A Farm Dog Should NEVER Do This

So I had a bit of a training setback with Toby, our Maremma Livestock Guardian Dog. And I know it's only puppy behavior, but it's important to ensure that this type of thing doesn't happen.
KZbin: / goldshawfarm
Web: www.goldshawfar...
Facebook: / goldshawfarm
Instagram: / goldshawfarm
Twitter: / goldshawfarm
Send us mail:
Gold Shaw Farm
PO Box 225
Peacham, VT 05862
About Gold Shaw Farm: Gold Shaw Farm is more of a farm-in-progress than an honest-to-goodness farm. Our dream is that someday we are able to transform our 150+ acre parcel of land into a regenerative and productive homestead and farm.

[@BradMyers]

Your dog is a teenager right now, if you only have to discipline him one time, you are doing great.

[@brendamontanye9877]

I am not convinced that he is a teenager yet. LGDs need about 2 years to be considered reliable. Too many folks believe they are done training when the pup is a year or so old. Well, that's what I've read. We adopted our LGDs when they each were 6, which conversely is considered getting old for a LGD. It's always something, haha. I'm glad that you are taking training seriously, regardless. I'm really glad that you have mentors instead of relying on comments like this one :)

[@BradMyers]

​@@brendamontanye9877 relax, it was a funny comment. Regardless of the age of the dog, they always need taken care of which is food, love, and discipline.

[@HannaFardew]

@Truelove and at the time this video was recorded, toby would have been 4 months old as he got toby at 3 months of age

[@kaiserwilhelm1938]

Wrong. His dog in the video is in adolescence. 'Teenager' behavior in livestock guardian breeds is entirely different, and will be seen 2021/22

[@dona4him942]

How about, he's more like a toddler.

[@lizarnold87]

That was no harsher than you would yell at a child for running towards the street....you have to be the daddy...good job..

[@dindinprivate3477]

I have been a dog trainer for 40 years now. I have never worked specifically with farm dogs, but as far as proper training for a pup you did exactly the right thing. You corrected him at the moment of the crime with a tone of voice that he could recognize easily as negative feed back. You talk to him all the time as well as giving positive feedback. You are ABSOLUTELY CORRECT in your decision not to use a shock collar.

[@alwayshangrygirl463]

I'm so pleased to see a dog trainer who stands against shock collars. It makes me so sad that lots of trainers actually advise shock collars "because they're safe if used correctly", which is horrific! There're dozens of KZbin channels who advocate for shock collars. They all thrush me in the comments, call me stupid and tell me that I know nothing about dogs. I'm not a professional trainer, but my family adopted 15 "dangerous" GSDs and a 2 year old rottweiler who was about to be euthanased for biting. My dad used the dogs for farming. All of them were sweet dogs and I could never understand why their first owners gave them up. Dogs are easy, you give them respect and explain boundaries, and they'll respect you back. Now I own a husky. He's 10 months old and very calm. He's the friendliest chap ever. He can get excited if he sees a dog that he's never seen before and for the UPS guy. Because everyone knows that UPS guys bring treats 🤣. No shock collars, no prong collars, just a simple 'yes/no" approach, delayed gratification training and a long lead (50 metres) for semi-free runs. I corrected him once (slight tap on the nose and said "no" strongly) when he was 3 months old and tried to bite my nose. I don't think that it was aggressive. It was more like "let me taste your nose". Otherwise he's a very good boy, knows tricks and can stay close off leash when I take him to a local shop. He can also say 'hello, how are you?" And thus became a local celebrity. Love him to bits and will never ever use a shock collar on him. The only thing he struggles with is to return to me when he sees a rabbit. Do you have advice how to stop him hunting rabbits? He's never killed any, but he loves running for them. And if he started, it's no way I can stop him. Another problem is that he doesn't do the standard still focus, like the majority of hunting dogs do. So I find it difficult to recognise when he's about to run. This is the only reason why I use the long lead instead of letting him off leash in field areas. I taught him "leave it" a long time ago. He's good at it, but it doesn't work on rabbits. So I bought a rabbit dummy to teach him "leave it". He leaves the dummy, but not real rabbits. Any advice is appreciated

[@alwayshangrygirl463]

Sorry for the essay. Any advice is appreciated 😀

[@denissefaylo9593]

@@alwayshangrygirl463 no you’re right. Many trainers go for the shock collar as an easy fix. I must say though, I have used a tense unit of a collar and it saved my rescue’s life. I had to use it to train him out of biting. I used it on myself before using it on him, because I wouldn’t have used it otherwise. A puppy should NEVER be exposed to a shock collar of any kind. An older very stubborn breed MAY need it as a last resort. NEVER as a go to tool. Same as prong collars. I see too many people leaving them on their dogs as if they were a regular collar and it’s upsetting. They are not dangerous, but they are not an all day collar. I’m thankful for your dad that took in those GSD. They are a handful but super loyal. Too many people give up on dogs nowadays for the dumbest reasons, or try to discipline them in the worst ways.

[@alwayshangrygirl463]

@@denissefaylo9593 I donno man. My dad taught GSDs with bite history without a shock collar. He did a lot of calmness training (like picnic training) and lots of trust training, some click training. And they listened to him. I've never seen my dad shout at them in an aggressive way. Nothing like that. I used the same technique when training my husky. And it works! I don't believe that huskies are stubborn or unruly or they want to escape from your garden all the time. I think that people who say those things about huskies bought a dog for decoration.

[@angieadamo2843]

@@denissefaylo9593 if a shock collar is needed the trainer should have one also

[@kattitaniummelonparker3408]

Pablo wants to know what Toby gets a treat for staying when he's being doing that all morning.

[@GoldShawFarm]

I tried to train Pablo. He had zero interest.

[@Bert2368]

@@winterszhuzhupets2 Wrong. No hitting of ANY type is done by a competent trainer. Anyone who has trained dogs for a while can very quickly tell when they encounter an animal that has been hit during some idiot half assed training attempt.

[@thegrim418]

@@Bert2368 Restraint and moderation. My folks used to breed dogs and most of the breeders and trainers they knew used flyswatters to discipline the big dogs. It made a loud noise that startled them but didn't harm them.

[@kylealexander7024]

@@Bert2368 animals understand voice tone well

[@susangarland6869]

Teenagers. They're the same no matter the species. That "no" was delivered perfectly, both in timing and in pitch. And, Toby, because he's the perfect dog, immediately responded after the first "no." The subsequent "no"s, by doggie logic, were directed at his retreat. A bit confusing. Next time, give one "no," and wait to see what happens. And that "only positive reinforcement" nonsense might work for purse Chihuahuas, but with the strong, intelligent, independent working breeds, it's very important that the line between right and wrong is crystal clear. You're doing an excellent job with Mr. McFluffy.

[@cookie856]

Chihuahua are the worst educated dogs in general, so no. Even with dogs scared of their shadow you don't.

[@possummilk2971]

@@cookie856 You've clearly never met a well bred chihuahua. Very sweet and willing to learn.

[@cookie856]

@@possummilk2971 I mean, well breed dogs in general are willing to learn.

[@leonasnake]

I feel like it's important to have balance in training dogs. A dog needs to know when it's done something that isn't ok, and not overdo it, as they'd be taught by other dogs. I don't believe you did anything wrong. Quick, stern, no physical harm. I'm sure Toby will grow to be an excellent working dog 😊

[@mariemaroney7891]

He’s pretty smart, he listened right away to you. Apparently you’re doing something right.

[@myakye]

i wouldnt worry too much about what others say about training "your" dog, remember what the mother dog would do if her pup would do something she didnt like...she would growl or even possibly snap at her pup to put it in line.

[@helenscott8202]

Or use her body to knock him sideways.

[@SunraeSkatimunggr]

Considering how young Tobby still is, that was a small "bad". Good job. My two year old blue healer mix still has a hard time staying as long as Tobby did.

[@lorineidtinytoadplot744]

You handled Toby perfectly, he instantly understood he was doing something wrong and came to you. I instantly thought WOW nice job. He obviously respects you. After working with rescues most of my life I have to say this dog isn't going to be one, coutos to you 👌😊

[@mercswifejl]

Everybody is a critic when it's not their business! Do what works for YOU and TOBY!! If someone gives you advice and it works? GREAT.....that works for you! Watching these videos (being a trainer) you've done an amazing job!!! Had I thought you were missing/lacking something that could cause harm to anyone I may have made a suggestion but you got this!!

[@GoldShawFarm]

Thank you!

[@LaughtersMelody]

I'm glad to see that the barn cats are tolerating Toby now, even if they still don't look entirely pleased, lol. :)

[@Lizard1582]

This is like the only channel where I watch every upload.

[@GoldShawFarm]

Thank you!

[@bibliotek6450]

Have used these vids as teaching tools for rescues we place.

[@carloporter1373]

It's really interesting going back and watching your older videos. Toby was such a cute puppy and you can already see his potential.

[@robertcarswell2907]

I see no problems with you reprimanding Toby. He needs to know how to behave as a livestock guard dog

[@terrydodson430]

There’s different ways to train a dog and I think u and Toby r doing just fine. In fact, Toby seems to be learning faster than my Pyr., Dan , at that age.

[@GinaSiska]

I love how honest and humble you are about yourself...and I love how sweet and adorable Toby is 😉😇😘

[@ColonialFungus]

Negative reinforcement is vital for screw ups. Your doing exactly the right thing.

[@DougZaga]

Where in this video did you see him use R-?

[@tonytomato100]

@@DougZaga I'm sure you can tell he means positive punishment

[@ColonialFungus]

@@DougZaga I meant reprimanding bad behavior, might have used the wrong terminology.

[@DougZaga]

@@ColonialFungus Ahhh ok. thanks for responding. I only asked because I did not see R- or hear him speak of it. No harm no foul (peace) Have a great night!

[@DougZaga]

@@tonytomato100 I was not sure what was meant that is why I asked Solitaire. Thanks for that and after Solitaire's response it seems like that was the quadrant of OC he or she was talking about. (peace)

[@bennystropicalswimmigwolf8691]

very good looking Livestock Guardian pup

[@theresalind8031]

I adore Toby. ❤ He's why I've started watching. He is doing wonderfully. I believe that your obvious affection for the lil fella is the main contribution to his charming personality . P.S.Thank you for doing the channel.

[@aliiljah8224]

You are a very nice man. I love the way you take care of your critters. It's the same way I do. I love your videos and the way you edit them, they are hilarious. Toby is a sweet dog, how old is he? I live in Pennsylvania, we are not getting any winters or snow for quite a few years, it is my favorite season and I truly miss it.

[@leaflover9625]

Toby is doing fantastic. He responded immediately to your stern NO and came right back to you. And he always comes when you call him. You are doing an excellent job with him.

[@MrBeck-ly1kb]

Your doing great. I raised livestock guardian dogs 20 years. Keep up the good work.

[@vetiejanedeguzman722]

I meant I am having fun learning about how farmers got it hard. Super dedicated. Love it. :) I don’t think I can do it my self but is fun watching everyone else loving their farm life. Is like my dream self, or like my fairy tale life that I could only hope for. :) maybe someday don’t know when. :) thank goodness I you guys to watch, is so much fun on my free time. Thank you 🙏

[@DS-ky9dl]

You did it perfectly, done and over. We all learn by our mistakes and you still have that great bond with him.

[@skavossis5377]

He'll get it, he such a good boi.

[@Laflamablanca969]

He lookin thicc though 😏 well, his coat is 👍

[@hnktbt]

man i love your videos. they really bring me the wholesome peace i need to reconnect with the simpler side of life. thanks for documenting your journey and sharing it with us.

[@GoldShawFarm]

Thank you! It makes me feel really good to hear that people enjoy them.

[@Paul_Au]

I like how it appears that Toby the teenager now gets to sleep with the door to his "Room" open, and has a little run area attached to the kennel so he is able to begin "patrolling" behavior before you are even up... and possibly through the night as well. He doesn't appear to feel the cold... so I highly doubt he would be shivering in his "room" at night. Sending this message to you from Sub Tropical South East Queensland, Australia. Today's Max temp 37C ...98.6F

[@missyc13]

I love the way you train your dog! My sister in law just graduated dog behavior and how to train them, how to learn to stop something from happening before it happens and showed this video to her. She absolutely praises you on how you train and listen to the people helping you. She always says, a dog is like a child but with their own tells. Learn them and you can be their parent. Dismiss them and you have a dog that acts out

[@PensionerPondFarm]

We were sad to see Toby mess up there. He's a good boy! We're an up and coming NEK Permaculture Farm up by the border. We've considered doing more ducks and even geese, by your inspiration, for a more resilient homestead in the uncertain years ahead. We respect your bravery, breaking from Consumerism to a degree and braving the coldest part of Vermont here in the Kingdom. We watch your progress every week. Keep at it Morgan!

[@jdkOutdoors]

I want to say, “Thank you, Morgan.” This is gonna go long and sound kinda cheesy, but I mean every word of it. I’ve followed you since the early days. Thank you for the work you do on your farm and thank you for the additional effort it takes to share with the KZbin world. Thank you for your kind and patient nature. Thank you for your witty vlog commentary. Thank you for your love of animals and showing the reality that it includes harvesting for meat, predator control, etc. Thank you for sharing the history of your farm and the passion you and your wife are cultivating to keep it going despite the necessity for “real” jobs. I’m a bit of a reformed hippy. I have a real job. My wife has a real job. We both find your posts akin to meditation. 😂 We don’t “ohm” to them, but they are so fulfilling and relaxing. Thank you, Morgan.

[@electronicfreak1111]

I completely agree with you with the dog thing the best thing is a mixture of positive and negative reinforcement like with an infant they do something when you get angry do something right and you’re happy

[@jaypeabee]

You’ve done a good job with gentle training of your dog. I loved seeing the way you taught him.

[@BbyKiS2y]

Anyone who has no prior experience in training LGD have no business giving you tips. You do you. You know your dog best and how to get him to listen. So glad to see Toby grow into such a wonderful guardian. You did great.

[@egsuperduty]

Those are teaching moments. He will test boundaries. So giving him firm clear rules will help. Stay positive Morgan.

[@rottsrool]

I’ve been training dogs for years and you nailed it ! You caught the situation with Toby straight away and verbally corrected him nothing more needed well done.

[@LaneyandherGermanShepherds]

Good Balance training is so important ,coming from someone whom has a 6 PACK OF GERMAN SHEPHERDS!!I I really love Toby ,love learning about the LSGD

[@piteusx8440]

Your dog is a loveable doofus. IMO, one stern "no" at time of the negative action is enough. Too many stern "nos" might confuse the dog as he stops the action and he keeps hearing NOs. It's important to catch them in the act and use that stern NO at that exact time. They'll start figuring it out. Remember dogs can tell a negative sound by the tone of your voice. They just need to hear it. Whether it's a loud scream or stern tone, it's the same to the dog. Toby is smart and attentive. He was bred for it. A stern NO should be enough and perhaps a timeout if he gets too distracted. And don't forget a lot of treats and pets for positive reinforcements.

[@Berkeloid0]

Definitely agree, you could see he immediately knew he'd done something wrong and went to hightail it out of there, so the one 'no' seemed like it was plenty. Also looked like he got over it pretty quickly once he realised Morgan wasn't too upset with him which I think is perfect.

[@Jaxen90841]

Think he was just following the ducks.

[@phdtobe]

Piteus X Morgan, consider using a sound other than “NO” to tell Toby to stop doing something. A dog trainer who worked with me some years ago who trained dogs to perform for TV commercials taught me to use a raspy open-mouth undulating screeching sound to communicate to a dog to stop doing something. This sound cuts through almost any other sound and is not like normal speech, so there is almost no other time other than when he is be disciplined that Toby would hear that sound. And that makes it much more likely to effectively communicate “stop” to a dog than saying or yelling “no”.

[@OrangeMilks]

cfjackie46 that’s right! Never use the dog’s name as a correction noise or in a negative situation/manner. You want the dog to associate its name to positivity and also as a “command” to pay attention to you.

[@juliemcgugan1244]

Absolutely correct! When I correct my dogs, all it takes it a loud tutting noise, as they dislike harsh sounds and are super sensitive to overly loud noises (one is a formerly abused dog.) I can’t even use a clicker, as she is afraid of the noise. Don’t think that one approach fits all cases, Morgan. You and Toby will find your own groove! You guys are doing great, already and you will grow and learn together!

[@stephenriley9084]

Morgan, Dog training. You can pretty much do it all with your voice. Just like you showed. I think you two are heading in the right direction. Regards Stephen.

[@shortforsophie]

This video has honestly aged like fine wine. Not only has Toby become an exceptional livestock guardian, but he is also a beautiful, healthy, *happy* dog. It’s lovely to watch these moments knowing how well all your effort pays off.

[@EdwinvandenAkker]

I'm watching this in The Netherlands... on *August 18th.* When we had too many weeks of high temperatures and drought! It is so surreal to see snow. I can't wait to see snow!!! ❄️☃️

[@monkeynumbernine]

It's wonderful to watch all of them🦆 I have a blue fronted amazon parrot and my fiance has a tomcat... the cat out- weighs my bird by 15 pounds. Parrot is absolutely fearless and sends kitty running... any time I think kitty is stalking parrot, the tables turn and kitty ends up across the room, sulking and parrot is fluffing and preening. 🐦🐈

[@jazminebohanan1317]

You're doing a very wonderful job with Toby. He is still a puppy so he will have set backs still for a bit. But he is doing very well for his age! You're rocking at what you're doing!!

[@ianrobinson8974]

My girl has just passed 12 months old and she is 98% brilliant! Greeting from very warn Australia, keep it up.

[@clover309]

You’re a great dog dad and farm dog trainer. He’s well loved and will learn to be an astute protector!

[@aron8949]

The barn cat clearly is the one who made toby stay.

[@FarmerC.J.]

He’s a puppy! He’s going to try your boundaries many, many times until he matures❤️

[@gtdoering4630]

As a first time owner of two great pyrenees, I completely agree. The dogs were purchased to guard a small flock of chickens and turkeys. Our dogs are now two years old, and the first 18 months were a challenge (for them and me :-)) There were plenty of set backs and challenges. We are now all in a happy place, although I keep a vigilant eye out for any relapse. Keep up the good work - from my perspective, you are definitely on the right track. And by the way, my dogs are also mobile, chicken pooper scoopers

[@terraranch1459]

I love your videos and always have a great laugh. You are very entertaining and so enjoyable to watch. Great job with correcting Toby. He minded immediately and you have a great dog there. Hugs❤️

[@Pepper5655]

it wasn't a set back it was a learning experience for Toby and thats a good thing, thnx for sharing.

[@kirstenwaugh8473]

I know this is years later, but in case you see this I think you have done such an amazing job training your guardian dogs! I’ve just started watching your videos, and even though Abby is having her set backs I think she’s well on her way to becoming as proficient at her job as Toby dog is ❤️ Keep up the amazing work!

[@flashpointrecycling]

It is not s training set back. It is a training opportunity. He will not know the limits without your help. Good Job!

[@BornAgainFarmGirl]

Awe Toby is a fabulous PUPPY and you are as well . Looking forward to hearing more great updates .

[@morgaankelton5296]

I agree...the weather has been insanely warm for this time of year. I live in eastern OH and the other day it was 70°F

[@dawnchorus8907]

Hello, new sub here. Found your channel over the Christmas holiday and have been binge watching your back catalogue ever since. Love them all (but can't watch the "dispatch" ones, I totally respect your job though). Toby is YOUR dog and it's up to you how you train him, he is doing brilliantly so all credit to you. You are literally living my dream, good luck to you & Alison. Best regards from England.

[@GoldShawFarm]

Thank you!

[@jamesbertolina7903]

I just enjoy your videos. So wonderful to see people learning to farm the whole doing of it. Congrats !!!

[@maggievedrenne7379]

Toby is still a baby. You are doing fine. Believe in the same way.

[@Sassafras30]

You are doing a terrific job. Be confident and trust your instincts!

[@miichiii.]

I agree with you & respect you so much on the way u reprimanded Toby & trained him. I may not have a farm guard dog but I do have a well trained dog who doesn’t go to the bathroom in the house , who is not aggressive, & respects me & my family completely, he doesn’t even bark in the house unless he is protecting us ..I trust my dog with my life & we have never used force or shock collars . So I thank you so much for training him with love & respect but yet sternly. Great job!

[@michaelhaiden6718]

I have trained k9s for many years for protection and we used to use dogs for cow herding since your dog does not have a experienced dog to learn by you have to work harder voice commands alone with hand signals are best your voice changes over distance etc if you wanted to stay or or heard ducks in over a longer distance hand signals work best watch sheep headers they use sounds not words to communicate over great distances and sheep bable it's a lot to it all but damn worth it

[@scooterpush]

You and Toby make a great team. Love your musical choice.

[@cpnotill9264]

Wow Morgan you're doing an awesome job with the farm, KZbin, working and learning how to train Toby while enjoying him! Really good job and while so many people here have their opinions many of us have trained dogs and some with great success. No shock collar. 😁 What I feel is that you AND Toby are learning and you're both smart! Keep it up and thanks for sharing......👍🦆🐾😁

[@jameskensett3788]

Yeah I think the goose with grey wing tips is the pilgrim gander and the other pure white one is a emdem female. Great video btw :)

[@jimputnam2044]

Just like a child. Positive is good but tell them when they do wrong also. Got to be both ways, keep up the good work. I have had dogs you are doing great.

[@LostNationHomestead]

I think you are doing a great job with training Toby! He is going to make a fine guardian for your flocks.

[@bonafideslacker2626]

That dog's a gem; you're doing a fine job with him.

[@beesplease]

You always have such high quality and creative editing, Morgan! It really makes your videos super special :) thank you!

[@purplerain2922]

I just love your dog. He is adorable!

[@johndc7446]

You did the the right thing man. Discipline is one of the greatest form of love. That also counts in humans.

[@melindaalvarez9909]

Totally agree your tone commands and giving praise when he does good he loves to be petted by u use that also when he does good !! Don't let Toby eat any poop from eggs can't risk him getting sick from bird bacteria!! I love how u use movie clips especially with bloopers!! Really enjoyed this helps me destress!! God bless and thanks again!

[@georgettewood8894]

Good job for now with Toby..so good to be part of your channel..good partener..✅✅💎

[@nothanks150]

A 20 second stay for a puppy is a lifetime, nice work whatever method you’re using :)

[@judil3294]

Yes, here in NH Sunday we got up to 55 degrees! Crazy. It did drop to 40 by 8 am though as winter tries to push back in.

[@timberridgeranch4066]

You both are doing great! He's a pup he will have faults but you have a good idea on how to train him. Our Pyrenees was good with birds when she was a pup then she hit the teenage stage in her life and she had to stay separate from them. Now that she is 2 she seems to have matured alot and we are able to keep her with them 24/7 and knock on wood no issues. Its pretty amazing to watch a working dog work.

[@tvjacfarmingtrucking1774]

Tone of voice is your greatest tool for training!

[@cm.4828]

You remind me of the blues clues guy....awesome farm, followed you all last year an this year too! Good videos!

[@LifebyBrianAquatics]

Totally normal, bro. I caught my anatolian pup walking up to one of my hens and stepping on her right before I watched this (because he was bored). He's never killed any birds, but he has been caught 'playing' with the hens a few times, mainly when we leave the farm and the other dog is locked up. Without anyone to play with or interact with he eventually gets bored and tries to roughhouse with the chickens. So we had to start tethering him when we leave if the birds will be out. Only time I don't check on my pup every half hour or so is when all the birds are locked up for the night. Toby will most likely keep doing stuff like that until he's full grown, that's why you have to watch them basically constantly. LGDs weren't originally meant for birds, so it's always a challenge to get a dog that will be a good LGD *and* not want to chase birds when they are puppies. They need some amount of drive to be effective guardians. You are certainly right to correct him, but that's not gonna stop him from being a puppy. The correction probably will have to be reinforced multiple times before he is mature enough to accept it. I find if I redirect their attention on to food, or playing with me immediately after the correction that it is more effective too. The reason is that he's expressing his natural instincts, if they are simply stymied they don't go away. If you redirect that playful energy on to a toy after telling him no about the ducks, he will get to express the energy and learn what is an appropriate way to do so. Good luck!

[@deescord2000]

I'm so happy that the algorithm recommended me your channel ! I LOVE to have come later in the creation of the channel, this way i can binge watch everything ! I love what you do, living me dream.

[@marlenekutcher938]

You are doing find with your training Toby. Being consistent is the best way to train a dog. Do what works for you. Reinforce the good things and giving the dog love for doing good things or just because he is part of your family. He growing fast and seems very smart.

[@stephaniemomma]

For some reason I’m upset that 8 people disliked this video! Lol. I think you’re doing great with your pup 🙂

[@GoldShawFarm]

Thank you!

[@catrionaspeight8826]

Consistent, Morgan. Exactly how you responded to Abby when she did the same thing.

[@Safiliel]

disciplining your dogs is good for their life. Toby will be much happier in the long run if he understands the rules. Your response was totally appropriate, I am studying dog training and its my passion. So I love seeing people doing the right thing.

[@renepena3024]

I look forward to and REALLY enjoy your videos!! 😁

[@LunchBoxNM]

My dog Woody is 11 and he is a very good dog. I still need to set him straight every blue moon. You are doing good man. You got a good dog there.

[@Citystead]

Dogs are like kids everyone is going to judge you on how your raising them and give you advice. Really you just have to do what you think is best.

[@aeonstar5867]

I was just a little bummed you cut that music off at the end, you have such great pick of music. All in all this was a very enjoyable video to watch. It's inspiring to watch Toby train you so well, a very good farm dog indeed.

[@mandydavidson2146]

It's more than obvious that you love Toby..... and obvious that Toby love's you.

[@tracybruring8440]

LGD training is totally different than dog training. I rolled my LGD from the day he entered my property as a pup and to the day he died he lay down every time I walked up to him. however he was death on coyotes.

[@Maxine420]

The way that you are training toby. It has been similar to how I train mine.

[@sandibutler4877]

I think you're doing a great job! I also don't think he was chasing or going after the ducks, looked like he was just going to follow but still he needed a correction. I love this channel!

[@spetsnatzlegion3366]

Damn there is one hell of an echo in your valley! Toby is getting on really well, it’s great that he knows to back off as soon as you say and as just hope he learns from this.

[@sueo.6731]

Toby is a bad, bad boy with sweet little white eyelashes. Auntie Sue should come pick him up - LOL! Totally adorable. Thank you for not hitting or using shock collars on him. I think you are a wonderful dog dad! And he is a keeper!

[@inglis7086]

you did fine with Toby - making a dog into a well behaved member of the farm takes time and patients = a lot of commands and praise and correction then repeat it's like raising human kids it's a lot of work but well worth the effort

[@bobbybabylon1385]

wow you know nothing about livestock dogs.

[@Berkeloid0]

@@bobbybabylon1385 What's wrong with training a livestock dog by giving commands and praise when it does something right?

[@alvinchipmunk3759]

Bobby Babylon ugh ppl like u just wanna start arguments

[@donnajohnson9324]

My boy is 7 month's old different breed and I have chickens I find some times they won't to play with live stock and I agree with you on the shock collars ect and I do the same as you he is doing well your young boy

[@christyjohnson6967]

Just love going along with you and Toby as you do your morning chores (from the warmth and comfort of my cozy kitchen 😊) You are doing such a great job with Toby. You should be proud!

[@GoldShawFarm]

Thank you!

[@cynthiabrennemann3513]

I like that you do what works and not what you are told the only way is. Some dogs do require physical or shock correction. Some do not. As with kids, the type of correction you should use should be based on the individual, not what you've already decided.

[@santryl]

It has been reported by ornithologists that birds will "climb on top of other birds to assert dominance" so you might not have chosen the wrong sex or species, it could be the geese determining rank or status in the flock. You are doing a great job! love you videos

[@vetiejanedeguzman722]

I am a fun. I am new but loving it so far. Super interesting. I had no idea that wow is really a hard job. So many chores to get done every day.:)

[@genevievegreene1595]

He is doing great. So are you.

[@dsauce1257]

Watching in March 2021, definitely gonna say you did a good job training him