Girls' Generation - Beautiful restriction, 소녀시대 - 아름다운 구속, Lalala 20090625

[@bettyanderson7650]

That's why Seohyun is harmonization queen. And jessica's voice is like heaven.

[@MsCheese2000]

Betty Anderson umm no.Jess’ voice is pitchy even if its hight.

[@justdb4]

I agree with you 100%. Their voices together is just so amazing and breathtaking.

[@justdb4]

@@MsCheese2000 her voice isn't pitchy, but piercing like a violin... just because her voice is more forward does not mean she doesn't have a angelic voice because she does. Jessica still has an amazing voice. I mean I feel in love with her voice because she has a timbre similar to my own. Very forward and pericing in our singing.

[@kimyerim9884]

@The RedSmasherPERIODT

[@kimyerim9884]

@The RedSmasher It’s like their part time job is being a Jessica hater like- boo can’t even dance baby shark well or sing twinkle twinkle decently sooooo I would shut it

[@김진호-w1k7i]

서현 거의 화음쌓는 기계

[@ngeo88]

After listening to New Jeans version, i come back 11years ago 😂😂😂 this is still the best 😊🥺

[@Chilling688]

I thought new jeans made this song

[@ngeo88]

​​@@Chilling688I like New jeans , after SNSD I stop following kpop for a while, New jeans bring me back to kpop. To be frank, New jeans vocal level only can compete with Seohyun , not even the level of Sunny, no hope to compete with Jessica, Tiffany and Taeyeon 😅😅😅😅

[@PiggySiblingsOfficial]

@@ngeo88 No not even Seohyun…. Her B-side and her cover of bang bang is top tier.

[@MooKrob9935]

​​​@@ngeo88 with respect, newjeans as a group still cant beat sunny, the weakest vocalist in snsd vocal line. The best vocalist of nj is hanni right? She is still cant beat sunny.

[@brixfernandez]

​@@ngeo88 nahh can't even beat Sunny her vocal technique is no joke

[@lingodream460]

Sunny's vocal on this was amazing. No one can replace SNSD vocal line for me. The best vocal line to ever exist.

[@토레타-m5j]

확실히 소녀시대가 노래 진짜 개잘함

[@miny9972]

서현 화음 잘 넣는다 저때 19살밖에 안된 애긴데 ㅋㅋ

[@youngn.8289]

소시 화음장인

[@yb3542]

전주예고 피아노과 나왓어요원래 피아노 잘치는애들이 음감이 좋습니다

[@lilylily-cv6lm]

2023년에도 듣고 있어요. 서현 팬이예요.

[@dododoibobobo]

들으면 들을수록 써니 목소리가 진짜 제대로임. 써니파트마다 귀에 꽂혀서 킬링파트됨…😊

[@mymemine97]

I'm comeback here after watching " a time called you" and realize that SNSD was covering this song

[@ESP1009]

막내의 라이브 정말 안정적이예요.

[@jjju8397]

이때 소시 많아봤자 20살 아님..? 요즘은 20살이어도 갓기라고 떠받들면서 노래 못해도 봐주고 라이브는 하지도 않는데 이거보니 요즘 아이돌들 꿀빠는거네.. 소시는 데뷔한지 얼마 안된 이 시점부터도 다 음색 쩔고 노래 살벌하게 부르는데ㅋㅋ

[@ahkit10]

5 main vocalist, 5 different ways to sing, 5 different attractions, 5 angels^^

[@MrDennie95]

So-phrodite Wonie 2 main ones and 3 lead ones

[@JS-wj1cs]

An Hoang At snsd’s level, the lead vocalists can easily become main vocalists and the dance line can easily become lead vocalists.

[@loveyou4695]

So-phrodite Wonie 1 main vocal and 4 lead vocals

[@SD-ir1vf]

5 main 5 lead 5 all you don’t know how lucky we were to have them. As said by Peter Green don’t ask me what I think of you I might not give the answer that you want me too.

[@SD-ir1vf]

Gege Pok. You can eat shit with what you said

[@MSdontstalkme]

Both snsd and nj versions are good, but I absolutely love snsd version more. The high notes and belting are stronger, more satisfying to listen to

[@vanillacinnamon]

Agree. Once in a while i listen to both vers, but i listen more to snsd. Plus their voices are distinctive from each other

[@Catz1a]

Bless this vocal line honestly i mean Seohyun's harmonies and Sunny's chorus part

[@JYODKSSJHPSYNYZJK]

I admit sunny did outbest tae and sica here for me. and i love seohyunnie's hamonization. i love her anyway.

[@danrenepadua4814]

U just love her then. Haha

[@heavenmorgan1535]

@@danrenepadua4814 I'm Taeyeon and Sooyoung stan but it's true sunny outbest taesic here in this song.

[@SweetWitches]

소녀시대가 부른 아름다운 구속 진짜 너무 좋다

[@eve3828]

진짜 요즘 걸그룹 누가 음악 방송에서 5명이나 보컬 그룹으로 이렇게 마이크들고 생라이브하냐? 요즘은 상상도 못할 라이브 방송이다.

[@honkyu]

직속 후배 레드벨벳

[@고구마-t6s3s]

@@honkyu 레드벨벳 5명이 다 저정도로 부른다고?ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@honkyu]

@@고구마-t6s3s 라이브 찾아보셈 닉값 떨지말고.. 차단함

[@kho2004]

김종서 혼자 어유롭게 부르는걸 5명이서 부르네

[@sdgd-jv5bx]

@@honkyu 어차피 이제는 4명이서 부를거지만 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@anhtieu2118]

Sunny, can I say that she used her voice so wisely here? while Sica and Tae used head voices to hit those high notes in the chorus, she used falsetto to make it sound softer and sweeter at some notes. and not that she couldn't hit high notes with her head voice, Sunny and Sica has widest ranges in S9 in my view! ^^~ people usually think that Hyo had the longest training time started in 2000. actually, Sunny, who has been trained since 1998 in Starlight and then changed to Wheesung's Company before joining SM, is the longest-trained-singer in S9. her vocal teacher was Wheesung, so I believe she's trained as well as Tae or Sica or anyone else. but she never boasts herself in front of people, which makes me admire and respect her more and more. go Sunny Bunny~ XD

[@SunnyNadina]

Have you listened to Sunnys OST The Second Drawer? Her voice is absolutely gorgeous

[@anhtieu2118]

SunnyNadina I did, and yes, she sounds so angelic but grievous at the same time in that song. and her voice, I believe she was selected by SM not for her looks or dancing skills, or even singing skills (those old days she was kinda weak in controlling her voice, however it's improved a lot now) but for her voice. it's special in its own way and really rare in a good way! ^^~

[@TimelessGap2]

It just goes to show who have the better skills and I've been telling people that for years but they believe in titles and not the actual talent. I keep telling them that singing is more than the voice but how you utilize that voice. When it comes down to it Sunny is the better vocalist for this purpose. Her strength and control is out of this world. It's not about how powerful or how much you sing. I always questioned & complain about Sunny not singing enough but at times I find myself thinking that's how she wants it. I find myself thinking that she's the kind of person that doesn't like to standout/outshine others. Also her personality... her shyness maybe a big part of it. But then again she stays in the background to avoid people talking about her family situation/influences. And its not just her music career but her acting too. She was chosen to play the main role in a drama but turned it down because she thought it was too much of an important role for her debuted work. Also she once said that she doesn't think she's pretty enough to be an actor. We all know that's anything but the case and also damn sure that she would've dominated that world if she did take the role because from what little we saw on Horror Movie factory she's one hell of an actor.

[@baepinkobsession]

Sica and Taeyeon didn’t used head voice in here none of them are and only sunny who used her falsetto in the chorus

[@TimelessGap2]

Roy Echague Taeyeon & Jessica always use their head voice... Jessica voice is just soft. Taeyeon voice is powerful and this is why even when they do sing cutesy songs there is always some high notes or powerful verse/lines so she could song because she's not as versitile with her vocals.

[@jjlovegs11]

지금 걸 그룹들이 제일 봐야 할 영상인듯 보거라~~ 이게 레전드 그룹 보컬 라인이다

[@하윤슬-c7m]

써니 목소리 너무 좋아...

[@jungeunlee5603]

그 시절, 우리가 사랑했던 ‘소녀시대’

[@93DLareg]

Sunny really good at ballads .. she really nailed it .. :3

[@mic-shellcrackson3800]

Katsura Kotarou This isnt a ballad tho

[@mungmungwalwal]

서현이 화음자판기ㅠㅠ진짜잘함

[@bigpiney1000]

Sunny sings with a smile. you don't even have to see her to know. you can hear it. Sunny fighting!

[@lucasdasilvaaugusto3413]

Yes!! She makes my heart melt

[@bigpiney1000]

I am happy that you all love Sunny as much as me. :)

[@TimelessGap2]

Sunny is my life line.... I can't go on without hearing her beautiful soothing voice. They say no one's perfect but I guess they didn't heard about or saw her when they said that. She was God's gift to mankind and boy did he made a good choice. She's the only member would could plaster a smile one anyone's face just by standing on screen. You don't have to hear her, just seeing her beautiful smile is enough to take you through anything life throws at you.

[@LindsayWells]

maknae's harmonies are the best ^_^

[@aex2309]

No wonder when i listened to NJ new OST, it sounded familiar then I realized binge watching SNSD live performances before and this was one of those songs ❤

[@vanillaraven2618]

ohmy same reaction

[@vanillaraven2618]

different versions .

[@dscdsc2345]

Same! I immediately came here after listening to NJ's

[@kimogdoc1204]

@@dscdsc2345 same HAHAHA I remember listening to this performance and loved this song because of them

[@fernfernsone]

Me toooooo

[@documents04]

Only the best vocalists can sing this well, snsd is another level

[@Darkangelike]

I really love when Sunny sings like this and not with an over exaggerated high pitched voice.

[@Sunnybias]

Yeah, her powerful voice is very underrated

[@tiffanybeatles]

아련하고 그립고 아름답다 다시는 돌아갈수없는 시절

[@TheBB1994]

This version is still the best.

[@mountainrigi]

얘네가 부르니까 노래가 되게 블링블링하고 귀여워지네요

[@무걸시즌4존버]

2024년에 들어도 참 좋네요 ❤

[@taehyunpark193]

써니 최고, 난 이 노래 처음 들은 후로 지금까지, 이 프로가 감사한게 써니가 이렇게 좋은 표정을 가졌다는것. 그걸 봐서 좋아요~ 그게 벌써 10년이 됐네요^^ 물론 다른 맴버들도 멋있고 좋아요~^^

[@dadukii]

"처음이야 내가~ 드디어 내가~" 01:05 제시카 02:36 태연 03:06 써니

[@TileJun]

누가 더좋냐고? 제시카

[@liltunwin]

3:05 what I always came back to this cover for. That chorus from Sunny is 👌

[@E-nok]

wow me too~

[@Samuel-th6fw]

SAME! She might not be as famous for her vocals but she seriously outsings both Taeyeon and Jessica here.

[@ytngng]

saw Newjeans cover, then I suddenly remember SNSD covered before too. omg different generation with different feelings. Love it. I really love harmonisation. Really make me miss Soshi a lot. They did a lot covers with harmonisation perfectly.

[@KPOPTESTING]

I love this version but njs is pretty good too, this song can’t go wrong

[@클레오빡돌아-m4j]

이거 알고리즘 선택 언제받냐 춤추는 아이돌 그룹 보컬라인이 이렇게 라이브 잘하고 타가수 노래까지 완벽하게 소화하기 쉽지않음

[@CEX-x4c]

이게 정상인데 아이돌자체가 그냥 개쓰레기 문화라고 생각되는데 아이돌그룹 대부분 노래 좆같이못해서 개좆같음 한국가요판이 어쩌다 이지경 됀지 모르겠음

[@TheVivaciousPrincess]

Jessica taeyeon and Sunny nailed the high notes..

[@LINDAKATA16]

seohyun sounds excellent...her harmony is so great

[@rosemaemartinez8459]

Seohyun looks so pure and beautiful. Her eyes just sparkles so beautifully here♥

[@istandanielthesamoyed1172]

What I love about SNSD's vocal line ( apart from the fact that they are so talented ) is that each has a very unique and distinct voice , it's like ice cream with many flavors :p and they harmonize so well !! they are amazing

[@bigpiney1000]

Sunny is my girl. she is way too underrated. her personality shines through everything she does.

[@markycua3410]

Yeah she nailed it. Im so sad she didnt always get the best lines in their songs. She's way better than others. :(

[@istandanielthesamoyed1172]

Rydel Cuachon maybe she will have her solo soon :)

[@markycua3410]

I hope so. Im always rooting to that possibility. She had a great and amazing voice.

[@istandanielthesamoyed1172]

yeah ~

[@희희-i4m]

소시 보컬라인은 진짜 아이돌 역사에 다시 나올수 있는 조합일까 ...? 🥺🥺 너무 자랑스럽다 🫶

[@kryznahmarlealautrizo6711]

seohyuun is the Queen of harmonization. i also love the part of seohyun & Tiffany. sunny's unique voice jessica's sweet voice & taeyeon's powerful voice

[@Harudal]

어릴적 소녀시대로 인해 이 노래를 접하고 10여년이 지나서도 계속 들으러 온다. 참 노래 잘하는 그룹 소녀시대.. 여기서는 써니. 제시카가 돋보이네

[@포항사나이]

수정) 2021년에도 들으시는분 손? 2020년에도 들으시는분 손?

[@choi-zu6ng]

다들 잘한다 ㅠㅠ

[@장원준-s8g]

저요

[@kingsgogo]

2021년에 다시 듣습니다 ㅋ

[@sonshine6849]

Me i miss this 5 singing angle 😭

[@vini2196]

서현 화음이 레게노네 ㄹㅇ

[@이하-e1v]

벌써 10년전이라니..ㅠㅠ 이때 본방으로 봤었는데 다시 보니까 뭔가 아련한 느낌 제시카 같이 부르는게 최고였는데.. ㅠㅜㅠ

[@journey2586]

써니 목소리 왜 이렇게 좋아... ㅠㅠ 💕

[@areyoumarriedtothemusic4635]

Jessica's belts 1:21 true queen! also Sunny's beautiful voice!!

[@chaluaysuaykae4599]

jessica & sunny so good feeling T-T

[@itgetsworse601]

Seohyun's harmony is just on point Taeyeon's warm voice Jess's unique flawless voice slays us Sunny's pleasant voice SNSD QUEENS

[@dian71485]

Tiffany?

[@zixunqis2202]

Tiffany where?

[@girlsgenerationtaylorsversion]

since you forgot I'mma just say, Tiffany slayed her part 😍

[@itgetsworse601]

​@@dian71485 damn I really forgot 😭. I love Fany too ❤❤❤

[@soobhan4425]

태연이랑 서현 같이 부르는거 너무 좋다!!!🔆🔆

[@roxxhexx3813]

SNSD had the most line-up talented girls in the world, they are totally amazing vocals😍 and Hyoyeon,Yuri,Yoona,Sooyoung are the most amazing dancers, they totally complete each other

[@aida.6771]

Now after watching how Sunny absolutely effortlessly sang the part that was also sang by two main vocalists (and which has some difficult elements) try to tell that she can't sing. You simply can't.

[@TimelessGap2]

the syung When they did say she has the best delivery & most vocal techniques of the other. Oh and let's not forget that during all that perfectness she was just smiling.

[@snsdexo3436]

Unnies line❤️

[@jakepark5807]

써니도 진짜 잘하는데 너무 저평가 당했음... 근데 써니 이노래 진짜 좋아하는듯 저번에 청불에도 불렀던것 같은데

[@83root2]

아 여전히 이버젼은 너무나 아름답다 풋풋한 소녀감성 목소리와 뛰어난 세션들의 연주!!힐링 음악중하나!!

[@미니병]

오랜만에 다시들어도 좋네.. 안정감에서 태연이 독보적이고 다들 음색이 좋아서 듣기가 편안함

[@hiee4450]

서주현 최고👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

[@istandanielthesamoyed1172]

The harmonization is overall great but I think the harmonization between Seohyun and Tiffany was sooooooo good :)

[@kryznahmarlealautrizo6711]

agree....

[@TimelessGap2]

Well they're the closet in range.. Seo is Mid to Low while Fany is Low. TaeSicaSun are all high. Sun being the highest then Sica.

[@비타민넌나의]

처음부터 끝까지 서현이 화음 다 넣내 화음 장인ㄷㄷㄷ

[@김규헌-z6s]

멤버들끼리 목소리 합이 너무 잘 맞는거같아요 귀 녹는거같아ㅠㅠ

[@Youcantdie]

Sunny

[@dianangwin]

Sunny with the warmest voice. ^_^ ♥

[@ezaymalik1457]

I really prefer Sunny singing this song, she could really express the feelings that 's within the song .

[@Sunnybias]

Sunny fits this song perfectly!!

[@sonshine6849]

Me too

[@g4df74g1h]

뉴진스 좋아하지만 보컬 탤런트만큼은 진짜 소녀시대가 넘사벽이다. 음색도 다 개성있었고. 제시카 태연 목소리 콘트라스트 너무 황홀. 내가 처음 사랑했던 아이돌. Sm은 노래잘불렀음. 태연한테 사랑에 빠지고 노래를 계속듣고 엇그제 같았는데 벌써

[@danaibero7118]

This vocal line in one of the best of kpop.

[@norf2690]

why this vid is one of my all-time fav snsd performances 1) so much airtime for seohyun

[@zixunqis2202]

Taeyeon??

[@viviscenebz]

Jessica isn't nasally. You should check out some of her belts. She definitely is the best at belting after Taeyeon.

[@markjosaphatsiena6597]

@Shoot !🔫Take a Panorama what song is it?

[@thomhenri3179]

I'm in love with Sunny's voice

[@SD-ir1vf]

Sunny and Seohyun sound great together. I love all five of them. Sunny the most.

[@arafadmuhdfikri1353]

Jessica's hi note gives me goosebumps. she sang the chorus passionately ; ).. so proud of her

[@dhgus]

뉴진스 리메이크 듣고 여기까지 왔네 뉴진스도 나쁘진 않은데... 소녀시대가 확실히 다르긴 하다.

[@cfsinc]

곡 스타일 자체가 옛날스러운 적당히 늘어지고 내질러야 되는 곡이다 보니 적당히 구세대 가수가 불러줘야 잘 어울리는게 아닐까 싶네요. 요즘 싱잉랩 세대 보컬들이 부르면 트렌디하게 들릴수는 있어도 제 맛이 안나는??

[@Kop-r5n]

​@@cfsinc걍 실력차이

[@meaninglesz]

the harmonization of my seo is like heaven in my ears:))

[@치즈케익-y8r]

혹시 2021년에도 들으시는 분 있나요?

[@김민수-k8r]

2022년에도 있어요

[@skyk5625]

2022년 또있어요

[@onlygg-ex2lo]

아이리버 mp3에 음성파일 저장해서 듣던 어린이가 지금도 찾아옵니다ㅋㅋㅋ

[@ramzznee]

여기요~

[@Jade-us3zm]

2022 도착!

[@Kimchijoayo]

써니!!!!! 헐😮😮😮😮😮노래 이렇게 잘했었구나 !!!???? 다 너무 레젼드다 진짜 😊

[@GorjessSone_]

I want a taengsic and sunsic duet!

[@움-r6z]

왜 한국인이없냐 이노래는 여기서 써니가 제일 잘부른다 다들 잘부르지만..

[@weesiangsim2707]

Finally remembered I heard this first and now New Jean is singing it, it’s like passing the baton

[@sonelove335]

seohyun! queen of harmonization!!!

[@keayannadavis9836]

honestly seohyun' harmonies carried this whole performance

[@Samuel-th6fw]

Wouldn't say it "carried" it, because everyones performance was seriously winning on its own. The harmonies just elevated it to a whole other level.

[@iszsvnnyknight5688]

Awesome Sunny 😍. imo she outbest both Taeng & Jess here. love Seohyun's harmony and Tiffany's vocal color too.

[@markycua3410]

Yeah she sang this song comfortably than thise two :) Sunny

[@Kaslanyan]

@@markycua3410 tbh all of them sang comfortably it's just that like taeyeon and seohyun they don't show much facial expressions

[@markycua3410]

@@Kaslanyan its been years since i made that comment hahaaha. I really like sunny's voice. She just naturally have higher vocal range compared to other member.

[@musicmdds]

interesting fact: main vocalists in snsd are usually the elder and shorter ones...seohyun being the exceptional case:p

[@JAEJOONCHO]

서현 화음 부분만 따로 듣고 연습하고 싶다 ㅠㅠ

[@samnangprum2280]

This was 2 years into their career and they slayed so hard

[@braze6798]

소녀시대를 이어 뉴진스가 이곡을 리메이크했음❤❤❤

[@JG77999]

이노래는 써니 목소리가 제일 어울리네

[@smalllady6996]

I love NewJeans, but nobody covered this better than Girls Generation

[@lovingbean]

sm이 보컬을 진짜 잘 조합해서 데뷔시키는것같음 ㅋㅋ 신화, 동방신기, 소시, 샤이니, 엑소보면 진짜 멤버들끼리 보컬합이 너무 잘맞아

[@anhtieu2118]

the more I listen to this live, the more I admire Sunny's voice. though it's quite a sad song, if you search for the lyrics, but she can make it sound both sad and sweet at the same time. not many singers can do that. like Taeyeon, her sad songs almost make me shed tears many time. but listen to Sunny's the 2nd drawer, I can feel a little sweetness in it, which comforts my soul. that's why I said her voice is really rare and truly a gift! plus, whenever listening to her, I can't help but imaging her smiles, bright ones or just a light ones :x

[@bigpiney1000]

i don't think that it's a sad song. more of a song of overcoming things. Sunny shines through everything she does. I agree with the smiles. :)

[@JS-wj1cs]

Sunny’s first OST “finally now” is worth listening to too. Its filled with emotions and you’ll get really immersed in her voice.

[@att1056]

재수할때 우연히 이거 보고서는 10년동안 생각날때마다 보러오고있어요

[@att1056]

12년째인 지금도 가끔 보러와요

[@WolfNblue]

저도 12년째네요^^

[@Томирис21]

SNSD's vocal line aged like a fine wine. I love them so much. The harmony and and different voices come together to make good music.

[@phaimen]

i remember falling in love with Sunny's vocals here

[@zanjelo3273]

Oh my Jessica!!! That chorus Is perfect 😍😍 Sunny's sweet voice though 😊

[@MrILNaS]

Seohyun's consonance is so wonderful!!!

[@jho0725]

써니 목소리 좋다

[@BADiaz-lh2nd]

SEOHYUN IS SO GOOD AT HARMONIZINGGG!

[@tineericke6727]

This performance is so perfect, taeyeon and jessica's high notes are so on point. Damn I miss these kind of moments

[@kimogdoc1204]

Came here after listening to NewJeans' rendition of the song. I miss SNSD so much 😢❤

[@jamesbagnall1]

Five of the world's best singers in one group. Is there really any wonder as to why SoShi are untouchable when it comes to girl groups? Not just in Korea, but also everywhere.

[@mhinapot28]

seohyun's voice is really good. she's very talented :) all of them are talented

[@n1WayBTer]

Aaaaaaaah Sunny Thank You, they would have let her sing alone or with Seohyun. Sunny I LOVE LOVE LOVE YOU

[@rhedzsky7239]

sunny is my bias she have a good beautiful voice saranghe sunny