From a Concerned Neighbor to a Sugar Mama

It’s a “Judge Mathis” throwback from 2019!
The plaintiff claims the defendant robbed her three times. She says some of her neighbors even identified the defendant as the thief, so she’s suing for stolen and damaged property. The defendant argues he never robbed the plaintiff. He says other neighbors started harassing him, including one who threatened him at gunpoint. He’s countersuing for emotional distress.
Now, the plaintiff is back for another case. But this time, she’s the defendant.
The plaintiff and defendant had a fling together even though the defendant is 20 years older. They eventually moved in together. He gave her his credit card to buy items for their home, but he claims she went on a shopping spree instead. He’s suing for a rental deposit, credit card charges, and harassment. The defendant claims the plaintiff is a liar. She’s countersuing for breach of contract and emotional distress.

[@tamikadillard2108]

This kid didn't stand a chance. He already judged him before he had a chance to speak.

[@MrLenroc82]

This is why my Father and Mother always made a point about appearance. People will judge you even though they shouldn't. But you can control that perception through appearance

[@shaybuttacream5553]

@@MrLenroc82yeah I get that appearance is important but this young man had on shirt, tie, slacks and his hair is what they wearing it’s not dreading he said it like his hair was a mess! He had already judge just because he said he smoke weed.

[@timothyjacob6381]

Birds of a feather often flock together. You’re probably on the porch smoking weed all day as well. 🙄

[@nettricegaskins1871]

It wasn't his appearance that was the problem. It was his demeanor. His bad attitude and how he addressed the judge. He did that to himself.

[@DelphineBaxter]

His presentation messed him up

[@rena24k71]

The defendant didn’t say anything disrespectful. Judge Mathis 100% profiled him.

[@dawnlee866]

I agree

[@marleonetti7]

to me the second case proved that this woman also lied in the first case . she got her nephew to pull a gun on the plaintiff and the plaintiff simply said what he thought the gun brandishing nephew wanted to hear . this woman should have lost BOTH cases .

[@DelphineBaxter]

He presented himself wrong telling the judge I smoke weed and his demeanor be for real u sound stupid

[@DelphineBaxter]

He profiled himself

[@girlfriennn3645]

He definitely was disrespectful with certain choice of words. He has no professionalism but I don't think it is his fault. That's how he grew up. I feel like it was easy to blame this robbery on the young man because he doesn't speak well. He also doesn't have much confidence or decorum which makes it easy to assume that he is a part of the robberies.

[@ninamarley5945]

That’s fucked up. He judged him off the back.For someone who “uplifts the youth” he really put him down.

[@mrs.deeparker6934]

Yes the judge was wrong ....I believe she is a lier she like young guys this 2 time on the show...

[@shawndagaines971]

Totally agreed

[@crownjewels6370]

As someone who says that they want to see the youth do well and do something with their lives he definitely put this young man down. It sounded like the young man was saying how he is getting his GED while also helping someone with a landscaping business and watching his sick dad. He gave that young man no chances to explain anything and it was frustrating to watch. I hope he did not send that young man down a path that was basically spoken over his life and I hope that young man continues to better his life.

[@earnestcharles9513]

Dude disrespected himself.

[@wendelladams3010]

Judge definitely surprised me on this one definitely wasn’t cool

[@TexasBorn_TexasRaised]

Mathis pre-judged that young man. So many young men in prison today for that very reason.

[@marysimmons3481]

He didn’t pre-judge him. That boy was standing there high as a kite and he has a daddy that could have been in the courtroom with him let him live you and we’ll see who’s telling the truth. I guarantee you breaking your house to testify. He said that he been there longer than that, and they never had no break-ins, only talk about break-ins that’s what he testified to…. Man need help.

[@TexasBorn_TexasRaised]

@@marysimmons3481 Do you mind typing that in English?

[@bernicebrown5918]

She dated a jail bird but act like she had class 😒 poor kid in the first case she probably lied on him.

[@HB76558]

Second case she is a suga momma paying for dingaling.

[@WifeyType19841]

​@@HB76558😆 🤣 😂

[@ManifestedMELANIN]

I'm pissed off

[@solomonkush5687]

Thats how them old woman be in the first case old boy probaly was not her nephew he probaly was her young side dude

[@crownlethal2k187]

😊😂😂

[@amma2x310]

That 2nd case portrayed her in a whole new light

[@Craftyvisionswecreate]

JM calm down this lady has no evidence he broke into her house. You ain’t gone say nothing about him pulling up pointing a gun. If he was guilty he’d be in jail.

[@marleonetti7]

yup , the nephew was committing a felony by brandishing a gun on someone with the intention of intimidation .

[@cushe83]

If you don’t think the neighborhood don’t know who broke into who house then you don’t know anything about these situations

[@lynchsc420]

There was also no evidence he pointed a gun either. However as you know in America they can go off of witness statements. and since this isnt criminal court much of it goes on the judge’s discretion. Most of these cases there is no physical evidence

[@timothyjacob6381]

No surprise you’d believe “Ray Ray” because you and the likes of you gravity towards those “types” and often pop out of wedlock “those types.” 🙄

[@tomswill9189]

Facts I said the same thing. This shit was a turn off. Wow really JM

[@sweetcee117]

Judge was definitely aggressive towards the young man. He was judged from the beginning, and that wasn't right. There was no evidence that he was behind the robberies. Why didn't the man who told the woman weren't there or write a statement if he saw everything

[@jamesstewart522]

She stated the neighbor was best friends with the defendants dad. He may not have wanted to put himself in that situation. It happens all the time unfortunately.

[@dawnlee866]

@@jamesstewart522So why say anything?? People irk me with that, I saw so & so or so & so said but don’t tell them I said it😂😂😂

[@marleonetti7]

to me the second case proved that this woman also lied in the first case . she got her nephew to pull a gun on the plaintiff and the plaintiff simply said what he thought the gun brandishing nephew wanted to hear . this woman should have lost BOTH cases .

[@MrLenroc82]

In real life, you cannot control a person's mind but can control their perception of you through appearance.

[@teelove2564]

Rightttt!!! ❤❤❤

[@dknohoward6933]

THIS LADY AIN'T 💩 Her incarcerated ex probably broke into her house in the other case! Judge Mathias you got yo head bumped by this trick 👌🏽

[@dknohoward6933]

Lol 😂 OK Judge Mathias ✋🏿 My apologies! You figured the lying rat out😁 You are now again my favorite TV Judge 😎

[@crownlethal2k187]

😂😂😂

[@quequekhari]

I honestly feel like the defendant in the first case was telling the truth

[@charishopwood5261]

Me too

[@angiec13]

@@charishopwood5261 Me three...If he's honest about smoking then why lie about stealing ?? cm'on Judge Mathis

[@dawnlee866]

Me too

[@dawnlee866]

She got her karma

[@user-wj6qe6ed6j]

Me three

[@islandgirll2650]

MATHIS WANTS A 20 something year old to know about court ethics. The young man wasn’t being rude at all. Since when her-say is admissible in court with no direct evidence?? Judge Mathis was so mean in this case.

[@lmarie711]

Probably because it's arbitration and not actual court. Pretty much is at the "judge's" discretion. He just has to believe it's likely, plus the show probably pays the judgment.

[@nettricegaskins1871]

Oh, he most definitely was being disrespectful to the judge. His mannerisms, demeanor and language was offensive, esp. to a court judge.

[@leavitrisethomas5254]

I believe it had a lot to do with the producers

[@mikeprice8307]

So in the later episode she was going with a 20 year old getting her back blown out admittedly 😂

[@beb5407]

​@leavitrisethomas5254 he had no court respect and he's telling the judge what to do. Plus he was lying that's why JM was on to him

[@deejai1173]

Why is she leaning into the mic 🎤 like Bob Barker asked her to make a bid!? 😂

[@letitiacooper98]

Lol yo right tho I bid 100$ 😂JM❤❤❤❤

[@lindatoombs3319]

She wanna buy a vowel😅

[@Mr_Porter]

😂 I swear I be hollering whenever I see litigants doing that. This is not a rally or a council meeting, that mic is just a prop. It came with the stand 😆

[@shundalee5669]

😂😂😂

[@PrincessPearl65]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@HISTORYunfolded304]

As a Blk Man I feel disappointed that a Blk judge would criticize a younger 20yr old kid about his Hair(while dressed accordingly)when JM basically has the exact hair style. We’ve spent years trying to be excepted for our Texture of hair

[@nannynewsviews542]

Yes that comment upset me the most, I did a double take.... like what is wrong with his hair? He was dress nice too, he did need better posture, and possibly some guidance on his GED and future.

[@angelabrown5539]

EXACTLY. When he AND his son have the same hairstyle on his new show, that is mot worth watching. Instead of encouraging him, he just ripped him to pieces and threw him out like a nobody. He was so unfair to that young man.

[@dawnlee866]

I’m still trying to figure out what was wrong with his hair??

[@josecartersr.670]

1st case JM profiled that young man as bad as the police do too many times to young men like him and my sons. Not cool.

[@dawnlee866]

@@josecartersr.670 yes he was rude to that young man. JM must’ve been in a bad mood that day👎🏽

[@sybilwhite1259]

I never thought Judge Mathis would be so impatient with this young man Judge Mathis didn't even let the young man explain his side of the story. Shame on the plaintiffs and the Judge

[@Ginaaaa87]

Went from neighborhood watcher to suga mama 😂😂

[@thickmadam4709]

They are a fool for this one! 🤣🤣🤣

[@mikeprice8307]

How she used his card and he was paying the 60%?

[@Only1RonA]

😅😅

[@kizzyrock]

Ladies... please STOP moving men in with your daughters... or sons who you do not KNOW!!!!

[@dylanmh31612]

Especially someone young enough to be your son

[@mikeprice8307]

They can't help it its their nature. Juvies, pookies & tyrones 😂

[@jenn_x.]

What really got me was that they later all moved to a 1-bedroom apartment. Wth?

[@kizzyrock]

@@jenn_x. Oh wow!! I missed that part! Just wow!!!

[@ak24553]

@@jenn_x.I know!!! I thought I was the only one that noticed that. She have lost her mind!

[@melwilliams1252]

Here we are JM all ready passing judgment on this young man...he is so quick to rip a young black man. He can't wait to try and embarrass him!

[@9lkkjjiujjiuuu]

💯 right he won't do that to a white guy

[@gt43025]

@@9lkkjjiujjiuuuYes, he has

[@MeechMedia]

@@9lkkjjiujjiuuudo y'all watch this show!? He does that to everybody lol guess he was in a bad mood today

[@buttalove5437]

I’ve been trying to tell these folks! Mathis is ridiculous when it comes to black males smmfh

[@9lkkjjiujjiuuu]

@@buttalove5437 ok I'm glad I'm not the only one that sees through him

[@Criminal.Lawyer.2024]

In the first episode Marquette had just bought a house that was being burglarized. In the second episode she is living in an apartment she shared with a guy who is in prison and then another guy who she claims was beating her. So, she went from "protecting the neighborhood from crime" to polluting the neighborhood with criminals.

[@youmakemelaugh1797]

Yes she threw me for a loop real quick🥴

[@jayjackson8607]

Plus she put her nephew in a situation that would have caused him to go to prison. Over her home being burglarized. They also never said where the photo came from or showed the photo to verify if it was the defendant

[@marleonetti7]

because she was lying the whole time . she was probably squatting in the house and got evicted for not paying the rent and then had to find an apartment . she is a scammer that dates boys who are not even old enough to go into a bar . she and her family are weirdos .

[@kiki4507]

Karma

[@AhrazYasharahla]

😂

[@Beat__The__Odds]

If you’re reading this, you got this… DON’T GIVE UP 🌹🖤

[@simmonsblendina]

Trying FAITH ALWAYS TESTED 🙏🏿

[@makaylaturner6510]

Thanks for the encouragement🫶🏽

[@user-dd8zw3xf7m]

Perfect

[@Godchild50]

Amen thank u same to u

[@drea6385]

Thanks!!

[@mygarfield11]

This women said she owned a home and now moving into an apartment. What happened her house...JM prejudged the young man and believed this woman who clearly doesn't make good decisions

[@maxinecox850]

Thought the same thing! Hum..

[@pumsirel]

I thought the same thing, like what happened to the house

[@NaeLashay-yp3eg]

A one bedroom apartment at that

[@urluvizmyluv1999]

Many ppl lost their home due to foreclosure when the housing market went bust.

[@mrflynn01]

They kept breaking in her home, why would she stay???

[@TheQueenrevolution]

JM was unfair. Ppl need to go to real court.

[@ms.sevenohfo]

I definitely agree

[@EikoKaykoCarol]

Or at least judge Judy. She doesn't accept hearsay

[@_MoneyMike_]

🤣🤣🤣

[@gongzilla527]

This is a real court you big dummy!!🥴😑

[@PrincessZaire100]

@@EikoKaykoCaroljudge Judy would’ve gotten on him for the same things Judge Mathis did

[@gladissanchez2408]

2nd case makes you question the 1st case. She may or may not have lied, but on the first case she sure did laugh at the young man trying to defend himself. When you laugh at someone (as if the young man was a fool), then sooner or later you will repay of that mockery. What goes around comes around whether it’s today, tomorrow or years from now.

[@dawnlee866]

Plus she claim she owned a home..now she in a apartment?!? She definitely got issues 😅

[@mikey6679]

Facts

[@theventxwiz8]

You are 100% correct

[@kaylee3867]

@@dawnlee866 I don't think that BISH owned that house

[@queenandcrown]

Absolutely!

[@jaxxgirl76]

Mathis was too hard on that young man he didn't deserve that.... Of all people, Mathis should know not to judge a book by its cover.

[@HISTORYunfolded304]

Exactly,shame JM.

[@1maggotbrain]

Not really!

[@musaa7919]

@@1maggotbrainyes really he is, his black lol I’m black was well saying this 😂

[@rwwdzzm5608]

Mathis wasn’t hard enough too many black young men are coddled. The world is not going to coddle them they need to be prepared for life.

[@TheSneakerFamily]

Damn it's like she's two very different people from the 1st case to the 2nd case.

[@quequekhari]

Nah she was the same lying mf. She just didn't get caught because Judge was too busy stereotyping the first guy

[@brendawright5353]

I wonder what happened to the house she was buying in the first case

[@kaz2977]

She aged quite a bit

[@quequekhari]

@@brendawright5353 I didn't even think of that

[@veronicaforever01]

@@brendawright5353 That’s my question too. Where’s the house ma’am?

[@Nm-pk6uh]

As someone in their late 20s, i wouldn’t even move a 20-year-old into my house especially with children and this 40 year old did, and is shocked he was immature like girl what???🤣

[@joeyjackson200]

Why is he running behind grandma tho😂

[@WifeyType19841]

​@@joeyjackson200😆 🤣 😂 😹

[@thomashammond16]

She a trip😂

[@sofantastic35]

How she win the case with no evidence? Judge Judy would never!

[@kkthedrummer8999]

Facts

[@eleanormcgee1507]

He should report Jm to the Bar & sue her too

[@101KANDYCANE]

That part

[@sheldoncole7276]

Right just ridiculous

[@adrianknight1406]

Mathis unfairly prejudged the defendant from the very beginning of this case in my opinion. Oftentimes a person's appearance and disposition will determine how they are percieved and judged which is sad and unfortunate. Seems to me like he needs more guidance than anything else. Mathis took the wrong approach as he does all the time.

[@user-zg4jh8qr2h]

I totally agree

[@siloamking2486]

It's called tough lough. Judge Mathis is not there to be their friend.

[@liona1657]

I 100% agree. This woman is there to destroy the young man's life.

[@debbielovingyahisrael6459]

Agree

[@Kolistwaky9161]

He is hard on everybody. Period

[@ESTENT-cu7qd]

In the first case judge was mad at the defendant for saying listen but in the second case she keep answering him by saying wassup and he didn’t say a word smh

[@CS48293]

Jm pretends he’s from the streets but cut street guys any slack for speaking the way they’re used to speaking? He apologized and told you it was a habit

[@Baethovin]

That's because the was just a spoiled kid in the streets for a moment. He got locked up early and changed his life. He actually came from a stable background

[@mrflynn01]

@@Baethovinno that’s not true.

[@sheldoncole7276]

Judge Mathis be doing to much sometimes he didn't have to do the defendant like that

[@user-bx7yr4yc1t]

Judge Mathis can be so cruel at times.

[@GoinHam10Four]

Let men talk to other men. That's what's wrong with our troubled youth today.

[@Kolistwaky9161]

Keep it real. He is hard on everybody

[@tagz3924]

@@GoinHam10Fournaw fam it’s difference he hold lot of power and she move responsible with that type of power. Judge Mathis like to make pre judgement before the case finished

[@GoinHam10Four]

@@tagz3924 you're upset at how this young man presented himself and was further judged by it? People get judged everyday from women to kids to police officers to whoever. Don't come on here condoning a young man that look like he has no goals in his life and has nothing going for himself except smoking weed. I hope you don't excuse this type of behavior in your own life.

[@blazebrown9102]

Make this make sense, what is the 40+ year old woman with a minor daughter allowed a 20 year old man to live in w/daughter and he's physically abusive...! She definitely got tricked or desperate?

[@jacal420]

She thought she was going to remind judge Mathis of her last case and pick up on that same energy. LMFAO 🤣😆😂😆

[@MyThoughtzAndOpinionz]

I don’t think the plaintiff was really immature, I think he behaved exactly like how a 20 year old is expected to behave. I think the defendant was upset because he didn’t behave like he was 40😂

[@jaediixoxo6090]

I got the feeling she is a compulsive liar and she plays the victim..

[@khambrelmathis6101]

That’s exactly how they are… these types are the ultimate victims, they never are wrong

[@thomashammond16]

Bad decision maker.

[@ivyunnanelson]

She went from Plaintiff to a Defendant 😂

[@sheldoncole7276]

The defendant wasn't trying to say "look" on purpose it's a habit people have a habit of saying things they say a lot

[@mikeprice8307]

Duh he said that already 🙄

[@sheldoncole7276]

@@mikeprice8307 if you don't get on somewhere 🙄

[@mrflynn01]

That’s a habit that must be broken in court on the soot!!!

[@clemm9771]

You can't go on a job interview speaking like that. Be hood when necessary, speak appropriately when necessary

[@mavava1]

She accused young man for crimes she has no proof, than went to prison, bring 20 years old man and use him. Well, now is time to pay. That's Karma!

[@kizzyrock]

I don't have an issue with age gaps, but I do have an issue when the older person complains that the younger person is immature....uhmmm

[@lydiablake-simon7555]

No u should have a problem with it . Because if it was a 48 year old man all u women in the comment section would be calling him a sexual predator preying on a young 20 year old girl . Well why are none of u saying this 48 year old woman preyed on a 20 year old boy ? She is a sexual predator in my eyes if you're 48 years old u should be with somebody your own age .that way the maturity level will be matched . U cannot be with a 20 year old at 48 and think your in a serious relationship . I already know u alot of u women will defend her behavior by saying men her age go with young girls in they 20s all the time. To some extent you're right , however a 48 year old man knows he can't build a serious relationship with a 20 year old girl he just wants to have sex with a girl in her 20s not a relationship big difference.

[@kizzyrock]

@lydiablake-simon7555 Im speaking about age gaps IN GENERAL....not this specific case only...Please don't tell me what I should have a problem with.... I was speaking about men AND women, so you're jumping to conclusions. One thing I don't tolerate is negative energy. God bless you

[@kkthedrummer8999]

He is too young about the same age of her kids WTH wrong with you SMH

[@kizzyrock]

@kkthedrummer8999 Again....I said I do not have an issue with the age gap(s). This is speaking in general, not to this specific case. Lastly, please do not curse and disrespect me. We are adults and can agree to disagree without disrespect. Have some respect

[@estellebeharry1831]

This woman is a predator !!!

[@shannonh5347]

Case #1 - no proof should have equaled no judgement on this woman’s behalf. I hope JM reviews this and sees he was unfair/wrong on this one. Why would you speak such horrible things over his life. Very sad.

[@Only1RonA]

The young man's physical appearance was decent for court. JM attached the young man's hairstyles. That was sad.

[@clemm9771]

He didn't speak anything horrible. The young man's demeanor was off and his respect was not there. JM handled that just fine

[@elopersdmv]

She finessed JM the first case. For all we know she accused the first boy of breaking in bc he wouldn’t sleep with her. She obviously likes them young. 😑

[@khambrelmathis6101]

That sounds about right

[@naenae5279]

Probably!!!

[@str8flyness23]

That was her karma for falsely accusing the boy in the first case!!!

[@tiffyfittaz6550]

That man was her karma for how she dealt with the other young man cause I don’t believe he robbed his house

[@nickynick_]

The stumbling over her words at the end of the 2nd case 😂

[@sarasmiles712]

She aged 15 years in 4. Yikes! See what happens when all you do is profile your neighbors? You age like a banana😂😂

[@geo745don]

Like really going from MILF to GILF

[@4eversatin]

😂😂 I thought that she looked awful

[@paulheath8073]

The counterclaim on the original case was dismissed but the defendant had a witness

[@paulheath8073]

And then the return of the plaintiff being sued once again the counterclaim was dismissed without showing evidence but this time she had no witnesses at all & what the defendant said to the plaintiff was false, he was 100% truthful & won the case, you can't say false statements when the case is won

[@sirkyte4048]

Well, JM seemed a bit angry with the 1st case. Yes the defendant did not have proper court etiquette but at the same time, he didn't really allow him to speak much. Nor did his witness have a chance to speak. 2nd case, this lady makes some questionable decisions. Makes you wonder about the 1st case. Smh

[@Lynette_Shine]

We've got to handle these young men better. Treat and talk to them like human beings, remember they don't always have the best stories. You heard him keep mentioning he live with his father, that to me says Mom (very important figure, especially to young men) is absent? Let's remember to show them some Love and Patience, please! Shaming them is absolutely unbeneficial! Protect your neighborhood by protecting our young people. You can get a family member killed or hurt really badly involving them in things, never would I call my precious nephews over for something like that, NEVER! It could turn out badly, then what. We too emotional! God Bless our Young People, and give them WISE Adults with the Wisdom of God to help them, I pray, Amen!

[@Blackguns22]

Sounds good but remember we l8ve in a society that judges before even lknowing anything

[@cupofchi_]

amen!

[@tanishajohnson5602]

I want to know what happened to the house she bought? Why her fiancé went to jail? Why keep taking someone back over and over, keeping ties for 7 years? And like the judge said, moved a 20 years old in with you and your daughter into a 1 bedroom apartment?

[@urluvizmyluv1999]

With her daughter whose probably about his age

[@waltonjones5411]

Poor decision making habits in men, jobs, and use of birth control. Unfortunately, it is too common in our community.

[@sheldoncole7276]

Judge Mathis "what do you do in the winter" Defendant " I don't know "

[@user-zg4jh8qr2h]

I like Judge Mathis but I think he treated that young man unfairly. Hell people say anything when a gun is pulled on em. U would too…

[@ak24553]

And he had no right to pull out a weapon and no proof. That’s illegal and the Judge didn’t say anything about that.

[@carolharris5455]

That woman was lying and crazy both cases. Wonder how Judge feels now!!!!

[@LaTravelsandEats]

They must’ve cut a whole lot out of the first case or maybe I tuned out because I cannot understand where Judge Mathis came to the conclusion that the defendant was guilty. They literally had not a thread of evidence.

[@tjbooker9948]

Second case. He seems like he's got enough sugar of his own.

[@kikilovejc]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@asiyab8116]

Wow 😂😂😂😂😂

[@dahmeneekah]

🥴🙃😏

[@Peoplesuk]

What kind of idiot tells a judge that he stands on his porch all day smoking weed..lol🤦

[@quequekhari]

The kind that is showing he's honest. Judges usually don't mind in civil cases or at least tells them to stop talking

[@kkthedrummer8999]

The same idiot makes a comment like this

[@sheilataylor7497]

Sugar mamas fiance probably broke in her house. 🤣😂

[@rubyjaez]

This is sad!! This is what happens in our justice system with our black men. They instantly get stereotyped, discriminated against then unfairly convicted and sentenced. She had no proof that he broke into her house. She didn’t even have proof that the neighbors said anything, he ignored the fact that the nephew pulled a gun on him, and she had her family running down on him. I wish the first young man would’ve called the police and pressed necessary charges on her and her family. Then the second case exposed that she was dealing with criminals herself. Why didn’t she call her nephews for Adrian? 🤔 How do we know that the company she kept isn’t the one that stole from her? This lady is a manipulator and she preys on younger Men.

[@tonywoods5652]

Why did the judge criticize the defendant's hair. I mean he was dressed neat and his hair was faded neatly and lined up.

[@sheldoncole7276]

The defendant seemed a little nervous in the first case

[@marleonetti7]

he didnt get nervous until the judge yelled at him , but before that he was bold because he knows he is not guilty . that woman showed she lied about everything because in the second episode we find out that she did not BUY the house , she got kicked out and had to find an apartment .

[@rubyjaez]

@@marleonetti7how and as he bold when he said nothing? He just stood there. It's called stereotyping then discriminating against someone because of their appearance. If Judge Mathis truly cared he would’ve checked the aunt and her nephew for stalking and pulling guns on the man. They produced no evidence, not even statements from neighbors. The police didn’t pursue charges because they had no evidence that he did it I knew Judge Mathis made up his mind when he refused to hear what the witness said and didn’t care about the gun being pulled. Which the nephew admitted to.

[@sheldoncole7276]

@@marleonetti7 absolutely right

[@sheldoncole7276]

@@rubyjaez agreed

[@tjporter8089]

I really don’t like how he judges ppl before even giving them a chance. The defendant seems uneducated but that doesn’t automatically make him guilty.

[@sheldoncole7276]

I wonder what's up with the defendant from the first case now and what happened after the case🤔?

[@victoriabewry862]

Ultimately, the second case was her KARMA.

[@TiffMarshall]

Case 1: It’s unfortunate that so many young men go into court and are inarticulate. He may have had a better chance if he was clear and concise. Literacy is so important. Studies show that illiterate people receive higher jail sentences for this very reason. I hope he’s a productive, law abiding citizen. We need more mentors for boys, especially Black boys.

[@user-zq6fl5kd3h]

We also need to consider how the children are brought up ; the education system , ect. He is also a young man as young adults are still trying to find their way and I say this as a young woman. The expectations we place on children that come from different backgrounds and ect are just too unrealistic. Not once did judge bother to ask him if his background, but immediately judged him. What if this young man has IEP ? There could be multiple reasons for what you claim is his “illiteracy” instead judge was of a BULLY and judgmental. With learning disabilities to expect one to behave in the way you would is not possible , and that may be the case here. So judge may have just bullied someone with a disability. We may never known because he wasn’t given a chance.

[@dahmeneekah]

Judge handed him callously. I'm so disappointed.

[@urluvizmyluv1999]

Awww she got the same energy JM gave the first defendant

[@klovefamous7077]

What a horrible judgment on that young man. That nephew of hers look guilty, and she has no proof, Judge Judy would have thrown that he said she said raggedy case out!!!

[@BrooklynBullshit718]

The judge did that kid wrong.Never gave him a chance to state his case properly.

[@anastacia0189]

doyle calling the lady "silly" after JM read her 😭😭💙

[@sybilwhite1259]

Well,Well,Well turn about is so fair play all these years later the Judge sees her in court again this time he sees just what she was really about. She's a trifling individual and so called mom 😮😮

[@smoothlyabrasive9805]

JM said his hair looking crazy but it almost like JM hair 😂

[@Joey_Lance]

The defendant claims she was the “sugar mama”, but he says they agreed to go 65/35 on the bills. Sounds like he ended up providing the sugar.

[@mikeprice8307]

She used his card too 😮

[@MegaMarquette]

He was providing the sugar 🤣

[@Joey_Lance]

@@MegaMarquette 😂😂

[@letitiacooper98]

Damn she was on here two different times 😂

[@deborahmcdonald2111]

HE WAS SO PREJUDICE TO THAT YOUNG MAN AND IT WAS DESPICABLE. HE WAS TOTALLY DEGRADING. HE NEEDS TO COMPENSATE HIM FOR THE HARASSMENT HE POURED ON HIM IN THAT CASE

[@glf9834]

No he wasn't being prejudice, the young man was over 18 didn't have a steady job he sits on the porch and smokes. He needs a mentor. JM was speaking the truth to him.

[@fundifferent1]

She changed a lot in 2-3 years. And something is off about her. JM should deeply regret that first ruling based on the second tale.

[@nae80West]

Yep

[@lola9919]

Judge Mathis straight up judged that man…he ain’t deserve that

[@sheldoncole7276]

Not at all

[@MariwittheI]

I am glad for the plaintiff he deserves that much. Like who keeps going to the playground for dates? That woman knew that he was as young as her own child😂

[@youmakemelaugh1797]

Damn she went from night to day in these two cases real quick tf is wrong with her???🤦🏿‍♀️

[@kkthedrummer8999]

She lied on the 2nd case you don't think she lied on the first without proof specially if the police didn't believe her I like JM I know he feels bad

[@OaklandMind]

totally turned out

[@fundifferent1]

Why is she so long winded!?? "Um Judge I'm here on your television court show today on this wednesday afternoon to explain to you and all the viewers that I am here on behalf of all of the hard working American citizens of the community of which I belong and representing today before you and the courtroom of this television tv show right here today, your honor to explain thus before you and hereunto hence forth."

[@OaklandMind]

🤣

[@Toriab]

JM must be dealing with some trauma because the way he treated that man was not right. JM judged him from the beginning

[@sheldoncole7276]

The defendant sure does say "you know what I'm saying" a lot

[@Marlon-oe1dd]

I'm surprised JM didn't say..No I dnt knw what yu saying I'm nt yo man 😂 You knw wat esle thats strange We dnt knw hw to tlk to a judge on National TV but on 1st 48 when thy in the interagation room wit alot of Yes ma am No sir smh

[@jaxkboiiz2938]

If 2019 throwback ima dinosaur 😂

[@stephenstudivant7829]

Makes me feel like my sons don't stand a chance, standing in front of any judge just like I didn't some years ago. Black male judge or not, power indeed is corruptible no mater who it is

[@dezaraewynn5990]

“I hope you go to jail to keep you from being killed” as if you can’t get killed in jail?🤦🏾‍♀️ The comment about his hair was definitely not needed he’s trippin the guy looks put together!

[@gemini-yu6gf]

wishing that on someone is crazy & he as a judge should know how prisoners are treated. that’s horrible & i feel bad for his kids growing up with a man like that

[@mikeprice8307]

He came dressed with a tie too

[@sheldoncole7276]

I been looking for the first episode for a little minute

[@kennyblackbird5674]

The kid needs to learn a trade.

[@2B2350]

1brm apartment 😂😂😂soooo who slept whr cuz she had a daughter 🤦🏽‍♀️and wht happened to the house she owned back n the day🤔

[@keektini]

I BELIEVE THE JUDGE WAS 100% WRONG!! I CAN'T JUDGE MATHIS. I TRULY BELIEVE THE PLANTIFF LIED ON THIS YOUNG MAN. HE DIDNT ALLOW HIM TO TALK.

[@princedlotti4181]

Not to be judgmental but this is the scariest type of woman- she looks like a librarian but had a fiancé who went to prison then moved a 20 year old guy into his apartment- had her nephew confront someone in her neighborhood - accused a young man of a serious crime with no evidence

[@krystaperry288]

And JM generation eats that look up.

[@nicolesamuels8879]

She may have been interested in the neighbor who she brought to court and became furious he wasn’t vibing

[@davidwhite8955]

He said his hair look all crazy! 😂😂😂

[@1234pixy1]

I hope the defendant in the first case is ok... mercy.... this was cold.

[@mosesmcgruder]

1st case: the defendant does need to get himself together. However, I do believe that the plaintiff's nephew pulled a gun on him. You can look at his demeanor/ energy he's giving. Hell if someone pulled a gun on me I'd tell em what they'd wanna hear too. 2nd case: serves her right.

[@eleanormcgee1507]

I believe him

[@coreycalloway3268]

Hair looking crazy? C'mon judge, ... WE ARE NOT OUR HAIR!!

[@TalkswithMellow]

Mathis is at it again. Man is too emotional to judge based on evidence and facts.

[@sheldoncole7276]

Right

[@kibella28]

I’m trying to figure out how she went from community watch advocate in the first case to delusional in the second at her big age. Get a grip and heal!

[@khambrelmathis6101]

They can’t heal…. They’ll do everything but heal

[@theventxwiz8]

She lied in the first case saying she had "children" in the house, which turned into 1 daughter in the second. She also lied and said she bought a house in the first case which turned into a 1 bedroom apartment in the second. I believed the kid after he said her nephew pulled a gun on him and he basically just went along with it. She got the pretty girl treatment in the first case, but came back looking like life caught up with her like the lies she told. For all we know, she could have been sleeping with the kid in the first case, and set him up after she got tired of him. The guy in the second caught her cheating on him and smacked her for it.

[@sheenaperez1882]

He profiled him, he didn't stand a chance. Smh...

[@destinyawaits2807]

OH OK, COOL. I am not the only one watching the throwback. Why this lady keep repeating herself? We get it girl, you are trying to preserve the neighborhood🤣

[@dahmeneekah]

😂😂😂

[@nicolesamuels8879]

She was a first time homeowner on the last show.

[@balowskibally1797]

This is injustice. He allowed his emotions to get the best of him.

[@CMarieCantBeBroken]

Yall better wake up, that boy was lying his butt off, I bet yall kids get away with anything. 😂