From Berlin to a kibbutz in Israel’s Negev desert

[@Sandra-Gibora]

I discovered your channel after seven October and I have been slowly binge watching you. I really appreciate what you do and I liked understanding where you come from and why. Be safe, you and your family.

[@leyla2210]

😂

[@Michaelsiphophillips18]

Extremely down to earth living . Good support system . From Lemba Tribe of South Africa

[@bikerabbi]

I went to Israel in 1970 when I was 17 to Kibbutz Hulda. I was too young and dumb to properly appreciate it. On Shabbat, we Ulpan kids were sent to members' homes for lunch. A guy was there who served my meals. I was too young and dumb to appreciate who he was. His name meant nothing to me. After I'd left and a few years later, I learned who Amos Oz is... 😮 Thank you for this great series of videos. Your work is greatly needed - and I appreciate it! 😂

[@Sandra-Gibora]

Wow!

[@Iblk13]

That is insane.

[@christopherthompson5216]

Oren lovely video, I spent 6 months as a volunteer on Sde Boker in 1984 and had a fantastic time. I am bringing my two grown up sons to visit Israel next April. Keep up the good work and take care of yourself and family.

[@avihairapoport9521]

One of my fav places in israel. :)

[@19bendunk]

Close to the amazing ramon crater! Don't forget to go see the stars

[@1watsonwatson]

I was a volunteer at Sde Boker in 1988

[@NikCan66]

Very honest video and takes a lot of guts to do this. Best wishes from Ireland 🇮🇪

[@Travelingisraelinfo]

Thank you very much!

[@NikCan66]

@@rylancorbin4840 that could be a serious violation in some jurisdictions. But why do it in the first place 🤔.

[@goodputin4324]

@@Travelingisraelinfo du ist Deutsch?

[@healthy3074]

Just curious, what takes Guts? Just being a Jew, living in the desert, leaving Berlin? Just curious. Thanks.

[@goodputin4324]

@@healthy3074 living in occupied territory

[@ullaghallstrom]

I have been working in Hatzerim and Palmach Tsuba as a volonteer 1973 1974 .loved it

[@idontspeakminecraft1475]

I have no idea where is that and I’m from Israel

[@idontspeakminecraft1475]

@gelzinna לא חחחחחחחחחחחחח

[@yakov95000]

@@idontspeakminecraft1475 If you are Southerner or have been in Army you know Hatzerim

[@Ultrapro011]

Awesome, i really wanna know how so many people from abroad knew about those kibbutzim and had the courage to travel to israel to work since that would not have worked that good as in today's world

[@hscollier]

I have not been on a kibbutz or a moshav since 1985, it would be interesting to see the changes. Our son lived on Hatzerim in the Negev, and we have friends with two young children who moved from Be’er Sheva to a kibbutz in the Negev recently. Hope to visit again after Covid restrictions are lifted. When we do I definitely want Oren as a guide in Jerusalem. Even with as much time as I’ve spent there in the past I always learn something new and very interesting in your videos.

[@alihaydarnar9543]

The kibbutz is the most unique possibility of collective living /working or farming, often with children care inclusive. Thanks for upload!!!

[@seruzadok1205]

I am still living in South Germany, but I want to immigrate one day to Israel forever.

[@etrigueros]

Let's trade.

[@idontspeakminecraft1475]

You’re always welcome 🇮🇱

[@ggarza]

Congratulations on moving to Israel. Blessings to you and your family!

[@eliptikon]

I‘ve been to Kibbuz Lotan in the Negev and to Geva in Jesreel Valley. Loved them both.

[@tristanuaceithearnaigh7660]

These vidos are so informative and fascinating to watch. So glad I came across your videos, You are not afraid to encompass all aspects of life in Israel including the political situations and social nuances that you experience in Israel. I first heard about the Kibbutzim as a child in the 70's in New Zealand, our school teacher was a Jewish lady who showed us things about Israeil. I was fascinated even back then that a community could be so cooperative and united idealistically..So glad to hear that the Kibbutzim in Israel are still going strong. Please keep the videos coming.

[@erpollock]

I spent Pesach 1972 in a religious kibbutz where my college roommate was a daughter of veterans who came via the kindertransport - from Germany to England to found the kibbutz in Israel. The kibbutz had a guest house and I worked in the kitchen making pretty desserts for the guests. Now the kibbutz has a factory and makes furniture for synagogues. I think my former flatmate is an administrator in the kibbutz. She grew up in a children's house and the lady who cared for the children had the most honored job in the kibbutz. It was a very simple, utilitarian life - but in summer, since the kibbutz was paying her tuition at college, my flatmate was assigned to lead a group of 13 year old girls as a counselor. I thought - how restrictive! She can't choose freedom in summer. But I, too, had to spend my summer as my father expected in the US - working at a real office job to make the money to pay for the last year of my own college. So the same difference. I was not free myself. An interesting experience. It required responsibility and maturity to live such a life. What my flatmate most wanted - was privacy.

[@simko8665]

Kibbutz Lavi.

[@skontheroad2666]

Kibbutz Lavi I presume? Hardly "a typical kibbutz" (neither in concept or practice). But if you ever go to visit the hotel (it is a resort actually and great for families), be sure to book in the new building (it's worth the astronomical price, relatively speaking).

[@simko8665]

@@skontheroad2666 I was in the hotel there about three times in the last 20 years. Why hardly a typical Kibbutz?

[@skontheroad2666]

@@simko8665 Do you know what a kibbutz is (or is/was supposed to be?)? Is Lavi the only one you have ever been to? And when you went, did you just go to the hotel for a holiday? I am only asking so I know how to answer your question properly. (Also, if your answers to the questions were No, Yes and Yes, then I would suggest just googling what is the history of the kibbutz, as well as what is a kibbutz (2 different answer in many cases), and that will likely answer your question.

[@skontheroad2666]

@@simko8665 I will say that what definitely IS typical kibbutznik style at Lavi is the terrible food in the (depressing) cafetería! I don't know what time of year you stayed there but the prices during the Chagim (holidays) are outrageous!! If you have little kids (and can all fit in one room--we had to leave our luggage in the hallway one time, it was so tight!), one can almost justify the expense (almost!). But with some advance planning, I think there are better options, whether up north, or by the Dead Sea or Eilat.

[@carllaney7897]

Thanks for sharing your story and telling about life in a kibbutz.

[@gloriouswavechurchinternat8831]

I am pastor Kingsley, I think you are so kind God bless you in advance and I want to discuss something too with you if you don't mind. Hope to hear from you shortly. Thanks

[@ajNKaj]

My trips in the last two years benefitted very much from your videos

[@antonyobara8382]

Much love of the channel from Moshav ein yahav..🇰🇪🇰🇪..kenyans represented

[@pmorganworkshop]

This was an excellent video, as always. You have a really great way of explaining things and I learned a lot about kibbutzim.

[@Travelingisraelinfo]

Glad you enjoyed it!

[@acchaladka]

Every former kibbutznik and volunteer be like: 😢 sigh...I should have stayed.

[@pamreynolds6812]

I lived on kibbutz Gonen for 6 years . We sent our children home at the end of the day . I would love to live on a kibbutz in the negev

[@ralphnetta4563]

So well said and explained! I always learn something NEW about Israel every time I watch one of your videos and look forward to seeing and hearing from you more often now that your back. As the months go by and you and your family are acclimated again and we’re ALL out of this horrific time I certainly will look too see more tour type video. Stay healthy and safe my friend. Look forward to meeting you at the end of March as you recommended. New Jersey, USA

[@tiskwell]

Thanks a lot for this video! Kibbutz is a unique organization of Israel and I want to know more about it!

[@martawyszniewski7424]

i love how you explain things in all of your videos/ i subscribed to your channel after watching your long video about living in the forest - you are a great person and very honest truthfull which some people on KZbin loose after beimg on KZbin for too long

[@ajNKaj]

Marta Wyszniewski yes i followed him too and discovered his time in woods. Really something. He has an engaging style. Our two trips to israel were assisted by his videos. We hired vehicles each time and simply ticked off places he told of. We went to several in same direction in same day except dead sea we spent a day and then Masada.

[@vicihuizinga8157]

We are traveling to Israel in September and I’m preparing myself for this trip by watching your videos and have learned so much already. Thank u 🤸‍♀️

[@Travelingisraelinfo]

Hey guys, Amazon is great! But buying directly from me is even better! If you enjoy my videos then you’ll love my booklets, where you can find all the information I deliver on my three most popular tours. It would be a great help to me in these challenging times. Thanks! travelingisrael.shop/

[@DahlemDorf]

would you be able to tourguide dimona or ness ziona?

[@smc3117]

Love your videos. They're always very interesting and informative. Thank you!

[@petermurphy9651]

Oren and family, well explained and congratulations for being upfront and honest. May alll of your endeavours reap bounty. Thank for sharing.

[@ajNKaj]

Peter Murphy a great prayer❤️

[@petermurphy9651]

@@ajNKaj Amen

[@franceslock1662]

You need to tours for Jewish people who want to focus on Jewish culture, sights and history. Thank you for sharing your story.

[@ishalocke1123]

Thank you for this info! It’s great info and updates! Keep sharing your experiences!

[@BBRAIN1977]

stayed 4 times in Barkai visiting friends. Loved it there. People are friendly and had a great time there.

[@eyesontheprize6637]

Thank you, I enjoyed this very much.

[@raykleiner3151]

Thank you for posting this. Did not know you were in Berlin. One day I will return to Israel (tachana ahorna) never thought about a Kibbutz. Love the Negev. Something to think about......

[@markhirstwood4190]

Love this. I'm addicted to your videos, Oren. Keep it up. Toda raba.

[@ajNKaj]

Interesting. I wondered how your family progressed from the days in the woods in Haifa, wedding and first child. I love your videos

[@Travelingisraelinfo]

Thank you so much!

[@Jewish_Whiskey]

I Love Israel 🇦🇱🇮🇱

[@h54h52]

Loved kibbutz life. Was a volunteer on four of them and one asked me to become a member. If you want to see real socialism visit a kibbutz! What is fascinating is that part of original kibbutz philosophy was to do away with the traditional family and marriage (hence children brought up separate from parents), make women equal so that jobs were interchangeable etc. Over time however they found that women didn’t want to be mechanics or work in the fields all the time, that parents didn’t have the joy of watching their children grow up (the children developed a group loyalty to other children!) and other stuff. So eventually they moved back to a more traditional lifestyle and more privatised life style - as he says!

[@simko8665]

At the first years of any Kibbutz they needed workers. If every woman had to watch her small child there were not enough working hands. That's why they decided of the Kindergarten at day time and separate sleeping from their parents. In that way only two women were required for 20 children instead 20 to be watched at home by not working mothers. After a hard day in the fields their parents needed a good night sleep. Anyway, that is not the situation anymore for some decades. Instead of man/woman power there are machines which is doing the hard work.

[@h54h52]

Sim Ko I wouldn’t argue with that, but once some basic supply of food and shelter had been established then basic roles such as child bearing, home building and hunting /protection began to blossom.

[@MrJm323]

Wait a minute, ....did they try to get rid of marriage?? How did men and women relate to one another? Did the kids know who their father was? Didn't men and women live as couples in their own small homes? Were they not married, typically?

[@thejewishredneckprepper4675]

Here in America the Kibbutz is popular amongst the middle class and the rich. They are called gated communites.

[@deanl0]

Very good story that brings us back to the good ol days , Nice to hear that it's still happening , Always Positive..

[@lilymcnabb6621]

i have always loved the idea of a kibbutz. i am American so I prefer the less centralized version of finances, but do like the communal kitchen and responsibilities. I have considered moving to Israel though funding my way would be an issue. Another idea has been setting up a kibbutz like arrangement here. The economic reality here in the States is abysmal but most are deluded that this is a phase and not the new normal. I would like someone to walk this path with me though at the moment it looks like I am on my own.

[@danneeley7248]

Excellent, interesting video. Thank you, from Texas

[@lsknuo]

What a great content! Please keep on doing such great videos.

[@andrewwalton9700]

I lived on a kibbutz for 18 months between 02 /82 & 05/ 84 ! I loved the kibbutz way of life & i even considered making a life of it . Alas i returned to Thatchers dole riden GB but i still love the Kibbutzeem & Israel . Perhaps the fact that im a christian living in a jewish state played a part in my returning home to Bleighty . Years later that decisions seems a bit silly but was my choice Rearly like your channel & if i ever get to Jerusalem again i will certeinly seek you out for a tour of the city .

[@BneiAnusim]

I really do enjoy your videos! Thanks.

[@aribencanaan26]

Mazol tov on the kibbutz life. I know they will never be what they were but they (kibbutzim) can adapt. The sense of comradship can endure no matter how crazy the world becomes. In 1972, i climbed masada (the snake path!)at daybreak and when i looked down it was so beautiful i thought nothing bad could ever happen again! I was very young and naive! Good choice on your kibbutz.

[@anhpam9205]

Oren , very well presented, as always. So glad you decided to come back here as your closing words were so true. I wish you and your family an easy adjustment. ושבו בנים לגבולם.

[@gracavasc]

Very good information about kibbutzim! Thanks!

[@pintusarode8878]

Hi sir 🙏 I am Mohan India. God bless you and your family Jesus name Amen

[@wilhelmienvannieuwenhuizen4119]

May you and your family be very blessed there. I also love the dessert. ♥️ You are right, your value to tourists visiting Israel is enormous. I am glad you are there and am looking forward to the time when we can visit places in Israel with you as our tour guide.

[@omidiranshahri3910]

Hi thx for your videos danke für alle ihre Bemühungen תודה רבה

[@hv0e25]

Beautiful video. Thank you!

[@dktrdaniel]

Looks amazing!

[@marie-joelleraussou]

I like your senseof humour intge first few minutes of the video

[@alliel5160]

Thank you for sharing. Great info. I stayed at several kibbutzim when I traveled in Israel - in the Galilee and in the southern desert. They were both beautiful places. Blessings to you and your family.

[@briansmart2045]

Thank you for your wonderful videos , really enjoy them . Blessings to you and the family 🙏🏻 from 🇦🇺

[@Volleyball_Chess_and_Geoguessr]

It makes more sense now that I realize you're saying salary and not celery.

[@ronaldmiller2740]

Thanks for your videos when I was In Israel I was In the I.D.F. ARMY then when I got out I had friends In a KIBBUTZ LOTAN 60km north of EILAT so I went to give my time and learn some thing different I helped with cooking digging in the garden building small houses and feeding the animals watch out the camels do spit...

[@robcorrente6065]

Thanks for sharing that with all of us

[@bcro83]

Super Video!

[@tessasaugbjerg3599]

I lived on two diffent kibbutz and loved it. Wish that we never leavede

[@hans5501]

Toll! Wenn wir hier in Deutschland Kibbutzim hätten, wären wir sofort dabei.😀

[@iska788]

I am German-Israeli and live currently in France. I have to think about you from time to time and hope that you are able to make a living in these very difficult times. Keep strong and all the best to you. Nathan P.

[@Travelingisraelinfo]

Thanks! I hope that by spring 21 it will be over.

[@ironfromicey8700]

Love israel💙🇮🇱 greetings from the Netherlands🇳🇱

[@davidt2362]

Great talk, even is already 3y 👏

[@pamreynolds6812]

I lived on a kibbutz from 1976 until 1982 i was lucky that my kibbutz the children went home at the end of the day. . It was up north . I am under the impression the kibbutz has changed . I f i were to come back could i find a kibbutz in the negev to live

[@issiedorenbush875]

Love your videos. Toronto.

[@busybeenature9092]

Great place to come back! Thanks bless you

[@sabrinafair35]

Very nice video!

[@cphye]

Thank you for sharing....

[@drommie4396]

be'hatzlacha to you and the mishpacha Oren-shana tovah from Canada

[@susheeldagar]

Love your story telling mate . Best of luck

[@alexanderlavrov3970]

always wanted to go to Israel but after knowing Israel so expensive , i have to recal and put the travel up on my dream .

[@yakov95000]

Its true, Israel is like Island nation allot of thing are internally made or imported far away like for example concrete to biuld houses or Cars.

[@idontspeakminecraft1475]

we r Jews after all

[@idontspeakminecraft1475]

And You always can host it’s very popular here 🇮🇱❤️

[@annexton3795]

I'm surprised at how green the kibbutz in the Negev is. How come?

[@christineamclearly-halton1581]

🤩 Awesome ✨🌷🦋 Thank you

[@geraldmccarty8630]

Yeah I don't blame you Berlin is probably a pretty exciting place to live i would definitely choose Israel to work live raise a family. I would love to live in Israel.

[@marcelovodovoz]

What's the current process to become a kibutz member? If you don't have a job outside the kibutz still give you something to do inside?

[@Travelingisraelinfo]

It is hard to say because in each kibbutz it is different.

[@danbenshushan5842]

ואוו מגניב בהצלחה בארצנו

[@laurajames723]

Great video, very educational too. Just curious though, I remember seeing other videos of Israel in which there was mentioned about the Negev being reclaimed and deveopled for agriculture through the slow drip irrigation system. This was a while ago. Is this still happening? And was it successful? Because where you are at the end of this clip, it looks like..well, the desert. Warm regards from Canada.

[@19bendunk]

There the city beer sheva which is really made progress in the last decade, and mitzpe ramon which is small town near the crater, but israel have big problem with the Bedouin community, which their youngsters going out of control with wild driving and robbery

[@natlim6709]

Love your videos. From Malaysia 😊

[@JimCvit]

I've been to both but never saw you to show me around. Of course this was like 12 years ago but still lol

[@dmitryzalmanov2453]

Thank you very much for the video! One thing is unclear to me: you mentioned the financial capacity to build a new house as a precondition to join a kibbutz, but isn't it possible to just live in a house that's available for rent? תודה!

[@Travelingisraelinfo]

You can rent only for a couple of years and then you need to build.

[@dmitryzalmanov2453]

@@Travelingisraelinfo Thank you, now I got it!

[@MrHmjg]

great talk!

[@bootloader3180]

Woody Harelson on minimals

[@UBETUBEME]

Now we know why 40 years in the desert

[@micheleventuroni2080]

3.11 " communism" and " dictatorship " are not synonyms. Socialism with a democratic management is exactly what communism has to be like, nothing to do with stalinism.

[@amaly9348]

Very interesting! I want to visit your country! Thxs for thé vid

[@carenlettofsky3045]

Real question - How many (or what percentage) of the kibbutzim turned into a moshav?

[@obrienjohnj]

I can't wait to go back to Israel and hire him as my tour guide.

[@ritvikdiv]

Nice video. Please post videos of the Jews settled in Israel coming from Ethiopia.

[@WAM-m3i]

How do you feel living in a stolen property?

[@enriquejosekravetzmalabud8530]

Great video. I made alia 8 month ago from Argentina, we are in bait rishon program. I have the same point of view as you, but I'm a north fan instead of Negev. See your next video

[@Travelingisraelinfo]

Behazlacha!

[@cyndiharrington1751]

If you are raising g your own food and build your own home why are the expenses high???Solar ENERGY and wind generators should HELP.convert motors to get generators to electricity

[@rubberduckDanson]

6:14 "...very painful video" LOL

[@shebadsouza9785]

Good information. Thanks.🙏🏻🇮🇳

[@8gomerpyle22]

If you speak Hebrew, German and English, you must also speak Yiddish.

[@mariavani8839]

I pray one day to visit Israel!

[@Yitzhakhazak]

Kol Hakavod. For a Jew, living in Israel and defending it has a higher merit than all the other commandments.

[@chryvalantia6521]

Very interesting information

[@dodyavichezer-abikhzer859]

Chag Succot Sameah to you and your family!

[@AsimoTan]

Another issue in kibbutzim: No good public transportation, far away schools, healthcare facilities require a car, etc.

[@DoreenBellDotan]

Which Kibbutz is that? I spent some time at Yahel decades ago. Lotan was just two caravans and a godzillion rocks then.

[@cropduster8798]

Possibly Revivim.....

[@7Steveski]

Thank you! As a student of history, it's no surprise that the Kibbutzim sort of fell apart. All attempts at communal living (or communism) go through the same thing. There are always lazy members who let others do the work, while they try to reap the rewards. Biblically speaking, "The laborer is worthy of his wage." Communal living ignores that reality. But it sounds like most Kibbutzim have dropped some of the more communist ideas.