GAME SINS | Everything Wrong With Assassin's Creed: Rogue

[@zachortiz5514]

You forgot the biggest sin...all of the box art gives him a hood on the templar robes but no such hood exists in game

[@ttchme9816]

And no musket that I seen in official trailer.

[@trunghoang4503]

it does, in restricted areas only

[@shawnschaitel838]

@@ttchme9816 its the dart gun if im nt mistaken

[@ttchme9816]

@@shawnschaitel838 yeah it is. They baited me into buying the game thinking I could play a actual equipment that is a musket

[@shawnschaitel838]

@@ttchme9816 they said it was a dart gun before launch same wirh the pucklre gun annoucement

[@marko8699]

I think mt biggest complaint about Rogue and Unity is that Shay killed Arno's father and Arno has 0 interest in finding out that Shay did it. He doesn't question it, never pursues it, nothing. It would have been such an epic moment to have the 2 of them meet and at least have some sort of confrontation

[@mcburn_]

Just Unity, because its writing was very abysmal and poorly done with unnecessary character deaths, none that you felt compelled enough to care about, with an improper lead-in from Rogue. It would've been better If, say, you went to the very same party that your father did and noticed a hooded figure and chased them to the rooftop, then had one final confrontation with shay. Needless to say, none of the AC games had excellent or fantastic writing, and never even bordered on good writing, not any modern ones anyway.

[@Lena25121987]

Mark Ondrejech I totally agree with you!

[@miroslavjovic3200]

I think there was definitely potential to connect the games in a better way and perhaps have an epic boss fight between Arno and Shay. Something like that fight that happens against his mentor in the clock tower. That fight and the Church level that had multiple solutions(even shown in the promo vids), those were one of the highlights in Unity for me. I actually really liked Unity and it could have been a much better game if the stealth mechanic actually worked and there was a proper whistle or distrast options that worked. The parkour and the controls needed work along with character lock-on in combat. And if the online portion was integrated better and the co-op was easier to get into. Some of the side missions online were soo much fun if you could get another player or two and communicate properly and take guys out in sync.

[@argueknaught1787]

Bob Stickman it’s also because Arno could never figure it out since there was no lead

[@matthewrodino3469]

Ok hold on... There is no way he could do that after god knows how long he was growing up with GOD DAMN DELESAIR(sorry about spelling) and there would not be any leads or clues, just a cold as hell case.

[@cameronrhyne7826]

Another issue you forgot to mention: After Lisbon, Shay storms into the Assasin HQ all pissed off like it just happened, despite the fact he just finished a 2-3 month ocean voyage. Hothead or not, a few months is quite a bit of time to actually think over the Earthquake, more then enough for Shay's rage to subside.

[@anonymousidiot7538]

Cameron Rhyne i mean what would you do if you indirectly killed almost a whole city's population

[@tychogoedhart286]

It could also be plenty of time to let it fester and broil inside of you, while you get more and more fed up with waiting until you can unload on the guy who made you indirectly cause the deaths of thousands.

[@soulofrei643]

There's such a thing as cooling down in the meanwhile, but the nearer you get to confrontation, the more those old feelings boil up again until they explode like what happened with Shay

[@totallynotacarrot4369]

He was probably stewing in his own rage

[@lytherael2309]

And funnily enough, they made a pretty big point of Haytham's journey to America. Shay just hops on back in five minutes.

[@kyrieeleison9599]

No one finds it Wierd that there are many haystacks in blackflag but no horses to be seen

[@xxCrimsonSpiritxx]

Bugisoft is all about convenience afterall

[@redhoodie4111]

Hay was used for far more than feeding horses.

[@jackofastora8962]

Hay wasn't just made to feed horses you mong.

[@llkurry9626]

NaysM true

[@cap5macca5jack5]

Agreed

[@mariokarter13]

Rogue One: An Assassin's Story

[@MrToast-so6vj]

And almost all the assassins die (spoiler alert) sorry

[@sagisdoodleverse9696]

Oh lord😂

[@derekbradley3763]

As if every gamer cried out in fear

[@ryanhowe6543]

Assassin's creed: the idiot plot

[@brmbismarck666]

@@MrToast-so6vj It's the Creed that is in North America that almost dies out

[@YTPrule]

6:46 I would add that Shay never ever tries lobbying his fellow assassins or considering a calm way to convince Achilles. He also decides to mindlessly shove the manuscript in his pocket instead of destroying it with his hidden blades or throwing the 100+ year old book into the open fireplace in the room despite having no reason at the time to steal instead of destroying it.

[@ryanhowe6543]

Shay comes across as an idiot to me for jumping to conclusions and his fellow assassins for not listening whatsoever, I feel like the whole thing could've been avoided if they didn't act like idiots

[@filipbarta8982]

There's one more sin: When Shay fell off that cliff he was at the Davenport place but then he wakes up in New York. In AC 3 you can see on the map how long does it take to get from one location to another. Shay had to be in that freezing water for days maybe even weeks

[@Modie]

My greatest problem with Rogue is, that its story is so serious, that you don't feel like you are allowed to do all the side missions. In Black Flag I did maybe 75% of the side missions during my first playthrough, just because the missions were set like "see you in a month". It didn't feel like the plot was the most important thing. But in Rogue all your missions are of most importance. So this huge open world just becomes something you travel through and not something you actually explore.

[@sjhmagic1]

well that was the point of black flag, exploration over story. the story wasn't that deep.

[@Modie]

I know that, but this is what was missing in Rogue. You can't just make a complete different game and then put on a mechanic that was designed for a completely different type of game. It just doesn't work.

[@eddiejackson1566]

How about the fact that they basically reskinned black flag to make rogue and didnt change 1 thing except the story.

[@austinstone478]

I always felt like rouge was just a large dlc for black flag...

[@peeko_luxx2873]

@@sjhmagic1In retrospect, black flag while focusing on the exploration and an open world feel, had some of the most compelling character beats and development. When I was younger it felt lackluster compared to AC2 and Ezios story, but coming back just last week, I was very much into the story more so than even back then. That parting glass scene still holds its weight all these years later, if anything more profound. Personally that is! All opinions and I do love how different peoples takes are in the AC fanbase! Cheers

[@ITheIM7IOmegaI]

This story had some great potential but it ended up being the shortest game yet. I wanted to see more haytham and his badassery.

[@sjhmagic1]

hell yes!

[@Lena25121987]

Yes. Haytham is sooo AMAZING!

[@imlivingunderyourbed7845]

I really like haytham,but at the same time I hate him

[@xxCrimsonSpiritxx]

shorter than liberation?

[@GTQcNumber1]

Oh and in regards about William Miles: In Assassin's Creed: Rogue, after Shay Cormac's story is uploaded to the Assassin network, a text states "William Miles is dead!", hinting the Templars found him. However, another message states "William Miles is alive." It was revealed in Assassin's Creed: Origins that he was indeed alive. So he was alive you just missed the other message lol :P

[@eagleinthesky264]

I honestly loved this game. We need to be a Templar again. It was a nice change of pace

[@kaiserschmitt]

And like he said, instead of using the assassin movement and combat system, ubisoft should change it to suit the templar mindset.

[@szabobence8111]

That One Guy have you played the game? Shay was an Assassin, so he could climb and stuff like that. So why should he just stop climbing and stuff?

[@ThatOneGuy7550]

Szabó Bence You clearly did not read the comment or you were just being ignorant. In no way did they CHANGE or ADAPT the game for a Templar playing style. Sure he WAS an assasin for the creed, but it was clearly stated he CHANGED sides idrc if you want Shay to climb up walls or not--they didnt even bother to experiment with the kind of possibilities the player could do. He maybe a Templar in name only but you still play like an Assasin. The only function for Shay to be a Templar was to serve the end narrative. Idfc he if climbs up walls if you're telling me you switched sides in game, give me the abilities and combat of a Templar Knight/Operative.

[@eliasneely4388]

That One Guy how does any of what you are saying contradict that it's a good game?

[@ThatOneGuy7550]

E Money Lol what an idiot, I am clearly saying that they did not make the game innovative or actually intresting because of the lack of Templar combat. I'm playing as an ex-Assasin who's now a Templar. The game is not bad just the combat mechanics are uninteresting as they clearly could've done more with the game especially for this narrative. But go ahead, stay docile.

[@ericemigh3869]

14:17 There's a few other people who already commented this, but literally the next sentence that appears in the chat room in the ending cutscene is literally "William Miles is alive." You can't just edit out the evidence against your position and pretend it doesn't exist. I usually enjoy your videos, but in this case, seriously, bad form.

[@mdean7299]

Exactly what I said, he is kinda cool, but he just used a part of whole sentence as evidence what freaking evidence is when you use two words of 15 words sentence ?

[@Ok11011]

Besides it's proved in many of the other games and even in rogue that William went into hiding and was PRESUMED dead but came back to lead the Initiates

[@MaxPwnzer]

Just doing his best CinemaSins impression

[@kairowskiller4006]

The reasons why I Iove Assassin's Creed: Hidden Blades Chase scenes Combat (somewhat) Running from destruction What I hated in Assassin's Creed: Trailing Mission Territory control Sailing missions (but that's just me)

[@Ibnmehmed]

You are so right

[@demonwolf570]

Kairow'sKiller 7 You forgot the dreaded tailing missions.

[@JazzyUnderscoreTrumpeter]

I agree with everything except the sailing missions, I actually liked them... I don't like the water levels though.

[@ThatOneGuy7550]

basically AC since Black Flag

[@dominicwilson1498]

No, seriously. FUCK the sailing missions.

[@imtrnr733]

Before even seeing the video I knew the ending sentence was gonna be "I make my own luck"

[@mrslicener21]

You're so right about the future portion of AC games having no meaning. Since Desmond died and the end of the world was averted, there's no realistic consequences. Now it's just episodes in the AC fiction universe. At least this had fun boat battles. Please do Binary Domain

[@thetinthdoctor]

I make my own luck, Dartigan!

[@adibfarhan6320]

😂😂😂 HAHAHA

[@bluebuddybop4937]

7:19 I am pretty sure that Shay was shot in the LEFT SHOULDER, but I guess your point still stands that he should not have survived.

[@eloise1579]

During the mission where you go after Achilles and Liam at the precursor site Shay quotes "Says the man who shot me in the back" and liam knocks the tree of eden.

[@craftergamer9058]

Blue buddybop he also fell head first and hit his head on the ice

[@Thalmor_General_Thranduil]

Well, Shay makes his own luck.

[@peeko_luxx2873]

@@Thalmor_General_ThranduilBut did you even realize, Shay makes his own luck?

[@DavidGraham221]

The fact that Shay doesn't have his hood once he becomes a Templar even though he has one on the cover should be a sin

[@dominicwilson1498]

See, that's the thing that's always bugged me. Why does EVERY villain in AC franchise has to spill their guts out (besides that one dude in Syndicate)? They act like it's some sort of middle finger to the Assassin/Templar in this case but they're only helping out their killer when they give them details about their plans. And most of these villains are "intelligent".

[@flaminG-Ghost]

I got 2 words for you, "Plot convenience"

[@ryancrafar3733]

The only person that didnt spill anything when they die is the woman in ac syndicate. I forgot her name tho but damn, thats a first in like, how many games?

[@eagleinthesky264]

Biggest sin should be how you can’t wear shays hood from the pictures/trailer

[@imlivingunderyourbed7845]

I'm really disappointed in it but the pop collar kind of grew on me

[@Cerstani]

Woohoo, another fantastic Dartigan video! It's amazing to see just how far this channel has come; keep up the good work!

[@SoulStrikes]

8:12 Altier???? I think you mean Altair

[@reggieloaiza7782]

Strikes, yeah it was a mistake from him apparently, since he does pronounce the name as Altair

[@danlandia2311]

Altaïr* if you're so annoyed with it

[@Forriedude]

This game came out the same day as Unity.

[@legoindianajones8363]

And better than it

[@MrOgge50]

“I found hope’s body Shay!” Did you really? Because I could have sworn you left for the Atlantic to find a precursor site after Hope was killed which Shay left for to hunt you down for. When did you even have time to return to New York for no reason and find Hope’s body which probably would have been removed by someone else by the time you arrived?

[@NEVRMD]

Shay:I make my own luck. Shay does make luck.He survived poison getting shot in the back falling down 50 feet two times and survived

[@danielthomas7193]

They're after me lucky charms.

[@StitchiiMinis]

Daniel are you ok

[@mack-attack-420]

@@StitchiiMinis it's too late... We've lost Daniel

[@poggies7639]

The best part is none of the Irish characters were played by Irish people and it’s super obvious (well and lucky charms doesn’t exist in Ireland of course)

[@danielthomas7193]

For context, I'm part Irish. So it gives me free reign to crack jokes about my people! 😆🇮🇪

[@TheCanadianmick]

My biggest gripe is how badly they designed Atlantic Canada, massive rock cliffs on Prince Edward Island, iceburgs everywhere, random mountain in Miramichi. They could've been accurate and the game would've been great, but as someone grew up in that area I just couldn't get passed it, especially seeing the whole area is can be covered in 3 days of driving to these locations.

[@rayX98]

Considering it's made by ubisoft Montreal

[@rayfarron6268]

Yeah. Newfoundland is completely different. And also the river valley, Shay did an impossible thing by sailing from Sleepy Hollow to Mount Vernon by the Houdson River. But it didnt bother me much, sometimes you have to sacrifice accuracy to favour better flowing gameplay. And none of the previous games were geografically accurate anyway, so Rogue wouldnt be different. Take AC II for example, they made Forlí next to the sea, just so Ezio could go to Venice by boat. What actually bothered me was Ubisoft changing the architecture of the buildings and churches of Italy.

[@bovie_bovie]

I feel the same way about the River Valley map. It bears almost no resemblance to the real Hudson River Valley. In the game, they made it into a delta and half of the locations are completely made up. They could’ve made it a long straight and wide river with all the IRL locations, and the gameplay & story wouldn’t have suffered.

[@velikan420]

About Sin #33, "I can sympathize with Shay being upset since he feels responsible for starting the earthquake that destroyed Lisbon, but it's not like the Assassins knew that would happen. They sent him there to retrieve a Piece of Eden, an artifact that does not cause earthquakes." Literally 10 seconds later in that same scene, Shay says why he thinks the Assassins knew the earthquake would occur. You yourself even said something similar later on in the video. I've noticed this happens a lot with "sin" channels, they sin something that's either: Already been explained, Being explained in the same scene they're sinning, or Will be explained at some point later in the movie/episode/game. It's annoying.

[@beniyukikuromatsu8696]

Once again, Dartigan does a better job then the “official gaming sins” channel. Kudos to you good sir.

[@vizoredchris]

In the fight against Kesegowaase, the only way to get full synch is to kill him using a puckle gun. Even if Kesegowaase somehow managed to survive getting shot by a mini cannonball long enough to spill his guts out, figuratively, the scene shows the two in close physical combat. If a perfect synch suggests the proper way Shay lived out the memory, the cinematic scene would be impossible. *ding*

[@quasarone3083]

One of the more underrated games in the series

[@darragh9837]

MovieNerd_EP THE most, it’s my favorite

[@quasarone3083]

I think it really suffered from coming out so close to Unity and looking very similar to 4, but its so good

[@belgianstuff]

Didn't they just make it so older gen players had a game to buy? Unity didn't come out for ps3 right?

[@MillerJustinFS]

Yeah, but it's actually a way better game than Unity. All these sins are mostly nonsense. It was super fun to play as the other guys for once and it also has all the weapons and ship combat as Black Flag(the best AC ever).

[@imlivingunderyourbed7845]

belgianstuff I'm no game dev but I think making games for last gen is easier than making one for current gens and they obviously put more effort to unity

[@mtotowamidiri]

DORMMAMU I'm here to make my own luck

[@bliczb8772]

I know this was not an option at the end of the video, but I'd love to see you counting sins of Metal Gear Survive.

[@reggieloaiza7782]

Blicz B, the entire game is a sin, i mean... YOU HAVE TO PAY 10$ FOR A F*CKING SAVE SLOT TO PLAY (and that's forgetting the amount of laziness from the devs to make that game. They had more than a year and MG:SURVIVE is worse than AC Rogue, much , MUCH worse)

[@bliczb8772]

+Reggie Loaiza Yup. And the "loyal" fans of this game are making so many excuses for its microtransactions and fact that it exists that... Gaming industry is dead, we killed it.

[@reggieloaiza7782]

Blicz B , More like konami and other bad companies killed it but we are still part to blame for it

[@chapelpluto4484]

Blicz B it would have to be a two part vid....

[@SkotKozB5]

Lighter ESRB rating? All AC games are rated Mature. What are you talking about...

[@connordrew2634]

Scott Crosby This guy literally complained about the most pedantic shit throughout the video. Half of it was flat-out incorrect and the other half was complaining that he didn't like part of the game.

[@batfreek77]

Connor Drew it’s satire sooo

[@connordrew2634]

AJ Neumann Ooh yeah, bitching and complaining how much you hate a game sure is high quality satire.

[@batfreek77]

Connor Drew read the about section on his trailer. It’s nitpicking. He’s not serious

[@DANtheMANofSIPA]

@@batfreek77 We overuse the word satire to the point of insanity

[@Setantacu]

14:27 William miles didn't die literally the next sentence in that message is William miles is alive

[@Civlover10]

Dartigan, the poison is killing Shay by slowing his heart until it stops beating, he needs to force his heart to continue beating and keep his blood flowing until a proper antidote can be taken, which by pure luck, Hope had two pills of antidote.

[@Y_wicked1117]

Can anyone else agree that rouge had better ship handling than 4?

[@ma70er]

0:36 "Those are all pretty good 'tenants' to live by" LOL The word you're looking for is 'tenets'

[@Doc_Trancy]

When the main character introduced himself, I half expected home to say: My name is Barry Allen and I am the Flash

[@TheMandalore4]

Anyone else notice at the beginning Shay makes a complete uturn back on the same tree to get back and surprise Liam. Why did he jump to that random cliff to turn around? Did he realize he passed his target afterwards? That's not a master assassin, that's a gamer watching KZbin while cleaning up the game world who walks past the chest they had marked on their map because they were distracted. Not that I'd know anything about that.

[@TheNin-Jedi]

Erase the sin of playing like a templar. Its literally the players choice how to play. You DONT have to play like an assassin at all. You could just walk the streets normally and sword fight and shoot everyone. But here are a couple of factors people forget. Shay is a trained Assassin so he's allowed to use his old skills despite defecting. Again. Players choice. Secondly. The games have never really actually showed you how a templar fights. Usually they just scheme and run away. lol

[@lytherael2309]

We don't know how Templars fight? Wtf do you mean? You say that like Altair didn't defeat Robert de Sable in a swordfight. Or Ezio didn't fight Rodrigo and Cesare Borgia. Or even Manuel Palaiologos. We've seen plenty of Templars fight. They're mostly just normal swordsman.

[@NonsensicalSpudz]

"take your communicator" what is it the 70s? just call it what it is a damn tablet

[@masteronmace]

I personally enjoy territory control, I get to see the city in which the game takes place in and it makes my gameplay longer.

[@bigbuckss4303]

Literally the next message is William miles is alive.

[@ruialmeida818]

Cheers for acknowledging the Tsunami on the Lisbon earthquake. I'm Portuguese and that's exactly what I thought - he escaped by ship but how about the wave?

[@Saint-Ocean]

Most of the dialog in this game is like boxed wine. Does it get the job done? Yes. is it good? no.

[@CErra310]

Good analogy

[@eagleinthesky264]

Saintocean some one saw gaming sins.

[@GeloLego99]

stolen

[@nadalcollins5532]

Saintocean rah yeah that is a good analogy From gaming sins

[@ThatOneGuy7550]

Saintocean would be great at GamingSins

[@ryatt9365]

Liam looks exactly like SGT Forge from Halo Wars.

[@primedout6818]

Totally forgot this game existed.

[@DC-hw7fw]

Jonathan Luc Me too! Did I miss something? 🙃😬

[@demonwolf570]

Daniel Cring It comes out remastered this month.

[@jonahbrown5669]

Demonwolf570 In other words, better resolution

[@demonwolf570]

Jonah Brown Yeah.

[@jadenbtw3407]

You finally did this

[@FrancescodePazzi94]

8:08 thats the opinion of that character, nothing wrong with it, and he is a templar as well

[@jadenbtw3407]

One of my favorite assassin creed games

[@felisasininus1784]

I hope in the “remaster” they fixed the weirdly loud metal noises when you drop swords on the ground and the weirder silent footsteps when you run on certain surfaces. Those two audio bugs are what kept me from replaying the otherwise okay game after my original playthrough on PC.

[@TheFirefish224]

"It seems abstergo is forced to download and use Uplay as well"

[@futureflash6331]

Lol him doing parkour and keeping his heart pumping would just spread the poison throughout his bloodstream faster the more he climbs the faster he dies the devs really should've thought that thru

[@Neo2266.]

I don't know either of the games at the end, but Binary Domain interested me more with that 5 second preview

[@mohammedhamed4204]

I think the person who works for abstergo got kidnapped or knocked in the head because the way she's trying to tell you all that stuff makes you feel like you got kidnapped and your still working for them

[@TheWwwyzzerdd]

I found it absolutely hilarious that the reason Juhani Otso Berg wanted Shay's memories so badly wasn't because Shay had some super secret lost Templar knowledge or they wanted to find some Piece of Eden he buried in Ben Franklin's backyard or something, but to throw the footage of Shay's memories into iMovie and make a video for the Assassins basically amounting to "Neener neener neener!" and that's it.

[@Pri-uk9sq]

Interior decoration subplots and charity quick time events...That's unique...

[@kiracodinson]

ok you must be pulling everyone's leg, cause the next message in that chain at the end of this game says "William Miles is alive." So yes, you were still mistaken. Enjoy your weekend.

[@kiracodinson]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/jqnEoa1nYst-nJI

[@nobody2996]

You know, I'm waiting for when one of these games finally has a fight between assassins that actually feels like one.

[@Aaaaa16325]

500 Sins for killing Adewale

[@camm3217]

IDK he did kinda sell out in blackflag and abandoned Edward without even implying an apology

[@jackofastora8962]

@@camm3217 bruh, he left for the benefit of the very assasins that Edward heavily crippled. He doesnt have to make an apology.

[@camm3217]

@@jackofastora8962 My dude that doesn't necessarily justify the fact that he pretty much sold out who was supposed to be his friend to roberts. I feel like some sort of "oh shit, sorry about that" is definitely deserved

[@untotenattentaeter368]

Yep

[@jackofastora8962]

@@camm3217 adewale held no obligations to Edward. He may have been in the wrong but even before his death he spoke highly of Edward. He held some shred of loyalty over the years.

[@bolleborre2013]

Am I the only one who hates getting pulled out and walk around that office

[@TrueMentorGuidingMoonlight]

The latter half of Sin 45 is what I use to explain the "optional objectives" of Splinter Cell Blacklist. UbiDev: "Look, it's a Blacklist laptop, a dead drop, and an HVT! But look at this level, all three are in different places now! This is some amazing work we've done!"

[@DarkshadowXD63]

Is this because of the remaster coming out in the next 2 weeks? I'm hyped I've been waiting 4 years for this remaster

[@aidagh5070]

Shay joined the templar order because of the anger and the goal he had (destroy Achilles). Remember, Achilles's trust and the brotherhood was everything he had. That's what someone who's lost everything would exactly do, in my opinion

[@rileywalker5460]

Destroying Achilles wasn't his goal stopping him from getting isu artifacts was his goal

[@dvader518]

7:24 Shay was shot in the SHOULDER, not head. 9:13 But mortar guns WERE a thing at this point in time so sin should be retracted.

[@kktt433]

Nothing like a good Dartigan binge watch on my day off

[@toddvogel8887]

Dear god, the options for the next video are two games nobody played, let's go with Vanquish then.

[@FrozenDeathPL]

Deus Umbra I hope he does shadow of war at some point I love that game

[@Farushion]

About sin #26. From my experience learning other language, strangely, language is a thing that you could learn fast by imagining an image thus, as long as you understand the meaning, it doesn’t matter if you can pronounce the language or not. It isn’t learnt just by defining word per word, thus it’s not really important to understand the word, but rather the meaning and the concept behind it. It’s really interesting.

[@Phanthief95]

2:58 Even though in Assassin’s Creed 3, which came out 2 years before this game, you literally play as an Assassin who’s half Native American.

[@stinger59605]

What does that have to do with it

[@rileywalker5460]

@@stinger59605 ubisoft said that conner was the first assassin and then they added this assassin

[@wagnertwenty-seven1798]

00:05 since i heard this sfx, i know there will be a betrayal

[@eagleinthesky264]

He has uploaded!

[@raiden3700]

I'm surprised you didn't sin the possibility that Ubisoft made the coolest looking outfit on the box but never actually have it in game

[@ruialmeida818]

Kudos for acknowledging the tsunami in the Lisbon's earthquake. I'm Portuguese by the way, and that was a significant point in our history as it marked the beginning of the decline of the Portuguese Empire. It also marked the start of the atheism in Europe.

[@RooknRolln]

"You ate my Easter chocolate" I MAKE MY OWN LUCK!!! "that doesn't make sense"

[@agachaempire1284]

*Every Rogue fan wants to know your location*

[@SheosMan117]

6:38 "Peace of Eden"? Don't you mean Piece?

[@jamesdenoia]

*ding*

[@mrbigman006]

It was a nice change to play as the good guys in one game of the franchise

[@Yetiman428]

Haytham looks no older in AC3, while Achilles looks young in this game but ancient in AC3

[@fourmoore5589]

I’m ac 3 u could actually see the gray hair on haythem and this game was a decent amount of time before 3

[@themysteriousredwarriorblo1662]

I always got annoyed how Shay kept saying “ I make my own luck”.

[@TreasonsBeta]

Reusing assets doesn't have to be a sin. Just look at Majoras Mask. They might have reused everything from Ocarina of Time but they took it in an entirely new direction.

[@thenomadsign8997]

What saves the game two words: Haytham Kenway P.D: artic parts, the epilogue.

[@neilvarma]

This. Could have been interesting but it was the same AC stuff recycled to boredom, this is when i jumped off

[@chihabeddinemerabet4829]

Lets all agree that the transaction in the beginning is badass

[@Bananaman431]

Every thing wrong with assassins creed rouge:everything

[@Blackout281196]

4:35 dude... Shay came for the Box, and that's exactly the point Washington is making: while he wasted time on killing an already dying Templar, his allies had time to escape with the box

[@xMetalhead2000]

Game had major potential but kinda wasted it, way to short and rushed

[@RandomGuy-sb5ig]

One sentence does not prove William Miles is dead... I agree Origins just glosses over stuff but in media unless you see a body usually someone isnt dead.

[@bluesyrupgc4224]

Is it weird that Sins Videos usually say that there are more French in Black Flag and Rogue than in Unity but in Unity I heard there are tons of French

[@cocobill0077]

I felt like they didn't knew if william miles was alive, they just jumped to conclusions at the end

[@pedromontalvojr4585]

7:43 That's exactly how I feel about Assassin's Creed the third. I'm glad I'm not the only one.

[@sdivine13]

The fact that he was a wounded assassin near the assassin headquarters and they weren't attempting a rescue might be a reason to believe he left them.

[@originalShorai]

I'll be honest, the territory capture mechanic is my favorite part in most AC games. It's like a story relevant way to control gameplay difficulty in game.

[@nicholasroberts7891]

The revenge storyline isn't like written in stone. Altair stayed loyal to an organization that bartered his father's life away

[@starkiller23610]

Yay!!! Love your uploads

[@ArthurD]

Just finished it. They polished all stuff they introduced in Black Flag, but story was too short. It was boring. Maybe only first Assassin's Creed was more boring, but plot twist at the end is what started the franchise.

[@ddddavyy8383]

The assassin's DID know the earthquake would happen. If you spy on Adewale and Achillies, you can hear Ade telling him about an earthquake following trying to retrieve the piece of eden

[@Elite7555]

That's something that really annoyed me after playing Rogue: Arno never uncovered the truth about the death of his father nor does he find the killer. The whole game you are busy uncovering De la Serre's death and dealing with the brotherhood's shit you should have never taken part in. And what is even more confusing: De la Serre was the grand master of the templar order. Why do they even send Shay to murder Arno's father? De la Serre had every opportunity to do this in a discrete fashion. After all, they were befriended, or so it seems, because Arno knew him. But instead they send shady Shay and somehow no one has seen him coming and going and no one ever mentions him.

[@phDexterable]

Well, he wasn't there to kill Arno's father but to retrieve the MacGuffin. As for De la Serre not killing Mr. Dorian, well, it's stated very clearly during the game that the french Templars and Brotherhood had a truce going as both organisations lost sight of their goals and purposes, miring themselves in politics. And both organisation going through a purge and inner revolution is a major part of the story. I also kinda found it dumb that Shay pretty much never comes up in Unity, but that's ultimatelymost likely because Unity was written way before Rogue or even Black Flag, development having started in 2010. I think the game might be trying to tell you that Arno concludes the same person killed both of his fathers with that weird drug induced initiation ceremony, but was being very vague about it if that's the case. Ultimately tho there's the fact that the game pretty much flat out states that Arno doesn't really cares about the past or revenge and pretty much only pursues De la Serre's killer for penitence so he can get back on good terms with Élise.

[@azk12k11]

'From Dartigan: Help subtitle this video'

[@obi-ytp-kenobi4712]

To be fair there was also an ''William Miles is alive?'' somewhere in there so it still was a mystery