Ghostface reveals all the Stu Macher clues in the Scream franchise | Popcorn Theory

[@sistapam]

Great video!!! A lot of time and effort went into this and it shows. And thanks for the little shout out 😊 Stu lives!

[@nERDbOX_official]

Thanks for watching, how have you been?

[@stevester9148]

*Stu explaining his plans to the new duo or group of ghostfaces every time:* ''So then you do a dramatic reveal, state your motives, pretend to have killed people I actually did, then you get killed, take the fall, and I move to the next batch of psychos who want to work with me. All good?''

[@nERDbOX_official]

🤣🤣🤣

[@mbuszka5295]

Probably in other words: To Nancy: You dropped Billy - lets REWRITE IT, so You can meet again! ❤️ To Mickey: I know, Nancy paid You already, but THOSE DAYS YOU GOTTA HAVE A SEQUEL. ❤ To Roman: I still don't believe, BILLY suppoused to listen to You, when You show him tape. And this "scapegoat" BS... But lets feed Your ego and I will tell You details of our spree and let You do my house set. ✌️ To Jill: *flirt online, then ask about date with Sidney, so she SNAPS.* To Charlie: *online - how to impress girl in STAB fangroup. To Amber: *You live in MY HOUSE! Pay respect.Also, You wanted dead guy comming back, huh?* To Richie: *I got cool concept movie and leaks on 1996 true events. Remaking STAB!* To Baileys: - To Ethan: *Don't You wanna daddy to love You like Richie?* - To Quinn: *I heard, You like Stu. I can also tell You some facts about his kills.* - Wayne: lets kids tell dad Halfway joke, but he never will tell anyone, he is himself, of course.

[@NeroBorgata26]

@@nERDbOX_officialor Stu could’ve been like, “I’ll bank your real life Stab movie that you want to make, then when your done you help me make a sequel” but of course they always lose and die and Stu is onto the next one…

[@NotoriousJ20]

This maybe the greatest Scream theory I have ever watched

[@nERDbOX_official]

Thank you for watching

[@rxndofficial]

This is hands down the best video I've seen on KZbin in a long time. Entertaining all the way through. 🔥 Stu 🔥

[@nERDbOX_official]

Thank you for watching

[@Paylo_Cash]

Yeah I agree I watched one a year back about who killed who but this makes alot of sense to me tho

[@azsolar5168]

Definitely missed a few Stu Clues like the call Gail gets being from a Woodsboro phone number but pretty good overall.

[@nERDbOX_official]

Thanks for calling it out & thanks for watching

[@chocolateice24]

I believe Stu and Jill are alive consider they both wasn't shot in the head was originally gonna come back in Scream 3 and 5 and will most likely come back as partners in Scream 7💯💯💯

[@nERDbOX_official]

The #s are low, but people have survived those gunshots to the chest

[@yinyangphoenix]

@@nERDbOX_official It was almost dead in the heart and anything within a few inches of the heart would probably rupture it. It would be technically within the head shot rule but it would not be realistic and this franchise is built on its realism. They’re not bringing back Jill. At least, I hope not.

[@asterix1912]

0:29 nERD bOX, behind you. Behind you nERD bOX, turn around. Behind youuuu

[@nERDbOX_official]

🤣🤣🤣 my dog attacked him the first time he came at me with a knife

[@asterix1912]

@nERDbOX_official 😂

[@thomasclark3098]

A Major clue is the fact every killer since the third has been obsessed with making a movie out of the circumstances of the murders just like Stu was obsessed with making a sequel.. the only exception was mrs Loomis and Mickey altieri

[@gay_ghostface]

You know what also makes sense since 3. Is the police station scene where Sidney gets a phone call from Ghostface. She says the person is dead. And the person recalls her being a friend. Stu?

[@johncap6495]

Stu just wants empress Billy read my theory above you see what I think

[@devilghostface8798]

Jill wasn't intersted in a movie either

[@thomasclark3098]

@@devilghostface8798 Jill no, but her partner Charlie was .

[@AllisonM90]

​@@devilghostface8798No but she wanted the fame Sidney has had.

[@shamon85]

loved this

[@nERDbOX_official]

Thank you

[@alx-vn8gs]

There is one other Stu clue, which is the drawing of Dewey Riley’s corpse; this is another drawing that was likely not sketched by Richie Kirsch. Remember, shortly after Dewey was killed, Richie, Sam, and Tara left the hospital, heading to Modesto. They ended up at Amber Freeman’s house, which was the location of the final act, which Richie was killed in. Therefore, Richie would not have had time in which to sketch this drawing. Furthermore, at the time of Dewey’s murder, Richie had already gotten into the elevator, along with Sam and Tara, so he did not even see Dewey’s corpse. Therefore, the drawing in question was likely sketched by Stu.

[@nERDbOX_official]

Excellent catch

[@azsolar5168]

I don't think Stu was the ghostface that attacked Tara, I think that was Amber, Amber is very slashy and not very efficient as evidenced by Tara surviving and her other attacks in the movie. There also could've been 2 ghostfaces in that Tara scene, maybe Stu was there, but if he was there, it almost seems like he was toying with Tara and then maybe Amber just failed at finishing the job. But I definitely think Stu was the one on the phone. He say too many things that indicate he's older and not of Tara's generation. I think Stu has only been attacking legacy characters and he does it during times when he has his followers killing people so he can slip in & out undetected.

[@nERDbOX_official]

If I remover Stu from the equation, you are right. It was Amber. She has a killing style. Letting the knife drop into her hand into a downward stabbing position

[@dragonballradiant2744]

Then why isn’t Amber’s shoulder, and neck injured. From the door being slammed on her.

[@NeroBorgata26]

When it comes to Tara in the opening of the fifth film, and then the security code to the door locks being opened and closed, I always thought that it was actually probably her mother on the property with ghost face

[@name4195]

About the height in Scream 4. Emma is 5’2 but she actually wore 7-inch boots when playing Jill, so the character is probably 5’9 in universe.

[@nERDbOX_official]

Oh my god, that is insane!

[@name4195]

@@nERDbOX_official Yeah, it’s really cool since it shows that Wes cared about making sure the actors are at least close to the height of the stuntman unlike Radio Silence that straight up said they don’t care if the actors are like a foot shorter and to just ignore the height inconsistencies.

[@newkoviak]

This is the kind of video Ghostface would upload to push a narrative

[@nERDbOX_official]

🤣🤣🤣

[@Dhampire1976]

Fun fact: Stu was considered and planned to be the Ghostface for scream 3,but several script changes and plot adjustments got rid of this. So the concept is out there and even referenced in scream 5 but I doubt they'll do it so late in the series, especially for a joke character

[@nERDbOX_official]

Well, Columbine happened

[@Jim222001]

Funny that in Scream groups on FB. So many people worship Roman and act like Billy & Stu were crap. No one still talks about who killed who Scream 3. Scream 1 and its characters people still talk about the most. Scream 3 doesn’t even have what makes the others fun. You know who killed everyone, Roman.

[@nERDbOX_official]

Scream 3 is ranked 5th for me, but if Angelina cones back as Christina, they could make that movie be 1 of the most important films in the franchise.

[@Climinator-op6kh]

Also, when you think about it, Jill is the only Ghostface to achieve her goal even in death. Remember she was a narcissistic type and wanted fame therefore she would’ve been uploading videos of her and Charlie’s murders to the dark side of the internet. Stu loves fame so he could’ve mentored her into this or might be the leader of one of the sites that Jill was a member of.

[@nERDbOX_official]

I loved her motive & I thought she was one of the best!!

[@Jim222001]

It’s interesting and all but Billy’s Mom definitely killed Randy. She even says it was her. Since he bad mouthed Billy.

[@nERDbOX_official]

Yeah, but I can combat saying that there have been many killers in real life who claimed kills they didn't do

[@nightbreed16]

Surprise Sidney!

[@nERDbOX_official]

Great line

[@johncap6495]

If I was writing 7 can use any actors I wanted the ending would be Angelina death fake in 3( looked so fake) plus she wore outfit in woods and supermarket calling during the party while Billy and Stu were busy Stu was preparing to be ghost face so maybe he didn’t make calls… Now I worked in politics in court system… I saw cases fixed and elections in real life… now Stu’s rich parents are rich they easily could pay off town… he said my parents will be so mad at me.. so like good boy he stayed in hiding…NOW going into 5 Stu parents are getting old ready die and he read about Scream 4 getting him hungry again… he has nephew killed and soon his sister too get all his family money… this the cult he got Richie and Amber and two killers in 6…( plus still has Angelina who went school with them only thing I forget to mention… Stu killed Dewey… now after his cult is killed off other then Angelina he continues to hide during six because Bailey family is cop and Kirby… ghostface said in 6 I don’t care about movies… Stu would never say that… So my full circle ending… Stu has been calling Sam driving her nuts since no doctor will help her making visions of Billy more potent… in the grand finale ghostface starts saying things that only people alive in part one would know So naturally this turns Sidney and Gale into fighting each other not trusting her cause only Gale and Sid heard lines.. this only thing that breaks our hero Sidney Plus no other ghostface really ask the trivia or talk on the phone like part one… So in reveal Sam and Stu reveal themselves.. Sam mirrors the pyscko part.. she believes she Billy like Norman Thought he was mother… Billy is the true father of ghostface.. Roman was only a son… Stu energy on fire cause he was so obsessed with Billy abd let’s admit casting Melissa was great choice her and Billy got the same eyes and they never lie.. Stu off to races since they lovers on top of it.., and seeing man and woman stabbing one another may even be the only reveal to ever top the original Then Sidney kicks everyone a$$ Hope ya love that mr ghost face😊

[@nERDbOX_official]

I love it.... after part 5, I was thinking we were going this route. Stu would have returned in 6 to go after Sam, killing Tara at one point. In our finale, we would see Stu square off with Billy. Yes Billy, Sam would have a full mental break after Tara's death & would allow Billy's identity to take control & for their final showdown, we would see a monolog where Billy is arguing with Stu in certain flashes. Sam would win & she would then go after Sidney in 7, to end the franchise.

[@johncap6495]

@@nERDbOX_official I like that our Stu yeah baby they become lovers and Angelina is still around some Jill and Romain fan said v this entire theory stupid cause Roman bench’s 400 I’m like I did in real life too there no way in hell he could do all that alone. Especially the blonde in room. She was on phone while he was in their. she was on the phone with him and he was on the phone with her. Also when ghostface used lines from the original movie Sidney and Gale start fighting cause they are only ones left alive And footage she planned she could find in box she forget to watch it cause of how everything went down. It shows Stu parents paying Woodsboro officials off to say document his death I worked for city of Philadelphia I saw elections fixed as well as court cases so yea that happens all time very META But Stu had a thang for Billy too. Picture him abd Sam lovers but she’s Billy then they stab each other abd Angelina involved for dramatic effete sge could bee ghost face in bathroom the woods super market etc I told craven I thought they were making two movies he made video didn’t say why he thought that. Only you and Darren from STL podcast mentioned my name Also remember Stu cried about his parents so he obeyed and stayed in hiding with Angelina had help Billy with the hembry and drew Barrymore three people hang her and she called get gang out the house And he had his nephew and maybe sister killed to so he can get his family money We don’t need a cult this brings everything full circle and it may actually be as good as part one. No reveal toped the first and Mickey was my number 3 they could do prequel on him alone cause he was killing people

[@nERDbOX_official]

@johncap6495 love it

[@mbuszka5295]

There is also elephant in a room, that nobody ever adress, even if probably was as big influence on Stu and his blunt misogynistic lifestyle and believes, as Nancy was on Billy. And this is Leslie Macher, Vince's mother, role in Stu being Stu we know - attention needy, constantly bored, fun obsessed killer, who believes, everything is a game. I thought WHY they portraited Schneider SO TERRIBLY? As Macher family, suppousedly rich guy from "good home", he ends being just...sleezeball. 🤔 And reaction of 5th movie kids shows, unlike Loomis, Macher's name got not black famed. And Leslie is suppoused to be RICH. If making audience feel sympathy, especially if someone murdered is connected to Legacy...WHY Vince is everything BUT THAT? Is Leslie at time neglectful mother, like her own parents? Does they carry stamp of being Machers...but THEN, WHY LESLIE STAYS AROUND TOWN her parents left, as Vince is around? Is it possible, that Vince death could be Stu's REVENGE on Leslie for leaving him, no matter himself(as originally this scene was BRUTAL AF), or through his 'believers', when he got occassion? 🤔 Just...EVERYTHING around Stu is portraited negative and EVERYTHING around Billy is almost dry sucked. It is too big of a coincidence. If I was, like You said, writing SCREAM 7, I would make Leslie and her "better son", Ghostfaces...then in final, she talk, like she take revenge for Vince, because Sid and people connected to her took her EVERYTHING money, name, family(as husband left her after Vince was killed) and even son... and Stu comes out from behind her, stabbing her to amplify symbolism of it, in the back, saying, she forgot to mention HIM. Take off mask, while still holding Leslie at a knife, shocking everyone as Stu says, Leslie, she never introduced him his newphews and as one died(never admitting he was behind it), he made effort to reach other and comes out, they share opinion, that Leslie as mother SUCKS. As Leslie took care of Stu, when being older sister, I believe she is to him of Judith Mayers importance. So, almost like mother, she is "root of his evil", like in HALLOWEEN. And he probably felt it just as harsh, as Billy with Nancy, when she left him in his opinion, alone. But he got no Moreen to blame, so he projected on his flings. Then they hanged out with Billy, created "Guess how I am gonna die?!" game and created Ghostface, each of them seeking with projected hate for women, that can't be trusted, because in fact that what most Williamson SCREAM is about. 😉 So Stu manipulating newphew, who tells Leslie, that she never loved Vince, as she never loved anyone, siding with Stu, while Stu smiles saying dramatically "Rest in peace, Judith Myers." and gutting her in front of everyone, who are too stunned to react. Sid vs Stu is for me very needed for serie conclusion, but Stu vs "his Judith", aka Leslie, that is epithome of neglectful, selfish and dowright "blond bimbo bossy girl"(aka ironically Stu's type of chick, probably taking roots in just exactly her constantly ignoring him and his need to prove himself to her - killing her being symbol of letting go of that need), as I imagine, is as needed. 🤔

[@johncap6495]

@ I don’t think Sidney or Gale would care about his sister why didn’t we hear that in one either. Sidney/ Gale only ones left I think if they hear certain lines and they do trivia which they rarely do in others. I think it break Sid into thinking Gales behind it. And it may throw them off into arguing which each other that’s why I think by this point nobody Sydney is too strong psycho logical way to care about Leslie since she never met her that’s the only difference I think but if ghost face says I always had a thing for you said and like different things still saying like yeah Baby even in the ghost face Voice that’s gonna get her like all thinking like what the hell is going on and plus it looks like you seen a ghost said that was that line till it’s all for a full circle but unless they bring Melissa Barrera back we’re not gonna get that whole ending it would really be cool if like they just like lied about it and really had her because that she would be under the mask the whole time until the finale. Maybe still want a sister or two killers and Angelina is his girlfriend because somebody had a hot Roman Park three there’s no way and Wes Craven filling it that way it was too over the top for one guy to pull that off especially when Jenny McCarthy gets cold because she’s in the roping room with all the girls faces on the phone with him so she would’ve heard them talking

[@mindlessamusement7095]

OH SHET!!!!......the "your dead".....was always taken aa a threat.....but it was a statement of presumed fact.....sydney always thought stu died....but she surprised he isnt....🤯🤯

[@nERDbOX_official]

🤷‍♂️

[@JediKryze]

Stu didn’t figure out Randy’s “secret”… Randy confided he had interest in Sidney. Stu possibly being alive is no huge secret or item worth noting. Facts better support Det. Kincaid is Sids actual half brother and o.g. Ghost face responsible for pushing Stu and Billy.

[@nERDbOX_official]

Kincaid her half brother?

[@disclaimer.imjokin]

Scream 7 writers are 1000% taking from this video.. i bet they have contacted you and youll be credited

[@nERDbOX_official]

It would be awesome if they did, we laid out it all out

[@tylerdean42]

This is fun speculation but the ghostface height difference doesn’t work. We already know the actor in the mask is not the actors of the revealed killers on purpose. Otherwise lots of fun clues to think about.

[@nERDbOX_official]

True.... but my thinking is that you can use these mistakes to your advantage. Just like Lillard being at the frat party. Use it....I mean, it's right there. Lol

[@sdixie666]

Love your videos !!! Best scream breakdown on KZbin !!!

[@nERDbOX_official]

Thank you very much. It means a lot

[@mbuszka5295]

Irony in jumpscare, that You add. By end of first movie, we got jumpscare and as much, as it could mean nothing...WHY only *one* killer comes back to life? And why franchise insist on almost BULLING Stu's character. If it never got conclusion, it will end just it. Bulling character. Like, if SCREAM was suppoused to be about TWO killers, why each new movie we got Billy D riding fest, with franchise milking THEIR legacy as HIS, each way possible? SCREAMverse is now practically blunt since especially 4th movie, as third got so little sense, that I just don't feel like thinking about it...😅 But each next movie? It DRIPS of blunt mocking. Like, if it got no reason, then...did they made goal of bulling Matthew Lillard character SO MUCH? Just got...no sense. 😅

[@nERDbOX_official]

Yeah.... bine ofbit makes sense if he doesn't come back

[@mbuszka5295]

@nERDbOX_official "None of it", I guess? 😉

[@XxDelkarxX]

Not sure if the ghostface voice is crap ai or a really bad voice changer.

[@nERDbOX_official]

Ai

[@dragonballradiant2744]

What do you think of the directors saying? Stop focusing so much, on how tall the killer is

[@nERDbOX_official]

This is sloppy stunt casting, to be honest. The stuntman should be the same size as the revealed killers