Grading the 2023 FRESHMAN QB Class One Year Later (Honest Evaluations)

The 2023 freshman QB class was loaded with superstar talent, but how did everyone perform in 2023? Today, we are going to take a look back at this class and grade the top players and talk about how they did, enjoy!

[@ScottFisherCFB]

Alright the Arch Manning grade part is a joke, but I do wonder if he will actually live up to the hype! What topic should I do next?

[@JacobBerger-wq2jj]

I need help understanding why he doesn’t transfer away to somewhere where he would start? Cause Ewers is the starter for a while. And do a video about Iowa. Their new offense/new scheme and new OC. Their qb room sucks too, so a preview of the most intriguing power 4 teams this upcoming season would be nice for the next couple of months

[@andrewmohrmann3599]

I would love to see a breakdown on how you grade offensive lineman, as a casual football viewer, they don’t exactly get highlights so it’s tough to understand what makes someone like Joe Alt so much more dominant than someone considered “raw” like Kingsley S. From BYU

[@SpoonHurler]

​@@JacobBerger-wq2jj because that was what he said he'd do... sit year one and if Ewers stayed compete. We are all under the impression Ewers won't pull a Spencer Rattler. Also getting a lot of NIL monies can't hurt.

[@SportscardLyle_onIG]

Eli manning sat 2 years… it worked out for him

[@willeubanks4957]

The Arch grade is fair. If he is amazing you would've thought he could pass up Murphy and be given the opportunity to throw more than 5 passess. Not to mention he did play a significant portion of Texas Spring Game and he actually looked awful in that game.

[@chevyjr1862]

Bro was on demon time with that arch manning grade i am weak😂💀

[@keodahui7504]

Dante Moore deserves a grade of D…He had almost no competition at QB and floundered when the lights were too bright, in big games. He’ll transfer again next szn bc Oregon will always have stiff competition at QB.

[@flydawg7784]

I was going to say you should have added Noah Fifita from Arizona. I thought he was from the class of ‘23 seeing how he seemed to win PAC-12 freshman of the week honors every week. But I double checked just to see and it turns out he was class of ‘22. I was very impressed by this short guy who came out of nowhere and I was hoping he would come to Washington with his coach but he stayed put. He would be an interesting subject for sure, great young QB.

[@yae7467]

redshirt. he came in with his hs teammeat tmac. was partially the resin tmac flipped from oregon

[@Bertswrld]

Fifita was very impressive, small but fast on his feet. Good QB

[@dman1069]

Wildcats

[@g.williams2047]

Collandrea is a gunslinger QB who made a lot of freshman decisions. He was and will continue to be very exciting to watch as a UVA fan!

[@andydiaz6119]

Loved this video, would like to see more like this kind of video in the future

[@alexwatkins1931]

Please do this with every position! Love this video would love to see how other freshman at RB, LB, WR have panned out etc

[@thejac0nyt654]

At 9:00 Im looking forward to having Nelson as a bronco! Hopefully he'll help our program succeed again like we did in the 2010s.

[@justinsuggs1258]

This is a nice young class of QB's

[@patrickcounts6516]

You should do a video on Mike Mathew’s

[@bmartin6493]

Inching into MattBeGreat territory w this one😂

[@mwcarolina]

How can anyone grade Arch??

[@JACPOT3rddd]

He ain’t that good bro

[@mwcarolina]

@@JACPOT3rddd how do you know?? I didn’t see him play 100 snaps last year!? Did you!!??

[@JACPOT3rddd]

@@mwcarolina we’ll see this year. I might be wrong but I don’t think I am .

[@mwcarolina]

@@JACPOT3rddd more like we will see in 2 years, Ewers isn’t losing his starting job to Manning. That’s the issue with Manning, Ewers

[@JACPOT3rddd]

@@mwcarolina but see that’s proving my point. If Arch Manning was REALLY that guy he’d be starting over Euwers already. But I get Euwers does have NFL potential so he gets the start for next year but still..

[@thebryceisright4851]

Can't wait to see what cutter boley does after this season.

[@random_user688]

Do this same format for different class 🙏

[@cesarespinoza8110]

malalchi nelson is an F the reason he only passed 3 times in the season opener is because he was the 4th string qb and had a pwo qb in front of him he transferred to boise state because that was really his only optikn

[@chasewilliams1286]

No Brock Glenn ?

[@PrideT2D]

Lanorris Sellars is going to be a good QB. he is criminally underrated

[@terriblegamerdotexe1527]

I’m telling you Avery Johnson is going to be really good the dude killed us in highschool he looked like a high level player already and I think he is mentally very sound

[@zacharyscott6779]

IF and this is a big if, Arch Manning ends up being as good as everyone thinks, he will only need one good year to be seen as a first round pick. Add in the fact you can say hes got little to no wear and tear on his body if he goes this route, and the NFL will love this. Plus hes living the dream right now as the most famous backup in the country. Havent you seen Blue Mountain State? Backup QB is the way to go.

[@RCHJ2022]

I'm admittedly biased but I don't get the Avery Johnson hype. I get he's young and fast but he couldn't beat out Will Howard who KSU fans were HAPPY to see transfer. I get he is athletic but I just don't know. we will see.

[@ronaldtentschert6876]

Avery Johnson will be the best out of all of them,he has that thing.

[@michaelvaladez5460]

Ready for Dylan raiola

[@rj6110]

he won't be good until he leaves nebraska

[@JacobBerger-wq2jj]

@@rj6110 Exactly. Nebraska is cursed and nobody will fix it

[@jrgm5382]

Arch Manning just looks dead inside

[@bobbydibiasi9956]

Tell me you have CTE without telling me you have CTE

[@jayjayjayjjj]

Nico is going to be the best and its not even close

[@adamlewis4736]

LMAOOOOO

[@Cooljohn760]

😂nice troll

[@jayjayjayjjj]

@@Cooljohn760 im not trolling

[@adamlewis4736]

@@jayjayjayjjjbro is confidently wrong

[@chipparmley]

GBO!

[@Cooljohn760]

Hope Sellers can Gamecocks to lead a respectable record(7-5 or better).Please don’t turn out like Lorenzo Nunez.

[@JacobBerger-wq2jj]

I checked South Carolina’s schedule a while back, no way they win more than 6. It would even be a miracle to win 6 with that schedule that they have

[@thecrwster]

With nyck harbor and rocket sanders he’s got all the pieces. Hope the d can just hold a couple drives

[@benjipedro6686]

Don't sleep on the gamecocks sellers the truth

[@dany-ps2my]

4 wins at best would be expected with that schedule

[@popskerry]

How are you going to give Manning an F , when the kid barely played, he was never going to start over Ewers and that wasn't the plan, your hate is showing

[@phipsdeus2]

To be fair, these guys are playing against teams quarterbacked by millennials.

[@tiddiesattic]

I'd tackle Johnson by his hair every time.. he'd thank me in the long run 😂

[@Alex1552project]

Donte Moore is a fickle little kid…can’t make up his mind…bet he transfers again after this season

[@davidnelson6874]

The background music was so annoying I didn’t watch the video.

[@Victor-Vargas]

Ah okay so you're just another Arch hater.

[@sreal1]

Tryna play it off as a “joke” dude is all over the place 😂😂

[@hunterking6033]

"Honest Evaluation" when you have a guy who didn't play graded with an F in the thumbnail. Not gonna watch this. You've turned into a clickbait hack. I'm unsubbing.

[@bobbynofsinger4897]

I watched it and he does say that it’s probably unfair to give him the F and the only reason y is because he is probably the most hyped player of all time just to complete 2 passes his freshman year.

[@hunterking6033]

@@bobbynofsinger4897 if it's unfair, why give a grade.. CLICKBAIT. It's low integrity garbage. And the media hyping someone doesn't mean anything. You either grade players by the same criteria or you don't.

[@davebowman5152]

I would give him an incomplete grade. However, if I needed to give him a grade it would either be F (or D-). Dude was hyped to be the next coming of johnny manziel (without the partying) by a lot of the media and some (especially Texas) fans and he did absolutely nothing. If he doesn't play much this year, he might be the next great college QB bust. Big reason he was even the number 1 recruit was because of his name.

[@hunterking6033]

@@davebowman5152 no one compared him to Manziel. Peyton was mega hyped when he was a recruit. Didn't start until late in the year, wasn't good. You eat clickbait trash if you want. Choose stupidity.

[@davebowman5152]

@@hunterking6033 if that's what your opinion is that's fair. One of the great things about this topic is there is a wide variety of opinions. I honestly hope that Arch comes in next year, plays well, and proves everyone that he is as good or better than he was hyped to be.

[@CashColorCannabis]

It seems like almost all these players will play for one or two schools over their time. That transfer portal is always open

[@johndavis9321]

Yup