Forged in Fire: The Scottish Dirk Tests (Season 5, Episode 10) | History

[@dirkrol3471]

"your blade did not made the cut... The judges will tell you why" Judges: "it didn't cut"

[@ILMENTULATORE]

LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOL

[@paquack]

Lul.

[@nawfpawz]

Doran: "ikr"

[@darien4969]

Well wtf you want them to say? Learn how to forge a real blade?

[@sjov7079]

@@darien4969 I think this is where i say, r/whoooosh

[@natebardwell]

Can we all just take a moment to appreciate how constructive and humble the people on this show are?

[@jorgeg5923]

But will it KEEL?

[@bigmike1547]

I keel you

[@henrythestik6792]

I was going to say the exact thing but searched the comments to see if someone already said it. XD

[@madnessstar9819]

Wtf is keel? Is it kill?,

[@jorgeg5923]

Its literally the most popular running meme of the show@@madnessstar9819, you uncultured swine

[@viniciusfalcao2069]

It would kill

[@timcs1970]

Feel bad for him. I understand that he messed it up, but he was such a good sport. Top marks lad.

[@logank.strong7398]

Jonathan is a good friend of mine. He and his wife are legitimately among the sweetest human beings I have EVER met, and I truly mean that from my heart. They're raising some fine kids, as well. He still makes AMAZING, beautifully crafted knives.

[@johansmallberries9874]

A reality show competition where they root for each other? Madness.

[@pierresandklef4121]

they are rooting for the craft :)

[@lait3967]

that apple test guy goes into a hot topic, sees the cashier "it's definitely a cutter"

[@dobson.]

That's the best thing I've read

[@reigncloudzz]

LAIT he looks like Santa Claus and i love it

[@b_f_d_d]

Lmaooo

[@420abxzxd3]

It will keel

[@johndeer8644]

Keel

[@samsham3148]

KEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

[@thvikingedits8872]

@@samsham3148 you forgot the L

[@samsham3148]

@@thvikingedits8872 keel

[@darthtrudeau4907]

Silence I keel you!!!

[@kayliel2180]

"That poor barrel" lmao

[@russwilliams9585]

So much user error

[@janbadinski7126]

@Anonymous Anonymous No they don't. The have a strict criteria dependent on the blade itself and the assigned task. I'm sorry you missed that.

[@afk4dyz]

That mustache dude did not use the full mass of the blade for the 2nd dude. Definitely some bias and or user error.

[@felix-nah]

The fruit ninja guy?

[@CSG0103]

You could definitely tell a difference in the way he wielded the 2nd and 3rd blades

[@Camino377]

@@afk4dyz No, look again. He's using the full blade but it catches on the first apple and rolls back.

[@jakewolf079]

What a great guy...I'd love to see him do this again

[@tylerrose3633]

2:20. This is why Forged In Fire is my favorite show.

[@OneTruePaladin]

Buy Doran’s blade first people it helps a lot

[@JCOwens-zq6fd]

I have handled a bunch of real antique dirks & some of them have what amounts to a short 3 finger grip. Historical 1 handed weapons tend toward smaller grips. Like 4 inches is the standard.

[@john117masterbaket3]

Ya think they should test sharpness then durability

[@john117masterbaket3]

@Mac Chambers Thank you that make a bit more sense.

[@sethgriffin6014]

@Mac Chambers is right, they do sharpness second to see how well it keeps an edge after the abuse

[@SAJ.GAMING]

but as an attack knife it should b tough enough to defend and stop the assault

[@foolslayer9416]

Or maybe a test before and after the durability.

[@potatomaster1908]

@Mac Chambers after a single cut of METAL BARREL

[@ibrohimhakimov6435]

"That poor barrel" "KILL THAT THING!"

[@robertfitts5194]

Way to many uncontrolled variables to be consistent everytime. This is not a true test to see whose blade is superior

[@pandaman2994]

robert fitts What would be a more accurate test?

[@robertfitts5194]

@@pandaman2994 eliminate any user interface. Make all blows/strikes/hits equal in power and force. It cant be equal if he hits things with- Knife A: 30lbs of pressure KnifeB: 15lbs of pressure Knife C: 65lbs of pressure None of the results will be the same or consistent

[@immortalswordsman62]

@@pandaman2994 ooooofffffffff burn

[@dn2ze]

Panda Man two death row inmates fighting to death. For reduce sentence lmao

[@bigmike1547]

@@dn2ze thatd be the sickest movie though, Netflix release

[@jazzcat1239]

The guy that was chopped was great. Loved him.

[@mrjzz2703]

That took on a dark turn 😂

[@jimbob8162]

Abio genesis I like his name, Doreen Doreen. LoL

[@JAMamation]

"I'm going to be taking each of your *dirks* and testing them, by *hammering* them *six* *times* *each* into this oil can".

[@phongers87]

You could say those judges really tested their mettle. 😏 I'll see myself out lol

[@logancloete3597]

I want Phil’s dirk so much. It is a beautiful piece

[@ns7027]

For a second i thought 2:50 was Sméagol!. Lol

[@themissouriphantom]

Let’s not forget about the steel, some steels hold better edges than others.

[@LordBathtub]

I'm such a child just chuckling every time they say 'Dirk' 'Overall, your Dirk held up pretty well'

[@furretch]

It's funny but shut up

[@daKoenig]

that's what she said

[@drunkgorilla]

The guy in the middle looks like Macho Man Randy Savage

[@zero3778]

The guy with the blade tested last was sweating bullets but I'd say this to him - Your blade took the most damage BUT it was still able to completely function as a weapon and cut. One of the other blades might've taken little damage but it wasn't functional as a weapon because it couldn't cut. You will move forward.

[@oliverhernander6047]

The question is... Will it *KEEEL*

[@jumperfrog5666]

I like how he said "POOR BARREL" Then "LETS KILL THIS THING"-DIE!!!!!!! LMAO RIGHT NOW AND SAYING WTF.

[@JustinTopp]

3:00 that’s the worst apple cut test I’ve seen yet lol

[@CXonthefly]

Dirk's Are Made For All Around use that includes shopping making stuff out of wood cutting so a wedge-shaped blade is not that big of an issue now for fighting knife it is but Dirks are typically fighting knife

[@ethankaminski2402]

Dorin seems like a cool dude

[@aloha_amen3049]

Head up, Doran i see a master in you yet!

[@diegoramirez8708]

I have always had my eye on the black tomahawk shaped weapon on the wall behind the table, I really want to see it in action

[@joshuaconcepcion7731]

These knives can be added to Fruit Ninja.

[@Sterling.]

His blade didn't fail the sharpness test, he clearly didn't swing correctly

[@bell7824]

Yep i agree

[@Tinker.Studio]

yeah barely caught the first Apple and then missed all the rest

[@Sterling.]

@@Tinker.Studio for real, they are usually accurate but for times like this there NEEDS to be a redo (they check the slow-mo footage before making a decision). I mean even if the blade wasn't as sharp, it started to cut, then he essentially pulled the knife out...

[@marca6597]

Did you listen to what he said? The blade was more of a riping hit. It broke the apple. Not cut and you can see he used a solid bar to guide the blade.

[@Sterling.]

@@marca6597 Did you see where he hit and how he dragged it through weakly? He barely clipped it and then put very minimal force behind the push, allowing the blade to barely even touch the apples. Even if his blade was flawed he didn't swing correctly enough to show it

[@Emil-qs3gy]

Please tell them to make a butterfly

[@ANKITSINGH-ln8gt]

At 2:57 he cut the apples slightly from inside ... He should properly move his hands outwards the apples

[@lighthouse44]

Doran is a class act

[@ВикторЗадябин-ы4ю]

Can somebody explain me why did they perform sharp test after hitting knifes into the barrels so they had lost their sharpness?

[@caganzorlu]

Виктор Задябин because they are kind of looking for a best blade which can maintain its sharpness even after took some serious damage

[@alybadry203]

It's to see which blade maintains sharpness which means it's still useful after being damaged slightly

[@alybadry203]

@Ebiegberi Adonkie exactly and he's asking why they test the sharpness after abusing the blades , it's to see which smith is the best at keeping his weapon in good shape after all the abuse it goes through

[@mynamesjeffhardly]

I love how the guy keeps saying "It will kill"... I'm sure all of them can kill lol A pencil can kill.

[@mivias6768]

2:43 thank you kind sir

[@erikaushamburg8279]

Wow what a cool format! Nice show!

[@kaushalraipancholia3765]

Judge: **Proceeds to damage the blade. Judge: Sorry your blade didn’t make it. Contestant: Why? Judge: It is damaged.

[@adnanrafiq5894]

Look at 2:21 thats so satisfying

[@cocleve99]

I thought it was funny cuz he goes, it’s a fighting knife. But dirks were primarily used on ships

[@houndofvalinor8188]

Now I need a dirk

[@eric_the_red5600]

I really wanted the guy to win. He seemed like a good dude

[@pershing5286]

2:20 Looks like were having apple pie tonight!

[@sasukekun6112]

Lol these people act like they worked their hole life for this knife hahahaha

[@deltreks]

you're up are you ready?

[@webbsitetheguy]

That is the best pun

[@harrisonpalmer-ball4938]

What pun, I missed the joke.

[@sethle5442]

The oil can sounds like it’s grunting

[@689k3]

he’s philling nervous

[@abdullaadel6430]

You can see the stress

[@conorolaf1762]

The wood should be from timber native to Scotland.

[@timbrwolf1121]

Leave it to the scotts to create a knife that also doubles as a way to open kegs

[@darenmcdrummond6819]

The guy sent home looks like a dwarf like in an anime

[@johnleonard3951]

seems he could have put the blade more forward on the 2nd cut test

[@christian_7624]

“Snapcat”

[@SayuOCE]

So this is where Doran's Blade comes from

[@cherry.w7418]

But will it KEEL

[@going_dark]

Doran's Blade

[@weenusman7548]

4:10 you get it blade did not make the cut * drums play *

[@EmptyShellCasing]

0:30 Poor barrel😢😢😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@ShOoTeR7386]

I work for a company that we have these in stock by the hundreds. Not the blade the so called barrel.. It's not a barrel it is a drum.. Black iron steel drum to be exact. Hope to see if it WILL CUT

[@0dd29]

KEEEEEL

[@mrshark8094]

Barrels!!!!

[@MoricsR.BrivMurnieks]

Well i feel that some of the judges knowledge on dirks are average at best. Dorans Dirk absolutely had a huge handle for a classical Scottish dirks. Maybe a little bit thin if he was talking about the smallness in that sens, but you could easily shave 2-3 cm off form the length of that Dorans dirk handle to make it more classical.

[@Dudewheresmyspider]

"your handle is relatively small for a Dirk" These guys know nothing about Dirk's. They have notoriously, historically small handles for their design

[@jerrickbak8604]

thats alot of damage

[@germaincasse]

Isn't that quite dangerous to give them a knife when you're telling them they're eliminated?

[@gluehuffer2869]

Dat poor Berral

[@ryryphel8517]

But it will keel

[@jajareyes7529]

Doran's blade is real lmao

[@pdfmusic_]

I’m Scottish and I like dirks

[@peacekeeper__7813]

I personally don't think they should operate those tests where they test how well the weapons survive. Imagine you are the smith who created the weapon and sees your hard work being broken because of the test. It is necessary but still not pleasant

[@Sl1ckG0ku]

If it breaks or it can’t cut then that’s on you. The purpose of the strength test is to see if the blade can survive Being damaged

[@dominikxyz2500]

they didnt said about the keel..

[@ClipsVi3w]

But will it keel?

[@Krisowoxo]

THAT POOR BARREL WHAT DID IT EVEN DO TO YOU HUH

[@markozacar]

Those apples should be loos and the swing should be done by some kind of machine, that way all blades should have equal chance performing. Old guy cant hit with same force, direction and angle everytime.

[@BunnyDzombie]

So this is what andy serkis does in his spare time

[@mr.adamdawn2947]

I've been watching few forge in fire videos and I realize the old guy always had problem when he swing. Is it me or he doing bad? like really bad.

[@lethalfumes]

He swung super weak with the second blade, and almost missed the apples with the third blade, but he put way more force into it

[@cv4809]

It's just you That guys clearly has experience in wielding blades while you don't

[@miniwhitecookies3bobthebui67]

Me and my dad whatcha you guys so cool

[@serizawatamao8159]

Poor barrel..😂😂😂

[@coldturkey-se1xr]

The real question is does it keel?

[@ianbuchan1793]

Nobody is going to hammer a knife into a barrel in real life

[@Hellhorde.]

So much error with the apple test he didnt have the blade as forward as the others, i think the smiths should be the ones doing it so that the only ones to blame are themselves.

[@Alex-pj9jc]

they should all do the sharpness test first and then the strength

[@Sl1ckG0ku]

Alex Janoher Nah

[@furretch]

Your dirk has a small handle

[@goodini026]

wouldn't it make sense to do the sharpness test first as opposed to the strength test? obviously they aren't going to perform as well after the strength test

[@markmoore4079]

The point is to see how well they can hold an edge, because if they can't hold the edge, it's not useful as a weapon.

[@goodini026]

Mark Moore thanks for the clarification

[@qingcai8192]

Wait so do they loose their weapon

[@kugelblitz9190]

Those poor barrels

[@ooff129]

Why do you do the durability test before the sharpness test

[@Sterling.]

To see how well the blade held up during the durability tests and how well it kept its edge

[@soulfulfool]

he should be called Durin 👍 fun guy sadly he lost

[@lucossy_5674]

Hello

[@mr.froggyman9366]

Hi

[@MehediHasan-ku3po]

2:20 fruit ninja wants to know your location

[@cardiGUNner]

I thought it was drink

[@Red-ek1gd]

Yet again another Smith was disqualified thanks to human error

[@MrMrjones333]

How about tou test the sharpness FIRST. THEN damage the blades

[@cainrf401]

It’s WONT keel