Fresh Air - Who actually left 1D first?

[@AD-tl8zv]

I think the plans for a solo career after 1D for Harry started in 2013 from the moment Jeff Azoff came in, they all knew boy bands have a short life span and Harry knew Zayn wanted to leave the band which will lead to the band's demise (Ed Sheeran said in a radio interview that Zayn left the band a few times, it just wasn't public knowledge, search on YT Ed Sheeran Zayn and you'll find the interview I'm talking about... Zayn just came back every time till he didn 't anymore in 2015). Harry was always ambitious and surrounded himself with the right people, it's enough to take a look at the circle around him, the Azoffs are a very powerful family in the entertainment industry.

[@shaziakhan9798]

Finally someone got it right. Harry is not just a happy go lucky cute guy. His biggest threat was Zayn and still is a rival. I find Harry calculated and quite illusive. Zayn is more honest but feels he can't talk about it openly.

[@AD-tl8zv]

​@@shaziakhan9798I completely forgot about this comment, but now I stand by it even more after Zayn recently said in the Call her daddy podcast that certain people didn't want to sign contracts and he knew the end of the band is coming. Even though he didn't name names, it's not hard to figure out that the only one except Zayn who had any chance of a successful solo career and who took the right steps towards it was Harry. Zayn knew that Harry had powerful people around him to help with the solo career, he also knew that boy bands only give 1 successful solo artist (look at JT, Robbie Williams etc) so his biggest chance would be leaving first, getting that huge buzz that his unexpected leaving would create and riding it all the way to the release of his solo album and it worked, great first single, number 1 song and album. And Harry would obviously always do well and he did. So both played smart. Harry was intelligent to get the right people, Zayn was intelligent to keep his copyrights, unfortunately Zayn's anxiety proved a stumbling block down the line, but hopefully now he was come out the other side and he can rebuild. Wishing both success!

[@Paradox-nt5ce]

I was crying when Harry didn’t sing his lyrics and the “i will survive” one ,after he left the stage immediately! 😟. Great analysis btw!

[@peachesandpoets]

I don't know about him distancing himself from the other boys. Obviously he and Lou were not friends (thanks Larries) but I feel like he and niall were good to the end. But of course yeah the lack of chemistry was obvious and sad 😔

[@palokalaba5120]

Any one else notice that Harry never mentions Zayns name.... Like ever...? Its always he or someone.....

[@user-pz1xd4nu8r]

Yes I noticed as well. I mean I know using pronouns instead of someone's name is pretty normal. But people usually use the name AT LEAST once. It's unsettling how Harry has never spoken Zayn's name at least once after he left. Except once during that one time in late late show but that's it.

[@Aknayirpuna]

This is not even related but this comment made me think of south Asian customs where women usually never say their husbands name like never out of respect 😝

[@zarrylegends9443]

He did once though while giving an interview for Made in the a.m. Remember? "All songs were written with Zayn in mind..with all of us in mind"

[@palokalaba5120]

@@zarrylegends9443 I have never seen that interview just a clip.... Do you have the link to it by any chance? Would love to see it.....

[@februaryone5923]

@@zarrylegends9443 and that was a slip of the tongue ( the one time he should not be exposing that the songs were for/about Zayn) which he immediately tried to cover up with " with all of us in mind"

[@tabithacastro805]

Thanks Zarry Legends -- another great analysis. *PLEASE excuse another long rant:* I have to say that I don't think that Zayn's departure and Harry's decision not to do so was due to H being "considerate" and Zayn not being so. Harry was in a VERY different position in the band verses Zayn's. Harry was the "golden child" of the band where Zayn was always the "dark horse" literally & figuratively. From Zayn having his song ideas rejected, to having signs in the audience labeling him a "terrorist", to being ignored or silenced during later interviews, to the point of becoming more internal (looking at interviews from the early 1D days through Zayn's split, you can see him evolve in very marked ways, from being shy but able to respond to questions, eloquently, to being completely silent). *"Fly me to the moon, PLEASE!"* ~ZM shortly b4 his exit from 1D I truly believe Zayn endured a lot of mental & physical anguish in 1D, as long as he did because of his deep and abiding Love for Harry. And yet, to this day, he's been made a pariah for finally removing himself from the toxicity of it all... I believe Harry's "Matilda" (a German name and a literal name for a Sunflower)is a kind of apology and acknowledgement of Zayn's experience within the toxic "family" that was 1D, for Zayn. He came out of that situation very damaged, on many levels... It's all so heartbreaking to me and I entered this Zarry world as a lover of Harry's lyrics & music -- what a blessed curse the discovery of Zarry has been...💔🖤🖤🌻💚💛💗

[@zarry25]

Ate q encontrei alguem q pensasse = a mim amei ler o q vc descreveu pra mim e a pura verdade bjs

[@nlbhaduri]

Wasn’t Jeff Azoff already sniffing around Harry in 2013? You know, we’d be mad as a fan base to expect 1D to stay “forever young” and sing to us like we are all teenagers. Come on, any artist worth their creative weight must EVOLVE! To stay the same is to stagnate. I personally am glad that they broke up because we got so much more interesting diverse music from it. I will ALWAYS love 1D but they ALL needed to go their own way. They were PUT together...and eventually that must come apart.

[@justwhatilike...234]

I was so shocked @7:15 ... Never knew Harry did that. It was so telling of the pain he was in . . . I’ve only been in the fandom for a year, but I’ve watched over a thousand videos of Harry ... both solo and in 1D. I knew he refused to sing weigh in “Little Things” and that he changed some of the lyrics at concerts for fun, but I have never seen him not finish a song . . . The guys looked as surprised as me! I have always thought Harry deserved more credit for staying with 1D, even when his heart was no longer in it ... and you can substitute Zayn for♥️ ... If Larry were real, why wouldn’t H have stayed in the band? That was what Louis wanted and you have shown that here! Very enlightening video!😽

[@zarrylegends9443]

Well, I have been in fandom for less than a year and there's always something new for me too🤭😅 Tbvh, I think we can always find something new from each theoretical Zarry video. In that show, where he didn't sing just one freaking word "my life" indicates that it meant something to him. There are a lot of things Z and H did that we might not understand, but those actions were/are meaningful for them. I wanted to also highlight boys' reactions especially Liam's. And the way H boldly/proudly did not finish without caring about reactions. Many say he was ill that day, but looking back when wasn't he ill😅 Thank you for your feedback 💖

[@hieronymousblack3364]

So true. Instead they all seemed to hold it against him and blamed him. That teasing and the nasty quips for no reason increased during the last months Zayn was there and after he left.

[@merlinadavis5456]

Zayn & Harry surely acted like lovers .. it’s a tragic love story like most usually are .. 🇯🇲🌷🇮🇳

[@peachesandpoets]

I'm a long time fan so I've seen that before but in context that is so heartbreaking. ♥

[@peachesandpoets]

@@zarrylegends9443 Liam is such a doll, his reaction was like "uh woah are you okay?"

[@hieronymousblack3364]

This is soooo good. Entertaining...laughed my ass off... then the angst hit, the sadness and everything else. Your quips and notes... love! Your insight on the fact that H was also in on leaving and doing his own thing. Yet things didn't go as planned and Z was left with no choice to go it Aline and bare the full force of his decision. And how that played out in their relationship afterwards... great catch. Info I've never seen or heard of...and everything was put together and flowed so beautifully. Didn't want it to end.

[@zarrylegends9443]

Awwww I'm blushing here☺️ You're overcomplimenting me, but thank you so much 🤗🙈 I honestly think H and Z are so different, yet their views on life are similar. Z knew when he said that they never talked will shut the media down for ages and Z is not gonna be asked no questions about H anymore. H is much more media trained, yet his body language gives him away in his (ex)bf- centered questions. But I also believe there are certain Zarry questions that are forbidden to be asked in any kind of interviews 😤

[@hieronymousblack3364]

@@zarrylegends9443 you're welcome. I actually under complimented you. You know how I can go on and on. Didn't want to be too extra.

[@hieronymousblack3364]

@@zarrylegends9443 I think so as well. It's just so odd that H is asked about the rest of the boys in regards to their relationship now and after the band. Yet when he's asked about Z, it's always about how he feels about how he left...as if they're trying to either get him to say something negative about Z. But like you said, no one asks if they've met up or are friends now.

[@supernova7848]

I remember seeing this ! This was after the interview where Harry was on voice rest and had the App on this phone that would talk for him. I don’t know how he managed not to break down. Liam helped him keep going during the performance.

[@zarrylegends9443]

@@plumcrazee9 💖💖💖 For someone coming from general public you know too much about them😁 And about the interviews, I'm pretty sure Zarry topic is blacklisted in interviews especially when it comes to emotional ones. Also they always pretended that Z and H weren't close. It worked though, people are buying to this

[@cristinleo5526]

😭😣💔💔 oh my god.. When he shout his name it rip my heart into pieces!! 😭😭 harry is in soo much pain... I just cant imagine how he can handle it. 💛💚💔

[@Paradox-nt5ce]

I saw all the 44 times Harry sang that part on Tour and he neither stretched it too long nor added that deep “i” vowel sound! 😉

[@whitedevil2305]

It’s FROZAAAAAAAAAAYYYYYYYYYYYYNNNNNNNNNN

[@GeetaThosar]

Superb and very well researched and touching video💖I feel even zayn should have waited like harry for the right moment but its always said that someone has to take risk. He took risk so all could managed to do good in their solo career and whatever Harry and Zayn decided about solo career they are still supporting each other's solo career behind the doors as their lyrics speak a lot but audience would have liked to see them supporting each other front of all. Hope to see them back together as they are cried a lot without each other💗Actually Harry started solo career and dint even inform Simon and he said i dnt feel to do that . He too behaved here like Zayn so they both were on same track. 🥰

[@incognitocommenting]

6:32 oh harry...it's always his body language that gives it away isn't it 😂

[@kimberlyaglapion9767]

Wow! This video packs a lot of info in just 10 mins. Great job!

[@HoursaDay]

Harry was really shoveling the BS with Howard Stern.

[@graziedean3206]

H left "my life" out because his life is Z 😢 💛💚🌻

[@user-qp9sj4gw1u]

Wow🤩.. most zarry only speak about harry songs and harry perspective (ZD) and hell negative nowadays abt Z. Ur videos standout in analysing zayn's side of things and very Fresh. I always wondered y ppl blame Zayn for 1d split, since they even made an album n released after he left. They could have continued even add a new member. But even after hiatus ,Zayn is getting blamed ,even now. Don't ppl have brain?😱 I think zayn didn't want the boys to split just bcoz of him,like they would all go for hiatus since Zayn can't cope up. Zayn wouldn't have liked it, he could see others r enjoying it. That's y he left alone, wanted them to 'beFour'. But ppl r biased n wanted to bash him. And the way they all said they didn't know he wanted to leave n unaware of his health. Louis drama🤨 Wat a coverup. Still Zayn is always a bigger person he did favourite Louis child pics, got back with harry🥰. More importantly u r the only zarry analysing Zayn's Rainberry, too much,fingers etc songs. I m excited to see ur videos , everytime I hear Icarus,lucazade, truth, rainber mom album songs I wonder y nobody analyse these songs, is it bcz they don't want to say anything bad abt harry? But every zarry hearing these zayn's song would definitely wonder abt it🤔but can only find the answer in ur videos.. keep going❤️🙏

[@zarrylegends9443]

Thank you sweetheart for all encouragement ❤️☀️ I feel like IF definitely didn't get the recognition it deserved. Zayn is very talented, but the way he views how his messages are needed to be conveyed is different from other artists. Today he has released unofficially his 24 minute rap consisting of 5 tracks for sure. I have always waited for him to rap since I heard Pillowtalk with Lil Wayne. So I thought maybe by these interpretations I would contribute a bit. Regarding 1D, I am not a directioner, nor have ever been. So my opinion is unbiased and objective I believe. I think Z and H have both always wanted to leave and be free. Look at Harry now, look what of a free soul he is, how he can self express himself. In my opinion, this craving of Zarry to have a solo career was one of the major elements that united them in a way that others could not relate. But Z was more vocal about his desires, H was more low-key, and he had this inner gratitude to the management as well as fans, so he just could never do the way Z did. Both did right, I'm sure although H was hurt at the time, he knows now it was right for Z to leave. Some people say if Z would have stayed, 1D would have lasted longer, because Z presence would make H be there. But I believe H would still have pushed again for hiatus and they would have still gone a break with the only difference , with 5 of them. Throughout many following İnterviews it's undeniable that the other lads didn't want it to end. Louis said "that's what Harry wanted" So, it's for you to decide what triggered the band to fall apart😌👀 I also think whatever happens, these two won't stop writing about each other because their love is in their art and it doesn't go beyond that..

[@user-qp9sj4gw1u]

@@zarrylegends9443I do like other boys, I just didn't like the heat Z had to go through while Harry had none even though he did break after. Anyway I m excited for ur analysis on #yellowmetal❤️. twitter is on fire today. ZD bashed Z in her website Harry's lover Z never speaks with a pic of Zayn with his hands covering his mouth which is unfair when she refuses to analyse IF ,NIL. It baffled me since he keeps speaking in all his songs calamity,rainb,toomuch, truth. Zayn's rap resonated my feelings" you know I know I conversation with u in so many ways. U r so dumb so I will speak like I have never spoken before and u will hear me" I am so happy he is watching everything n his fans feelings as well and ur channel does help n satisfy analysing his lyrics.. Thanks for ur reply. I m looking forward to ur #yellowmetal🧐🔥 Zayn got pissed off with everyone saying he never speaks and poured all his thoughts on it and said take it🤣🔥🔥🔥

[@nedamn8119]

He said he 'd survive but look at him he was destroyed 🥺💚💛

[@rupzierupz]

7:02 heartbreaking 😭

[@glamgalvogue9741]

Zayn is mostly quiet through different interviews,like he is left out on purpose 🥺🥺🥺🥺

[@anthurium3010]

Looks like it to me… I guess this part has been planned by their management and had directed the interviewer who n who’s not to be interviewed. There were a few interviews that Zayn was silenced. I can imagine how Zayn felt during those times. And there’s one interview, Harry told the interviewer to let Zayn speak and there were other times when Harry acknowledged Zayn’s responses.

[@peachesandpoets]

Love your channel!

[@zarrylegends9443]

Your love keeps me going 🔥

[@whitedevil2305]

Meee toooo

[@inamartina9985]

U have the best zarry video

[@rushnishyama]

It's a shame that US has sold only 14k albums , I am not supporting any US artist here on. Zayn is a British artist and we Brits value him. He will.be globally recognized. I dont even understand how G is so much more than the beautiful music Z produces. Their child gets more recognition for goodness sake and Z hardly speaks about her. I am fathomed by the racism and biased attitudes over in US. He is talented beyond words, these sorry ass people can stream some basic music like skin 69m and Zayn cant even get 20m. Thanks how bad it is and that 20M too is global listeners. Sorry about my rant. Just feel he is more deserving. And about Zarry, totally think that so much has happened it feels like their public reconciliation would far away. And Zayn claiming he never really spoke to H after he cheated around 2018 on Z makes it even harder. ( some one wrote about it)

[@zarry25]

Ate encontrei 1 video q pensa de harry o q eu penso adorei

[@DernLud]

Great video. 💚💛💙🌻

[@zarrylegends9443]

Thank you ♥️

[@liftintrophy]

please analyzing nobody is listening, i love your mind!!

[@zarrylegends9443]

Sure I will, but first I need to finish IF and FL🤭😂🤦✅

[@liftintrophy]

@@zarrylegends9443 okayyy i'll wait

[@teiaalexander7131]

💛💚💛💚💛

[@tracysanders8113]

He sang I will survive when Louis broke up with Elinore.

[@zarrylegends9443]

Sure he did

[@muppididivija4876]

🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@harryspeace6316]

It's always Harry who ends up suffering the most...this is so sad for me

[@zarrylegends9443]

Let's not victimize either of them. They both are in this together and share the suffer

[@harryspeace6316]

@@zarrylegends9443 its not good to romanticize either and it's not victimization since zayn besides tattoing women on the body has children with them but i believe they'll be together too

[@zarrylegends9443]

@@harryspeace6316 watch Harry tattoo O on his body😒😅 I guess at this point romanticising them is also something we should not do anymore but I love your positive take on Zarry as end game💗

[@harryspeace6316]

@@zarrylegends9443 i'm honestly not being positive, it's somenthing i really feel but i don't unsdestand a lot zayn's attitudes

[@zarrylegends9443]

@@harryspeace6316 in the end, it's H that understands him the most and we should let things be so. I believe his actions based on reasons we don't know about so that's why I'm taken aback in criticizing him or H these days. (which I will still do in my new vid)

[@peachesandpoets]

What performance was 7:11?

[@zarrylegends9443]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/fqvRg3mMjaZ3grM