Deception: Murder in Hong Kong (Game the Game)

[@DevilboyScooby]

Paula's catchphrase should've been "I am the witness, and you can trust me, because I'm being very obvious about it."

[@enterusername2084]

You gotta love a person who can’t lie even when it doesent matter, some people are more pure

[@SuperPostin]

For those who kinda wanna play along, skip to 10:38 to not know who the murderer, accomplice, or witness are

[@tahmeed9281]

At 3:53 she says the Forensic Scientist will point first to the Murderer and then to the Accomplice, but the rules say they are pointed at together. Basically the witness is not supposed to know who's the Murderer and who's the Accomplice between the 2

[@AaronShegrud]

From the Witness description - "They have no way of knowing which is the Murderer and which is the accomplice and they do not know how the crime was committed"

[@AaronShegrud]

Fair enough, though it is good for people new to this game to know how game breaking it can be if this rule is broken so they can make an educated decision to purchase this game.

[@robertyoul]

Making them by definition not a witness lol.

[@AaronShegrud]

The story is that they saw both criminals leaving the scene, not the act of the crime. Thus still witnesses.

[@nickcampbell3812]

I noticed that in her explanation video and pointed it out. She says to point at the murder then the accomplice though the rules say they should not be able to tell who is who. Edit I'm now realizing the video I watched is the beginning of this video.

[@nickcampbell3812]

At 21:29 you said "And technically you can pull Location [of Crime] or Cause of Death" Though the rules say "The Forensic Scientist draws a new tile from the draw pile. This tile replaces one of the previously used Scene tiles except "Location of Crime" and "Cause of Death". This is one of the things you do differently from the rules that may affect your games in the future.

[@katiewong2051]

Also, I think it is clearer in Chinese of what everything means, because the phrase 畸形 can only mean that person is borned disfigured, but the word disfigured can mean both after the murder or that person was borned disfigured

[@JannPoo]

I think they simply used the wrong word. Malformed, Misshapen are better words for that. Disfigured is never used to refer to a physical flaw someone was born with.

[@rhysjonsmusic]

Paula gave herself away immediately

[@custersword7746]

Maybe, but the Forensics expert gave everyone too good of clues that pointed directly to the evidence too, which could have lead her to do that.

[@rhysjonsmusic]

Custersword too good of clues? They were miles off as far as who the murderer was.

[@LoLCTHSKateer]

i mean... the murderer did literally built an entire charade of "night time blood letting rave" and his time of murder is "noon". Yeah... real close...

[@rhysjonsmusic]

LoLCTHSKateer but that could just be a joke. But for someone at the start the game to immediately mention the weapon and evidence. Any murderer would think thats too uncanny to be a genuine guess

[@LoLCTHSKateer]

I was replying to custersword. I am whole heartedly agreed with you that Paula gave herself away. But somehow, KZbin decide "nope, even thou you're replying to the comment, i dont give you tag name". :< okay

[@DungeonDad]

I saw this at my LGS the other day. Looks cool! I would love to see this played with 12 people though.

[@BlimpMcGee]

It gets draggy

[@murrayleach5996]

it did feel super on the side of the murderer balance that more people would balance.

[@ImaginaryMdA]

Lol, Witness was pretty obvious. 3 people keep guessing and only one is consistently spot on, XD

[@theDiRTYeightSUPER]

Rules wrong. You don't say who the murderer and accomplice is to the witness. You point to both and don't say anything..

[@drut001]

House rules, play however you want as long as it is fun.

[@Ashtarte3D]

Depends on how your group wants to play. I've only played it twice but I rock at mind games and manipulation (not sure if I should be proud of that, lol) so I made an awesome witness the second time and didn't get caught.

[@chadvader974]

www.google.co.uk/search?client=firefox-b&dcr=0&biw=1920&bih=943&tbm=isch&sa=1&ei=5w6tWsbQKsqOgAbO56qQBw&q=stickelr+for+&oq=stickelr+for+&gs_l=psy-ab.3..0i13k1l2.17564.20538.0.21386.27.18.0.1.1.0.116.1280.12j4.17.0....0...1c.1.64.psy-ab..13.12.938.0..0j0i67k1j0i10k1j0i13i30k1j0i13i5i30k1j0i8i13i30k1.56.fmne1wlsmwE#imgrc=ew2vmauSFR5rGM:

[@ZwoolkTheNarwhale]

Ashtarte I

[@MrShooter72]

Yeah, definitely fine to play it the way they did, but it does make it MUCH easier to guess the witness at the end if everyone knows that the witness can directly identify the murder and is not choosing between two possible choices.

[@galenc1a]

This is a really fun game. I played with some friends for the first time and actually won as a witness! I nudged them to find the murderer and accomplice and I didn't get killed! Haha. Thanks for the vid!

[@jarrellsanchez348]

"Is it Becca with the radiation or Becca with the hook?" Neither, it's [Becca] with the good hair.

[@EmmaBonn96]

I love how this game makes stories of murder. The classic mean girl sulfuric acid face disfigurement.

[@snordg]

I love that dinosaur dress!

[@nickst.laurent3914]

You can create a link in the info card to the previous videos on how to play rather than reiterating it in the actual game. This creates more unique content and also gets right to the action

[@Hahahahaaahaahaa]

Or just embed a time stamp for the skip. I don't mind not having to open another video if I haven't seen the rules, but if I have it would be nice to just say "no thank you!"

[@timkelly1204]

With my group we always leave out the witness and the murderer can pick 2 cards from any group (2 cards have to be in the same group though). A lot more fun and challenging.

[@TimothyWhiteowl]

why the hell would he remove disfigured... it's fricken acid.

[@haravikk]

Why on earth did Erik get rid of the disfigured clue? It seemed more obvious to eliminate the location as everyone was getting too tied up on that, not sure what the other cards have as possibilities (relationship wouldn't have helped point to glue I guess) but disfigured was ideal for reinforcing the acid.

[@patcon314]

While they said you can replace the location tile, you can't.

[@VinegarAndSaltedFries]

Happy Birthday\Belated Birthday Becca!!!!!!! Keep up the great work.

[@johnodonnell2495]

Great show! Really bring the game to life. Fair play Becca + co!

[@lucaspiccoli7090]

Becca did a very good job explaining the rules of the game, and it was very fun to watch the playthrough. I like this format much more than Tabletop's, because it has a better flow to it. First, a complete rules explanation and then just the game being played. What I didn't like so much about Tabletop (still a fan) was that it was heavily edited and the camera kept going away from the table and into the players monologues too much. Very good job, looking forward to watching more of the series!

[@malixcorvin777]

Lucas Piccoli I would’ve preferred tabletop to be full length vids at least. I don’t mind the cutting away bits, but I’d like to watch the whole game.

[@EmrysTernal]

10:21 That's wrong. The Witness is supposed to know who the Murderer and Accomplice are, but NOT WHICH ONE IS WHICH. He pointed to the murderer while saying they're the murderer, etc. Oops!

[@todorkon]

Yep, which pretty much determined the outcome of the game (barely refraining from saying spoiled the game) - the witness knew exactly who the murderer was, got her exposed but was not careful and got discovered herself and lost the game.

[@shallendor]

Paula introduced me to the great Zeus School KZbin channel the first time she was on here, and this is the 3rd time i remember her being on here. Paula is always the so entertaining!

[@PaulaDeming]

:D

[@murrayleach5996]

your always great on gtg, this one made me laugh so much. critternation.

[@SowerOfMustardSeed]

During the very first Evidence Collection Phase, the Forensic Scientist should have had all six clue cards laid out first before placing any bullet markers. Then he could decide the order of which clue is given and the manner of how each clue is given (e.g., length of time taken for thinking before placing a marker) to strategically give hints to the investigators. The discussion may start as soon as the first marker was placed. The forensic scientist could therefore give clues by placing the subsequent markers strategically to steer the discussion direction.

[@GD-tt6hl]

I... I... don't have 3 friends...

[@custersword7746]

I moved out of state and I didn't have any friends. I invited some coworkers to meet me at a food place down the road after work and we could play some table top games as long as we all got something to eat or drink. Later, I met some magic players and as soon as we started hanging out and stopped playing magic, we started having fun with real games.

[@katiewong2051]

Well I am from Hong Kong and we eat take outs pretty often cause it's cheap in Hong Kong Just saying

[@Savaemaz]

Did anyone else notice that the signature at 22:57 is Barack Obama's??

[@LambertBowden56]

17:57 What was Becca Scott doing?

[@custersword7746]

Woohoo Murder Mystery game! Good luck and may the best villain or hero win!

[@JoaLoft]

RIP TableTop, I guess?

[@honrethgaming8347]

Yeah...RIP Tabletop.... enter Snoretop.

[@E-name]

In the arms of the angels

[@madroswellfan]

Best show on geek and sundry.

[@dicoterra6113]

madroswellfan watch table top it is a smoother better production of this and the players are now so camaraderie shy as so of these fokes

[@КоусараАнастасия]

Thank you so much. This video is really helpful :)

[@BoardGameSanctuary]

This is one of my favourite go to party games!

[@wombataldebaran9686]

Makes me miss TableTop... Aaand now I´m sad

[@Chronically_ChiII]

What happened to them?

[@wombataldebaran9686]

@@Chronically_ChiII Got cancelled, after Will Wheaton got a lot flak from the internet or something (don´t know exactly).

[@Tysia200]

To me this is a spiced up game of mafia. The game seems great but I think I'll stick to the good old mafia variants that I came up with my friends as kids. I would never betray my childhood accomplishments.

[@felipedaniel3149]

Como eu amo ser um geek ❤

[@gregputnam7243]

So this a mash-up of Clue and Resistance?

[@vordaq]

This game seems really stacked against the murderer.

[@FaithChick18]

Erik... didn't he do backyard fxs?

[@HotaruZoku]

Scott's vest is spot on. How does one garment meet standards for both Hong Kong club wear /and/ steam punk?

[@peterissmilgzids6266]

you are the best Becca

[@10175978]

I've met better.

[@minethulhufhtagn7239]

Murder Weapon: Sulfuric Acid Clue: Glue Forensic Scientist Cause of Death: Poisoning (chosen) Doesn't really fit the murder weapon and is very vague, can be applied easily to others. Severe Injury (better). Location of Crime: School (chosen) Probably the best option. Does point at glue. Victim's Build: Disfigured (chosen) This was also very good. Suggests the sulfuric acid. Motive of Crime: Jealousy (chosen) Lots of good options, including this one. Only money and power would have been bad. Time of Death: Noon (chosen) A good choice. Likely equal with morning and afternoon since location is school. In Progress: Relaxation (chosen) Nothing clearly stands out as a clear choice here. Like assembly and visit could have worked as well. I think the major mistake by the Forensic Scientist was selecting Poisoning for cause of death (again, fits too many others and acid is generally not considered a poison...it's an acid), then not swapping it out when it was clear many folks were jumping poison to accuse everybody. Especially don't swap out disfigured. Social Relationship: Colleagues (chosen) An OK choice. For sulfuric acid, I think Lovers would have been better. You've already got jealousy, so why not play into that. Rarely do colleagues use acid to attack a colleague of which they are jealous. If the motive was hatred, maybe. But only a slight misplay. Not removing poisoning, which was confusing many folks was a mistake. Pulling relaxation was good, since it moves away from puzzle being an option. But the one with the puzzle was the only investigator that wasn't a witness, so not needed. Corpse Condition: Decayed (chosen) An OK choice, but to me points strongly at radiation. Incomplete might have been better and would point strongly to sulfuric acid. I know only being an observer and not under any pressure or time constraints makes me think I could do better. The hardest role in this game seems to be the forensic scientist since they have to listen to what people are using to connect weapons and clues and swap things out to de-emphasize the red herrings.

[@calsela]

In progress should be Trading , you have to stick some stamp to the paper to legalize the trade or smth. People wont choose the other weapon because the only poison that can disfigure the victim is only Sulfuric Acid so they wont pick the wrong weapon from other people (Wine , Illegal drugs, Pills and Overdose cannot make the body disfigured) If you drink sulfuric acid, your organ will melt or even made hole on your stomach or something. The forensic put Relaxation like who relaxed with glue on his hand? I know some people get high smelling glue but that is not the common way to use glue.

[@indevious9659]

1:15 something adds up here and I don’t like it.

[@jamespooh2]

Great video!

[@mattdaitsman5694]

I saw Erik Beck and clicked.

[@michaldanek7734]

So many misconceptions about sulfuric acid... First, acid is not poison. It's just not. Second, what school would ever have sulfuric acid?? That's insane!

[@HereKittyKitty44]

school was for GLUE not acid

[@AdrianKramarzyk]

happy birth day Beca!

[@Redtail_hawk]

Happy bday Becca!

[@BenRangel]

Is it allowed for the forensic scientist to be so slow in adding the clues? That kinda makes it obvious which clues are the most certain ones and which are less relevant.

[@Chronically_ChiII]

So they should put them all at once.

[@nickjohnson1208]

Where's the Mountains of Madness episode that's mentioned? I'd love to watch it

[@tiggerpete]

awfully similar to a game i remember from summer camp called mafia, it was just played with a few cards from a regular deck of playing cards. it was always a lot of fun,

[@tahsinthoughts]

The woman in the denim jacket with glasses/bangs looks like Jessica Day (Zooey Deschanel's character in New Girl) I'm sure she gets that a lot!

[@johnglendavis]

omg I own that let's summon demons t-shirt and it's my fave!

[@pochinnie17]

I thought only the investigators can guess who the murderer is.

[@mouselim72]

Becca, the accomplice should make the guess and throw it at the murderer (Pisha) but choose the wrong items to get the real investigators off the trails.

[@ShadesinMirra]

Happy Birthday

[@joshuaesmero1464]

got this game and it's amazing, always have a great time whenever I play it with friends.

[@Brettbren]

*ERIK "BFX" BECK!?! His channel (Indy Mogul) was one of the first channels that I regularly followed and watched.*

[@appleseller154]

Wait. Did we have a Dresden Files reference in this episode?

[@damianhoffman6311]

Very late to the party, but I was wondering the same thing. Glad you asked it!

[@lime7494]

Take a shot every time they say the word "disfigured"

[@NeoEvincar]

3:24 Someone has been reading the Dresden Files I see!

[@G00N3R7883]

Happy birthday Becca :)

[@felipet.m.]

Happy Birthday!!!

[@GlennDeBlock]

How do you know when a round is over? How many rounds are played in total? And can all the badges be spent in any round?

[@chloebastone4445]

Glenn De Block the round is over after everyone takes their turn making guesses of who and what. At the end of the round the forensic scientist changes one of the clue cards.

[@GlennDeBlock]

Chloe Bastone ok so everybody plays their badge at the end then? Why would anyone play it in the beginning with less clues?

[@chloebastone4445]

Glenn De Block no you don’t ever actually have to play your badge. Your badge is for when you wanna accuse someone. It’s strategy to gather a bunch of clues before you accuse someone, but you can also throw your badge if you are down to 2 options (people)

[@chloebastone4445]

Glenn De Block it makes more sense when you actually play the game in person because you get into rhythm with it

[@GlennDeBlock]

@@chloebastone4445 whats the advantage of spending your badge early?

[@patcon314]

Can't replace location or cause of death tiles.

[@unknown360ful]

ERIC BECK?? FROM BACKYARD FX?? INDY MODUL??

[@CrowMercury]

That was a great game but quite the bad example, as the witness was extremely obvious and the others were too oblivious.

[@jenniferhuer]

This is a board game version of the awesome group game "Mafia."

[@bradleygolden7000]

happy birthday!!!

[@DinkieChan]

Oh look, my cousin Johnny is on GnS. Neat.

[@verYCreepyDoll]

this reminds me of werewolves of millers hollow

[@mickb5037]

Fun group to watch but if you don’t show us the secret information, we can guess along with the investigators instead of knowing who done it, and how, from the start.

[@akimura5720]

happy birthday!

[@paveroud4084]

Happy b-day Becca :b

[@feanaaro8652]

This seems very unbalanced in favor of the murderer. The investigators have to guess their identity (1 in 5) and 2 items, while even if they are caught, the murderer just has one in three chances of winning by pure luck guessing at the witness (even asides any chance of actually individuating them during the game).

[@custersword7746]

The investigators get multiple clues, additional improvements to those clues, multiple guesses, they can still collaborate even after guess wrong, and none of it is a die roll. The hardest part is the number of forensic tiles and you HAVE to put something on them. So, "Tie" and "Relax" and "Noon" were all red herrings, but other words on the same cards didn't help either. You don't want to guess the murderer. You want to deduce and accuse, even if you are the murderer, you want to be able to be convincing enough when you accuse someone else.

[@feanaaro8652]

I understand that. I'm just saying that even after the investigators have "won", the murderer still has a very good chance of winning anyway. 1 in 3 just by luck, and more than that if the witness is not super skilled at disguising him/herself

[@KamramBehzad]

Agree entirely. I thought you only include a witness if there are more than a certain number of players. With 5 the murderer's chances of getting away with it is too high.

[@gorram]

The witness is only for games of 6+ and is optional. I don’t use it for less than 8 tbh but I can understand that for the sake of showing everything in one video they included it in a game this size

[@tylerstevens1904]

Resistance is far superior. The episode of Table Top featuring it was its very best.

[@christheisen6089]

So this is the new Tabletop show I see?!

[@QuestForPerfectSound]

Hey, it's the original backyard FX guy

[@xsaberfaye]

Becca is gorgeous!

[@ezamal89]

Where can I find Paula’s socmed

[@PaulaDeming]

Hi! You can find me on twitter @paulademing

[@emilysmith3594]

Fun fact: the “signature” card has Barack Obama’s signature on it.

[@DigitalicaEG]

"Get more friends " 😭

[@the.nikkoman]

it's like a longer version of The Resistance: Avalon

[@ericm3327]

We don’t know who the murder is yet, -me it’s Paula

[@kylecoleman6221]

Shouldn't the witness only know the murderer, not the accomplice?

[@TheSchrodingersSpy]

to answer 10 months late: the witness should have no way of knowing which of the two is a murderer or the accomplice if we were going by this happening in a real life situation: both may be at the scene of the murder but the witness may be unable to identify who is actually committing the crime. however by the game book it says that the witness should only know which two people are bad, and not know their roles

[@icareg]

There is something kind of depressing seeing a woman as foxy and expressive as becca scott. im locked out

[@souIsynapse]

How is sulfuric acid poisoning lol

[@joelcole161]

Trying, but just can't deal with Becca's "Disney channel host" delivery... Maybe I'm not the intended demographic.

[@honrethgaming8347]

Its Tabletop.....but crappy

[@theDiRTYeightSUPER]

Not a patch on Table Top...

[@LTdrumma]

kinda just as good to me, expect if I think of the best Table Top episodes

[@MC-xw2ro]

I feel like him being "too good" of a murderer would have made for a better episode. Were some of the other players just too butt-hurt?

[@lqbtqwinn1739]

Why does the signature look like Obama's?

[@razlem]

i swear these people are cartoon characters xD

[@E-name]

It just isn’t wil Weaton....

[@codypannell9463]

And here's another episode of "Where's Will Wheaton?!"

[@jpwfilmarchives8076]

"I FeeL LikE I DiD a GoOd JoB!"

[@bayareamasto]

Paula was a terrible witness.

[@blind_surgeon]

I'm glad this is here to help teach the game but MY GOD the people on Geek & Sundry are absolutely insufferable.

[@taylornickens6842]

BOB THE SKULLLL

[@knivesthec10wn]

Can we get tabletop back please? I use to love this channel but since alpha you can smell the sell out in the air.

[@zepheris]

Wil was pretty angry at the alpha shit and I doubt he'd be willing to it again.

[@elemen_ts13]

No I like becca

[@paulbuehler8596]

Whoever was responsible for scanning the cards to be used as graphics needs to go back to scanning school.

[@fivebearrugs]

LOL like the Push card with two right hands on it...