Waqia KARBALA Ka Tareekhi Pasmanzar - Part 4 - Javed Ahmed Ghamidi

[@GhamidiCIL]

GET THE APP To Ask Questions and Join Community Discussions! www.ghamidi.org/app

[@ahmadzafar3948]

Hazrat Ali (A.S) ki khalafat or un ki khalafat ki jangain os ko kis nazar se dekha jay ga q k os waqat Hazarat Muawiya (R.A) to govoerner e sham ty? Or kya Hazarat Ali (A.S) ki khalafat ko baki khulfa ki khalafat he ki nazar se dekha jay ga ya nai?

[@amanoallah5911]

خلفائے راشدین نے حضرت علی کے دور تک یہ روایت عملی طور پر ڈال دی تھی اور اقتدار پرامن طور پر منتقل ہوتا آرہا تھا،مذہبی حیثیت شخصیت اور تقوی کے معیارات پر جانچے بغیر صرف سیاسی حیثیت سے دیکھا جائے تو اس اصول کو اپنانا چاہئے تھا اور اقتدار کو اصولوں پر فوقیت نہیں دینی چاہیئے تھی،غامدی صاحب سے اختلاف کرتا ہوں

[@ameenkamboh6645]

Sw at

[@baba747baba2]

طلقا۔ کیسے صحابہ ھو سکتے ھیں ؟؟؟؟

[@abdulsamad5903]

Us waqt decision making localized thi kun ke centre ka order dur daraz tek ponchanay ka koi modern system mojud nahi tha..

[@zeeshansarfraz6951]

لکھتے لکھتے قلم ختم ہو جائے گی مگر پیارے رسول صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم کی تعریف کبھی ختم نہیں ہوگی

[@Shagird-e-Ghamidi]

شُکر اُس رَب کا کہ جس نے مُجھ ناچیز کو استادِ محترم غامدی صاحب جیسی عظیم نعمت سے نوازا! 😍 💕

[@SufiNamaa]

دل خوش کر دیا اس شیعت کے پر فتن دور میں جہاں عوام کو پرزور انداز سے شیعت پہ مائل کیا جا رہا ہے، کوئی تو سچ بولنے کی جرات رکھتا ہے۔ غامدی صاحب آپ کو سلام!

[@ShabnumAli-s7v]

بہت ہی بہترین تجزیہ ، واقعہ کربلا پر زندگی میں پہلی بار کسی عالم دین سے صحیح صورت حال پر روشنی ڈالتے ڈاکتے ہوئے دیکھا ، نہیں تو پچھلے ساٹھ سال سے وہی جزباتی تقاریر دونوں طرف کے مکاتب فکر کے علماء کرام سے سننے کو ملتی تھیں ۔

[@quez]

Until we don't neutralize our mind, it's hard to listen and Ghamidi sb is an example of an amazing listener and mubaligh. Allah bless him

[@irfanahmedmaznani8380]

Quran ko nezon pe uthane walon se log itna inspire hen!!! Quran hume sub cheez sikhata he ku phr siyasat he ho per iss tariky ki siyasat ki talwar jo haq ka gala kaaty aur jaabir ko zinda rakhe!! Astagfirullah

[@ogamiyashin2036]

کیا بات ہے جناب سُبحان اللہ،آپ نے کس طرح اور کتنی خوبصورتی سے مسئلے کو سمجھایا کہ آپ ہی اس طرح سے سمجھا سکتے تھے۔جس میں عقل و شعور ھوگا وہی سمجھ سکتا ہے۔آپ واقعی ایک باشعور عالم ہیں۔

[@politicalbakwaas5872]

he has endorsed the principal of Might is right which shows his mediocrity

[@rf4061]

بار بار سنا بار بار سنا اور اس نتیجے پر پہنچے کہ اس دانا انسان نے اپنے ھر ھر لفظ میں موتی پرو دئیے ،اتنا خوبصورت تجزیہ واہ واہ سبحان اللہ واقعی عقل و خرد کسی کی میراث نہیں ھے

[@jilanivlogs4718]

Brilliant and pure analysis now my mind is 100 percent clear about tragedy of karbala this explanation is acceptable for every muslim and forget stupidity of firqa parasti and become unite. That is why I always say that GHAMIDI SAHIB IS THE IMAM E WAQT. Peer Bakhsh Dahri from DADU SINDH PAKISTAN

[@iZeeshan]

علم کی دنیا،جذبات کی دنیا نہیں ہوتی۔۔ بہترین تجزیہ

[@syedtousifrazaraza410]

Only labbaik ya Ali labbaik ya hussain labbaik ya hussain labbaik ya hussain labbaik ya hussain

[@mustafaalikhanpathankhan1596]

Bhut hi umada treqey se apne jaber hukumranao ko un k jurm se bari kiya hai .great scholar

[@ahrar25]

Though i am an admirer of Maulana Ishaq and Engineer Ali Mirza, one can easily take a guess how much we people are pissed when some gives commendations to Muwaiyah and his son. But i must accept given the ground realities and geopolitics of that particular time.. Ghamidi Sir is absolutely right. Brilliant scholarly analysis

[@miqbalkhan2014]

Agreed with the openion of Ghamdi sb.

[@tanzilurrehman7450]

Ghamdi sab your approach is best.

[@zeeshanali-yu8jp]

Allah may bless Ghamdi Sb and give him health and long life. I find no other Islamic scholar who explain things so logically and is so rational. And who doesn't do emotional exploitation.

[@Ayra_fatima2]

I agree with u.and always there is proper explanation. Unfortunately muslims cannot digest this truth...

[@riazahmed-gf8qm]

Personally I stand beside Ghamidi Sahib.

[@areh3756]

انتہائی جامع اور معلوماتی ۔ شکریہ غامدی صاحب

[@riazurrahmananwer1972]

Sir ghamdi sb you are GREAT thinker and analyser. Hifzak allah. مدرسوں میں پڑھے ھوٸے کوزے میں بند دماغ والے بونے یہ سمجھ پاٸیں گے۔

[@asimqureshi173]

ابے او کسی گٹر کی پیداٸش ، ہر عملی میدان میں تجھے مدرسے والے ہی نظر آٸیں گے افغانستان اس کی تازہ مثال ہے ،صرف باتیں چودنے سے بچہ پیدا نہیں ہوتا ، لوڑو

[@ihsanahmedwains]

Jizzak Allah Ustaz e Mohtaram ❤️

[@amiriqbal3145]

إِنَّا لِلَّٰهِ وَإِنَّا إِلَيْهِ رَاجِعُون اچھا تھا آپ چپ ہی رہتے !!!!

[@qasimjahangir5308]

Kamal k zavia nazr ma sha allah ustaaz muhtaram

[@nasreensiddiqui3107]

غامدیصاحب نے بہت کچھ سوچنے پر مجبور کر دیا جزاک اللہ خیرا کثیرا

[@rf4061]

یہ ایک اتنا خوبصورت نقطہ نظر ھے کہ اللہ کی قسم عقل سلیم نے چیخ چیخ کر اس کی تائید کی کہ یہی سچ ھے اتنا logical اور categorical تجزیہ کرنے پر اس دانا انسان کو مبارک باد

[@AbidHussain-lo9oo]

آج کا فیصلہیعنی آپ کی ھجرت کا واقعہ آنے والے زمانے کے مفکرین کی نظر میں بہترین اور اعلی سیاست اور تلوار کا فیصلہ قرار پائے گی ۔

[@mohammaddar4773]

بہت آدب و احترام کے ساتھ۔ آپ سے اختلاف ہے ہزاروں صحابہ کی موجودگی میں یزید کی نامزدگی اسلامی اصولوں کے خلاف ورزی تھی

[@baatuni11]

bhai woh kab mana kar rahe hain??? woh bata rahe hain ke talwar ne faisla kia tha is liye logon ne khamoshi se manne main hi aafiyat samjhi

[@bigboss8575]

وہ بھی یہ کہہ رہے ہیں کہ جب زور آجاتا ہے تو تدبیر کے پرخچے آڑ جاتے ہیں ۔۔

[@ayaanferoz6045]

ایک دیانت دار انسان کے تجزیہ کا با معنی نتجہ یہ ہی بنتا ہے

[@syedatifhussainin]

Bohot khoob ustad Ghamdi shb. As you said someplace..... The greatest gift that the West has given to us humanity is that it has taught the world a method of peaceful transfer of power. Respect 🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@kaytube1010]

Concept of Peaceful transfer of power originates from the concept of Democracy and Democracy is an Islamic concept. A king handing over his power to his son is not peaceful transfer of power, it's just a change of name. West succeeded in devicing a method to implement democracy because of the progress of technology, without technology also a method could have been device, it didn't happen though, but it's not the fault of Islam.

[@aabidjungclasses3654]

Love u ghamdi sir From Kashmir....

[@jariabatool1262]

We r very lucky to have a scholar like Ghamdi sahab

[@usamaahmed6526]

Zabrdast Ghamdi sahab Jazak Allah

[@kavinbruch1115]

امدی صاحب نے بڑی ہی خوبصورتی سے اسلامی حکومتوں کی طریقہ اقتدار منتقلی پر بحث کی غامدی صاحب کی ہر بات سے اتفاق ہے تاریخی اور علمی لحاظ سے بالکل درست منظر کشی کی گئی ہے مگر ہزار لعنت ہے اُس شخص کی حکومت پر اور اُس شخص پر جس نے نواسہ رسول کو شہد کیا .

[@aamirali891]

Never had a such an analytical views; full respect Ghamdi sb .

[@noorulislam5266]

The great scholar and freedom fighter Molana ubaid ullah sindhi analysed this issue in similar way very before

[@abdulhayemanais7652]

مولانا سندھی کی کتاب کہاں سے مل سکتی ہے؟ محترم جاوید غامدی نے بھی انکی کتب کا مطالعہ ضرور کیا ہوگا.

[@getevennow]

Incredible wisdom of the ages and clarity of mind

[@irfansayed414]

This is, indeed, an extraordinary discourse. Now, I realize that some people are upset; and naturally so because of the sensitive nature of the incident. Without going into needless theorizing, I will simply state that Javed Ghamdi Saheb has merely tried to develop an academic framework for analysing the Karbala incident. Hopefully, this can provide the underpinnings for resolving some major differences within the Ummah. Mind you, towards the end Ghamdi Sb does acknowledge that he is not trying to justify who was on the path of 'haq' and who wasn't. Of course, Imam Hussain (AS) was on 'haq.' While his caravan approached Kufa, he was advised by acquaintances not to proceed further since the people of Kufa had retracted from their allegiance. Had the Imam been incited by the 'politics' he would have surely receded. But, being the grandson of the Holy Prophet, he preferred the option of martyrdom. The 'heroes of Karbala' will survive till eternity. YAZEED, on the other hand, will be cursed forever. Unfortunately, Mawia (RA) will fall on the wrong side of history!

[@xaltideinvader]

Totally wrong

[@mamir2713]

nabi k hukam ko mane ya taqeek ko mane sab se afzal hukam e rasool he

[@syedshakeelabbas4764]

Ap ke is bian ney mere nazdeek ap ke ilmi qabliat per sawalia nishan laga dia, mazid ilm hasil karen aur Allah sey madad mangey.

[@bigboss8575]

ایسے عالم کو سمجھنے کیلئے، عقل اور حافظہ کا معیار بھی تھوڑا اونچے درجے کا ہونا لازمی ہے ، ۔

[@taimurahmad8430]

نسل پرست

[@asifnazir60]

بہت شکریہ جناب غامدی صاحب دراصل ہماری تحقیق پر ہمیشہ جذبات ہی غالب رھے ھیں۔ بقول اقبال آئین نو سے ڈرنا طرزِ کہن پہ اڑنا منزل یہی کٹھن ہے قوموں کی زندگی میں

[@ADH2516]

اتنا خوبصورتی کے ساتھ سمجھایا ہے آپ نے جزاک اللہ خیر اللہ تعالی آپ کو بابرکت اور عزت والی زندگی عطا فرمائے

[@tahmeenamufti127]

Very well explained.

[@imranAlam-rp7qk]

Respected Ghamdi Sahib, you have described the incident of Karbala from a political point of view. As a Muslim, keep in mind the religious point of view as well.

[@abdulqadir-nd3ek]

Sir what is religious in the episode of Karbala? Pl enlighten

[@lh.yazdani6653]

کربلا ایک خالص سیاسی اور باغیانہ کارروائی کے ذریعے حکومت پر قابض ھونے کی کوشش تھی۔اس کو مذہب کا رنگ خود حسین نے بھی نہیں دیا۔ان کی کسی تقریر سے نہیں لگتا کہ وہ کوئی دینی ایجنڈا لیکر عراق جارہے تھے۔ان کا مسلم بن عقیل کو حالات کا جایزہ لینے بھیجنا،کوفیوں کے خطوط کے جواب میں بنو امیہ کے خلاف پلان ترتیب دینا اور حج کو بیچ میں چھوڑ کر روانہ ھوجانا سب کچھ سیاسی عمل تھا۔امام حسین کی کاروائی میں صرف بسم اللہ پڑھنا اور لکھنا دینی کام تھا باقی ساری کاروائی سیکیولر سیاسی کام تھا

[@roomanhamza7170]

@@abdulqadir-nd3ek eng lol

[@mujtabaali6431]

Very different and innovative approach, worth noting. This type of debate is necessary in Muslim community

[@angelmikael1555]

khoob mgy bohat psand ai guftgo apki❤

[@seemaimdad369]

Allah,s systems are different which is nomination by Allah and his prophets announce it and people have to accept the Allah,s decisions then sword is not the answer

[@khalidshai4575]

Ghamdii sahab you are the best

[@qamaramin5506]

Kamaal analysis

[@Adeelhaider01]

Yes, from a political point of view as ghamidi sb said to consider ground realities, the analysis made it clears so many things. Keeping our religeous attachments and pre assumptions aside if we look at it historically we may not get distracted. I personally feel digging deep into the matter debating who was on haq or on batil, it will keep us divided.

[@ahmadmanj]

Hassan sb, Few questions hopefully you can raise them in the next session. Treaty between Hassan R.A & Muawiyah R.A stipulated that Muawiah will not appoint an heir after him and decision should go to (for lack of a better word) a council. Ghamidi sb kept re-iterating there wasn’t a succession process in place had that been in place outcome would have been different. 1- There was a succession process and that succession process elected Ali R.A. 2- Muwayiah R.A. rebelled and refused to accept legitimate orders from an elected. Ghamidi sb also didn’t mention RasulAllah’s prophecy about death of Ammar bin Yasser. Just a final note -It seems that Ghamidi sb thinks (based on where he left the conversation) what happened to Hussain R.A was called for (since he rebelled in-front of an authority that prevailed through sword) my question here is if you don’t see a problem with Muawiya R.A rebellion, why don’t you apply the same spectrum Hussain R.A? Did Muawiyah/Yazeed not violate the treaty they made with Hassan R.A? Also this seems like a very week argument since other empires around that time had a hereditary Monarchy system it was okay for Muawiyah R.A. to opt for the same system. Shouldn’t the Sahabi of his stature be the first to introduce a system based on Quran, rather then going completely opposite of it? Wasn’t his decision in direct contradiction of a Quranic order? No question about effectiveness of Umayyad dynasty and it’s capabilities, but it’s still tainted with blood of Hussain R.A. (same way U.S gave the world a lot of things, but it doesn’t excuse the fact with it did to Native Americans and early blacks) If being ruthless is what Ghamidi sb consider effective, then perhaps we should stop condemning China too. I have learned so much from Ghamidi sb, and I wouldn’t be lying if I said that he practically brought me back when I almost left Islam. But the argument he provided for his opinion isn’t up to his on stature. I really hope you can raise these questions to him and hopefully he can respond to these in the next session

[@hashamkhan9517]

no thewre was nothing in treatry not to apoint heir by muawiyah and hassan . have you any sahih sanad for ha. it was lster addition to vdefame muawiyah. weven no one objected muawiyah you are breeaking treaty with hasan . they objected it is not right to appoint your son successor.the did not even raied isue of hasan treaty because in that it was not mentioned to not to apoint heir...

[@shorts.area_924]

Well raised questions.

[@ahmadmanj]

hasham Khan in this case Muawiya R.A violated a direct Quranic order by appointing an heir.

[@yasirali9824]

Agree

[@zenda40]

@@hashamkhan9517 What were the points of treaty between Hasan and Muawiya?

[@muhammadazam7141]

A upright scholar ,Mr javeed Ghamdi ,understanding of island

[@izharahmed1660]

A very good description of early islamic history and a very good advice to the muslims dont become a judge for matters among sahaba;they were the most pious pple ever witnessed.let Allah decide whats right and wrong on the judgement day.

[@humangreatly9693]

No doudt about that but the books and prophets train of them came to give the Godly laws so that everyone is accountable and yes humans are not perfect and perfect judgment day is the final day . And who ever is talking about sahabas isnt there is an surah or ayt in the book that says the PUNISHMENT is doubled for even the phrohets family and half for the slaves . So becare ful of what you say.

[@syedellias5730]

Very good analysis of Ghamidi saheb on pre Islamic history.... Kaun haq per hai kaun bathil per hai nahi maloom... Magar Thalwar ke Zor per Sulthanath chali...

[@jamilkhan715]

Excellent. His view point should be considered the ultimate truth. Every right thinking person will agree with him. Wish him all the best and pray for his long life.

[@akhtaradil5586]

Outstanding explanation

[@abdulgaffargoolamfareed7633]

What happened was not (in my humble understanding) as a result of perceived lack of a "workable" system. On the contrary the rebellion was to PREVENT the system from being implemented. As was proven later beyond any shadow of doubt by muawiyah's ra own statements and his violation of most of the treaty with Hassan ra. To be continued

[@kd.9631]

True scholar.

[@asimnaz148]

No one has ever discussed that issue with such an approach which more logical and impartial

[@mohammedamir0809]

V smart v v v smart without going in any kind of controversy Mr Ghanmdi produced some facts and figures But its v big but that in any kind of circumstances you can't forget who is standing on the other End

[@umairalikhan47]

The way he explained the scenario behind it is exceptional amazing work gahmidi sb you truly are an Allama

[@saleemahmad5811]

Zabardasht tajziya kiya ghamdi.sb.sochne.samjhne.ka.tariqa.bata.diya.jaza.kallah.kher.

[@shahbaz2k]

Wow that is what is called a scholarly explanation!!

[@shahanarizvi1008]

Apney deen ke doshmano ka jo itna favor karey osey aap scholar kehtey hain?

[@shahbaz2k]

I think you misunderstood my comment and his explanation’s context. He gave a historical perspective of the era’s events devoid of the religious context. He reiterated it many times that he isn’t addressing right vs wrong, for now at least.

[@shahanarizvi1008]

Shahbaz H. That is called slow poisoning

[@AliHaider-hy9sh]

@@shahanarizvi1008 Jazbati logo ko ilam o daleel kaha gawara ha???

[@raanimughal8405]

@@shahanarizvi1008 Deen k dushman kehne se pehle tahqeeq kijie plz...ye fesla Hzrat Hassan ne qabool kr Lia tha..

[@mehmoodchughtai7689]

Jazakallah o Khaira Excellent

[@fazalhakeem1910]

Behtareeeeeeen sir...

[@gillzadi2196]

مومن وہی ہے جو حق اور باطل میں فرق کرے۔

[@MuhammadUsman-tn6bi]

Great ghamdi sahab u changed my opinion what a scholarly explanation

[@homeadress3071]

Kia bat hai ghamdy sahib kounsey dastori rawait aik tarif nawasa rasool houn aur dosery tarif aik sahaby ka baita yeh kahan ka insaff hai key jis ko mano jisey itaat wajib ho agar ussey kay khailaf uth kharay houn tou khazoor yeh gunah kabeer hai

[@salimahmad7414]

Janab Ghamidy Saheb is absolutely right. We have to keep emotions at bay while going through HISTORY.

[@alinawazkhan984]

Very good

[@khawajaarif3743]

اللہ تعالیٰ ان کو صحت والی زندگی عطا فرمائے آمین

[@salmanisar2469]

شبیر صاحب مذہبی پس منظر میں نہ دیکھئے ۔حضرت معاویہ بہترین انسان تھے ۔20 سال کامیابی سے ریاستی و ملکی امور چلائے مگر جب اقتدار منتقلی کا موقعہ آیا تو اسوقت آس پاس کے ممالک مین یہی طریقہ رائج تھا ملوکیت ۔اتنی بڑی ریاست کا نظم و نسق چلانے کے لیے کوئی دستور یا آئیں موجود نہیں تھا۔لہذا جو ہو رہا تھا انہوں نے بھی وہی کیا اب انکا بیٹا کس حد تک اقتدار کی ہوس مین چلا جائے گس کو معلوم ہوتا تو اتنی بدترین صورت نہ ہوتی ۔

[@Flower-kx4qe]

ahlebait a.s ne kabhi zalim ka sath nahi diya tha👍

[@salimahmad7414]

What an excellence, What an excellence, What an excellence. Listened this part from end to end. And, I don't have words to commend. It's really remarkable.

[@politicalbakwaas5872]

no, he is wrong in accepting might is right

[@sachkasath9439]

Very nice sir

[@haroonbaig5674]

Despite differences wd Ghamidi sahab...excellent analysis.

[@gohar606]

Asslam o alykum, us hadid Ka Kia kry jis my Likha hy k Hazrat Ammar ki shadat ak baghi grow kry ga. Ammar un ko jannat ki traf bolay gy or so grow un ko dozak ki traf bolay gy.

[@haroonbaig5674]

Here i mean da political analyzse is excellnt not other thngs.

[@Mir-Chakar-Baloch]

Allah apko lambi zindagi de. Ustad Ghamidi. Bhot kuch sekha hai aap se.

[@IrfanAhmad-xy7wd]

very very well said

[@zulfiqarrajput6163]

میں آ پ کی رائے سے سو فیصد اتفاق کرتا ہوں،

[@rf4061]

واقعی یہ ایک منفرد approach ھے ، اور اتنی منفرد کہ عقل سلیم نے چیخ چیخ کر اس کی تائید کی

[@AmjadRashaid]

Nice sir

[@letstalk6280]

a very different point of view......but the very satisfying point of view

[@mukhtiarahmedmukhtiarahmed8807]

Masha Allah Allah Pak apko jaazayee kheir shaht tondrasti ata frmaye aameen jaazak Allah kheir

[@remedify3633]

🌹Brillient analysis 🌹

[@user-kj2tt8ce9m]

Karbala ka waqiya muslmanon ki deeny pasty zahar kerta hai

[@talibeilm3049]

Ajeeb daleel di hai aaql se nehayat door hai. Inhone sawal ko pahle apne frame work mein fit kiya aur phir jawab diya. Sach baat nahin kahi. Inka apna frame hi ghalat hai. Agar jang e uhad mein kuffar jeet jate to yh bhai sahab unke sath khade rahte k talwar ne faisla kr diya. Magar chunk rasool jeet gaye to ab unke saath hain. Yani haq, batil, sahi ghalat in k nazdeek kuch nahin. Jo tareekh mein fateh hoga yh unke saath honge. Doosra sawall uthta hai k kya Islam ilahi mazhab nahin hai? Kya Islam mukkamal deen nahin hai? Dono ka jawab hai "ilahi deen hai aur Mukammal bhi hai to phir Islam mein iqtedar ki muntaqli ka Jo usool pesh kiya gaya kya woh qabil aml kyun nahin tha in ki nazar mein ? Yh sahab kah rahe hain k nahin tha. To kya yh sahab Islam ko adhoora aur aibdaar system man rahe hain? Agar nahin to jinhone is ilahi nezam ko disturb karne k liye talwar uthai yh unke supporter hain. Yhahi mantaqui nateeja hai. I strongly disagree with his analysis.

[@MuhammadRizwan-wf8zz]

متفق

[@slahuddin7442]

Very nice great

[@naseemsoherwardy2534]

Very practical approach. Thanks for giving correct view

[@asadaman5163]

good effort Ghamdi sahib

[@umerriaznawab9320]

بہت خوب جناب بری شدت سے اس نشست کا انتظار تھا

[@adnanawan4783]

Keep in continued, it is a different way of looking at the sanea e Karbala

[@mushtaqhussain1688]

Sayed ki zat Sirf or sirf Ahlebait hain or koi nahi ho sakta.. .

[@historyliterature3611]

سیدنا عمر رضی اللہ نے انتخاب خلیفہ کے لئے ایک کمیٹی بنا کر دستوری روایت قائم کی تھی۔

[@mubasherahmad7557]

Very well described and well defrenciat religious and political perspective and aspect with an extremely positive approach.

[@mudasirbashir5736]

Breathtaking intellectuality

[@hammadarshad5981]

So true may Allah bless him

[@larryjhon1482]

Very good anylasis of that time

[@sairaqureshi8470]

It’s amazing. This is called a genine research

[@tabasumsha7035]

Main aqal or ilm ki banyad par aap se ikhtlaaf karta hon

[@Azhar3400]

very wrong off the topic dialogue , the programme is based on wrong Question? how does this Question answers/justify the Zulm of Yazeed or Shahadat of Imam Hussain(AS)?

[@Kalia7347]

Yes ur right main nai beh jitni video deakheen hain un main sawaal ka jawab nahi diya

[@irfanghulamnabi6875]

Good good good

[@pirbux4535]

Truly the Lord of scholars the Legend Ustaad Ghamidi Sahib others have to learn from Ustaad IMAM

[@Ayan_quraishi]

i agree with gamidi sahab

[@aounabbas8970]

Ghamdi sb on one side u give an utmost importance towards the Holy Quran and Narrations of Holy Prophet(PBUH).However, while arguing ur opinion on this sensitive matter u r ignoring the predictions of Holy Prophet(PBUH).No doubt u r one of the greatest scholar of ongoing era but u have no right to intermingle the facts with ur self created arguments.By giving these arguments u r challenging the authority of Prophet sayings.

[@syedmohsin_555]

@Noorul Hasan khan Listen how an Ahl e hadees scholar has challenged the credibility of Hadees e Amaar: 1. kzbin.info/www/bejne/lYmQoqqlf6qrfsk 2. kzbin.info/www/bejne/rJDSi3mBbt6mgKs 3. kzbin.info/www/bejne/gGHEgmqaer2MpNk Agr yehi kaam Ghamidi sahab krty tou kehny walay unko Munker e hadees keh dete.

[@munirahmedal-munir7495]

مختلف اور منفرد اور تاریخی حقائق کی روشنی میں ایک مدلل تبصرہ ہے۔۔۔۔

[@alibashir5897]

غامدی صاحب پہلے میں آپ کو نہیں سنتا تھا کیونکہ کچھ لوگوں نے آپ کے خلاف غلط باتیں پھیلائی تھیں۔ لیکن آپ تو بہت بڑے عالم ہیں۔ ماشااللہ

[@rf4061]

محترم غامدی صاحب،،آپ کے logic اتنے خوبصورت اور perfect ھیں کہ بے اختیار دل سے نکلا کہ غامدی واقعتا ایک بہت بڑا دانا اور wiseman ھے اور ان کے ھر ھر لفظ میں موتی پروئے گئے اور عقل سلیم نے واہ واہ کرکے اسے تسلیم کیا