Gair islami tareeky se zibah kiya gaya gosht bismisllah per kar khana? Javed Ahmad Ghamidi

#islam #quran #ghamidi #sajidhameed #almawrid
Official Websites: www.al-mawrid.org and www.javedahmadghamidi.com
Official email: [e-mail]
Submit a question: www.al-mawrid.org/askaquestion

[@SaeedKhan-en2ho]

I have no words to describe the beauty of your answer Ghamdi sb

[@asmafirdos8311]

Very sensible answer of a very. Sensitive question....

[@syedamjadali5255]

Ghamdi sahib ka aik shandar bayan...

[@fareedwattoo8573]

SubhanAllah itna khoobsurat tareeqay sa kabi kisi na explain ni kiya

[@manzoorahmad919]

Boht khoobsurt jawab??? Aaj me pehli bar samj gya ki agr Nathu Ram b janwar ko zabah kr day,to woh b halal hy. Aaj say mazay sai nathu raam k zabah kiye huay janwer khayen gai. Thanks Gamdhi sahib

[@fareedwattoo8573]

Bhai kia nathu ram Allah ka naam ly kr zibah krta ha. Unho na ye btaya k Allah k naam k begair zibah ni kiya ja skta.

[@manzoorahmad919]

@@fareedwattoo8573 Gore say sun bhai....Fir comment karna

[@badarjamal5534]

Meri phunnu ki toh Alhamdu Lil Laah hui hui hay khatnay. 😘😊🙂🙂🥰🥰

[@s.u.b..]

جزاک اللہ خیر. اللہ پاک اپ کو ہمیشہ خوش رکھے🤲

[@naghmakhanum5761]

Ma SHA Allah Perfect answer JazzakAllah

[@JHS950]

JazakAllah khair for a great explanation ❤

[@faysalmohsin7291]

What an amazing one & only interpreter of Islam.

[@hinalatif7856]

Beautiful explanation.

[@bashirbaig8087]

Very Nice answer ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@amirshahzad9673]

JazaakAllah

[@mohammed-nf7vb]

very good, thanks, sir.

[@user-pu2ou8uo9t]

Mashallah Sir I am your big fan

[@asiabano1040]

Excellent

[@jedahsaudia1746]

Mashallah

[@saminafarhan7660]

Jazzakallah

[@engr.rashidiqbal237]

MashaaAllah

[@khanmehmood5248]

غامدی صاحب اپ کی عزمت کو سلام

[@TawwabKhan-hz6bf]

عظمت ” !!

[@TheZahidmasood]

اللہ آپ کو ہدایت دے

[@hanifdana5217]

Khatamallahu ala qulube him

[@iqbalfazli371]

very prudent answer..may not be digestible to many....

[@ShahidIqbal-ze5np]

Nicely elaborated

[@zanmar6764]

Very well explained

[@shabirkamran5399]

Clear understanding

[@qarig.rwsool7046]

الله تجھے ہدایت دے

[@msdtpt7225]

Allah hum sabho ko hidayat de. Ameen

[@raeesfamily9737]

@@msdtpt7225Aameen

[@Farooq11122]

AAMEEN

[@Naseemahmed619]

Bhut khob gamde sahb ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@mmaqboolkumar56]

U beauty

[@imransharif4664]

میریمعلومات کے مطابق اب چائنہ میں Laboratory Meat کمرشل بنیادوں پہ تیار کیا جاتا ہے

[@skinfo9138]

kiyaa baat hi

[@HasanRaza255]

Beautiful answer mashallah

[@tab00pk]

100% right.

[@user-ry8dd1xq7r]

In America Halal meat $13-15 per Lbs from store $3.00 per lb. Difference Halal /Harm 🐐🐐🐐🐐🐐🐐🐐🐐🐐🐐 Sydney Australia ♿🦘🔥🦘

[@alphazeta321]

Lab grown meat ma animal cells ko pattry dish ma grow Kia jata ha . In ko zaroori chemical provide kiay jatay hain. Jub cell grow krty hain tou unhain mila kr burger patty bnai jati ha.

[@ElPsyAgent]

Yai Video 2015 ki hai tb nahe thaa Lab Grown Meat.

[@tahirtutorial6630]

Ager janwal ko zibah kr k cell nikale to jaiz he

[@tahirtutorial6630]

Zindha janwar se koi chez /cell lena bi murdar k hukam me ata he

[@tahirtutorial6630]

Ager zabha kr k cell nikala jaye aur lab me meat banaya jaye to jaiz he islam me

[@user-kl6dy2yk7u]

اسلام علیکم ورحمتہ اللہ وبرکاتہ سر جی میرا سوال ہے کے کیا روضے کی حالت میں وینٹولین ھیلر استعمال کرنے سے روضہ ٹوٹ جاتا ہے مہربانی فرماکر رہنمائ فرما دین

[@Microstar5656]

Muslim is the basic criteria..

[@kalsoomsaeed6582]

Kash chand bi science technology saay decide ho Orr mulaha saay Jon choothy

[@kausarjawaid886]

Absolutely ot

[@usmanrafiq7080]

Logical

[@alphaballerz3008]

میرے خیال سے جو چیزیں کو قران میں حلال کر دی گئی ہیں وہ حلال ہیں, چاہے ان پہ کوئی کیا پڑھے لیکن جو حرام ہے وہ حرام ہے . اور جہاں تک غامدی صاحب کے سوال کا تعلق ہے کہ جان لینے کے وقت تو پھر تو مچھلی کی جان بھی ایک جان ہے اس کو کس طرف define کریں گے

[@shakilahmad2046]

Koi kya padhe ajeeb baat hai aap ki.Allah ka nam lena hi hai.

[@alphaballerz3008]

@@shakilahmad2046 پھر اگر اپ خنزیر پر اللہ کا نام لے لیں تو کیا وہ حلال ہو جائے گا ??یا اگر کتے پر اللہ کا نام لے کے ذبح کرے تو کیا وہ حلال ہو جائے گا??

[@shahidpervaiz786]

Buht Acha sawal pocha hai kisi NE

[@mohammedrizvi9161]

The tradition of 'halal' method of production of meat was nesacititaded to ensure that the blood was completely drained out from the animal as most of the bacteria is in blood. The shelf life of meat will be very short and meat will quickly spoil if the blood is not drained. meat can be preserved for a longer duration, especially where there were no refrigerators in the old days in hot climates and the weather was hot.

[@masoodkhan]

Ji Tareeqa eejad ho gayaa hai

[@TawwabKhan-hz6bf]

“ اللہ کے نبی پہلے مجھے ذبح کریں ” !!

[@saudparvez7049]

Ye hi tareeqa bataya gaya hae deen me tab hi to Bismillahe Allahoakbar isee liye padha jaata hae

[@alphazeta321]

Ghamdi sb. Lab grown meat aa chuka ha market ma. Singapore ma Mac Donald ki outlets burger supply bhi kar rhi hai. Iss ka Kia hukam ha.

[@aleenamateen2764]

Should be Haram if non Halal components have been used to grow it

[@ElPsyAgent]

He said agr janwar ki jaan nahe ly rhy or gosht hasil kr rhy tou koi msla hi nahe. Wo Halal hai

[@rashadasadia7265]

چائینیز نے آرٹیفیشل طریقہ سے گوشت بنانا شروع کر دیا ہے...

[@asiawaqas3655]

What abt pest control process... They also hv life..

[@hafizulasad987]

SAARY RAAT HARAM KHAA KER PARHTA RAHA,TO KUCH NAZAR NAHEE AYAA.

[@marjinaaquil2991]

Abhi masnavi gosht ban chuka hai aur oui l'achat bilkul gosht jaisi hoti hai

[@hafizulasad987]

DUSRE DIN HALAL KHAA KER BEITHA TO AMAL KAA RUHAANY ASSAR ZAAHIR HO GIAA.

[@mazharyjhashmi9512]

masnui tareeqe se ghosht tayyar ho gaya

[@Walkingaroundtheword2686]

If yes then we can eat it

[@ElPsyAgent]

Yai video 2015 ki hai is wajah sy Ghamidi Sahb didn't mentioned lab grown meat.

[@ronosama]

Japan mai bana hai

[@hrasheed1981]

An example of fish is interesting. When u bring it out of water it suffers a lot. Life is a life whether of animals walking on land or swimming in water. You forcefully bring it out of it’s natural habitat and can observe it’s suffering when it is dying. We should recite the name of Allah too when killing a fish too. Another interesting fact is that even plants have life too 😂😂. Even though we cannot hear it with our natural senses. It is a proven scientific fact now. So why not apply the same rule for every thing we eat 🧐

[@ethics_academy]

According to this logic vegans are also life killer 🐼

[@hafizulasad987]

HALAL YAA HARAM CHECK KIYYA THAA,ISTEHARAH KE TAREEQAH SE.

[@saudparvez7049]

Ulte seedhe sawaalat aur unke hawaab aqlse bahar ki baaten haen

[@EliteStyling]

سوال کا سیدھا سا جواب کیوں نہی دیتے کہ وہ گوشت حلال نہی ہے

[@mehjabeen9419]

السلام علیکم معذرت کے ساتھ بات گول مول جواب صرف خون نکال دے بغیر اللہ کے نام لیے تو ٹھیک رہے گا میں یہی سمجھا ہوں اپ کے جواب سے

[@imranmehmood6072]

poora sunen khoon nikalne ko bhi zaruri qarar dia hai

[@manzoorahmad919]

It means that if Manmohan Sing and Nathu Ram slaughters an animal,it is halal for us.

[@Voyage_Vignettes]

Now there's a way to produce meat scientifically.

[@Moodus55]

Ghamdi sahib’s answer seems very logical and correct but I think it’s incomplete. If taken literally the wordings of Quran, then two conditions must be met specifically for meat (but other foods too). (A) it must not procured (killed) in the name of any other than God (Allah) and if the above condition A is met, then (B) it can be made halal by reciting the name of Allah on it. We know that even when an animal is properly slaughtered some traces of blood remain in the meat. Especially animals that are hunted down by Muslims, a lot of blood remains inside the hunted animal. So in summary, Ghamdi sahib’s answer is for ideal situations, but under less ideal conditions meat products such as McDonalds etc may be consumed without overdoing it. Kindly comment and enlighten. I am no scholar of Quran

[@sarfrazsae9226]

If you live in United States of America then you need a bridge to stay in main stream culture, social, moral values. Otherwise life gets too difficult and loneliness like in Gaza so if you can't eat (you don't have to but can't stop) means you can't make your life easy at a time onve you need it then you have no bridge and one day a war will start or speead out to burn up whole country where you live then you have no peace, no easy way to live or survive. Hope, people understand better.

[@gondalahmed2933]

نہیں تو جب مچھلی بھی ہم پکڑ لیتے ہیں تو اسے پانی سے محروم کرتے ہیں نا ؟ یعنی باھر نکال لیتے ہیں تب ہم اسے مارتے ہیں وہ ہماری وجہہ سے ہی مرتی ھے ہم نے ہی کھانی ہوتی ھے یہ بات سمجھ نہیں آئی۔ مچھلی کی جان لینے کا حق پھر ہم کیسے رکھتے ہیں ؟

[@mazhariqbal3270]

جناب قرآن مجید میں تو صرف سور کا گوشت اور خون حرام قرار دیا گیا ہے جو میں نے پڑھا ہے باقی قرآن مجید کے مطابق کون کون سا جانور حرام ہے اس کی مطلق قرآنی آیات کا حوالہ دے کر وضاحت فرمائیں عرضے نیاز

[@thewarrior6519]

Fish also die with pain

[@snbirdsfarm673]

Christian ka zabiha Kesy kha sakty ha Jo hazrat essa ibn Maryam ko Allah ka beta manty Hain naozbillah Khuda manty Hain aesy to Hindu ka zabiha bhi halal hujaega zabiha srf musalman ka or mohid ka kha sakty hain

[@Lifelines7204]

I live in non Muslim country and halal meat is not available all the time.Most of Muslims from Pakistan India don’t eat anything which isn’t halal certified.But Arabic Muslim they eat chicken because they believe they can eat meat if it is slaughtered by followers of other book and something about electrocution.i think we follow strict regulations in India Pakistan more than Arabs.But I still can’t eat chicken which isn’t halal certified

[@bapu8984]

Masoom momino ko bargala raha h 😢

[@muhammadanwar-bt8hm]

Artificial meat has already been made.

[@TawwabKhan-hz6bf]

“ غیر اسلامی ؟ ” !!!!!

[@manclt704]

اگر کوئی صاحب غامدی صاحب سے قرآن میں ذبیحہ کے بارے میں جو آیات ہیں ان کا حوالہ نمبر معلوم کر کے لکھ دیں تو عین نوازش ہو گی . کیوں کے ایک صاحب نے پوچھا تھا کے قرآن میں زہیحہ کا ذکر صرف قربانی کے جانور کے لئے کیا گیا ہے لیکن روز مراه کے گوشت کے لئے محض حلال جانور کا ہونے کا ذکر ہے لیکن ذبیحہ کا تذکرہ صرف قربانی کے ساتھ ہی ہے

[@TheIrfanmd]

Ghamidi sahab stil doesn't know that for years artificial meat is available to eat. Could someone tell him to update his knowledge about science so he doesn't treat such question with derision.

[@Darfarooq]

He talked about this in 2015, check video date. I suggest you Update ur knowledge also.

[@arsalanmajeed1236]

Does that mean, we can eat Kosher Meat because it is slaughtered in the name of ALLAH by a Jew.

[@WaseemAhmad-if9jb]

Aisey jwab koi ahmadi Muslim ya us jaisa koi admi hi de sakta h

[@user-rq9vv5tb2w]

بالکل غلط۔۔۔ مچلی کو اللہ کے نام کے بغیر حلال اور باقی ۔۔۔۔ جو غیر اللہ کے نام پے کی ہو حرام ہے ۔ جس پر کسی کا نام نہ لیا ہو ، اللہ کا نام لے کر کھایا جا سکتا ہے۔

[@iqbalsheikh8216]

🤡

[@mariasea3869]

if you say, ' I start with the name of Allah (God) who is very kind and merciful.' then no issue if you live born in a Muslim family and live in united state of America. otherwise you cannot claim that make your life easy in Islam.

[@Babasayee]

Halal money's then okay darling but Incase money's with zulam chori or crupt or lazy perpouse Long days or in pokt jaab bojhi sluka shouldn't be with people's money 200time Allah names or anything anyway anyone's harmful for anyone can't Halal food Haram with Haram Halal with halal pak with Pak plat pleet

[@shabbirs]

Chand dekhnay ka masla khatam nahi huwa. Aap apnay ghalat aqaid hum par musalat na karein

[@pappu33]

Kuch bhi ?

[@ahadshahid5953]

Still not practical answer.

[@nouman79]

Why Muslim care so much about halal😂😂

[@serajakram]

Doston aise sawalon me waqt barbad karne ke bajaye Seraj Akram ki kitab Talaash padhiye. Puri duniya ke musalmano ki aankh kholne wali kitab.

[@shyFarsi]

Ghamdi saheb ko dekh kr judge krna , pecheeda hy. Confusing, impossible hai

[@ronosama]

Ye Aleem hai? But i think he is wrong 😢

[@badarjamal5534]

Agar koi Musalmaan baghair khatna kay shaadi kar kay uski beevi kay sath Jamaa karta hay aor Uskay ghar 9 Mahinay baad baccha yaa bacchi paida ho woh halaal musalmaan hoga ya hogi ?? 🤔🤔🤔🤔

[@HaroonKhan-pi5so]

Absolutely wrong

[@abdulusmani7421]

Ghuma fira kar jawab Mushriq ka zabiha haram hai ghamdi sb kidhar baithe ho

[@impishbrothers2693]

Ye kya admi hy..door hi raho is sy

[@bhb9926]

Ghamdi sb with due respect you are 100% wrong in your opinion. The glorious Koran has categorically ordained that food and meat of people of the book is permissible for believers. Similarly, the glorious Koran has declared that except dead animal, flowing blood, meat of swine and an illicit offering in the name of a god other than Allah is prohibited. The glorious Koran in sura hajj declares that only sacrifice of an animal must be conducted in the name of Allah and not routine slaughter in our day to day life. Besides, the glorious Koran also declares that before eating anything you must recite Allah's name. Finally, your argument that when you kill an animal it is a painful process so you must recite Allah's name is flawed, because a fish when caught also passes through a horrible pain that we endorse with the adage "fish out of water". So, please stop preaching anything that the glorious Koran refutes vehemently. You will be answerable before Allah Almighty for such statements.

[@ahmeraziz4931]

You mean to say that only in eid ul Adza the qurbani we do requires Allah u Akbar and the routine slaughter of animal for meat doesn't necessarily require the zabiha process. I am living in the US, so the normal meat available here in marts is permissible to eat?

[@imtiyazahmed1028]

U r illiterate

[@bhb9926]

@ahmeraziz4931 Yes, this is what the glorious Koran declares. The wisdom provided by the glorious Koran is crystal clear, provided you read all relevant verses on a subject together. Only then can the holistic perspective be understood. Do you think the Christians who always believed in Trinity would recite the name of one true God while slaughtering an animal? Never. Still, their food is declared permissible for believers. So read the glorious Koran critically, and you will find that many practices in islam go against the declarations of the glorious Koran.

[@MNS260]

Quran it selves says that you have to say Bismillah Allah Ho Akbar, it is must. You can eat at Jew's hotel they says the same thing in Hebrew but not the case in Christians.

[@fawad750]

Quran isn't contradictory. Trinity, despite belief in God being one of them besides Jesus and the Holy Spirit, was there at the time revelation of Quran, and yet Allah allowed eating food of the People of the Book. Pork is forbidden to all people of the book. Anyone declaring himself a Christian or a Jew serves the food, Muslim can eat as per Sura Maida and Sura Baqra verses, lest one is counted among deniers of the verses or due to personal choice. Allah allowed the permission, one shouldn't take with a pinch of salt. Eventually, He can't resile from His verses. Each one has a wide range of choices, something for the Liberal and also something for the puritanical if it pleases one. No compulsion in religion!!

[@TheMAK65]

Allah na hamaray leya pida kiya hai isleya Hindus ki logic par janay ki zaroirat nahi. Quran ki wazah ayat hain.

[@obaidnawaz5309]

Then, according to ghamdi...jhatka will be halal ... if in the name of God. With a smile on his face and calm posture, he easily goes against Islamic principles of slaughter, and his audience follows him.

[@MrUmar72]

Ghamdi Sab what if that animal wants to die and allows you to slaughter it , will we still require Allah's permission ?? If yes why then ??

[@AbdulGhaffar-wn8gu]

غامدی کا ذاتی نظریہ ہے اس میں شریعت کا کویی عمل دخل نہیں ہے

[@meme-od2vs]

نام نہاد عالم دین ۔۔۔۔

[@WaseemAhmad-if9jb]

Abey Jihad Alame din ko Dekho, kath mullon k follower

[@WaseemAhmad-if9jb]

Nihad not Jihad, automatic system fault

[@meme-od2vs]

@@WaseemAhmad-if9jb نام نہاد عالم دین ۔۔ نام نہاد عالم دین

[@saminafarhan7660]

Mashallah

[@user-ps5be9bo7f]

Mashallah