Good Not Great with Josh Peck & Ben Soffer

Jennifer and Pumps are joined by two of our favorite podcasters, Josh Peck & Ben Soffer, the hosts of the Good Guys Podcast. Josh has had it with yoga instructors who think they're now some kind of "spiritual giant" and Ben has had it with the insanity of tipping culture - ESPECIALLY at a self-checkout. Jennifer puts the boys on the spot with a salacious Had It or Hit It question that leads to Pumps revealing a very scandalous answer.
Come see I've Had It live on the Hot Sh*t Tour! More info & tickets available at linktr.ee/iveh... and subscribe to I've Had It wherever you get your podcasts.
Thank you to our sponsors:
I've Had It is brought to you by Cologuard®. Are you 45 or older? Start screening for colon cancer with Cologuard, an effective and noninvasive screening option for adults 45 and older at average risk for colon cancer. Rx only. Learn more at Cologuard.com/hadit.
This episode is brought to you by Peleton: I've Had it Podcast is brought to you by Pelton. Find your zone with a 30 day worry-free home trial of Peloton Bikes. Visit onepeloton.com/home-trial.
ZocDoc: Go to Zocdoc.com/IVEHADIT and download the Zocdoc app for FREE. Then find and book a top-rated doctor today.
Subscribe to our Patreon: / ivehaditpodcast
Follow Us:
I've Had It Podcast: @Ivehaditpodcast
Jennifer Welch: @mizzwelch
Angie "Pumps" Sullivan: @pumpspumpspumps
Special Guests:
Josh Peck: @joshpeck
Ben Soffer: @boywithnojob
The Good Guys Podcast: @goodguys

[@rocketgum0]

What I heard about “ozempic shaming” was that it wasn’t targeted to obese people but that now that more people is taking it, it is reducing ozempic stock for diabetic patients who had it prescribed … Just don’t know how much truth is in this

[@AmandaJo_]

Yeah the only backlash I’d heard about was people being upset that non-diabetic, already-thin people (or at least people who were only slightly overweight) were using it when they didn’t actually need it.

[@mckenziert24]

yes exactly ^^^ & I think with it starting with celebrities taking it when they weren't the ones it was made available for also caused issues. my mom is diabetic & is prescribed Ozempic & she hasn't been able to pick up her prescription a little over a month now & just spoke to the pharmacy who said there's 40 people on the waitlist & it will be MONTHS until they have stock. what makes it worse, is her doctor prescribed an alternative just with a stronger dose in lieu of the Ozempic & insurance refuses to approve it 🙃

[@katc2040]

​@mckenziert24 wow that's ridiculous and you know all these doctors are grifting by prescribing it

[@youralien93]

Most people are no longer on ozempic, they’re on Wagovy or Semaglutide, neither of which are FEDA approved to treat diabetes so they are solely weight loss injections

[@pinkish410]

When that guy said "There's something vital about Trump" i almost turned off the podcast. I mean after Jens explanation, she definitely saved it, but oof i didnt like that

[@Fig__Newton]

these guests were lowkey off brand for jen and pumps

[@angelamarie3044]

Had the exact same thought.

[@connor_ryans]

JENNIFER MAKING SURE SHE MENTIONS THAT SOMEONE CALLED HER A CENTRIST IN EVERY EPISODE hahahahaha

[@emmachristine8501]

“I’m an entrepreneur” is the new “ I’m inbetween jobs right now”

[@Wapluigi]

… Can’t believe Kylie let this one slip through

[@pinkish410]

theres plenty of fat people that are confident as hell while also being fat. They shouldnt be made to feel like they have to change at all. Skinny people do have a moral hugh ground which is why you felt like you needed to take a drug to be one of them.

[@Fig__Newton]

this might be the first episode i didn't finish. if pumps flirts with karen-ism, these guys flirt with straight white repub vibes

[@pinkish410]

SAME. first one I literally had to turn off

[@ShannonKennedyVideos]

They more than flirt with it. Ben’s MIL is a literal terrorist.

[@alaine57]

Lighten up

[@Christy-zd6zw]

It's okay to dislike some people. Just be mindful about judging groups of people based on their skin color and sexuality.

[@russellmo94]

@@Christy-zd6zw repub means republican, fyi.

[@Ohdoch]

they give me "uneducated brother in law desperately doesn't want to appear homophobic or sexist at a family dinner" vibes...

[@haleycrummett2169]

that is literally who Ben is....

[@ZoeyZoco]

*JEN* complains about being called a *”Centrist”* and then has these guests on which just makes her look more like a Centrist! LOL gals don’t have these guys back on, sorry they were *NOT* the vibe

[@BenSMorrison4]

Pumps is one of our greatest legal mines! Joe Biden should put her on the Supreme Court!

[@jameymonroe954]

Merrick Garland WHO? The Princess Diana of Podcasts! Forget Amy Coney Whatever! Pumps will put those butt hurt Trumpies in their place! AND THAT'S 4 THE PERMENANT RECORD LISTENER!!! 🤭🤭😍😍💋💋💋

[@digbycrankshaft7572]

What is she mining?

[@karlaa8651]

Love Jen&pumps but these guys are literally insufferable lol this is probably how josh peck felt when that yoga instructor lady talked to him.

[@swerves]

Yeah REALLY not feeling these two.

[@tortuguista1058]

Jen’s trauma with being called a centrist is so real of her

[@tiah1927]

Also, I’ve had it with businesses asking me to donate to their charity. They have already made the donation(they can afford to) and my donation goes to cover what they’ve donated. Then they get a huge tax write off with my money.

[@PeanutHead411]

These guests did not pass the political typology test

[@devancollier8951]

DID NOT pass the political vibe check

[@freyagiselle]

Not Kylie ignoring all the comments about these horrible guests😭😭 it's okay to admit you're wrong guys. We will always love y'all

[@markivicic7194]

Full episode of Josh Welch's tattoos! We want to see them all and need explanations! LOVE Josh!

[@paris13sanders]

Ladies. I need you to both know that Ben’s wife is the daughter of Pamela Geller who is banned from the UK for her nutty Islamophobia….

[@ShannonKennedyVideos]

For real. Did they just not know this?

[@jemenfous9343]

Still no scrubs 😢 On another note, I think y’all have had the most impressive lineup of guests out of any podcast ever (and, of course, Josh Welch has been the most impressive guest by far).

[@claudiamm8658]

😂

[@Trouble226]

What Josh did to Jeanette was low and I don't think I can support this one. Love y'all tho!!! ❤

[@michaelakatherine2431]

Bumping this comment because this is the most valid

[@russellmo94]

The “Good” Guy’s takes that makes me think they should reconsider their name: -Facetune is unnatural and bad unless they do it -Women who wear heavy makeup to look attractive are unnatural and misleading and bad, but porn is natural and good -Couples should consume same porn at the same rate or breakup -Fat people are inherently unhealthy and unhappy -Skinny people all have a good relationship with food and a high self worth -The spirituality and faith of young women isn’t worthy of respect, unless they agree with it, even when they’re paying them for the guidance. (genuinely what do they think yoga instructors are there to do) Also, i hope they would confront or intervene with the “friend for years” who picked someone they didn’t like or parented in a way that was so egregious it completely changed their view of them. It isn’t their responsibility to, but i’m judging them loudly if they don’t feel like it is.

[@fanficisvalid]

I'm glad I'm not the only one who had a few red flags crop up as they talked 😅

[@weltallin1828]

​@@fanficisvalidsame

[@brittricc]

​@@fanficisvalidyes Josh has had more than a few red flags over the years too. I was surprised they had them on, not my favorite

[@Antonio-hj3ox]

Glad to find this comment thread bc same.

[@effiejackson3260]

Not a fan of these two guests. The comments about women using makeup to trick men are highly problematic.

[@Graymage69420]

I agree… haven’t been a fan of Josh peck as an adult. Feels sketchy

[@Binstabih]

They also acted like jeanette mccurdy asking them to delete her episode was a personal attack🙄 she’s dealing with a lot imo she doesn’t need her narrative to be outside of her control in any way rn, even if the “good guys” think she looked good, it’s up to her to decide if she looked good

[@haleycrummett2169]

it was funny to me because Ben's wife BRAGS about her use of facetune constantly!!

[@emilywaterman5061]

Yea. These guys kinda suck

[@Skippertharipper]

I got bad, women hater vibes from these “good guys”

[@effiejackson3260]

Literally same. Was coming to leave the same comment.

[@Graymage69420]

Yeah same… also the weird fatphobic comments about fat people lining US pockets… weird

[@effiejackson3260]

@@Graymage69420Totally. Gives “Big Pharma makes you sick to keep you buying medicine” vibes. Like, I’m sorry, if I’m sick I am taking antibiotics. That’s not Big Pharma making me their bitch. Give me a break. Also, isn’t Josh Peck a crazy Trumper?

[@Fig__Newton]

I just came here to say the same thing omfg

[@DOCDOCFLAMINGOS]

Yeah definitely not sure what kinda vibes I got from them!!??!!........ BUT very sure it Wasn't "Good Guy" vibes!!!!

[@claudiamm8658]

This episode was strange. Were the guys pretending ? They sounded very fake. Love you Jenn, Pumps, and team

[@Fig__Newton]

Ben sounds scared of women ngl

[@User98030]

Not sure about these guys… 👀

[@gabrielrecio3707]

I don't understand the over concept behind staying and looking young. I mean I'm only 26 but I think people are much more attractive when they own their age

[@gloom1553]

It is definitely standard to tip at a coffee shop lol.

[@tobipradasri4089]

I had a tattoo when I was 23, Had it done by my friend who thought she knew Chinese with a tattoo’s equipment so we got it done and it was supposed to say “Better than a woman” but it turned out 20 years later I revealed it to my friend who actually speaks Chinese and she said Oh girl, that tattoo is said “ Country girl” and I’m dead 😂😂😂

[@johnstonwalker1712]

Totally true about how we think we are 28 for ever and then we see ourselves in the mirror or facetime🙂

[@weenpeen]

So relieved to see I’m not the only one after reading these comments. I couldn’t quite put my finger on it but something about these guests was so off-putting. I could feel the pretentiousness oozing off of them. Love Jessica & Judge Judy Diana tho

[@skybaby444]

I love the words about sugar/food addiction.

[@DallasABG]

Do you think Jen and Pumps knows Josh from Drake and Josh or do they think they're giving rhe guy with a Oppenheimer Cameo his big break.

[@marybethgardener111]

Wow.....This was a great one! It's good to have such great belly laughs in the morning listening to your show :)

[@yellowleaf28]

Angie and jenn are special - their way of saying “I’ve had it” is unique, classy, and funny in their point-making, the exact opposite of these two guests whose tone and ranting is the commonplace/amateur “I’ve had it” that i previously expected.

[@AmandaJo_]

Yikes, the skinnier=healthier narrative is really dangerous. Not every fat person is inherently unhealthy y’all. (And not every fat person got that way because of too much food-genetics plays a huge role.)

[@marlynnek6449]

Not as dangerous as the "you can be obese and healthy" narrative.

[@Graymage69420]

Yeah I didn’t love the way he talked about that. Definitely comes from a place of self hate from being a former fat person

[@AmandaJo_]

Unfortunately I used to be that way too and let fatphobia rule so much of my thinking about my own body and other people’s bodies. I know (at least in American culture) it takes a lot of conscious effort to unlearn that stuff, so I don’t entirely fault him for thinking that way since it’s a pervasive issue and something you have to actively choose to change your mindset around. It just sucks to see it platformed in a place that usually feels light and safe 🙁

[@pinkish410]

Not every fat person is that way because of over eating, or even unhealthy eating

[@OShelya]

Ben NAILED everything in regards to obesity and Ozempic. BRAV-FUCKING-O!!!!!!!

[@Benji_1982]

I’ve had it with the tipping everywhere as well. As a career server in a restaurant, it’s upsetting noticing more and more people are tipping less due to the extreme abuse of the act of tipping. Please continue tipping your servers and all other appropriate service workers for our actual wages are based on it.

[@effiejackson3260]

Kinda audacious that these guests feel baristas shouldn’t be tipped. Do they wanna come steam their own milk?

[@JeremyMYG]

If there’s a tip option available for something, I’m throwing in a tip. Until a livable wage is provided, I want to do my part. Appreciate y’all!

[@reggieroon]

I have a question for the editor of this episode. Why didn't you record and splice in Josh and Ben's video feed throughout. Cuz we can't really see them, they're so small on that tv.

[@riannonadams4154]

I swear to fucking god my boyfriend and I are just going to elope. All the shit about weddings is mind bending. Really grinds my gears.

[@gummybrain]

As a gay man, I never felt beholden to any rules about weddings. My husband and I did what we wanted: no religious service, no wedding party, no speeches, no rehearsal, no special dances--just fun, food, and drinks. And you can do what you want, too! Do only the parts you want to do, and people who don't like it can stay the fuck home.

[@hushpuppy698]

As someone who felt this way and had a wedding anyway, just elope boo. Spend the money on LITERALLY ANYTHING ELSE.

[@katc2040]

I felt the same way until I tried on a wedding dress in a thrift store and I was like oh shit this feels amazing

[@ooscardls]

In order to solve the tiping problem in the US the companies should pay the worker like in other countries for instance

[@emilykawaii123]

"O, that he were here to write me down a centrist! But masters, remember that I am a centrist; though it be not written down, yet forget not that I am a centrist."

[@Olivia-uy8bi]

Just directed this play lol 😂😂😂

[@Kike_mv]

“The Karen in me” 😂😂😂😂 I love pumps

[@CollinWoo]

beautiful contemporary universe clash

[@blakedonegan9178]

Great episode from you guys as always! Hopefully the guests are gonna be a better fit next time though 😅

[@clytemnestra]

Absolutely love the Ozempic hot take

[@user-gl4id9cr5u]

these guys are lame

[@joshpeck]

Thank you for having us Jen and Pumps! We’re huge fans and loved having you on Good Guys!

[@ivehaditpodcast]

We love you right back ❤️❤️

[@Ohdoch]

Really?@@ivehaditpodcast

[@juliemiller424]

Please put a camera on Kyleigh we want to see her too

[@pinkish410]

I get the tipping fatigue but it does sound a bit shtty that a bunch of wealthy white people are upset about an extra 2 dollars here and there

[@kariwilliams786]

I’ve heard the guests paying to go to a wedding is a common practice in Canada! Helping pay for the wedding instead of getting expensive gifts etc.

[@EarfMuva]

i laughed so bad this entire episode😭😭😭 I didn’t know Josh was from New York until i heard him start talking lol

[@patriciathomas7549]

TIPPING! My local fish market now presents the payment iPad for an 18% to 30% tip for the guy who wraps up and hands me my raw fish! They don't cook it, they don't serve it up. The fish itself is $35/lb and they ask for a tip for serving me over the counter! Un-fucking believable! The kicker is that they know their regular customers and the ones that don't tip them, they ignore for as long as possible.They will serve everyone else before they will get around to the ones they know don't tip. 🐟

[@jameymonroe954]

TRUE STORY! My cousin Karen from NC is MY KAREN! The Karenism is very strong with this one! Mama don't take no mess! PERIOT! ❤🤣🤣🤣😇😇😤😤

[@mags-lv8hb]

I know for a fact that one day soon people are going to be beating down the DOOR to be on this show

[@dwoww]

THANK YOU FOR THIS!!! I literally only just started watching y'all 2 weeks ago (safe to say im obsessed) and i've been a longtime watcher of The Good Guys, so these two episodes are the best thing ever! ❤️

[@ashleyy222]

As a subscriber of good guys, what in the heck 🤨

[@saiaquarius]

I don't listen to them but are they acting differently than normal?

[@melaniemann8852]

I need someone who has thrown one of these Pat to attend weddings and someone who has attended to be a guest. I need a full interview.

[@nowa5623]

How is watching porn a natural instinct?

[@aliadan22]

THE KAREN IN ME 😂😂😂 I LOVE Y'ALL 💞💞💞

[@user-dd8ej5qp3e]

however wrote that gay comment was not gay

[@Starrgazed]

Glad I found this podcast ❤

[@gamabussy]

getting my "live laugh love" tramp stamp asap

[@soonertutoring]

I almost gave up on this episode and then they got to the fat people section and brought me back in. I really appreciate the take and am glad people finally understand we (fat people) are just trying to be normal and Ozempic and Mounjaro have been game changers. Mounjaro changed my life!

[@tiah1927]

To cover the cost of labor while paying for the product??!!! Isn’t the cost of labor covered in the cost of product???

[@mauricejennings]

PUMPS IS LOOKING FABULOUS 🪭

[@rebeccajaron]

Fantastic episode ladies you’re on top of your game 💯

[@mags-lv8hb]

omg a 3 day weekend in Provincetown i wont get covid from!

[@kayladulhanty3410]

Okay but I was chatting with someone the other day and it was crazy to me to hear her say so casually how everyone has got one photo that was overdone with photoshop. I can’t relate. I already have body issues why would I worsen it! To me it’s crazy!

[@Bipperbopper]

The guests aren’t a good fit for the show and it feels odd that you guys aren’t willing to listen to your audience. I understand why you ignore people calling out your hypocrisy around being “anti capitalist” even though you have a huge amount of ads for unethical companies such as better help and hormone treatments (in one episode you talk for a while about how it’s ridiculous you can just advertise medications in the US but you do it anyway) because it makes money but you need to start practicing what you preach.

[@angelabritt9267]

I was invited to one of those weddings this summer and all I could think was “I don’t like them enough to do this”

[@juliepowell2446]

TIP for TIP Requests: "never look directly into the sun - bad for your eyes"

[@ginnydileo5168]

Sorry, one more. John Lovett from POD Save America. That would be amazing.

[@Christy-zd6zw]

These comments are disappointing. The "you're in" or "you're out", "us" versus "them" mentality gives me the chills. It's a path to violence and war.

[@nowa5623]

boooooo josh peck

[@TonyOnYourTV]

Dont say that girl I’m 28 now lol

[@PatrickkSteele]

Ben Soffer sounds just like comedian Brad Wollack

[@kathynguyen7683]

Does kiley do ANY research on the guests????? Horrible this week.

[@rick98765]

Two things. One.Pumps, the color correction of your camera is offensive. Why does this editor want you to have jaundice? Two. People in the comments, i have HAD IT with people using the word "problematic" to try to sound smart. Your use of "problematic ' is problematic, hunty.

[@ginnydileo5168]

I want to see Trae Crowder and Brian Tyler Cohen on here more than I want to breathe.

[@1boogiebetty]

Inspirational quotes on boards in houses. or worse, boards naming the rooms, as if. . Like Laundry, Kitchen, Bathroom.(JoAnna Gaines)

[@skylarhoney2775]

josh is too funny 😭😭😭

[@yellowleaf28]

and jenn thought pumps was loud…

[@thevivirose]

I LOVE this podcast! But these guests aren’t it in my opinion.

[@jennyzimmerman3481]

Drug dealers always put entrepreneur as their job on Facebook.. If you haven't seen it.. You missed it

[@lisa63artist]

I have a few things. 1) The short video - like a few week ago - of Jenn escorting Pumps to the SVU, with such chivalry, is hot and I mean as in classy, hot women. 2) Jenn, your turn of phrase and beauty with words, oh come on over and just talk while I melt. 3) About tipping...I've had it with, when you dine at a restaurant with a group, and you can't get separate checks, so let's say me, I get the check because I don't have cash on me for this so I'm agreeing to put it on my credit card, and everyone is giving me cash for their share. They're adding up what they ordered, including tip, this goes around, then I gather all the cash and count it. Wtf, it's short of the total, like by a lot. Then it's a whole ordeal of going around, and some people can't do math and others only figured in like a one dollar tip. More cash gathered, but we're still $50 or something short, and everybody acts like the check is settled and it's fine to stick me with the shortfall. Then they're getting up, doing the hugs, leaving the restaurant and here I am stuck with a big chunk of the check. I hate these people. They're grifters as a group. F them all.

[@jigglybits2092]

ive had it with “good guys” podcast having bad takes on whats going on in gaza.

[@skybaby444]

You’re not just terrible pickers. The pickins are overwhelmingly terrible.

[@davisbrowne1906]

Social engineering. Not new. Not new at all. Come on now. Think.

[@jayroc62]

wafflehouselover8733? Lana really thinks she’s slick

[@justanotherrichkid1053]

I love the “Good Guys”. Ben is awesome.

[@dwoww]

PS, you guys should totally do a pod-swap with Ben's wife Claudia and her podcast The Toast!!

[@kylecj221]

I’ve been a toaster since the beginning up until recently with their wild takes…they couldn’t disagree more politically so I don’t see that happening.

[@gabrielle7540]

Man. I used to LOVE Josh Peck as a kid. But jeez he sucks as an adult

[@HH-gv8mx]

Pumps looks thin. Is she still on Ozempic?

[@ethanbrown350]

Catch it Hasan

[@jt4351]

Aaawwww, Americans. These comments are HI-LA-RI-OUS.

[@domoniquecoetzee5515]

I agree with this statement about the tipping thing. It is bullshit. I am happy

[@HarryOtterr]

Noooo not Josh peck 😭 I’d like to see like Jeff wittek on the pod. Or tana

[@katyallred3393]

Damn, there's no one who will spread vitriolic and harmful misinformation about fat people and fatness like a thin person who used to be kinda fat. The ozempic rant was genuinely soooo hard to listen to and made me so sad. If any listeners want a much more thoughtful, nuanced, and 300% less deranged conversation about Ozempic, please listen to the Maintenance Phase podcast's most recent episode about it. This was a bummer for sure.

[@morallycorruptFay]

These guys suuuuuuuck

[@laurenjojo]

The minimum wage has definitely been raised in the last 15 years. Sometimes I think you two talk out of your ass.

[@russellmo94]

The last federal minimum wage increase was 2009. That’s what they’re referencing. There are places where minimum wage has not changed since then.

[@katc2040]

Federal.