#FROMMGM

[@geekademy]

I have a discord now! discord.gg/HrgasKNd You can support me on Patreon and watch without ads here: patreon.com/geekademy

[@kimmylive2127]

Watch the tv series Dark Matter. It was time travel and it depended on his thought process where he would get sent. He also took some kind of drug.

[@NickBittrich]

F Yes!!

[@nae_folk810]

I don't think Randall was having a seizure, my guess is he was seeing the cicadas again.... Just a guess though.

[@Gods_Harbinger_2_The_12_Tribes]

I think this is the black thing on the table. kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z3vbcqlpYraCsMUsi=MDGR-0QEQcgBVskd ty for your videos:)

[@SBzKillFrenzy]

Victor saying "I couldnt get home" during the reunion with his dad...killed me!!!! Loving this show

[@jaymierae9890]

Niagara Falls 😭😭😭

[@SBzKillFrenzy]

@@jaymierae9890 I was chopping onions lol

[@Ready4Raw]

same

[@angelae5748]

Weirdly, the scene didn't emotionally affect me. I guess the scene was over-hyped and too syrupy for me.

[@SBzKillFrenzy]

@@angelae5748 I'm not saying the scene...I'm saying the words said during the scene. Victor (Still with a kid's mind) saying "I couldn't get home" in a way that felt like he thought his dad would be disappointed in him. That's the thing that killed me.

[@tekservices8699]

The actor that plays Victor is doing an incredible job. That scene with his dad was movie material

[@beewest5704]

😭😭😭

[@LeaGholson-t6w]

💯

[@LNVKRmusic]

same with kenny a couple episodes ago! the acting is top tier in this show!

[@akhilezsabino1548]

yeah.. Scott McCord is an incredible actor :)

[@mrsw2923]

Why isn’t anyone freaking out over the fact that even though she got out it brought her right back.

[@candicecurry8800]

Yeeeessss talking about how could she not bring help. lol 😅

[@KenLieck]

@@candicecurry8800 Wasn't that exactly what happened at the town meeting?!?

[@Gabriela-zi1wl]

Right ? Like she was brought back so there is no hope of getting out cause your gonna come back

[@Mofi357]

half that town is waste of skin fuk em

[@seciak595]

For 2.5 seasons, we all wanted a general meeting where everyone would tell each other about their experiences in the town, but when we finally got that meeting, I think everyone just wanted it to end and for everyone there to shut up already xD

[@carlie-10]

I think jades right to many people in a meeting, caused anarchy. People fight and argue nothing gets resolved. That’s why the government keeps most stuff from us 😂 causes uproars.

[@seciak595]

@@carlie-10 Jade sentence about it is my favourite :P

[@Jreaddy]

Yup lmfao, if come to terms that 99% of the ppl in the town are useless and see nothing know nothing and are just there for Boyd to protect and save. There’s only a few important characters, and even between them only half actually see or hear things. A legit town meeting would/should just be victor telling everyone what he knows, nothing anyone else sees or hears means shit, besides letting us know who plays what role.

[@ashelywebb5612]

Lol you explained it perfectly

[@cjones4047]

same lmao sometimes when you ask for what you want for a long time coming you dont even have the same energy

[@angelae5748]

You can't volunteer to be a martyr and then get mad about the outcome. Both Tian Chen and Randall volunteered to help, and Boyd told each of them "No" or "go back", "or "go inside" multiple times. Both decided not to do that. They put their lives on the line to help others - don't blame Boyd. Don't blame anyone. It is what it is. That comes with the territory if you decide to be a martyr - and that's why there aren't many true martyrs.

[@Ready4Raw]

Thank you!

[@GAMESURVIVOR-dc6nb]

Nice statement ,and I be seeing this. And was like. How they go blame it all on Boyd. Cause Boyd always want to deal with things alone but they chose to help. Now the results are for Boyd .hell no! I agree with you.

[@EricDeanCampbell]

Typing as I listen. 1) yep bottle holding a melted candle. 2) Mannequin head from the 1940's. She has a plastic clothes pin clipped to the mouth. There is a decoration or tattoo drawn on the neck. 3) They didn't kill Randal so that he could squeal on Boyd for leaving him, undermining his authority (as opposed to him being a day reminder). 4) The black thing with 2 lenses is a "viewfinder" 3d image viewer, with round disks that provided real 3d. This one is probably dated 1950. 5) On the box by the toy police car, that's not a 'map', it's how older labels in the 50's were made, when the paper started to peal off, the blue backing showed. This is just wear. 6) The numbers on the walls, most likely reflect the movements of the trees. Under the white figure is the old map of the tree locations. Victor is tracking them. There is a group of 10 trees circled in the upper right, and direction of movement lines. 7) The white figure is holding up 6 fingers, it's deliberate, not just a bad drawing. I'll post this now, and edit additional comments. EDIT 8) The view out of the window changes dramatically from remembered night to actual day. Almost like it is a different window. Oddly they left the plowed road and the snow pile at the bottom, in the shot, it forms a deliberate line between the town and colony house. Us vs Them. That was a very important shot, as when she first arrived, this was not seen. Now it's meant for us to see. EDIT - 9) When Tabitha and Victor's dad get out, they'll be facing a police investigation for the missing Ambulance men and cop. Leaving is no longer a great option for them. EDIT: 10) The round object in the basement is a wool wheel, you feed sheared wool into it and spin (literally spin) it into yarn. It fits the decor, and would be a common household item before 1900. The press above it, with the T handle is also from the same time period, as is the icebox it is sitting on, and the wooden dresser behind it. They have probably been sitting there as the original objects moved into storage. The room also contains scales, shipping boxes and an artdeco swivel stool with arms, probably from the diner, and a hanging fruit basket rack. EDIT 11) Elgin is wearing a black bird on his t shirt. You will note that it wasn't visible clearly until he entered the basement and put on the hat. EDIT 12) I'm surprised the D4500CT BUS is still there, as the production would have to rent it every time they shoot it, unless they got a deal on a wreck, but it looks new to me. EDIT 13) When the town duplicates the outside world, it only copies part of it, for example, the MOTEL sign but no motel, and no room for one to have ever been there. EDIT 14) the numbers you obtained look to me like 1032, but my copy of the show has the paper scrubbed and no image is visible. EDIT 15) The bottles in the tree are not just to hold the numbers, but also so that the trees can be found again when the wind blows, because the trees move. The trees transport you to random places, but Victor's mother said that one tree was "special" as it would take her to the tower. He forgot to mention that it is reserved for the "chosen one" to go to the tower, which is why when Dale used it, he was transported into concrete. It was punishment. Perhaps transport to the tower is only allowed when you are of Victor's family or have something he owns. Perhaps. When Tabitha entered the tree the bottles clinked in order, indicating a coordinate transfer system. When Dale entered, the bottles did not clink, indicating no coordinates were routed. OK that's all I had to add. Thx.

[@Ready4Raw]

Thanks great comment!

[@jasoncaldwell5627]

GREAT observations, Eric!

[@EricDeanCampbell]

Oh, one thing I forgot in my big speech below, lol, is that when Boyd yelled "You CANT break me!" the only witness was the dog, who immediately bolted to tell the creatures. The dog's a spy. I'd like to go back over the entire series to see when the dog appears and what he learns.

[@BBBNESSA226]

That meeting pissed me off 😭. No one is sharing the right info or asking the right questions.

[@deilor7612]

Most people are dumb 🤷🏽‍♂️

[@beewest5704]

I knew it would not be the meeting we wanted. 😢

[@deilor7612]

@@beewest5704 Like Jade said, meetings with more than 3 people are useless. 😄

[@angelae5748]

No one was listening or being patient.

[@fitch099]

To be honest...the entire show and the lack of answers is making me as upset as those fromilies! We're on episode 5 done, half way thru season, and we havent learned anything new. I wonder if there is no ending planned. That would be a let down.

[@drippi2129]

I think when they do the ultrasound on Fatima, their going to see Diddy holding a bottle of baby oil.

[@geekademy]

🤣🤣🤣

[@lindawebb5379]

😂😂😂

[@teovu5557]

Meek mill voice: daaaaaaadddy yeaahah uHghJjjjjJJJjhhhhh

[@RJ-ek7ov]

😂

[@edwardgonzalez6331]

🤣

[@wellmanfarms9855]

My favorite quotes from FROM “Stop the GD bus!” “Donna! There’s a bus parked outside the diner!” “The marker was dry., it was a bad gift!” “If there are more than three people at a meeting, it’s pointless.” “You’re still the worst fng priest I ever met!” “Are you real?” “Yeah, I’m fng real., are you fng real??” “You so much complain… complain, complain… Stop complain!”

[@DelceniaDamesTucker]

Yes, You made me laugh, there are more Jade lines that I love but these are a great start.

[@yupitsme9713]

I agree 100%! I was yelling at the TV 😂 "yeah, go to the cops and tell them your people are stuck in monsterville and see what happens" Tabitha obviously left the boy in white out of her explanation. Victor lost hope when he was alone, I think that's why he lived so long. The boy in white is helping Victor, his friend. Victor's dad is the key.

[@jasoncaldwell5627]

Right? The woman found in the wood with a concussion is talking crazy? She'd be Baker Act'd in a flash.

[@mz.yumyum1461]

If she went to the police they would have automatically questioned her about where her family is thought she did something to them and she would have been locked up in a mental asylum oh wait they don't have those anymore okay she would have been put in jail!!! That's the new mental asylum!!!!

[@shaquilleknights3197]

Asking why Tabitha didn't tell anyone outside pissed me off like bro, when yall first entered the town even yall didn't believe.

[@TJM-2023]

They never showed the polaroid of Julie. I'm pretty sure that when we do see it, it will be a screaming dull-eyed Julie; because a camera captures the image of a person. The image of Julie is that she is feeling the screaming, hearing it; because she's still captive and no longer herself.

[@jasoncaldwell5627]

AGREED. I think they'll wait to show Julie in the photo as a smiling monster.

[@melissaw.2461]

I thought the same. It's gonna be a doozy

[@lilmami8877]

Yes I was waiting for this moment I need to see that picture! 😱

[@Alchemic09]

We all know Dale would be the one in the pool, but I expected him to fall from a great height or something, not fulfill the VERY CLEAR foreshadowing done in season 1 🤣

[@kriild]

I thought he would be half stuck with his lower body

[@beewest5704]

​@@kriildYes.

[@SoulyG]

What foreshadowing?

[@leonardogajdasic]

​@@SoulyGSomething about CONCRETE evidence I think

[@ElizRued]

Which foreshadow??*

[@katerinayotova3479]

I just want to say how much I appreciate your videos, there are so many out there just filling their videos with recaps pretending they have clues. You are the only one doing it for real! Thank you 🙏

[@dwaynesession5969]

Say it again because all these channels keep saying they have clues in their titles. The thing is that their clues are terrible. "Fromland" KZbin channel is by far the best. This channel is right next to it. In terms of production this channel "Geekademy" is the best. Second to none

[@dwaynesession5969]

youtube.com/@fromland?si=nrR7ampvD6coEWeX

[@Kurious_Kiwi]

This is by far my favourite episode. The emotional roller coaster was insane. Getting to laugh with Elgin and Julie. Crying for Henry and Victors reunion. The shock of someone being literally encased in concrete, I had my hand over my mouth the whole time, like Oh My Goooood. Good thing is FINALLY people are starting to discuss things! I really loved Tabitha and Jade's conversation in front of the tree. I'm also enjoying Sarah and Victors relationship, its very sweet. But during the town meeting I was super pissed off with Donna, she interrupted Henry when he was about to mention the bottle tree in the real world 🤯 like woman please shush! I find it very fascinating that Henry was void of hope for years but as soon as Tabitha arrived and told him Victor was alive, his hope was back, and then he was immediately pulled into Fromville. Also fascinating how Henry pointed out there's a motel sign and no motel. It made me think, maybe all the buildings were pulled into Fromville first, like all the trinkets and cars are.

[@enzoelise]

Go find the torch Boyd used to see the cave. Bring it to the town and light it and voila, the motel appears … the only problem with that is other things may appear also in the town. More sinister, older things.

[@elizabitty213]

I am so glad Boyd yelled at the people of the town! Like I get the idea that maybe it’s good to keep everyone’s spirits up but enough is enough, all these people are adults and need to join reality and help out! When those 14 people were killed by the monsters after Fatima’s party, the whole household left Donna alone to clean up and bury everyone like wtf?!! No more of this nonsense, all hands on deck lol sorry rant over lol

[@shalinalewis2957]

👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾

[@elizabitty213]

@@shalinalewis2957 lol thank you ☺️ 🤣😅

[@TheCasanovaPugilist147]

yeah the people of Boydville really need to listen to Boyd. It's his town after all.

[@elizabitty213]

@@TheCasanovaPugilist147 hahahaha yeah I mean they are all fine to let Boyd and Donna and Tian Chen do all the work around town while they just walk around and do nada but when things go wrong, everyone’s got better ideas lol

[@shalinalewis2957]

Now hopefully people will shut up about daily or weekly town meetings 😂

[@TheCasanovaPugilist147]

Things are heating up in Boydville.. I mean Fromville. Really liking this season so far. Can't wait for next episode and see what happens next in Boydville... Fromville Fromville I mean Fromville.

[@LeaGholson-t6w]

Lol Boydville, he did say it was his town. I was like when did it become yours🤔

[@TheCasanovaPugilist147]

@@LeaGholson-t6w it's always has been Boyd's. Don't you forget it😉

[@jasoncaldwell5627]

I think burying personal effects of the dead prevents them from becoming monsters. That's why the Boy In White told Victor to bury that stuff in the suitcase. And remember, theonsters each keep items or personal effects inside the monster tunnels. Now we see the stuff "buried" in a trunk from the 80's in the basement. I can't believe there wasn't a can of hairspray in there. Or hair gel. Journey on cassette tape. I think destroying the personal effects destroys the monsters. I think it's their weakness.

[@harbingerranch]

Dang this show is bringing all the emotion this year. Man Victors reunion with his Dad was great TV. Wow!

[@BattleDamageProps]

Randal wasnt having a seizure. Let me explain, one of the things we were taught when dealing with casualties overseas is to make sure your buddy dosen't have his weapon in his hand if he comes to. What happens is they may relive their last conscious moment and act it out. Randal just regained conciousness and thiught he was still being messed with by the monsters. That and blood loss, he's in shock. Hope that helps.

[@jasoncaldwell5627]

Poor Randall- they had to stitch his face closer without painkillers. I hope they gave him morphine once he was at the Medical building/school.

[@BattleDamageProps]

@@jasoncaldwell5627 good news is most of his skin was there, so they could just clean it all and flop it back on for it to heal up with the stitches.

[@nikkienikkie4310]

The bottle on the coffee table in colony house was used as a candle holder. A popular idea in the 60's/70s using wine bottles typically - god Im old lol

[@NiconD80]

I get the point of ppl asking questions about police - they are now desperate and think, she could just go there, ask about missing ppl and say that she knows where they are. But 1) c'mon, who would believe in town with monsters, 2) you can't just ask google maps to create a road to Fromville. If town wants to solve the tree riddle they must collect all information, not just in fragments. Boyd also didn't talk a lot about his tree experience. They could invite Julie , because she also used the tree. I'm disappointed about this whole meeting - instead of listening and asking right questions, they were just shouting.

[@beewest5704]

Is Victor onto something wanting to find Jasper? Did Fromville try to distract him by bringing his father to the town?

[@JoeysMagGoth]

The moment they stepped into the basement I thought "Igor is gonna have field day here!" 😆

[@geekademy]

😄

[@jesslovesdisney9362]

Your rant about the town meeting was hilarious, because it was EXACTLY how I felt too!!!😂

[@Larry_Canonica]

I think we can quit it with the notion that Henry is a bad dude or hiding something. The missing motel is kind of the elephant in the room. And we'll, Henry just said it. I wonder if it will be important. You would think the town folk would be more cautious after surviving even a single night 8n Fromville. I also have this notion regarding the numbers. What if they are the distance of the trees. The same numbers Victor had made his life work. And did anyone notice the merry go round is in one of the images with a giant arrow pointing at it?

[@siimakyaks]

Your rant was so hilarious and satisfying! That town meeting was frustrating af.

[@kaylen6302]

Thanks for the amazing videos. You’re so humble . Best from theory creator 🥳

[@TipToe71]

Omg I cried like a baby when Victor reunited with his father 😢 also could those number are coordinates? I also think the numbers Victor has written down could maybe be about the trees? Idk I remember he counts the amount of inches the trees move. Also I just gotta say Thank you because your videos are literally the best when it comes to discussing From.

[@Gabriela-zi1wl]

I think exactly the same as you! Victor numbers have a map too with green triangles (trees) and the numbers inside bottles wore all out when dale enters the three so I think they are coordinates and victor knows more about the magic trees

[@carlie-10]

Loving the longer videos!

[@Calinotch06]

Ellis is so useless, but he tells Boyd that all he does is sit around? wtf

[@wellmanfarms9855]

Hey, so glad you MADE another video. This is the best commentary one can find for all things FROM. I LOVE IT! This is my therapy session- Have you ever heard of the show Talking Dead? It’s an after-show for fans of the Walking Dead. You would be great at interviewing the stars and analyzing the storyline! Plus, I would love to hear interviews from the writers., think about it! Fans could play quiz show games about your theories and win merchandising related to the From show- like a mini bottle tree, or a metal lunchbox via Victor. 😅😂 Thanks for your thoughts- it does my soul well

[@Elwood128]

That George Carlin opening bit was brilliant.

[@schuuty]

I believe The Boy in White understands (or perhaps controls?) the faraway trees’ mechanics, and if he’s not involved in the usage of them in some capacity, the person who steps into one of them gets a Dale ticket. The bottle tree is seemingly the only one that can potentially take worthy/invited people to the lighthouse, but there are other trees that took people to places where they were supposed to go too. How the numbers are connected to it, I really cannot guess yet, but I don’t think they are about that one specific tree, more like the trees in general. Trees and their roots are a huge theme in the show. I don’t think the faraway trees are temperamental per se, we just don’t understand how they work yet. I should watch the whole series again to double check, but if I remember correctly, there was not a single instance when someone used a faraway tree (and lived to tell the tale) without the Boy in White’s interference or say so. Please correct me if I’m wrong.

[@nazimjones4573]

I think they are 3 bottle trees and the roots connect making the symbol he keeps seeing.

[@jasoncaldwell5627]

I think each dimension gets a Bottle Tree. Fromville, Camden, the Lighthouse are all in separate dimensions. I think the four digit numbers inside the bottles are coordinates for the tree teleporter. Removing them moves the teleporter destination so the Tree no longer goes to the Lighthouse but into the pool wall.

[@trippy5519]

that final scene actually disturbed me damn

[@juliusbank9561]

Lowkey made my skin crawl

[@robertsaunders1345]

Great video as always Igor. Doesn't the basement in Colony House where Julie and Elgin found the polaroid camera look like the same location in Victor's flashback of Christopher talking to Jasper. Likewise, the basement stone arches look like the arches of the Martin's dungeon. Lastly, the bicycle looks like the bicycle that Jade stole. Keep up the great work.

[@jes88sim]

I have never been more convinced that Victor mapped out the bottle trees and he made them.

[@jasoncaldwell5627]

Maybe- but there's a huge map on the rear of Victor's trailer that we need to see again.

[@michaelwindon681]

I think you are right about Clara, Elton was in the house with her, but when juli comes in he is about to wack her! Clara was in there tormenting him, then she comes in late and not hearing the story but she is the loudest. she giving away herself...

[@Larisa_Baker]

I think the numbers in the bottles are house numbers. I think that Tabetha went safely from the tree to the lighthouse and out because Victor gave her his lunch box and it had his house number written inside. Perhaps they need to have a certain destination and a house number to get out.

[@Ready4Raw]

It was good to see Elgin and Julie being silly and smiling.

[@wellmanfarms9855]

The black thing looks like a “View finder” a toy that you hold up to your eyes like binoculars and you see cool 3-d pics of different animals, objects, people… usually Disney characters or similar One of my favorite nostalgic toys: Now, they sell them to look like it, but you can upload your own pictures to it- but , back in the day, you had these tiny, circular negative size inserts that fit them. Hold it up to the light, and you have a vivid, three D pic

[@nikkienikkie4310]

I had one as a kid in the 60's

[@JR-bm8dl]

It is a Viewmaster. I still have the one I got for Christmas in the 60’s along with reels of the moon landing, TV shows and movies.

[@Mofi357]

I got "Bambi" and "Cars" movie lol

[@jasoncaldwell5627]

It's worth noting that Tabitha has had multiple concussions- one just THE DAY BEFORE. Seriously people. Tabitha was babbling on the ambulance because she had her head bashed for the third time in a few months (tops!)

[@jeffreyarndt2066]

If you follow Julie down the stairs of Colony House (21.44), the wall behind her has a large red stain (ripped wallpaper) with 2 holes that look like eyes. It looks like the red monster from the cave drawings. I can't believe it's a coincidence.

[@Alchemic09]

Everyone thought this was the episode people would finally grow a brain and start communicating, we see jade and tabby sharing stories, the townmeeting etc. instead it is the episode where 90% of the town behave like rabid animals, and interrupts the person they ask something of, on the first 5 letters.. The ending redeemed it though

[@jasoncaldwell5627]

Now we'll get two new people - replacements for Nikki and Dale. Hopefully the new people will be less annoying.😜

[@sumtingwong8592]

30:08 this scene and shot specifically messed with me, why have so much open screen space just for that empty chair next to Elgin. Was on edge because looked like kimono lady was gonna be sitting there, thay whole scene threw me off because felt like potential clues. Never got to see Julie's photo.

[@joannawinters6592]

The only thing Tabby could have done better was to not freak out and cause the accident. Otherwise she didn't have time enough. If she had more time there, outside, she could have searched for other people who might have gotten out, together with Henry.

[@brittanyofhouseblackwood]

So I've seen people complaining other places about Miranda hearing voices because of the LSD trip and how they think it's stupid, but what people don't get is that there are literal scientific studies done on psychedelics and parallel universes! Specifically DMT which is the chemical in your brain that makes you dream and that floods your brain upon bodily death! There's a reddit thread about how 94% of people who have done DMT have seen the SAME ENTITY'S and have seen the same places during their trip! "DMT, psilocybin, mescaline, and other similar chemicals allow the brain to better observe quantum phenomena that are always occurring" a quote from a KZbin video on a study! DMT is in the part of your brain called the penile gland and that also happens to be where mysticism says your "3rd eye" is located! It's actually really cool and really valid for this show! Also I used to do drugs many years ago and I've done 3 types of hallucinogens and I've seen some pretty unbelievable things that I can't even explain! 😂

[@berisilin1337]

If you remember well Martin said that there are things in the forest that people were never meant to see. It's kind of the same thing in "From Beyond" 1986, where they use a device to see beyond our normal perception, which allows them to see creatures who can in return see them and attack them. The device works by enlarging the pineal gland (which is the one I think you meant to talk about). But if people complain about this theory it might because the fact that people see something when they are high doesn't mean it's real, could just be hallucinations and not visions.

[@jasoncaldwell5627]

Great post. Now, go back and watch the end of episode two and episode three again. The camera keeps focusing on people drinking the water. Jim drinks a glass of water from the tap and suddenly the phone rings- something his kids didn't hear. Elgin is drinking water and suddenly sees the Kimono ghost. Each time Elgin sees her he's bathing or drinking the water. There's several more scenes of people drinking the water in episode three. A crazy suspicious amount. I think the water is contaminated with Ergot- it grows nation the woods of north America and causes Hallucinations, paranoia, hand tremors and madness. Sound familiar?

[@brittanyofhouseblackwood]

@@jasoncaldwell5627 isn't that a theory about what happened during the Salem Witch trials? People being poisoned and hallucinating?

[@brittanyofhouseblackwood]

@@berisilin1337 yes! That's it...autocorrect ducking sucks lmfao

[@Bigguy13-sy6mk]

If you believe psychedelics actually let you see another reality or something your probably a moron. Hate to say it but the truth hurts

[@kelsey.targaryen]

Interesting note about seizures. They take place in your frontal cortex, which is also responsible for your emotions. So it seems like this place gives people seizures and effects to make them emotionally, weak and more vulnerable to the monsters.

[@berisilin1337]

14:30 Nicky died so we could have the cannibal scene with Fatima. Also I was wondering if the bullet might have damaged Nicky's intestine so the blood was tainted with "wastes". 32:46 They are being stupid because if Tabitha had said something to the police and they believed her, she would have probably ended up being a test subject and not in any position to help Fromville people. Yes I watched X-Files a lot :D 44:50 It looks like some kind of crafting device, maybe a spinning wheel to make yarn. 48:00 We don't know if Julie's picture is normal, they start playing with it before they look at it, there still is a possibility for a weird thing on the picture. 1:03:14 I'm sure most of us and not only Boyd had this "told you so" moment. We just knew. Also I think the CGI is meant to look like that because it makes Dale's agony even more grotesque and horrific.

[@RahYisrael99]

Tabitha could have told these things to her mom. Anything makes more sense than her lying saying they're all safe together

[@17jades17]

Tabitha also would've become a suspect in a potential murder case of her family, because where are they? and no a magic village filled with night monsters is not an answer. She would have either been locked up in jail or a psychiatric institution tbh. She already had a police escort with her in the ambulance. So I also would not have said anything and just kept a low profile.

[@jyguzman933]

The town meeting wasn't useless to me as it was to make people understand that Boyd is there to keep them safe specially after what happen if you just go thru the tree. Is for people to trust and listen to Boyd.

[@Marchingvenusaur]

Jade was hilarious in this episode. I hope that he and Tabitha have a little adventure arc regarding figuring out the bottle tree. I do like Tabitha's character more now just because she is one of the only Matthews Family members who is REALLY looking for answers and doing things.

[@Trifelivin]

We are never finding out what is outside the tiny cabins. 💯

[@TuffLuv1984]

I think the numbers at the tree are coordinates? Makes sense cus it takes you places and if you mess up… you end up half encased in cement.

[@Calinotch06]

What did they want Tabitha to do. Even if she got people to believe, help her, and return with them - How would the new arrivals help them get out? How can the police help them remotely?

[@MollsMollica]

Boyd's kid has some balls. All he does is get high and draw all day.

[@jasoncaldwell5627]

And screw his hot girlfriend and get stabbed. Could be a worse life, honestly. We need to look at Ellis' drawings and room. Ellis has a pencil drawing of the glass from the Lighthouse on his wall. The painting on the wall behind the bed is obviously Miranda's work- not Ellis'!

[@moniquee9685]

The first clips are EXACTLY how I felt watching the diner scene ! So frustrating!

[@antoniomoore2520]

The map is the faraway trees and the places it takes you. Victor has been keeping track of the trees and where you end up. Also i believe in the finale of last season Jade saw the symbol and it work like a map of which trees lets you leave pike a subway map!

[@PurpleAlize]

22:17 the map you mentioned, Jade found the same box of blocks when he went into Victor's room,

[@jaymierae9890]

10:30 Jim is the worst.

[@memohattami6898]

I hate him so so so much from the start agggh ,, and dont let me complain about his whole family 🤦🏼‍♀️

[@DelceniaDamesTucker]

LOL!!! This is the funniest recap that you've done to date, I was laughing my butt off! I so appreciate everything that you stated, and I felt the exact same way. Great recap/review, I can't wait for the next one. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@RoyRoyce_]

I was so glad to see dale go, he was on my nerves so bad i was yelling at the tv lol

[@chidelin3]

@geekademy I really think something happened to Randall in his backstory that involves abandonment. If you think back to his first night in the bus, the monsters were talking to him and tapping on the door. Randall then started flipping out on them, and as he was talking they walked away. He started yelling at them not to walk away from him. When he yelled at Boyd it just made me flash back to that moment. I think the monsters are using that weakness to manipulate him.

[@helamanafitu5694]

Victor and his pops made me cry never cried so much in a show

[@AymanAlzahrani]

that intro made me watch the whole video and like and subscribe, great job I love the way you analyzed the episode

[@beewest5704]

😂😂😂 love your rants. Glad I stumbled on your channel!

[@elvieann4949]

Whenever they say they need to tell people and get help. I wonder what exactly they expect the "help" to do? Do they worry that maybe they'll strand the "help."

[@jasonthomas9729]

Your intros are getting really good lol In defense of the diner people It kinda makes sense. We don't know the background of the characters, what level of education they have, what life experience, how long they have been here and how stressed they are etc. During Covid we saw all kind of crazy reactions from groups of people in real life. This type of stuff isn't that unbelievable.

[@Gabriela-zi1wl]

The worst part of the meeting was people not letting Henry finish what he was saying,cuz the whole victors mom story was so important ,that made me so angry !at this point this people doesn’t even deserve to know

[@skullscorp]

Just hang one single bottle with one number only and it should take you to that one place/time etc because it will have no other choice because there will be no other bottles. The only problem I see it that they will be probably not able to get back. Why don't they ask Victor - he knows a lot about the travelling trees 🤦‍♂🤦‍♂🤦‍♂🤦‍♂🤦‍♂

[@elizabitty213]

This episode was jam packed! WOW! 🤯 Cannot wait to hear your theories on this! Now I watch ❤

[@jaebeablessings1005]

Remember, Victor measures whether the trees have moved, and they have. Those numbers are near trees in the drawings, and the zeros are circled over more than once...not sure what that means. The first scene, you asked about the bottle on table...it is a melted down candle in a bottle. Pretty common in 70's or hippie era. The thing on Victor's nightstand looks like a view master toy. You look through the other end and view the slide of images. That doll head on the wall, just looks like a mannequin head with an ink pen sticking out of mouth. Something some would think is cool or funny when their high??

[@jasoncaldwell5627]

The head on the wall behind Tilly shows her two faces nature. She's pretending to be something she's not.

[@lisasafay536]

Ah! You had me at George Carlin! The best there was!

[@DoeDitto]

Now we see why colony and town are split… the town meeting didnt work 🤣😭

[@ru99414]

This series is so good for the right reasons, no matter how it ends up. Nothing is frustrating, behavior of characters is largely not blown out and exaggerated. Seems like they actually know how frustrating much of main-stream series are, therefore I always feel like every minute of each episode is worth the time. Just allowing the teenager girl and black dude to have a conversation and fun without escalating it for no reason shows some dignity from creators...

[@toxicflame15]

tabitha woulda been thrown in handcuffs and interrogated for months

[@KaylasBestie]

Enjoyed the video. I've said this before and will continue till the end .... As much as I ADORE Victor, he's an unreliable narrator ... in all honesty, you CAN NOT believe EVERYTHING that he says. This is a young boy, full of trauma, in the body of a grown man. Victor forgets, refuses to talk, and lawd knows what else ... I wanna believe all the things that he says, but I can't. We also wondered why or what would happen if a town meeting was held .... now we know. 😢

[@ammeg3404]

Unless Victor’s “sister” Elouise was just a parentless child that his mom took in and just told him to treat her like his sister. It’s not adding up. Because the dad didn’t even ask “what about Elouise?”. It’s weird!

[@Trifelivin]

You are tops in FROM content! Look forward to your videos every week

[@JNR22B]

He was calculating the movement of the trees perhaps

[@crazywomancreek1]

Jade is my favorite character. Boyd is annoying. The not following through on these story lines is annoying. This is the 2nd season with Tillie. If she or Donna are up to no good, they need to reveal SOMETHING! Tabitha not getting help: how the f is someone supposed to get help?! You never know how you’re going to get to the town! Plus, she wasn’t there long enough to get anything done. The boy in white probably opened the portal for her to get through the tree to the tower, but not for Dale. Help? You see what the cop did. She started shooting everywhere.

[@lyly25lila65]

Exactly go to the authorities and tell them what? I got lost with my family in this place where monsters come out at night and none is able to leave ,but some way I left coz some kid's ghost pushed me from the lighthouse,they will probably put her in jail and start looking for the dead bodies of the rest of he family

[@missDataScience235]

No one rants as good as us Slavs😂It felt so satisfying❤️

[@szajkaninidanda]

Other predictions: 1. There is a big bad that want to escape 2. To escape it needs certain actions from certain people 3. The goal is to make townpeople miserable so special ones (for sure Boyd, Tabitha and Jade, maybe someone else is also essential) need to break the curse that trapped BB (big bad) in this place. 4. BB has magical powers but not limitless. Monsters are its minions. BB can hear the conversations and looks at real world and it says stuff to monsters. 5. Boy in white is a BB or its minon. He is manipulation and putting pieces to places so he can get the result (breaking the curse). He COULD tell Victor how to escape all these years thet they were friends, couldnt he? He does not want Victor to go. 6. Previous cycles were failed attempts. 7. Something went wrong the last cycle so the BB "reset" killing everyone. Or BB realised that it need one person like Victor to do something. Or actually last cycle people were close to break the curse. And Christopher actually saved lur world by sending monters to kill everyone. 8. BB cannot talk to monsters during the night. It only tells them stuff during the day. 9. There are also other monsters in fromville so BB needs to make people conditions bad but also keep most importa t ones alive so they will not stupidly die. These are my thoughts

[@jovonecater6691]

Ik its a reach, but could eloise be that thing outside? Fresh vegetables planted, those “scare crows” can act similar to talisman, etc., traps being planted

[@TheJeof1000]

On Boyd trying to catch one or to know where they are hiding during the day... what do we know about the Monsters, they are slow, meaning they don't run and afraid of daylight. How about, while in the bus, in the crack of dawn, when they about to go back and hide, "Boyd follows the monster back to there hideout" they can't hurt him or even or they can't stay out that long for the sun is going out or even run... What do you think?

[@joannawinters6592]

But they know where they are, don't they?

[@TheJeof1000]

@@joannawinters6592 i don't think so.

[@allcitybighec]

Igor roasting the characters is hilarious

[@el_moviefan]

I am so angry at people thinking that Fatima going to the police would result in anything useful. You can literally go the police and say that you were robbed or raped, and they would gaslight you into believing that nothing happened lol. A friend of mine was robbed once and the police was like “nah, you lost it, don’t lie”. And I was the witness that he was robbed!! 😅

[@beewest5704]

She would just ended up in a psych ward. The police will think she has something to do with her familiy's disappearance & Fromville is just her cover story.

[@el_moviefan]

@@beewest5704 yess! Exactly!

[@grindtoothmedia120]

Experience has taught me that people generally do not listen very well at all. In fact, they are often distracted by other things in their minds, they can hear things that were not said, and interpret things in ways that are entirely opposite to what was said. When I was younger, this shocked me. Now that I am older, I anticipate it and take more steps to ensure instructions, or things I say, are heard and understood as they are intended. Regardless, I was also frustrated by the town meeting scene. Writers get carried away with creating conflict and sacrifice smart characters to serve that conflict far too often. That kind of character inconsistency can ruin a show, story, or a character severely if it happens too frequently. I find this happens a lot more in modern television productions. I suspect it's because the writers come and go more frequently, especially if the show carries on for several seasons.

[@jenniferrose745]

A like and a comment simply for the Supernatural reference. It made me giggle. Loving your From content.

[@chasehenderson8773]

"Was she listening with her @$$?" Dude... oh my gosh. I'm keeping that line for life.

[@raulortiz547]

If we include quantum mechanics. The children watching the roots grown might have caused a constant collapse of the wave-function (somehow) and created the Fromville CTC paradox loop, now, evidently this is not a time related loop but only spatial loop. We also know that the lighthouse and dungeon are not accessible by normal means. Meaning they might be further loops. The faraway trees are redirectional cones within the anomaly loop. Imagine a circle and the cones dictate the directional curvature of the loop. Onces you move within a cone you are redirected wherever the cone goes. Thus they keep going back to the plac they began at. But that does not mean there can't be secondary cones that direct off the circle ind to other sub-loops, the faraway trees. The numbers in the bottles must have something to do with the state of the cones and how to redirect them. Is it related to light? Boyd lighting the torch brought him back to the dungeon, but just when the torch was back to it's original state. Also the lighthouse is an important light source. Or maybe its object related. There is a reason why the show has given importance to the objects in storage, in Vic's suitcase and Sarah's christmas ornament, in the cave and now under colony house. I can't help but feel like it's related to quantum states and the observer theory and how to collapse the wave-function into specific states. And these objects help collapse the function into certain states because of memories. In quantum physics, a tree exists in every possible quantum state until it is observed. For example, a tree could be both fallen and not fallen at the same time. The outcome of the tree depends on the observer's observation. It is strange that the characters only enter the loop once they observe the fallen trees/roots and collapse that wave-function for that state. While the children observe the trees to make sure they remain in the not-fallen state, causing the loop. Bacause of this, it makes sense that the re-directional cone anomalies are within trees too. How did someone in the times before Einstein figure out that continuously collapsing the wave-function would cause a CTC? IDK. Maybe it was a modern experiment (70's) and it caused a retroactive anomally. If state-related, would placing the trees back in the not-fallen state be the solution, just like putting the torch back in the burning state caused a spatial change?

[@grisselabreu3817]

I think maybe Victor was adding and subtracting his steps to reach the tree line? It does look like he drew trees right next to his equation… and its mentioned that the trees are “alive”

[@LeaGholson-t6w]

"Everyone there is so F'n stupid" 😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@angelae5748]

2659 could be February 6, 1959. It could be someone's birth date, someone's death date, or a date of some historic event.

[@austin91522]

Not gonna lie. Never thought about the whole “motel is completely missing thing” victors dad is on to something