to several of these

[@winstonknowitall4181]

@@FyrenMagus Sadly, you know nothing about rules of this show.

[@sumphatguy]

@@FyrenMagus Did you watch the video you linked? Even if he did lie and that's how the trick was performed, there's a whole lot more to the trick than just a "gimmicked bottle." He would have fooled them regardless.

[@kenmartin7613]

There are different bladders in the bottle. He moves hand up and down the carton to release different drinks...... then he rips the carton open exposing me as to the fact that I have no idea how he did this. Well done sir.

[@WStercn]

The bottle aka container he said was noy gimmick! So how ?

[@Armlace]

You were correct. The bladders were just special and already gone when he destroyed the gimmick.

[@htp1146]

> There are different bladders in the bottle. Nope :D

[@Ranjan596]

There were too many video cuts, many frames were missing. And one time you were holding the milk box one way and the very next second you were holding the milk box the other way. And only while pouring the orange juice you squeezed the box and not while pouring the other drinks. Also while pouring the cola you hid the glass and mixed something. And at the very end you hide the glass with your hand while pouring the milk and I'm pretty sure something is hidden in the milk because that is the only time you tilted the milk box completely upside down to pour something from the box that we are not meant to see. There's definitely something that had been poured along with the milk and that's the reason you hide the glass completely with your hand while holding it and so it was possible for you to pour the milk that fast without spilling even a drop. Very bad magic even if you fooled Penn and Teller. Not at all cool man! 😏😪😔💔

[@Ranjan596]

​@@htp1146 He poured the bladders into the milk at the very last and hid them. He also hid the glass with his hand while pouring the milk and that's the only time he poured something from the box totally upside down to pour the bladders into the milk and hide them. And also no one drank the last liquid that is the milk. Hehehe!😂😂

[@amazingpopup]

The trick is not played in one shot but several shots. There 's a lot of things can be done between shots.

[@keth8947]

This. P&T got screwed over on this one.

[@user-zi8lg5qu1h]

He was like "And that is exactly what I wanted you to think"

[@harvey0076]

Lionel looks like Christian Bale when he smiles.

[@RequiemDream]

I watch Penn and Teller for many years now, I also watch Fool Us since Season 1 Episode 1. I'm from Switzerland so when I did read in our news that a Swiss person for the first time fooled Penn and Teller and was on the show I was very veeery excited about it. But... I have to say, I didn't like the trick and the performance at all, nor do Penn and Teller, they hate this sort of trick, they even said it before on the show when someone did a pick a drink trick that they hate it, but his performance and everything was fantastic, this one here, I didn't enjoy... And I'm not talking about methods here, thinking about it, there are many ways to achieve what he showed yes, but I for myself, I just don't feel it, like Penn and Teller. Normally they always make some compliments how awesome it was and and and, nothing here... And they spoke so open about it just because they did not care and where thinking this is anyways not gonna be on the final show (which happens, I know the insides from some people)... But he fooled them, which I think was his only achievement and is possible with something like this... Like the woman who got 3 trophies but really 95% of all didn't like it... I'm a little bit sad... Anyways, greetings from Switzerland and congrats for the trophy

[@Acujeremy]

So this made the Swiss news? I loved this trick. I thought it was great! I just didn't like how he held the cola glass.

[@alexhetherington8028]

Fantastic trick, fooled the heck out of me and I loved it. Congratulations on winning the trophy. Say hi to the cows for me.

[@LionelDellberg]

Thank you very much! It makes me happy to ready your lines and it motivates. I did say hi to the cows and they moo back ;-)

[@turtlepythongraphics1899]

heyo just to let you people know (whoever thinks that the carton is dry), there is a waterproof (or any liquid proof) coating lining the inner walls of the carton so that's why it doesn't drip and appears to come out dry

[@nyChannel09]

Jo. Tetrapak nännt sech das. Inne eschs wasserabwisend

[@turtlepythongraphics1899]

@@nyChannel09 ​ Oh! Merci fir d'Klärung.

[@nyChannel09]

@@turtlepythongraphics1899 Get mega vel lüt wo meined, dasses gfaked esch wäge dem. Chönnt jo scho si dass d Innewänd nie nass gsi send, willer d flüssigkeit i chline säck dinne gha hed. Aber de undersched wörd mer ned chönne gseh, wills unabhängig devo öbs flüssigkeit dinne hed oder ned, zu 99 prozent glich usgseht.

[@dr.floridamanphd]

I was thinking exactly what Penn was thinking. It had to be a gimmicked container. When you ripped it open and showed that it was bone dry on the inside… 🤯 Amazing trick!

[@DrakeOola]

Container wasn't gimmicked but the liquids were never directly inside of it. If you put balloons or bags inside of a container, the container is still ordinary and not considered gimmicked.

[@Yarblocosifilitico]

@@DrakeOola aaaah... nice! As he rips it off (upside down), the balloons fall to the mouth and remain hidden. So simple, so elegant. If that's how it works, it shouldn't be too difficult to replicate. Perfect for a non-skill trick to amaze family or friends with! edit: wait, not so easy. Upon rewatch, the carton is open and nothing but a few drops (seems like milk) fall. Nothing on the floor on a later cam angle. How did he made the 'true containers' dissapear? The balloons or whatever explain why different liquids require grabbing the carton at different heights, but what happens when they're deflated? A filter could solve it, but that would count as a gimmick, right? Still, I can do it at home, I hope. Oh, wait further still! It isn't milk but something that dissolves the balloons or whatever the containers are. Maybe safe to drink or maybe he takes the hit haha, idk. Hmm... Also, how do you ensure only one liquid pours if there's no gimmick? It could be that the people on stage are accomplishes, and he's just releasing colorants into the same liquid (by pressing at different points of the carton). But I dont' think that's it. In fact, I don't think I'll be able to replicate it after all hahaha, I'll have to make the easy version of it, which might be to just buy on of those cool ancient poison jars :P

[@kushtrimzogaj2827]

Notice how he was holding the bottle in different ways each time the drink changed

[@chrispartosbro4555]

Id say to pop clear balloons of drink inside, clear so that when they pop they come out into the milk, cola and orange and you don't see them in the drink, the original cap was modified and went inside the carton to hold a shot of milk, when that was removed the next drink could come out clear and so on.

[@SplendidFellow]

But the container isn't gimmicked. So... wizardry?

[@samcrowe4084]

The cola was already in the class and the color of the tray hid that, you can see him cover the class with his hand and you never see the Cola pour

[@leabutzer3927]

You did it! This trick is amazing.

[@fala-nova6557]

Why is the milk carton completely dry on the inside? Amazing trick 😀

[@matthewmarquis8732]

That's what I thought!

[@bigplanett]

There was most likely a switch off camera. I'd be more impressed if he'd been there in person.

[@saifmohammed2977]

My thoughts

[@EA_47_]

Because the drinks were not stored in it

[@James-tk9oy]

@@bigplanett some one at fool us knows how the trick worked and you cant use your camera.

[@TonyGanzerMedia]

Glückwunsch!! Ich war einmal als Journalist in Züri tätig. Es hat mich gefreut, ein Schweizer als Fooler genannt zu werden!

[@norespect]

That cola pour was so natural.

[@Acujeremy]

Yeah that was the weirdest pour but it still doesn't tell us anything.

[@danadurnfordkevinblanchdebunk]

Lionel pronounced his name in the intro. Funny how both the host and Penn pronounced his first name wrong, even though Teller had it written down phonetically correct on his note pad.

[@LionelDellberg]

Well, yes, good observation. It was actually quite funny. The "problem" was that I tried to pronounce my name the American / English way and P&T and also Alyson went for the Swiss pronunciation.

[@jean-philipped.371]

I think that little transparent bags stored liquids and at the end, there throw away in the last glass (the milk comes from else where)

[@handsomerockus]

Container had milk Cola was already in the glass For Lemon soda, Wine, & OJ, he used various hidden hoses which were blocked by the camera angles.

[@elaceaceak2357]

I remember mat franco did something similar and it wasn't the box that were gimmick there was already something in the glass. And when it will bi mixed with water it will give different colours

[@matthewklein660]

If that was true then how does the orange juice come out of the carton orange? It's not the glasses that are gimmicked.

[@headgamemaker8385]

A pipe runs from his arm into a small hole near the top of the container. By moving his arm in a way, the pipe always stays out of view except around the 2:50 mark where a small glimpse of it is visible near his elbow. On contrary, he may be wearing built-up prosthetics on his arm to make it look like his veins are popping out slightly. I have no clue how it was done but this was my guess.

[@PedroNevesPlus]

Im swiss and just here to say this is a common swiss packaging product. Maybe a trick around a liquid film like we see nowadays for water, pressing enough to break which ‘bubble’ he wanted?!

[@daniele83d]

Well, he said that the container wasn't gimmicked at all, so it has to be the liquid 😅. I think you're right 👍

[@daniele83d]

@Videogames, Music & Movies it always could be a camera trick in this situation... But it would be to easy, or not?

[@MrXBT2000]

@@daniele83d Fool Us does not allow camera tricks, pre-show work or planted audience members - the producer knows how the trick is performed.

[@morbidmanmusic]

Excellent performance, and "beer guy" was funny.

[@LionelDellberg]

Thank you! Makes me happy and motivates!

[@Cloakfiend]

Just looking how he squeezes different areas on the carton means its got bags inside. The last glass was ridicoulous. Try and fill a glass full of milk in under half a second without it going everywhere...lol. a few of those drinks already had stuff in them.

[@BrianSu]

That is definitely part of the trick but there are other elements too.

[@donwilliams495]

Superb Slight. Bravo!

[@gediminasusevicius2668]

I still can’t believe the container is not gimmicked. Well done

[@djr4yman]

Liquid came from somewhere else as some poeple have been commenting here

[@Riscs]

The trick is pretty populare in my area the milk container isnt gimmicked at all, the gimmick is the audienz and the glasses Just watch how he hold some glases with his left hand to hide something in it. And also some ppl or maybe all of them dont drink there liquid (watch the 4th guy) he clearly didnt drank that If u dont not trust me simple google it guys^^

[@milkmanconspiracy4346]

@@Riscs those kinds of tricks are against the rules of the show and all tricks are revealed to the producers who sort of act as referees.

[@double8tz]

The secret is from the the glasses used, the glasses had different flavors when they reacted with water coming from the container it generate those flavors

[@revendisio]

@@double8tz Including the bubbles from the soda? Eh...no.

[@frankrosario4409]

It's very clear that it was a gimmicked container. Just look at where it was squeezed on each pouring of a different liquid and to what extent it was squeezed.

[@jhsdfjhgjh]

The bearded guy has so much personality that he almost takes the focus off the performer... 😺

[@martineldritch]

Any hedge wizard can fool Penn and Teller and audience with actual magic but I admire when magician can fool without diverging from standard model of physics as defined by CERN scientists in Switzerland :-)

[@mchammer1313]

I think this is fake with camera tricks. And moreover, observe the position of his thumb between cut scenes. there is no continuity.

[@keithnaylor1981]

Why can I buy one of these magic cartons? Imagine having one of these in your kitchen! PROPER magic without a doubt!

[@LionelDellberg]

😀🙏😀

[@james9031]

Small pouches inside the container .with very thin layer separates each layer . pressed every layer when pouring into different glass .he moves his fingers from top to bottom.look at in the last he withdraw something in his right hand when he destroying milk pouch from the bottom .he holded it .and throw in the air in the last.and important thing that container was not wet from inside .also look at the portions .all were different .from starting .milk was very less in the start .that why he put on the table for next move .and lower the finger

[@sharad3454]

He said, the container was not a gimmick. What you said is the same thing Penn teller guessed. He fooled everyone.

[@james9031]

Yes the container was not a gimmick .but a solid thin layer of products.

[@Acujeremy]

That doesn't explain how he can pour coke now, sprite now, OJ now.

[@oMeGa0122]

If you wonder how the trick is done. Here is how. 😁 The milk was in a small cylinder compartment hence he only poured little amount with 67⁰ angle. Then he screwed the cap as you can hear it in the background. After that he removed the cylinder and hid it in the black tray. Now the bottle is filled with water and it has two edible water bubbles inside, one on the top is filled with orange juice and the other on the bottom filled with swiss wine. For lemon juice. He had the glass already filled with lemon powder. You can see it in some frames. You can see the cristal clear water pouring out but later it's a not clear. Same goes for the cola. It's a powder in the glass. See how he is covering the entire glass so you cannot see the pure water pouring out. At this stage there is no more warer For the orange juice. He squeezes the top water bubble and pour out the juice. For the wine, he squeezes the bottom water bubble and pour it out. There was no orange juice left because the walls of the container is hydrophobic. Then for the last glass of milk that he gave to no one. He took a glass containing milk powder then poured whatever left from the swiss wine and the edible water bubblea into it hence the shacking so the jelly bubbles comes out so he can later open the container without any trace if anything. You are welcome

[@lj1653]

what a fantastic presentation! you would make an excellent bartender being able to dispense any drink like that :)

[@LionelDellberg]

🍹🍷🍻😅 Thank you very much! 🙏☺️🙏

[@megalotusman]

There is some strange editing in this video. At 3:37 you can distinctly see he is holding the carton on the green lines, yet when it cuts to the close up he is clearly grabbing it close to the middle. Am I mistaken? There are also sound effects of pouring when you can't see the liquid being poured and no sound effects when you can. I really have no idea how he's doing it, my best guess is when you can't see him pouring and hear the sound effect he's actually filling it up with the hand that's holding the glass. But this confusing editing makes me think there is simply nothing in the video that might reveal how it's done because it's been edited out. Either that or, when he pours the milk out for himself at the end, he's hiding that he pours out the "gimmick" itself. You can't see it because the milk is opaque or the glass is a trick glass. He never appears to take a drink of it even though he acts like he's going to.

[@FahadArez]

A couple of things- This is adopted closely from the colour coded magics. He uses colors to disguise. See his T-shirt, black colour / lower portion to disguise for cola. Green to disguise the lemon soda and white wine. He is even holding the bottle in a manner to make us focus on the bottle while he uses his sleight of hand effectively. The milk when he pours first time is possibly from his left hand (the cap of the bottle) The milk that was poured last is also not from the bottle. Notice he covers the lower portion of the glass. To summarise- the bottle only had one colour liquid and some glasses could have colour agents. Probably the bottle had only transparent liquid. Cheers to the volunteers acting the shit out.. Claps!!!!

[@tasa4904]

Now that you mention it, I thought that the Cola looked flat. It would normally be fizzier if poured like that.

[@benf6822]

They said at the start the volunteers were innocent, it would break contract if they were in on it or pretended it was something it wasn't.

[@Cloakfiend]

The orange juice came out orange not water mixing into orange powder.

[@EJuliusF]

The volunteers are always legit. That's the rule of fool us. Try again, kid

[@crck1227]

i agree with the cola part, 👍👍👍

[@panda4247]

I don't like this trick in the context of Fool Us. Usually with a good trick, I have no idea how it was done. With this, I had multiple ideas (gimmick box; box with water and the flavor powders in the glasses), so it did not impress me. I believe P&T also had at least these two explanations, but by the rules they can only guess one. The pouring of the cola was obscured by your hand, so that is a clue for me that there was something in the glass already. Also, the constant changes of camera angles did not help

[@le3b]

I can't believe the carton wasn't teh trick, for sure there were small capsules with liquid inside, that's why the first time he poored the milk, it was too little, and quickly stopped filling the cup

[@kratkidokumentarci224]

And constantly geting his hand lower on the container, and at the end he fills cup fast and i saw there was white vine first before milk.

[@zoeherriot]

@@kratkidokumentarci224 have you considered that there are two audiences. One is us, and one is P&T. The point of the hand going lower may have been to mislead them into thinking the container is gimmicked.

[@beatsteiner8592]

Du bist und bleibst der Beste….. Einfach nur DANKE!

[@ajthesavage214]

2:43 The cola glass is pre-filled (he also wears a half black shirt to hide the cola) 4:02 glass of milk is also pre-filled The video is edited in some-way or another. At 3:38 when he starts filling the wine, he is holding the milk carton at the bottom, cut to the close up and now he is holding it around the middle, and next scene again at the bottom! The act was performed in a way which didn't peak my interest and I am not even interested in knowing how it was done.

[@jamesreed5678]

It looks like you're right about the prefill. I assumed he obscured the cola glass to hide that he was pouring water into a drink powder at the bottom of the glass. But, we don't ever see the cola glass less than full. Yes, she felt the bubbles and it was real cola, lol. The camera editing on Fool Us is very annoying. I think the close-up of the wine fill was not from that performance. His finger position on the stem of the glass also was different in the closeup.

[@davewhiting9730]

He said that the container was not gimmicked, however when he opened it, it was dry. And the sides appear to be made from something that would help keep it dry. So wouldn't that in itself make the container gimmicked?

[@Armlace]

Thats just the regular coating of drink containers. The carton itself was not "gimmicked" but it contained a gimmick, so it actually was a gimmick and he got busted. Just a really weird showing from the production team tbh.

[@steroidbarney8273]

Did it bother anyone else when the production added in the extra oh's & agh's? Not to mention the extra laughter..

[@DavidM1337]

The shows production is very cringey in many aspect. The moderator being the most obvious part.

[@FunBoysGaming]

@@DavidM1337 Jonathan Ross was such a good moderator. Shame he got replaced with Allison..

[@ChronoZero]

@@FunBoysGaming Well, i guess he didnt want to stay in vegas. Remember that the first season was in england

[@420SupaK]

Easy to figure out. I would say there is capsules or bags of the drinks inside the milk carton. And they get punctured when the bottle is squeezed in different spots. Awesome idea. Pretty sweet trick to teach yourself. Being born in cottage on a mountain side probably doesn't offer a lot of props to work with.

[@marioyacoub]

7:05 When Penn says ‘You’re a magician, you’re a liar’ he said it as a matter of fact, so why should we believe the guy when he says the container was not gimmicked?

[@JT-ii9qn]

The producers know how the trick is done and wouldn't award him a Fool Us trophy if he lied.

[@marioyacoub]

@@JT-ii9qn it is a very well crafted trick but I suspect he argued semantics with the judges when he claims the carton isn’t rigged if something else is placed inside of it

[@CallMeMrChainmail]

@@marioyacoub This! It's the most annoying thing about the show these days. This is the second trick I've seen where the fool is that the gimmick isn't technically part of the prop.

[@SethiozProject]

awesome trick, I was gonna go with fake container too, but if you say it's not, then my guess would be that you had a hidden straw / hose running along your hand. Hidden by either sleight of hand or synthetic skin. I'd go with synthetic skin, like full hand glove, that looks exactly like skin. this way i can pour anything out of it and have containers hidden in my clothing.

[@lazynomad42]

When it comes to your Swiss magic trick, I find myself feeling neutral.

[@zantas-handle]

Oh very witty!

[@lucapuccianti7239]

Swiss*

[@thisiscait]

He's from Switzerland...

[@FunBoysGaming]

@@lucapuccianti7239 it may have been intentional

[@spicytrashpanda]

I have no strong feelings about this comment one way or another.

[@philbofettiArchive]

Are all the liquids in dissolvable sachets that pop when pressed into? That would be pretty clever.

[@Blondie42]

Tough people over there to be wearing shorts this time of year.

[@nakedsnake6076]

swiss arnt exactly known for toughness xd

[@LadyDragonsblood]

It could have been filmed during the summer, to be aired later. TV shows like this are usually filmed months in advance.

[@mavfan1]

You think the show is taped then shown a few days or weeks later? 🙄

[@draintheswamp1588]

That carton he tore up was dry. When he poured the first glass of milk, it looked like that was just about all the milk because the volume of liquid coming out slowed down at the end of pouring. Right at 2:00.

[@CallMeMrChainmail]

I’m sorry but the camera cuts and re-shoots really kill this trick. It doesn’t look like magic, it looks like camera tricks so it looks less impressive than if it were a single camera shot all the way through. The showrunners ruined this performance.

[@geraldschober1676]

camera tricks aren´t allowed on the show. there´s a jury behind the scenes who are told how the trick works and if penn & teller won´t come up with the method by themselves, it´s a fooler.

[@dan18118]

@@geraldschober1676 but there is some editing... anyway it should be one shot, it just doesn’t make you believe when they change angles. They shouldn’t even do these location shots anyway, i lose interest when there not there at the scene

[@xxray88jlxx]

How do you only have 1k subs I wish you the best man

[@LionelDellberg]

Thanks, buddy! Well, I’m not very active on KZbin, I should may change this.

[@ss_avsmt]

I always get nervous when Alison has to do the small talk while penn and teller figure out.

[@Quintessenceofdust7]

Fr its kinda awkward when she talks with them while waiting for P&T response

[@prodr0xxthefirst267]

I'm glad it's not just me. She does about as well as I would in that situation. Some of the guests do not help either as they are nervous themselves.

[@myalteregoartist]

This is a great act.

[@sahithinarva890]

I think there are two ways to do it. 1) idea which is similar to getting drowned in water for hours together (supply) 2) some of the drinks were not delivered from the container but an alternative source. (Slight of hand).

[@michaelgibbons7014]

Sorry bud the correct answer is that he is, in fact, Jesus Christ and he was simply transfiguring the liquids.

[@tailorslow7917]

@@michaelgibbons7014 😁 i'd stick with that too

[@sheilalewis5045]

Definitely thin latex bags that are each popped one by one before being poured, maybe a small pin of some type on the inside that just needs to be squeezed from the outside of the box. they are so stretched that they shrink down to nothing once popped , then he pours them out with the remaining liquid when he pours himself a glass, you can almost see them plop out at the top of the glass.

[@cfov]

At first I thought the carton was gimmicked as well, but then you ripped it apart. I thought about Penn's idea before he said it, but thought that would be tough to design so I have gone back to my next idea. I won't be specific about what I think because of the gravity of giving away the trick. Am I close?

[@vincentjohnflorio]

Hey, fun, I got your hint and I'm not even him! I have a family member who shares an interesting in what you speak of.

[@mubashir09i2]

Gravity won't work like this. And one or two turns itself make them mix. Black cola and that lime soda will definitely

[@Malfehzan]

Superbe routine, Lionel! Congratulations on the F...-U trophy !!

[@srujan2482]

First of all his thumb had different squeeze spots for every drink ..idk how the carton is not a gimmick

[@heartbreaker2690]

he's lying to Penn and teller

[@double8tz]

The secret is from the the glasses used, the glasses had different flavors when they reacted with water coming from the container it generate those flavors

[@srujan2482]

@@double8tz i don't think so ..becuase ,then the lime soda and cola should have been bubbling uk

[@Mobin92]

@@double8tz The orange juice was already orange though. Maybe just some where like that, e.g. the coke seemed most suspicious.

[@leviblum9514]

So geil! Es isch mega cool mau e Schwizer zgseh bi Penn & Teller, super Uftritt gsi! 👍🏻

[@LionelDellberg]

😊🙏😊

[@danielec]

Not completely sure you're Swiss... Where's Rivella?

[@Elusime]

Rivella isch Läbe 😍

[@TorQueMoD]

That was awesome Lionel. Well done :)

[@LionelDellberg]

😊🙏😊

[@remconet]

Okay you fooled them, but as a viewer this was kinda weird to watch, since the camera cut away so often it hardly feels like a magic trick anymore. I wish you could've done it live with them.

[@DustinPlatt]

The guy with the beard is like that one extra in a movie who is in the background trying really hard to get noticed so he gets a role somewhere else.

[@DOC_951]

People all saying the container had bags or something... when that’s what the official guess was, which was wrong.

[@yc1094]

Wrong. The guess was that the carton was gimmicked, not that it had bags, which is different. The bags came out so the container wasn’t gimmicked in the way p&t guessed as the carton was examinable after the trick. Obviously there was some sort of gimmick, p&t wouldn’t be allowed to guess so broadly, their guess was specific as was his answer.

[@MrXBT2000]

They guessed one specific way of gimmicking the carton, where the gimmick would be hidden within the walls before tearing it...

[@DOC_951]

@@MrXBT2000 well if you saw the reveal video, looks like he most likely used those gelatin spheres that break with some moderate force, which is likely the correct answer based on how the magician was squeezing certain areas

[@MrXBT2000]

@@DOC_951 I was merely pointing out that P&T made a very specific guess about how the carton could have been gimmicked. That means that their guess would be wrong if the carton was gimmicked in any other way, hence it being wrong does not exclude what may be preceived as a gimmicked carton, just one specific way of hiding a compartment division gimmick. I will however not discuss the method in any detail in the comment field of the magian's video.

[@DOC_951]

@@MrXBT2000 there’s already a channel who does Fool Us explanations, and he went into a lot of detail about this one

[@Nico12420]

I think the glasses are gimmick because it will be hard to keep those liquids separate from each other in a milk carton! I'm truly amazed by how you did it!!! Congratulations, I hope to see you attempt to fool them again!!!