Good Morning Mike, Thinking out loud: If you cupel it and get a nice bead - you're still going to separate the metals in the bead to figure out how much of each you got. Put it in acid & get the gold. Save the time, a little cupel, & propane for another project! Glad to see the old crucible worked as a cupel! I've had good luck using portland cement - just never did a button as big as yours. Have a great day, Jim
@royalrefining61822 жыл бұрын
Hi. Its way too hot for starters, shouldn't be bubbling like how it was at the start. To oxidise the lead it needs oxygen. A small blower adding air over the top will solve that problem. Or don't put it into the furnace have it in open air and use or fix the torch to a stand and let it do its thing. To start have the flame hitting the lead directly, once molten fix the torch so it's blowing over the metal but hot enough to keep it molten. This is when it starts "driving" and you'll see the lead oxide start rolling off the molten bead and into the cement powder The slag forming on top isn't lead its most likely copper and tin and most likely others through the jaw crushing and what not. This slag must be scraped off (and kept in case) whilst the reaction is happening
@matthewf19792 жыл бұрын
I just remembered all the failures from the last video! I was feeling bad for you.
@djcbanks2 жыл бұрын
Whenever I cupel things in my furnace, I get it hot, open the lid, then turn of the burner and let it sit/let fresh air into the kiln and repeat. I find if you leave it running, it uses up all the oxygen and cupellation will take forever. But if you get it molten then turn off the flame and keep the lid open, it goes much faster. For me, it’s ideal to keep it molten and keep the lid off. I also like to use the blower side of my shop vac to blow air over the top of the furnace and that helps tremendously as well.
@TrevorsBench2 жыл бұрын
I watched the MBMM video where Jason ground up whole boards before it went on the shaker table. The amounts of PMs in those boards was small considering the volume of base metals. Jason's process will work great for copper recovery but any PMs will get diluted by the large amount of base metals and separating the two after is proving near impossible, as you're experiencing The only way to capture PMs with any certainty is to cherry pick the boards first to eliminate the large volume of base metals.
@omegageek642 жыл бұрын
It is certainly looking that way. Even just recovering the copper is no walk in the park.
@kylestrokelitus3602 жыл бұрын
how frustrating that the base metals dont just disappear....im being serious cause this is frustrating. lol
@TheDurdane2 жыл бұрын
Thanks again for this very nice experiment, Mike. I think there is a problem with the shape of your oven. The gas comes in, in an angle and creates a vortex and rapidly moves and disappears upwards. The extra oxygen you mix with the gas, therefor, isn't efficient i.m.o. Electric ovens, with a door on the front, will let circle the heat in the oven, i.e. convection. Adding air using the outside port from a vacuum cleaner could help indeed, but still the lid on top will not help. I think the suggestion of doing the process out of the oven with a broad torch in a stand (as someone else in this thread suggested) could give a positive outcome, since the oxygen that is taken from the surroundings are directly applied to the material in cupel. You have to watch out for the temperature of course, but that can be measured (which I recommend anyhow in any kind of setting you use). The temperature can be controlled then by applying and removing the torch; which also has the advantage that when the flame is not on the cupel, oxygen isn't blown away.
@Pyrannasaurus Жыл бұрын
Cupel them more together. Dont know about oxide absorbtion in cupels, but maybe there was zinc and tin oxides that use up more than lead oxides?
@Enjoymentboy2 жыл бұрын
I think the bubbling you had in the crucible cupel was due to moisture and not trapped air. I'd heat up the loose cement to around 450-500°F and hold it there for an hour at a minimum to make sure you drive off as much moisture as possible Just like when I do casting with plaster molds you HAVE to get all the water out of it first before you even consider letting molten metal touch it. And while I have not done it myself I have seen where people have a second air tube inlet in their furnace to allow them to add more oxygen without affecting the flame itself. That might help speed up the oxidation. But seeing the amount you started with and that you're under a half gram and STILL haven't cleaned it up I'm really beginning to think there have been a lot of losses along the way. Not to say you've done anything wrong though. this stuff happens with trial and error. That's why I like to go back to tried and true methods when dealing with an unknown. Figure out what's there first and then find alternate ways to get it out. I know it's not what most people would do (or want to hear) but I still think you're best bet is to do an HCl soak first to get rid of any tin, zinc or aluminium and then work on what is left. When you have such a hodgepodge of metals all mixed together like this it's never going to be a simple 123 process. But I do commend you on this. You really are giving it the old college try and not backing down.
@keithyinger33262 жыл бұрын
At 16:42 when your talking about wondering if there's enough oxygen in the furnace, it sounds like your burner is pulse jetting. So part of the extra oxygen that you are thinking you might be sucking in is getting burned inside the burner tube before it even gets into the furnace. I have a gas burner and furnace like that myself as well and I know how finicky they can be to get to burn at a low temperature, but if you can get it to quit pulse jetting, you might be able to get more oxygen into the furnace itself before it gets burned up on the way there. I can hear the burner earlier in the video and it's a nice steady Flame with no pulse jetting. Like I said though, I have a setup like that and I know that might be impossible to do at a low enough temperature.
@bocamint49372 жыл бұрын
Does adding an air supply help?
@djcbanks2 жыл бұрын
Yes it will help speed up the oxide production and subsequent absorption tremendously.
@frankzahn77732 жыл бұрын
Yes, redo them with a little more lead. Love your vids.
@clairleasure4342 жыл бұрын
I was wondering if the oven you got in your last pickup video would go high enough to use for this process. I know lead melts a little over 600 degrees but not sure how hot it would need to be for this. Maybe shoot Jason at mbmm an email to see if he would be kind enough to give you some pointers. Love the experiments keep up the great content.
@carlgodfrey2974 Жыл бұрын
The temp for this process should be around 1800 degrees for best results. I watch a lot of MBMM videos that Jason posts.
@KD0CAC2 жыл бұрын
Still learning here , but this is what I think I know ;) I am questioning cuppelling in fueled [ propane adds moisture & ??? ] so the need for induction / electric heat ? I Do not remember if you were familiar TIG & MIG welding ? Need to have specific gases depending on what your welding , in this case you need o2 for oxidizing . Not that I know it will not work , my guess, not as it should with fueled heat - giving multiple gases besides the water [ this comes from knowledge - in an emergency used " unvented propane heater " in RV in the winter , let alone been hearing about it many yrs. ] Next thing that occurs to me is - thermostatically controlled heat - either fuel or electric - to control phase transition / from liquid to gas , the specific metals - much lower for lead [ 621.5 F ] etc. And not using "gas welding / cutting torches with gold , temps for cutting & welding 3200 F " . Gold - 1943 F Silver - 1763 F Platinum group above gas cutting / welding . Again to get to work better - you already got some real cuppels ;)
@KD0CAC2 жыл бұрын
Dang , got caught by metric issue , ox acetylene fahrenheit F is 5800 - 6300 ;)
@kylestrokelitus3602 жыл бұрын
proceed by doing what you stated....add the results to about 30g additional pure lead and cupel with lid cracked at a constant temp no greater than 1750 F I believe is what I was told. I use an electric muffle furnace and have yet to get a cupellation process that works even remotely close to what I learn from here on youtube. My guess is impurities just as you suggested, so try and refine them again? Looking forward to seeing the next video.
@josephgardner5891 Жыл бұрын
your melt was too hot. only heat to ta little over the melting temp of lead.. your making something else at the hi temp you used.
@johannesdesloper84342 жыл бұрын
I have no expierience with this, but I do watch Jason a lot. Jason says Copper is hard to cupel. motherboards have loads of copper ofcourse
@johannesdesloper84342 жыл бұрын
I've seen Indians cupel a lot. When they do a rough cupel they just use a stainless steel tub on a blacksmith fire and skim off the oxides with a steel rake. They usually also add some Silver to act as colector metal.
@PaulAllee Жыл бұрын
You can but one now you got that new job
@SaraJean85 Жыл бұрын
Not all the way finished.. it WILL BE A BEAD IF ITS DONE
@shaneyork3002 жыл бұрын
I was and am so behind on watching your videos!
@kenjett24342 жыл бұрын
In my opinion would be better to break it down with acid that way there is opportunity to test to see just what is there.
@matthewf19792 жыл бұрын
Oh, he’s tried that. This stuff is a tough nut to crack.
@kenjett24342 жыл бұрын
@@matthewf1979 true he tried it on material before it was smelted. I was referring to what he got in this video after smelting and cupeling. With all the junk removed what's left is a alloy of precious metal. Breaking it down with acid will allow testing to see just what metals make up the alloy.
@jamisontaylor8782 жыл бұрын
Temperature is key my friend
@omegageek642 жыл бұрын
What is the ideal temperature?
@kylestrokelitus3602 жыл бұрын
@@omegageek64 i believe no greater than 1750 F, but im a newbe myself
@djcbanks2 жыл бұрын
For your reference: Lead melts at 327 °C, lead oxide at 888 °C, and silver melts at 960 °C. To separate the silver, the alloy is melted again at the high temperature of 960 °C to 1000 °C in an oxidizing environment. The lead oxidises to lead monoxide, then known as litharge, which captures the oxygen from the other metals present. The liquid lead oxide is removed or absorbed by capillary action into the hearth linings. This chemical reaction may be viewed as Ag(s) + 2 Pb(s) + O2(g) → 2 PbO(absorbed) + Ag(l)
@kylestrokelitus3602 жыл бұрын
@@djcbanks just trying to follow the equation what is the 2(g) or is that a typo for 2(S) since the sulfur atom gets released as the oxygen atom replaces it right?
@keithyinger33262 жыл бұрын
@@djcbanks I was wondering if the irregular shape of the buttons at the end might be because they had Platinum Group Metals in them. The temperature in that furnace might not be hot enough to melt them completely. So once it gets to a certain concentration of precious metals, it just solidifies and the reaction stops.
@robertjeffery32372 жыл бұрын
just part the beads with nitric acid.
@ManMountainMetals Жыл бұрын
Lead oxide is being blocked from the cement by the graphite crucible.
@davidstevenson21132 жыл бұрын
Dont buy a electric furnace as they continually break down, i have been doing precious metals recovery for alot of years and the best thing i ever did was buy a gas furnace !
@frantiseklaluch66052 жыл бұрын
Well, gas furnace is realy great, when cupeling a lot, no doubt. For hobby, small tabletop electric furnace does not cost kidney and does the job well. Mine was like 400 USD just 10x10x10 cm (4x4x4 inch), handles #12 cupel (I use #8 max).
@baja2212 жыл бұрын
I vote throw them in a new cupel with a couple grams of lead.
@ManMountainMetals Жыл бұрын
Leadpool jokes are a sure sign of heavy metal 💀 toxicity see your doctor immediately.
@frantiseklaluch66052 жыл бұрын
EDIT: I think, that the temperature was too high (above melting point of silver), also the capacity of cupel is at some temperature (980 celsius) and it is absobtion of litharge (PbO), othewise the oxides run through. Look at fireassay EU (not com), a lot of knowledge there. This looks like my first cupeling atempt. I made cupel out of magnesium oxide and clay flower pot. Disaster. Then I bought cupels from Spain (company Fireassay), they sent me all the know-how documentation as bonus, works like a charm...
@ManMountainMetals Жыл бұрын
Leadpool jokes are a sure sign of heavy metal 💀 toxicity see your doctor immediately.