10 MOST OVERRATED Sucky Fragrances EVER (According To You)

[@Atif_Ph.D._Kate_Bush_Fan_Club]

1:08 JPG, Le Beau Paradise Garden 3:48 Creed, Aventus 4:47 Prada, Luna Rossa Ocean 6:39 Giorgio Armani, Acqua Di Gio Parfum 9:14 Maison Margiela, By The Fireplace 10:45 Chanel, Allure Homme Sport Eau Extreme 14:04 YSL, Y EDP 17:28 Rasasi, Hawas For Him 19:00 Versace, Eros EDT 21:34 Maison Francis Kirkdjian, Baccarat Rouge 540 BR 440 is quite simply unique and a masterpiece. I'm shocked this is even on the list.

[@YouTalkinToMeBro]

Thanks! Time stamps AND names...much appreciated.

[@biscuitninja]

The hero we need!

[@Tiger4971]

Thanks. I can't be bothered watching the whole video. All his videos are way too long.

[@B400]

Prada Carbon is the best prada cheaper option.

[@samueloguet7721]

Br540 unique ? Not anymore ! Im so sick of this DNA it makes me nauseous

[@benzabeast]

The editing on this vid is all over the place, from the names of the fragrances to the fragrances shown. Wild 😳

[@danmatthews4803]

Yeah, since he handed off editing to someone else the error rate is shockingly high.

[@neoNashShaggy]

Paying someone to make videos of this quality every single day will do some normal mistakes Premiere and After Effects timeline gets crazy hard to control with so many effects and stuff

[@danmatthews4803]

@@neoNashShaggy true, but in this case, the captions are wrong. That’s not special effects, it’s words. Also, they often use the wrong bottle in the picture…not a fragrance by the same company being discussed, but the wrong bottle from a different company.

[@neoNashShaggy]

@@danmatthews4803 Videos are 20 Minute videos, by a person which probably isn't a professional fragrance guy, so it is a wrong parameter to use in my opinion, its "normal" to even use the wrong bottle when you don't know fragrances

[@erikamarquez1863]

Am I tripping or are most of the images not matching the product being talked about? 😅

[@ChrisSanzV]

Editor was high on this one 😂

[@PerfectlyFreedom]

Maintaining consistency DAILY sure is difficult lol

[@valzalel5203]

Fragrance enthusiast ghosts be doin the most

[@Atif_Ph.D._Kate_Bush_Fan_Club]

Captions on screen at 6:39, 9:14, and 10:44 are wrong.

[@tinus4256]

They are auto-generated, there's bound to be mistakes AI hasn't advanced quite enough for perfect captions yet 😅

[@BeauMillionFragrance]

Love the channel. Editing on this one though. It's seen better days lol

[@Ryan_Feik]

TikTok is a menace to the fragrance world.

[@GearheadExplorer85]

I would argue that TikTok is a menace to more than the fragrance world.

[@Ryan_Feik]

@@GearheadExplorer85 very fair lol

[@Ysoserious1]

My daughter just had to have that Ariana Grande 😂

[@carlosg2151]

Correction, Menace to Fragcom 😂

[@Kai0nTheMoon]

I was thrilled to see it get banned. Shame it only lasted a day.

[@tylerss20]

lol, Ash what is up with bottle images and fragrance descriptions in this one?

[@Fadamaster]

Chanel allure homme sport eau extreme and Ysl Y edp are excellent fragrance, certified compliment monsters

[@marxeric1913]

@@Fadamaster I love YSL Y (I got 5 bottles on this line). EDP is the best. Easily no.1 favourite from my 30+ fragrance collection.

[@richardspurgeon8954]

Oddly I'm not fond of either I like the edp intense and the reg sport.although I wouldn't say both you mentioned don't draw positive attention .

[@BigDaddyDeek]

Just sniff some detergent , that is YSL Y in my opinion

[@JamesBond-zd5jx]

Don’t like Y and neither does my wife. I do like Myslf.

[@mikeg6913]

Coming up with new video every single day must be exhausting 😂

[@Trainens107]

Micallef when talking about Replica lol 9:39 and Parfums De Marly Sedley when talking about Allure Homme Sport 10:48, what was the editor on lol?

[@HardRockinJohnny]

I love Prada Luna Rossa ocean. As they say everything is subjective and to each his own.

[@bradymccoy2672]

it is okay, I loved it when I first got into colognes. I think a really annoying part is how they took it in a winter smelling route when its called ocean

[@JamesBond-zd5jx]

I agrée. It gets better every time I wear it.

[@WeddingDocumentary]

The editor really botched this video

[@sameold5050]

And stretched it to over 25 minutes with nonsense.

[@jjdiaz486]

​@@sameold5050 😂😂😂

[@bootneylee9802]

ADG as CK Essence. By the Fireplace with GNTONIC image. Chanel with Sedley JESUS CHRIST!!😂

[@Lecream1]

Plot twist…the editor is the same director and producer lol a lataffa representative 😂

[@TurtleOriginal-j2k]

@@bootneylee9802why use the Lords name in vain? Jesus Christ died for us,man

[@adamjones5931]

How did Sauvage not make this list? Y'all crazy...

[@Victroll47]

It is not bad, it is just everyone seems to have it, specially ppl with 0 perfume knowledge

[@letterkeys4440]

overhyped isnt the same as overrated

[@saintofthemosthigh82]

Right?!

[@saintofthemosthigh82]

​@@letterkeys4440 and it's both of those lol

[@buiux]

i agree 100%

[@2160michael]

I agree with Acqua Di Gio. I'd also include TF Tobacco Vanille, and most of all...Xerjoff Alexandira II

[@byMRTNjournals]

Tobacco vanilla smells like raisins in an old dusty drawer

[@jeremyjackson8196]

PDM Layton

[@pallemaniac]

I've never understood how BR 540 became so popular. To me it just smells like band-aid. 😆 So interesting how different our noses work.

[@SenszR]

same

[@nikolaslaz3193]

As a Hawas fan boy,i have to say, Garrett Mercier,we are looking for you!

[@Det1911]

It's garbage I literally gave the bottle away

[@josq81]

10:45 PDM Sedley 😅

[@schneir5]

Paradise Garden overrated??? How?

[@mhassouneh]

I really hope not! I'm blind buying it tomorrow 🤞

[@BigDaddyDeek]

I think TikTok made it too famous but I honestly think it is second best JPG Parfum they ever made

[@michaelbullock8011]

Great video with some great choices in there and I enjoyed it and have a blessed day

[@01bigtrev]

Absolutely agree with acqua di Gio and whatever is happening with all the confusion. I’ve just ordered the parfum 2024 version. I’m so glad I never got the 2023 but who knows there might be another change. I’m still not entirely sure I’ve gone for the right one as I know a new Profumo/profondo? Has come out?

[@basilfabian05]

It's crazy that although Bleu De Chanel is the newer mens line from Chanel, the Allure Homme line gets more hype. To point that Chanel sees it doing better and it is enough for them to give the Allure Homme line a new flanker instead 😮

[@rano2613]

Rasasi, Hawas For Him is glorified domsetic cleaner scent. BR540 is masterpice. I wanted o hate it, then I bouth partial bottle and it's masterpices. I didn't were it so I sold it. But just yesterday I bought 200ml bottle this stuff is amazing. And none of tne clone can even hold the candle to it.

[@techforge-Nate]

Prada LRO EDT is such an awesome summer scent you can wear anywhere. The rest are arguably deserving for one reason or another.

[@travisn346]

Allure Homme Sport Eau Extreme is a top 5 designer of all time. Outside of BR540 and By the Fireplace, that's actually a solid lineup of respectable fragrances.

[@jusskitten9773]

I just tried layering Micheal Malul x Gent Scents EDGEWATER with CDMI today and it’s very nice. EDGEWATER actually smooths out the rough opening of CDMI and together on the dry down? heaven!

[@matthiasz.4485]

I really, really can't stand the smell of BR540. Its gives me a headache and makes me nauseous.

[@solsisod]

Don’t wear it

[@samueloguet7721]

Sameeeeee

[@matthiasz.4485]

@@solsisod I don't wear it. But you just smell it everywhere.

[@jeffyacks6864]

This list looks like a recent list from Chaosfragrance!

[@All_True_Especially_The_Lies]

I might have over 100 frags but still love EROS.

[@mattclark2655]

Eros edt and parfum are amazing. I cosign your message.

[@BZFOG]

I have over 100 fragrances as well, and Eros Parfum is the only one I own a backup bottle of. Will always be one I enjoy

[@BigDaddyDeek]

I have tried over 100 Parfums. Yet every single year in spring I buy Eros. I just hope one day performance will match the amazing smell. On my skin , lasts about 3-4 hours max

[@maicolll]

​@@BigDaddyDeekTry on your clothes yet? It lasts 8h+ for mem

[@TerrainJeremy3945]

Prada Ocean Edt is hated on and I dont get it. Its fantastic. I get lots of compliments from ladies and I love that fresh zingy bergamot along with the fresh iris and caramel. Its awesome. Overlooked by many because of YT reviews. Not me I aint overlookin, Im on my second 5 oz bottle baby..Lovin it. Aqua Di Gio line has became a mess i agree. It needs to end period. Sales are there its lived big for years now Come on Armani, I love you guys but come on we need a new line thats bigger and better. I wont buy any more Aqua Di Gio nope its over. Thanks ASh!

[@kerrynorth2968]

Not sure about anyone else but when I say synthetic when talking in a non positive way about fragrance it has nothing to do with natural vs non-natural, as I understand that most scents especially from designer houses are synthetic. For me when I say it smells synthetic I mean screechy usually harsh, abrasive and not pleasant as there is certainly a harsh synthetic and a pleasant synthetic for sure.

[@Dano_EightyEight]

I swore Angel's Share was going to be in this list.

[@bradymccoy2672]

I think the thing with angels share is that it really is accessible to basically everyone. in many areas its the only niche in sephoras, so people can easily get access to it. anyone can wear it, and it really does smell amazing.

[@phantomspaceman]

6:55 Armani CK One Essence? They should have left Profumo alone.

[@2008PrimeRonaldo7]

You better check By The Fireplace part again😂 some editing mistakes with picture and text

[@sameold5050]

Unbelievable this takes him over 25 minutes to wrap this up. 🙄

[@josecoronas8716]

What's the best aqua di gio? Now I'm confused

[@JamesBond-zd5jx]

Imo, none of them.

[@alexanderramirez8713]

Anyone have any idea when Eros Energy is supposed to come out. Everytime you search it, it just says Versace released it this year.

[@donaldtrump4206]

October

[@alexanderramirez8713]

@@donaldtrump4206 I've heard August. It's supposed to be a summer scent, are you sure about october?

[@freq18hz]

Please do another ADG ranking since they basically changed up their whole line for this year

[@mattclark2655]

I have the clone of by the fireside.. it has a pleasant twist.. smells like hennessy and maybe a splash of marshmallow.. i love that.. for $20.. but if the o.g. smells even MORE smokey.. no way id pay much for that.

[@SmellsAddicted]

Ash is advertising for Lacoste? 😱

[@gobybryant1001]

I’m liking the new Lacoste designs as well so idk if he is really “advertising” for them

[@SmellsAddicted]

I was only joking

[@CaysonLangham]

Not M Micallef gin tonic being shown in a clip about fall and winter, warm and sweet💀💀

[@MichiganJohn]

I agree AHSAE is really overrated and also miss represented. I see lots of people saying its a summer scent... its a spring fall scent to me at best and to me smells way outdated. The original Allure Homme Sport is more timeless to me.

[@gregconrad1894]

Agree with the last one (non-spoiler). I went on vacation to Thailand and it was everywhere, both male and female... in +90 degree heat. Overplayed.

[@Shadow2The]

No problem with anything on the list except maybe Y. Aventus should have been number 1.

[@troymoviemadness7130]

I was thinking about buying a prada cologn if i do which one do i buy ?

[@wisecoonie]

Prada l’Homme intense. Best in the Homme line and overall the best Prada fragrance.

[@troymoviemadness7130]

@@wisecoonie I meant to say prada luna which to buy

[@wisecoonie]

@@troymoviemadness7130 none. l’Homme intense way better than any LR for that matter 😂

[@mattclark2655]

Black... black.. and then buy black again. It's fire.. with that said.. im copping ocean as my second purchase from the house.. but its not touching black.

[@Trax17032]

Depends on what you want. Black is more of a fall / winter scent. For a year round scent, I'd say Carbon. I wouldn't buy Ocean though, any of them.

[@Richard-l3m]

BR 540 couldn’t agree more

[@jabr1076]

Br 540 is not overrated. It's a great smell. They just need to reduce the price. For an example, if naucatica has never been cloned, that's it mean that its a great fragrance? Grand soir is a simple blend but there are not so many clones out there! But once it being over cloned, would u say it overrated?? No, just reduce the price

[@scoot5642]

@@jabr1076why would they? that price and all of nyc wears it? they don’t need to reduce the price at all

[@blackcat6508]

Br540 is like Sauvage, they became victim to their succes but they still smell amazing and gather compliments left and right.

[@jabr1076]

@@scoot5642 well, thats fine. i have br 540 and al haramain amber rouge. the clone smells exactly the same but it projects better and better longevity! wayyy better than the original.. witch is a shame cause the clone is just a fraction of the price. Highway robbery by Br

[@misterelom]

Prada Luna Rosa Ocean is pretty much my out-the-shower fragrance. I like it but rarely wear it out the house anymore. I kinda think Eros Flame is overrated. I don't hate it but just never got the hype for it. I like the OG Eros EDT better even though I haven't reached for it in ages.

[@fredvissul759]

I was putting off going on the BR 540 band wagon, though i never smelled it. Just based on the notes and description and the hype made me want to be different and avoid it. But, i finally got myself a clone of it, Club de Nuit Untold. I didnt like it the first day that i smelled it. It was kind of what i expected, sweet and on the feminine side. But, i sat there and thought, well, i do have other sweet, partly feminine frags that i like, so why should i hate this one just for being somewhat feminine. C H Bad Boy Cobalt is sweet and somewhat feminine, and i love it. Lattafa AM Radio is also sweet & a little feminine, but i love it. So, finally, i decided that yes, Club de Nuit Untold was not too bad. I especially like the dry down, and not more than 3 sprays. I would not get the og BR 540 though.

[@AubreyfromOregon]

you haven't smelled it but you wouldn't recommend it? what kind of logic is that? you should try it before you make a judgment.

[@anthax1]

I didnt know Chanel Allure Homme Sport was called Parfums De Marly Sedley 10:45

[@SmellsAddicted]

I love By The Fireplace ❤ It is a perfect holiday scent to me.

[@Ryankam91]

I feel Paradise garden is only being mentioned because like every new JPG its bought up then sold in decanters for the first few months. Then tik tok fragrance sellers push it soo hard. It's an amazing fragrance

[@pkj77]

i´ll never pay the crazy over price almost every fragrance has gotten these days, Acqua di Gio line has me confused now, i lost track on what is what

[@g.d2450]

pdm Layton should have been on that list, i ended up selling off my bottle as that menthol note makes me feel nauseous and a lot of others don't like it also

[@wadimkrzyzaniak3767]

Curly said once in one of her videos that BR540 is basically a single molecule, just like ambroxan or other iso e super. Ash, can you somehow comment this statement?

[@JamesBond-zd5jx]

It’s more like 2 molecules. One is ethyl maltol and the other Iso E Super. Not hard to make.

[@murglasski]

Paradise Garden is really impressing me! A wonderful summertime scent!

[@Nater9-9]

Chanel Allure Homme Sport Eau Extreme is a masterpiece. The dude that suggested this needs help 😂

[@sasazivanovic777]

He's out of his f...... Mind !

[@mencantbewomen]

Dude is just mad he spent all the money on it and his mom didn't even toss him a compliment.

[@ecorona9552]

Before I watched, I expected any number of JPG frags on here. I got in a sample of Paradise and thought, eeew. It's a muddled mess of crayons, musk, and coconut. I was so disappointed. Other than Aventus and Allure, I agree with this list. Probably should have the entire 1 Million, JPG le male, and Armani Code lines on here. They all have this underlying scent of waffles and pancakes and Dr. Pepper, in the Code, IMHO. I don't wanna smell like breakfast and soda 😂.

[@professorlip]

I refuse to tolerate any CASHEE slander. 😑

[@mattgagnon5866]

I don't like 90% of men's fragrances (at least I wouldn't wear them) but I think that Y EDP is one of the best. I wear it a few times a month all year round. BR540 smells feminine to me. I understand why it is on this list.

[@wynonasbigbrowndragon6121]

Fierce is very meh. So are all of its similar ones. I have a bottle of Azzaro Sport, but I paid just over $20CAD for it. No way would I pay Abercrombie and Fitch prices for a smell so generic. Pleasant, but generic

[@letterkeys4440]

I blind bought percival and was initially disappointed - Its one of those scent profiles that grows on you for sure. Its fresh out the shower which allows it to be worn whenever and it garners tons of compliments which raises its prestige to me everytime

[@MrStrangerinthewind]

Can any clone house make a BO140?

[@DVinstapics]

I like BR 540, I like it a lot on women, but the purely insane amount of clone and inspired by fragrances out there made me simply roll my eyes when I smell it. 90% if frageances I smell outside on women are BR540 or it's clones and I'm tiiiired of it. That's why I like Armaf's Untold, it's different than most

[@hg.3318]

couldn't agree with you more. i live in NY, and is like every other person wears it, clone, no clone you name it, construction worker, grocery store worker. i'm so sick of it. i'll never purchase it again,

[@chimezieobiwulu1347]

I don't seem to be able to smell the untold

[@DVinstapics]

@@chimezieobiwulu1347 strange, I smell it easily and it laaaaaaasts. I mean my wife sprays it in the morning and when I got home in the evening I could still smell it

[@SmellsAddicted]

I prefer Luna Rossa Ocean EDP to BDC or Sauvage. It's not my favorite Luna Rossa, though. That is reserved for LR Black.

[@cheekster777]

Hey ash, thank you.

[@rickymemeti1826]

Was waiting for this 👏👏 absolutely will never wear these

[@jeffhoward9208]

By the fireplace is my clubbing signature scent...... Really nice, strong scent; 2-3 sprays lasts all night & into the next day. I don't like musky or overpowering colognes, this manages to not cross the line.

[@noahmoehogany]

Who edited this?

[@81mj]

I never smelled it, but a few months ago my brother blind bought BR540 because of the hype & was highly disappointed.

[@saintofthemosthigh82]

Yeah br 540 is just exhausting at this point lol

[@seanmcneil2903]

What is melow ?

[@mvr2579]

I don't like "fake" apple with geranium. Mostly near me. On someone else, it is fine. So YSL edp and Eros are a no go

[@sulleyd5702]

BR540 haters just mad its been cloned succesfully that much and thus very popular. Let's admit it: people who smell nice also hate when others smell like them. With BR540 being around this much it just means many people will stop using it just to avoid smelling like others. If BR540 was less popular y'all would jump on the train instead. (ok some BR540 clones are really bad, especially considering the nose-blind people oversrpaying it)

[@jersheybone]

Argos Baccio Immortale… got it, smelled it. Scared me away from trying any new fragrances ever again. 😖🤢

[@BonitoFlakes24]

To be fair… Sauvage uses natural bergamot in its opening and YSL Y edp uses apple, a pure synthetic note lol

[@Snedz496]

Aqua di Gio Parfum 2024 (Magnetic cap) is soo close to profumo that you wouldn't even be able to tell the difference if you didn't have them side by side 🔥

[@DemitriusMaximus]

What’s the best br540 clone. We need another video lol 😆

[@GucciButNotGuilty]

Al Haramain Amber Oud Rouge

[@OutOfMind43]

JPG for all 10 places, easy

[@scoot5642]

except le parfum. he can stay

[@bh7984]

Chanel Allure Homme Sport Superleggera is coming up 😆 GentScents is turning into Chaos (pub untended)

[@wisecoonie]

How van you call Prada Luna Rossa Ocean a “blue” fragrance? It’s not even remotely comparable to blue fragrances like Sauvage, BDC, Dylan Blue…

[@ezraspielvogel2972]

By the fire place is great with Rave now, it’s a super Smokey pineapple

[@desertfenton]

IMHO, overrated and over-hyped are two different things. BR540 is over-hyped, meaning extremely well known, and popular, and talked about, etc. and we’re just bored. Overrated means it does not deserve to have the following or accolades that it does. BR540 is NOT overrated - which is why it is over hyped. It is an incredibly beautiful scent and will be an all time classic. It’s just saturated the market - like Aventus - another one that we might be bored with, but that is not overrated.

[@jimmyvegas5208]

People seriously still consider Aventus "niche"? lol

[@tresmiller2933]

Currently, for me, it's Cedrat Boise. I know some love it, but it's not for me.

[@Alex-vi8ux]

Who the heck made this list. How can sauvage have not made that list.

[@neoNashShaggy]

Don't be harsh on the editor for the mistakes If only one guy is editing 20 minute videos every single day, he probably doesn't have a life with doing so many effects and transitions in Adobe Premiere and After Effects inside of the timeline Its just a hard task to do quality videos, which are 20 minutes long every single day, it comes with compromises Minimum 2 or 3 editors needed for so many videos with this lenght

[@richardspurgeon8954]

Michael malul added smoke to a similar dna, and i love it, Br540 to my nose should be a female fragrance

[@xAvi-PR]

“My friend will edit it for half the cost” 😂😂

[@en5om]

6:57 - GIORGIO ARMANI - CK ONE ESSENCE ?

[@Q_N-]

Couldn’t agree more with the 1st place 🤣

[@isnad07]

Mixed up many fragrances and their names. Time for an upgrade?

[@cristiancarmona1463]

I don’t agree with Allure eau Extreme at all.

[@BigDaddyDeek]

Bleu De Chenel is for me number 1. You can 100% find the same smelling parfum for like 15$ . Nothing unique , nothing even close that will blow anyone away. It doesn't smell bad , is the best compliment for this Parfum

[@mattpruitt442]

You should do an alexandria fragrances LV clone review. They seriously have the best and longest lasting dupes on the market.

[@widehardo2216]

Editor was for sure tweaking while editing this one lol

[@jesseman123]

I hate to say it... But after the first Acqua di Gio, all the flankers have been horrible in my opinion

[@danielsobi8419]

When you showed Chanel Allure Homme Sport the title in the bottom right corner said Pdm sedley

[@quietone1201]

I love br540… extrait.

[@mrsae2]

If memory serves Dylan Blue was originally held in higher regard than Eros..then overnight Eros became the one to have so I get what the he was saying ...nothing changed about the fragrance except marketing.

[@charlesgreene8883]

I agree with all ten, great job gentlemen!

[@franzhanz8945]

I'm confused about sauvage not being on that list.. Like fr.. 😁

[@TonyBarger]

I expected YSL Le Nuit De Lhomme (which is my favorite).