What is the Best Caliber for your SBR?

In today's video we test SBR's in a serious of strenous tests to find the best caliber for your short barrel rifle.
bit.ly/garandthumb Bulletproof Everyone hoodie!
Patreon Signup - / garandthumb
Onward Research onwardresearch.com/
SDI School: sdischool.co/Garand
Xidax Computers: tribelink.co/Xidax
Insta: / garand_thumb
GarandThumb on Facebook: / garandthumb1

[@onepathofreason1]

This is really awesome that you are using a new block for each round. Thank you for incurring the expense to bring us this much education and entertainment (edutainment).

[@GarandThumb]

we do our best!

[@michaelstanton8363]

@@GarandThumb use 125 grain for the rattler at range

[@richardmueller7023]

Thanks GT and crew! You guys really do make my Sunday mornings, to the point where I look forward to your videos. Stay awesome guys!

[@frozennorth6527]

@@michaelstanton8363 110-125gr can do 500 pretty decent. Most people get it for for subsonic capability though, a lot of people sleep on the supers though. 10.5 seems to be absolute witchcraft for mine.

[@matthewmason831]

Yeah that was amazing, it’s so much easier on the viewers so see the performance. Must be very expensive.

[@MigratoryWhimbrel]

For those of us trying to keep track of which guns are being used: Mark 18 -- 10.3 inch barrel, 5.56 mm Quickhatch -- 8.1 inch barrel, 5.45 mm SIG Rattler -- 5.5 inch barrel, 300 blk Arsenal _SAM7K_ -SLR- -- 8.3 inch barrel, 7.62 mm FAL OSW -- 11 inch barrel, .308

[@nicholascecil6733]

About 10 minutes in, he said something about the O2 self igniting in the wound channel? Can someone please explain or help me understand?

[@guillainbarre1]

search for diesel effect @@nicholascecil6733

[@Sophisticlesenergy]

​@nicholascecil6733 so when a round enters a body cavity at extremely high speeds it forces the flesh to expand due to gasses spiraling the round and Hydro-Kinetic displacement. That's a principle of energy transfer involving fluid. When the temporary wound cavity is created the fluid then rushes in to close the vacuum created. Compression of oxygen within a vacuum causes ignition.

[@BadHaddy]

@@nicholascecil6733 He's probably referring to one of the many theories about the light emissions of ballistic gel when impacted by a projectile. It is GENERALLY believed to be a Sonoluminescence event, others believe is is some sort of dieseling of a fuel source in the gel itself. It's been generally studied, and is easily observed, but not rigorously investigated and published in a peer reviewed journal to the point of reaching consensus. It is not observed in organic ballistics gel (gelatin.)

[@Sophisticlesenergy]

My issue here is that i think they went very short on the 300 blk barrel, I would have liked to see at least a 9 inch barrel tested. Preferably a 10.5 but to my knowledge 5 is not the most common 300blk barrel length. Would just love to see 5.56 and 300 blk tested at the same 10.5 barrel length, bet the 300 blk stomps it.

[@joek5352]

Would really like to see the 300 black tested with supersonic ammo. Using subs in one caliber and supers in the rest is not an apples to apples comparison.

[@nostaw100]

I agree and he used a 5 inch barrel thats a nudered round at 5 inches its widely agreed 8 inch is the shortest you should go for 300 and most people like myself use 10 inch for 300 and 12 - 14 for 5.56 you get the optimal ballistics to length ratio from the calibers that way

[@joek5352]

@@nostaw100Totally agree. In theory, the can should add some additional velocity, but not enough to make up for the ridiculously short barrel length.

[@omegaalpha2974]

300 blackout & possibly 8.6 are it( assuming that you use supers for long range ).

[@smokingcrab2290]

Supersonic blk defeats the purpose of the round imo. The round was made for maximum signature reduction. Supersonic does not facilitate that purpose.

[@SlavaUkraini1114]

@@smokingcrab2290 it's an option, but what makes 300 blk so good is that it's multipurpose, you can use subs for quiet shooting, but you can also switch to supers with nothing more than a reload.

[@tomi6261]

Team 300 Black here. Being able to instantly switch from crazy quiet subs to very respectable supers, without having to change a thing on my gun, makes it the most versatile for me. Caveat - I hardly ever shoot past 300-350 yards.

[@DaveSmith-cp5kj]

Even if you shoot out to 800m you are good. Travis Haley a decade ago did a video of him shooting that far with an aimpoint which is wild. With a LPVO it is well within your capability no problem.

[@Captain_Coleslaw]

300blk is essentially a 308 round i think? So with the correct power behind it, its the same as a SBR 308?

[@cody180sx]

@Captain_Coleslaw 300 Blackout/7.62x35 is a .308 bullet in A .223 case, not as much powder behind means not as much ass behind it as a .308

[@tomi6261]

@@Captain_Coleslaw Excellent point, that I unfortunately can not confirm. I do not know the true ballistics of the 308 in an SBR. The barrel length would of course have everything to do with the results. I can tell you that out of my 6.75" barrel, my handloads are accurately running: 220gr Berrys subs at 1025 fps, calculated at 513 ft lbs at the muzzle. And my 125gr Speer supers are running 2000fps which results in 1110 ft lbs. And 110gr Hornadys at 2150 fps, which comes to 1129 ft lbs. You can compare these to whatever numbers you find from a 308 SBR. But, the physical size and weight difference of the weapon and ammo still makes the 300 BO a crazy good choice for me UNLESS you are shooting very long ranges.

[@tomi6261]

@@cody180sx You are probably correct in the category of supersonic full power loads. But if shooting subs, a 220gr 300 BO will outperform the 308 in any and every recipe simply because you can not safely load a 220gr bullet in a 308 case due to pressures. For supers, a short barrel (like 6"-8") will neuter the ever loving hell out of a full power 308 round so it may be closer than you think though. Plus, the recoil, report and blast of the 308 will be pure hell. "If you shoot this at night and you will die" Lol.

[@youtubesucks2369]

Ive never been more excited for Mike to show me the results of something so short !

[@xaxsimplexescapex]

they're actually perfectly average, more common than you think!

[@bQQm132]

5.5" is pretty big actually. Even perfect. Yeah, Perfect.

[@johndavid5862]

Ummmmmmmm......... you ARE still speaking about rifles..........., right?!? 😐

[@TalkingFlannel]

It’s pretty average, I think.

[@davolbc]

Remember you're supposed to measure a barrel from the bottom LOL.

[@matthewmason831]

Damn, .300 blackout should’ve had supersonic options tested too. Great video!

[@GarandThumb]

next time for sure!

[@CiviTac]

300blk is really designed for subs. It makes more sense to run a mk18 then 300blk imo when we are talking full power rounds

[@WayStedYou]

​@CiviTac dunno. Some of the results with a higher speed 300 blk would probably outpace the 5.56 with such a short barrel due to powder burn and you push the energy way up vs the 200 grain subs

[@CiviTac]

@@WayStedYou with the weight differences and the lethality of both being comparable at full power id take 556 every time for a “combat loadout” with an sbr. No hate against the 300blk but I’ve never met someone who buys that caliber for their main squeeze. It’s always a niche gun like for gooning and home defense.

[@prelude2tube]

​@@CiviTacif you're looking for big damage out of a short barrel, 300blk supers (especially in a soft-target / hunting round) are not to be underestimated. AAC's Sabre black tips are devastating from a short barrel, and (like for like, surpressed or not) are still meaningfully quieter than the mk18.

[@tiredoldman]

.300 Blackout is probably one of the most effective round for an SBR. It was designed for that purpose. I’ve used various SBR’s during my time in the Corps and even own a few. The SBR is meant for close quarters and short ranges. I really appreciate the video though. It’s especially helpful for those who are new or have little experience with SBR’s. I watch your videos often, this is just one of the rare occasions I have something I think is useful to add.

[@robertkaschner1655]

I've tried the 300 blackout and I'm just not sold on it being a great performer. .45 hollow points and 12 gauge buck are pretty hard to beat. That said, 300 blackout is always on the shelves and can share parts and cans so maybe it is worth building one again.

[@mannamedbanjo]

The advantage is you can get supers, subs of so many different grain weights. It's a jack of all trades ammo.

[@carsonhunt4642]

Lol. You mean it’s the most effective for subsonic? It quite literally has the same impact ballistics as using a .45 pistol. We all know pistols don’t drop ppl the same way rifles do.

[@officecomputer8887]

lmfaoooo you talk about your time in the corps but not about your time on red it?

[@tommygunn3260]

Video suggestion: if there’s a SHTF situation and you can ONLY grab 1 rifle & 1 pistol, what are they? And what’s your kit? I think lots of us wanna know!

[@Zamotak]

A solid Gas Piston AR15 in 5.56 and a Glock 19. Ammo would be extremely common and replacement parts for both would be rather common as well.

[@Tranitus3]

Want this video

[@n0xxm3rcyxx]

its about that time.

[@m0rbidhusky]

I’d run an AR-15 and a glock 26. Very common guns & ammunition, and the 26 can take a greater variety of magazines than something like a glock 17/19.

[@MrLandslide84]

Something 5.56 (AR) and something 9mm for availability. Once you run out, you don't wanna have .224 valk/6mmARC or something else weird and have no gun if you are able to link up with someone.

[@Rooobviously]

Every time that I go to order gun parts I hear Michah saying “primary arms” in my head so that’s where I order things from now.

[@frosty3693]

I have two PA 1x6 FFP ACSS scopes for 7.62x39, quite versatile depending on what ranges you shoot. Thinking about their prizm site for my next build.

[@theKashConnoisseur]

Doesn't hurt that they're a solid company that stands behind their products, either.

[@DevDog67]

​@@frosty3693their micro prisms are way better than they have any right up be for $300. It's kind of insane. Plus the motion on/off is pretty sick.

[@Dylan.More-Veiny]

I’m gonna stay clear of PA from now on tho. Have a slx 1-6 lpvo that won’t zero. Won’t even hit on the paper

[@fmlymn1]

I have 6 of their products and am happy with them for the price point

[@lukeletkeman8835]

The accuracy issue on the AK wasn’t the ammo, it was the MRO😂

[@Citybreakdancerman10]

My thoughts exactly. I have that exact rifle with an MRO and it was my problem haha

[@GarandThumb]

lol damn. Just my luck. Although not my fav its been solid for 6ish years

[@K-bob_45]

You know AK’s are notorious for have bore to bullet size mismatch due to being made all over creation by every country ever right?

[@morphius747]

Had some guy tell me that too, .311 bore in Russian/Euro Ak's but we shoot .308 bullets from our Tula or Winchester (American)ammo @@K-bob_45

[@investigativeoutcomes9343]

not in America. lol@@K-bob_45

[@marshmellowboy323]

The informational and gear videos will always be my favorite, thank you for the knowledge Mr. Thumb

[@MrBossuporbowout]

This was one of the most subtly funny yet informative videos I've seen. Great job guys

[@TheTopGun920]

300 Blackout is my preferred round for SBR, but man 308 is such a beast.

[@timewave02012]

Supersonic, though. Subsonic is neat if you need to be extra sneaky, but for most applications, especially self defense, supers win.

[@user-yt5uw4kh5u]

@@timewave02012 agreed

[@EarthAltar]

Check out the IWI Tavor bullpup in .308. 16.5" barrel with an overall length of about 29". There you'll get almost full velocity out of the round in a similar sized package as an SBR. Around two grand.

[@echofoxtrotwhiskey1595]

@@timewave02012Depends on context. Supersonics are awesome no doubt, but sometimes you don’t want everyone in a 2-3 block radius knowing you just discharged a firearm.

[@Infidel5723]

I have a 10.3 in 308 🙃

[@Pienimusta]

If you have been struggling in your life with a short barrel, hit that subscribe button.

[@Token_Black_Guy]

Just get nore pumps in big bro

[@ALovelyBunchOfDragonballz]

If you ever feel bad about your short barrel, just remember that in some cultures shorter barrels indicate superiority 😆

[@RussXnimbusX]

I may have a pencil barrel, but I can write War and Peace with it.

[@dynasty2295]

What if your barrel changes depending on how hot your rounds are? 🤔

[@varuug]

@@dynasty2295 It's modular.

[@nicholasdangelo8174]

Wow, this is an amazing vid sir. Absolutely stunning the results with the 545. 556 also very stout on the gel. 300blkout punching through the block was awesome and 308 did work on the block! Awesome content this was great thank you!

[@jakesalerno1932]

Awesome video! Would have been interesting to see how a SBS 12 gauge would have compared the the various rifles.

[@Rolf97]

Everyone always asks, "Where is Charlie?", and not "How is Charlie?"

[@CatTechSupport]

300 and 8.6 Blackout are the quietest options you have.

[@GarandThumb]

big facts

[@ItsBiscoitoIndeed]

​@@GarandThumbscience has occured

[@brandonrupp5880]

I haven't heard that.

[@nomad5454]

True but from a practical point I'd only run 8.6 as a. Bolt setup trying too stock 1000+ rounds at that price for ar is crazy

[@xxxlonewolf49]

Bayonet is the quietest caliber

[@gagedellin6634]

Great video Garand, love the focus on combat performance and aspects instead of straight up ballistics and accuracy. Would love to hear opinion on the 6mm ARC, especially in a 14.5 inch barrel or shorter. There are videos of people shooting a 14.5 inch 6mm arc over a 1,000 yds, just not with a combat focus. I wanna know what someone with a military background thinks of the round and its capabilities. Keep up the great work man. God Bless!!

[@jamesdyson7126]

Excellent Dad Advice ! Thanks Mike and Micah ! Great video !

[@THEchefdoggy]

"You poor fuckers" - The most relatable comment GT has ever made. Thank you for always being a man of the people, by the people, and for the people.

[@mitchellstiles3260]

“But I know you poor fuckers are probably firing the cheap ammo.” He knows his followers😂

[@jacobkean03]

The 5.56 never ceases to surprise me with its combat effectiveness but now that I got myself an ol lady and two daughters I’ve swapped to the .300 blackout for home defense considering the most common threats I have are the desperate tweakers and coyotes going after the livestock. The concrete test kind of changes my thoughts on the penetrating power of the 5.56 compared to the .300 blackout.

[@jeb6361]

Where do you have steel in your house?@@michaelpratt3142

[@neglectfulsausage7689]

shielding on spacecraft is meant to stop 10 km/s bullets of meteorites. Mass still matters. @@michaelpratt3142

[@jonah8133]

@@michaelpratt3142 Yeahp, I've seen tests where certain barriers are hardly dented by 300 blackout whereas 556 had some serious penetration

[@dababcock9]

With home defense as the primary intent, being able to shoot through barriers and still have good performance is not always considered a good thing. Usually, with home defense, the object is to have something that's effective enough to quickly incapacitate the attacker(s), while not having a tendency to over-penetrate, so as to hopefully not be a threat to the neighbors. You also need to positively identify the bad guy before you pull the trigger. Generally, legally speaking, the last thing that you need to be worried about is shooting through walls to get the bad guy(s). That's gotten a good number of people in serious trouble when what they thought was the bad guy... wasn't. I know that 5.56 (depending on barrel length and bullet selection) often tends to start to upset when it hits the first layer of drywall. It's still effective at getting the "bad guy", but an errant shot is less likely to go through multiple walls, unlike the 9mm (which is one of the major reasons why most SWAT teams have switched from the MP5 to the AR platform in 5.56). So far, I haven't seen similar tests on how different .300 blackout bullets perform in that kind of environment.... but I'm very interested in seeing any such tests.

[@jeb6361]

@@jonah8133 Where do you have steel in your house? Why are you interested in penetrating steel?

[@robertbernard651]

This is a question I've been trying to get an answer for 15 years, excellent clip. Thanks 😊

[@granttetterton4491]

We need more of the becoming deadly series!!

[@wasdawasda3849]

Would have loved to see .300 supersonics as well since that's the thing about being able to switch with a magazine change

[@GarandThumb]

yessir next video for sure

[@eljefeamericano4308]

Great video. It's a shame the 7.62x39 rifle was being so fussy. I'm partial to that caliber in shorter barrel lengths.

[@PNWhashmits]

X39 from a 10.5" FTW

[@twelvepercentitalian2511]

I wouldn’t be worried about it.

[@Min4Mass]

Its the 300 blackout we have at home.

[@AlreadyDeadInside83079]

Great video! I've been wanting to see an SBR comparison and effectiveness video for awhile. 🍺 🍺

[@BradMillsOK]

That gel impact with 308…. Wow lots of energy

[@alexwalker2582]

3-0-Hate is a standard for a reason.

[@francisdotso8594]

Love the content, but would love to see more of the becoming deadly series come back

[@GarandThumb]

We are working on it

[@theKashConnoisseur]

@@GarandThumb I know it doesn't get as many views as some other content, but the information is invaluable, and that makes it evergreen content in a big way. Thanks for everything you and your team do for gun culture.

[@PoliticallyInsensitive]

​​@@theKashConnoisseurI read a bunch of comments like this last week and I'm still calling bullshit. Even the lowest view count was over a million iirc.

[@theKashConnoisseur]

@@PoliticallyInsensitive well, the commentary that the "becoming deadly" series didn't perform as well is based on GT's own comments he's made in podcast interviews. Views are great, but they don't always equate to financial success. And a million views might be a lot for one channel, but disappointing performance for another. It's not a dig on the content by any means, I find it highly valuable. But unfortunately being prepared is still a bit fringe even within the 2A space.

[@deand5602]

@@GarandThumb mega based, thank you mr. Thumb

[@cristianpatino2211]

Love ur channel man, please never stop and live forever, thank u

[@rgochina]

Amazing video! And in the end, all things resume to 5.56 and good old .308. Nothing more is really necessary.

[@cosmicbilly]

Garand thumb has been killing it with these uploads! This dude never fails. Keep it up bro, i love your channel so much.

[@user-ns6le3sm6j]

10.5 inch with 5.56 is accurate and comfortable, and designed for urban warfare 👍

[@JohnJones-op8uf]

Thanks for the vids. Mike!

[@grizzlyadamsmtb3012]

I built a .300 blackout with a 10.5 inch barrel shooting 220 subsonic. So much fun I love it. Can’t wait to get a suppressor for it.

[@GUNNER67akaKelt]

Yeah, .300 BO would be my thought. The cartridge was designed for short barrels. Not sure why the comparison was with subsonics and not hypersonics. If you want to compare subsonics, they should all be subsonics. Hey, the .300 doesn't do as good as the rest. Wow, who saw that coming, right? Next comparison: why they the 9mm doesn't measure up to the .308.

[@XxxSIGMA_SUPERIORxxX]

300 BO deserves to be suppressed.

[@nickadkins7765]

Definitely would have liked to see a 110gr barnes tac tx round out of an 8 inch +/- barrel on the 300 black out for comparison! I'm sure the ballistics, effective range, and certainly the weight would have changed significantly.

[@Rotakor]

I agree with this 100%. I would also of liked the 10.5 inch barrel.

[@bona-fide-mtm]

Agreed

[@sfdclay]

Agreed, 300BLK is a true dual purpose caliber, having similar performance to 762x39 when using supers, yet being the only option for subs

[@goawaybaizuo]

Definitely agree with the 8" barrel. I think thats way more common than a 5.5.

[@leftyeh6495]

10" barrel is supposed to be the best velocity wise as powder should be burned by 9-10" for sub loads. If you're shooting supers you may as well have a 16-18" barrel and get the velocity.

[@Nono-rh4lr]

Great rundown. I would have loved to see what the SuperSonics would do out of the rattler. I know subs are popular for quiet but the 300 black runs well with suppers

[@mattjay6633]

Same! My home defense rifle is a 9” .300 with a surefire 300sps. Yeah subs are fun for range plinking, and some of the aggressive HP/expanding rounds would be great for “sentry work” or just staying quiet….. but primarily I would be using 110gr supers. Suppressor still makes it relatively comfortable to the ear, but you also get the benefits of a rifle round in regards to ballistics and capable distance….

[@TheDkb427]

@@mattjay6633 not that I've done it but you could possibly download a 110gr vmax or even the Barnes tac-tx to still expand but really quite. Think that would be around 1800fps or something. Would limit further out but still better than subs to me anyways. Hell anything over 125 just pokes 30 cal holes.

[@leftyeh6495]

If I want to go loud I'll just pick up a 5.56 with v-maxes. The blackout does subs quietly. I bought a can to be quiet. Supers are very not quiet through a can indoors. 😂 It can be a versatile round. It's just that many have tried to make it do a bunch of things it just doesn't do well. It really does quiet subs well, so let it be great there and quit compromising.

[@rickfinsta2951]

@@leftyeh6495 I disagree. 300blk out of an 8.1" barrel is nearly identical in external ballistics to a 7.62x39 in the AKM platform. Or you can think of it as a light 30-30 loading from a much shorter barrel. You get lower concussion when not suppressed, and suppressed with subs is quieter than a similar barrel length in 5.56x45. Also more barrier blind, etc. I never use subs in my 300 stuff it is a waste of good bullets LOL. 300blk is just about perfect for domestic (CONUS) law enforcement or self defense use. That said I'm not going to turn down a 11.5" 5.56 if it is handed to me, either.

[@chopinbloc]

​@@TheDkb427sorry, the 110gr VMAX stops expanding well above the speed of sound.

[@pops55650]

I love the .300 Blackout but it’s nice to see how it stacks up and what to expect, and not overhype its capabilities. All this raw data is pretty amazing,

[@somethingposerish5807]

This isn't a fair comparison. Should have used 150gr supers. Would have done way better in all tests Edit: also 8.5 or 9 inch barrel, not 5.5. They literally used the gimpest 300blk possible

[@michaelchristian8084]

@@somethingposerish5807I agree on the caliber grain. He said they were going with 55gr cause it’s the cheapest and most used and then goes with 220gr for 300blk which is not cheapest and most used. The 150 would have performed much better at the distance shooting and gel.

[@gVert404]

@@somethingposerish5807tbf the main purpose of 300blk is to be subsonic for suppression

[@painmt651]

I would rather have a 7.62x39, and just reload rounds for specific performance that is not obtainable from cheap factory ammunition. 300blk is too expensive.

[@twelvepercentitalian2511]

5.5 inch barrel for 300 blackbout is too short. 9.5 inch-10.5 is the sweet spot.

[@bmyvettjr]

keep up the good work GRAND!!!

[@161monkey]

Welcome back Micah! So happy for you and your growing family!

[@alwarberigai5955]

I like how Mike casually threatened to fire Micah as a joke.. could have been real if he wanted it to…😮

[@161monkey]

Haha, I think Mikes loyal. Also, totally on brand for these two. #Bussin

[@Sassquootchen]

Gotta love that GT videos are always ready to go right when church is done.

[@TheDankCat127]

Amen 🙏

[@ed1968man]

I just picked up the Primary Arms SLx 1X Gemini for my PCC. VERY HAPPY!!!

[@johnmorganjr769]

Thank you GT !!! Much needed !! 🇺🇸 💥

[@alexc414]

I will admit, when it said "AD in 3, 2, 1" I was waiting for an accidental discharge...

[@GarandThumb]

LMAOOO

[@B0SS5]

12 inch 6.5 grendel is the best in my opinion you get that great accuracy at distance and crazy good knockdown power in a small ar-15 package

[@GravelGuerrilla]

6.5G is good because of the wolf ammo being cheap. But, these rounds really excel with higher quality ammo and long barrels. I feel like it's a 5 cylinder engine, in a world with 6 cylinders and 4 cylinders and turbos and superchargers available. The advantages are there but, so damn subtle that you might as well reach the peak performance. And if you're there, just buy a 6 ARC or a 6 creedmore. You'll beat the 6.5G guy every time.

[@rhandley1000]

I highly recommend the FAL OSW. Awesome rifle

[@CarnivoreDog]

These are the types of comparisons I enjoy the most.

[@josiahb55]

Nice. Would love to see some old school optics reviews back. Like the primary arms PLxC 1-8 yall have been talking about.

[@sfdclay]

He said in a prior video he won’t be reviewing any primary arms optics because they are channel sponsors

[@jameslyddall]

Absolutely cracking video from you guys, have never fired anything more then a .22 round being from UK I would love to do some outdoor shooting/fitness sessions at some point in the states. Looking at booking some time off next year to see what courses are available.

[@bass779]

Hope you can make it!

[@FL-Kman]

Hell yeah bruv! Come across the pond!

[@musicman1eanda]

If you're a gun loving UK subject, please feel free to come over here to the US to become a citizen and switch places with one of our communist anti gun leftists 😊

[@charleseatherton7396]

You should move and stay here in the USA.

[@jameslyddall]

@@charleseatherton7396 I would love to, work in central London live in a nice place but commute an hour plus. Dealing with international clients all day, to be honest I’d love to get a place in Arizona. Love that part of the country. Being from the UK I’d find the place Mike shoots from to cold I’d chose somewhere warm like AZ.

[@alexanderhaile6196]

Loving the SBR test data. Some video ideas... I'd like to see a video testing different kinds of 5.56x45mm (M193, M855, Mk262) through various short barrels, both against ballistic gel and common barriers (cinderblocks, wood, etc.) for CQB purposes. Then a test of M855 through different barrel lengths against Lv3 armor. Obviously M855 should defeat Lv3 armor, but through the shorter barrels the velocity would be decreased. I'm wondering how short the barrel can be before your use of M855 becomes irrelevant against Lv3 armor.

[@AldoSchmedack]

Me too on vest!

[@F3d3xdad]

Keep up the great work!

[@user-yc8tj6iy1j]

308. Is the Lord's caliber. Love the vids man.

[@txhookey5608]

Winter usually means bumping up calibers, especially with shorter barrels. Would be interesting to see the same ballistic gel performance through several layers of cold weather gear.

[@walthermodel01]

Great fukcin idea

[@hunterfishman7119]

MEME: WHEN THE PEOPLE IN THE COMMENT SECTION ARE SMARTER THAN THE GUN TUBER THAT IS ONLY INTERESTED IN LIKES, VIEWS & SUBS!!! NICELY DONE GOOD SIR! IF ONLY WE HAD FULL ACCESS TO THE EQUIPMENT HE HAS, WE WOULD PUT THESE IGNANT FOOLS TO SHAME WITH OUR ACTUALLY ACCURATE INFO & TESTING!

[@teampyle9835]

With rifle cartridges the clothing makes almost no difference. There's lots of videos that show ballistics gel with clothing and there isn't any noticeable loss in performance.

[@PD-we8vf]

That channel is tan by Paul Harrell.

[@teampyle9835]

@@PD-we8vf yes thank you

[@mitchculpepper738]

Being a 6.5 Grendel fan, I’m curious what it would do out of 11.5” barrel. With muzzle velocities of 2300+ fps with 120 gr. bullet and 2500+ fps with 90 gr. Varmint nightmare, it seems this would excel in your test.

[@CatMask556]

Awesome video, man. Any idea when the next Becoming Deadly in the Mountains video is coming out?

[@Teh_R4v3n]

Wish there was 6.8 spc II, I always heard it was amazing in all lengths

[@sfdclay]

Yeah too bad that round dropped off and failed adoption

[@rustyshackelford3781]

Love the comparisons and the different tests. I do tend to run cheaper ammo for training except for my Mk18, I only run issued amo which for training is the Hornady sbr 75gr bthp, or hornady 75gr tap.

[@eindride1268]

I really hope Garand Thumb comes around to reviewing the best Ar15 in the S-tier category. Between Noveske, Lmt, Larue, Radian, DD, Kac, HK, and a couple others, it's so hard to get solid unbiased answers as to which company offers the best, and which offer superficial prices for what you get out of them. I'd love to see a test between all 16 inch 5.56 models, and possibly test the popular variants that don't fit that (like the Mk18) just to see which offers the most. Obviously they're all proficient enough, but it'd be cool to find the king of op-tier Ar's

[@joek5352]

16”!? Most people buying Gucci grade rifles are likely mounting a can and don’t want to end up with a 20” + platform.

[@eindride1268]

@joek5352 Well genius, it's a good thing the test is to compare between companies to see who makes the best rifles, and not a test to see what everyone is wanting specifically. I don't give a fuck what people are using it for, the point of comparitive tests is to compare positives and negatives, and if you don't use the same dependent factors (barrel length) to test with, you're gonna get inconsistent results. I did mention to add popular variants that don't fit that bill, but that's because they're highly regarded

[@zombieslayer7759]

Of all the highest tier AR-15's, the rifles from Blackout Defense are probably the best of them all to be honest and they aren't even the most expensive of the highest tier rifles (they're a little over 2 grand).

[@eindride1268]

@zombieslayer7759 First time I've heard of them compared with S tier rifles, so ima doubt that

[@joek5352]

@@eindride1268 Everyone watch out. This guy knows everything. And will sarcastically call you a genius if he doesn’t agree with you.

[@262fire3]

Thank you I fit well with my musket.

[@luckyomen]

6.5 Grendel is surprisingly great out of 12 inches.

[@weinerdog137]

Not surprised

[@jessesimmons4503]

6.5mm Grendel is what i would choose. especially in a Draco.

[@luckyomen]

It's limit in a short barrel is very much 12inches. anything shorter is too slow for the properties of the bullet design to be effective. otherwise, it performs really well out to 350 yds@@jessesimmons4503

[@adamg574]

6.5 grendel is heavily slept on. Love that round.

[@evans9748]

Idk, still using the 300blk subs during the 300 yard shots kinda defeats the whole point of 300blk, it would have been more realistic to have switched mags to supers, which is exactly how it was designed to be used.

[@GarandThumb]

this is fair - hindsight is def 20/20 after we make videos

[@jayjohnson3732]

I would add that using a 10” blackout would have been better. With that Barrel length the supers are as fast as 7.62x39, carry much more energy than 5.56 at 300 meters, and would be even quieter with subsonic ammo than the Rattler. Don’t get me wrong, I LOVE the Rattler, but it’s not the most versatile blackout platform.

[@GarandThumb]

we went off of heavily used mil rifles

[@evans9748]

@@GarandThumb exactly. no one is running around with a 10” barrel, plus the Rattler still uses the 1/5 twist you won’t get on a 10” anyways.

[@frosty3693]

I am guessing the rifle is setup for subsonic and going to supers would require a gas ssytem and sight zero change. Would have liked to seen it too.

[@ruger1405]

love that osw fal

[@lemon8513]

Thank you sir for bring the FAL to the test and to mention South America, we do love your content!

[@lemon8513]

🇧🇷

[@curtrobinsongarage5452]

Keep up the great content. Your one of my favorite channels. Thanks for the pewtainment.

[@GarandThumb]

I appreciate that!

[@carterlarson5130]

The Billll drill is so essential in learning to control your firearm.

[@davidreem7716]

Great dad advice on many levels

[@lukel4783]

I love this channel so much.

[@Mandalore6311]

Loved the video. Fully admitting I am a .300 BLK fanboy, I feel the cartridge may have been done a disservice. In addition to being optimized for "short" barrels, one of the primary selling points is the wide range of bullet selection compared to other cartridges. Seeing the performance of supers in this video would have been nice. You maintain the advantages mentioned like excellent suppression at the muzzle, as well as low flash signature. That being said, it was a nice surprise seeing how it performed against the cinder block.

[@leftyeh6495]

You may as well have a 308 for anything but subs. The 300 is great for factory ammo selection in subs and supers. 308 is worth the jump to ar-10 if you're just shooting supers though. Suppressors and flash hiders are for noise or flash suppression. A bare barrel you're not going to know the difference.

[@somethingposerish5807]

​@leftyeh6495 nah, 300 is dope, 13grs of powder vs 45+, not to mention most of that 45+ is wasted. Also ease of brass collecting. I get so much 300blk brass from all the 556 guys who don't reload 😂 Edit: saw you mention jump to AR 10, to clarify, that defeats the purpose of cqb

[@Mandalore6311]

@@leftyeh6495 thanks for explaining suppressors and flash hiders to me? 300 BLK should be run suppressed, nobody mentioned bare muzzles.

[@Mandalore6311]

@@somethingposerish5807 not to mention the exact points from the video, .308 guns are heavier and the ammo is heavier.

[@bower31]

@@leftyeh6495 Yeah definitely not the weight and size of 308 is not always a worth while trade off. 300 supers preform really quite good, and you can carry a lot more of them.

[@josholdham1033]

Cool video, but I would love to see a comparison video like this just for 300 BO. Different barrel lengths, subs and supers etc.

[@95dodgev10]

A couple vidoes ago he did compare sub vs supersonic through a suppressor and the travel time of the round at longer ranges. At long range when they filmed from basically over the shoulder you could actually see the subsonic flying through the air.

[@cpgeorge2518]

Definitely a great video

[@codywhitmire8850]

Great videos guys. Please do a video on the 350 legend

[@Robespierres_Ghost]

300 blackout then 762x39. They are much less sensitive to barrel loss compared to 556 and 545.

[@Mike_858]

Hardly matters when you are using 69 and 77 grain BTHP, those fragment and expand at velocities as low as 1800 fp/s making 10'' .223 AR's very useful.

[@user-qo3yy9nv1u]

Paying 3x for .300 over 7.62 sounds fun.

[@Ntmoffi]

I'll take cheap 30 cal over everything else.

[@johnmarkfeiger-no5ri]

Personally for short barrels I'd go with 7.62x39. It packs quite a lot of energy and is a more ubiquitous round than 300 blk

[@hexdontae]

@@Mike_858holy shit cope harder 🤣

[@rascalmatt6713]

Without watching the video yet... the "Old School" of thought was that a 12.5" Grendel upper was shooting super sonic out to 800-850 yards. Decent weighted round as well so that would probably be my best all around shorty set up. without putting a whole lot of thought into it or research for that matter.... or at least no recent research for about 2-3 years now.

[@WhistlinBullet]

Awesome video!!!

[@BigDub78]

Cant wait to see you review the 8.6 and maybe with Q's boombox it would go well with this video

[@atlanticancameos5131]

17:25 Pretty sure I ran with more than 7 rounds back in Afghan. Love the videos mate.

[@GarandThumb]

hahaa meant to say mags

[@atlanticancameos5131]

@@GarandThumb😂 All love man, keep up the good work

[@heatheruntz5315]

I recently had to sell my shorty 308 galil with an 11.8in barrel. I came upon hard times and it was the least practical of all my guns so it had to go. I still have my 16 308 galil ace though so that is another reason I picked it to sell. The furthest out I shot the shorty 308 was 400 yards. 556 is probably my favorite shorty round but 308 is the most effective imo

[@alexanderp8037]

Check "jaegar micro galil ace"

[@heatheruntz5315]

@@alexanderp8037 hell yeah dude that thing is sweet! When my financial situation is better I am going to get one of those or a mk18

[@TheGlp007]

Great stuff

[@evanwells6284]

Personally, I would pick supersonic 300 blk. Maybe a 110 or 125gr bullet. I think it wouldn't have any issues with lethality or short range drop, and it could probably get 90% of 16" barrel velocity out of the 5.5. but it would be loud.

[@shelbygto2]

You need to try 6.5 grendel vs 6mm arc. 6mm arc may perform better than all!

[@theIsoEnvoy]

Would like to see more of 6.5 Grendel , love that round

[@hossep2695]

Ever since Ian did a video on the HK 56, I've been wanting a Favella Fireball for my own collection.

[@SmallHandsBigBite]

Got to say that this was a really well sorted video. All it was missing was a meat target with a high-tech Fa-Leece bullet stop (Love ya, Paul). I grew up almost exclusively with AK's and practical AK kit and manual of arms my whole life until just 2 or so short years ago when I transitioned into, of all things, an FAL (L1A1). The Manual of arms felt very familiar to me with little adjustments needed. Personally, I love to see how you showcased the real world advantages of these 7.62x39/51 rounds. Though I also want to state that I never once felt burdened carrying my AK kit or my FAL kit. I'm curious what magazines you used to weigh out the AKM kit - Steel, Circle 10 Bulgarians, Magpul Gen 3's? I have tried, but wouldn't consciously trade those two rifles for anything else in the world. Doesn't mean I don't practice and get familiar with other systems though.

[@TheDkb427]

I'm the complete opposite lol I have not will not get a commie gun lol. Merica!! Seriously don't want another caliber to deal with.

[@AngelAcosta-cm1zi]

​@@TheDkb427you do know there's a lot of aks chambered in 556 they're pretty much the same as an AK in 5x45 but train with what you're comfortable with just wanted to let you know

[@hamhocks]

You should do this same video but with other popular calibers like 6.5 grendel, 6.8 SPC, and the 6 ARC.

[@Brayhz99]

Thank you ❤

[@Chefjbf]

The background music is such a vibe 😎⚡️

[@mhicaoidh1]

I'd suspect the optic mount on that 7.62x39. I've shot a lot of Russian x39 and never experienced shot deviation like that at 300 yards.

[@GarandThumb]

same - that was our thought as well. Super bizzare

[@mhicaoidh1]

@@GarandThumb Just remembered another thing ... there's an outside chance it's the booster on the muzzle too. Had one years ago throwing shots low left and low right. But, that was consistent and somewhat predictable. Took it off ... straight as an arrow.

[@gatormcklusky5850]

I'm waiting for Geissele's new addition to the field, their currently working on two new rifles in 6 mm ARC.

[@kalanipitmon7817]

Oouuu i like.

[@LRRPFco52]

KAC made a 6mm Grendel as well. Just wish they would do 6.5 Grendel.

[@dustinhamm6972]

It looks like they are using a new camera to me. Super smooth and instant focusing.

[@martinsprick2031]

Well done sir! Multiply and replenish the earth/

[@octaviusnorvelantis8934]

I’m going to die before the “Becoming Deadly” series is finished

[@ryanandbrookemontgomery5397]

Would be nice to add 300 blk supers in there as well

[@TrailBum]

Odd. My 220gr 300BLK hand-loads tumble so quickly, and they almost snap in two. I haven't shot into gel, but I shot into rotted timber dust. They might sometimes break in two, but usually bend at 30-90 degrees. I can only imagine the wound-cavity they would produce. Very fun video!

[@mrad69]

I can’t stop thinking about, Rome!

[@SwissTankGrunt]

Very nice video. I was expecting the 308 will bust the other SBR's, only downside as here showed the heavy weight. For me is the 308 Battlerifle the way to go, as it is also not such a big deal to carry 10 Mags, you just need to be fit and do a smart loadout. 😎

[@GarandThumb]

hahah being fit always helps

[@lolinskimk6]

Or carry like 20 mags of 5.56 and not run out of ammo

[@HeisenbergFam]

11:52 editor deserves a raise for that well made scene

[@joshuagibson2520]

You should go outside instead of watching YT 22 hours a day.

[@channel-rv4hz]

proud of you

[@casinferneycf45]

Is stuff is awesome. Love this kibd of learning.

[@mastadlo]

Let's get a 6.5 grendel video. Think it's an under-appreciated round.

[@byronc.9861]

Agreed. Ive taken a 12.5 out to 400 on 2moa plates. If youre not running subs, it's the ideal ar 15 caliber for sbrs (discounting the price per round).

[@alanw1775]

Agreed. 6.5 grendel would smoke any of those one way or another. "Start slow and end fast" as bill alexander said.

[@officecomputer8887]

6.5 grendel is obviously the best sbr caliber

[@officecomputer8887]

an sbr wont really benefit from the extra muzzle velocity but will benefit from the heavier round @@ryoannazuk949