Response to 23 Questions - Part 47 - Pehli Wahi ka Waqia , Ghar e Hira - Javed Ahmed Ghamidi

[@GhamidiCIL]

GET THE APP To Ask Questions and Join Community Discussions! www.ghamidi.org/app

[@PATHANSIRCLASSROOM]

Ghamidi sahab ko Allah lambi umr de, mere dil ko itminan hota hai inki ilmi guftugu sunkar..

[@ghousemohd3110]

Jo bhee banda Dil se quran ke hidayat ku sahi samajhna chahta he Aur amal karna chahta he woh gamdi sab ku zaroor sunne.

[@nadeemshahid8003]

ماشااللہ بہت ھی زبردست

[@ghousemohd3110]

@@nadeemshahid8003 jazzakallah bhai

[@reyshaconsulting5550]

Wow, no words to describe my feeling of being educated on such a critical issue which has never caught our attention. May Allah bless Ghamidi saab and not to mention waiting for the next video and hope it comes sooner. Jazakallahu Khair!!

[@reyshaconsulting5550]

@@testsonysony8248 Brother you have to wait, also you are welcome to 'disagree' but do not abuse anyone. Everything is a point of view and nobody is telling you to agree, if you have a better argument then present it rather than slandering.. Its a sign of jahils. Thanks

[@sarangvision5533]

@@testsonysony8248 sabar kro waho b bta dea jayeega, jahil insaan , ye elm ke dunya ha , tery baabu k nah , qabroo ko sijdi krny , laanatee insaan,

[@hussain2805]

@@testsonysony8248 So you are asking the same people you have termed 'donkeys'....you are an absolute joker and a 'kid' in the room........don't bark, rather present your disagreement with evidence or just 🤫

[@smshafique9873]

@@reyshaconsulting5550 : Befitting answer !

[@umarssuet]

Wow bunyedain hiladin Ghamdi shab na aj. What an scholar Mashallah.

[@uzmaashfaq3536]

MashaAllah, In my opinion, He’s the most humble and polite Aalim of this era .,Nay Allah give him a long , healthy life n bless us with his knowledge n understanding of our deen . Ameen

[@humanbeing30]

No doubt sir you are Allah's rehmat on today's generation .🙋🏿‍♂️

[@shafikkhan6214]

He is. Alhamdulillahi rabbil Alameen ❤️

[@ahmedhassan6943]

What a scholar we are so lucky to have him amongst us may Allah protect and guard him in every way ameen

[@centric145]

So sad😭no Translation

[@AftabAlam-vl4iz]

I'm feeling blessed to understand the value of rationality and unbiased research. 📚📕📗📘 I'll try my level best to cascade this to my offspring.

[@zakaullahsarwar]

کروڑوں، لاکھوں اور اربوں سلام استاد محترم کے لئے ۔ اللہ تعالیٰ آپ سب پر اپنی بے شمار رحمتیں فرمائے ۔

[@AKayFiles]

Subhan Allah.; what a True revelation by his eminence Ghamdi sahib. Masha Allah.

[@maazahmed2438]

Rasool Allah (S.A.W.) ki nabowat ki shaan itni tehqeeq aur ghaur o fikar se bayan karnay par Allah apko ajar-e-azeem ata farmaye! Ameen! Thank you!

[@teea2987]

Allah jaza e khair ata farmae Javed Ahmed Ghamidi sahab ko ilm o aqal k dariche kholne aur Islam ko samajhne main hamari rehnumai k liye.

[@qurantafseerbymrsadnan2837]

Aslamoalakum ghamdi sahib aap kesy hn ??aap Allah k kitny kreeb hn k aap Qur'an ko melawat sy paak bian krty hn Allah ke rahmtain hoon ap pr ameen suma ameen

[@ghousemohd3110]

Ameen beshak

[@quest...6246]

جزاک اللہ۔ اللہ آپ پر اپنی رحمتیں نازل فرمائے آپ نے دل سے ایک بہت بڑا بوجھ اتار دیا ہے۔ پچھلی روایت جس میں رسول اللہ صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم کی گھبراہٹ اور ورقہ کئ پاس جانے کی بات کی تھی کبھی بھی مجھے اچھی نہیں لگی۔ وہ رسول اللہ صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم کے شان کے بلکل خلاف تھی۔ آج آپ نے جو تفصیل بیان کی ہے، اس سے دل کو بڑا اطمینان ہوا۔

[@G-raa-c2k]

Heard of this version for the first time in my life. Makes more sense to me. Being scared in presence of Allah or His messenger angel is really not believable especially for such a beloved Nabi . Thank you for bringing this in light .obliged sir.

[@Adept.maneuver]

Allahoakbar! Allah ne apko boht nawaza hai Ustaz Ghamidi sahab! Allah apko dunya o akhirat mei jaza de apke is amal ki jo ap aj k dour mei kr rae hain! Ameen

[@mohsinmyrs]

Jazakallahu Khair, I can only thank as this information was so detailed with such great analysis and all my life nobody even bothered to tell about this nor I had the curiosity to know more. May Allah help you.

[@malikaleem398]

Jazak Allah kher ...ustad e mohtaram is a man of dignity and extreme knowledge.

[@haideralisheikh5361]

100% proper chain bni hai pakki authentic yahi hai first wahi Jo ustaad ghamidi Sahab ne btae bht shukriya sir apka Ek Ek word samjh Aya h

[@Exploreworld-v3n]

Jitna jitna mai apko sunti hon meri islam k bary mai confusions km hoti hein ….meri khawaish hai k kabi is zindagi mai ap sy mil sakon

[@Umair_Linguistics]

May Allah bless you always sir

[@omarqadeer9935]

SubhanAllah....SubhanAllah.... I'm out of words and my eyes shed tears after listening the truth about the whole riwayat..... Allahu Akbar.... Alhumdulillah.... May Allah give Javed sahab huge reward for took the truth out of the fold. MashaAllah...

[@zafarkhan-oh3rf]

Indeed u r an eminent Islamic Scholar of all times... JazakAllah

[@AKayFiles]

Waiting anxiously ....

[@tahirabbasakhtar5451]

Thanks to Almighty Allah, we are blessed with this genius scholar.

[@muhammadaslamjavaidmalik3708]

Highly impressive style of Ustaad e mohtaram for the students like us! May Allah bless Ghamdi sb a long life! He is an asset of this Ummah! Seen is the second name of Taddabur and Ustaad e mohtaram described all episodes with all his grip. I always wait for new episode and enjoy quenching my thirst. Thanks Ghamdi sb and Hassan Bhai! Assalam o Alakum!

[@ambreenrafiq9719]

Great sir ap sochny per majboor kar dety hy great knowledge 👏 👍 👌

[@klacontactbackend7710]

Jazzak Allah ❤

[@reemanavida4146]

Host ka "Accha" kahna is so cute,,, today he said 4 times,,,,, very informative n interesting lecture,,, waiting anxiously for next telecast,, lots of respect from India

[@mubashirjutt785]

I think u have a crush on host

[@reemanavida4146]

Why not he is like my son,,, Allah bless him ,,,

[@mohammadjawaid5579]

Ghamdi tusi great ho Ma sha allah.allah ap ki hifazat farmai.

[@Exploreworld-v3n]

Gamidi sir is sadi k sb sy bary scholar hein a great researcher

[@ayshashahid2398]

Ghamdi Sahib is most humble, polite, scholar . He has taught us how to understand Quran and our Deen in most objective, rational manner. MashaAllah ❤

[@Mhasan9488]

جزاک اللہ محترم استاد غامدی صاحب و محمد حسن الیاس صاحب

[@mohammadayub4087]

JazakAllah janab ghamidi sb so invaluable description about our holy Prophet Muhammad e Arabi SAW

[@Grr_rrrr]

سبحان اللہ۔۔۔۔میری ناقص رائے میں ناموس اکبر کا مطلب سب سے بڑا نامہ بر یا سب سے بڑا پیغام رساں یا messenger in chief ہی ہو سکتا ہے۔

[@buttaurangzeb5412]

Javed ghamadi is just love it allah aap ko sehat aur tandrusti day all time great for me I don't think any other better prayer than this prayer allah qabool farmaey aameen aurangzeb butt from Switzerland daska sialkot siranwali ❤ ♥

[@MuhammadNawaz-lk8ug]

JazaakAllah khair. Please publish all this discussion in your monthly magazine "ISHRAAA" Lahore.

[@qasimjahangir6796]

بہت عمدہ استاد محترم

[@thelanguageguide]

Haza MIN FAZLI RABI... ALLAH AAP KO LAMBI UMER DAY... YE MAY AAJ FRIDAY KE DIN...RAMZAN KIEY MEHANAY MAY ALLAH DE DUA KARRAHA HOUN.. ..

[@r.mtubafathima4717]

Bismillahirrahmanirrahiim Assalamualykum ALLAH ki aap par rehmat ho 🤲🇸🇦

[@asififtekhar1411]

Eye opening session

[@shehzadshrif132]

اللہ غامدی صاحب کو سلامت رکھے۔بڑی شائستہ و شستہ زباں اور عام فہم انداز اور منکسرانہ لہجہ سبحان اللہ۔

[@mukhtiarahmedmukhtiarahmed8807]

Zabrdast Nice very beautiful ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️ ustajh ji

[@tabindakhan9860]

سبحان اللہ سبحان اللہ

[@imransafdar5]

Mashallah great explanation

[@akhtarkniazi]

واقعتاً علم بڑی نعمت ہے اور اللہ نے غامدی صاحب کو علم سے سرفراز کیا ہے۔ شکوک کی دھند چھٹ جاتی ہے جب ان کی باتیں سنتے ہیں۔

[@mukhtiarahmedmukhtiarahmed8807]

Allah Pak apko sallamt rakhye shaht tondrasti jaazayee kheir lambi Umar ata frmaye Aameen ya rabuollalameen jaazak Allah kheir

[@rehanmajid2115]

Outstanding explanation about takabul-e-hadees❤

[@sarangvision5533]

My teacher my love , sir Ghamdi sb

[@masaabsoha]

Kiya baat hai Sir Aap ki JazakAllah 🌷🌺🌹💐

[@muhammadsajidjavedkhan7577]

Best Regards & Respect for the Emam of this era

[@reflection5057]

Mubalagha! Even though I admire him a lot but to call him the Imam of this era is pure hero worship which he himself would not appreciate!

[@frstriker1098]

@@reflection5057 true, he is against all these exaggeration

[@funnypeople9508]

اللہ آپ کو جزائے خیر عطا فرمائے آمین

[@faisalsiddiqui1718]

Mashallah bohat khoob

[@woods123]

MashaAllah so nice explanation....

[@mohammadmoin1411]

Waiting with excitement..!!

[@misbahuddinpirzada3056]

Mashallah, my respectable teacher may God you live a long life with his great bless.

[@selfsculptingman8475]

Jazakallha Ghamidi Saheb

[@parveziqbal7607]

Assalamualaikum Ghamidi sahab and Hassan sahab Eagerly waiting for the finalization of your very much required "Hadees (Hadith) Project" especially in the form of Books.🤲

[@SurgeonSuhailAnwar]

Yet another amazing issue - through and critical appraisal of the literature

[@shaziasaher3557]

Mashallah jazakaAllah sir Speechless

[@zabitkhan2529]

God bless you sir, eagerly awaiting for next session...

[@madmax5756]

Jazakallah ustaz e mohtram❤

[@faisalmusic3566]

المورد کا مطلب تو پیاس بجھانا ہے تو یہاں تو پیاس بڑھا دی جاتی ہے ایک ہفتے کے لیے ۔۔۔۔۔اف۔۔۔۔۔۔۔ اب اگلی جمعرات تک پھر مجھے زندہ رہنے کی دعا مانگنی پڑے گی۔ یہ اتنی جلدی کیوں نششت پوری ہو جایا کرتی ہے۔

[@qurantafseerbymrsadnan2837]

Super such farmaia jitna sno utna km h allah say dua h k woh ghamdi sahab ke umar sehat aor iman ke slamte k sath draz kry ameen

[@meharbabu2606]

Alhadulillah very nice lecture

[@ilayatshah9079]

wow mind blowing analysis by the one and only living legend Ghamdi sahb. Mashaallah

[@Fatima-yp7in]

غامدی صاحب کی فہم و تدبر سے لبریز تحقیق سن کر یہ معلوم ہوتا ہیکہ جو مولوی حضرات غامدی صاحب پر یونہی کیچڑ اچھالتے ہیں انہوں نے محض سرسری طور پر اپنے نصاب تعلیم میں بخاری مسلم پڑھ لی ہے اور اسی کو علم کی معراج سمجھے بیٹھے ہیں انکا تحقیق سے پھر تحقیق میں بھی فہم و تدبر کرکے نتائج اخذ کرنے سے دور دور تک کوئی تعلق نہیں ہے بس بخاری مسلم کا سہارا لیکر عوام کو کنویں کا مینڈک بناکر انکو بھی تحقیقی مزاج سے عاری بنادیا ہے لیکن اب الحمدللہ ذرائع ابلاغ کی برکت سے عوام نے گھاس کھانا چھوڑ دیاہے اور ہمیں یقین ہے آنیوالا دور غامدی صاحب جیسے محققین کا ہوگا انشآءاللہ

[@naqibullah9658]

Bhut khoob. Ap nay bhut khubsoorat tabsara kia hay

[@sarangvision5533]

Yes , ofcourse, Mulvio ni kitaaby srf roob jmaany kely rakki hoe hoty , unko khud b pt nah hota , k esmi kia likka ha ,

[@outlanderr7448]

Mullan ne "ilhaad" ka rasta khool diya, aise jaise zaroo qitaar barish kai mah hoti rahe, Shayad Gamdi jaise loog humein is Barish se bahir nikalne ka rasta dikha rahe hein.

[@ElectronicInPashto]

Apni zandagi men pehli dafa men kisi mzhabi aalim se mutasir hua.. Ghamdi sab is the...I have no words to praise him..

[@gmdssss12341]

Subhan Allah...

[@ElectronicInPashto]

Subhanallah Subhanallah Subhanallah...Great scholar..

[@mominmehmood8795]

Mashallah, bohut umda, aankhein khol dene wali guftugu ki hai Ghamdi sahab ne, jazakallah. mera aik ilmi sawal hai: Muhaddiseen ke iss usool se hum waqif hain ke woh sanad ke saath saath Quran o sunnat aur ilm o akal ki roshni mein bhi rawayat ko parakhte hain. agar Imam Bhukhari ke samne dono rawayatein mojud thein tou unhon ne Ibn-e-Shahab ki rawayat ko ibn-e-hasham par tarjeeh kyun di? kya ibn-e-hasham ki yeh rawayat, kisi muhaddis qubool ki hai? Guzarish hai Hassan Ilyas bhai se, agar ho sake tou aap agli nishist mein ghamdi sahab se yeh sawal pouch lein. Jazakallah.

[@ihsanyousaf1160]

اسلام وعلیکم غامدی صاحب اھم جگہ پر بحث جاری ہے

[@asifraza8124]

For me new information, Well explained by Jawaid Ghamdi

[@mohammadayubhussain6694]

Sub han Allah.

[@NajamTameem29]

واہ غامدی صاحب۔ بہت اچھے طریقے سے بیان فرمایا۔۔بات بالکل واضح ہو گئی۔۔۔قرآن کے بیان سے بھی بالکل عین مطابق۔۔ لیکن مجھے ایک اشکال ہے۔۔ پہلی وحی کے اترنے کا واقعہ حضرت خدیجہ رضی اللہ تعالی عنہا سے منقول ہونا چاہیے تھا۔ حضرت عائشہ تو اس وقت بہت چھوٹی تھیں۔؟؟ واللہ و اعلم

[@sarangvision5533]

Yes good observation

[@zakaullahsarwar]

There is a long wait.

[@mohammadjawaid5579]

Great scholar in this era.

[@shahidafwan1102]

Very interesting

[@majidaziz6178]

ماشاء اللہ

[@pupilofghamidi5842]

Mind opening۔۔۔۔۔

[@Dany_writes]

Amazing scholarly work

[@shakeelkhan-rg8tp]

Allhumdulliha sir Thank you very much Allhumdulliha

[@geoschool5533]

ہم بہت خوش نصیب ہیں کہ ہم دور غامدی میں جی رہے ہیں

[@AhmedRaza-gq3je]

بلاشبہ غامدی صاحب امت مسلمہ کے اس وقت کے بڑے علماء میں سے ہیں بلکہ غامدی صاحب کا موازنہ امام ابو حنیفہ، امام مالک اور امام شافعی سے کیا جا سکتا ہے۔ الیکٹرانک میڈیا کا شکر گزار ہونا چاہئے کہ اس وقت کے امام سے ہم بھی سیکھ پا رہے ہیں۔

[@salmanisar2469]

Different view . no doubt ghamdi csahb you presented true picture of wahee .Allah bless you

[@WaqarAhmad-sy1uq]

پہلی سورہ سورۃ الفاتحہ ہے،،!

[@outlanderr7448]

I am considering to become muslim once again, jab taak wahi ku na samjh liya jay.. Quran ka "khuda ki taraf se nona" possible hi nahi. Blind believe is nothig cause it can bring you no where,, i not only doubt islam but jst forget it and learn about Hinduism, Budhism, all but abrahmic traditions. Magar gamdi sab ki baat se lag raha hy ke how "quran" is revealed by creator. Conciously understanding can hold one,s feet so firmly that even whole world cnt move. Thanks to Gamdi for his noble work.

[@NeverCurseTheTime]

Allahu Akbar!

[@shankykhan5577]

mashallah

[@shujatalirana796]

Great sir Allah app ko jazzy khair day

[@AbdulHafeez-cq6oo]

wahhhh Mashallah

[@alamkhan-lr8qt]

Can’t wait to hear the next SubhanAllah Please also comment on why old concept got famous in ummah

[@akmal.Tararr]

MASHALLAH

[@AftabAhmed-od4vb]

سر جی تسی گریٹ او۔۔ ۔۔۔۔۔۔۔

[@designaids]

Eye opening lecture Quick question or rather request if Ghamdi sb. can also bring it in discussion that by the time Bukhari was launched both of these two versions of same event were already reported and only one version (second) sounds authentic by its contents then why Bukhari didn't consider to report both versions if not only the second version?

[@wajeehasajjad5204]

Mashallah Mashallah

[@imrankatti]

Assalamo alaikum @ Sir Ghamidi! ‘Ru’ya e Sadiqa’, is needed to be explained exclusively Jazakumullaho khairan w ihsanul jaza

[@shabirkamran5399]

Ghamdi Shaib Always very logical, backed up by books.

[@fareehasaleemi9403]

excellent

[@irshadumerfarooq7901]

Mashallah

[@englishtopashtotranslation6834]

I am speechless