SIGMA 24-70 f2.8 II REVIEW | DON’T BUY the Sony 24-70 f2.8 GM II Unless…

This video is brought to you by Squarespace. I've been using Squarespace for over 10 years now and I think you should give it a try as well. Get your 14 day trial at HTTP://squarespace.com/froknowsphoto If you decide it's for you, use the code FroKnowsPhoto at checkout to get 10% off your first order.
FROPACK4 is HERE with 14 all-new custom Lightroom presets!!! Check it out
froknowsphoto.com/fropack4/ (40% OFF)
This is a REVIEW of the Sigma 24-70 2.8 DG DN II Lens for Sony E Mount Cameras. I spend a lot of time comparing it Sony's 24-70 2.8 GM II and pose the question....should you not buy the Sony and go with the Sigma? I answer that exact question in this video.
Listen to RAWtalk, the FroKnowsPhoto Podcast wherever you listen to your podcasts. Or head on over to froknowsphoto.com/podcast
This video was filmed with the Canon EOS R5 and RF Canon Lenses Canon.us/r5fro
Order a Bernie Photo Book right here www.berniephotobook.com/buy
Download MyGearVault, it's FREE and the best way to keep track of all your camera gear, receipts, prices paid, date purchased and more mygearvault.com/#download
Get a FREE Guide To Capturing Motion In Low Light Situations froknowsphoto.com/ (look for the orange box)
Want to send us gifts, swag, letters...here's our P.O. BOX
PO Box 3715 Philadelphia, PA 19125
USE CODE FroKnowsPhoto at squarespace.com/froknowsphoto to get your 14 day FREE Trial.
Gear I USE
I SHOOT RAW T-Shirts store.froknowsphoto.com/
I support Allen's Camera a mom-and-pop Camera store that's been around since 1977. allenscamera.com/fro
Follow me
►KZbin: bit.ly/frotube
►Facebook: / froknowsphoto
►Instagram: / jaredpolin
Please help us continue to make FREE content
by purchasing one or all of the FroKnowsPhoto
Educational guides. To check out previews of
each guide click here.
►froknowsphoto.com/guides
#FroKnowsPhoto #JaredPolin #REVIEW

[@froknowsphoto]

which one are you buying and why???

[@daandy952]

got a sigma 28-70 2.8, loving it

[@wglee010]

none because i dont have a camera :(

[@joshlikestosmile]

Sigma 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

[@renestaempfli1071]

I still have the old 24-70GM, but hardly use it anymore on the A1 and A9III. Instead, I use the Tamron 35-150, as I found this a more versatile zoom range for concerts and indoor sports.Yes, the 15fps limit is a bit of a bummer. So my trade off is using 1 camera or 2 cameras on an event. Most of the time, I opt for one. If SONY would offer a 35-150, f/ 2-2.8, I would get it without hesitation.

[@limagepicture9023]

Waiting for the Sony GM 24-70mm f2 😉

[@BBP0227]

No sniff test!!!!!! No wind test!!!!! Without these tests I don’t think I can believe this review!!!!

[@joshuamontgomery0]

Clearly a biased sponsored ad

[@tomasmorales814]

he’s compromised !!

[@jimpanse3089]

What would sniffing it tell you? 😂 is that a fetish thing

[@5minutefilms12]

No water proof test either! I like to shoot while I'm swimming!

[@JesusChristSaves.]

​@@jimpanse3089 Hes the Weirdo that does it every review lol

[@JohnCocozza]

Thanks for the video Jared. I bought the version 1 off your recommendation and still using it today for jobs. It is my work horse lens ranging from portraits, events, landscapes and even in video production. Always great to save some money.

[@thesharpercoder]

Cool thumbnails! I love the wide angle distortion from the “camera in your face” perspective. 💯

[@RealThore]

i don't need it...i don't need it. But I want it On a serious note: I use the Sigma 24-70 version 1 as a professional concert photographer and haven't had any issues that would give me a reason to upgrade. It's a fantastic lens and because I'm not using a body with more than 15fps (though I'd love to use the a9iii) I don't see a reason to upgrade

[@bluwasabi7635]

I just got one very recently. It seems fine to me, but since you've used it more do you think that the auto focus improvement of the 2nd version would be worth buying another lens for? Also 10% lighter bla bla bla whatever

[@RealThore]

@@bluwasabi7635 weight difference is negligible. I use 2 A7iv with battery grip, so I don’t really care, if it’s an always on lens on something like the A7c I’d think about the GM2 (but as a hobbyist spending about double the money doesn’t make a lot of sense tbh). Can’t say anything bad about the AF on the Art v1, there may have been some out of focus shots but that could’ve been the camera as well. Currently the Art v2 is just $200 more than the v1 and I’d spend that money on a lighter and more modern lens, when the price goes down for v1 (or if buying used is an option, I got mine used) I’d recommend v1 more likely over v2. The only issue from the v1 I know is the dust accumulation under the front glass. Sigma says they have fixed it but I don’t know about that for sure

[@dnadarsh]

Lens lock is something I use all the time. Over the year, the lens sags more and more,e specially in event photography setting where you the camera handing off the strap and your movement makes this sag I've noticed on my copy. It might be a different expericen for someone else's usecase but happy they kept it. Great video as always Fro! 🙌

[@timotmon]

Love those baseball photos.. that font on the Philly jersey is fire.

[@JimEmbury]

Good review Jared. Thank you

[@thomassager1755]

Every time I prepare for a little concert photography, I go thru your low light guide again. Sooo helpful to have some lead clues in mind when I'm in the small concert venues with sub-optimal lighting.

[@sottosopra4769]

where can I find that low lights for concerts?

[@sabya11377]

True. Noone would comeback to query about the lens used when pictures are as similar as Sony GM OSS II

[@stevenwaldstein2249]

Thanks for the video. I bought the Sony GM II. I bought it two years ago when it came out to replace my original GM version. The two year earlier availability was key even with its elevated price. Also used to buying Canon L glass even though I’m not a working pro. Have not regretted a single GM or GM II purchase. I prefer to buy once and try to buy the best. Take care.

[@MikeMena]

I can see that lock switch helping a lot for studio portraiture. I hate double checking I’m at correct focal length!

[@_connor935]

I absolutely NEED that lock switch on my SIGMA 24-70 f2.8 I. I carry my cam most of the time on a clip on my backpack with the lens facing down. Without that lock switch i'd be having the lens in my way 24/7

[@dougmorato]

Very, very honest review. Would love to see a bit more on video side as well.

[@eyecreatereality226]

That 24mm portrait was nice

[@MartinB0]

Jared, thank you for review. As owner A7R IVa and 1st gen of Sigma 24-70 I was curious about version 2. Looks fine, is lighter, has aperture ring and lock. But I will stick with my 1st generation because none of improvements are interesting for me :)

[@joshmaldonado6614]

Jared, Do you have a review of the Sony 24-50 f2.8? I have an a7cii and have that lens in order just to keep things small. Just would like you take on that lens. Thanks!

[@Studioakbar]

thank u your content is best and so help full for me thanks bro

[@landonhammett]

Jared can you get your hands on the new Tamron 28-75 for Nikon to review?

[@ItsPinecone_911]

Both lens looks good and the Sigma would probably be my pick out of these 2 due to price and me being a hobbist. Question about FroPack4. Will those eye and skin adaptive presets work in LR Mobile or is it for desktop/laptops only? I do all my editting on my Samsung S23 Ultra at the moment sicne I dont have a computer.

[@mike_s_media]

Shooting on the Alpha 1 I'm going with the Sony GM II all day because I'm not giving up the capabilities of the a1 in video or photo to save $1k. That being said, I started with the version 1 Sigma and still have it in the case as it's a great lens but where I'm at now there's no need to sacrifice purpose use features to save that little in the long run.

[@duarantes2077]

Your line of reasoning makes perfect sense. Excellent video, man.

[@smoke362]

Nice review

[@lowtahcheng]

Hi jared, did you happen to compare the distortion between sony vs sigma at 24mm?

[@Mikeguardiani]

For the slot on the hood, can you just buy the Sony hood and put it on the Sigma or won't it fit?

[@riparianlife97701]

My main work lens is the Sony 24-70 GM2. It's nearly magic into the sun, and my biggest moneymaker is sunset portraits on the beach.

[@asmashingwayita9200]

Gerald Undone showed a better performance for the new sigma during a flair test!

[@blessedmamba]

Is there a video about the difference between this particular lens of Sigma V1 vs the V2? thanks!

[@RaaschMedia]

Does this Vii feel better on camera? I have the version one and it feel so front heavy and bulky. Wondering if this one is more “centered.” Thanks

[@TheArtofKAS]

I think one of the better parts of the video is Jared's entire portrait discussion. Both of these seem like absolute beasts when it comes to versatility and to me that is a strong selling point on both sides. Great review as usual 👌🏾

[@philipgilligan_art]

Thanks Fro, as a non professional i was unsure which to get, 24-105, 20-70, gm ii 24-70 or this sigma I don’t need speed just the ultimate image quality……. Which does great or great enough to sell a print from please Sir?…… shooting on an a7iv (convert from fuji last week) mostly landscapes wide open townscapes, few portraits plus a little video but rarely video

[@kuang01]

i agree, yes, that brand name, top of the line, is a must for the client. coz they don’t know and they want to be sure. save your time for the debate and explanation. just like you are in a suit.

[@iroggi]

Good review, but what about color? Sigma lenses I've used in a past seemed a bit greenish compared to Sony.. I already have some Sony lenses and "linear manual focus" on new GM II series is a real benefit for video shooting.

[@olaniyionabanjo6574]

Between Tamron 24-70mm G2 VC and Sigma Art 24-70mm, which would you recommend?.

[@ItzSlushie]

As long as they address the dust issue with the version one I’ll be happy

[@rgreeneish]

I bought of them and they were both full of dirt. Returned them.

[@SaminHangzhou]

Not a dig, genuinely curious why you shot that commentator at 1/800 with an ISO of 1600? Was it just a heat of the moment thing and didn’t bring the shutter down? Or a reason to it?

[@worldofwiz]

i like a lot of the 24mm shots

[@DirectorDavoPaul]

The lock on the Sig ll is actually useful, I walk 100 yards or so a few times a day on family shoots and it definitely slides out if it's not locked. Useful in the real world.

[@BootStrapTurnerVideography]

Already own the 24-70 f2.8 "mark 1" Sigma lens. While super compelling, likely will keep rocking the original as the cost difference won't yield a significant image difference. That and the resale in the used market has likely dropped with the new lens offering being the desirable one.

[@etiennededurocher]

Now the question is... what to choose between the Sony I and the Sigma II?

[@puckhead1221]

If I shot high FPS with the A9 or A1 you get the GM all day, but if you dont then you might want to consider the Sigma Art. If you use it all the time then maybe get the GM too since its lighter and slightly better AF.

[@kevinl8791]

Question for videographers, which one would you choose, Sony 24-105 f4 OSS vs new sigma 24-70 art mark 2 f2.8? btw I’m using a Sony zv-e1, thanks!! 🙌

[@CybrSlydr]

I didn't know there was a new version coming out! I got the original based on Fros review and love it.

[@rgreeneish]

lets hope they can keep the dust out of it. I bought and returned 2 of the V1 lenses for dust issues.

[@mr.kalakaarmm7716]

bro i love you hair style ❤

[@kostasrestas]

what about the dust resistance ???? At Sigma 24 70 no1 was very easy to dust dots to came inside the glass, like ridiculous easy. Like , one walk at the park was enough..

[@MarbooJr]

I'm just here to find out if its a dust collector like its predecessor

[@Allen-Trav]

I am a Canon "lifer". But these quality Sigma e-mount lenses have me thinking it may be time to pick up an A7 iv to test the Sony waters and the huge e-mount lens ecosystem. Loved the GOT references. Ha! Ha!

[@iGeng]

Does it lens creep on a backpack clip?

[@COLEA001]

I photograph weddings and I was hoping Sigma would have an answer to the v2 Gmaster. I’m a little disappointed that the weight is almost similar.

[@ElMundoDuro]

I wonder if this lens focuses faster and better on Sigmas own native L mount than on 3rd party Sony bodies.

[@jasonzakszewski3718]

Always the second place I run for a new lens review. I sold my version one last year and went to a 35mm gm and kinda miss a mid range zoom. Still have to decide if I want this or go with the big chonky boy Tamron 35-150.

[@yessum6477]

If you don’t shoot sports consistently then the 24-70 would be the best option imo

[@Xirpzy]

A 24-70 is a more versatile run n gun lens. I have a 28-70mm lens and it pretty much always stays on my camera unless I want the most background compression or shoot wildlife.

[@Timmyfox]

Rather curious how this compares to the Tamron 28-75 G2

[@Reportageandart]

Unless you’re shooting major league sports professionally or anything that needs 30+ frames per second then sigma all the way.

[@poikatiikeri]

wish they had made the previous size but f2

[@BryanMiraflor]

Jared, my Sony 24-70mm GM2 does lens creep. I wish it had a locking mechanism.

[@enjoygary]

Has it always done that?

[@TheERKAER]

Jared let's test GFX 100 II with 500mm F5.6 :D Can't wait till moment when u gonna do this :)

[@oslerelizondo5342]

Need a tamron 17-70 review

[@kaszrack2859]

Will there be a sigma 70 - 200 f2.8 2? I'm currently looking for that kind of zoom if there is one to come out I may hold off until it arrives.

[@CrazMonkey1]

Prob not anytime soon, and by that I mean a couple years, as the 70-200 f2.8 sigma for Sony came out in December 2023

[@pattaraj]

off the topic, i love you presets look great

[@kwomack5399]

I got the Sony 24-70 GM2 because I had tons of events to shoot this month. This Sigma is not expected until May 31 and is too late for graduations and other end of school year activities.

[@PaulRadaker]

I literally just purchased the original Sigma 24-70mm f/2.8 DG DN Art, and the return window closed a few days ago. Ugh

[@yessum6477]

So photography wise sigma and Sony are the exact same, now time to go to Jared undone and view his review for the video front which will make my ultimate decision

[@thefrenchexpedition]

do you miss not having 85mm? I wish they would make a 24-85mm

[@brookspeacock5302]

Tamron's 28-75mm f2.8 version II! For $350 less.....bam!

[@David_Quinn_Photography]

If I was looking for a 24-70 on Sony A I'd be all over that v1 if it went on sale.

[@poikatiikeri]

i don’t think 24-70 2.8 is a starter lens 😂 it’s still expensive and i’d say it’s more of a do it all pro lens

[@simonmaduxx6777]

definitely not a starter lens, whoever says that is high as a kite.

[@ThePyroBass]

I have the 2470GM2 because it was in the set with the A7R5. Recently got myself a Tamron 35-150 and asking myself “will I really be using the GM2 any time again?” So thinking about selling it while it still has warranty. I also have the 12-24 2.8 for wide angle situations. So I think I can live with the 24-35 gap if I sell the 2470GM2… 10fps is max for the A7R5 anyway If I later on discover I need a 2470 I can still buy the sigma and still have saved about 600-700€

[@hendrixg]

Do you ever get tired of making lens reviews and wish you could follow your dreams to become a dancer?

[@jwate]

I used Sigma Gen 1 24-70 for a few years. Later I received a gift of the 24-70 GM ii and the stabilization for video is far superior.

[@earthtoandy_]

These lenses do not have optical stabilization though, so not sure why they would be different.

[@ChrisJohnson-wl2kg]

@@earthtoandy_because Sony only supports standard stabilization for 3rd party lenses not the extra stabilization option.

[@SJtoday52]

When does this release? I just ordered the 35mm 1.4 GM and I’m thinking about canceling it for this sigma version 2

[@GuitarRJP]

May 31

[@SJtoday52]

@@GuitarRJP you’re amazing. Thank you for your response. I’ll keep the 35mm. Maybe get the sigma next month.

[@ismailcetin383]

If you compare it with the Sony 20-70mm F4 which is the same price- which one would you recommend?

[@AleksaKiaTech]

sigma for sure, 2.8 aperture is game changer

[@shem44]

For video work, no focus breathing compensation and no linear focusing is a no go.

[@sottosopra4769]

this lens has linear focus

[@mohamedsahi9621]

Hello, if you have a Lens Sony 24-105 F4 do you buy this New sigma's Lens?

[@michaelschuhmann682]

You didn't talk about vignetting at 24mm. That is usually an issue with generic lenses. Thanks.

[@VantaBlackhole]

Non issue. Most of the companies are leaving it to lens correction software.

[@Britton0932]

BROOOOOOOOOKLYN!!! Great Preset!

[@BryanMiraflor]

i wish manufacturers stopped making lenses that suck in dust. i liked the Sony 24-70 GM 1st Gen lens cause it was internal zooming instead of telescoping zoom.

[@jonhill9918]

No sniff test? No wind test? How do I truly know if I should buy this lens without those tests?

[@froknowsphoto]

Oh man. How did I forget that

[@Beezzzzy_]

If this lens had 30fps I'd already pre order it. As a sports photographer I have to go with the Sony GM II which sucks.

[@warpspeed9877]

I can have the 24-70/2.8 and 70-200/2.8 from Sigma for the price of Sony's 24-70/2.8. I never use 30fps. It's a no brainer.

[@Madtography]

I'm waiting for a 20-75mm f2-3.5 sth...

[@buzzj89]

No wind tunnel test?!?

[@Octa111]

How am i going to know if this is a solid lens without a Wind Tunnel/Sniff Test !!!! 😊

[@078gregory]

When Sigma will release the same lense for Nikon Z mount...

[@phil_aesthetics]

freakin canon man lets gooo we need sigma rf

[@JasonTaylor-po5xc]

I got the first version of the Sigma 28-70 2.8 - for $899 - apparently $100 off. Now I know why. The guy at the shop didn't tell me the version 2 was out. Looks like the version two is going for about $1200. Either one would be fine so why not save a few pennies. I really like your distinction regarding pros vs hobbyist. Hobbyists should certainly go for the Sigma lens since the differences are _so_ minor. Working _pro_ - sure, go for the Sony if your budget can afford it.

[@kevenspargo6829]

There’s still only one version of the Sigma 28-70. (28 on the wide end, not 24.)

[@JasonTaylor-po5xc]

@@kevenspargo6829 Yeah, I have the 28-70 - I didn't realize there was a 24-70.

[@jordanmitchell1433]

11:07 Except for the Tamron 150-500 ;)

[@SPDTDL]

The version I had huge dust issues, is this fixed?

[@briandoyal7338]

Later production version 1 lenses from Sigma seemed to be fixed. Hopefully this one is not affected.

[@adamdrakestudio]

Found the same.

[@RealThore]

@@briandoyal7338 I got my replacement from Amazon in mid/late 2022 and still have issues with dust. Nothing visible in photos, but not great as well

[@MyOwnUTube1]

Im in a spot to buy them bith new with only a $150 price difference. It will be going on a sony a7c ii Does anyone else have some more opinions between these 2

[@_oneclickaway_9862]

@12:01 The kKkid. THE KID

[@mrbalbastv]

Does the fropack work on lr mobile?

[@Separade]

He literally shows it half of the time on a mobile phone. Please use the thing sitting on your neck.

[@MrCoolAttitude]

Nikon pls let Sigma back on the lens route for Z cameras.

[@DiogoReis]

The problem with the sigma for me is the zoom ring, I can't deal with the zoom rotating to the opposite side... It's a muscle memory thing that keeps me back from buying the sigma...

[@kaiyicool7452]

Are you shooting with pre production camera hmmm why u mentioned that u shoot with rf lenses instead of r5?

[@LetiB76]

Not dropping any money on any new lenses like these , they are Boring ! … not you Jared , the lens manufacturers keep remaking the same lens with slight variations. Really wish there it would have been innovative such as 20- 70mm f2 . Next thing you know , Sony will drop the hammer with an f2 standard zoom . In either case it would have to compete with the Tamron 35-150 f2/2.8 , now that was innovation !!

[@Mowikan]

The more lens test I watch the more the question rises: are there any bad lenses out there?

[@orendo]

That Star of David made me smile. Thanks, Jared.

[@Soso_mtb]

Sony 24-50 or Sigma 24-70 ?

[@The-Tall-Photographer]

The bit were you says ours don’t suck. There are some ok presets out there but most ruin photos.

[@ridley793]

Hi Jared, there a rumour that Canon may be looking at a monthly AI subscription for there new cameras. Have you heard any rumours coming out of Canon about this?

[@carlennis9413]

I like Sigma lenses but they are simply not as good as the GM lenses in my opinion, it could have been the copies I have had but I wouldnt buy them again unless they come out with something I want that Sony dont have. I do have the Sony GM ii and love it.