CONVERSING ISLAM with Hamza Ali Abbasi - Episode - 4

[@GhamidiCIL]

GET THE APP To Ask Questions and Join Community Discussions! www.ghamidi.org/app

[@yaserhasan3639]

Why is this poem not in mainstream Pakistani media. I know people in Pakistani are not ready for this but there is no better time

[@abdullahazzam5000]

You are very good student Allah ham sabko Sach talash karne ki salahiyat se nawaze ❤Amin

[@creativehead6388]

Everytime... Each and every time when I listen to u guys.... I am just amazed.... U r doing excellent excellent excellent excellent excellent work.......

[@shabnamshafique355]

I m watching all this discussions almost non stop this is so interesting..... Coz almost i hd the same questions to b answerd...really enjoying the discussion👍👍

[@misshumii]

Very beautiful poem ma sha ALLAH keep up the good work may Allah bless uh always. Allah talah humsabko sahi raah pr chlne ki toufeek de or hidayt de.. Aameen

[@khalidhassan5218]

Love the conversation so beautiful open and easy to understand jazakAllah.

[@hashirmurtaza6292]

Waqie ghamidi sab nay yay seekhaya hy k ikhtelaf k bawajood mohabbat kiesay kurni hy... r yay k deen seekhna kiesay hy..good farhan bhaii

[@nuzhatsher9305]

Bohat atcha lg rha bht se swalon k jwab mil rhey hn.

[@muhammadsiddique3975]

Ma sha Allah. Stay blessed.

[@JavedIqbal-vi7qh]

Two comments: (i) Standard of conversation and level of contents are excellent. (ii) Hamza Ali Abbasi speaks more than speakers.

[@kubrab2617]

Allah talah kamyab kare aap sab ko..

[@DanishHayatDani]

بالکل بھائی!!! ماشااللہ بہت اچھی کوشش ہے۔ یہی بات دعوت و تبلیغ میں اللہ کے راستے میں نکال کے سمجھائ جا تی ہے کہ سب سے پہلے مسلمان اپنے نفس کی اصلاح خود کریں اور پھر غیر مسلمان خود ہی اسلام اور مسلمانوں کی زندگی کی طرف کھچے چلے آئیں گے۔

[@ilayatshah9079]

What a fruitful discussion Mashaallaaah. Loving each part of it

[@abdulrazaq6908]

Good conversation for new generations Allah will you jaza

[@nusratara4034]

It is a universal message of peace . Good job

[@sidryan363]

I was about to be an athiest and was about the to declare this officially... But you guys are answering questions that I was almost kicked outside mosque for asking... Behavior needa to be changed else we will be the most people leaving Islam...

[@nawabali5368]

The poem excellently reflected the current religious thoughts crisis Amazing

[@ligerbomb7991]

Very good series Masha'Allah

[@zeeshansadiq5680]

A great effort guyz. The presence of Hamza and Farhan Bhai is a symbol that counter argument is knocking on the door and it will open inshallah one day.Allah bless you👍⁦♥️⁩

[@abimhd4513]

Keep it up Hamza and Ilyas. You guys are doing great! Hamza yaar tu beech main baat na kata kar thora sabr karliya kar kuch nahi hota hum baag nahi rahay we are here to listen lol

[@MrOracle01]

Excellent initiative. One suggestion going forward, please keep discussion on topic.

[@jessedarling9505]

SO Interesting 👍👍👍👍👍👍

[@zeeshanshaikh4968]

Mashallah it's True, i literally Heart touching Poem, Heartly❤ Thanks to #Hamza ali bhai & Ghamidi islamic Centre Team.👍🏻💐🌹

[@13sidd79]

Please add subtitles to this! ✨ My mom is Pakistani and she really enjoys your information and discussions but I can only understand basic Urdu and I would really like to know more! Thank you!! ✨

[@fsaiyed]

All of this series in now available with English subtitles. Hope you can understand it more now. JazakAllah

[@iamrandom1]

Very good effort MashAllah

[@hashirmurtaza6292]

Excellent sessions

[@seemanad4]

Excellent

[@kharlsiddique9294]

Allah bless you

[@MasoodKhan-cx5zw]

MashAllah

[@asfaahmed2725]

Surah AL Ahzab 33rd chapter verses 73 pages 418 to 427

[@ridudragneel219]

Very good talk

[@zumanazerin4194]

Please add subtitles. Many people are interested but are missing out.

[@fsaiyed]

Done!

[@extordcars6794]

Gr8

[@syedrahim694]

ماشاء اللہ ❤️ Learned alot from your podcasts.. Need more intelligent and intellectuals to be included in your group. Best wishes ♥

[@lovehumanity1815]

Very nice effort....

[@syedarshadali8351]

حمزہ بیٹا آپ سے گزارش ھیکہ اس منفرد نظم کا کلپ علیحدہ سے بنا کر یو ٹیوب پر ڈالیں اور اسکا واٹس ایپ کلپ بھی نشر کریں ۔ شکریہ اگر یہ موجود ھے تو مجھے ارسال کر دیں مہربانی سے

[@dinoor55]

MashaAllah great job, as how to understand simple and self explainitory Quran, unbiased Note, Volume is too low ???

[@arkk0907]

As salaam alaikum Do you have a separate video of the poetry recited? Thanks

[@iqramryam7899]

I have a question!! Jese k apne btaya k nabi sirf Allah ka paigham de k chale jatay hain. Lekin rasool k through Allah ki adalat ka aik namona dunya me show kravte hain. Tu hazrat noah (AS) or bki saray anbiyan jin qomon pe azaab aye? Wo rasool tu nai thy? Lekin unho ki qomon pe bhi azaab aa k aik akhrat ka namona pesh kiya gya. I'm a little confused in this?

[@jim1117]

brother Jinka aap naam liye hai wo rasool hi the .

[@tahirhassnain820]

❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@devpulsetechnologies]

السلام علیکم میرا سوال یہ ہے کہ سنت متواترہ ہونے کے لیے کتنے افراد کا بات کو نقل کرنا ضروری ہے.؟ جب ایک شخص نقل کرے تو خبر واحد یا حدیث 2 شخص نقل کریں تو پھر کیا حیثیت ہو گی.. 10 صحابہ نقل کریں تو پھر کیا ہو گی. کس تعداد پہ جا کر وہ عملی تواتر کا درجہ پائے گا... میری مخلصانہ گزارش ہے کے حسن بھائی میرے اس ذہنی کشمکش کے معاملہ میں مدد فرما دیجئے.. جزاکاللہ

[@fsaiyed]

سنت متواترہ کہتے ہی اسے ہیں جس میں کسی گنتی کی ضرورت ہی نہیں پڑتی اور نہ کسی سند کی۔ اگر کسی بات کو دس پانچ لوگ نقل کر رہے ہیں اور اس کی سند یں متعین ہو رہی ہیں تو وہ سنت متواترہ ہو ہی نہیں سکتی۔ وہ اخبارِ احاد ہے۔ سنت سند کی محتاج نہیں ہوتی، اسے پوری کی پوری نسل منتقل کرتی ہے۔

[@shabnamshafique355]

Excellent effort Amazing ,interesting n helpful discussion to understand the last msg of Allah I m a writter n a debater if u ppl need my help in these areas I m always ready It will be an honour fr me to join this ghamdi centre. 😊

[@pashteen8348]

Yeah did the same.. In a one go i watch the whole series.... It almost clear all the misconceptions that we had for years

[@ranaabdulhanan1992]

Same...میرا خیال ہے ان کے سننے والے رائیٹرز اور ڈبیٹرز زیادہ ہے

[@sophosalpha]

The whole problem lies in Ghamidi's views. He is a modernist who tries to explain Islam in an apologetic way to fit the modern secular liberal feminist paradigm. Islam is an absolute truth and we need not compromise on any of it whatsoever. In order to understand how some people today understand islam from a liberal perspective, we need to deconstruct liberalism. Liberalism is a modern project whose philosophy can not be proven from first principles. To get a better picture of how liberalism warps some people's understanding of Islam, I suggest you to listen to Brother Daniel Haqiqatjou and Mohammad Hijab. I request you to bring brother Daniel Haqiqatjou and Mohammad Hijab to speak on Liberalism and modernist apologetic understandings of Ghamidi

[@smarteye4249]

@@sophosalpha the form n shape of prevalent Islam, which is more of a medieval jurisprudential discourse, should be more apologetic to the world. Contemporary Muslims are curse and menace to the world. We have inflicted damage to the intellectual n logical discourse of Human species'. We have inflicted physical damage to the world, we have no contribution for the comfort n prosperity of world n Humanity. Whatever contemporary Molvis n medieval jurisprudential teachers have taught n preached in the name of Islam can be anything but not the religion from the creator of this universe. It's illogical, nonsense phonetical, Hateful and disgusting. May God reward Ghamidi for his efforts to cleanse Islam from false traditions.

[@anwarhusain1952]

Hamza Ali agar beech beech me zyada toka taki kam kare to ................... ...................,..?

[@syedzeenat4452]

To Iska Matlab ki jese abhi wo rasulallah SAW or hazrat Ayesha RAA ki shadi ke upar jo live TV pe like unki insult ki gayi thi uske chalte jo log naare lagarhe the ki "gustakh e rasul ki ek hi saza, sar tan se juda " Wo galat tha ?

[@DanishHayatDani]

اور اسلام کو سیکھنے اور پھیلانے کے لیے ہمیشہ یہ کام Volunteers ہی کرتے ہیں۔ صحابہ کرام سے لے کر اور اب تک جہاں جہاں خلوص سے دین کی محنت ہو رہی ہے وہ ہر کوئی Voluntarily ہی کر رہا ہے۔ تبلیغی جماعت میں لوگ لاکھوں روپے لگا کے ایک ایک سال کے بیرون ممالک ساری دنیا میں اپنی جان، اپنا مال اور اپنا وقت لے کر جاتے ہیں جس میں سب سے اہم اپنا تزکیہ نفس ہے۔

[@IqbalArifUtman]

Indeed an excellent effort, but a humble request @iamhamzaabbasi at times speaks more than required, likewise his interpretation and "outta of the context" and control laughing distract, and spoil the overall sense and spirit of the program.... Looking forward to your response

[@asimayyubi397]

Learn to be patient with people. Everyone is on a journey. Not everyone is on the station you might be on.

[@iZeeshan]

غامدی صاحب کو بھی شامل‌ کرو بھائی ایک بار

[@sarfarazjaliawala3626]

Very well explained mashaallah but i want to ask about the wars and expansion during the era of hazrat umar (ra) as he was not rasool furthermore if we categorize the world there are two genres 1) Zalim and 2) Mazloom, we muslim ummah is mazloom (palestine, kashmir, syria, yemen, iraq and uyghurs etc). How can we peacefully preach seeing our sisters getting raped and our getting our children killed? I am very confused 🤔

[@akifinignite3391]

Ghamidi sahab kahan hain

[@mha8252]

Achi discussion hai . pr meri aak guzarish hai. Islam apna taa'ruf "Deen" kah kr krata hai. Is'hey baar baar "maz'hab" kahne se confusion ka ande'sha ho sakta hai kiu k "mazhab" ka word islami literature me kisi ki khas mazhabi fiqr, interpretation k lie bola jata hai; e.g. hanfi mazhab , shaafai mazhab wagera, yaa duser'ey mazaa'hib k sath as a common name k tor pr bolney k lie bhi istemal hota hai,, mager jab specifically islam apne mash'mu'laat k sath zair-e-bahs ho , to "Deen" bolna zada behter hai.

[@ullahzia879]

Paris FRANCE 🇫🇷 ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤J'AIME BIEN ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@abubakar8863]

Hazrat rasool sw k baad jo shabi hzt abubakar, hzt umer unka aml kya tha? Wo tho islam or quran ko aapse zyada samjhtey honge unhone kya Kiya markat, zabardasti muslman banana Ghulam londi banana...or 40 saal k ander hi imam Hussain ko shaheed kar diya? Wo kyu nhi samjh sake wo sab batey jo aap aaj 2020 me samjha rhey ho 😊

[@dr.tayyabamjad5882]

Although you have made it very clear in this video that you do not intend to make a new sect, but still, its not in your control to stop people from perceiving Ghamidi's point of view as a new sect. As an example of this, I recently saw a video made by traditional molvis saying Ghamidi as a new sect. And as per my humble opinion, this would happen more in future because unfortunately for many people it is easier to tag you as a new sect rather than understanding and accepting your narrative. An important point to consider here is most of the sects we see today, the founders of those school of thoughts never intended to make a new sect, however, the followers do that. Therefore, in an attempt to avoid such misintrepretations, I humbly request you to please do not use Ghamidi sahab's name in any of institutions and projects. You gave the example of Allama Iqbal and Quaid e Azam universities. Well, those are the unanimous heroes of the nation. No one could publically disagree with this. On the other hand, Ghamidi sahab sadly have a large number of (publically speaking) haters. Therefore, considering these harsh realities, you need to be very careful whenever you use Ghamidi sahab's name. Other than changing the name of institute, you also need to clarify the issue in your future videos again and again that you're not laying the foundation of a new sect. You really need to do this repetitively. Thank you

[@asimayyubi397]

It is not possible to cure all patients. There will be many who will die of illness.

[@dr.tayyabamjad5882]

Another point regarding the same issue: You said Ghamidi sahab strongly opposed the idea of using his name for the institute. This is because Ghamidi sahab already knows the long-term consequences of it. On the contrary, you still used his name to give him respect according to you. Well I'm sorry to say that this is not respect. If you had respect for him, you would have obeyed him. Now, even though he is apparently agreed with your decision, but this is still an undesirable thing for him. If you don't believe me, please ask him once..

[@fsaiyed]

I humbly disagree with your point of view and even if I agreed, changing the name of the institution is not an option now. It is not easy to change names. People who raise this point saying it will create a new sect, do not really understand the dynamics of how sects get created. Sects are based on schools of fiqhs not on the names of people who interpret religious thought. There is no sect called Ghazalwi or Shah Wali ullahwi, or maududvi, etc. Ghamidi sahab is not a faqih, his work is on the whole religious interpretation. By the way, Ghamidi sahab opposed it in his humbleness not because he disagrees with the initiative principally, he agrees to the principle and ideology behind naming such institutions after someone. We can not do anything against his principles. Maulana Maududi himself inaugurated an institute named after himself in Lahore, no one raised this point that it will create a separate sect. Therefore I believe that saying naming an institution after someone may create a new sect is completely baseless.

[@asifiqbal5258]

I don't think it is prevalant view point in Islam to establish khalafat .India second most muslim population in world selected India to be their home for example.

[@hashirmurtaza6292]

Sacrificing souls. May allah reward all of them

[@sophosalpha]

The whole problem lies in Ghamidi's views. He is a modernist who tries to explain Islam in an apologetic way to fit the modern secular liberal feminist paradigm. Islam is an absolute truth and we need not compromise on any of it whatsoever. In order to understand how some people today understand islam from a liberal perspective, we need to deconstruct liberalism. Liberalism is a modern project whose philosophy can not be proven from first principles. To get a better picture of how liberalism warps some people's understanding of Islam, I suggest you to listen to Brother Daniel Haqiqatjou and Mohammad Hijab. I request you to bring brother Daniel Haqiqatjou and Mohammad Hijab to speak on Liberalism and modernist apologetic understandings of Ghamidi

[@sadafsherwani605]

You are nots ping us boring