What a nice change! Most reactors I've seen have hated on Jenny pretty hard. It always astounds me. It's nice to hear some understanding of her. Good for you!!
@janeldavis9058 ай бұрын
Seriously! I don't understand how people don't get why Jenny is the way she is. I've only ever felt sorry for Jenny. She's a tragic character.
@outspkn1237 ай бұрын
@@janeldavis905 many of us get why Jenny is the way she is, we just ultimately don't care all that much. any negative behavior can be traced back to something in a person's past, that doesn't mean they can't be judged negatively for it. hell, if this movie reflects real life, her father probably suffered the same tragedy she did, doesn't make him any less of an asshole.
@reneerocha17966 ай бұрын
I don’t understand the Jenny haters either. Clearly they made it crystal clear to begin with, what she and her sisters endured in her childhood at the hands of her father 😢
@PowderedToastMan4208 ай бұрын
According to Tom Hanks he said, "Sometimes when people go to Vietnam, they go home to their mommas without any legs. Sometimes they don't go home at all. That's a bad thing. That's all I have to say about that." ✌️
@robertfishburn85457 ай бұрын
The simple innocence of him relating it to his two best friends from the war, nothing truly deep or poignant but at the same time, what he said has alot of impact.
@orchidwave25748 ай бұрын
Jenny's loss of innocence was compensated for by Forrest's retention of it.
@PowderedToastMan4208 ай бұрын
I've seen this movie like 30 times, and I still tear up. ✌️
@tomreichardt60447 ай бұрын
me too
@jamedraa84728 ай бұрын
Jenny was always doing the very thing she advised Forrest to do..... "Just run away..."
@kmvoss8 ай бұрын
Great reaction. Happy holidays. :) Edit: Also some really insightful comments on Jenny at the end. I don't remember someone having such a great take on her psychology on a first viewing.
@goldenageofdinosaurs71928 ай бұрын
Whenever I see a reaction to this movie, I immediately go to the comments to see how the reactor responds to Jenny. So many miss it & I don’t usually watch reactions where they just shit on Jenny the whole time (I do the same with Saving Private Ryan & Upham).
@that.ll_do_pig8 ай бұрын
@@goldenageofdinosaurs7192ditto
@midnightmadness71568 ай бұрын
Top 3 favorite movies of all time. I used to quote from it in university often. Also.. FINALLY, someone who understands Jenny and where she is coming from.
@BigGator58 ай бұрын
"Life was like a box of chocolates. You never know what you're gonna get." Fun Fact: Theatrical movie debut of Hanna Hall and Jacqueline Lovell. Casting Notes Fact: The girl in the school bus with the red hair is Tom Hanks's daughter, Elizabeth Hanks. Historical Fact: During the ambush in Vietnam the enemy is never actually seen. This led many combat veterans, especially Vietnam veterans, to rate this as one of the most accurate combat scenes in movie history. It was very sudden, the enemy wasn't seen, and it happened very quickly. Music Enthusiast Fact: Inspired by Lieutenant Dan Taylor, the military veteran character he played in this movie, Gary Sinise co-founded a rock and roll cover band called "The Lt. Dan Band" during the mid-2000s. The band often goes on USO tours to play for U.S. military personnel stationed around the world and also plays various benefits for veteran-related causes. Sinise was awarded the Presidential Citizen Medal in 2008 for his charity efforts. Double Duty Fact: In the movie there are four actors/actresses who play multiple roles. Gary Sinise plays Lieutenant Dan as well as all of his ancestors. Mykelti Williamson plays Benjamin Beaufort "Bubba" Blue, as well as the waiter opening Dr. Pepper bottles when Forrest meets JFK as an All-American. Sally Field plays Forrest's mom, as well as a male reporter during Forrest's run across America. Tom Hanks plays both Forrest and his Confederate ancestor.
@christhornycroft36868 ай бұрын
I love this film, and have since I first saw it when it came out on video. Forrest's reaction when he finds out he has a song is so great, because it shows that despite his low IQ, because he grew up without a father, he probably felt horrible in that moment, like he was an absentee, neglecting father, too. When he asks if his son is smart, that's because he knows the hardships he's had to endure and doesn't want that for people he cares about. The two main themes of the movie are about facing your problems head on and not running away from them (Jenny putting her desire to run away after being abused by her father onto Forrest) and that Forrest, despite his low IQ, understands something most of the "smart" people in his life don't. The "stupid" guy was teaching them about what life is really about. It's totally unrealistic, but somehow I buy it because of the writing and the performances. When Lieutenant Dan stands up for Forrest against the prostitutes who were mocking him, that's another great moment. Dan is angry and bitter about losing his legs, but deep down, he knows he's lucky to have a friend like Forrest - and he makes people want to be better human beings. He inspires people because he's figured out a greater truth about life than everyone else.
@TheMajestyD8 ай бұрын
classic, still brings me to tears some moments
@axr71498 ай бұрын
Tom Hanks won 2 Best Actor Oscars in consecutive years. FORREST GUMP (1994) was his 2nd win, with PHILADELPHIA (1993) being his first. Do not miss PHILADELPHIA, which also stars Denzel Washington.
@MomCatMeows8 ай бұрын
Philadelphia is so good. Heartbreaking but wonderfully acted and directed. ❤
@gallendugall89138 ай бұрын
makes me cry every time
@sandraback78098 ай бұрын
I love how perceptive and empathetic you are. I was introduced to you during Band of Brothers and again, you are so enjoyable to follow along with. 😁
@sem1conscious8 ай бұрын
In highschool in the 90's they'd show this movie all the time.
@ahhdavy8 ай бұрын
The part when he decides to run, when they’re not showing his face, that’s actually Tom Hank’s brother running 😊
@alicestevens82918 ай бұрын
It is perfect. I've had the argument about this. People say it's overhyped or that people in the era it was made had bad tastes or something but that just is not true at all. It has the accolades it does because it is literally a masterpiece and a lesson on how film production and story telling should be done. There is no denying it. I came to that watching it this year as well. I had seen this with my mother when I was very young and felt I maybe hadn't been able to absorb the context right so I gave it another try, doing with some other things too. And with knowledge of filmmaking and stage under my belt now too. And yes, perfect is the apt word to use.
@richardheinz8 ай бұрын
You've had a real argument about a fictional character?
@michaelg25298 ай бұрын
Some recommendations for drama: An Officer and a Gentleman (1982). Working Girl (1988), both movies are moving and are forgotten gems, and for a crime thriller try Jennifer 8 (1992). No jump scare or gore. All are worth seeing l even if you don't use them on the channel. [edited to correct my spelling. Wow.]
@tfpp18 ай бұрын
20:29 - I thought I was listening to a train whistle, damn! 😆
@darthmaul138 ай бұрын
Love this film. Saw it in the theater in 93. Hope u have a merry Christmas & happy new year.
@chrisbuck9629 күн бұрын
I really think the whole message to this movie was he literally listened to whatever he was told to do as opposed to letting your pride and ego get in the way and look where it took him lol
@solvingpolitics31728 ай бұрын
Delighted that you reacted to this wonderful movie!
@MarcoMM18 ай бұрын
Great reaction like always, this movie its one of my favourites its such a masterpiece of cinema. Every character moment or performance in this movie is incredible perfection. The story is simple but interesting, funny and heartbreaking at the same time. Some fun-facts about it, the movie was based on the 1986 novel of the same name by Winston Groom. The author actually went to write the first draft of the flick before it went into production. Forrest was supposed to be a heavier man who sat at 242 pounds and stood at 6-foot-6. In the book, he became a wrestler, went to space and even hung out with an orangutan. And some fun-facts about this movies, Tom Hanks’ brother did some of that running in the movie Jim Hanks, himself an actor and filmmaker, doubled for his older brother on set, including in numerous sequences featuring Forrest’s high-knee, arm-pumping run. Tom hanks daugther was in this movie in a cameo if you keep an eye out for a surly redheaded girl in the bus scene, when young Forrest can’t find a place to sit (until Jenny invites him to sit next to her). That’s Hanks’ daughter, Elizabeth. While actor Peter Dobson played a not-yet-famous Elvis Presley as a lodger in the Gump household in a brief scene with young Forrest, the voice belongs to none other than actor Kurt Russell. Why? Russell, who was uncredited in the film, had played Presley already in a 1979 biopic directed by John Carpenter titled, appropriately enough, Elvis. And if you are wondering what Gump says in those few moments of radio silence? Well, according to Tom Hanks, the full speech reads: “Sometimes when people go to Vietnam, they go home to their mommas without any legs. Sometimes they don't go home at all. That's a bad thing. Keep up the good work.
@elliotcontreras85408 ай бұрын
Merry Christmas to Indian Calypso
@captainofdunedain39938 ай бұрын
Hello lady! I always enjoy your videos. I thought maybe you could take my movie suggestion that no other reactioners seen it much before. 1) Rounders 2) In Bruges 3) Manchester by the Sea 4) Layer Cake 5) Chaos Theory 6) Logan Lucky 7) Notting Hill 8) Silver Linings Playbook 9) Spy Game 10) RocknRolla
@CapturedByKen8 ай бұрын
“Is he smart” always gets me
@victorcachat79848 ай бұрын
Great reaction!
@FeaturingRob8 ай бұрын
This is one of those perfect movies. You would think there would be no remake...but... In 2002, Paramount co-produced an Indian version of the story in Hindi. Laal Singh Chadda stars Aamir Khan (as Laal/Forrest) and Kareena Kapoor Khan (as Jenny/Rupa). It is not a blow-for-blow remake, things are altered for Indian culture/history. I loved it and thought it was a brilliant alternate take on the story. The film also credits Eric Roth for his Oscar-winning screenplay and novelist Winston Groom as inspiration and basis for the new version. I have heard some folks do not like it...but I did. Here are a couple of Tom Hanks movies I suggest: - Apollo 13 (which also has Gary "Lt. Dan" Sinise) - Philadelphia (Tom won the Best Actor Oscar for this the year before he won the Best Actor Oscar for Forrest Gump, and only one other actor in Oscar history pulled off back-to-back Best Actor wins, Spencer Tracy in the 1930s). - The Meg Ryan/Tom Hanks rom-com trilogy: Sleepless In Seattle, Joe Versus the Volcano, and You've Got Mail. - The Dan Brown/Robert Langdon Trilogy: The DaVinci Code, Angels & Demons, and Inferno...all directed by Ron Howard, Tom plays Harvard symbologist Robert Langdon, the hero of Dan Brown's thriller novels. Each film has a major cast around Tom. The first two are amazing, the third one is not as good, but has moments. - A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood - Tom plays American children's television icon, Mr. Rogers. - Splash - Tom's first hit film, directed by Ron Howard. - A League of Their Own - That Thing You Do! - Tom's debut as writer and director. Liv Tyler is the biggest name in the cast. About asmall-townn rock band that has a big hit in the early 1960s. Lots of great music. The title song is a major earworm! I don't know if you have seen these, but there are easily 6 other Tom Hanks films that are also really good, that I didn't mention. The guy rarely puts a foot wrong in his choices of films to make.
@Trashcan-Man8 ай бұрын
Hope you start feeling better soon. Being sick is the worst.
@JumboSeventyNine8 ай бұрын
Winston Groom who wrote the novel was paid $350,000 plus 3% of the profits of the movie. Altogether that totalled $350,000. Paramount created another company to make the movie that then charged paramount enough money that Forrest Gump made between a $31-60+ million dollar loss. Paramount then absorbed the company charging the money meaning it never paid them a cent and never paid Winston Groom a cent of the profits supposedly never made. Its not unique. Return of the Jedi still hasn't made a 'profit' nor have some of the Harry Potter movies. He did get a 7 figure pay day for the second book which would never be made in a behind doors settlement. Its one of those examples of a beautiful film being bankrolled by some very questionable practices.
@TheBlackRanger1878 ай бұрын
Forrest Gump is definitely an exceptional movie, but I wonder have you seen “Mississippi Masala” it’s a romantic comedy starring Denzel Washington, Sarita Chowdhery and Mira Nair. It’s a very interesting film exploring the relationship between a young black man from the American south and a young Indian woman from Uganda. It’s a very interesting film if you haven’t seen it.
@calm7138 ай бұрын
IMO, everything about this reaction video is good--except that it's slightly OVER-EDITED and is missing key points along the way, it doesn't feel continuous, it should have been about 10 minutes longer for an epic movie like this. Just my two-cents.
@PILLGATESUBEEZY8 ай бұрын
All-time great movie.
@kevincid56888 ай бұрын
A great movie without a doubt, there are many wonderful Tom Hanks movies, and there will be many recommendations in the comments but I want to make one in particular, another Tom Hanks movie called "Road to Perdition", It is little known but very emotional, I really recommend it a lot. 👌🏼
@brendaklies2058 ай бұрын
Did you know the house was a facade
@allisongrinnell51078 ай бұрын
It still really bothers me that the news reporter refers to Forrest as a “gardener” from Alabama. He’s a decorated war veteran, owner of a multimillion dollar corporation, and world ping pong champion. Gardener pfffft.
@cometgirl2177 ай бұрын
First, I totally agree! Second, I presume that was an intentional filmmaking choice to demonstrate how often people fail to appreciate the accomplishments of anyone seen as “other” (and further endear Forrest to the audience)
@NerdyBigBrother8 ай бұрын
Honestly I have the biggest crush on you lmao. I wish I could watch these movies with you seriously, your attention to detail and your emotions are so beautiful.
@Rudy40998 ай бұрын
beautful reaction. =;-)
@billcliffordakabillthephot22498 ай бұрын
"Like he knows what love is!" Wow, you are clueless because I feel he knows more about love than you, or me!
@umasridhar74728 ай бұрын
❤❤
@abirrezwansheikh29308 ай бұрын
react on hacksaw ridge
@abirrezwansheikh29308 ай бұрын
why dont you react on bhajrangi bhaijan??
@ClaytonMacleod8 ай бұрын
Please get rid of that spinning circle nonsense.
@thecoolj452218 ай бұрын
Why are you watching this movie its awful. I can't stand it
@bigdream_dreambig7 ай бұрын
🤦♂ This film is widely loved and is generally ranked as one of the 100 best ever made.
@thecoolj452217 ай бұрын
@bigdream_dreambig So is Titanic it won best picture and is widely loved and ranks among 100 best movies ever made lists and I know people who hate that movie too what is your point exactly?
@bigdream_dreambig7 ай бұрын
@@thecoolj45221 I have no problem with saying "I can't stand it." However, asserting that "it's awful" is unjustified -- and it's a useless statement unless you provide additional specifics about why you think so.
@thecoolj452217 ай бұрын
@@bigdream_dreambig I can provide statements why I think it's awful
@bigdream_dreambig7 ай бұрын
@@thecoolj45221 And yet you haven't.
@cliffwheeler7357Ай бұрын
I loved your reaction, especially your empathy towards Jenny. My only disappointment was it was to short!
@sebastianbermudezcastellan7736Ай бұрын
please reaction to miracle in the cell number 7, the turkey version
@usmcrn44182 ай бұрын
Forrest was taught to run away from his fears.. which is what he did. But eventually, like all of us.. he had to face life. Good or bad.
@usmcrn44182 ай бұрын
Your voice is fine, your eyes are pretty and your enthusiasm is infectious.. PLEASE.. carry on! ❤️
@Nostalgia94785 ай бұрын
Finally someone who cries at this movie as much as me. lol
@roberthopper29276 ай бұрын
Hello, I would like you to react to the Snow Society movie, thank you
@reneerocha17966 ай бұрын
One of the greats!! 😊❤
@dragana05396 ай бұрын
:)
@Supermanlegacy.7 ай бұрын
"People will notice the change in your attitude towards them, but won't notice their behavior that made you change."
@nonchalantd7 ай бұрын
♥
@user-fv5ms4sz8e7 ай бұрын
How many Jennys are out there, that we walk past every day and we never consider their desperate plight and their need for true Forrest Gump style friendship? Our world is hurting and we are too indifferent to ease the pain.
@kunarmakun7937 ай бұрын
the place they living in .. thats the kind of place i wanna live in when i retire .. its looks peaceful and quite ...
@dragonweyr447 ай бұрын
Jenny had AIDS She felt she didn't deserve love because of how her father "abused" her
@krisfrederick50017 ай бұрын
Tom Hanks is literally incapable of making a bad film, back to the 80's...Even when he's portraying a "local idiot" he's absolutely brilliant. This actually freaked us out when we were kids because my Mom looked exactly like Sally Fields and we thought she had a secret movie career. Literally cried when she died. When Forrest, realizes he's a Father and asks..."Is he smart?" gets me every time. That's emotional intelligence.
@Animexlover-si3tx7 ай бұрын
hello didi please watch demon slayer
@Moon_Dancer-O8O7 ай бұрын
I wish you and your family a happy new year 2024.😊😊 Kind regards from Germany.❤️❤️❤️
@XeonAlpha7 ай бұрын
I _highly_ recommend Steel Magnolias. Sally Field at her finest (she won an Oscar for that movie). Plus who doesn’t love Dolly Parton.
@jonmcnabb64217 ай бұрын
now try watching fried green tomatoes!
@lucianoa317 ай бұрын
I cry each time with this movie, never gets old. Great Reaction 😊
@sagargimhavanekar56297 ай бұрын
Please react to 'The Last Samurai'
@Heru30057 ай бұрын
If your going for the 90's Tom Hanks trifecta, Apollo 13 is a must watch. Between this, The Green Mile, and Apollo 13 Tom was the gold standard dramatic lead for a while.
@chrisajourney7 ай бұрын
First time I watched this movie, I was 12 years old and on a long haul flight. I cried my eyes out. Beautiful movie ❤
@MFBloosh7 ай бұрын
The fact that this movie, Shawshank Redemption, and Pulp Fiction all came out in the same year (1994) is crazy. Such a great year for movies.
@DHONI-MISHRA7 ай бұрын
Please see MASTER MOVIE 🔥
@williamjones60317 ай бұрын
1. The music rights alone must have cost a small fortune💲💲 2. Kurt Russell did the voice for Elvis. 3. IRL Sally Fields is only 10 years older than Tom Hanks. 4. Having gotten his degree Forrest would have gone into the Army as an officer like Lt. Dan. Not a recruit. His ASVAB kills that. 5. He actually saved Lt Dan twice. Once in the field and again to get him out of his post war funk and Dan turned his life around. 6. Normally an enlisted Army person would be fully aware of his/her separation date. 5. Jenny did indeed give him the best gift ever (it wasn't the shoes)😋 8. Jenny died of Hep-C from dirty needles when she was in Caliphony.. 9. It's ironic that Lt. Dan told the guys to take care of their feet because he loses his. 10. At the rally Forrest says, "Sometimes when people go to Vietnam, they go home to their mommas without any legs. Sometimes they don't go home at all. That's a bad thing. That's all I have to say about that." 11. You have had a ride through recent US history and culture. From Elvis, John Lennon, Abby Hoffman to Vietnam and Watergate. Even the jogging craze of the 70's. About the only thing left out was streaking. 13. "Sometimes I guess there're just aren't enough rocks" 14. Haley Joel Osmentt/Forrest Jr. steals the show in "The Sixth Sense" with Bruce Willis. 15. Often when he's finishing a segment about death, he ends it by saying "That's all I have to say about that" 16 Keep in mind if Jenny wasn't wasting her life seeking men like her father and was with Forrest he/we wouldn't have had this incredible journey.
@dennisvdwerf7 ай бұрын
Man you're gonna die watching the green Mile with Tom Hanks. Right up your alley
@paulamoya79567 ай бұрын
My favorite Movie . Loved your reaction.. I cried so many tears with you yet Ive seen it a hundred times . There’s no way to watch this without ruining your entire day with swollen eyes and red face like I have right now . AGAIN!⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
@AmbarishR457 ай бұрын
Please React Blockbuster Malayalam Movie' RDX'
@johncarpenter37517 ай бұрын
Love your reactions, so glad you made it to Forest Gump finally. I know your gonna love it!!
@stallion787 ай бұрын
Watch “the pacific “
@Roller-Ball7 ай бұрын
NOTCE TO EDITOR...........I bet you edit the reviews with either headphones or earbuds. In doing this you make the reviewer 2-5 times louder than the movie, when you finish. I understand between music and audio in the movies. This makes it really difficult to hear the parts you post. Please go to another computer and listen to the post. You will hear the difference between them. I am not trying to be disrespectful. Reguards: Rollerball
@blackkatt7777 ай бұрын
Happy Holidays! I hope you are enjoying the time with your family. I am so excited to watch this reaction. This movie is absolutely worth every accolade made for cinematic art. It hits different if you are familiar with American history and see how genius the writer was at making a pure hearted man like Forrest the catalyst for historical events. My heart broke for Jenny's long personal hell and Forrest's ability to love her when she couldn't love herself yet. This is one ofcthose movies that people should definitely put on their watch list. It gets you hard in the feels.
@sliceofheaven30267 ай бұрын
Charlie btw was the name for the enemy in Vietnam.
@djgrant87617 ай бұрын
The range of emotions on your face is so refreshing. Thank you for reacting to this film.
@peterhansen49317 ай бұрын
Nice reaction - I really like lieutenant Dan 😊🎄👍🏻🇩🇰
@WaywardVet7 ай бұрын
Everyone who's seen this seems to have an instant reaction when you mention "Forest Gump". For me, it's immediately thinking of Fleetwood Mac singing "Go Your Own Way" as he runs uphill with a crowd following.
@starlord34967 ай бұрын
Just imagine living Gumps life. All those moments in history. I thought living in space was epic. My hero’s Forest Gump, Chuck Norris, Kevin Bacon. ;-)
@Sherman1fan8 ай бұрын
He had a back problem (probably scoliosis) his legs were ok. Jenny had Hepatitis C, as the author explained some time after the movie came out. Most speculated it was AIDS as that was common at the time, but Hep. C was still unknown.
@sivannatalie7 ай бұрын
Oh wow.. I always thought it was HIV. 🤦🏻♀️
@hotmail3058 ай бұрын
Grear reaction:) You have more Tom Hanks to react to : The Burbs (Comedy BIG (Romance Comedy Joe Vs Volcano (romance comedy Sleepless in Seattle (romance comedy
@tofersiefken8 ай бұрын
Life is like a box of chocolates in the following ways: You want it to be abundant but not heavy. You want it to be a diverse variety to sample without a bunch of gross, weird, abnormal stuff. You want it to be sweet to savor, not greedily devoured. What else would you add?
@jkennedy10488 ай бұрын
Great analysis of Jenny. And, as usual, a great reaction! 😀
@MikeWileyComedy8 ай бұрын
I like your edit. Jenny: You think I could fly off this bridge? Forrest: Bye bye Jenny.
@sneakypoptart3888 ай бұрын
That line breaks me single time. "Is he smart or.....is he like" gesturing to himself 😭
@mamakat1148 ай бұрын
Thank you Aish for not bashing Jenny. Trauma is an awful thing. As a Survivor myself, I hug you having such heartfelt insight into not wanting to tarnish Forrest.
@bronzewand8 ай бұрын
If a movie/story could ever be called perfect.. this is the one
@anitanino84358 ай бұрын
This is such a great movie I cry every time
@XeonAlpha8 ай бұрын
“Is he smart…or is he like me?” That line broke me.
@sivannatalie7 ай бұрын
Same
@enicole12038 ай бұрын
So happy you understood Jenny, I get so upset when people get hostile to her instead of understanding her. Yes she kept making bad decisions but she was a broken person since she was a child, and she was afraid to taint a pure good person like Forest even though she really always lived him.
@axebeard60857 ай бұрын
Like Fight Club, this film is too intelligent for many viewers. The thing to remember here is that WE NEVER SEE THE REAL JENNY until Forrest meets her at the apartment (and maybe not even then). The film goes out of its way to show us the Jenny that Forrest sees. Unfortunately, a lot of people don't understand the concept of "unreliable narrator". They watch a film and think that what they see on the screen is a completely accurate account of what is happening. For those people who don't understand unreliable narration, Jenny is a VERY uncomfortable character. The see how horribly Jenny is treating Forrest, but at the same time they're feeling how the film is portraying her as an angel. Because of this, they feel like the movie is telling them that Jenny is perfect and Forrest just deserves to be treated badly. With this limited understanding of what happening, they are furious at "Jenny the Villain" because she seems to treat Forrest horribly and get away with it. But understanding what the film was trying to do does not mean I have to like it.
@damienrichards97437 ай бұрын
@@axebeard6085Maybe because for some if not most the concept of Unreliable Narrator is just showing and/or telling without actually going about and doing it if that makes sense. One thing is this and whatever the next and the layperson with average intelligence of any and all kinds are supposed to be okay with that. They need concrete telling/showing otherwise they can theorize all day all night long without actually knowing that it is what they mean, just told/shown in a different way. And it's not just about calling it nuance either. They are taught to look at that, and when they don't see it, it's a mystery that must be solved through speculation and fan fiction. And when comments say otherwise, they get defensive and say along the lines of, "well they should have told/shown us that that is what they mean, not whatever the hell they pulled out there". Messy stuff Unreliable Narration is, but it is what it is. Just my two cents. I could be wrong though so correct me for that one my bad. Much love and respect.