GINA ALICE Redlinger plays Rachmaninoff: Rhapsody on a Theme of Paganini, op.43

[@qdfirejade]

All of these comments critical of her performance and comparing her to Lang Lang are unnecessary. If anyone can play Rachmaninoff to this level, and has memorized the entire piece, and not screw up during an entire performance deserves applause. Think about all of the hard work to practice and perfect each note, and let go of the pressure and stress of performing live. It is not an easy feat. Let's enjoy the music and give her credit where it's due, regardless of the fact that she's Lang Lang's wife, she's trying to make something of her skills. It is so easy to criticize when you are not the one performing.

[@Almedicosis]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z3PEh5mgjNWEZsk 没有比较没有伤害

[@Almedicosis]

still this interpretation is BAD horrible

[@TomCloyd]

@@Almedicosis Says who? And why? Are you the voice of the gods?

[@TomCloyd]

Linda Wang - Well said! I couldn't agree more. Musical performance is not a sport, but an effort made by a human being, and when we lose sight of that we dehumanize the entire process. I will always object to this.

[@qdfirejade]

@@Almedicosis you're free to interpret this version to your preference, but try to acknowledge the effort that someone made for your entertainment.

[@vocalchords3609]

My mother always said when she heard me criticise someone unfairly - "Don't criticise Silver because its not Gold!" Gina is a stunning musician! For those who can Read the score, Play the Score - from memory - With an orchestra - Under pressure of performing for all eternity as your playing is filmed and recorded? Come on - this is WONDERFUL - and as a professional musician, those giving this the 'thumbs down' might like to reflect on my words and remove their unjust and frankly ill-informed negative responses. Thank you all involved in this energising and superb rendition of an awesome piece of composition by Rachmaninov too don't forget!!!! Imagine creating this one piece! Respect to all and thank you again.

[@Almedicosis]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z3PEh5mgjNWEZsk compare to yuja she has already quit playing？right？

[@TomCloyd]

@@Almedicosis Nope. Quite wrong.

[@TomCloyd]

Thank you Vocal Chords - I strongly agree.

[@yodservant]

The pressure on this young lady is phenomenal....bless her ♒🏜️🐅🐯

[@haminguyen9598]

What an astonishing performance! Sending you all lots of love who enjoyed it as well 🤗🙆‍♀️✨

[@Almedicosis]

horrible playing please try this better version kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z3PEh5mgjNWEZsk

[@iuliaujeniuc731]

Superbă interpretare, superbă pianista! Grazieeee

[@evaguedel9376]

I loved everything about this performance ! Very gracefully presented, a joy to watch !

[@Almedicosis]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z3PEh5mgjNWEZsk try this better version

[@TomCloyd]

Lovely, clean, articulate. I thoroughly enjoyed this performance. One of the loveliest parts was watching the dance of her hand and arms. A professional dancer would be no more beautiful. Such a joy to hear and see!

[@Almedicosis]

try this better version kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z3PEh5mgjNWEZsk

[@TomCloyd]

@@Almedicosis The difference between your response and mine is that mine is personal. It is made by human being. I love Yuga Wang and especially her Rach. #2 performance, but that is a different person at a different time and place. I respond to both. You merely want to rank them in absolute terms, without giving us your criteria. There ARE no absolute criteria in art. It all reduces to personal taste. Wang's performance is NOT better until you stipulate your criteria and make your argument. Until then you are merely expressing your personal preferences without making it clear that they ARE just personal. This is just poor rhetoric on your part, I will argue, because I stipulate "good rhetoric" to be clear assertions backed by overt argumentation. You offer none.

[@mariadelcarmenperez2215]

Astonishing Performance played with bravura, brilliance, and beautiful lyricism. Spectacular pianist! ♥️🌹🌹🌹🥰 Your astonished fans

[@주경란-t4r]

Wonderful! Congratulations on your marriage with Lang Lang, and also having a baby boy. Hope and pray that you'll continue to grow up as a great artist in God's abundant blessings.

[@nickk8416]

I love this Rhapsody on a theme of Paganini. Very nice playing!! Not an easy piece.

[@Gina-br2nd]

Lovely performance, Gina. 💞💞💞

[@belindasmith4690]

Beautiful 👍❤️🎹🎹🎼🎼🎼🌟

[@AgneseFiducia]

Congratulations for your pianist career and for the marriage with Lang Lang ❤❤❤👏👏👏🎉🎉🎉

[@Invisiblewinds]

Hey you sounded great!! I’m glad that you’re still working on your career no matter what. All the best to you!

[@Almedicosis]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z3PEh5mgjNWEZsk yuja wang played the same piece much better

[@Invisiblewinds]

@@Almedicosis So what? There are always someone better out there.

[@Tracy-mz9bi]

@@Almedicosis there is a person do better != u r silly

[@andreaswinterhalter]

Vielen Dank für die schöne Musik und alles Gute zur Hochzeit!

[@toewomg]

Beautiful playing !

[@dloug6296]

这录音钢琴比重太大了吧，太近，和乐团不融合

[@instantesdelucidezyesperan1291]

¡Linda, a la dimensión que sea!

[@la_princesse_des_beauxarts]

16:33 favorite!

[@lindalulu2196]

WOW!!!

[@toomanybytes]

It's clear early on that the recording itself has noticeable technical issues. And I don't understand why everyone else here doesn't understand it.

[@1004god]

한국에서도 공연 해주세요 아름다운 피아니스트 지나양^^

[@CruceEntertainment]

Clean performance. A little slow tempo, but I’d rather it clean, and slower also helps me learn it myself lol

[@tunabomber111]

16:38 Groundhogs Day with Bill Murry.

[@evaguedel9376]

Great pianist!

[@kastasn1]

Lang Lang is the king and Gina Alice the queen.

[@yohoexpo]

Fantastico,hablas ingles,frances,aleman,corean y chino.

[@Supernova-1988]

Looking forward to see you in Hong Kong 🌝

[@susannacychan]

Clean, beautiful, sentimental, natural. Personally, I like her version better than Lang Lang's indeed, because of the cleanliness and natural interpretation, while both are superb!

[@stephenliu1989]

Bravo!

[@Almedicosis]

empty seats，try this better version kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z3PEh5mgjNWEZsk

[@liszt1811chopin]

她好漂亮

[@audreydowney6605]

Lang Lang finds a perfect wife, and she is beautiful

[@KENBU123]

In my opinion she has really good technical training but the tone quality is not my cup of tea. Still a great couple with Lang Lang though!

[@dirkstrickland135]

Honestly, I would place the blame on the recording and the sound engineer if there were one. The tone quality of the piano is a bit off due to lack of resonance. In fact the entire orchestra sounded flat. On the other hand, I think her weakness is actually her technical ability. She was able to render variation 18, slow and romantic section, beautifully. Yet she was clearly struggling in faster and more technically demanding variations. You can feel the strain in her performance in variation 15/19/24. Lang Lang's performance, also at the age of 24, was much more effortless and fluid.

[@lotusbuds2000]

@@dirkstrickland135 Valid point of view. You must be a pianist!

[@republiccooper]

@@dirkstrickland135 no, from watching her technique it seems she doesn't produce a powerful sound. But I find nothing wrong with that. We get used to hearing a piece a particular way and it becomes our preference. To me is nice to remind myself that there are other ways of playing familiar pieces.

[@leixu9719]

@@republiccooper in another interview in Chinese she also mentioned and agreed that pianists should play powerfully in a concert hall because they play for the audience, not for the pianists themselves. additionally this is not a nocturne from Chopin. If she holds this point of view but doesnt produce a powerful sound, probably it's not only due to the intention, but also due to the technique. Honestly, the performance is too flat, not only her, but also the whole orchestra's. I dont feel any passion in the music.

[@republiccooper]

@@leixu9719 I see.

[@roberthuber5589]

bravo !

[@tonyli6277]

演出精彩！先赞一下！但不知是合奏的乐队的脱节，还是她的interpretation，总觉得差了点什么，不够俄国味！相比之下还是喜欢Lisitsa的演奏多一点。

[@jinxuanjiang1315]

可能大乐团和顶级钢琴家的版本听多了，这个就不太给力了

[@Almedicosis]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z3PEh5mgjNWEZsk try this vrsion much better

[@L00D00]

0:14 All these empty Seats !

[@elizabethvhwong]

Bravo.

[@foolishbit]

這首曲子她真的彈得不好（但人美是真的），特別是最著名的 variation 18 ，可以聽聽她老公彈的版本，就知道差異：kzbin.info/www/bejne/inubmIJ8o7qsidU 但也許在交響樂團真的也有差，中間變成在比大聲，鋼琴蓋過弦樂器，太過於搶戲了。 近代來說，還活著的鋼琴家，個人覺得 Vladimir Ashkenazy 把 Rachmaninoff 的曲子詮釋得最好。這幾年的新秀，Daniil Trifonov 也表現不凡。

[@paulshi2821]

16年去世的Zoltan kocsis也很好，Trifonov我觉得以后肯定会成为大师级的钢琴家

[@Tracy-mz9bi]

Gina和这些独奏家还有差距

[@demingweng3445]

琴弹的怎样不加评论。但这个指挥骨定问题很大。很多错在指挥。可能太注重挥手的优美感。只能说像业余的。

[@Invisiblewinds]

de ming Weng 哎哟懂挺多，你来说说看指挥错在哪了？

[@thaliagraichen8312]

我也觉得有点儿问题。但不好说。钢琴音过于硬狠，没变化，不过我觉得还是很搭乐团的整体水平

[@joshleung8808]

樂團的水平真的有點差

[@haijieriji9587]

好的她也配不上

[@amelaumusic]

@@haijieriji9587 她確實彈得一般，但有你這麼損人的嗎? 也不是頭一回看見你了

[@haijieriji9587]

@@amelaumusic 弹得一般没啥~出来骗钱还要高价票就有点呵呵了~ 现在又靠大胸细腰在大陆综艺上骗钱~哎~

[@amelaumusic]

@@haijieriji9587 唉就不能積點口德? 批評她的彈奏方式可以, 但是你確定你現在不是在人身攻擊嗎...... 你也是彈鋼琴的，就別扯到甚麼胸大胸不大上面了，而且參加個綜藝秀個恩愛還犯法了? (我不便評論騙錢不騙錢的事，因為我確實沒有去過她的演奏會，沒聽過她的現場演出，不知道她的票的價錢高不高。)

[@haijieriji9587]

@@amelaumusic 现在开始多栖发展~出单曲~我倒是挺佩服她会写歌~但唱得也就是个卡拉ok水平~

[@semidokt]

Grausame Interpretation! Keine Musikalität! Ich erkenne das Stück nicht mehr!

[@Jack-hy1zq]

The piano is not voiced correctly. It is objectively too harsh.

[@mutu7966]

弹得太乏味

[@Almedicosis]

弹的真差 赶紧听听yuja wang洗洗耳。horrible player！the most pianist！

[@Almedicosis]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z3PEh5mgjNWEZsk