From Jāhiliyya to Islam | D1 02\19 From Last Emperor to Last Prophet - David Powers

[@ef_aliwc9386]

When I watching this video i remember Quran 4:46 Surah an-Nisa God said Among those who are Jews, there are some who displace words from (their) right places and say: "We hear your word (O Muhammad SAW) and disobey," and "Hear and let you (O Muhammad SAW) hear nothing." And Ra'ina with a twist of their tongues and as a mockery of the religion (Islam). And if only they had said: "We hear and obey", and "Do make us understand," it would have been better for them, and more proper, but Allah has cursed them for their disbelief, so they believe not except a few.

[@petergrimshaw492]

This is actually jolly funny. Fine presentation Mr Powers.

[@TheCinamanic]

Just lovely. Baarakallah fee a7sani a3maalikum

[@A.--.]

Leo 3 and john were when and how far away? What were they basing their own views on?

[@A.--.]

Was the Tahleel verse revealed before or after the marrying Zaids ex-wife verse? Hint: This will help eliminate your confusion.

[@A.--.]

Its humourous that a christian bishop leo or john (whos believes are based on an unreliable source namely bible see Bart Ehrman) would conclude Muhammad committed a sin. A sin is defined by God through a Prophet. Relying on unreliable books to decide what is snd isnt a sin is a non-starter argument.

[@A.--.]

Where does Quran say that Prophethood passes on to sons? Since all humans are connected to Adam everyone who ever existed that claimed prophethood could be validated as being the offspring of a skipped line from adam. This argument of yours doesnt make sense.

[@tc7500]

Funny he said as recounted the story of Muhammad renouncing his adopted son that the “ people Muslims and Jews and conveniently or purposely OMITTED the Christians when Many of the Quraysh Arabs were Christians.

[@stadiamak692]

Ridiculous... You aknowledge there is no one there to witness him seeing and lusting... Its obvious its fabricated from storytellers

[@fadwasoliman7410]

I watched the whole thing there are no evidence on what you claim you relay on a conversation of two non Muslim people about a Muslim prophet that is just baseless claims

[@A.--.]

version 2 seems accurate

[@stevenv6463]

Very interesting idea but doesn't the revisionist argument (besides not accounting for its lack of attestation in the documentary evidence and manuscripts) not account why this revision would take place in this historical context but the debates and conflicts of the Umayyad, Abbasid and Abdullah ibn Zubayr's competing political claims? Also maybe it would be enlightening to consider the traditional Islamic traditions that claim that originally the verse said that the prophet Muhammad (saw) IS the father of his nation (presumably in a metaphorical sense) and was later abrogated to say that he IS NOT the father of any of your men. Also the parallels being drawn between some Christian conceptions of the prophet Muhammad (saw) and Heraclius in regards to marrying a divorcee/relative and some religious establishment people being against it really reminds me of Herod being criticized by John the Baptist (as) for marrying his brother's divorced wife and then lusting after his niece and stepdaughter.

[@A.--.]

"at his time someone must have argued zyed was a potential prophet" There you have it folks look at this connect-the-dots approach. Completely unacademic, cornell should take note there is a lying connect-a-dotter on their payroll.

[@tc7500]

I’m glad you cover the manipulation of Quran and how they remove part of a verse and added it to another!

[@A.--.]

"it is reported that as many as 100 verses were removed" Again look at you gutter level of evidence. Trying to sell narratives will harden the hearts of disbelievers and strengthen the conviction of believers that disbelievers are spreafing lies and fake news. Source your evidences you lier.

[@tc7500]

Are you trying to help Muhammad? No man visits his daughter in law when He, Muhammad knew that she was alone!

[@tc7500]

Committed to memory! 😂😂😂

[@A.--.]

First Muslim was Khadija. Ali was first male to become Muslim so your wrong there as well. Pretty much your conspiracy theory desires is a big W

[@tc7500]

Nothing make sense on the SIN because everything everything about Islam is a big fat lie!

[@tc7500]

There are more version of the story in Islam about Muhammad taking Said’s wife.

[@tc7500]

Sorry you are wrong because you are relying in Islamic Narrative which have ZERO CREDIBILITY!

[@tc7500]

The early movement was an Arab anti Trinity Christian movement in exiled in the Persian territory of today’s Iraq. Persia used arab mercenaries to fight Byzantium and after both powers got financially and manpower exhausted the Arabs rebelled under the leadership of a Jew named Umar. The Jews were also under exiled in Persia and together with anti Trinitarian Christians and pagan Arabs went to conquer Jerusalem. The Jewish Umar after entering Judea started decapitating Christians and eventually met a Christian monk named Lord Gabriel who converted Umar to Christianity. Lord Gabriel gave Umar an Aramaic Syriac book of Christians Hymns which became the beautiful 25% of the original Quran! The first coins minted by the Arabs had a Christian cross ✝️. The Dome of the Rock was constructed on a Byzantium Military observation post and the original inscriptions were about Jesus. All the Arabs civil war battles happened in Today’s Iraq and never in the Arabian peninsula. All the words, Muslims , Islam, Muhammad biography were written 200 years later in Persia. Again, the original Christian movement was changed by the Abbasids in Persia under the influence of the Anti Trinitarian Arab Christians and Jews exiled in Persia. Later the Abbasids didn’t want the NEW IMPROVED version called Islam, to be perceived as an OFFSHOOT of Christianity or Judaism anymore but really as a superior and older religion than the former 2. Everything about Islam is a Lie upon lies upon lies to coverup previous lies and that’s why nothing makes sense!

[@A.--.]

Jesus is connected to Abraham only thru his mother so your hypothesis is failed on the spot. Good job audience 👏👏👏