[가요대제전] aespa - Illusion + Girls (에스파 - 도깨비불 + 걸스) FanCam | MBC Music Festival | MBC221231방송

[@윳-n9c]

난 어쩔 수 없는 스엠의 노예다 하... 너무 예쁘고 노래도 좋아서 기절할 것 같음. 연말 무대 찢은 짱스파ㅠㅠㅠ

[@min113o]

여기 한명더 추가요🥹

[@치킨아이스크림]

저도.ㅠ 이런 겁나 쎄고 파워풀한 무대 좋아요

[@Jake71531]

👏👏👏

[@에스파는신이야]

저도추가요😭

[@커비면토끼]

그리고 의상도 오늘 레전드 게임캐릭터st

[@shiningyzh]

karina's left shoe 😭 god this girl is so professional 💗

[@minhtrang9501]

4:55 omg 😅

[@shiningyoonie]

Which stylist gave her them cheap ass poor quality shoes??

[@가가기기-m8y]

잠시 안 보여서 잊고 있었는데 에스엠이 역시 미모는 탑이구나 오랜 만에 봐서 그런가 ㅋ

[@콩이-b9i]

역시 스엠이라 그런지 노래 실력은 4세대 원탑인듯... 음색이 좋다고 해야하나 기교가 좋다고 해야하나 목청만 크게 라이브 하는 게 아니라 좋음👍

[@marky080]

닝닝 진짜 사람 홀린다... 미친 존재감의 현신

[@하느리-l7w]

에스파가 4명 피지컬이나 비율이 똑같애서 ㄹㅇ 조화로운 느낌임.. 아까 무대 보다가 개예뻐서 입벌리고 감탄 하면서 본 거 살면서 처음 ㅠㅠ

[@yuro8874]

근데 실제론 키차이가 꽤남 카리나가 생각보다 더 크더라고요 굽으로 많이 맞추는듯

[@hihi-po2tb]

얼굴합도 진짜 좋은것 같아요 다들 AI컨셉 최적ㅋㅋㅋ

[@kim-mh8fd]

@@yuro8874 넷다 얼굴작고 비율좋은편임

[@애리-g8l]

@@yuro8874 카리나가 167~8에 제일 작은 닝닝이가 163~4라 그렇게 차이가 많이나는 편은 아니더라고용

[@Naeviss-mr6cv]

@@애리-g8l 162

[@almirah_]

Karina shoe sole😳 she remain professional despite of her problem with her shoe sole.

[@ASI1485]

The soles of Karina's shoes in left leg is half off(3.54) But she doesn't care it and dances well. How professional she is❤

[@zmalxnsk4fffirie]

레전드무대 갠적으로 에스파 무대중 제일 좋아요

[@pixierainbow7]

Karina's boots were falling apart and she kept her cool.

[@omuomu143]

karina danced so flawlessly that no one noticed her shoe sole fell off, including me. i wouldnt have noticed until someone pointed it out in the comments. she had my attention from the very start! keep killing it out there, karina, you're our main dancer

[@붸웨레레렐]

에스파 라이브 진짜 잘한다

[@PurpleMoon7100]

Is it just or is Karina's shoe sole detached and she did the whole performance like that...wah 🥲

[@anonymous37h]

aespa slayed they were singing live plus their stage presence plus they were synchronized now i never want to see anyone dragging them my girls litterally burned the stage😍

[@gleekpopdancecovers]

I can’t hear their voice, I can only see their mouth is doing lipsync in Korea,when they go to other they never have lipsync,when they go to other countries there mic is on and in Korea they doing lipsync

[@anonymous37h]

@@gleekpopdancecovers bro this one is in korea and it is live there performances before this on other shows were also live

[@gleekpopdancecovers]

Is not live,Is lipsync,I can see there mouth is doing lipsync

[@anonymous37h]

@@gleekpopdancecovers bro you are not being serious??are you?? everyone here in comments including me can see they are live singing even who attended this show also said they were live ..do you know more than who actually attended show

[@sergio_07829]

@@gleekpopdancecovers there's something called like a backtrack for ur information. To hear better live vocals, watch the original performance that the cameras filmed and listen itnwith headphones.

[@sayitstar]

Karina 😭 so professional, no one notice her shoes bruh!! Omg my girls!!! They so freakin goodd I’m so proud of them 👏🏻🥺😭🫶🏻

[@meisanastrophile]

Karina managed it very well. She is a very excellent performer! ❤❤❤

[@paunamidatta9000]

What happened to her shoes

[@gianghuong7906]

@@paunamidatta9000 Her shoes (soles) broke

[@pikachubread]

@@paunamidatta9000 the sole of her left boot started separating from the rest of the shoe at some point - you can see it at ~1:40, 1:55, 3:02, 3:31, 4:15, 4:46, 4:52, 5:02, etc. when she walks sideways or lifts her foot! hopefully she didn't get hurtsm should invest in quality shoes, though...

[@paunamidatta9000]

@@pikachubread wow she is so professional I didn't even notice it

[@aeD4RK]

Their STAGE PRESENCE improved so much,OMG!!! Imagine next Come Back ......They are like warrior princesses now. They don't perform,they SLAY. 💙🌙⭐🦋🔥

[@wingofwinter888]

they never have problems with stage presence its just some weirdo cant catch how to perform next level. because there is no songs like next level before in kpop realms. just because they dont get it, doesnt mean aespa under performed or has no stage presence.

[@aeD4RK]

@@wingofwinter888 agreed.

[@kayzebx8660]

@@wingofwinter888 LOUDER👏🏾🗣

[@paunamidatta9000]

@@wingofwinter888 right 👍

[@Leigh-uz9wz]

@@wingofwinter888 yes lol some fans just don't know the real meaning of stage presence and some are just riding the hate train 😂 that word is way too used they don't know what to insult them anymore

[@듀-v5r]

에스파 사랑해❤❤❤ 올해는 더 많이 활동하자

[@박세연-z6v]

오늘 라이브 한거같던데 잘하더라 스엠아 .... 라이브 좀 많이 시키자 오늘 라이브한거 반응도 좋던데 윈터는 진짜 성량큰듯 소리가 잘 들림

[@kim-mh8fd]

라이브 맞음

[@user-fj3qe6dc9d]

전체 라이브였는데 ㅋㅋㅋ 사녹갔다옴

[@kim-mh8fd]

다들 다 라이브 했음 사녹갔옴

[@hihi-po2tb]

올해 라이브는 gma, 일본쇼케,코첼라, 지미키멜등등 진짜많이했는데.. 공중파에서 한번실수하면 너무치명타라 안시키는듯ㅠㅠ모모일이후로...그래도 자주해주길

[@kim-mh8fd]

@@hihi-po2tb 공중파에서 데뷔때부터 ... 라이브했대 연말도라이브 증거나왔음

[@lumberinglumbering]

우리 에스파 라이브 너무 잘하고 마이들 응원법 넘 최고고 🤍

[@reynavilladolid8147]

4:28 onwards their synchronization is amazing esp. this move 4:38 that looks like they're all creating a circle in front of them, insane!! And of course, Winter hold up 4:41 is the best!! So powerful!!!👑

[@paunamidatta9000]

They really improved I am really excited for their next comeback

[@hyunlixxie2662]

2:08 winter is really a detailed dancer, her movements are both sharp & smooth

[@Emmzii4496]

Karina handled that broken shoe like a pro. The girls all slayed as always.

[@hehewq5989]

Karina is such an incredible performer, her shoe broke but she still slayed, it's so hard to notice too

[@anstkd258o]

그래도 지젤도 연습 많이하고 본인이 성장하려는 노력 보여서 좋은것같음 뭐라하던 이제 자기가 평생 걸어가야할 길이니까 본인이 잘 가꿔나갔으면 좋겠다~~~ 에슾하 화이팅 나는야 스엠개딸 ~

[@jele3438]

오늘 진짜 에스파무대 너무 이쁘고 멋있고 헤메코 완벽하고 무대도 너무 잘했어..!! 최고야 에스파!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@viclusiv]

Live Vocal OMG

[@뭐하숭]

헤메코 레전드다… 진짜 각자 미친 장점만 부각되는 무대

[@euvp7330]

언니들 진짜...헤메코 다 완벽한 무대ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ

[@orangemangocaprisun]

민정아 생일 축하해!!!!! 23년에도 더 많은 사람들에게 예쁨 받고 좋은 무대 많이 많이 보여줬음 좋겠다 에스파, 마이 모두 행복꽃길만 걷자 사랑해♥️

[@아무개-d9d]

각자 필승 스타일링 하고 등장한 전설의 무대…..

[@hsgajiiqgizzzhuss]

필승 스타일링이ㅈㄴ웃겨ㅋㄹㅋㄹㅋㄹㅋㄹㄹㄹㅋㅋㅋㅋㅎㅋㅋㅎㅋ너무예쁨 에스파 진짜

[@xxun_.k]

민정아 생일축하해에!!!!!! ❤❤❤

[@dlfshfrhehsajrrl-bq7bu]

에스파 진짜 도깨비불 같다 사람 홀린다...

[@user-uc6df7jd2]

흥도 없고 억지로 하는거같음

[@dlfshfrhehsajrrl-bq7bu]

@@user-uc6df7jd2 이 영상 저 영상 다니면서 악플만 쓰네 그럴 시간에 밖에 나가서 신선한 공기도 좀 마시고 햇빛도 보고 사세요 화이팅! 사녹에서 에스파 엄청 방긋방긋 웃으면서 신나게 했어요☺️

[@밥-k3h]

@@user-uc6df7jd2 억까 하느라 힘드시죠??힘내세요..

[@RT-hb2nm]

4세대: 아이브 르세라핌 뉴진스 삼대장 에스파 아이들 엔믹스

[@친구네밥상]

@@RT-hb2nm 아이들은 4세대 아니라니깐

[@sbs0914]

happy birthday winter

[@hrkim6203]

조금씩 생각은 다르겠지만 카리나 이번 메이크업 미쳤네.....전형적 SMEnt. 여신상을 극대로 끌어올린 역대급 메이크업... 2022년 보았던 모든 여자 중 가장 예쁜 것 같음

[@q_thmini9157]

本当にaespaちゃんは凄い こんだけ激しいダンスなのに、全然音ブレずに最初から最後まで生歌で歌える… マジで努力家、本当に憧れます スタイリング神ですっっっ

[@my011]

오늘도 역시 대박이당 그리고 민정이 생일 축하하고 마이들과 지민이,애리,민정이,닝이줘 새해 복 많이 받으세요. 앞으로도 화이팅합시당!!

[@adilafrds6718]

Karina's shoesss ㅠㅠ good job karinaaa. aespaaaa fighting !

[@aeD4RK]

AESPA STYLISTS NEED A RAISE,now their every stage outfits are slaying!!! 😎🙏💯

[@thangbithit_]

Their stylists don't deserve it. Take a look closely to Karina's boots, the heels in her left leg's boot almost fell off in the second half of the performance. It was Karina's confidence and professionalism that saved the situation.

[@aeD4RK]

@@thangbithit_ if a boot's sole fall off it's not the stylists fault but the brand cuase the stylist only gave them all new outfit. Stylist only dress them in best possible style and there they did there job perfectly.

[@setioajinugroho3659]

@@aeD4RK LMAO

[@di0811]

@Thang Luu Not only second half performance, it actually fell from the beginning, well done Karina

[@EmerieAdams]

@@aeD4RK Pretty sure their stylists are also responsible for putting together looks that are danceable in, that’s why they are specifically in this industry and not in editorial or runway styling, etc

[@psicoestudos6276]

Karina did all that with a broken shoe DAMN she really is good in everything 🔥

[@Letinhy]

에스파 2022년 수고했따!! 윈터는 생일 축하해 🎉

[@dreamer4475]

No one's talking about Karina's professionalism & that shows how good she is since a few only noticed. Like girlies' shoe got detached and danced like it was nothing.

[@junlim6699]

진짜 도깨비불이 명곡이고 안무도 잘만들었다. 타이틀보다 더 많은 커버 영상이 있는것만 봐도ㅋ mbc 카메라는 그나마 봐줄만 하더라

[@liod324]

짱스파 넘넘 이쁘고 무대 멋지다ㅠㅠㅠㅜㅜ!! 너무 너무 고생했어 올해도 새해 복 많이 받고 건강하고 즐겁게 활동하길 바래♥

[@bangvelvet6418]

Best vocalists of 4th gen. They're stable + slaying those runs and high notes like a pro. Good job, Aespa!

[@aishia2575]

if i hadn't seen the post on twitter about the sole in Karina's shoes falling off, i wouldn't have known it. the fact that she performed well despite of that is really amazing. karina's such an outstanding and amazing performer, seriously.

[@tiyjmntg216]

The way Karina performed was still professional even though the soles of her shoes had come off👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻Really she never showed any lack on stage🔥🔥4th generation best idol for me💙

[@yunanousha3541]

Karina is beyond professional! No one notice her left sole shoes is broke! But she still singing live and slaying❤

[@Psychic-01tube]

에스파 2022년 한해도 고생 많았고 2023년에는 더욱 더 좋은 아티스트 되어줘~!❤언제나 파이팅~!

[@sowonie4927]

Karina is so soso professional, she did not let her broken shoes bother her performance at all. Tbh, if there is no fan cam I bet no one will know about this. She just slayyyy as usual. 🫶🏻

[@km-2321]

Karina danced so well even tho her shoes was brokem 😭. She's a leader for a reason! Best Girl 🔥❤️

[@olalla8398]

울 짱스파 대단해

[@Bilalsarfraz8]

Aespa performance was next level. Simply out class. Amazing vocals , dance, beautiful lovely. Min-jeong best. ningning wonderful. karina real AI. Gesiel mindblowing. credit goes to Mys for their continuous support.💖💖💖 💖💖💖Aespa loves mys

[@jhj-m6z]

라이브 잘하는디

[@mohamadhusaini1974]

aespa stage presence >>>>> aespa live Vocals >>>>> I'm so proud of our Metaverse Queens Stan aespa you all

[@yyy6781]

karina's shoe sole is broken but she managed to continue till the end💯💯

[@danissegomez7953]

no one can stop them. She will take off and kick her shoe off if she needs to so she can perform well🔥🔥🔥

[@smolmambean9429]

The way karina showed no sign of struggle despite her shoe being almost completely broken is insane

[@O5l6]

와 실력 더 늘었네... 걸스 활동 때 보다 칼각이고 지젤 원래도 ㅈㄴ 잘했는데 실력 더 늘어서 너무 머시씀...ㅠ

[@ivana9467]

damn all the hype in the world that Karina is getting is not enough!! like how can she be this talented, a great rap/vocal, visuals on a 100, great dancer, leader, good at English, and professional.. like I just don't get it, she must be computer generated 😆 not once did she let us know half of her shoe sole was hanging by a thread, and still did every single dance move perfectly! she is one of a kind, hope she gets more artistic freedom in the future 🥰

[@pamela-uu8mu]

karina's shoes falling apart 🫣 her professionalism 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻😍

[@hsgajiiqgizzzhuss]

에스파는신이에요

[@urfavpage9685]

did anyone notice karina’s shoes in 3:03 she did really good to continue with that i hope next time the stylist check those little details to make sure the girls will be alright

[@abigailelardo6419]

Karina is such a great artist, dancing gracefully with broken boots 🙌🙌🙌 I think the stylists should check all their outfits well so that this will never happen again.

[@anthonyroimangilog5057]

Thank god, karina didn’t get hurt with her broken boots 🙏🏻 she so professional ✨

[@shineing9227]

GISELLE IMPROVED SO MUCH!!!

[@evia0913]

Karina is really a professional performer. I'm so proud of her... AESPA FIGHTING!!!

[@aeD4RK]

Aespa SINGING LIVE is just the end for all haters....❤️🤩😭🔥They did it so well,nobody can compare my girls. FIGHTING!!!

[@minj17]

우리 누나들 진짜 젤 멋있고 무대 넘 잘하고 이쁘다 22년도도 수고했고 23년도도 우리 좋은 일만 가득하고 행복하자 새해 복 많이 받고 사랑한다 누나들 민정이 누나 생일 진심으로 너무 축하해!!ㅎㅎ🥳🎉🎂

[@Jake71531]

민재형도 새해복 많이받으세요~🎉🎉🎉

[@user-uc6df7jd2]

남자가 방구석에서 걸그룹이나 응원하고 그저 한심

[@user-dj8hw3rm4c]

@@user-uc6df7jd2 할 줄 아는게 악플 다는거뿐인 너보단 누굴 열정적으로 좋아해본 저 분이 더 성공한 삶인듯

[@user-uc6df7jd2]

@@user-dj8hw3rm4c 인생 제일바닥이 아이돌 따라다니는 애들인거 다아는데 뭔 성공 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@letsgigigi]

@@user-uc6df7jd2 방구석에서 걸그룹 응원하는 건지 일 하면서 에너지 얻는 건지 니가 뭘 아는데 ㅋㅋ

[@mackiesa3385]

Winter live vocal 😘😘😘😘

[@-t4194]

찢었다.. 23년도 힘차게 달려가 보자!!!!

[@성주현-l8c]

마이분들 응원소리 든든하다❤

[@manciosbkxlan]

에스파 라이브 개짱짱하네

[@Ivylovesyouso]

1:34 karina’s shoes 😱😱 how she kept dancing omg 👏👏

[@hyeonpark_10]

윈터야 생일축하하고 새해복 많이 받아❤

[@brotherjin9725]

확실히 라이브를 해야 보는 사람도 흥이 생긴다

[@supershysoty]

I love winter's styling, ningning and giselle's hairstyles and karina's overall look

[@마이하고픈]

에스파 멋지다!!~😆 사녹에 가신 마이분들 열심히 응원 해주셔서 감사합니다!!😚 에스파! 새해 복 많이 받고 민정아 생일축하해!!🎉 마이분들도 새해 복 많이 받으세요~✨️

[@leos6078]

The looks fit them so much. We love Y2K queens 🫶🏻

[@cristian_glow]

KARINA SAID SLAY SHOES 💋

[@minmin-uh3cc]

OMG how could I become more satisfied about NingNing's outfit, really love her style. She approved her vocal to us again at the end of 2022. Couldn't love more. and happy birthday Winter❤❤❤

[@Ioo0i]

メイクも、ヘアセットも、衣装・ステージ演出から全て最高。痺れる…最高……

[@bloodyxzz2024]

Happy birthday minjeong

[@왕-i6c]

와 진짜 카리나는 이세상 사람 아닌 것 같다 너무 예뻐

[@NoBody-mp4ui]

Minjeong HAPPY BIRTHDAY 🎂🎉🎉

[@IsabelleStoney]

닝닝 걸스 라이브 개지리네 ㅋㅋar뚫고 나오는것좀봐..닝닝알라부ㅠㅠㅠㅠ

[@brotherjin9725]

윈터는 계속 뚫고 나왔다...닝닝은 한 두번 뚫고 나오니 표가 나지만 윈터는 계속 뚫고 나오니 눈치도 못챈다

[@smame-n4b]

@@brotherjin9725 존나 어쩌라는거임 그래봤자 투메보 둘 다 잘 불러

[@lykalu8220]

The way no one is noticing karina's shoe until someone is pointing it out 😭 she's such PRO performer

[@aishia2575]

will never stop praising Karina's charisma on stage, she's so amazing.

[@racey1992]

The fact that no one noticed Karina's sole detached from her shoes shows how professional she is. Just wow!

[@lonruiO_orven]

에스파 이쁘고 무대 진짜 멋져 짱❤️❤️❤️❤️ 사랑해 영원하자 ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@dooh]

Winter's outfit cheffs kiss 💖💖💖💖😍😍😍😍 Happy Winter Day 🎂🎂

[@misoonichan]

헐 카리나 얼굴형이 진짜 미쳤다. 삭발해도 예쁜 미모

[@mackiesa3385]

Omg winterr dance 🔥🔥vocal 💗💗 and sp better 💞💞

[@정승우-g9o]

에스파 새해 복 많이 받고 올해도 짱 화이팅

[@타꾸-p3c]

마이들 응원 진짜 잘햿음!! 민정아 생일축하해 🎉 💕

[@frd_rck]

I'M SO PROUD OF GISELLE SHE DIDN'T MAKE MISTAKES IN THIS PERFORMANCE AND THEM SINGING LIVE IS CRAZYY

[@Leigh-uz9wz]

Karina the main dancer. Karina the main character.

[@flosknm2550]

Karina's boot is tearing off, look how professional she is

[@melisahmel2411]

Saya tidak bisa berhenti menonton ini, karena mereka begitu mengagumkan, iloveyou aespa ❤️

[@agilhoo2733]

Karina shoes omg .im proud of with her im not realise if thers no notice about karina broken shoes amazing karina

[@hyunlixxie2662]

winter improved so much

[@iamme3912]

생일축아해 윈터 ☃️❄️