Fragmentary Clues Leads To Killer | The New Detectives | Real Responders

In suburban New York, a young mother is brutally murdered in her kitchen. Police race to identify her killer but fragmentary clues left at the scene are all that remain. In Idaho, an elderly couple is found shot to death in their home, I-witness accounts vary and police look for clues and then look to forensic science to identify a suspect.
Content owned and licensed from New Dominion to Little Dot Studios.
For all questions, please contact [e-mail]
#RealResponders #NewDetective

[@Zanderreid571]

From all these documentaries I've watched, I've learned that the only way to get away with murder is to never commit one.

[@kencienavarner630]

@Rhito Mero, that is a fact👍!!

[@ileanamuntean7338]

Why would anyone want to commit murder??? Nothing is worth taking a life, these people are total morons. It's ok to kill in self-defence or to protect an innocent, but this would not be murder.

[@HdHd-hp6qz]

@Rhito Mero Not true. The easiest way to get away with murder is to either kill a prostitute because the police won’t use too many resources to finding the killer or inject an overdose of heroin into a homeless person. The police will automatically assume they done it to themselves.

[@Zanderreid571]

@@HdHd-hp6qz Idk what you been watching but most of these crime shows I've watched have been about murderers who kill prostitutes, sure it makes it harder but people still don't get away

[@FateTurns]

Nah, that's not getting away with it. The only way I see yo legally get away from murder is self defense, or during war times.

[@priscillamurphy7229]

Staying home watching New Detectives keeps me entertain. Eventually I fall asleep listening to the narrator's soothing voice.

[@nancygaudicos7521]

Same here. But got some problems. I am having nightmares after falling asleep watching…

[@hellymad123]

Me too

[@timmyshore3755]

do you want to fall asleep together ? 😉💋

[@rajeshadya]

2 concurrent life sentences doesn't make sense for 2 premeditated murders.

[@richardkranium2944]

Kind of defeats the point of there being 2.

[@maureen624]

This is why I call judges "wise men"". If not a brother would have been convicted for a crime he did not commit.

[@janetmccoy7945]

I agree with the smart judge. However, this case doesn’t set Rught with me. The perpetrator seems mentally slow. I winder if he got a proper defense.

[@joycekariuki46]

Watching from Nairobi kenya 🇰🇪

[@Reddbeaver]

Are you free, or oppressed in Kenya? In your opinion. Thanks friend

[@sharoncoombs5851]

Perfect love watching Nairobi Kenya .That person asking if you are free or oppressed in Kenya hope u let him no u r free or choose to b free wherever God place u freedom in Christ

[@nancieongera6269]

🇰🇪🇰🇪🇰🇪🇰🇪

[@hullyokwanyo346]

Watching from Nairobi Kenya

[@samdoors5132]

It’s pretty scary how the detectives charge the older brother with flimsy evidence luckily the judge didn’t go along with it or he’d be doing two life sentences and his sick brother would be free to kill some more. Never get friendly with the weirdos in your neighborhood they might take it the wrong way personally I get along good with my neighbors I just don’t get over friendly I don’t invite them over for dinner or for a swim in my pool.

[@Stardusted1]

Stabbed AND shot? That’s pure hate.

[@hustlenut7910]

Yeah no kidding, you have to have a heart of glass to commit such evil

[@bensonyeboah3910]

6

[@jamesharris184]

More so if you're stabbed first

[@HdHd-hp6qz]

The worse I’ve heard is someone be stabbed shot then thrown over the side of a building.

[@eh-i1841]

I just think,that to shoot someone,in the face,is beyond evil.

[@evelynfidler6285]

Eliminate means guilty until proven innocent

[@davidtydeman1434]

I know this a tv show and therefore only a brief summary but I don’t understand how the first case was convicted. There are many other possible explanations for the evidence as he worked for the victim and therefore had contact with her. Also voice stress tests and lie detectors have been proven repeatedly to be junk science and worthless apart from intimidating vulnerable individuals

[@cynthiatolman326]

Voice stress test seems like junk science. If I find my spouse dead I'd be stressed to the max.

[@murdog62]

"Seems like junk science" Thankfully, science doesn't care what things "seem like". It only cares about analysis based in the scientific method. Voice stress and emotional stress are two separate things. Read a book, dude.

[@cynthiatolman326]

@@murdog62 very nice comment. I'd be proud of writing it, have a great day, dude

[@quinn3974]

@@cynthiatolman326 I hear you Cynthia. Science has become so weaponised these days in my opinion. Climate Change, COVID-19 2 easy examples of where science is imperfect.

[@xxxxxxx1128]

@@quinn3974 yup the Democrats and liberal think scientists are god but they forgot that god created science! For humans to figure how to help us and god can reverse everything human do in the name of science! I dont know if I expressed my self good but is my problem never learned how to Express myself and my english maybe not good I am bilingual english my 3 language

[@prometheusunbound7628]

It's not junk science. It's bogus science, like polygraphs.

[@JackGordone]

The punishment for first degree murder ought to be the death penalty, not 25 to life.

[@aridyaacob3172]

Yep, a life for a life.

[@narteyernest8]

U can't just waste life like that.

[@quinn3974]

Minimum LWOP

[@marilynvallance]

@@aridyaacob3172 So many miscarriages of justice in the US. Difficult to resolve when you’ve executed an innocent person.

[@aridyaacob3172]

@@marilynvallance only when you have definite and irrefutable proof then.

[@rebeccabangura8822]

Twenty five years sentence for the life of someone taking for nothing, that is ridiculous

[@shangshangan3590]

25 years is better. I watched a lot of murder documentaries and some murderers got 5 years😢 esp Canada, Australia and UK

[@ailleananaithnid2566]

@@shangshangan3590 That depends on the circumstances of the homicide. If it’s on impulse - rather than premeditated - that’s manslaughter rather than murder. It’s not about the country but rather the degree of malice involved. We would certainly punish someone who strategizes and plans a murder than someone who panics or kills someone because of a sudden Impulse. That’s black letter law. 🤷‍♀️

[@shangshangan3590]

@@ailleananaithnid2566 i watched a lot if documentaries. It doesn't depend on premeditated or not. It's depends on the justice system. Lot of premeditated murders the murder only got 7 years in jail. Some got 5. There are some people who are doing drugs and neglected children but got life with ni parols.

[@shangshangan3590]

@@ailleananaithnid2566 try to watch the documentaries of the countries I mentioned. You'll understand what I'm talking about

[@BCSoHappy]

@@shangshangan3590 what cases in Canada? And look at Norway where that mass killer got only 17 years.

[@marilynvallance]

To whoever writes the introduction it’s eye witness, not I witness.

[@tessgrutter9893]

I highly doubt Lenny was trying to give that older lady a “hug”… I bet u anything it was creepier than just a innocent hug.

[@valeriemacphail9180]

Lanny must have given her one hell of a rub up, for her to ask him to not come back! How could a woman have the slightest idea that defending herself from sexual assault could set off so much homicidal rage? The Kathleen case at least had been given one red flag, the sinister arson attack with explicit graffiti message could only come from a badly deranged, dangerous mind.

[@johannas.l.brushane2518]

It puzzles me as well when watching various true crimes stories, or reading about current cases in newspapers. How the hell is someone in this day wired in their head to percieve the world around them being arranged to them having a right to another person and do to them as however they please?

[@sankiegreyling6309]

How can a crime scene photographer take such bad photos

[@chrishicks609]

@@johannas.l.brushane2518 lllllllllllll))lol

[@marshareemullings2461]

Greetings to all my real responders family i hope all is well in this pandemic. Once I hear the intro i know its the greatest narrator ever so soothing 🥰🥰🥰🇯🇲🇯🇲✌✌

[@Sammy_shammy24]

Same to you! Much love✌️💙❤️

[@julietgover2832]

Regards🇦🇺

[@charlesjames1464]

Hi there fellow citizen.🏁⚅

[@OdoneAngel]

💯🌹

[@sethalbert1239]

Its plandemic...

[@NickPenlee]

It doesn't say much for the relationship between the Buchanan brothers. Lenny/Lanny was prepared to see his brother Robert take the blame for the crime, whilst Robert, during his confinement on murder charges, seems to have failed to make the connection between his brother's access to the .22 rifle and that he wore similar shoes, but a size smaller. It's also odd that the police, during their preliminary investigations, didn't consider both brothers as suspects given the circumstances, eg. access to murder weapon, did they buy shoes together on a shopping trip, were there times when both brothers worked with each other in cutting grass etc. The Judge was correct to throw out the case against Robert but he may well have deliberated longer over the other brother had decent evidence been presented at the same time.

[@rogersimpson9725]

I could never pass a stress test because I have an autoimmune condition which causes high anxiety along with other problems. Even if I was innocent. I would get a lawyer right away and probably refuse to answer questions. I would let the lawyer do the talking. That's what they're paid for eh. Actually my condition affects my communication as well. All the more reason to have a lawyer. I heard it said that if You're innocent you don't need a lawyer. That's a lie.

[@murdog62]

Voice stress is not the same as emotional stress. And its not admissible in court anyway.

[@sureshpatelism]

We once had a murder in our apartment complex. Police was interviewing everyone. They asked us questions which we answered. It's when u have done something, u maybe shaky, nervous and have different stories.

[@spreadthelove77]

Correct, Roger. Only cops say that to try and get a confession. Detectives are not your friend. Get a lawyer every time.

[@penniewyatt9391]

I feel ya, similar conditions, I would just cry uncontrollably. It’s embarrassing.

[@charlestaylor2193]

hey which auto immune cause i also suffer from anxiety

[@jessiearies1912]

So sad 2 c her leave her home in a body bag! So young! No one deserves that!

[@Kkayoodle]

The mathematician using the wood grain, etc to recalculate the dust shoe print photo blew me away. Maybe I should have paid more attention to Mr. Kresson,lol

[@ailleananaithnid2566]

“The two were devout church goers.” I hear this all the time in true crime, yet it’s completely irrelevant. Many killers, including serial killers (Dennis Rader to name one,) were “devout church goers.” It shouldn’t be used as shorthand to imply that anyone is a good, honest & kind person.

[@junomorrison8245]

@@_Meng_Lan *Sigh* No. They did not "attack a whole group of innocent people". They pointed out that saying that someone is a devout churchgoer doesn't have anything to do with being a good person. Good and bad people go to church. I'm Roman Catholic and I also hate it when they use the "Devout churchgoer/Good Christian/actively involved with the church" descriptor. Christian doesn't automatically equal good and it annoys me when my religion is used as a shorthand implication. On that note, you attacked all atheists and insulted them as illogical and small-minded. Please be mindful of the harm words such as this can do. To quote Ephesians 4:32, "Be kind to one another..."

[@channelone4655]

Remember, the fit and well don't go to doctors. Church is full of sinners. Going to Church doesn't imply someone is good, merely that they know, and accept, they aren't perfect.

[@malcolmledger176]

@@_Meng_Lan The existence of air can be proven, even though it is invisible. The existence of `god` cannot. By any means.

[@channelone4655]

@@malcolmledger176 Yes. Indeed if all books and knowledge was eradicated in one go, eventually all the science books will be rewritten, none of the religious texts would ever return the same, if at all.

[@maggieoneill3355]

Christ??,he's obiously obnoxious if he exists.

[@vwitty5189]

Nothing can hinder the LASER PRECISION INTEL of any Honest Sharp Detectives anytime.

[@richardkranium2944]

Even honest detectives make assumptions and then use loaded questions on people not smart enough to get an attorney right when the police want to talk to them. Or can not afford one while assuming innocent people have nothing to fear.

[@vwitty5189]

I made such a different Comment because all MICRO SECRETS are under Crystal clear Exhibit by them.

[@lauraatkinson4790]

Both Carlos Cajigas and Michael Fernandez are currently in prison. Fernandez will be eligible for parole in September 2022. Cajigas will be eligible for parole in July 2034.

[@dianawatton7570]

Pardon me but I had to chuckle when the narrator said New York doesn't have a lot of crime Etc.

[@Joelswinger34]

Great detective work on these!

[@TNT-km2eg]

25 years ?! That dirt should never be walking the streets again

[@theranjithjay]

1997- Suburb of New York- A young mother, 32 year old Kathleen was shot and murdered and her husband Jim Martin called 911 and an ex employee, named Carlos was a suspect then in another case an Idaho, the Downer couple were murdered and a man named Bucannon became a person of interest.

[@lorimav]

Does this cone out on Mondays? If so that's great, this on Mondays and A&E's I Survived on Wednesdays.

[@billgatesleavingyamomshous8177]

Nightmare fuel before bed 🛏

[@nrich5127]

Call me racist or what ever but for murder 1st or 2nd degree it should be life with no parole - the victim is never coming back so your sentence should reflect the crime.

[@shericebrown490]

I totally agree with you 100 percent or they get lethal injection or the electric chair

[@HdHd-hp6qz]

So if someone chops someone’s arm off the best thing for the court system to do would be to chop the perpetrators arm off to make it reflect the crime ?

[@richardkranium2944]

I wish it worked that way. Unfortunately most of the cases get closed by making a deal which results in a confession and the missing details for a lesser sentence. The person usually knows they are on the right track and wants a deal before there isn’t one.

[@henchyheld3925]

The odd thing is that as we are watching this in the early 2020's, the murderers who got 'life' are now FREE. Especially if they got a third off, (for good behavior 😥)

[@quinn3974]

Disturbing

[@CocoAvalon]

No, not in the USA. Life is usually actually life or at least 50 years.

[@brutusminimus2612]

Life sentence, without the possibility of parole. It’s one of the things the UK could learn from the US.

[@courtnypowell162]

Cctc''

[@poonambhatia8867]

Lanny was not a slow learner !He was sharp enough to let his brother face the charges by lplaying the innocent slow learner !

[@sandyc6569]

Both cases are sad!

[@Time4House]

Seems like many of these episodes are reposted as new, but were actually aired previously

[@danielebruno1531]

Precisely.

[@fatimaahmed8813]

If the shoe prints don't much, alter the original photographs. Now, you have a case for charges 🙄

[@MrAmeame]

Bruh you really can't trust family 😶😅😂

[@gargshivam024]

he said she was like his mother. Oh dear.

[@mangafq8]

Why did it take the cops 1-1/2 years to investigate Lanny? I mean the gun was at his father's house and he was the brother of the initial suspect.

[@timmyshore3755]

mostly because a lot of them are incompetent.

[@waterboy8999]

Slow learners....

[@adamscease4126]

Slow learner... Lenny... When do I get to tend the rabbits

[@kol2han]

The best channel of dedectives series. I already addicted to this channel. I want to say thank you.

[@Aviertje]

The Lenny case is maddening. Forensic science is like 'hey, we have the same model shoe but a different size', and the cops don't immediately go check the shoes of the suspects family and acquaintances? My first thought was literally 'oh, these were a xmas gift or bought at the same time as the perpetrators'.

[@tokidada1010]

Why do these criminals never get rid of the shoes they wore during the crime? Lol, don't get me wrong, though. I'm glad they get caught.

[@kimoyasappleton6533]

The person who took that shoe photo had to resign🤣🤣they doing that person bad

[@veritagwallace1956]

I’m surprised that the ‘knife’ wasn’t identified properly! It’s a ‘carpet knife’!

[@dusancorlija9088]

Two life sentence ??? 🤣😮

[@jenniferbatnes7391]

The law in US is too soft to criminals. Why two intentional killers not get death penalties?

[@dave1283]

That's NOT what a .22 rifle sounds like. 🤦‍♂️

[@rhondasisco-cleveland2665]

Poor woman

[@jamesharris184]

Smart cop. The forensic examiner made me laugh the way he babied that slide on that gun. No one who handles guns would do that, since it may leave the gun out of battery and you're handling it in a way it was never intended to handle. During these shows we identify most of the participants as actors but for some reason that gun Handler looks authentic but he was very far from it.

[@jamesharris184]

@Wreck and Carey it's the newest thing in guns... they mostly prefer duracell's but once a gun is out of battery it won't work

[@RICDirector]

🤣🤣🤣

[@TariAkpodiete]

Almost railroaded the wrong brother into prison

[@timmyshore3755]

happens all the time toots

[@TariAkpodiete]

@@timmyshore3755 > so true!

[@richardkranium2944]

Nice brother.

[@Moodboard39]

Westchester county is NY state, not New York city. The narrator was mistaken.

[@jayone3442]

he said the suburbs of NYC

[@garyseven4896]

25 yrs for murder b.s..

[@Brian1Graves]

The murder weapon was a 9 MM the weapon showed tested was a .45. Details folks, details.

[@markemerson8399]

Oh! I was ready to convict the older brother Robert!

[@_Meng_Lan]

Even robert later said they got the shoe sizes wrong. Robert said his were the shoe prints but they wont listen. Corrupt

[@justindunn1942]

Can't stop Binge watching this show and fbi files. Is there any other shows like this on KZbin if so send me links to them

[@libertybellz6831]

Youve found other shows to watch by now, yes or no?

[@samdoors5132]

It’s a shame but more people get away with murder then those that are captured. In the first program both of those warlocks should have got 25 to life or life with the possibility of no parole

[@kencienavarner630]

Oh my goodness 😱 why killing innocent people 😡😰??!!! Heartless animals where do you coming from?? 💀

[@tonyduckworth3290]

Shoddy police photographer

[@abocas]

All the Jane and John Does and those not found ..... are victims of those who got away with it. But mostly, probably, incidentally ..

[@adamscease4126]

Idaho 🙄

[@fjdkfdfjdf33]

I'm not an investigator, but even I know that a door cannot be a jar.

[@prometheusunbound7628]

Ha ha. But if you notice, they said the door was "slightly" a jar, so I think you're good.

[@ktloz2246]

:) A jar is a container, ajar is slightly open.

[@richardkranium2944]

Good one.

[@James_Bowie]

At 40:30 ... how come this critical piece of evidence was not obtained the first time around? Was the neighbor stupid or did the police fail to interview him?

[@HobbyOrganist]

2000 Sabin Dr Ammon, Idaho

[@rinijumiyati4243]

Im watching this at monday 18 September 2023 At 20.10 From Hong Kong

[@suqambi7591]

sad an an innocent woman was murder..I wonder whose blood was on the glove they didn't say 🤔

[@tonybrock5288]

How do you deal with KZbin shadow banning comments?

[@timmyshore3755]

live with it

[@orangetabby445]

People quit

[@timmyshore3755]

are you a quitter ? 👉🙈🙉

[@timmyshore3755]

i don’t watch this stuff my grampa says it’s depressing and detrimental to my development. 👉🙈🙉 you can’t make me watch it either.

[@ariadneschild8460]

Why comment then?

[@mohammadrezarezaei6751]

they know well,police caught with them anyway. but they do theirs crime anyhow. because they have disturbed mind. and taking life would be no matter of all for them.,in theirs view life costs a penny.

[@charityfernandez6113]

I am a fan

[@bostonteaparty3926]

How can you call this the NEW Detectives when these are the same old ones from Forensic Files???? This is from 1998!!! It aired on Forensic files moons ago

[@tonybrock5288]

What if Lenny's brother had worn his brother's shoes to the crime scene? Knowing that his brother was mentally impaired and that he would likely unknowingly take the fall? Matching shoes alone is surely not enough evidence to go on? This is a double crime that has likely not been fully solved... The fact that these shoe prints were clearly found in 2 different places in two different media (mud and blood) clearly points to the fact that they were intended to be found. huh? I think the cops jumped to conclusions that both they and the real killer wanted ... Get closure and walk away.... Problem solved ...

[@timmyshore3755]

excellent sleuthing 👍

[@knpdii3592]

No wonder, America stood always as the greatest. Up until now my poor country Phil cant live like these era of late 1950s to early 1980s of america up until now it can not compare their greatness. The economy is quiet rising in my country, rising buildings but employers salary cant buy a decent house in cash, just new trains from metro to near province like many years and same politicians sat but still no trains built for far provinces. How pity Philippines.

[@ronpearson998]

I support the police, but it's like every other job, some pass with 51% and others with 99 %. This applies to all people you interact with.

[@richardkranium2944]

Police are generally police because they were C average students in school.

[@HdHd-hp6qz]

Im sick and tired of these snake oil salesmen adverts that keep interrupting my viewing.

[@KingCast65]

6:29 DAMN that's a hirsute man. I'd hate to be his plumber. Or actually I would like to be his plumber, steady money there. 20:44 GF is hot AF with that vacuum in her hand LOL... seriously tho she's a cutie!

[@timmyshore3755]

dad this isn’t a dating site

[@Mrrobackenson1]

British cops are far better me thinks.

[@2msvalkyrie529]

Rubbish !! The British Justice System is a joke. Murderers out on parole after 15 years. ???

[@cynthiaarnold4739]

The detective with the blonde hair dresses unprofessional dye blonde hair clashes with the suit color

[@timmyshore3755]

her feet are unpolished too. look like guy feet. yucky. my grampa says unpolished feet are a sign of a lazy woman.

[@fransforsellm8143]

first commenter!!!

[@jasoninrikes1925]

Am first

[@karenrubenmoss9307]

Prime example why they should banish ownership of guns.

[@2msvalkyrie529]

Yeah right ! All the bad guys would be queuing up to hand in their guns ?!?!?!

[@karenrubenmoss9307]

@@2msvalkyrie529 I truly doubt it, but clearly something has to change.

[@darklynoon6847]

If I ever get arrested I’m getting naked first….🧖🏻‍♂️ lol

[@timmyshore3755]

can i watch ? 😉💋

[@dalong0]

too bad America is petrified to carry out needed death penalties!...

[@davidsavage7079]

Seems like many of these episodes are reposted as new, but were actually aired previously.

[@carolyns99]

There is more than one channel putting these up - it gets very confusing.

[@richardkranium2944]

They were. Many times over. On top of that, if you watched Law and Order you probably seen their version of the cases.