(G)I-DLE Is Too Controverisal in the Latest Comeback?

[@d-4azerty755]

What's happening with this (G)I-DLE comeback? A 1.1 billion won investment, all for two MVs? - No, the 1.1 billion won covers the entire comeback, not just the MVs. This includes costs for song recording for the entire album, music video production, promotion, visuals, merchandising, travel, accommodation, etc. Accused of multiple plagiarism? - Allegations from random Twitter users crying about a dance move or a dress color aren't plagiarism. Canceled schedules, two members hospitalized for overwork? - People can get sick; i know, it's crazy. Banned songs? - Only KBS has banned a song from its broadcast network. Worst of all, being criticized for leveraging feminism for fame and money? - Women who write, produce, and sing about women's empowerment since their debut and achieve success for it. Still better than achieving fame and success because your studio orders an entire album from someone else.

[@BeBossTV]

Woah... First, thank you for tuning into the video, and second, I do appreciate your respectful criticism of the points brought up in this video. Personally, I totally agree with you in the last point and when doing research about how Cnetizens having really negative reaction about the girls' promotion, I also feel like they were trying to nitpick and cherry pick specifically this comeback just to support their hate.

[@piasquare]

no 1.1 billion just for super lady mv!

[@misteryemisterye]

They just confirm now that its soley for MV only

[@lmy327]

Haters are trying really hard here.........

[@Bloomingkpop6661]

But it's true dude by some pace, I'm a neverland, trying my best, but theirs streams and views are flop by their standards...

[@musicc-nmixx]

@@Bloomingkpop66611.2 million pre orders is a flop?

[@Bloomingkpop6661]

@@musicc-nmixx Yeah sure, the pre-orders were not, everybody had high expectations. Song was nice too, but for some reason it is not charting very well! Wayy worse than queen and nxde...

[@musicc-nmixx]

@@Bloomingkpop6661 yeah they already got robbed by a music show when they got 0 points for physical sales so

[@esther1900]

Why can't you understand that this song isn't that good?

[@babette5918]

(G)I-dle DIDN'T change any lyrics to "Wife". Looks like when it came down to the money... (G)I-dle chose integrity. Unlike the makers of this video.

[@ariatripleizandxin]

I would like to say something, companies do take legal permissions before taking other concepts. IT IS ALL DONE LEGALLY.

[@canufindthemall]

This video is so foolish lol 🤣 Gidle is one of THE most iconic groups in kpop rn I think people can't digest a self producing FEMALE idol group, that produces albums to title tracks AND decides the concepts 🤣

[@BeBossTV]

Thank you for tuning into the video 🩷 Actually, I was on the girls’ side and the whole video is about discussing all the matters in their latest comeback 💪🏻

[@vixxexo6855]

Self producing does not mean better. Sometimes it is better that proffesionals do their job. Like Wife has so meaningless lyrics and is beyond cringe. Also what is everyone’s obsession with playing victims? No wonder nobody likes feminists. Not everything is because of gender.

[@caliguladurrendon2764]

(G)I-DLE went all out with this one, it's not going to be for everyone, and domestic charts are not the best measure of success. I'd rather support a group that has a message and stays true to themselves than one that simply goes with trends and produces stuff that isn't distinctive. If it's controversial with incels and anti-feminists, I'd say it's working.

[@indisa099]

They're perfect, go girls!

[@BeBossTV]

Indeed!!! They should have been praised rather than being twisted as the villain ☠️

[@campaignresources]

The comparisons to 2NE1, which happens to be pronounced as 21, are ridiculous. In fact all of these controversies are ridiculous. Anyone who uses internet trolls known as netizens as a news source has no credibility.

[@regretisathingofthepast]

Haters gonna hate...K-Netz are gonna bitch. I-DLE is setting their own boundaries. Get used to it.

[@cherry-yr6zj]

Gidle *breathe* Netizens: they're plagiarizing *inserte whatever name you want* 😡

[@misteryemisterye]

People should learn the diff between Plagiarism and Inspiration And the MV shots and concept photos laid out in this video are just generic; other artists did those before. Why are we always jumping on GIDLE every comeback

[@palkoy1278]

Haters always HATE but my mothers ATE

[@flapyap2051]

(G)I-DLE decided NOT to change the lyrics to be resubmitted. This video is providing false information. They stand by their message and insinuating that they did not is insulting.

[@babette5918]

Looks like when it came down to the money... (G)I-dle chose integrity. Unlike the makers of this video.

[@vixxexo6855]

Wife has no message. It is just meaningless lyrics like what is my «my loom is so twinkle twinkle.»

[@flapyap2051]

cant help that you're a dense headed racist @@vixxexo6855

[@slavushonokmixes]

@@vixxexo6855You can always check their previous songs. It’s all due to prevailing primitivism. Every group does that. Annoying but at least idle actually did smth new

[@laylisajeniane3657]

so if i say one ,two,three in my song in korea it plagia now ok

[@MB-ic3ou]

Wait… uplifting women and empowering women to believe in themselves is… controversial?? oh we are never making it out for he patriarchy i fear

[@vixxexo6855]

Super Lady is not the controversial song, but Wife. Wife has meaningless lyrics and Miyeon’s part is explicit in korean.

[@jdj10078]

when there is much controversy over songs , videos, lyrics. it only makes you want to watch listen more....SMART

[@user-xg3qr8ue8e]

Haters are asshole

[@Itx_gidleu]

Look even if haters gonna hate and netzens are just jealous, Neverland will always support them and I think that naming it Superlady is really made for all the kpop women and bringing back the 2th and 3tt gen we need more of this Hiphop, retro style!!! 🔥😎🔪🏴‍☠️All gidle salyyy

[@BeBossTV]

🔥🔥🔥

[@innnews6299]

Not wasted at all. The best album, songs & concepts of the year.

[@Jennie.almeida]

Nah not the best

[@earthshuman3864]

Really they are doing best at music right now only 4th gen girl group that have women wibe while other have teen Watching them is fun and have mature aura unlike other groups

[@BeBossTV]

You are so true!! I think they are also the only one to constantly speak up about societal problems, especially misogyny, and few famous girl groups have done that ever 👑

[@sandanic.3488]

Haters gonna hate anyway. Let's just ignore them.

[@user-xf2vf9wn5j]

Sorry, but there are some truly amazing songs on that album. The overwhelming sense I have as a neutral is that the wrong ones may have been selected to lead with.

[@BeBossTV]

📢 Update chart ranking of 'Super Lady': “Super Lady” on the MelOn daily chart, peaked at #30 before starting to fall in the rankings. On the hourly chart, the highest the song reached was #21 briefly on January 30 around 9AM KST. Pann users also pointed out that this is the "worst-debuting rank" song of (G)I-IDLE, even lower than “Senorita” and “Oh My God."

[@stonehands1142]

The music show wins and rise in charts will come eventually just based on the empty house they have for the next two weeks. More importantly, "Super Lady" was written and designed by Soyeon to give the group a proper opening song for their tours and concerts as they target a transition from 5,000-10,000 capacity venues to 10,000-20,000 capacity arenas. It's the demo for fan expectations when they go to a (G)I-dle show now.

[@blablabla-dq5ch]

As at to date ... They won 3 already

[@babette5918]

2 weeks later and it still hasn't peaked yet. Both "Wife" and "Super Lady" made it into the top 10 of some charts.

[@jdj10078]

i love Idle my favorite group, you never know what is going to happen with these ladies, they are unpredictable and go at their own pace...there is no other group with the looks, style and experimentation as Idle....i love their attitudes, always thinking outside the box, they are so funny too. i dearly love them so much...i never get so excited for new music from them...i know it is never boring and always the talk of the town for whatever reason....they are so different so talented so loved.

[@Yorashin4605]

I bet they are blinks

[@nothanks5162]

It looks like when it comes down to money they...no girl, They might've done the song, but the company still has a say. They accepted the controversial lyrics at first but the company cannot be behind not getting any promotion whatsoever. They still need to eat and keep the lights on. And G-Idle is the money maker right now. They get a say, but they're still working in a company. They need to make some money or else no one can see them. Also... can't people get inspiration from something? Everything's already been done. You add a new color, tune, vibe, feeling to it and make it yours. That's what artists do. Sure, sometimes you'll strike gold, but you can't do it every single year, every few months. Like come on man. They're hated for referencing others while other idols do the same thing over and over again, with barely any inspiration behind any of it. Most don't even help make the song or anything. It just...worked once so now, let's do it again. It goes to show that women can't do well without getting pushed back every single time they make a move.

[@dmitrykim3096]

1.5 million sales first week, 5th in kpop history by a girl group. Haters gonna hate

[@robbybautista249]

I feel sorry for those haters,well if they fall on melon music well i just read that they got good rank in itunes,specially in the U.S. still congrats,about the picture of coppying i just pass by one picture of LESERAFIM i dont what hybe was thinking havent they saw the one group that just also i think release new song or album both groups are.almost wearing a almost look a like clothes the only difference is their back ground?one is black.

[@wiwrld7531]

this account are haters and all haters are trying to make gidle go down. so stfu . the queen is back madafaka! 👸

[@roline.c]

It's obviously a tribute not coping

[@mamanucht7333]

People who hate on wife are nasty their rooms obviously dont twinkle twinkle

[@jdj10078]

Gidle never disappoints ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤😊

[@xvaeirs]

tbh I think the SLAYED this comeback. Hate isn't what they deserve sure maybe to YOU its a bit different. But hey, every kpop group gets a bad comeback you can't just hate them.

[@jdj10078]

oh my they wore white fur what a crime , what about everyone else that wore white fur , it is a STYLE omg so silly

[@leaadorna5682]

,,just stay healthy gidle❤

[@ressivVEVO]

It gave me 2ne1 and after school

[@Pookasoul]

Where do you get your infos, dude? You got several things outright wrong. I-dle never changed and never considered changing the lyrics for Wife. Never. Cube literally put out an announcement saying that Wife was a B-side, and they would focus on promoting the title song, not changing Wife's lyrics for broadcast.

[@playamelodythateverybodyknows]

their recent comebacks was fun...but i always comeback to lion, hwaa and omg era it was just epic

[@Ranmaru95]

I can relate, even the B-sides Dahlia, Maybe, Put it straight were superiors :x I like the comeback tho, but I won't find me listening to it on repeat I think

[@o_o9220]

Nahh Gidle is serving❤

[@Jennie.almeida]

Serving shit 😂

[@jasonreyes8654]

Kpop fandom can be the most toxic I swear

[@catherinethecatlike]

The pronunciation of some of the words like “2NE1” “Aespa” make it difficult to watch this video 😬

[@slavushonokmixes]

Ну Люси, ну богема 😍 И Мия раскрылась по-новой. Ну Королевы!

[@rinimarlina2201]

Kbs is going crazy they let I know I love you ftom txt WHICH LITTERALY HAS THE LYRIC PLS USE ME LIKE A DRUG. NEW JEANS COOKIE WHICH THE LYRICS HUH WELL AND MACARONI AND CHESE BY YOUNG POSYE WHITCH LITTERLY HAS THE LINE MACARONI CHESE DRIPIN ON MY BODY LIKE WTF WHY BAN WIFE WHEN ALL OF THOSE SONG IN MY OPINION WAY WORSE

[@0dnieflores]

Hahaha haters gonna hate. .thats all. True fans will appreciate

[@ROYAL_BTS_ARMY-fp1cf]

THERE ARE TWO VERSIONS OF SEVEN FOR A REASON 😂😂😂JUNGKOOK IS SMART 💜🥰

[@LordUni123]

Why is it a controversy if you refer to your peers and previous inspirations? Tbh to me it looks like haters going the extra mile to throw shades. They could have criticised the songs for their musical value. Super Lady and Wife aren't the most impactful tracks they released.... but instead the haters focus on irrelevant things

[@luffyoongles]

shut up already lmao

[@marcellawong229]

SoYoung is to blame !!!!😤

[@BABYMONSTER_RORA_RAMI_AHYEON]

What ????

[@alexabliss7800]

I think this song is kind of like "Teachers" by Daft Punk. It's like they are just giving credit to lots of people who they think deserve it because they have been important and made an impact. If that was the case, I loved the idea. (+I think IDLE is already finishing their job, they are on the final stretch)

[@pocky11stick]

right, after soojon departures idle been doing too much feminism

[@sindieltaylor2147]

'Too much feminism'🤮

[@noroaa]

cuz its true, if soojin was a male in a boyband he would stay

[@sandanic.3488]

Too much feminism? Even before Soojin departure idle always had feminism coded in their songs