Gamers Reactions To Red Dead Redemption 2 Sad Ending | Mixed Reactions

Gamers reactions to Arthur Morgan death and possibly the saddest moment of the entire game of Red Dead Redemption 2
Click here to subscribe! ► bit.ly/2DuXTB5
Featured reactions
Intro - 0:00
1 - 1:03 - Alyska - / @alyska
2 - 3:00 - Hollow - / @hollowpoiint
3 - 4:42 - Marz - / @marzz
4 - 6:51 - Beasty - / @beasty
5 - 8:59 - H2ODelirious - / @h2odelirious
6 - 11:17 - 8 Bites - / @8bites
7 - 13:00 - QueenTofu - / @queentofu
8 - 15:06 - TmarTn2 - / @tmartn2
9 - 16:27 - xJuliettex - / @xjuliettex
10 - 17:57 - Anida Gaming - / @anidagaming
11 - 20:09 - xChaseMoney2 - / @xchasemoney2
12 - 21:53 - Typical Gamer - / @typicalgamer
For business and other inquiries email me at - [e-mail]
► Support the channel by leaving a like if you enjoyed this video!▼

[@Goatsht3423]

A Loyal man was left to die. Being loyal to the wrong people is dangerous

[@mcarthur215]

True words you speak

[@mr.derpknight2272]

Way too true

[@adityarana1271]

More Truer words haven't been spoken

[@sahil-vm3od]

@Micah Bell why not

[@sahil-vm3od]

@Micah Bell its not that simple

[@nickohara6506]

Red Dead Depression

[@dapaintbrush6965]

So true

[@nickohara6506]

Da Paintbrush 69 when I finished the game I didn’t speak to any of my friends for 3 days

[@dapaintbrush6965]

@@nickohara6506 dammm. Arthur was such a great character man

[@nickohara6506]

Da Paintbrush 69 let’s hope we can finish our lives like Arthur did, Honorably.

[@dapaintbrush6965]

@@nickohara6506 well heres to hoping

[@rizpect01]

No One ever thought about Charles, he is the true friend of Arthur, he buried him with honor RIP Arthur :(

[@adrianslasmanis9017]

Yes charles is underrated

[@scoutman66]

I'm so fucking glad that Charles pulled through everything. If he would've died, I probably wouldn't recover

[@jacobhayes8324]

I think Arthur had a few good true friends. They just died

[@BlasterzHD]

@@jacobhayes8324 Everyone who died in the story would've sided with Arthur. Hell, if Hosea was still alive, the whole side choosing wouldn't have happened.

[@platinumhunter9759]

Saide was a true friend as well

[@ncrranger5186]

Fun fact the actor of Dutch actually got emotional in this scene and cried

[@ArmiaKhairy]

for real?

[@ncrranger5186]

@@ArmiaKhairy yes

[@Jadefrost_10]

@@ArmiaKhairy yep

[@PrederNationteam74]

*Proof?*

[@bingus9813]

@@PrederNationteam74 this comment

[@nbgyguy]

Start of rdr2: YEEEEEHAH IM A COWBoY BABY End of rdr2: *what's the meaning of life?*

[@Mreeg.]

For real the moment I beat the game I felt empty

[@hollownxt1295]

Thegamingegg That was exactly the same way for me

[@kaskad_1]

CoWBoi* or CowBoah, not boy

[@luisenrique7240]

Nathan BG Young Lol Same here, the feels man

[@drixy7205]

I think I lost my soul when I witnessed Arthur's death

[@Nobodysurvivesevenonebit]

The most legendary character of all time Arthur Morgan.

[@crimsonlord525]

@@loganmitchell9254 nazeem from skyrim

[@AM-zq4zi]

@Logan mitchell you should respect his opinion because in his opinion (and my opinion ) he is the best

[@vinizin8291]

@@AM-zq4zi Idea? You mean opinion?

[@loganmitchell9254]

@@crimsonlord525 Hmmm, close but not either

[@loganmitchell9254]

@@AM-zq4zi You should respect mine

[@dikprintt]

The reason I cried so damn much was because Rockstar made Arthur such a real character, so real in fact that he almost felt human. I’m in love with this game.

[@eliasharris9349]

We all knew how this was gonna end, but it still hurt like hell, man.

[@KITN._.8]

When I he talked the nun about being afraid….I realized what was going to eventually happen. It hurt so god damn much.

[@Kakapuuks]

I didn’t even care that he died, I was just pissed that I couldn’t live on a ranch as Arthur.

[@JamesCastle-vd1lc]

i recently played this game with 5 years worth of spoilers under my belt cried my goddamn eyes out

[@user-qe6lp1tt8p]

I HATE YOU@@Kakapuuks

[@thegreatchipman]

@@JamesCastle-vd1lc Same. I though since I knew the story it wouldn't affect me. I was wrong

[@hehincredible7615]

This shows what rockstar could do when they try their hardest.

[@Hence_Diane555]

Pc port shows what rockstar could do when they try the least.

[@bruh-bn3ni]

this shows what rockstar can do together, multiple departments worked on this. for GTA 5 only one did I think. hope GTA 6 can compare with this

[@hairylegs1319]

Agreed, although I doubt they can top this absolute masterpiece@@bruh-bn3ni

[@memegod4674]

Now they gonna remaster gta V for the next 6 years

[@ljc1278]

@@hairylegs1319 gta 6 is the only game I have hopes for anymore

[@trafficcone4503]

What hurts the most, is hearing Arthur taking his last breath

[@forrestreed9350]

Yeah but the motivation he inspires crawling to his place is crazy

[@samulimoisio720]

Yeah, and it's also realistic, when we humans or animals die slowly like that, our body takes a final deep breath and then it's over 😔

[@forrestreed9350]

@Arthur Morgan UNDEAD NIGHTMARE CONFIRMED 😂😂😂

[@karlijnbellemans8964]

@@samulimoisio720 the Cheyne-Stokes breathing is mostly heard by people who are about to die

[@Dat-Boi-Camoja]

God damn 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢 like he’s saying *”well shit I can finally rest now”*

[@elil8094]

I cried like a baby. I had to step away from my monitor because I was so heartbroken. It’s crazy how something like a video game can really get under your skin. It really felt like I was losing a friend

[@KITN._.8]

I milked the game when I was going through depression and emotional abuse . Losing him, I don’t think I’ll experience something worse. He died alone, all Fucking alone.

[@elil8094]

@@KITN._.8 this game came out the year I really struggled with my mental health. I was suicidal and I was using this game as a way of distracting myself. I made a conscious effort to not finish the game, because I wasn’t ready and the ending had been spoiled for me. The feeling of finally being able to finish it after 6 months of mental health treatment was both incredibly sad and was a proud moment too. I guess it was kind of symbolic for me, that I was willing to let it go. (Then I played story mode 5 more times lmao)

[@KITN._.8]

@@elil8094 that’s great, I’m happy you found solitude. But I don’t I think it can be that for me. I’m too attached on all accounts, I don’t think I’ll be able to let him go.

[@ketchupidk8193]

Arthur Morgan, Joel Miller, Lee Everet are all legends that have died😭

[@XDRevnge]

Don't forget the God of L U M B A G O

[@lepsikilla6998]

We’ll Tlou2 story writing is terrible…soo Joel’s character basically sucks…lee only got one season from the walking dead but yea there goats

[@anomanopy8087]

I was thinking about that. They better not add Kratos to that list, man...

[@ArbiterofMankind]

@@lepsikilla6998 What is TLOU2? I've only heard of the untainted TLOU.

[@lepsikilla6998]

@@ArbiterofMankind one of the trashes games ever

[@RelaxedNedy]

If you didn’t help John get to his family just don’t talk to me

[@Thatbluef150]

Fax bruh

[@a.k.aambrose5560]

What about cutting Micha's right eye?

[@lemskio9624]

I did both endings with high honor, not saving his family with high honor causes micah to lose his eye

[@jamessotelo3336]

Regardless of which ending, you still draw Micah and the Pinkertons away from John, allowing him to escape

[@BurningSorrows]

Exactly true facts bruh, family comes first before the money, that shit can come later

[@thestateofdelaware8057]

“Come on Dutch, DUTCH COME ON!!! *Angry rat noises”

[@exodustimes4266]

That smirk that Arthur gave afterwards was everything

[@lololovy1188]

Idk if I cry or laugh

[@skeleton599]

AUREEEGHHGH

[@45jmo]

Shame Arthur got stage 5 lumbago

[@johnmarston2590]

Micah: *whines in rat*

[@unstablenecrophage278]

And this is why we still play single player games and gaming is the purest form of entertainment. Hours upon hours shaping and connecting to a character for him to die is a horrible way. Its enough to bring anyone to tears

[@Pluvillion]

To this day, seeing everyone's reactions as they witness Arthur's final breath never fails to get me.

[@MrBlack252]

The little hint of laughter from Arthur after Micah walks off mad showed that Arthur saw Dutch Walk away from Micah and he knew that Dutch finally believed him.

[@MrBlack252]

@@Gamfluent it's more of a relief laugh, like he can now die knowing Dutch believes Micah is a rat. And I know alot of people wanted Dutch to shoot Micah right there or even pull Arthur up and sit there with him as he took his last breath but if Dutch did that then it would completely negate who he has become over the course of the story and who we see in RDR1. Although Benjamin Byron Davis said that after they shot that scene and after he walked away he had to stand there for a few moments because he was balling his eyes out. He said they probably have motion capture footage of Dutch crying as he's walking away.

[@vinizin8291]

@@MrBlack252 "Dutch believes Micah is a rat" Yeah...maybe. Not sure, since Dutch sided with Micah on the epilogue, and in the first game he was one of the villains. Dutch knew Micah was a rat, but he still didn't care.

[@MrBlack252]

@@vinizin8291 ok well Dutch didn't side with Micah in the epilogue first of all. It was hinted throughout the entire conversation that Dutch went there to kill Micah and take the money. That's what Dutch was going to do all along he was going to kill Micah because he knew. When Dutch saw John it changed. He knew Micah still needed to die but he wasn't about to kill John to take the money so he just left. He even says "same as you I suppose" when John asks what he was doing there.

[@oscarwang7227]

@@vinizin8291 Micah was manipulating Dutch by agreeing to every one of his ideas. That way he seems more loyal. Throughout the game, Dutch’s ego gets damaged. The ending isn’t really happy for Dutch. By that point he definitively knew that Micah was the traitor, but admitting to that was admitting he was wrong and his legacy was over. In the end, when Dutch finally shoots Micah, that is him facing his failure. He doesn’t get redeemed but he finally admits to his faults instead of shooting John and continuing to lie to himself.

[@vinizin8291]

@@MrBlack252 When Dutch said that he was there for the same as John, he meant he was there for the money. If he meant he was there to kill Micah It wouldn't make sense. Why didn't he kill him already If that's what he meant?

[@javierescuella3911]

I’m happy most people had the honorable ending. That’s the real way he is supposed to leave.

[@royalinterista5148]

What about you? you and bill took dutch's side. DISAPPOINTED

[@Jagmkkk]

ROYAL GAMING if you look closely , Javier Wasn’t pointing his gun at them , he had it pointing up

[@mello_boi2339]

You know who so he never actually sided with anyone

[@SonLam2k1]

ROYAL GAMING javier like micah the survivor but always be brother to athur that why in the end he just run with bill and never look back he don’t chose a side

[@snipercow861]

Dam u Javier

[@Yahoo07_]

Rest In Peace old friend. "I tip my hat to you, one legend to another."

[@anabenskywalker122]

Man you just hit me with a massive wave of nostalgia

[@stickmanstudios4609]

Arthur Morgan was a man of honour and respect. He was the kind of man youd want to have behind you in a fight. Arthur was a brilliant person within the Red Dead Redemption series. Arthur is what pulled me out of my depression. Arthur is the reason I love life. I am eternally thankful for Arthur being in my life, in-game or not.

[@patrickmusqua8076]

The fact that the actor who plays Dutch cried his eyes out makes me think that Dutch cried his eyes out walking away. Technically he did...

[@The0neWhoWa1ts]

Wait for real???... Damn...

[@nathanspencer5014]

@@The0neWhoWa1ts he did the actor said he walked away crying in one of his interviews

[@The0neWhoWa1ts]

@@nathanspencer5014 no wonder his In-game counter part Sayed quiet when walking away...

[@elijahtbh.]

Damn

[@the_fatcowboy8097]

Thank you for telling me I feel his pain

[@shax232]

When Arthur died, it literally made me depressed for a week

[@alexmercer5414]

Well you knew Arthur was going to die

[@BurningSorrows]

I feel you

[@therandom20000]

And my horse

[@mabbott946]

We will most likely never see Arthur in another red dead game either ripperoni

[@alexmercer5414]

@@mabbott946 he probably will be referenced in another game

[@Zinc876]

That last mission was hard..not because there were difficult shootouts, but because I had to play it with tears running down my eyes as it went. Also when he was taking his final ride with his horse, and hearing the voices of people he helped..that also broke me. Oh, and the horse..I had the pure white horse with me the entire game. When it got shot and he comforted her before running off with John, fuck. This game made me care so much and fall in love with its characters. They felt so genuine.

[@Foxy-Plush]

Notice how in the beginning Arthur was more cruel and mean but after being exposed to TB he started to change into a very good and honorable man. This shows how our lives change how we act after an action or something has changed or happen it shows that life is short and that we should always change our act and our ways before it’s to late.

[@rituEllie]

I got the impression early in the game, before I knew any of this, that he was a decent man living a bad life through circumstance and learned behaviour. Many people are like this, and it takes work to break out of that... I love that for Arthur. He was trying to follow what he knew was right in his heart, not what he was taught he was meant to do as an outlaw (Obvs depends how you play that is, lol)

[@Ozzie_Mandias]

As blind prophet Cassidy’s said... That which is killing you will help you see the Devil’s lies...and he did especially when Dutch started killing in cold blood and began grooming new young disenfranchised people... Arthur realized what Dutch always was... we have all been though this... once we see a trusted relative groom us... only we did not realize until we became adults and saw said relative do it to other young people. Hosea May have had a soul... but Dutch was always a demon... and even Blind Prophet Cassidy calls Dutch.. “The Devil”.

[@M_martinez65653]

Yeah....that's literally the entire point of the story....

[@sreenaths6829]

He was still showing genuine concern for the gang even at the start. Him and Hosea were the only ones questioning Dutch when he planned to ambush the O'Driscolls.

[@raghost3147]

I only cried 3 times while playing a game, and it was all red dead 2 1. When my horse dies 2.When arthur dies 3. When we see his grave during the credits

[@LaMishiMish]

Omfg you're not wrong. I watched my younger brother play through this, and I too cried when your horse gets killed. The option to leave it pains me, and Arthur comforting it while it's slipping away just twists the knife in the wound.

[@Njord16]

I started crying when you were on your final ride back to camp, then really started bawling when Arthur gave John his hat and my horse died.

[@stellamayfaire1426]

4. when i read his diary, playing as John

[@crazyfish9523]

I shed a tear during Arthur’s final ride.

[@jipidy]

I got angry when my horse died it was a good horse full bond but I replaced it Arthur dying made me cry

[@AbeZchannel]

it's amazing how quick people go from cursing Micah to being silent for Arthur's death.

[@XDRevnge]

The va for micah hated himself after playing the game

[@kukkik7039]

Who wouldnt

[@ilovedragonball2435]

Everyone hates Micah but they owed Arthur respect when he died

[@yoshpeters3079]

Yes when I first beat it I can’t believe how fast I had to switch gears from crying like a baby to being serious when John is riding with his family. Rip a legend the goat game character who is more than a character he is a part of me and lots of people.

[@DieHardRedemption]

​@@XDRevngeMicah is that excellent as the main antagonist that even Peter Blomquist hated him (his VA)

[@Waysubs]

I had the worst honor possible until the last few missions and I looked it up and realized that honor had a significant role to play in the ending so I did everything in my power to get good honor and it made the scene with the deer so much better because the deer almost looks like he would say “you did it”

[@thomasgreen3060]

I played Arthur Morgan's final "ride" in Red Dead Redemption 2 last night and I cried for about 45 minutes after. Wow! I am tearing up just thinking about it. No movie has ever done that to me before. I am not even going to play the last 20% of the game. RDR2 is a work of art. I'm crying again.

[@patrickheslin2085]

No! U have to keep playing, avenge him!!!

[@alboorts]

KEEP PLAYING IT KEEP PUSHING

[@thomasgreen3060]

@@alboorts I got him. I got Micah.

[@alboorts]

@@thomasgreen3060 good now play rdr1 it’s worth it it takes place after rdr2

[@LateNightHalo]

We all knew where the story was going but it still hurt to see it end. What matters is that he tried in the end. With the time he had left, he tried. He died as a better person than he lived. He sought some form of redemption. What a good game

[@BigIronOnMyHip69]

Well, they didn't have to kill off Arthur, they could have written it to where he never gets sick, but that he runs away like John and his family but he runs away with Marry in the end, like the 2 talked about in chapter 4. Arthur wanted to get out. But still his death is very sad to this day.

[@LateNightHalo]

@@BigIronOnMyHip69 if Arthur “got away” then I don’t think the story would have been good. The game shows us that “if you live a bad life, the hurt you caused will eventually catch up with you” Arthur’s death was sealed the day he beat a sick man to death for just a few dollars. All he could do was redeem himself before his sins caught up with him

[@BigIronOnMyHip69]

@@LateNightHalo yeah I understand why he died, I knew it pretty early on, didnt take long to put 2 and 2 together to know he was going to from when Thomas Downes coughed in his face while being very sick and dying shortly after. Then Arthur starts coughing throughout the game and I knew he got it from Thomas, just didn't know the exact sickness. I still just wish Arthur could have had that happily ever after ending with Marry :(

[@mcm4rr]

@@BigIronOnMyHip69 well that would ruin the entire point of the game. The entire game is about getting redemption for your sins that you did in the past, before you die. Hence why it's called red dead redemption.

[@mcm4rr]

This applies to both rdr games. Both john and Arthur died in the end, but redeeming themselves before that. Arthur sacrificed himself so that John and his family might live a good life. John sacrificed himself so that jack and abigail might live a good life. I'm sure john could've escaped but that meant he would be hunted down for the rest of his life, along with his family. He wanted his wife and son to have a good life so instead of letting them live worrying about the law, he sacrificed himself to let them have a decent life

[@MrMctrae]

I cried so hard at the end, my wife came into the room, and she knew why, Arthur is more than just a game Character.

[@c-moon8789]

Ik

[@damn8648]

Gamers dont have wives Btw im kidding

[@jacoblounsbury1686]

Ya my brother come upstairs from downstairs he knew I was going to cry

[@thepurpleyam4078]

He’s more than a game charakter. *he’s a game character*

[@RIP_cayde-6]

thank you for saying that partner

[@iitickle6510]

Watching that beautiful buck turn and look at us before peacefully leaving was insanely painful. I didn't realize Arthur was gone until that very moment.

[@LFAN1976]

First time I shed a tear for a videogame character, in spite of seeing it coming. Congratulations to those who wrote, developed and produced this masterpiece. By far, the best game I ever played, and the best story. By far the best videogame character. RIP Arthur Morgan.

[@FedezPros.89]

The First Time i start the game: WOAH IM A COWBOY The end: i want my cowboy back 🙁

[@revo0157]

OH FUK U ALIVE.

[@richardsarcilla1533]

@@revo0157 WOAH WOAH CHILL

[@revo0157]

@@richardsarcilla1533 DUDE HE’S GODDAMN GOD

[@iandanskin8188]

Your ok boah

[@TheEmpiresStrongest]

Alfred: God in the DC Universe Arthur Morgan: God in the Red Dead Redemption story.

[@tanaka9260]

Damn it’s already been 2 years. What a memorable game

[@mr.derpknight2272]

Shit you’re right. I didn’t even realize

[@navenici3493]

Really??? Good god that’s crazy. This has and will always be one of my favorite games. A goddamned masterpiece is what it is.

[@rickyg9669]

Not til next month, it’s still 1 year and 11 months

[@nellym759]

Holy i got it on chrismas

[@paulharper4196]

I only started playing it about a month ago, we inherited a ps4 a year ago but I had no real interest in gaming anymore, that ship had sailed several years ago, rdr2 was in the pile of games and I largely forgot about it. Eventually, I decided one Sunday after the kids had gone to bed to load it up and give it a go. I loved the original rdr, all the gta games etc, well holy shit this knocked all of them into a cocked hat. Easily the best, most immersive, beautiful and emotional game I've ever played. I finished the epilogue an hour ago, then decided to come on here and see if Arthur's death kicked anyone else in the feels as much as it did me. Yep. I feel hollow. Like I've actually lost a real life friend. Crazy that a game can make one feel that way.

[@nanzy21]

When Arthur died i cried so hard, especially since i took Buell on my last mission. When he whispered thank you It just hurt because i remember that amish was like a friend to arthur and he asked me to take care of him. Then i remember that at least amish will see Buell again and arthur can let him know we got the boar after all. He was a good man, and he did his very best to redeem himself at the end and everybody noticed that.

[@randomguy3080]

I always heard Arthur was a great character and when I played it, I didn’t see it, I thought he would be perfect, but then I realized that’s why he’s an amazing character, he’s not perfect, he’s just a guy, trying his best to do the right thing or survive depending on your choices, he feels like an actual human being, like a friend we lost, and man…. It hurts… it hurts

[@johnlex5688]

I just watched Arthur Morgan dying 12 times... *Dude, why.*

[@Alpysf]

I probably did it even more, why are we so hard on ourselves?

[@octopus3376]

It is so hard being someone who bought the game and finished it when it 1st came out, it is extra sad when you don’t see the ending on youtube

[@no_one01-5]

Because Arthur deserves our love.

[@johnmarston1468]

İs depression game but best

[@alancortes2787]

Your hurting yourself

[@jenstoddard6179]

Arthur didn't die alone, he died with us watching over him.

[@lostemu8988]

:,)

[@gerardwayseyelash]

@@RIP_cayde-6 Rest In Peace. 🥺🖤

[@tarikccix1954]

@@RIP_cayde-6 are u taking care of your horse Arthur bcs if ur not im coming to heaven for you 🤣

[@jukkaputtonen4797]

With the deer which he killed in the beginning of the game

[@and-168]

And you didn't help him

[@Jimbarleyy]

Crash of worlds/unshaken is one of the most chilling soundtracks for an ending i’ve heard in a long time. Also when he rides back to camp and i hear that song, it feels like i really knew this man. You damn rockstar writers, hats off to you!!!

[@medhros]

When Arthur was about to ride to his death I remember saying "oooh, Arthur..." and I see a lot of people doing the same. It is such a beautiful character that (in my case) did so much good things.

[@speedissped3967]

The fact that he crawled just to be right in front of the sunrise is just even more sad

[@alejandrotiradomagana7913]

The sunrise is symbolic it represents his redemption. You can guess that the sunrise is fake if you watch the others finals

[@oldarthurmorgan6319]

@@alejandrotiradomagana7913 there not "fake" it's a real sunrise because this is the canon ending tho yeah it means his redemption

[@the_mse]

He said something about wanting his death to be while looking at a sunrise

[@elyjah9388]

@@the_mse You're close! During Chapter 3, Tilly, Hosea, and I believe Lenny are around the table by Arthur's tent and they all talk about how they wanna be buried, Tilly asks Arthur and he brushes it off before pausing and saying he wants to be buried to the west so he can watch the sunset and think of all the good times they had. And his grave in game doesn't face the west, but it is on the west side of a mountain so he can watch the sunset, Charles most likely overheard and buried him like that.

[@the_mse]

@@elyjah9388 close enough lol

[@francosanchez1152]

Top 5 best protagonist of all time 1. Arthur Morgan 2. Lee Everett 3.Old man Kratos 4. John Marston 5. Joel Miller

[@butter6959]

Why did I think you wrote spider-man?

[@Tux12411]

Ezio Auditore is one of my personal favorites

[@antonbrig5171]

soap mactavish

[@randomgod6371]

Where is solid snake?

[@Piegeamorue]

Carl Johnson

[@_int_4652]

Remebering those days with Arthur where we hunted down animals, did fishing, killing bounties, horse rides and many more😢😢

[@hoppingh907]

The reason this scene is so emotional is because the player gets to see Arthur’s growth throughout the game. Rockstar found a way for Arthur to grow in a good enough way that the player feels an emotional connection to them. So when he dies, we aren’t just losing a video game character, we are also losing a comrade and a friend.

[@Lazyboijere]

That final ride to the camp broke me down knowing Arthur’s story was coming to an end, what a great character.

[@s3npai486]

I cried like a baby and I dont normally cry

[@AshYamz]

God damn. That was too much

[@elrisitas3052]

"Be loyal to what matters" -Arthur Morgan to John Marston at 1899

[@cyrosubod2317]

You’re crying bro look at your profile you’re crying 😭 and i 😭😭😭😭😭

[@elrisitas3052]

@@cyrosubod2317 haha you're right

[@jacks2538]

@@elrisitas3052 and after that point, he put his family first with trying to stay pure and even built them a permanent home and resting place...

[@XDRevnge]

@@elrisitas3052 R.I.P el risitas and Arthur morgan

[@dailymadness5159]

Thanks for the mixed reactions. I always like to watch other people react to something that made me cry so that I have someone to cry with. Looking up people's reactions to something that made me cry is the first thing I do when I'm feeling sad.

[@themask9344]

Rest in peace Arthur... you will live in our hearts until our end

[@maxpaynegk]

"Is he going to pull through?" The song: Naw.

[@thegamingboi4342]

Is he going to pull through The song: youre not that guy pal

[@brenale_heartsJesus]

😂

[@johnroc4497]

When Arthur said "I tried, in the end, I did" is when I started crying

[@RIP_cayde-6]

at lest the others made it,and John

[@pegatrisedmice]

it was the look towards the sunrise and the music that got me.

[@ezio6834]

I cried when Arthur said “I gave all I had I did”

[@baganda2129]

@@ezio6834 me two

[@lepsikilla6998]

I started tearing up when Author helped Tilly, jack, and Abigail…best protagonist ever…I definitely started crying like a little bitch when John called author his brother

[@thewhiteknight8595]

Never have I had a deeper connection with a video game character before like Arthur Morgan. I miss him. :(

[@juliuspearce]

Arthurs character was so well made and rockstar really did great to make us feel connected and feel attached to Arthur. The ending made me cry but I like to think Arthur was able to die a happy peaceful death helping John and his family and his death was not in vain

[@TrystonTX]

Arthur is the best Rockstar character. Live and die by the town

[@nbgyguy]

*best fictional character

[@brobro9169]

@@nbgyguy yes you are correct.

[@prska]

@@nbgyguy agreed

[@MostDopeLarry]

Yes sir !

[@TrystonTX]

2Dank 4U Agreed so

[@Hgtgvhj]

Beastly just said the realest thing about Arthur. He was a good person deep down but he didn’t belong in society and he owed his loyalty to the gang

[@patrickhughes9304]

That’s kind of the core story is about 2 men (Arthur’s and Dutch) who realize abruptly that the world no longer has any use for them. One accepts it and goes peacefully into his good night while doing as much good as he can. The other fights and kills like a cornered animal, carrying on wounded and afraid for a reason he doesn’t fully understand until a hunter finally puts him down.

[@Hgtgvhj]

@@patrickhughes9304 I think Dutch started to realize that the world was becoming more civilized, therefore his dream of utopia wasn’t possible anymore

[@jorgeloredo100]

Arthur (the good king) Morgan (the evil witch) a character constantly fighting with his own duality

[@delete7316]

Bro I was literally balling for hours, I’d played 100 hours doing loads of bs in the games world and really getting immersed into Arthur’s character and when he died it felt like I lost a friend. I had to pretend I was ill for school because I was to upset to do anything else. What a fucking game man!

[@mayurmaisuria7763]

Red dead redemption 2 is by far the best game I have ever played. I have never cried for any game ever. When I played rdr2 for the first time I bawled my eyes out, especially in this scene, and when Arthur's horse dies. I was sad for about a month after finishing the game. This game is perfect.

[@Megacooler96_]

This is by far the best story and set of characters Rockstar has created. It'll be tough to top this. This is a top 10 game in the 2000s for sure

[@hehincredible7615]

Wait until GTA 6 blows this out of the water, I can’t wait

[@Megacooler96_]

@@hehincredible7615 hopefully, im still worried that the main people left Rockstar could affect future games

[@herredward9277]

@@hehincredible7615 I mean, GTA is all fun and over the top action and satire, Red Dead is story, world building, and character development.

[@andreakevin8685]

Silent Hill 2 says hi to you

[@vinizin8291]

@@andreakevin8685 Is that game created by Rockstar?

[@snxipezp4994]

i have only cried 2 times in my life 1: when i was born 2:

[@vinizin8291]

I guess everyone cried when they were born lol. (Idk but i have a feeling i'm gonna get wooooshed.)

[@motionmadness2735]

C4T I wanted to but nah... I ain’t gonna ruin this moment.

[@vinizin8291]

@@motionmadness2735 It wouldn't even count, since ik it's a joke

[@devongaming7253]

A way out

[@motionmadness2735]

@@vinizin8291 yeh i guess hehe

[@brianboru8858]

This hit me on a level that I was not expecting. I lived in hope he would somehow survive throughout, praying he would find a cure and escape, then he died and it felt like losing someone I knew and cared for weird as it is to say. Couldn’t play as John for at least a month afterwards lol. This storyline is better than any game, film or TV series created.

[@Yaboymasonyuh]

i feel them. when i got to the end i was crying so hard. arthur was such a good character

[@fordhampton]

I literally played the game a second time to see how the un-honorable was. I “accidentally” picked the honorable ending again.

[@patrickhughes9304]

You have to actively bust your ass to get low honor. The things that reduce your honor reduce by minuscule amounts and the things that raise your honor raise it by a huge amount. That’s why I’ll always consider the sunrise ending the canon ending.

[@fordhampton]

@@patrickhughes9304 yeah I agree, but it’s just SO hard to be a bad person...

[@ig-_-os1342]

Salute for him please

[@SmokeyMcpott-hv4pq]

@@patrickhughes9304 what do you mean? Its so easy to get low honor, you can just go around shooting people, and stealing their wagon, and sell it to the fence. You can rob stores everywhere, and just randomly get in bar fights. Those are just some of the things to get low honor. Frankly you do, and you don't have to bust your ass to get high honor, sometimes in missions, or random encounters you can get a high honor boost, but other than that it also goes up a miniscule amount. Thanks for reading

[@adamc_vp77]

@@patrickhughes9304 I mean it is called read dead redemption, arthur redeemed himself and was rewarded with the death he wanted

[@thedarkknight727]

I guess he found Lenny in the end.

[@MariaMartinez-ee4sq]

🤠🤠🤠🤠👍👍👍👍

[@kangerooman5558]

😔😔😔😔😔😵😭😢

[@boop1757]

HaHaHaHa FoUnD yAh LeNnAyyyyy but still it's sad.

[@chompisxd1311]

*arthur kick heaven's doors" arthur - ¡¡¡¡LENNYYYY!!!!

[@x-rax716]

@@chompisxd1311 He will be at hell.

[@DineroSucio754]

Hearing Arthur weezing trying to breath hives me so much anxiety because I had very bad asthma as a kid. I know how that feels.

[@ck.s]

Even though we knew he's not going to make it.. still we had a small hope but when the song kicks in, we just blank out.. feel hollow.. the entire story of Arthur runs through your mind... very rarely a video game death makes this much impact.. Gotta give credits where its due to not only Rockstar as a whole but to each person who was responsible for this...

[@thedarkknight2221]

If this were made into a movie or mini series critics who never played a video game in their life would call this the greatest western ever made.

[@thedarkknight2221]

SuperNinja's Personal Channel excuse you Red Dead Redemption 1 has an opinion on that.

[@paulharper4196]

Watch a series called hell on wheels. It actually has quite a few similarities with this game.

[@awabali1062]

Totally agreed

[@nicoth.412]

I would bingewatch Red Dead Redemption 2 if it was a show on Netflix...

[@ibuprofriends]

lmaooo

[@KimJongUn_DPRK]

"For loyalty is both your blessing and your curse" -Blind Man Cassidy RDR2

[@ultimatechessplaya]

that man makes much more sense now that i listen closer to his quotes

[@nathanridenour8380]

imo this is the most emotional ending and the best, when you can watch the same scene over and over and cry every time, then you know they did a damn good job on the storytelling and charcter development to draw out the emotion

[@theberetdepression8217]

I never cried whenever Arthur died, but I always got this chilling feeling, like I lost someone valuable in my life.

[@alperenerol1852]

Real men don't cry Rockstar: *hold my plan*

[@srivatshans1747]

More like *hold my protagonists*

[@yankoelgueta1116]

Hold my mangoes

[@virgin1792]

Hold my legendary rat pelt

[@pratamaputra570]

Hold my moneh

[@pavasite4278]

If you didnt cry from this then you're not a real man

[@antonioreyes2304]

Just seeing Arthur’s death is like watching your close friend die 😭😭 definitely enough to make a grown man cry

[@antonioreyes2304]

I miss playing as Arthur

[@jukkaputtonen4797]

Yep...

[@XDRevnge]

@@antonioreyes2304 where girls cried: Susan Where bois cried: Hosea Where everyone recieved a jumpscare: Sean Where men cried: John Where Greek gods cried: Arthur

[@Alicia-dv6vg]

@@XDRevnge where girls cried : molly where boys cried : Susan Where men cried : hosea Where real men cried : John Where legends cried : arthur maybe next is me ;(

[@averymusicalperson]

@@antonioreyes2304 forgot to switch account?

[@liambenn1214]

I would give anything to re experience this story again, truly incredible

[@soleelk8504]

I just finished the game a week ago and I didn't cry until the epilog when I said to my friends (who all beat the game well before me) "I don't want to play as John, I want to play as Aruthr, he's my favorite protagonist." That's when I cried.

[@grimm3593]

Three songs to guarantee me to cry 1. That’s the way it is 2. Don’t think twice 3. Crash of Worlds

[@Akos20003]

What about Mountain Hymn?

[@dakidskidboxer5631]

This is unrelated but you should listen to Korn - Daddy. Try not to feel uncomfortable and break down.

[@legatelanius9762]

You mean Unshaken?

[@caye3712]

La vie en la rose is a big one

[@englishpatriot545]

For me 1.deadmans gun (rdr1) 2.may I stand unshaken(rdr2) 3.thats the way it is (rdr2)

[@kem276]

When Arthur's horse died, (Tenesse Walker you get in the very beginning) I started to tear up. When Arthur tells John they both won't make it, realization kicks in on what's about to happen. And finally, when Arthur dies, even though I knew it was coming, I didn't expect it. This, is when I started crying. Didn't play the Epilogues for another month or so.

[@apurvashanker]

I didn't play the Epilogue for months either lol The game ended with Arthur, IMO. The epilogue was just context for John's story. John's story, as good as it was, did not feel good after losing Arthur as the main protagonist. Too big of a transition.

[@bungersinyourarea]

It's been almost 3 months since I completed chapter 6 and I still haven't touched the epilogue, it just isnt the same game without Arthur

[@somerandommushroomhead1534]

I just finished the game and when Juan died (my horse) I wanted to kill every Pinkerton in America

[@Suzuha_Amane]

micah dies in the epilogue

[@tubtubsablubblubs3996]

I actually had Beau’s Horse… fucking sad

[@dice1331]

I remember in the game, even just visiting the barber and seeing Arthur's face struggling and weezing, I felt so bad. My man did everything he thought was right. It just pains me that he died alone, even more so that he wasn't mentioned in rdr1. Yeah I know the devs didn't have him in mind back then but still..

[@SyNc2005]

I can watch this ending, a million times. And each watch through I will have the same reaction. I’ve never cried so hard for a video game before, but this ending had me bawling. The game was great at making you love, or hate, each character. And I felt a deep love for Arthur throughout the game. RIP Mr. Morgan. And Burn in Hell Mr. Bell. A quick note, I love how they represented his change in the ending. When asked he said he wanted to die facing West, watching the sunset. But in the end he was facing East, watching the sunrise.

[@connerc.1963]

RDR 1 ending: ahhh, but I want to keep playing as John RDR2 ending: I wish I was still playing as Arthur

[@lmd664]

RDR1 ending: I don’t wanna play as Jack I wanna play as John RDR2 ending: I don’t wanna play as John I wanna play as Arthur

[@luigicavallo270]

@@lmd664 Rdr 3 ending: I don't wanna play as Arthur, I wanna Play as Isaac

[@luigicavallo270]

@@Alen2707 Arthur's son

[@luigicavallo270]

@@Alen2707 *had

[@Alen2707]

@@luigicavallo270 he died how

[@tommo5597]

Arthur wasn't just a video game character - he was an example to all of us to be the best we possibly can.

[@zachforde3798]

Well said

[@milkncookies1115]

U know he killed hundreds and stuff right

[@bingus9813]

@@milkncookies1115 Yes i know

[@shawnthompson2303]

@@milkncookies1115 O' Driscolls, Raiders, Murfrees, Night Folk, KKK .... Yeah, such a shame Arthur had to kill them 🤦

[@shawnthompson2303]

you're god damn right.

[@user-pc4sj3pt1o]

Imagine if Arthur just wake up in the bar with Lenny after he dies

[@shannricco4772]

看到中文ID了，握手🤝

[@thebigmilk7407]

Love the smile Arthur cracks after Micah walks away defeated during the help John good ending.

[@nbgyguy]

I think everyone whos played has a deep connection with arthur ngl

[@bogomilpetrov2995]

Check the comments for Brix Cer you don't have to scroll much to find it

[@BurningSorrows]

I hella do, it was like I was losing a brother from another mother in a game.

[@adamkrajco1920]

I started crying when Arthur gave his hat to John..and then I just started balling

[@kraio-sfu]

I hope you mean bawling, otherwise I’m just imagining you pick and rolling on Arthur’s corpse lmao

[@koreancowboy42]

And gave John his bag

[@orangeportals]

@@kraio-sfu ROBBIN UP A TRAIN, FOR CAMP

[@1ZosoLZ]

I still cry even as if it’s my first playthrough while watching these

[@drybigmacsauce]

This ending still makes me tear up everytime

[@srenaml3632]

It’s nice that on Arthur’s last breath he wasnt gasping for air or nothing. He just calmly breathed in and out.

[@moniquej2997]

Technically when people die of tb, it's because they drowned in their blood

[@theuntitledproget2648]

I hope that how I will go calmly breathing in and out

[@jorgundom]

Remember when people said they didn’t want to play as Arthur? Not to be a cringe but this is the first time ive ever had 1k likes on a comment, very noice, thanks 👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽

[@makayla1223]

Oh how the turntables

[@RezeTsarBomba]

i dont remember that lmao

[@pimpstickmafia3997]

@@RezeTsarBomba a lot of people were saying they don’t want to play as Arthur because he looks like a prick

[@williamledbetter8409]

Now he’s one of the best game protagonist ever

[@ravenking1334]

@@pimpstickmafia3997 not because of that wasn't it because people wanted to play as John?

[@ajaniqmolina5285]

i just finished this part a couple days ago.. i’m not ashamed to say i cried so hard multiple times that i thought i was having an existential crisis and i had an underlying release when the floodgates opened. i still can’t tell and i still cry just as hard every time i see it. no control just waterworks and puffy eyes runny nose a headache and a damn good night of sleep. i don’t praise much but this was the best game i’d ever played with nothing else being close but am genuinely nervous that it truly struck a nerve.

[@Harrypotter-7]

Never had a favorite video game character until I played this game for the first time couple months ago. It’s amazing how you can come to love/care/idolize a character like this from a video game.

[@Ashgza]

I love every single one of you thank you fellas

[@mrlumbaki4564]

You love me too right?

[@Ashgza]

@@mrlumbaki4564 hi uncle yes

[@adityat.5366]

Love you too sir

[@motionmadness2735]

Do you love me 🥺

[@Ashgza]

@@motionmadness2735 yes fella

[@falseinnocence7937]

Stand Unshaken is a masterpiece within it’s own right; adding so much emotion to an already tragic moment. With that being said, I sometimes wonder if Mountain Hymn would’ve been a better song for this moment. Regardless it’s really something rare in games where you find yourself reflecting on your own person and wondering whether you’ll ever mean as much to someone as the character to a video game means to you. Whether or not you’ll be remembered long after your death by others or just fade away into obscurity, which I believe to be a worse fate than death itself.

[@hollownxt1295]

False Innocence Cringe

[@onepolishman8734]

HollowNxt damn sorry cool kid. You are so cool but fr stfu

[@ricardobeninca8356]

HollowNxt You are cringing me to death coff* coff*

[@ritchie336]

False Innocence so true my dude

[@Kinobambino]

@@hollownxt1295 it was a cringey ass comment ngl

[@IProbablyNeedHelp]

This has to be one of the most beautiful in game experiences I’ve ever had it made me cry a lot it’s amazing that this is a game they did a wonderful job :)

[@Santanamo.]

No matter how many times i see it, it still hurts like the first time, have a good existence in heaven Arthur, you will always be the best damn cowboy i have ever seen

[@gatorkid3653]

Hosea: how do you wanna go out Arthur? Arthur: I wanna watch sunset on the west. Man I didn’t even know that he would’ve predicted the way he went down. Depending on your honor of course. (Quote might be wrong but it was something super close)

[@coolbroccolie6455]

In a way, Hosea died so that Arthur would have the death he deserved. If Hosea didn’t die because of Dutch greed and Micha’s treason, Arthur would maybe never have understand that his way’s were wrong.

[@herredward9277]

He watched sunrise on the east. Turned his back on the wild west, and embraced civilisation.

[@kingtavish]

Herr Edward goddamit you made me tear up with that

[@JHAM29]

sunrise*

[@ethanabramov6345]

Hosea also said he wanted to be buried with friends and Lenny agreed. He is buried north of saint denis right next to lenny. And the quote you are referring to is from the same conversation. But arthur was talking about where he would want to be buried, not how he would want to die. His grave is faced west. just like he wanted, so he can see the sunset and remember all the good times he had

[@Horvie01]

The greatest ending to a character ive ever seen

[@francesco8320]

The greatest character

[@francesco8320]

Arthur and joel

[@vinizin8291]

@@francesco8320 Maybe he's a good character, but just dont say his death was as good as Arthur's. Not even close.

[@xJuliettex]

Oh, Arthur. He is so loved and so missed...

[@oykel4089]

As a trivia, The Deer in The Good Ending symbolizes what you had to do to get it very well, It symbolizes Sensitivity and Gentleness as what Arthur did in the good ending as in having the feeling that the debtors are in need more than him. While The Coyote inspires Pragmatism, no matter how cruel it is, you gotta pay what you owed, and what you find you keep, no matter if it was important to the person who originally had it

[@alex.sc.6670]

I cried so hard when my horse had canonically died as it was Buell, hamish’s horse he had given us as his dying wish. And Arthur’s death just sent me into a tearful spiral, I was bawling my eyes out.

[@indomemeusrex2292]

Even just watching this video, I tear up seeing Arthur die. And even back when I was playing through the story, I knew that his death was coming and how it would happen and, even still, I literally cried as he laid there...

[@Elias-sk6md]

A message to naughty dog : this is how you make a memorable character's death

[@oliverclytus7559]

Say it again but louder I don’t think Neil heard you

[@Portoman1923]

Oliver Clytus yeah he’s too high in his fucking ego to listen to people with valid arguments

[@loganator5565]

Ok dude lmao, RDR2 and TLOU2 are both amazing games

[@comradecat3629]

While i wish Joel had the same type of send off, the same time I find Joel’s death scene to work. It’s unceremonious because it is a harsh world with death looming around every corner. Same went for triss (even if she made more of a sacrifice than Joel, protecting him and Ellie instead of him trying to protect these people only to get backstabbed) she got bit, she got shot, dead. No blaze of glory we can see, just alive one second and dead the next. And I find it worked for me, showing how one mistake that he made out of the kindness of his heart lead to his death. I kinda wish that theme of death looming around every corner was more constant throughout the game tho because it showed us what kind of world we were in in the first hour, and the next time it happens is like 12 hours in with Joel’s killer no less. Her friend gets shot in the head unceremoniously and is left there while Abby just tries to survive. But that’s just my opinion about a game I enjoyed (until the rattler part, then it just felt like filler to get the game over the 20 hour mark)

[@loganator5565]

Dawson S, honestly, while I do wish that Joel could have had a better death, I think his death worked the best. It was harsh, unexpected, and set the tone of death and hurting for the rest of the game. You have to think about it like Abby; her Dad, the last person in her life (kind of like Ellie) is just shot and killed for seemingly no reason to her. That anger builds inside of her through her gaining all of that muscle. Her pain is shown through that, and by the end, she is ridiculously buff, BECAUSE it represents her anger, and need for revenge growing. Ellie’s need for revenge grows through her weight loss. After Abby gets away, Ellie is very gaunt, you can tell. This just another parallel between these two characters. And, finally, the last parallel, at the very end of the game, after Abby has spent all this time with (I forget the kids name, I hate blanking on names lol) Ellie threatens to kill him, after ALL of this, and after Abby says that she has moved on. This is just the cycle the game was telling you abt. The cycle of hatred and death. The cycle that started with Joel killing Abby’s dad for Ellie, Abby killing Joel for revenge, Ellie killing all of Abby’s friends and now threatening HER only person left. I kinda went on a tangent, but when you think about the story, and the characters like that, the game is just the masterpiece it was meant to be. P.S. the reason the Rattlers may feel like filler is because the story was supposed to end with Ellie getting her life with Dina and JJ. But, her lust for revenge sends her away again, making what should have been an end to the story for everyone, just another chapter.

[@sxthe4451]

Dude I’m not gonna lie this was the only game that made me cry....

[@therandom20000]

Yeh

[@colinjoudrey5953]

Mafia 2 when joe gets killed.. also rockstar lol

[@kukuhindustanigamer3663]

@@colinjoudrey5953 mafia isn't rockstar and Joe was never confirmed to be killed

[@tommycoolcat8215]

little Johnny Marston did not make you cry?

[@SgtNoPants]

The last of us 1

[@shubhendubhaskar6187]

I still remember the feeling of hope I got when they left and Arthur started crawling thinking he survived, but then the music hit and I knew, it was over. It took me 2 days to get over this, oh I miss him soo much.

[@edvardwinsagain3562]

Watching reaction videos of the ending still makes me cry after I finished the game.