Gaza & Migrant Protests Infiltrated by Radicals + Is Progressive Politics Dead? + Local Elections

On today's #NCFNewspeak, NCF Director Peter Whittle, Senior Fellow Rafe Heydel-Mankoo and SDP London mayoral candidate Amy Gallagher discuss:
* Far Left radical agitators are infiltrating Gaza protests on university campuses
* Middle class leftists stop removal of illegal migrants to Bibby Stockholm
* Do SNPs misfortunes mean that progressive politics are dead in the UK?
* Local election results
---------------
SUBSCRIBE:
If you are enjoying the show, please subscribe to our channel on KZbin (click the Subscribe Button underneath the video and then Click on the Bell icon next to it to make sure you Receive All Notifications)
AUDIO:
If you prefer Audio you can subscribe on itunes or Soundcloud.
Soundcloud: / user-923838732
itunes: itunes.apple.com/gb/podcast/s...
SUPPORT/DONATE:
PAYPAL/ CARD PAYMENTS - ONE TIME & MONTHLY:
You can donate in a variety of ways via our website: www.newcultureforum.org.uk/#do...
It is set up to accept one time and monthly donations.
JOIN US ON SOCIAL MEDIA:
Web: www.newcultureforum.org.uk
F: / ncultureforum
Y: / newcultureforum
T: / newcultureforum (@NewCultureForum)

[@NewCultureForum]

If you live in EDINBURGH or MILTON KEYNES join us on 7 May at 7pm. Email [e-mail] for more details. Cost: FREE. Meet Peter Whittle or Rafe Heydel-Mankoo and like-minded people from the local community.

[@phillipcarter8045]

IF you live in Edinburgh or Milton Keynes I feel sorry for you . 😊

[@Excommunicated-ei1ep]

I agree with your Well Meaning Sentiments behind this Video, but People like me (On OTHER Platforms), have been LONG Predicting this, since before the Armistice Commemorations, of Last Year tbh…”Free Palestine” is NOTHING More, than “Antifa” and “BLM” Rebranded! With both being Merged Together…with also Islamo-Marxists thrown in, to give their New Rebranding, an Air of “Authenticity”… …just in time for Several Western: General and especially Presidential Elections Season. “Free Palestine” will become THE One Branding, alongside maybe…”JustStopOil”? Btw, the Palestinian Flag, is also Perfect, as a Rebranding Replacement Flag…Especially for “Antifa”?! Because it has ALL the 3 Colours of: Red, Black and White, of the Original Antifa Flag, with the Black for “BLM” and the Islamic Green, for the Islamo-Marxists too! So basically from now on? Just as the Woke-Left Replacement Rebrand, of “Free Palestine” for the Name? The Palestinian Flag will become the Brand, that Rules them ALL…

[@phantomhorse8255]

@phillipcarter8045 why. ?? Seems they speak for the silenced majority!

[@benphilips9918]

Beggars belief that the new leader of Scottish labour should repeat Yousef's vile speech. What awful times we live in.

[@zeldagoblin]

Somebody told me Sarwar did the anti white rant before Humza.

[@whisper8742]

You all can seem to learn anything from it? Even veteran painters of WWI can get it through to you? 1925 was almost 100 years ago!

[@jeancaron9325]

Yousef forgot the skin,s color of the NATIVE PEOPLE!

[@AndrewFosterSheff69]

OUT OUT OUT

[@chelamcguire]

It is his bloody cousin.

[@johnmitchinson9577]

It should be noted that Labour supported the Scottish hate bill. So substituting SNP for Labour is not the solution.

[@rocky76dude7]

But UK public is ignorant and stupid .These three stooges have no clue and as usual are going to be proved wrong .Online harms bill will be felt next year when the I frastructure is built , and labour will be in spending double what the Tories spent and blaming inflation on Putin and the Tories .

[@marianlonge3060]

Exactly and now it will come to uk 🇬🇧

[@Viktors633]

True, and i know people who vote on impulse for Labour who dont even know that. If they did i think they would reconsider.

[@Gozzillacia]

Sarwar is a clone of Humza - both woke Pakistani Muslims !

[@erinloo8921]

The world health organization treaty will make all yr deliberations on politics and race completely irrelevant

[@easzq8]

It was always a grift. The riots of recent years were rent-a-mob.

[@user-uc8jo4nq1p]

The RIGHT needs to get together in big numbers

[@kellysouter4381]

If we gather we are known as the very far right and are called fascists.

[@phantomhorse8255]

@@kellysouter4381 have to grow a thicker skin and not be afraid of being called names. The word "racist" is becoming meaningless due to over-use.

[@mistymoor7114]

The right en mass are so apathetic they don't even know they are "right" could take a lot to wake them up or could be too late

[@Gozzillacia]

Scot here - happy to see the 65% of us who are pro-Union get a mention. You have no idea how irritating it was to hear the phrase "Humza Yousaf - the Scottish leader" when 96% of Scots had no say in the diversity clowns appointment as FM. And on the Union, we may be the home of the SNP - but, and you would do well to remember this when the battle lines are drawn, we are also the most avid supporters of the Union, you may well be thankful for the pugnacious Scots when push come to shove.

[@robertguildford]

Love your comment, man

[@benphilips9918]

Thank you Godzilla. We support you all the way. It's time for us unionists and Patriots to unite and fight.

[@dagwould]

BTW, he's not, or was not, the Scottish Leader. He's not a clan chief, he's an elected representative employed by the people to govern: that is to administer the affairs of the government. Not to 'lead'. The only thing he might lead is his own party, but don't insult Scots with the nothing that they need a leader (apart from a clan chief, of course). Grown ups can lead themselves, thank you. (from Clan Campbell).

[@Gozzillacia]

@@dagwould Scion of Clan Campbell here myself. I understand your point - but "Scotland's leader" is the phrase they use - and he had the power to gag the nation - no Clan Chief has that power. But - I see your point, all politicians should be servants of the people - however there is a current movement, by all parties (left and right) to raise themselves above the people. To become the new aristocracy. The political international elites. Why they ignore the will of the people on immigration say.

[@charliedrake247]

Islamic terror on our streets

[@user-zc4yd9ss7h]

I have not noticed a terror attack recently. When did this take place?

[@whisper8742]

​@@user-zc4yd9ss7h Tell us where you can walk safely, Rabbi? We'll wait...

[@phillipcarter8045]

And in our homes .

[@richardeastman9846]

Islamic terror? Sit-ins with signs calling for ceasefire in Gaza?

[@PhilipOsborne-rz9eu]

You're right weak government

[@perryray3947]

Little do these women realise that Islam is very patriarchal, conservative, and traditional; not liberal at all.

[@kellysouter4381]

Those women are embarrassingly stupid. They've thrown away all the freedoms we fought for. No more shouting in the streets for them once they've destroyed all our hard work.

[@phantomhorse8255]

That is putting it very politely. Islam is totalitarian and fascist.

[@Disabledpatriot4242]

Western women with no Muslim links converting to Islam is the epitome of western privilege!

[@janeburke147]

I thought they were supposed to be educated 😂a little common sense is needed,we working class know this very well

[@phantomhorse8255]

That is very polite. islam is a totalitarian regime...., homophobic, mysoginistic,and even anti-animals ... The sooner our brainwashed do-gooders wake up and realise this, the better. But probably too late now anyway..

[@eb4661]

Humza calling out Scotts being white tells it all. Isn’t it double racism to people with the skin colour of blue?!

[@Hickalum]

Damn I love Peter Whittle … And I’m straight !

[@DarkAngel2512]

Straight female and Douglas used to be my crush.😂😂

[@ravennfall6034]

@@DarkAngel2512 now that is crushing, i take it you are talking about Douglas Murray? sorry for your loss 🤣😂🤣 He's a great guy to be honest.

[@DarkAngel2512]

@@ravennfall6034 😂😂 Yes, indeed I am. And yes, I felt the same when I found out Will Young was gay after I was crushing on him 😭😭

[@kiwigrunt330]

And Andrew Doyle.

[@stevenpaterson5100]

Exactly Ami,FREEDOM!!!........but you're not allowed to say anything that might possibly offend anyone ,ever

[@AnnDale-ie3jn]

When you create categories of protected classes the state almost certainly creates a situation where the native population especially white men can be discriminated against and that is what's happening. rather then having a society that is race neutral and being judged in what ability or skills sets that person possess it now depends what identity group you belong to this create a very dysfunctional society and a injustice one

[@mogznwaz]

That’s Marxism for you

[@valeriegrimshaw1365]

Marx was a failure...his family suffered from his delusions even to the point of starvation and a dead child I read...must check it out properly

[@Disabledpatriot4242]

I’m disabled and I disagree with ‘disability protection’ in so called ‘hate speech’ legislation. Ironically it’ll punish disabled people the most as we’re very non PC!

[@MartinParsons-tr6wi]

Frankfurt school critical theory

[@marksutherland5161]

The labour leader and humza are friends, they went to the same private school 1 Yr apart. The only difference is labour does not want independence.

[@alexedwards6509]

The SNP don't want independence, they want power. How can you claim to want a sovereign Scotland, and be a globalist?

[@chelamcguire]

They are cousins.

[@marksutherland5161]

@@chelamcguire time to research that

[@rosaob5842]

The prime minister of Nigeria- black! The leader of the Nigerian army- black! Etc etc, can you imagine anyone of national office in that country saying that? The answer is so obvious it doesn't need saying, and we are officially done for.

[@gwenlillianlondon3772]

There is some irony in young minds seeking an education and getting a pyschosis instead, but, what excuse is there for the adults in the room?

[@MartinParsons-tr6wi]

Orwellian irony

[@Jw196O]

Reports are coming out of the US re university demos that a number of mobile phones given to migrants crossing the southern border have been tracked to these demos. This once again has the appearance of a certain Mr Soro's finger prints all over it.

[@professormcclaine5738]

Protests and mass hysteria is easier than actually studying.

[@johnl5316]

Not just "infiltrated" but instigated by and led by revolutionaries

[@Eric-kn4yn]

Trotskyites.

[@MartinParsons-tr6wi]

Captured revolutionaries

[@AlexRadiobomb]

Well said. The narrative TM is illogical. Yet they insist. Cognitive dissonance set to max.

[@carlagroves4810]

Thank you - I always enjoy your ‘chats’ - it keeps me updated as well as depressed 😔 😂- i am very worried about London and its future 😢

[@phillipcarter8045]

Worry no more it’s finished .

[@joanhughes3620]

I agree wholeheartedly with you. Masks worn yet supposed to be illegal. Anarchy on our streets. I feel totally broken.

[@MusicMatters95]

London is already lost.

[@Thechatteringclasses-oj6zy]

Rafe Rafe Rafe reads the room every time.

[@AnnDale-ie3jn]

Sawers speech is the same speech as Hamza Yousef but without the anger and contempt

[@valeriegrimshaw1365]

So Sawyer learned from Yousaf's mistake....and toned the aggression down but the sentiment is still there.

[@amazer747]

Hamza's rant was prior to the Hate Crime Bill which is not retrospective. However, it is in force for Sawers rant so therefore a criminal act should he have offended even one Scot.

[@lindsaytwort8655]

Nip every thing in the bud immediately! It works.

[@julianlord5366]

The "genders" are not separating -- these are *sexes* , not "genders".

[@MartinParsons-tr6wi]

Chromosomes don't lie

[@chelamcguire]

The news channel, here on YT called Redacted looked in to the paid activists at universities in the USA. It was covered this week and they advised that between $1.700 and $3,800 US$ are paid out to those fools. It's an excellent news channel each Mon-Thur, live 9pm GMT.

[@AnnDale-ie3jn]

The cast may change but the script is the same and that script is ant whiteness

[@nulix8237]

Call them antiwhite, and win the fight.

[@unwing3437]

A lot of these protesters are paid to be there or they dont really know why they are there in the first place. Paid for by who? The usual suspects i'm sure. When asked what their opinions are on the subject of any particular protest, most of them say they dont know. I saw one guy at a gaza protest say that he was just handed a placard and that he didnt really have an opinion. There are many yt videos showing that most people at these protests are just going along with the crowd.

[@LettyK]

Yes, it's a kind of hysteria.

[@anotherfreediver3639]

Amy Gallagher had a very good point about misplaced female compassion, and not knowing what the people they were supporting stood for. The same I think was the case in the Vietnam War protests of the 1960s, where both sexes who protested had no idea about the brutality of the North Vietnamese communist forces that they were (de facto) supporting, and that although the South Vietnamese regime was by no means squeaky clean, it was definitely the lesser of the two evils.

[@susanbrowne5544]

All these protests are a fashion, no doubt about it.

[@annapachaclarke2392]

Yes, and carried out by people who look as if the sleep in dumpsters😅

[@MartinParsons-tr6wi]

Useful idiocy

[@JoeCarroll-tr5hw]

Please 🙏 people are not voting 🗳️ for what they are done voting for the same thing over and over again.

[@bordersforbritain1295]

34:59 Liverpool. They are already working on the demographics there. See 'Joe Owens talking sense'.

[@saraa6040]

@Bongoon I agree. However,, that is why I find her so very compelling. She is consistent and knows her mind. Amy has a kind of strength beyond power dynamics

[@nickimorley536]

Amy would be an exceptional mayor or London, if not she has everything necessary to be in Government. She is of the people, educated, informed and so relatable

[@christinerussell113]

​@nickimorley536 I voted for her. Sadly, I am watching this after the news that Carnage Khan has won again. But that win was expected. London, my native city, is barely recognisable. It is now populated by immigrants, mostly of Khan's religion and who thus nearly always vote for a fellow Muslim. Or else lefty Liberals who are just 'thrilled' by diversity and mass immigration, they, living in their comfortable little bubbles, being rarely directly affected by its downsides. The white working class Londoner, like myself, are now on the verge of extinction. London, a once world class city, has been transformed into a world class, multi culti hellhole.

[@phyllislovelace8151]

Thank you one & all for this invaluable conversation, much appreciated

[@the_forbinproject2777]

Is Progressive Politics Dead? yes , it died a while back and no one notced then but the smell from the corpse is now quite strong (!)

[@joanhughes3620]

You are spot on.

[@MartinParsons-tr6wi]

It got h I j a ck e d

[@beamanact]

You know what also gives one's life meaning and purpose? HARD WORK, which these entitled college kids are loath to do.

[@andrewyorke3352]

👍🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿🇬🇧

[@petermcneill80]

🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🇬🇧🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🇬🇧

[@Signals927]

Outside Islam funding.

[@ianlawrie919]

Another excellent discussion with numerous valid points raised and finished off with on a suitably negative note 😂👏👍👌

[@John-ji1fl]

Unfortunately yes, Wales is a socialist state to all intents and purposes..I know I live here 😞😞 .. anyway I'm looking forward to attending one of your events.

[@sephus99]

The students protesting Israel in the US have, for the first time in recent years, chosen a position that the powers that be are firmly against. In some cases they are being dealt with by police on horseback or in riot gear, and the House of Representatives passed a bill with a very broad definition of antisemitism that seems completely at odds with their first amendment. Focussing on the behaviour of the students rather than the response to it seems myopic to me.

[@jezwarren-clarke2471]

London has fallen

[@jeancaron9325]

What is the different between a Colonizers and a Migrants?

[@avryllsixtus3429]

Very little except colonisers bring goods, money and education with them and modern day immigrants just take take take from those being colonised.

[@themossad]

Infiltrated??? It was that all along.

[@kaywhy245]

Do these groups rise when governments are unstable?

[@madcarew5168]

Free,Free,Plastecine!!

[@LettyK]

Hold-on Rafe, students in the '60s would now be in their 80s!

[@S_Edward_Burns_ArtsEditor]

Money silences all protests.

[@MartinParsons-tr6wi]

The opposite is true

[@S_Edward_Burns_ArtsEditor]

@@MartinParsons-tr6wi Protests are merely fashionable since the '60s by marketeers, etc.

[@MartinParsons-tr6wi]

@@S_Edward_Burns_ArtsEditor Agreed. And they tend to have financial backing. That's not to negate your initial comment, just to add to it

[@lrsco]

“A House Divided Cannot Stand” - Abraham Lincoln. Now, let’s think, what culture/religion do you think wants to see Western Culture to fail? 🤔

[@mindyobeeznis]

Oh I did not realize just stop oil went silent! How interesting

[@Linda-qn4bm]

Exactly!...that's why when been ask about why they are there they can't give an answer why they are l there...endoctrination and more...

[@johnhouston9764]

Great Britain 🇬🇧 the United States 🇺🇸 and Australia 🇦🇺 as well as western civilization in general is done.

[@johnroulston370]

Interesting discussion about Scottish left-wingery, wokery, and anti British culture. Dare I say my experience in Northern Ireland is similar: it’s Irish Catholicism that is the problem. As Rafe says the Celtic fringe in the United Kingdom is most affected but look too at Liverpool and other parts of England with high levels of Irish Catholic immigration.

[@seandoherty7081]

Would you elaborate further?

[@harryfoster6374]

Why Edinburgh it is in Scotland, Why. Why,

[@RichardEnglander]

27:10 Rafe - if any diversity is good then it peaks at something like 5%, after that it is diminishing returns then going into negative feedback and accelerating decay. If I was planning a society I would habe some diversity yes, but how many curry houses does Bradford or Manchester need? Would not Curry Mile be far more interesting if there were 50 nations and their foods there? You don't want just one Thai or curry house, you want two or three for reasons of competition keeping them on-form, but after that there are no benefits to more, especially with the RoP. Think about it, one more Muslim isn't going to make Bradford more diverse is it? if they really wanted diversity then the government would be encouraging more Japanese and Papuans....

[@annabizaro-doo-dah]

Your statement the arrested professors 'encourage'chaos is wrong.The brutal arrests I saw involved teachers recognising their students, enquiring what was happening wherein the cops violently turn on the prof & charge the prof with 'battery & assault'. Too stupid to realise they're being filmed. When you're right I support you. I😮n this case you're not.

[@Linda-qn4bm]

Divide and conquer there's their recipe

[@petermcneill80]

Exactly

[@marpot100]

Please can you invite Eva Vlaardingerbroek to the channel for an interview 🙏

[@marpot100]

Preferably with Harrison and Evan on Deprogrammed

[@saraa6040]

@Evola's Sunglasses where is Ralph?

[@harryfoster6374]

These mainly none white complaining folk all dismiss the coloured number of people in high positions here in the UK at the same time, and the fact that the largest number of white population is actually white at 85%.

[@ianbanks2844]

Jeez , this has come as such a shock to me . Without this production I would of been totally ignorant of what the hard left are up to .

[@MarjorieStoker-oj8fh]

Of course they are and it's working

[@JupiterThunder]

ULEZ = Jizya GET KHAN OUT

[@LettyK]

Cannot believe he was voted in! 🤦‍♀️🙄

[@debbielangton8371]

Utube banned 🚫 me for hate speach🤔🤔

[@RichardEnglander]

24:10 Amy, ever since they introduced uni tuition fees the students have become customers. The power to control the direction of the institutions became under the control of the students. Got to keep them happy. Our secondary schools although free arent much different, we should listen to children but we should not let them dictate to us. See the Greta Goblin for a great example.

[@elwolf8536]

They are one in the same to me

[@ColinJarrett]

To the gender split in terms of the left right divide. This has been on my mind for a while. Amy says that the ladies lack certainty. I this the void left by the removal of the male component in a relationship. Decisiveness, certitude, bullishness even. The guys over on the left are just trying to get laid IMO.

[@H.Hardrada]

Being pro-{tear oh wrist} is already pretty radical. I dont think they needed the help.

[@ravennfall6034]

Ahhh, Amy looking well rested, not to bad a result for you as a virtual unknown good for you, don't be disheartened. the only way is up 👍shame about the turn out though 45.4% last time i looked not so good IMO. i think people are getting fed-up of politicians, saying we will do this then not delivering. though not as bad as the rest of the country 16.1 in a certain area. :for Peter Whittle seems the pro-Palestinians have finally found your channel, maybe they might learn something about who they are supporting? then again maybe not. i really enjoyed the last few conversations, yes i'm a little behind, it's been a busy slow week for me. wishing you all a good week.✊ to the people :)

[@Linda-qn4bm]

Love and peace will make us free

[@user-ed6ff3bb4i]

"Smash Facism" .. ?? Does anyone using that expression today actually KNOW what facism IS? It would appears that they mean "Smash anyone who disagrees with us".

[@bestaqua23]

7:33 I'm trans and thet report is the best thing they ever happened nto Trans youth . I am not traumatized by the idea a young person with distress about their gender will get the most affective , less distractive and most comprehensive health care .

[@marianlonge3060]

Antifa

[@debbielangton8371]

They change the clothe to mingle😮 😎 chameleons

[@debbielangton8371]

Men are wearing hijabs wen needed 😮

[@debbielangton8371]

I never got a voting card🤦😎

[@francis88825]

IS THE BELL ICON SAD/KHAN BY ANY CHANCE😅

[@user-cc3yc9ni3p]

NO. SOLDIERS. WOULD. GIVE. THEIR. LIFE. ?? FOR. ROYALS. NOW. WE. KNOW. ABOUT. PRINCE. ANDREW

[@murphyorama]

The Hate crime legislation is still in place even though Yousuf has gone.

[@hadrianbird2645]

PLEASE LEND ME YOUR SUPPORT FOR WELSH INDEPENDENCE 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁷󠁬󠁳󠁿

[@sirnunnosfreyxo5449]

Well... sometimes we see the socialist symbol ( the fist) in the ""jordanian ""flag.... so...in a nutshell i guess it's explained...

[@debbielangton8371]

Police and Shira law😮

[@harveyyoung3423]

Part 1: Amy Gallagher's point at 6:00 mins in about the imposition of State Guardians for children/families, so children have two parents one being a the "State parent", in Scotland. its easy to see how this can appear to be deduced from the concept of international/internal right along when expressed through a combination of individual risk, combined with international social justice that schematises the individual under identity determinations derived from now a whole world data analysis by identities, that are then fed into determine national identity. Thus two metric of risk are in play: one that views the individual and family w.r.t identity as membership in whole world identity sets and risk, along with the view of that same individual and family viewed as members of that identity with respect to national risk. The use of risk here is not raw data but already identity specific in its framework of risk derived though mass identity schemas. It can thus be a simple system of positive feed back, or self fulfilling prophesy because: the identity-schematic data collection begins with the idea of identity specific risks then, collects data based on this semantic that will always just produce more supporting data and no exculpatory or contra data. The origin or genesis of this original schematic of data can be illustrated from the rise in the 1970's first in the US then hear in UK, of women's groups and communes. These grew up out of the anti Vietnam War protests initially by middle class white students. Indeed the anti Vietnam War protests, in turn, developed from the late 50's early 60's Civil Rights protests. A lesson perhaps, the hard core of protest groups, learn how to organise, develop skills in what they now call creating "Solidarities", and when one protest succeeds or fails then move on to another. as they move they can change or modify the data collection schema. Way back following the 2008 financial Crisis, the Conservative MP John Redwood, did a lecture ostensibly on the movement of Capital in falling financial markets, at Gresham Collage titled something like "Does every bust mean a boom somewhere else?" The investments have to go somewhere, like a kind of assumption of symmetry, eg the conservation of capital over time. Its not that money cannot be lost but rather that its does not as such just disappear. Now, the schematic data collection has also been justified in terms of Social Justice, by identity schemas of John Rawls's "Theory of Justice". Problem is Rawls neither thinks first in terms of identities schemas, or from the point of view of the whole world. The left have combined both these and argued for them from out of Rawls work in the 1970-1990s. Rawls offers the individual in the State against these schemas, he then remains anti Hegelian w.r.t the individual but, perhaps not so anti-Hegelian w.r.t. the speculative interpretation now of many on the left, that the international is the appropriate view for politics. Indeed Rawls did claim the "privilege" or original position of people of the State here before of the world of international law. In this he contrasts with Peter Singer's 1972 paper on prior international obligations and duties. Now what opponents of this need to be able to do is to argue for the family and children and parents as a basic category or ethical determination against the forces of legal economic individualism, and legal and economic international justice, supported by expanding data collections across the world though local and international funded organisations. Already we might feel we need a left like solidarity of families across the world, say trying to draw on international laws of The Rights to Family and a Culture, and so frame its justification in terms of international law and create there own data of state family intervention harms. That is obviously very difficult will take a long time and might even end up making a trap that returns you back to the lefts position. (Note I've just started catching up on the BBC Radio 4 Series "In our Time" after, it turns out, a two years hiatus. They have recently done programs on Aristotle's Ethics, Rawls Theory of Justice, and Anscombe, and Hegel's Philosophy of History.) Indeed the point i am making about the family is mentioned in the Aristotle's Ethics as against Plato, in that program at 9:00 mins in. This is not then a new problem. I haven't watched any further, and I've watched non of the others yet either.

[@harveyyoung3423]

Part 2: Let me try a different approach that i started to develop over 15 years ago. It is clear that Rights can be viewed as facing inwards or internally in the State, and facing outwards to the international super State context. On the one hand people think of Rights as laws as necessarily being mutually and internal constant. They know there are "challenges" but these are seen as so much details and ad hoc modification problems to the basic schema of identity. The problems are not viewed as fundamental challenges to the whole project justification. For the left going back to the early 1970's these are problems of priorities say of identities as women and as a member of an ethnic minority. They are problems we could call both psychological and in terms of the economics of distribution of welfare. In the case say of international welfare we might appeal to risk and harm and justice and allocate financial resources from the State to a third world country. We might also consider Rights of people to welfare in their State by identity and so allocate resources accordingly. These Justice and risk projects then face in opposite direction from the point of view of a State. Even in the case of the same concepts a of identity this is true. Now as projects these have their allocated money their targets and their many employees working in these projects. A person might even be involved in both projects. But when wee view them in terms of money, we see they are in conflict: between the internal obligations and the external demands. now a pure utilitarian will, just say look at harm as a transcendent metric and do the allocation from the global view according to most need. Any problems with this would be claimed as "change is difficult" and there will, be a "political struggle" for a time, within the State for the the proper utility risk metric to be recognised to determine the political regardless of local and national democratic resistance. But either way as money geos to one it does not go to the other a kind of conservation of financial expenditure. For these two be seen as genuine non reducible oppositions, as opposed to, teething problems of two same facing movements, we need the Stand point of the State from where what is allocated overseas is lost domestically. Thus the Foreign and Domestic are in opposition even for a person who shares identities with both of them. There must be some kind of Kantian economic justice synthetic a priori propositions here to be found regarding the fundamental Being of the State and its existence. It would be a very formal expression for the general shape of the State of Emergency without decree or exception, rather its like the irreducible nature of a reflex of survival. Its so close to us our language will not let us articulate it except from paradoxically outside but then it just looks like we just happen to be to one of many equal states. As if being in a State was choice made by an alien being from another world. The conservative party have messed up this thinking in talking about Welfare changes penalties and sanctions, in much the same way they did after 2010 with Universal Credit. Since this welfare policy is internationally internally related to, if contravariant with, international obligations, this ought to have being made explicit. The left have long ago lost the ability to grasp this irreducible shape of the State, that is why people can go on marches for emergency absolute rights for some international cause, and marches for Welfare for women with children. Of course what is very clearly true at this economic level for one identity is true in general for the rich content of historical culture and the shape of many identities in play. This international rights and justice project(s) legal determinations can in their theory sublimate the State altogether for international identities and solidarities. Indeed then an appropriate up bringing would be to create a person who is internationally orientated except for their membership or belonging to a particular international identity group or groups. I have herd the old arguments against losing the State to the international organisations and solidarities as creating “tribalisms” in the State. But his would be mere temporary mediation process for the withering away for the State, and the rise of international sub democratic and rationally organised identity solidarities. I mean you could have “British” as an identity, but it would be recognised as local and particular contingent part by the international standpoint. It might even return internationally in the form of people supporting Manchester United from all over the world. But is national identity like that or is that a State Lite or diminishing of the State. If this isn’t taken seriously your kids will be indoctrinated like this through internationally organised education programs, and the parents will now be mere biological carers of children as bare life, and the left see biological care as the lowest kind of human activity. Merely reproducing biological material fit for the professional educators to start work with. You will have no recourse or reply or criticism and no way out. Imagine the response if any to a problem from a family in a village to this that is addressed to some massive international organisation: the geometric Oak tree from the small acorn of a women’s anti domestic violence group in California in 1973. Imagine how long the investigation, the enquiry, and the court case and new policy would take. They will just put complaints and criticisms into the audit PRIOR TO the funding and pay you off as a matter of policy, before any changes. like a compensation deal or no further charges, to silence you.

[@harveyyoung3423]

Part 3: From the above we might make a seemingly bold claim, but one more congruent to the two sides of the State internal and external, that is domestic and foreign, that the left ought to concentrate efforts locally, while the conservatives concentrate efforts nationally. The private and family are then inexpressibly original and before the State and the international is merely regulative. That's to puta spin on the local elections and a hope for the general election. What this means in more structural detail is difficult to express so far. Maybe everyone after St Anselm got the Ontological Argument Critique wrong, including Kant. This was my first work towards a new politics and i didn't even know I was doing or moving towards politics at the time in the mid 2000's i was just philosophy.

[@harveyyoung3423]

Part 5: One way you might try in order to see why all this institutionally and middle classed backed protesting is not to trace it back to the 1960's and further, but to the 2008 financial crisis. So if you remember the outcry against the middle class that followed it, first the right and conservatives tried to claim it was a black swan anomaly, then due to too much male greed and gambling mind set and structural bias, while the left talked about weak laws and regulations and then the rich bankers and then the super rich 1% of the 1%. All this was done in the context of a State of Emergency styled so called "bank bailout", that means the gains go to the well off while the losses as risk ought to be targeted to those same middle class gainers. But of course this broke the rule of reason that said the middle class deserve the unearned income profit of house prices, because they take the risk of losses and bank ruptcy if it all goes wrong. In this case the losses were "socialised" to everybody by the State through the banks justified not by the less well off gaining the trickle down benefit money, but by the fact that economic collapse would effect the poor more than the middleclass. Metaphysically behaviourally this means carrots for the middleclass and sticks for the rest. All the dissemination's and distractions by the middle class and all the talk of emergencies and risks only held the line for a year until 2011. Its was only then that the middle class were able to collectively divert the talk of emergency and risk ways form the banker sand middle class and towards racism sexism and black lives matter followed by minorities in general. The post bank crisis enquiry circus called for "whistle blowers" and "speaking truth to power" like the middle class "blow the whistle" on themselves? so this became transferred sublimated to blowing the whistle on sexual assault and racism. And sexual assault ands racism became the new emergency. Its proper revolutionary Hegelian stuff. So ask your selves a counterfactual, if that is a thing, and ask who would be in the dock now if it wasn't for the marshalling of all this sex and racism, risk emergency 24/7 full media blackout, everyone has forgotten that their houses and over leveraged mortgages were falling prior to 2008 and after the bail out stabilises and then after QE they started to rise, and rose from Covid. It doesn't take a noble prize in economics to realise that the mass immigration has been substantial in keeping house prices high, as well as the supply/demand paradox that houses are not been built. I guess the next move might be to get us fighting each other over the crumbs of Welfare like form 2010 onwards. Point 1 I saw a lecture form Harvard way back at the beginning of KZbin and the economist outlined how the middle class mortgage situation was going to destroy the middle class in the West if something isn't done. A few years later the economist at Yale Robert Schiller said this in his 2007 version of his course, and his prediction actually started to happen during his lecture live! Point 2 Ever since the French Revolution the middle class have known the key to stopping revolution is to make sure the next generation of would be middle class, who in an economic crisis jsut have no expected job to go to, are kept happy or at least occupied less the devil get hold of their hands. Even Lenin held off the early moves for revolution because he said they have not yet built up a middle class vanguard to run the country after they destroy the infra structure. He said it was the difference between a revolt and revolution. The middle class have done their job well, I spend my days in my home library reading middle class books on logic and semantics, and posting stuff in KZbin Comments sections to New Culture Forum channel and others lucky KZbinrs. I mean I call my library a command centre but I guess Bruce Willis would say it's just a living room mate.

[@harveyyoung3423]

If I'm honest i think the the Right and conservatives in drawing on slightly modified but, incongruent with the present, versions of 1950's and 1960's Cold War Anti Communist and liberal arguments, followed by rehashes of 1980's neo-liberal arguments, see these "culture wars" the front lines of the battle. I on the other hand saw them as contrived distractions merely Hill 101 in a different battle. So i see myself has only fighting a regard action for the last several years. But now things have changed due to events. Geopolitics and the culture wars are more constitutive now of the battle and consequential of future possibilities no one could foresee. Maybe its all got beyond what the arrogant Western Middle Class with their algorithms and networks could have imagined. I mean though doesn't everybody know in a Crisis like this one conflict opening up make other possible conflicts look more likely Is that not lesson 1 of geopolitics 101. You see though my Critiquing the Middle Class like his will they now be able to say "I am with the Terrorists". Maybe some burocratic shift and they can deport me by right.

[@user-cc3yc9ni3p]

EPSTIEN

[@rocky76dude7]

He's delude the toff as progressive politics is expanding in UK with labour getting in .This show won't be allowed for much longer !

[@astrecks]

Can you rephrase that in English please?

[@creelbait]

Well, that's what progressives are famous for, Not allowing any opinion that their own biased hypocrisy disagrees with.

[@annapachaclarke2392]

Stop smoking that wacky baccy, you make no sense 😅

[@debbielangton8371]

Ive been banned fir cyber bullying Elon musk 🤣🤣🤦🚫

[@HallOshea]

Hes got a problem with white people 😂

[@rocky76dude7]

Toff outta touch with UK majority is here wearing outdated toff clothes -talking literature , civilised behavior .

[@mrror8933]

Innit

[@annapachaclarke2392]

Definitely too much wacky baccy for you 😅

[@englishbob9492]

Well dressed, well read and well spoken? How dare he!

[@davidmullen6011]

Quiff is with a history motto and no longer was a Rollo , modest smiler .

[@JupiterThunder]

pesky literature and civilised behaviour

[@debbielangton8371]

My neighbor goes bk to Afghanistan fir 3 monthe a year by car to france Germany etc no problems😮🤦🤦😎

[@sit-insforsithis1568]

What’s wrong with going to Germany or France

[@Danny-qq5nr]

He should stay there

[@haemka9906]

Joined, not infiltrated.

[@barbrokjelkerud]

Vaddå ”far left”, var finns dom????

[@djfez58]

This channel is utterly unhinged.

[@sonnytopboy4975]

Maybe it's not the channel 😂

[@juliangrove7441]

He keeps looking down when he says, 'white', does he need to read it...what is the body language here?

[@juliangrove7441]

I guess, when he looks down at his notes white=pause

[@Al-ie9ob]

Wow! Click click click. I’m a 54 year old Roman Catholic and this has nothing to do with HAMAS but everything to do with a genocide being carried out in Real time. If I was an Israeli I’d be ashamed of myself

[@The.Scum.Z]

From where you get these excuses? Isnt it too political !!!!😂

[@user-cc3yc9ni3p]

SAVILE. N. CHARLES