Game Theory: Markiplier, PLEASE Smash My Pokemon! (Markiplier Smash or Pass)

Special thanks to Keeps for sponsoring this episode!
Get 50% off your Keeps order! ► keeps.com/gametheorists
Theorists, @markiplier PASSED our perfect Pokemon design. How could that happen?! We used SCIENCE! Well, I guess that means it is time to toss science out the window and try again. This time, we are just going for the SMASH appeal. Can we do it this time? Can we design Mark's PERFECT Pokemon?
Watch Markiplier's response to our video here ► • Smash or Pass: MatPat'...
Submit your name for our new Pokemon! ► / markiplers_perfect_pok...
Thanks to Sketchinthoughts for making our new Perfect Pokemon! ► / sketchinthoughts
Thanks to Caitie Turner (Caiterpillart) for making our original perfect Pokemon ► / caiterpillart
And thank you to all of the artists who gave us permission to share their art of our perfect Pokemon!
- KittyKingRO
- CaffeineDemon
- DarknWindie
- Kiwidaru
- MetalicHotchoco
- Nicole Burdick
- RushLight Invader
- spiciemeatbale
- _Pizzaowl
- Skelegem
- BlueKnightGirl
- The_Artistic_Gremlin
- Konpeimimi
Get Your Theory Wear! ► theorywear.com/
SUBSCRIBE to Catch all the Theories! ► goo.gl/kQWHkJ
Need Royalty Free Music for your Content? Try Epidemic Sound.
Get A 30 Day Free Trial! ► share.epidemicsound.com/MatPat
More THEORIES:
FNAF, The FINAL Timeline ►► bit.ly/2MlHYFe
FNAF, The Monster We MISSED! ►► • Game Theory: FNAF, The...
FNAF This Theory Changes Everything ► bit.ly/2JUQUn6
FNAF, You Were Meant To Lose ► • Game Theory: FNAF, You...
FNAF 6, No More Secrets ► bit.ly/2LVCq4u
Credits:
Writers: Matthew Patrick and Tom Robinson
Editors: Tyler Mascola and Jerika (NekoOnigiri)
Assistant Editor: Caitie Turner (Caiterpillart)
Sound Editor: Yosi Berman
#Markiplier #Pokemon #SmashOrPass #PokemonSmashOrPass #MarkiplierSmashOrPass #MatPat #Theory #GameTheory

[@X-SPONGED]

Matt: "Honestly, I don't care what Mark says-" Mark: *"Pass."* Matt: _"...H O W D A R E Y O U !!!"_

[@LOKO22Bach]

It's almost as if that was the joke

[@gearsie_]

No, i don't have anything better to do, and yes i will play Minecrap, Dr. Pepper

[@Sp3ctralI]

@@LOKO22Bach ikr! Funny isn’t it?

[@JacobMead-ph1cx]

“I promise I won’t be angry” *proceeds to be angry*

[@NanaRedFox]

Matpat, you still miss one thing: TALL. The artist did an AMAZING job, this bird-pokémon looks absolutely incredible, but... it's WIDE, not TALL. Longer legs, longer and more "feminine" torso... the bird, again: looking incredible, looks way too short.

[@animorph17]

The first design wasn't symetrical and failed to have a tail. This second design is a shortstack. Both of them are not drawn well.

[@Paradox-es3bl]

Not that tall if the average was up to 5ft though.

[@pastelberru]

@@animorph17 yeah there are a ton of incredible pokemon artists yet he hires these two

[@papertowels9162]

@@Paradox-es3bl can you immediately tell the height of something based on an arbitrarily scaled image?

[@TessiSue]

@@Paradox-es3bl Doesn't matter. Looking at his reactions to the cat lady god shown in this video and also Lady Dimitrescu, height is a highly relevant factor!

[@mankdemes8887]

Matpat thinking mark would smash florges because of the flowers on its head instead of the fact that it’s literally throwing it back is one the funniest hard misses I’ve ever seen him have

[@noturboi909]

matpat literally has an IQ of 140 how tf did he miss that 💀

[@ionic7777]

@@noturboi909 iq doesn’t really mean much in terms of how observant you are.

[@noturboi909]

@@ionic7777 ight, BUT STILL, HOW TF DID A GROWN A$$ MAN MISS THAT 💀🤚🏼

[@brandonhey7797]

@@noturboi909 wait he does?

[@noturboi909]

@@brandonhey7797 ye

[@sir_r1174]

3:05 Often times perfection is overwhelming.

[@Sp3ctralI]

I’ve never thought someone would want another person to smash their own creation so badly

[@doug.1926]

The mf bots are here bruh

[@pighater1111]

way to many bots in this comments section

[@JagCrazyRusher]

LOL

[@jesperryles7810]

Ur early u got a hundred likes

[@STICKOMEDIA]

Ikr lmao

[@kdawgtb]

Markiplier is secretly working with Pokémon to get Matpat to make an entire generation for Pokémon

[@vakku03]

this will be a wierd region

[@bakerothman3163]

Pokemon theory edition

[@rinthewolf]

I would legit like to see Matpat make his own fakemon region.

[@pixslq]

Gen 10 the smasha region

[@paquitotorrrijas6292]

*#SI**kzbin.info/www/bejne/e5WoeIOtapZpo68** если все в порorcoño* 👇

[@Lord_of_the_sixth_house]

I feel like if MatPat ever did design the perfect pokemon for Mark, he would still pass just because he knows it'd drive him nuts

[@jiraiyair1462]

The sketches were better than the final product 🤣🤣🤣

[@um2913]

Fr I was like how did you end up here??? You had something

[@thegoldene999]

your right🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@heatherkelly5333]

Mat pat: "Creates 2 distinct Pokémon for mark to smash or pass." Mark: "Combines them into one with photoshop."

[@TheRhuen]

and boosts my ego as I wasn't far off on the prediction LoL

[@bleakautomaton4808]

That video was funny af

[@Fred_rick_vance_fritz_IV]

I don't know if Mark made an abomination or a master pice

[@FabledSorcerer]

Basically Mark passed on them both but fused them together and said smash. Mat Pat failed but still succeeded in a sense. XD

[@KadenCatPlays]

@@FabledSorcerer he failed to get a single smash but he at least got two smash in one. (Sorry. Bad pun.)

[@khiemnguyen8478]

“He refused to smash my pokemon.” Never in a million years did I think this sentence would be created.

[@achillachill5520]

Thats.. actually kinda true

[@mellisakuntz6407]

@@recitationtohear what

[@montraria3172]

@@mellisakuntz6407 it's a bot advertising a video

[@Jakepf]

Especially by Matt

[@mellisakuntz6407]

I know it's just the timing of the bot and what the things about

[@Dead_Body870]

'he refused to smash my pokemon >: ( ' one of the top with weirdest sentences i have ever heard

[@AwkwardGMCorbin]

“What is my purpose?” “To be smashed by Markiplier” “Oh my God! 😰”

[@zyaicob]

Yeah join the club

[@nicholasbradshaw6629]

I wish :(

[@juliuszjaszczyk7352]

You forgot about ONE thing, the most important thing about mark: he likes tall ladies.Yes, muscular but also tall. Look at hes reaction to Resident's evil Lady Dimitrescu

[@DaBunne]

yes as soon as I saw how short and squat the new bird pokemon is, I was pretty sure it didn't fit within Mark's range of preference ;) just based on what I saw in this video alone. I never paid attention to mark before now... lol what I learned about markiplier from this video is about 20 times more than I knew before watching this xD Matt just make yor new pokemon taller and you got it!

[@riverstein7251]

Also Auntie Nyan Nyan. He went nuts for her because she was so tall she had to bend below the ceiling. So like 11ft or 12 ft tall. Also extremely powerful as she boasted about being on of the oldest eldritch horrors in existence and threatened to tear him apart for messing with her nieces. It helped a lot that she had a very mature voice as well and commanded respect. Plus she and Dimetrescu are both elegant and respectful ladies in long white gowns. So, tall, powerful, mature, elegant, feminine, and violent towards him.

[@christiantwichell1375]

Exactly!!! That's what I'm thinking. Man, it hurts to see him overlooking that ONE POINT-😂😂 All of the Pokemon he had a really big effect with were super tall lmao

[@Yipper64]

Yeah, I think the tallness is a factor. The data might not say that he likes em' tall, but as matpat said in his last video, you cant exactly tell the height by the design. So its more about proportions. The bird there is about as wide as it is tall, a square-like figure. Which makes it not look very tall. Meaty, but short looking. Who knows, if Mark had a sense of scale, maybe he'd like the bird as it was... But he was given a nice slender tall body, and a beautiful bird face with flowers, and he chose both those aspects.

[@AddictedToBloxFruits865]

EXACTLY, I felt like exactly one thing that was wrong with this pokemon.And it is ONE HUNDRED% the height.

[@notadhdeveloper4994]

I don’t think he’ll like the new one just because it’s short. If you make it absurdly tall he’d love it.

[@TheAdvertisement]

6:43 Editors you cannot just casually show this cursed thing out of nowhere.

[@Anuca]

This is a definite pass from Mark. It's far to short that it's more like a teen girl than an elegant tall woman. ELEGANT and TALL Mat.

[@Nora-dp6mk]

Exactly he was annualized the actual heights but the smash pokemon don't look their height

[@ejokurirulezz]

yee he seems more into femdom

[@tahiyastacy8922]

Yeah I agree,but I personally think neferkitty was more smashable than this one.I'm not saying the design wasn't cool,the colors where perfect and that's a chef's kiss for me.but the new one was taller than it would've been a smash for me and mark too maybe

[@jjbarajas5341]

@@tahiyastacy8922 She just needed to be, iunno, maybe taller with a longer torso? Thicker legs and thighs? Needed more dommy mommy energy, doesn't quite say "step on me" enough. This one DEFINITELY needed to have a visible longer torso.

[@marli8907]

Hah. Mark combined them. He just put a vid up. Because you’re right. The elegant and tall of the 3rd is his vibe

[@heresywithana]

"I wanted to go bigger: "I wanted to go stronger" "I wanted to go pointier" Is not a great combination of sentences when mixed together

[@user-bo7hd3go9e]

MatPat is a brain burner!(Правдивое видео):..kzbin.info/www/bejne/mqbbmXSiq6-BgNU

[@dancercoffin6868]

@@anemarisa3601 🤓🤓🤓

[@neovalkyrie2070]

damn, 5 spam bots in only one comment

[@pakkunen8491]

Neo Valkyrie Thats a personal record.

[@BananaWasTaken]

Well it can make sense if you’re trying to make the strongest sword Edit: trying to get the coolest sword in a video game*

[@islandsicedtea]

Tbh I like a lot of those other sketches better than the final product decisions for both of them

[@grimsladeleviathan3958]

1:03 His confused toss up here just makes me lose my mind laughing. I don't know why, but it just hits that right spot of making me wheeze while talking (for some reason that's a thing I do when I find things really funny)

[@Yasahiro1011]

Mattpat, Mark is into tall dominant women it seems. You gotta give her proportions that make her tall. Neferkitti was well designed but she didn’t seem tall in terms of proportions. This bird Pokémon you made now is looking even shorter. That’s a guaranteed pass. If the joke one didn’t have his face, you’d genuinely have won

[@killnet5638]

MatPat is a brain burner!(Правдивое видео):....kzbin.info/www/bejne/mqbbmXSiq6-BgNU

[@timothyweathersby7011]

I feel like the fact that his face is on the Pokémon makes it better

[@SM_NEO]

Imagine Mark passing the new one and smashing the joke one.

[@CodeNameCheese_]

It also doesn’t have a feminine figure

[@Hamperter]

yes

[@sstheinsane8724]

The one thing that MatPat appears to be forgetting is that Mark is into tall women, the pokemon lack the height.

[@PerfectGoat717]

That’s what I was thinking

[@Philador66]

900th like

[@giggabiite4417]

It needs longer legs and most importantly, a longer thinner Body. This is just a head and chunky legs.

[@Eva-jg5rx]

Markiplier edit the Pokémon so you could smash it so does that count?

[@sstheinsane8724]

@@Eva-jg5rx At this point, we really just should, for Matpat's sanity.

[@Cylioss]

MatPat really out here telling Mark to go "Smash" himself

[@riban3768]

I would honestly love an entire Pokemon region dedicated to 100 of Matpat's Pokemon designs.

[@GeekyDoodles]

Markiplier: Passed on Matpat’s pokemon The Narrator: and so began Matpat’s villain arc

[@GeekyDoodles]

Wtf are these links doing here

[@elix-hi2742]

Matpat's Joker arc lol

[@tyrant-den884]

Mark's the villain here.

[@kaiju-maniacyt]

@👑⃤ ‎ٴ 👑⃤ no

[@crethan219]

@@GeekyDoodles what's up with the sudden uptake in youtube comment bots

[@creativecthulhu]

The heartbreak in Matt's eyes almost makes you think he was the one Mark passed

[@benito23453]

MatPat is a brain burner!(Правдивое видео):..kzbin.info/www/bejne/mqbbmXSiq6-BgNU

[@hyjinx1889]

@👑⃤ ‎ٴ 👑⃤ u dum

[@AerodynamixSky]

@👑⃤ ‎ٴ 👑⃤ no i will not subscribe

[@justabeholder4753]

​@👑⃤ ‎ٴ 👑⃤ I wasn't gonna be immortal anyway, and you didn't say how long it would take for me to die.

[@WhoAgain126]

@👑⃤ ‎ٴ 👑⃤ don't we all die anyways? That's like saying your gonna be a baby to a baby except they could understand you by words not expressions and make things more believable also you like loli's don't you? It's in your profile picture and banner i wish the loli police was real so i could call em on you

[@zombathinlostleghackercat5233]

Purple Egyptian Cat who likes to have control? Sounds like Beerus to me. XD

[@sakurauq]

10:26 I’m rating it a 1000000/10 for the lovely detail you made into that!

[@CrazyKoopaCat]

the fact that he's takin this so seriously is fricken hilarious.

[@iaboth4727]

He’s definitely not

[@Clairavoya]

It feels more purely just for content

[@zoltarservin510]

Imagine Mark giving out a well thought out and detailed 10 minute video explaining why he wouldn't smash THIS ONE either

[@thoughnut]

I'd love that honestly.

[@theshadowhuntress5645]

I honestly really hope so

[@user-rc6jd4tm4c]

its not even worthy to call smash

[@theoriginalstarwalker1653]

@hope im sure it is yeah

[@bleakautomaton4808]

You know Arin would lol

[@AvegaelGallardo]

Matpat : "what do you do in your freetime?!?!?!" Me: drawing pokemon "anatomy "

[@Ha1denLee]

The actual aggression in Matpat's voice for the first quarter of the video is crazy

[@candidesque6470]

The end result is absolutely stunning, however, since Mark's defining feature is that he likes *tall* strong women I really would have given the bird more height and added a cinched waist since many of his Pokemon choices were slender and long.

[@Chkprofilename]

Finally it's here *YES* *kzbin.info/www/bejne/rJ-biJesoNKHfdU*

[@killnet5638]

MatPat is a brain burner!(Правдивое видео):....kzbin.info/www/bejne/mqbbmXSiq6-BgNU

[@kayden8093]

right? exactly what I was thinking.

[@aster7420]

Matpat said Mark apparently liked heights between 4'5 and 5 feet and the bird looks to be just that I guess.

[@TCHNOGAMRGaming]

@@aster7420 while this is true I don't believe mark ever knew how tall or short his choices were, they often looked tall but were really short

[@MossOwnsYouYT]

I feel like it needs more of a narrow waist to be pulled into Mark' smash range. A lot of the concept arts looked really feasible.

[@user-bo7hd3go9e]

MatPat is a brain burner!(Правдивое видео):..kzbin.info/www/bejne/mqbbmXSiq6-BgNU

[@ciara7264]

Yeah I definitely think the concept art was Miles ahead!

[@ThatOneLadyOverHere]

Yeah, I was curious why they didn't go with some of the other sketch ideas... How tall is Stephanie, cause maybe it's MatPat's own preferences of shorter girls getting in the way? 🤷‍♀️

[@Sly-Moose]

@@ThatOneLadyOverHere 🤣

[@Gustavo-po9bd]

"No matter what Mark says this turned out great" "Pass" Cries*

[@twiharryfan212]

Okay but I love the birb even in a non-smash way. It's so pretty!!

[@zakariatouil3123]

I think the reason that taking the top result of every catagory and combining it didnt work is since the combination of features is what makes the pokemon "smashable". For example I like salmon and I also like vanilla, that does not mean id love vanilla salmon lol.

[@heathers.9740]

As beautiful as the final result is, you're missing so much. He likes long, tall, with big honkers. The sketches had a lot of potential. I'd say make them all into final products, send them as a series with your new bird to him and watch him react.

[@Novumic]

I think Mat is just projecting onto Mark at this point. Mark himself SAID he wants TALL girls. TALL! Stop projecting and just take the man for his WORD. My prediction for this girl is another capital PASS considering her proportions make her look so short. Mark doesn't read the actual height for the pokemons but we clearly see that his strongest choices all had proportions and body ratios that suggest tallness if you ignore the actual height written off to the side.

[@mica4614]

TALL with HUGE HONKER BONKERS MAT, HUGE!! CANT YOU SEE????

[@birdsmoko]

I definitely agree with that. I think that if they just lengthened the proportions, this one would've been more likely to be a winner

[@broomhilda8041]

That and I don't see the feather thigh-high boot like appeal with this one. I feel with the Lei they could have brought it more the the front to give a more bosom appeal. And again the legs being longer would have been better and I liked the hair style from the sketches more than the finished product.

[@ihsonat]

Exactly

[@callanmoran9743]

Markiplier: *Refuses smashing Matpat's creation* Matpat: *Challenge accepted*

[@user-bo7hd3go9e]

MatPat is a brain burner!(Правдивое видео):....kzbin.info/www/bejne/mqbbmXSiq6-BgNU

[@thedraftingax5963]

Yep challenge accepted indeed

[@hi-ougidemonfang]

It wasn’t a challenge. O.o it’s all in his head. XD

[@Cat-Bird]

Matpat: I'm back! Me: ALL I CAN THINK OF IS FNAF! WILLIAM AFTON; I ALWAYS COME BACK

[@bleakautomaton4808]

Quick! Someone warn the Game Grumps!

[@KookieStar]

Now Mat will fight Mark into a battle of smashing new Pokémon species xD

[@isaiah5048]

Bro may and mark having a fight over the perfect Pokémon to smash is the most hilarious thing to ever happen on KZbin 😂😂

[@xxkori123xx]

I personally love this design but I think a longer torso and legs would attract Mark more. He seems to like them tall.

[@kaiserwilhelmll8169]

MatPat is a brain burner!(Правдивое видео):..kzbin.info/www/bejne/mqbbmXSiq6-BgNU

[@GrandMasterTank]

All your replies are great

[@jjbarajas5341]

Tall and domineering

[@FelishaSt.Pierre]

I was thinking that too, this design could be interpreted to look a bit younger. Mark definitely passed on quite a few pokemon just because they looked young. So hopefully he won't see it as looking young lol.

[@excelraybina6703]

Let's just say he is keeping things a bit closer to his chest in case they have to make a third or fourth video on it.

[@coledibiase5971]

I love how Mat has once again totally missed the mark on this one again. Make it tall, skinny, 75% long legs, give it a sizable bust, and boom, you got a pass.

[@anonafiao1692]

One thing to remember is that he’s trying to make a Pokémon here. Other than jinx I guess, no Pokémon has like bust… wait what about those birds that like puff up their chest. That could work.

[@julianmartinez4719]

@@anonafiao1692 i like the way you think.

[@Zack_Zander]

The fact that Mark did that is amazing

[@huwutao8726]

@@anonafiao1692 Exactly

[@daystormzx2733]

how to about beedrill ? u know nark also smash this one and its just a god damn bee with stingS

[@joelbouma1640]

One important part for doing something so specific is that you need to make sure it actually lookes like a pokemone you did well both times but remember it must be perfect

[@reverything7261]

Mat Pat when markplier rejects to smash the perfect Pokémon: you can’t pronounce determination with out termination

[@doug.1926]

Matpat really saw all his life’s work go to waste when mark said “pass” Conclusion: Mark solos no diff

[@benito23453]

MatPat is a brain burner!(Правдивое видео):..kzbin.info/www/bejne/mqbbmXSiq6-BgNU

[@TheSabr]

Frfr

[@Sp3ctralI]

Wouldn’t you?

[@doug.1926]

@@Sp3ctralI yes

[@Sp3ctralI]

@@doug.1926 yeah, same

[@Soulstarrr]

He's 100% gonna pass this one. It's more of a sassy young girl then that tall mature woman type that he would more go for. I think that's where it went wrong for the first one as well. It wasn't this thing that would tower over you and destroy you. The second one is more.... interesting.

[@killnet5638]

MatPat is a brain burner!(Правдивое видео):....kzbin.info/www/bejne/mqbbmXSiq6-BgNU

[@Tiaan_the_Dragonslayer]

Yeah it just doesn’t seem like Mark’s type

[@basics388]

Yeah i you’re right

[@tezbertzero1915]

I think the sketches looked kinda more interesting lmao

[@noahmock6861]

He’s literally making a Frankenstein for markiplier to smash

[@Obbels]

I have never been more scared to click on a game theory video in my life

[@marifonseca31]

Matpat: I made Markiplier's perfect pokemon! Mark: Yes, but actually no.

[@passing.by.the.river.]

He did say Smash

[@RhiannonSmudge]

Attempt 2: looks great, but doesn't have that tall, daunting, "step on me" look that Mark fawned over ...I'm half temped to draw my own take on Mark's perfect pokemon

[@KJBobbyBillyjo]

Yeah I think i wanna try to redesign Neferkitti and this new Pokemon with credit to Matpat

[@KJBobbyBillyjo]

Why are all these bots flooding your reply section, bro?

[@Sly-Moose]

Do it. MatPat's failing on us XD

[@jjbarajas5341]

A job for furry artists imo

[@andrasjanosi3765]

Do it! I'm interested in your version.

[@bentleycato5917]

The ball opened after mat made it and a Reesie‘s AD

[@malimations]

These Pokémon are just far too short, it’s as simple as that

[@orbweaverx]

I actually think the first one was already pretty perfect. My guess is that the art style was a big part of it. He liked very exaggerated feminine features, but even though Neferkiti is feminine, she doesn’t have the massive eyelashes or tiny waist he liked in a lot of others. She has the power he wants but not really the ‘come hither’ half-lidded expression. (Either way I love the design tho, big props to the artist.)

[@skulljim9547]

As a furry both are smashable in their own right

[@dumbass762]

Watch mark's new vid, I've just realized that the pokemon HAS to look tall. Mark likes them BIG

[@zachmirza9815]

I feel like another issue was something matpat said in the first video, that mark didn't pick Pokémon like Lopbunny because of the social stigma around furry's. Neferkiti would be considered a furry due to her feline appearance

[@engelberthovel8566]

Like the other person said, the problem is that she's too SHORT!! Mark likes his ladies tall and MatPat keeps ignoring that fact. That's why he liked the other cat lady and not this one

[@nayanaaaaaa]

I feel like this one is more on cute rather on feminine though... am I the only one??

[@krispyboi9162]

Mark has tricked you. He has trapped you in a game of 4D chess that is rigged against you. He said "pass" to get you to make ANOTHER perfect Pokémon for him, thus making him have access to gain a ton of lovely Pokémon that he could smash. It will be a cycle of you making Pokémon and him saying no until he has a ton of Pokémon ladies that he can smash. *Big brained move on Mark's part*

[@greenlanterncarl2693]

This was confirmed to be false. Sowwy, but he sort of smashed this one.

[@krispyboi9162]

@@greenlanterncarl2693 Yeah. But it was fun while it lasted to think that Mark would actually do what I wrote.

[@thomasvangompel7211]

Oh yeah

[@robertlexx]

Por matpat

[@Newtonbur]

An endless cycle! 😂

[@LadyOnikara]

You created my perfect Pokemon, MatPat. Neferkiti is FABULOUS!

[@CeanM75]

Matpat's real name: Matthew "determined" Patrick

[@CeaserMadrazo]

Based on Mark's reaction to the 9 foot vampire lady from Resident Evil, I think he'd be more attracted to something a little taller. This pokemon kinda gives off "cute little girl" vibes, while Mark appears to be into more mature ladies. (The second one, not the joke one.)

[@buraphadtangsinsoophagoon9445]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/jGGypmZvd9eMqaM some one redesign the frist pokemon and its even better

[@ElHarmonyV]

From what I see, Mark is attracted to tall dominant woman so basically woman who can challenge him.

[@oooshafiqooo4722]

​@@ElHarmonyV yeah

[@metazoxan2]

Yeah the design seemed a bit too short. It was probably to make the legs stand out more but it was a bit much IMO.

[@KegianRux]

Spot on. Height needn't have even made it to MatPat's data sheets, as Mark wasn't looking at the stats. He probably would have smashed Neferkiti if she appeared taller.

[@TheRealGuywithoutaMustache]

“Mark if you are not into this one, then I know you must be trolling at this point.” Well, I hope Mark says pass so MatPat makes a part 3.

[@doug.1926]

Here he is

[@CYBERR0CKS]

MatPat just creates another FNAF length mark smashing pokemon series.

[@HelloIAmAnExist]

Same bot, same

[@salag8013]

Same

[@Insanerobert44]

To be honest, I saw one of the iterations with side posture, where the Pokemon looks more flirty to the side that I think Mark would actually fall into it. The chosen forms seems too.... Serious. And I think that was the problem with the first pokemon inspired from Egyptian side. Even the "strong legs" were not as strong showing in the shown image, they looked smaller and average in thickness. Also, point of view is veeeeery important when showcasing a design, no matter what you show so you must catch the best angle for it!!!!!!!

[@ironmanbom7462]

For this Pokemon but matpat you forgot them legs

[@Smile-ih5xf]

I would like you to put all the pokemon he smashed into an Programm that mixes all of them to one

[@hiitsme5524]

NO NO NO IT'S NOT TALL ENOUGH *IT'S NOT TALL ENOUGH* I feel like this is gonna get passed. But then we might get a part 3 so that's gonna be fun lmao

[@savvazotov4196]

That's what i thought too, like come on ...

[@duckduck5728]

Lmao mark modified it to his markimoo taste

[@samchav6818]

Lol, well … he smashed? Kind of?

[@knightofiron]

@@samchav6818 By doing what he did he made it taller, so all the comments were right lol

[@samchav6818]

@@knightofiron True

[@kixad6882]

Conspiracy Theory: Mark is going to continuously pass until Mat has essentially made a whole games worth of smashable pokemon. Edit: INTRODUCING: POKEMON SMASH AND POKEMON PASS! Nintendo's newest two games in the Pokémon franchise! But seriously though I don't usually make edits to my comments, just wanted to say I'm proud of the gold you guys come up with in the replies pfft- (I'm aware that Mark smashed, but I like the unforeseeable reality of Mat continuously making smash-able Pokémon because the thought amuses me.)

[@birthdayfruitecake8158]

It'll specifically be called Pokémon Smash, at that XD

[@archangelrapheal5231]

@@birthdayfruitecake8158 Yeah I can work with that LOL

[@FIVEBASKET]

Um

[@RGC_animation]

Well he smashed it so no.

[@kixad6882]

@@RGC_animation I saw but it was a fun conspiracy while it lasted, I did post this comment before Mark's reply after all. (Although technically he smashed a self made concoction of the two so no?)

[@SpasticSpelunker]

Imagine if this is the only survive video from the 2020s a thousand years from now

[@geustaccount5908]

"What do you think when you think Hawaii" "Pina-" "Flowers"

[@chuckfinley3906]

Matt, you’re taking hard data too seriously when it’s PERSPECTIVE that matters. The actual heights of Mark’s smashes don’t matter, it’s that they APPEAR tall and imposing based on their features. The art still looks incredible though!

[@alfonzomyriandes3843]

Art is at the end of the day subjective, You may look at a piece crafted masterfully and generated by AI, and then look at something else made by an amateur and choose whichever. ~\(o v o)/~

[@kurokyuubi8146]

Matpat is missing something crucial to every design,, mark likes tall and slender elegant pokemon, like lady dimetre-whatever and i suspect the reason he passed the kity cat is because it looks small and bulky and the one he simped over in the other game was tall mommy shaped, the new one looks extremely small and the legs share no similarities with the pokemon markimoo went awooga for so i think itll be a new pass

[@gracegrace2819]

“Mommy shaped” pffft 💀💀💀💀💀

[@mysterizmadi7866]

YES! My thoughts exactly! The bird especially looks like a child to me.

[@danut3181]

Yeah he likes tall and kind of skinny pokemons

[@AutisticBoardGamer]

Exactly! First factor is how tall does it look!

[@KanashimiMusic]

The red bird that he smashed (don't know the name of the Pokémon sorry) was small though.

[@Admiralturtle]

LOL "he refused to smash my Pokémon" that's a sentence i thought id never hear

[@existingiscool1263]

0:47 got me laughing louder than artillery bombardment

[@Gem_Blacklight]

markiplier: "mmmmm pass" matpat: *the feeling of failure in getting mark to smash your pokemon fills you with determination*

[@user-jm6qe6sz2p]

MatPat is a brain burner!(Правдивое видео):....kzbin.info/www/bejne/mqbbmXSiq6-BgNU

[@gotomyhomepageforasub4362]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/f3fcdaakgqiAepo Finally its here.

[@drv8094]

Whats with all these bots ffs

[@Th0mat0]

@Just anything happens a pipebomb?

[@fvclips9681]

someone set off a bot nuke in this reply section

[@Zack.W]

Markiplier: “Pass” Matpat: *-genuinely offended-*

[@user-jm6qe6sz2p]

MatPat is a brain burner!(Правдивое видео):....kzbin.info/www/bejne/mqbbmXSiq6-BgNU

[@canineatnight6026]

How many more do we have to see this 2 rivalary over smash and pass

[@thomasmonroe4717]

The funnest part is that mark reacted to the new pokemon, photoshoped one of the pokemons head onto the body of the other, and said smash.

[@TheStickCollector]

The saga continues Let's see how long this cat and mouse game plays

[@benito23453]

MatPat is a brain burner!(Правдивое видео):..kzbin.info/www/bejne/mqbbmXSiq6-BgNU

[@STICKOMEDIA]

Yea let's

[@jamesanimations4885]

Why are there so many bots

[@boister.1367]

Bruh the bots

[@martalitwa]

Im gonna break The holly 69

[@MoonWielder]

MatPat put effort of a trillion into deducing Mark’s perfect Pokémon and flunked, but you know that he's formulating factual science to the trial when he's trying once more within the span of months as a record.

[@user-lk2ex7ng8r]

MatPat is a brain burner!(Правдивое видео):..kzbin.info/www/bejne/mqbbmXSiq6-BgNU

[@gotomyhomepageforasub4362]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/f3fcdaakgqiAepo Finally its here.

[@LunaticKid889]

@@MrPhantomsDream just report them

[@justafox9773]

I love how Matt pat is treating mark like hes Matt's specimen.

[@oreoicecream1829]

666 likes monkaS

[@smallblackcat1998]

Now that I know that saying no to Mat will only fuel his desire to make you say yes

[@Lydia_Deetz]

For the bird, Lunarlu (Loo-nar-loo) or Lunara (Loo-na-rah) Because the feathers remind me of space, which can be associated with the word Lunar

[@colekiesler6218]

MatPat: “Markiplier please love my Pokémon it truly is a masterpiece.” Markiplier: “Yes and No for both.”

[@reasonablyleftpartiallyright]

Am i the only one who only saw "Markiplier please smash my..." when they saw there suggested videos. That was a bit... Sus

[@pickaxeboi3012]

yesn't

[@Temo-oi6mv]

matpat pokemon is terrable look at it heght and chest and it body it so small it lokks like a kiwi bird

[@timetraveller1233]

The way he changed the color scheme on the body basically says that the first was perfect except for a few small features and the body type, something that MatPat hasn't really focused on except for the strength in the legs and the fact that it should look fem.

[@Tanner_Shelton]

@@Temo-oi6mv were you born in 2014

[@X-SPONGED]

Matt: *_*Makes another 2 of Mark's Perfect Mon so he either smashes one of the other*_* Mark: *_*Opens Adobe Photoshop*_* "I'm gonna do what's called a pro gamer move..."

[@Dinohunter-dh6go]

Yeah lol

[@AU_Player]

"Im not a youtuber... *im a pro gemer*"

[@reubenoakley5887]

Nice SCP logo

[@primarchaether1569]

Neferkiti would probably be long since extinct cause it looks smart enough to use tools and therefore would be seen as a competitor for humanity

[@augustomoreira7441]

0:46 he looks so defeated omg someone feed this man a cookie

[@allycat5609]

As an artist, and someone who's really into design principles, color theory, etc., this really makes me smile. Its so much fun to see the design proccess you went through, and the concept sketches are a fun look into behind the scene stuff! Thanks for making this, even if Mark doesn't smash lol

[@sokaize]

Im not an artist, but it's awesome!

[@ocloudi6202]

"Colour theory" could easily be the 4th channel

[@gemsngold]

@just i c e bot

[@allycat5609]

@@ocloudi6202 i would unironically watch that and likely enjoy every second of it.

[@infinitylord4901]

Honestly I liked the concept sketches more than the the final thing they’ve just more attractive with cleaner sharper proportions and they also have more dominating poses. I also think you could have just taken your joke design more seriously. It actually is an appealing combo of flowing elements mixed with feminine feelings sharp and pointy ones. Even the color scheme works really well.

[@stacyaaa9471]

I'm glad to know I'm not the only one thinking that :D Honestly,I have a feeling mark will smash the joke design instead of the real one XDDDDDD

[@IzDBun]

well i mean, it's for mark to smash, but still

[@Breadheads]

Yeah I feel that the sketches look extremely better than the final product, sad they didn't one of them.

[@demodemou]

as a 2d concept lead artist, the silhouette/shape of what they were going for got lost on the final output. the final outputs are nicely rendered but i definitely agree that the sketches were more dynamic and appealing. the waist and neck were the biggest give away, the torso is too heavy in shape design and the pose looks stiff. the same applies to their first character from the previous video.

[@hiruyabebaw807]

i agree

[@Amk1020]

Matpat, one thing you missed with that bird was: TALL. IT NEEDS TO BE TALL. PERFECT SMASH IF ITAAS TALL

[@GotSwissd]

Neferkiti could be a literal pokemon and I love it.

[@justacatinabanana6279]

Mattpatt brought the concept of a friend telling you he’s gonna find you a nice girl on a whole other level

[@user-jm6qe6sz2p]

MatPat is a brain burner!(Правдивое видео):....kzbin.info/www/bejne/mqbbmXSiq6-BgNU

[@Weeb_Goblin]

They're going to make him a nice girl

[@beatslayer136]

If this goes on long enough, I wouldn't be suprised if he ends up accidentally making his own pokemon region

[@user-bo7hd3go9e]

MatPat is a brain burner!(Правдивое видео):..kzbin.info/www/bejne/mqbbmXSiq6-BgNU

[@ChargedJolteon2]

@👑⃤ ‎ٴ 👑⃤ you gained 11k subs from telling kids they will die big L

[@nerdyboi121]

BOTS BOTS EVERYWHERE

[@gammalolman580]

A region whose Pokémon were created to appeal to a legendary man, but failed to do so

[@zap4th368]

sorry about the bots. but it would be awesome to see what the theorist crew could come up with for a pokemon region

[@tristanapmont7291]

The Birds Name Is,... Pequinia, And The Markiplier Demon Is. Mardivoir.

[@solarianvoid-pi9428]

That intro was funnier than I expected 😂 If that birdie was taller, awoooooo~ definitely a smash from me 👀

[@LanguidWyvern]

I feel like he'll fail again, he's missing something and not noticing it due to sticking to data sets too closely I think. Long, slender, elegant. I think that's what needs to be added, he's only looking at data as he said towards the end.

[@animationtriangle7216]

It looks too childish to me, defiantly needs something taller and like you said more elegant, touching into more feminine features

[@1nkf4ng57]

I feel like the "hair" feathers are too long. That length would look more appealing on a taller pokemon, which is the main thing you've missed both times, height. Id be willing to bet if you'd made them both taller then he'd be more likely to smash. His biggest reactions were to tall, slender, powerful, feminine designs.

[@chsbob9]

I would concur, but your comment raised a question of it's own. Why would a bird based Pokémon have this level of ""hair" feathers"?

[@Zulk_RS]

Yep. Mark seems to like the Dommy-Mommy. See Lady D for proof.

[@gastonfourt5363]

@@Zulk_RS and Nyanlathotep He smashed her like 3 times with the counter back on!

[@vannahdurojaiye3276]

The third one...🤣 Matpat! Just gave up and gave Markiplier himself in a nutshell.🤣🤣🤣

[@cheezman]

The "and what do you do with YOUR freetime" line reminds me of the Wilbur Soot ARG video

[@MiketheBeef2]

I feel like this is just going to turn into a series at this point. A back and forth between Mark and Matt

[@user-bo7hd3go9e]

MatPat is a brain burner!(Правдивое видео):..kzbin.info/www/bejne/mqbbmXSiq6-BgNU

[@ahellofanimp]

Fnaf series but it's just Matt tryna find Mark a Pokemon he'd smash

[@killmeuwu559]

Gotta love how matpat keeps making the designs short, based on his data, despite Mark constantly showing he's into tall women

[@diorse8851]

Lol yeah I think if Matpat really want to get a pass he should look at marks other video’s

[@coletrainhetrick]

Also the fact matpat thinks Mark knows how tall these pokemon are, there's no scale to them, it literally is random

[@Sly-Moose]

I think MatPat's interest in short girls is leaking into his work 😅

[@martinm.4149]

Yeah. I think that's the point maybe. He just going off of data from the pokemon smash or pass videos rather than other data from other videos. That or he's just ignoring the fact that Mark likes tall girls.

[@NWolfsson]

@@martinm.4149 Also, he's a bit (as he realized) too focused on pure data and didn't stop to think where the data came from (Mark typically has TWO types of smash: Animal-like and humanoid-like, each with their own characteristics), which led to a new "perfect Pokémon" as janky as a collage of face parts of female celebrities.

[@ianstln]

im starting to see the pattern of a new type of war happening here

[@zaibjan6089]

I know. What about Markiflyer for the 3rd one.

[@naidemoonshine9522]

Im crying blood every sketch from the artist was more smashable than the end result

[@mooncat1321]

The final design feels to short and stubby imo

[@jaceangel9916]

@@mooncat1321 Yeah, to me the hair counts a significant fraction of the visual height and weight like how Zoroark was designed.

[@alexxs150697]

go woke go broke, matt is just trying to apeal to the woke with fat short and ugly designs

[@Paradox-es3bl]

I'd only say most were, not "every" sketch.

[@pastelberru]

For real, but a lot of the sketches were referenced off existing pokemon poses. Matpat needs to find a pokemon artist who has a higher level of skill

[@cassieanthony6383]

Everyone over at the theorist team is so talented and dedicated! For the 2nd attempt pokemon I immediately though of the name *"Kahetava"* a mix of the hawaiian words Ava - loosely meaning a bird, Etana - meaning strong, Kahuna - the hidden secret and Kahoni - meaning the kiss

[@MrGermandeutsch]

That is an absolutely gorgeous name that I 100% love already!

[@thegiftgiver878]

I agree with you

[@TheBeast94YT]

Nice

[@shoop1161]

GOT SOME BOTS HERE

[@3eveeX]

I can see that.

[@pandatm3741]

ive been a subscriber since 1982, i must say not your best video idea matty boy

[@deepdarkdemons]

I love the Undertale reference at 3:52

[@achtbitkeks]

*You missed something.* Mark is definitely into longer legs, arms and upper bodys and not the small squishy type this creation is and also bedroom eyes, *so I say he passes!* 😉😝 To the artist: Great work again, looks cool and fiiting enough to be official. 👍👍😍😍

[@kaliyahwoods1236]

Not wonder I felt something was missing! After looking a bit I definitely felt that it should have been a little taller. Still hoping Mark smashes though, this artist did an amazing job!

[@ziziorens348]

Yep, that's the ticket. I definitely feel like Mark prefers more slender Pokémons.

[@Thetravelingmonke]

Just remember tall powerful and large because remember lady dimetrescu

[@SauceyRedHN]

Yeah it was a bit underwhelming to see, I definitely expect it to be at least a bit taller and with an upper body; it doesn't look feminine enough.

[@crescentmoon5859]

@@SauceyRedHN it went from legs to head