Glazing Comparison: Sennelier & Schmincke vs White Nights

  Рет қаралды 59,540

Alyona's Watercolour Creations

Alyona's Watercolour Creations

6 жыл бұрын

Пікірлер: 118
@renmuffett
@renmuffett 3 жыл бұрын
I know Im late responding. I love watching color comparison videos. I just wanted to point out that although the paints you used have the same name, every one has a different pigment which make them very different in hue. White Nights is PV19. Sennelier is PR209, and Schmincke is PR207. I have found that PR209, (a true quin red) is very comparable in hue among most brands.. PV19 is really a quin rose. PR207 is warmest, new and I have not found it in other brands so far. Blessings. I enjoy what you share.
@joyfulldj
@joyfulldj 6 жыл бұрын
Sennelier is ment for layering, that is where it shines, where as white nights and schmincke need more work to get first layer right right away, i have all 3 as well, in mmy visual wc journal sennelier wasnt working to well for me; it seems to love my fabriano jumboblock though, where as white nights and schmincke tend to get blotchy faster on that block. I love all three for different uses
@salvatore7994
@salvatore7994 6 жыл бұрын
Very interesting video, I love the realistic vibrancy of Senellier, but also The German brand is so beautifull and delicate. The White Nights are so full of pigment, very perfect for an art that wants to hit immediatly who look. In my opinion it doesn’t exist the perfect brand, but the perfect brand for your style and your art. Thank you!
@AlyonasWatercolourCreations
@AlyonasWatercolourCreations 5 жыл бұрын
Yes I definitely agree! I am often asked what brand I would recommend but it's a question that is very hard to answer, and as you said depends on the individual's style and expectations :)
@Karla_Smith
@Karla_Smith 6 жыл бұрын
Fun to see these in action, and your poppies were a great way to see how these react. Thanks for sharing.
@pru5730
@pru5730 5 жыл бұрын
Thank you for this. You just helped me be certain about which watercolors I want to invest in at this time. I almost made a decision I would regret for my style. Lovely video. Cheers!
@Renilou2
@Renilou2 5 жыл бұрын
I am one of those people who will soak the paper to remove some of the sizing and stretch the paper. I want my pigments to soak deep into the inner layers of the paper to build up rich depth of color and value. In order to do that you want some of the sizing gone. When you glaze in this way allowing each layer to dry before another layer, you can get a painting that is so rich in color and depth it can be mistaken for an oil painting. Schmincke pigments are ground so fine that they easily sink into the paper. This might be why it seems to fade out more. But its also the only brand that you can keep adding more layers, as many as you want without it looking over worked, leaving you with the richest depth of color. With this method I use, I cannot use Sennelier because it will sit on the surface of even well soaked paper. Before I can get the depth I want it will lift and get streaky & blotchy. Check Susan Harrison-Tustain's work. She a world wide master of this day & uses Schmincke and explains why.
@monahli1597
@monahli1597 4 жыл бұрын
Renee Marks how do you remove the sizing? Thank you for sharing this, this sounds like something I want to try.
@aoutsky
@aoutsky 4 жыл бұрын
Monah Li soak you paper in water.
@renmuffett
@renmuffett 3 жыл бұрын
@@monahli1597 sorry for this late reply. Whenever you soak any cotton paper before stretching, some surface sizing will be removed. 140lb Arches for 5 to 7 minutes will be enough. Just put in clear lukewarm water bath. Lift out, press on gatorboard with dry towel and staple right away and leave to dry overnight or be bone dry. Before you add subsiqent lsyers of paint. Make sure layer of paint is bone dry. I use wet into wet with the 1st 3 layers. Susan Harrison -Tustain explains it all on her website.
@maggiebach5791
@maggiebach5791 5 жыл бұрын
I agree with those who say your choice to compare the three manufacturers in actual use in a drawing (versus a swatch) on the same page was useful and informative. Thank you.
@MeowMeowKapow
@MeowMeowKapow 6 жыл бұрын
Actually, I recently did a video in which I briefly talked about how sizing helps watercolors be a more pure color, where paper without sizing makes the color more dull. Because you were using the back side of the paper, that is EXACTLY why it looked more dull. I really like the idea of comparing these colors in what are basically functional color swatches on the same page, but more useful. I didn’t like sennelier or schmincke at first because they seemed so weak. I’m still trying to find a way to work with Schmincke that I like, but I have managed to fall in love with Sennelier. I use them most for portraits because you can layer on and on forever and it’s easy to get good subtle undertones in the shadows and things without them looking obnoxious. I use them a lot when I take paint with me to draw at restaurants and parks and such!
@AlyonasWatercolourCreations
@AlyonasWatercolourCreations 6 жыл бұрын
That's a good point, I am new the the sizing concept of paper, have heard a few times about it but not actually fully understanding what it is. All I know is that when the paper is sized the watercolour will look more vibrant on it as it sort of sits on top rather than getting absorbed. Need to look into that more. Billy Showell uses the reversed side of the moulin du roy paper for her botanical paintings, and a few of my viewers recommended to do that too. But thanks for letting me know, the seizing factor for the swatches is definitely important. :)
@Kyomiibrown
@Kyomiibrown 6 жыл бұрын
Alyona's Watercolour Creations The Mulin Du Roy Hot Press has a lot of sizing and repels water and is a difficult hot press to work with on the right side, which is why Billy will use the under side. However, colours on the right side of the MDR hot press are very very vibrant, more so than any other hot press I have used, the colours sing when dry. Arches isn’t the best for vibrancy in my experience, I’m not keen on the paper at all, I much prefer Mulin Du Roy COLD press. Sennelier paints offer a luminosity that is hard to beat when used correctly, they are made for glazing, a steady build up of light glazes is the way to go. White Nights appear vibrant yet flat, not delicate & not my choice to do a professional piece with. I much prefer watercolours that require glazing to build luminosity, it’s the sign of the good watercolour IMHO.
@Renilou2
@Renilou2 5 жыл бұрын
The best 100% cotton watercolor paper brands have internal sizing, meaning the paper is soaked completely in gelatin and the sizing is just as much on one side as the other as well as inside the inner fibers. The main reason for the up side of the paper is mostly for the correct texture it claims to be. I am one of those people who will soak the paper to remove some of the sizing and stretch the paper. I want my pigments to soak deep into the inner layers of the paper to build up rich depth of color and value. In order to do that you want some of the sizing gone. When you glaze in this way allowing each layer to dry before another layer, you can get a painting that is so rich in color and depth it can be mistaken for an oil painting. This is the method Susan Harrison-Tustain uses watercolor and she teaches all over the world and considered a master of this day and age.
@susan3156
@susan3156 5 жыл бұрын
Kyomii thank you for the insights. I’m new to watercolors and have been binge reading everything I can possibly find on paper, brushes and paints. Personally I prefer as white a background as possible and have found that so far the papers I’ve bought have a slightly natural yellowish colour so I am now keen to order the Mulin Du Roy as it’s a white paper. I wonder if the reasons behind Billy’s issues with this paper are due to the fact that she uses wet on wet? Hence the struggles to get this paper to absorb the water? I’m going to be taking her classes once my paints arrive but I also plan to take Anna Mason’s online classes, as far as I can tell Anna doesn’t do wet on wet but also does the layering. The possibilities are endless...
@charliebaker1427
@charliebaker1427 4 жыл бұрын
i love schmincke you tripping
@jillkama7614
@jillkama7614 6 жыл бұрын
So happy you made this video! Please do more glazing comparisons with other brands too!!!
@pixels2u
@pixels2u 6 жыл бұрын
Very well done - great comparison! Am definitely pulling out my neglected Senneliers to try some more glazing.
@kelseywood1582
@kelseywood1582 4 жыл бұрын
this was so interesting. Please do more comparison videos I love them!! Thank you so much
@brendalogan7940
@brendalogan7940 6 жыл бұрын
Great job Alyona! You paint beautifully. I'm really thinking about getting the Sennelier paints and the book.
@med3049
@med3049 3 жыл бұрын
Thank you for glazing with Sennelier, I've seen to many reviews/comparisons where they only put down one layer and than say it is not as vibrant as other paints. As you say, it is made to be glazed.
@lisat.6813
@lisat.6813 2 жыл бұрын
Thank you! I found this so helpful. :) I really enjoyed watching the comparisons.
@SwedePotato314
@SwedePotato314 11 ай бұрын
I have a 24 pan set of Sennelier and Schmincke, but my first love is White Nights. They were my first professional brand and they’re still my comfort paints. I love the flow of watercolors but in my personal work I use them in a very controlled way, almost like ink or drawing with paint, so the controllability of White Nights always made them so easy to use. My other love is Holbein for the same reason. They’re so easily controlled but both brands are so vibrant. I do love Daniel Smith, Schmincke and Sennelier and W&N but like you said, they are all lovely and all do what they’re supposed to do and they all do it amazingly but they’re all different. They have different properties and qualities and they all have strengths and weaknesses. It’s nice to know that there is a wonderful, professional brand of beautiful watercolors for whatever style and preferences you have.
@chopsticks51
@chopsticks51 2 жыл бұрын
This is absolutely eye opening! Thank you.
@melindastroup1844
@melindastroup1844 6 жыл бұрын
Thank you for this demonstration! Very helpful!
@sushanart
@sushanart 6 жыл бұрын
I wish you had done more glazings on the White Night poppy. It would have been nice to see how it reacts. A very nice and inspiring comparison! Thank you! ❤️👍
@AlyonasWatercolourCreations
@AlyonasWatercolourCreations 6 жыл бұрын
I was considering doing that at first, but the colour was already so intense that there was no necessity in a glaze. If I would have done a glaze on White Nights it would start looking "black", meaning the colour would turn so dark that you no longer would see the beauty of it. If you are curious how glazing works with White Nights you can see that in today's video actually, the poppy tutorial. Hope this helps :)
@annehale4462
@annehale4462 2 жыл бұрын
@@AlyonasWatercolourCreations a
@GregorysMode
@GregorysMode 2 жыл бұрын
Thank you so much Alyona, after a solid week of trying to get info, especially the glazing virtues of both Schmincke and Sennelier I have finaaly made a decision, Sennelier suits my purpose more. thank you for a stright forward comparision. =o)
@Mumu_UwU
@Mumu_UwU 5 жыл бұрын
Thank you so much for this comparison, it was very very helpful! Amazing! 😃🌈✨👌👍
@JacquelineJax
@JacquelineJax Жыл бұрын
Great comparison. Interesting how they are so different. This is also making me think of why working with the same brand in a watercolor art work may turn out better due to similarities values.
@cheralynn4417
@cheralynn4417 5 жыл бұрын
This was very helpful-thanks!
@awatercolourist
@awatercolourist 3 жыл бұрын
This is a very useful video, especially for beginners. Thanks!
@artycraftyalchemy
@artycraftyalchemy 6 жыл бұрын
Oh dear, now I want to add Sennelier to my collection lol. Thanks for the comparison.
@Kim_Bezoen_art
@Kim_Bezoen_art 6 жыл бұрын
Arty Crafty Alchemy haha me too! I have Schmincke which I love but I'm going to paris soon so I looked up the Sennelier shop to purchase some of their paint. I love how you can layer them so easily and they have a shine because of the honey. Can't wait! 😅
@didiirwin
@didiirwin 3 жыл бұрын
Alyona, I am a new subscriber to your channel and LOVING it! This was a brilliant comparison and, although I already own Daniel Smith and Winsor & Newton paints I will definitely be acquiring some Sennelier and possibly Schmincke now! I’m sorry, but I’ve just never been a fan of White Nights. Although the vibrancy of their colours is great, to me they always end up looking flat (maybe it’s just me LOL). W&N aren’t the greatest in this respect either btw. Thank you for these wonderful videos ❤️
@frelseren1
@frelseren1 5 жыл бұрын
Thank you, Alyona. It was a interesting review. I have all three brands, but I have only painting with Schmincke so fare. Now I now what to look after, haha :-)
@Mmmmagu
@Mmmmagu 3 жыл бұрын
I went and bought a 24 Schmincke set after watching this video, they look amazing!
@favorablyimpressed
@favorablyimpressed 6 жыл бұрын
An interesting comparison of colors. I always enjoy the swatching you do with various brands of watercolor. Now I don't feel so guilty buying so many palettes, as a new painter. The colors excite me.
@AlyonasWatercolourCreations
@AlyonasWatercolourCreations 6 жыл бұрын
On contrary, I think you will learn so much more by trying out different brands! In the beginning I was amazed how watercolours from different brands respond in such a wide range :) Have a lovely weekend!
@Renilou2
@Renilou2 5 жыл бұрын
Me too!
@SuperExadidas
@SuperExadidas 5 жыл бұрын
Thanks for sharing this demo.
@rboyarts5122
@rboyarts5122 6 жыл бұрын
Thanks so much for your videos! I’ve really learned a bunch.
@kimleon-guerrero9980
@kimleon-guerrero9980 6 жыл бұрын
Hi from your new subie in Guam ! Rest comparison, thank you for the video. 💞💫
@AlyonasWatercolourCreations
@AlyonasWatercolourCreations 6 жыл бұрын
Thanks you for support! :)
@ColleenM61
@ColleenM61 6 жыл бұрын
Thank you so much for sharing all of this with us. Once I decided to take art seriously I started purchasing all I could over a year ago. My studio will be complete in about a week and I cannot wait to get started. I have fiddled a tiny bit with journals...more like doodling, nothing serious. I purchased a ton of Sennelier...but found them odd as well and so many people seemed disappointed with them I was getting a little sad about my investment. I also have a huge stock of Daniel Smiths and just recently got 18 of the Schmincke. From all I saw on the Sennelier it just seems like I would have to learn a little differently with them. Your videos are such a helpful tool! Your right, different paints for different reasons :) I no longer have buyers regrets on the Sennelier!
@AlyonasWatercolourCreations
@AlyonasWatercolourCreations 6 жыл бұрын
Oddly enough I only had comments from people saying that they love Sennelier, which was hard for me because as a watercolour enthusiast I wanted to love them as well, but I just couldn't love them the way I love White Nights, Daniel Smith, Mijello or Schmincke or recently discovered QOR! I would say don't get rid of your Sennelier watercolours, keep them just for botanicals or floral illustrations that kind of a thing. Schmincke I find interesting, on one side they are definitely softer than other watercolour brands on the other they have colours that are beautifully vibrant and transparent. With Daniel Smith I have gone through a rediscovery recently, as you might have noticed in that 12 ultimate watercolours video 6 were Daniel Smith. So yes every one of them brings something pretty special to the artist's table :) I find keeping an art journals such a neat and satisfying thing to do! Even if you just want to doodle like you said, eventually it all connects. Things that I used to do art-wise years and years ago would resurface in the past 12 months. :) Have a lovely weekend! x
@OneTrueWord1988
@OneTrueWord1988 6 жыл бұрын
Colleen M If you haven't purchased your White Nights yet, Jackson's in the UK has excellent prices; much less expensive than Amazon. jacksonsart.com They pack everything so carefully, and orders to the US come pretty quickly. I have been happy with everything I have purchased there! You will love the White Nights.
@ColleenM61
@ColleenM61 6 жыл бұрын
Great to know! Thanks!
@minakshi005
@minakshi005 Жыл бұрын
Awesome comparison 👍👍
@HeiderosesPhotograph
@HeiderosesPhotograph 5 жыл бұрын
VERY NICE STUDY....THANK YOU SO MUCH....I WOULD PREFER SENNELIER, I LOVE THE WAY HOW THE COLOURS FLOW
@melodiasinger
@melodiasinger 3 жыл бұрын
Amo las 3!!!! Las shmincke, Sennelier y White Nigth, quiero las 3,para mi las 3 son maravillosas, sus colores y la forma de reacción ante el agua es única en cada una!! Las Shmincke las amooo ❤️😍🥰😍 Las White Nigth las amooo 😍🥰❤️🥰😍 Las Sennelier las amooo 😍🥰😍🥰 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Las 3, ya tengo una, me faltan dos mas!!!! Podrías comparar entre las Holbein y Winsor&Newton? Por favor? 🙏🏻🙏🏻 Gracias!!!
@carlycharlesworth1497
@carlycharlesworth1497 5 жыл бұрын
Hi there. I was a little disappointed that you didnt glaze the White Nights poppy as much as you did with the other two paints. I would have liked to see how it would have looked after at least one glaze. I have a set of White Night and I find the fact that the paint simply refuses to move even wet on wet, rather annoying. Would you have any idea why this is or can you hazard a guess please. Thank you for your video. It was really interesting to see the three different paints compaired that way.
@Lavastorm77
@Lavastorm77 4 жыл бұрын
Thinking it would be fun to try this with White Nights, Daniel Smith, and QOR.
@wongogubongo8844
@wongogubongo8844 3 жыл бұрын
Very helpful video.. thanks can i ask for a video wehe you use all of them in one picture to see how they mix together... because they use a different medium... do they seperate?
@aremedyproject9569
@aremedyproject9569 5 жыл бұрын
Just add a bit of ox gall (or wetting medium maybe?, never tried it myself) if you want a watercolour to move more.
@monahli1597
@monahli1597 4 жыл бұрын
A Remedy Project do you add the ox gall on the paper, when I wet the paper before the paint or do I add it to the paint itself? So glad to read this as my colors never move enough
@santen2309
@santen2309 4 жыл бұрын
I'm so tempted by the schmincke.
@jjsartjourney
@jjsartjourney 2 жыл бұрын
Can you do a video comparison on Qor and Da Vinci? I loved the way you compared these brands because when painting we have an idea of how they will look.
@AlyonasWatercolourCreations
@AlyonasWatercolourCreations 2 жыл бұрын
Thank you! I don’t think I own any Da Vinci paints. 🧡
@jjsartjourney
@jjsartjourney 2 жыл бұрын
@@AlyonasWatercolourCreations even a Qor video would be great. I got Sonnelier after watching your video and love them. Was thinking of adding some pop to my color collection. I got Mission gold but they aren't working as I want when I try to add color over another dry color. I wish I would have caught this before investing in them. That is why I am considering Qor, but want to be sure if they are good. I also see alot of people recommending Da Vinci, so was curious about them. Thanks for replying.
@larrywakeman4371
@larrywakeman4371 5 жыл бұрын
Sennelier honey watercolors are THE BEST. Sennelier's entire range, -Oil pastel, Acrylique Extra Fine, etc... are UNTOUCHED by other brands! Kimberly
@aeriacross770
@aeriacross770 Жыл бұрын
I'm glad I invested in the right brand. Both of their stores here in Paris is a delight. The sennelier here just looks so realistic/ organic especial in terms of the layers. I think this is what I need. The schminke is pretty soft but you definitely know it's a drawing. I can't explain it. The sennelier just evokes that old timey nostalgia feeling from watercolor paintings. And since they pride themselves on being the choice for impressionists and my style leaning towards that... I'm happy and content with my investment.
@urbangypsy69
@urbangypsy69 5 жыл бұрын
Do you ever spray/spritz the White Knight set prior to using them? I find they flow very well when the palette is sprayed with water and allowed to sit for 2 min or so before dipping in. The colors move much better. If I want control, I just wet with my paint brush.
@AlyonasWatercolourCreations
@AlyonasWatercolourCreations 5 жыл бұрын
Mine are so creamy I never find the need to spray them beforehand.
@halfabee
@halfabee 5 жыл бұрын
I have been trying to make up my mind between Sennelier & Schmincke watercolour paint. Had decided on Schmincke now I am beck to confusion.
@charliebaker1427
@charliebaker1427 4 жыл бұрын
go with schmincke
@ad6449
@ad6449 4 жыл бұрын
It really depends on what kind of painting you like to do. If you are still trying to work it all out, Sennelier makes a tiny kit of 8 half pans for around US$25. They were my first Sennelier paints and really helped me know what to get. You could pick out a few Schmincke half pans to try too for comparison. Start small, experiment, paint, and discover what you like.
@lindawilliams747
@lindawilliams747 3 жыл бұрын
You may already have been told this, but there is a very active "ASMR" community (please look it up) that would increase your subscibership a hundered fold, not only because of your lovely tutorials, but because of your *soft, hypnotic voice*. This is the voice of Heaven to those of us who can't sleep, or relax, or suffer from PTSD. I found you today as a watercolourist, and also thank you profusely for the state of profound physical relaxation you and your gentle voice have induced.
@kirihiri1106
@kirihiri1106 5 жыл бұрын
Which watercolor is better than Van Gogh?
@annahornfeldt
@annahornfeldt 4 жыл бұрын
But a color see flat om that paper, When you test diffrent colors or company you must use the same paper. Thank you, i love your videos, i have a good time of see this One ❤️
@Hevva67
@Hevva67 5 жыл бұрын
The Sennelier looks more natural.. The White Night looks really harsh and hard lined and the Schminke looks kind of wishy-washy. You may have just made up my mind for me, but maybe the Sennelier tubes are better than the pans.......
@ad6449
@ad6449 4 жыл бұрын
Hevva67 For myself, I use the pans for travel palettes and the tubes for the studio palette. The tubes seem slightly more vibrant in my experience yet your mileage may vary.
@65sunnyday
@65sunnyday 4 жыл бұрын
I' think I'll buy Sennelier as my next pan set. _ _NO, M Graham - NO, WAIT - WAIT __ SCHMINCKE!
@katlynequindiagan7743
@katlynequindiagan7743 4 жыл бұрын
I'm using white nights, glazing is possible it is just a matter of controlling water cause a little goes a long way.
@ColleenM61
@ColleenM61 6 жыл бұрын
Question Alyona, I have also wanted to grab a set of white knights. on Amazon the St. Petersburge is more expensive than the Nevskaya Palitra ones, is there a difference? It doesn't appear to be from everything I have looked up but I have to wonder as the price is very different from each other. Thanks.
@tmp0922
@tmp0922 6 жыл бұрын
They are the same but different same brand anyways St. Petersburg is the professional line Sonnet is their student grade., hope that helps.
@ColleenM61
@ColleenM61 6 жыл бұрын
Antony Michael Pugh Thank you, yes. 🎨
@AlyonasWatercolourCreations
@AlyonasWatercolourCreations 6 жыл бұрын
Basically Nevskaya Palitra is the "brand", White Nights is the name of the artist grade watercolour range. So you won't go wrong by buying White Nights. White Nights happen in St.Petersburg, hence why the set was called White Nights and the brand is established in St.Petersburg as far as I know. There is no mention of White Nights in 'Sonnet' as they are a separate range, and yes they are student grade. And they both are by Nevskaya Palitra. Confusing I know :)
@ColleenM61
@ColleenM61 6 жыл бұрын
Thanks, yes I see the ones that were half the price were called sonnet, I'll pass and wait to get the white knights ones then. After seeing all of your paints, I can see the use of the brightness and the control of the White Knights.
@karanseerah
@karanseerah 4 жыл бұрын
Heyy, amazing video. But I would like to say that princeton heritage is not an imitation of sable. It's just a normal synthetic brush. Where as princeton aqua elite is an imitation of sable :)
@TC-fq7cy
@TC-fq7cy 4 жыл бұрын
Schminke is my favourite for landscape paintings, but not for botanical one, For landscape Schminke’s Color mutation is great next day,but on botanical one their Colors are so dull.
@soon_to_emerge
@soon_to_emerge 3 жыл бұрын
So much paint goes straight into jar 🙈 Isn’t it better to add water to the pan or spray it?
@achromium63
@achromium63 5 жыл бұрын
What paper did you use for your swatch cards?
@mikuenjoyerXD
@mikuenjoyerXD 4 жыл бұрын
Arches, she also said it made the colors very vibrant
@quintessaence
@quintessaence 4 жыл бұрын
Hi! Very nice video, Alyona, but I am still doubting about my first watercolour set. 😂 Can anyone advice me on whether I should buy White Nights or Sennelier (the la petite variant, as I read that although being cheaper there's not that much difference to the artist grade one - and since I am not an artist nor wealthy)? I was leaning towards W.N. but after seeing this video Sennelier warmed to me... So yeah, can't make up my mind! Opinions, please? Thank you. :D
@ad6449
@ad6449 4 жыл бұрын
Tess Might I suggest trying the Sennelier 8 ½-pan set? It is the one in the little white tin? It has the primaries and allows one to try out the paints before making a bigger investment. You can also fine a starter set of Sennelier tubes, 5 in total, for about the same price. Both are excellent beginner sets and are under US$25.
@quintessaence
@quintessaence 4 жыл бұрын
A D you may suggest anything you want! :) Thank you for thinking along.
@ad6449
@ad6449 4 жыл бұрын
Tess May all this paint please you!
@halfabee
@halfabee 5 жыл бұрын
Comparing the Watercolour pigment between Jackson's own brand and Sennelier they are exactly the same pigments for each colour also the binder and tube size 21ml is the same. Jackson own brand is cheaper. Implies Sennelier makes Jacksons own brand watercolour paint.
@Renilou2
@Renilou2 5 жыл бұрын
What is the pigment number on your White Night quin red? I beleive it may be a different pigment number than the other two. Sennelier and Schmincke is a pigment PR209. White Night, I believe is PV19. So that will explain why its so much brighter, darker and cooler because that how PV19 is. Its actually a Quinacridone Rose/Magenta. More than one watercoor brand will call this a Quin Red.
@halfabee
@halfabee 5 жыл бұрын
Schmincke Quin Red Light is pigment PR207 Sennelier Quin Red is PR209 Jacksons do not sell Schmincke Quin Red Nor St Petersburg Quin Red.
@nursen2106
@nursen2106 3 жыл бұрын
re-watching this video after some month, I can now contribute something :-D the quin.... colours could be the issue, for what you want to achieve. not only schmicke has these intense quin... colours, that tend to look flat. for what you do, quina.. colours often don't behave like some artists like. I have heard from some artists now (and I mean master-classe level e.g. even Thomas Schaller mentions it at one point), don't use those all together. no matter wich brand. I can't say anything about Sennelier. I only had two very small tubes for experimenting as an absolute beginner. those were disappointing, which says nothing. but I have the white nights set (sadly - baught to quickly and too many pans at once), and I think, they are just different behaving colours all together. more rough and so. That it states quin....red may only refer to the hue. and the information they provide on their website is so low. I assume, it might be that. I only know, the moment, I want to mix and match, white nights is disapointing. when it comes to layer with different colours, the same. and only using one of the many affordable colours for one area and another for the next area. this to me is almost like painting a colouring book or for illustrations. I am not into that look. the moment you try something else, it is a struggle. I know, some Russian artists work with them. I still think, for them it is also a hastle. they just got used to it. the moment, they could afford something else, I bet the switch. Although those quin...(can't spell it - sorry) seem to be popular among some youtubers and for some, who like flower paintings, all in all I think, they are not so easy to work with and usually look flat. and that is why, I would like to see another comparison - with a different shade :-D It's like filling out a whish list for Christmas
@SuperExadidas
@SuperExadidas 5 жыл бұрын
Thank you for sharing these demo. I would like to order the Red, Yellow and Blue of Sennelier Artist grade in tubes, as a beginner, can you pls help me what color code l need to use in ordering? Thank you
@ad6449
@ad6449 4 жыл бұрын
willie cheng Sennelier has two starter sets to choose from. One is the small 8 half-pan set for under US$25 and the other is a five tube set with the primaries and a couple other colors. It is also under US$25. Both can be found at Jacksons Art. I liked the 8 ½ pan set as my first set of Sennelier as it had the 3 primary colors plus others. It was the perfect way to try them out.
@nathalie9040
@nathalie9040 4 жыл бұрын
Hi 😊. It' a good exercise to practice not to do "blooms". I don't know if that's how we say it 🤔.
@AlyonasWatercolourCreations
@AlyonasWatercolourCreations 4 жыл бұрын
Nathalie is it? Blooms are stunning ;)
@nathalie9040
@nathalie9040 4 жыл бұрын
Yes Nathalie 😊 I was talking about the water halos. Is it the same thing that "blooms" ?
@AlyonasWatercolourCreations
@AlyonasWatercolourCreations 4 жыл бұрын
Nathalie sorry it came out funny. 😅 Your name was filled in automatically. I meant to say “is it a good thing to not practice blooms?” - traditional watercolour artists try to avoid blooms but I find the blooms are a lot more appreciated in the modern watercolour art. Also depends on the style of the art. But having said that, personally I love blooms and find them stunning, especially with granulating or separating colours. :)
@nathalie9040
@nathalie9040 4 жыл бұрын
Thanks Alyona for your answer 😊. Have a good day
@heather333
@heather333 4 жыл бұрын
Schmincke is over rated imo. I find many of their watercolours chalky and opaque, more like gouache. You are correct in saying they have a larger drying shift. I think this is due to their pigments being corser - less finely ground, however, when you look at their colour chart, a high percentage are hues of two or more pigments, which means mixes are more likely to make mud. W&N and Sinnelier are beautiful watercolours. Excellent for glazing. The pigments are very fine and between the two brands I have found the best - pure, fine pigments for my various pallets. I haven't tried White Knights, but on the basis of this test I'll try a CMY a
@carlosdommar
@carlosdommar 3 жыл бұрын
I'm really surprised you find Schmincke "chalky and opaque", and I think Schmincke is know for its very fine ground pigments, but I maybe mistaken with this last one.
@raquelsanchez9668
@raquelsanchez9668 Жыл бұрын
If you want the watercolors to move in the water, just add ox gall to the water. :)
@luckarian6041
@luckarian6041 6 жыл бұрын
Lol, you wash the pigments away with your “wetting the pan”. Just buy an empty spray bottle, fill it with water and spray your pans before painting.
@sandjune2753
@sandjune2753 Жыл бұрын
If you do a comparison, it is best to do on the same paper for both/all. Papers can effect the result so it would be a unfair comparison . You would also need to compare the same pigment codes, or this too is an unfair and not a correct comparison. So I am disappointed in your review, as this is not a fair comparison
@sanayavg
@sanayavg 3 жыл бұрын
U didn’t do the white knights rose correctly.
@cataliniulian5972
@cataliniulian5972 3 жыл бұрын
do you realise that your brush is not for watercolour ?
@indigodande7542
@indigodande7542 6 жыл бұрын
Great Idea for a video a little bit unnecessarily long.
@nettiemoss324
@nettiemoss324 4 жыл бұрын
This is an excellent review for Schmincke v Sennelier but totally wrong to have White Knight in with those: WK is a much inferior, student/amateur/beginner brand whereas the other two are choices of professionals so you are not comparing like for like: as your result showed! but well done for attempting!
@AlyonasWatercolourCreations
@AlyonasWatercolourCreations 4 жыл бұрын
I prefer White Nights to Sennelier watercolour by far, the pigment ratio to binder is in my opinion far more superior! As far as I know White Nights are artists grade watercolour, they have a separate range that is student grade. :)
@nettiemoss324
@nettiemoss324 4 жыл бұрын
thanks! shall check that out as there was only one grade when I bought mine: maybe things have changed, hard to keep up!
@vladyslavsingur9979
@vladyslavsingur9979 3 жыл бұрын
WN is not student grade brand, is high end watercolors.
@carlosdommar
@carlosdommar 3 жыл бұрын
Good to know about White Nights as they are REALLY cheap (price-wise) in my town. But I mean CHEAP as half the price of Sennelier and 1/3 the price of Schmincke!
@achromium63
@achromium63 5 жыл бұрын
What paper did you use for your swatches?
@AlyonasWatercolourCreations
@AlyonasWatercolourCreations 5 жыл бұрын
This was the Stillman and Birn Beta Series sketchbook.
Comparing Daniel Smith to Sennelier Watercolours
20:51
Tammy Newman
Рет қаралды 16 М.
WHAT’S THAT?
00:27
Natan por Aí
Рет қаралды 14 МЛН
Эффект Карбонаро и нестандартная коробка
01:00
История одного вокалиста
Рет қаралды 10 МЛН
DEFINITELY NOT HAPPENING ON MY WATCH! 😒
00:12
Laro Benz
Рет қаралды 63 МЛН
I Tried All the Watercolors and These 7 Are the Best!
18:36
Paintcrush with Kristy Rice
Рет қаралды 284 М.
Review: St Petersburg's White Nights 12-pan Watercolour Set
16:13
Teoh Yi Chie
Рет қаралды 121 М.
My Top 10 Favorite Watercolor Brands - 2019 Edition!
21:52
Denise Soden
Рет қаралды 384 М.
Are White Nights Watercolors actually GOOD? 🤔
14:33
Emily Olson Art
Рет қаралды 27 М.
Vangogh Vs White Nights ~ Cheap watercolor set comparison
17:19
Niaz Hannan Watercolors
Рет қаралды 39 М.
Swatching Sennelier watercolors | FINALLY!!
25:44
My Fantastical Imaginarium
Рет қаралды 3,7 М.
Akademie vs. Horadam: A comparison of Schmincke Watercolours
32:24
The Colour Cave
Рет қаралды 6 М.
WHAT’S THAT?
00:27
Natan por Aí
Рет қаралды 14 МЛН