Graham Nash - Encore - RTL - RTL

[@billlord4203]

70+ years young and still as beautiful a musician as ever. There is hope.

[@bothedandi]

Thanks a lot Mr David Crosby!! So long CSN & CSNY We can forgive our friends but after a while the only forgiveness they'll understand is goodbye! Thanks for this Graham.

[@MarcoZucchi81]

What happened between Graham and David?

[@Ryanks12]

I think they're friends again now?

[@nigelgreenwood9010]

David Crosby had some "truths" about Neil Young getting married to a younger wife. Then Graham Nash leaves his wife of many years for a Joni Mitchell lookalike 30 years his junior. Graham took it to heart it seems. Perhaps not wise to say these things out loud, but, personally think Crosby is not far wrong. You say these things face to face and in front of them, not on TV or radio, behind their backs. However, easy to say when you've met the 'right' partner, but Graham in particular has always been a bit of a gypsy.

[@bennymwelch]

@@nigelgreenwood9010 Yeah, Crosby is a pretty terrible person from what I've read about some of the things he's done to other people, but Idk, it's never always just one person in a lot of these scenarios. I don't think there's much wrong with Neil Young marrying a younger woman though, especially when Crosby's wife is 10 years younger than him too, I wouldn't say Crosby is really justified for that. He may have had some valid criticisms for what Nash did however, and I wouldn't be surprised if Nash just had it with Crosby and used that as a way out. Crosby said they were all terrible to eachother, and honestly they probably all are terrible people, so it's really hard telling who's really the worst out of all of them or who's in the right or wrong. Just goes to show a lot of celebrity drama is just a bunch of petty one sided bullshit lol.

[@bernadettecognacpitre2380]

j,ai aimé à la folie toutes les chanson de Graham et je continie , 60 ans plus tard , amazing

[@braddakimo1954]

After all the great music C&N, CSN, CSN&Y created, made them legendary and unforgettable. I could tell from early on, Graham showed great patience with Crosby. What is amazing is how long Nash put up with it. There is always a limit. Sorry you had to put up with it for so long. Many of us can probably relate... "Next!"

[@rumpestillskin4671]

I don't think a younger man would appreciate this song like we older guys. Thanks Graham for performing this song.

[@mytoobusr]

Beautiful song, Beautiful singing, Beautiful guitar, Beautiful playing…Encore.

[@dadgad68]

Very moving Graham. Proves there's always a great song in a veterans heart.

[@BourneAccident]

I know someone who worked with Graham for several years. He said Graham was the best of the lot (CSN&Y) and one of the most caring and thoughtful persons he had ever met in the entire music business.

[@mariegalante2000]

Such a beautiful song. ❤

[@erintaylor5856]

I do love his songwriting. It's right on the surface. Accessible.

[@algrand52]

Graham Nash can sure write the most heartfelt tune as well as anyone in the music business, past or present. And he's got the perfect chops to slay that tune many times over.

[@petelaw44]

Beautiful song, Graham. Paints so many sad pictures, but still beautiful...

[@AisforAlibi1]

Saw CSN in Tallahassee in '92 or '93 - it was the best concert ever. When they are "on", they are really on.

[@Epulor1]

A great song needs two things. It needs musical knowledge and it needs emotion. This comes from both.

[@adampapadam411]

a soulful performance of a great artist!

[@muxux4]

Great song! Remind me of the good old days of "Progressive Rock".

[@stephenfeldman8104]

What you gonna do when the last song is over? What you gonna do when you can't touch base? And what you gonna do when the applause is all over And you can't turn your back on what you face? And who you gonna be when the lights are all fading? And who you gonna be when the band comes off? And who you gonna be when your heart is still aching And you can't shrug it off with just a laugh? Encore, encore The last song is over More, more The crowd's on its feet Sure, sure Adulation is so pleasing Encore, encore And what you gonna say to the last person leaving? What you gonna say when the light's turned off? What you gonna do if you stop believing That you can't seem to find what might be lost? And how you gonna feel if friends follow fortune? And how you gonna feel if the music dies? And how you gonna live with the soul sadly sighing Into the wind that is our life? Encore, encore The last song is over More, more The crowd is on its feet Sure, sure Adulation is so pleasing Encore, encore

[@seasandsummer]

Beautiful sad song. I wish you the very best with your music on your solo or any joint music you make in the future. Again, a beautiful sad song. God bless

[@exthomes]

I'm speechless, thank you Graham and thanks for the post

[@willythewave]

Such a beautiful song with so much meaning behind it. He wrote that about David Crosby.

[@kevinrombouts3027]

I think he is more than a harmony singer. One of the greats.

[@garydavison6839]

Very much looking forward to hearing this tune live in Oct. from the 4th row!!!

[@samspade1841]

Nice song. Beautiful guitar playing.

[@alicesings1971]

I love the Hollies in the long run. After being a huge CSNY fan. It’s a blessing to Graham he has Alan Clark. Now that’s a fantastic boyhood friendship although they had hard feelings when Graham left the Hollies. But now Graham is putting out his solo music. He’s a great singer songwriter human . Cheers 🎉🎶xx

[@petrslivinski7481]

Definitely!

[@peteypool]

Beautiful ! Made me cry,

[@auraros8]

It's a beautiful song, I love it

[@isabelstrid1045]

Amazing show over at the Harvest, Roanoke, Va.

[@WhitePrivilegeMohammedansSuck]

Compare his voice with others. Although, not what it used to be .. it's still incredible, simply incredible. What happened to the others? Mr. Nash, not only am I impressed, I am in awe. Thank you for the past five decades (I'm an old fart, too).

[@HearturMind]

He still has a wonderful voice. Life is short. I can’t give up just yet. Hope they can pull it together one more time. But that is easy for me to say.

[@mariettameister5208]

thank you so much graham,marietta.

[@ago7212]

Been a fan of CSN & CSNY for 40 + years. Great song with the lyrics definately making his point. Amazing how he's managed to retain the clarity of is voice at his age! Especially so, in comparing his to David Crosby's raspy voice after years of drug abuse.

[@gregcarrier8662]

David's voice sounds wonderful these days. Not raspy at all.

[@avitarmagnus9090]

Amazing lesson for the young who are so lost in souless measures with jello spines and no minds!!!! love it

[@petrslivinski7481]

The Hollies and incredible 60s English band right up there with The Beatles. I wish the original members would come together and do a world tour for their fans just for the memories before they leave us forever. Graham Nash love his voice: sounding great here without fancy recording techniques. Go Graham!

[@aldofromsf]

Graham Nash knew the Beatles back in the day.

[@petrslivinski7481]

@@aldofromsf The Hollies were recording right at Abbey Road Studios which the Beatles used. Incredible isn't it? The Beatles and The Hollies have the best music.

[@childrenofminervaofficial4316]

It would be cool for Graham, Allan Clarke, Tony Hicks, Bobby Elliott and Bernie Calvert (if he can be coaxed out of retirement) to get together and play the Evolution/Butterfly era material accompanied by an orchestra.

[@richalderson6069]

Proof that some of the best songs come out of frustration and anger. Crosby obviously has alot to answer for.

[@user-un6yp7bo9z]

All songs are love songs of some form. That's what songs are about ~ Love ~ As Neil Young so eloquently sang ~ Only Love can break your heart ;)

[@13magic74]

* a lot

[@algrand52]

No, he doesn't. Each member has their own failings. Some music writers just fanned the flames of an otherwise petty misunderstanding. And you fools just lapped it all up

[@bloozedaddy]

@@algrand52. As if all failings have equal weight. Nice try. Clearly the rest of "us fools" don't have your clarity of thought. Douche

[@algrand52]

@@bloozedaddy you're clearly an idiot. Where did I say failings are of equal weight? Go back to watching fox news, trumptard. Lol

[@fretkillrfan]

Bravo, Graham.

[@truthneverchangeswakeup2762]

Great song!

[@GlennHallLivingWater]

Very nice.

[@guillarmicrock7955]

belle chanson.........une de plus ...

[@DavidAndrewsPEC]

D'accord!

[@musicrelic8958]

Certainly wouldn't 'thank' Crosby for this but, sometimes when you get really emotional, whether it's pissed or happy, you are a little more open. Obviously, Graham was pretty 'moved to create' at the point of this song. Neil with "Tonight's the Night", Stephen with "Suite Judy Blue Eyes", EVERY song with these guys is about these guys in some way. Thanks for continuing to share. Thanks for the post too.

[@lanes58]

Forgiveness is intellectual. But, you cannot control your emotion. You can forgive someone and still be angry with them. At that point, you just walk away, and get on with your life. I hope there is forgiveness in Graham's heart towards David Crosby.

[@2minstral]

Love the entire album. Added to the best of 2016, Folk and Soft Rock Playlists on my channel and music promotion website. 8-)

[@elenatan4160]

Encore is a piece of nostalgia with sad melody. A cover of that song by Sinatra will be a hit I am sure but Sinatra was here no more. Will some crooner still around make a cover of that song?

[@dr.williambarry8571]

Brilliant!

[@danajames8889]

The song has a sad quality to it and I'm sure Nash has many conflicting feelings about Crosby, who's been his friend for 50+ years. The chorus melody reminds me of a song by The Blue Nile, although I can't recall the exact name of it. Just a sweet, heart-breaking song....well done, Graham.

[@n40tom]

Wow great tune . Graham Nash is a stand up guy that finally got tired of David Crosby's shit. Such a shame I've been a fan of CSN and CSNY since they started almost 50 years ago. As Neil Young once said "Comes A Time."

[@WhitePrivilegeMohammedansSuck]

Don't forget The Hollies.

[@nickklok4955]

There comes a time of drifting, there comes a time of settling down my friend.

[@algrand52]

Why is it such a shame to be a fan of a great group despite the failings of 1 member? You're not really a fan, are you? Think of all the great bands, every single one has one bad egg. Maybe you should go back to listening to your justin bieber roots. Lol

[@marypontieri7883]

One if my favorite artists and this is my favorite from the last album. I did not take it as directed at Crosby. I think it’s about reaching the end of the line in a career, an experience, a relationship... going through it now myself so this song is spot on.

[@rjb7569]

I think Graham has said in an interview on KZbin that it is about Crosby.

[@artandculture5262]

Christopher Capobianco He said it is directed at Crosby.

[@patrickalaggio3560]

BRAVO!

[@janesteward9915]

I love David's music personally. I never met Crosby but have seen CSN play live. The Byrds saw it before Nash when they kicked Croz out of the Byrds almost like 50 years ago.

[@olliedebhal7486]

Any idea on the guitar tuning used here?? D major...A really touching sound..that says a lot when its too late for friends to do anything but follow fortune.

[@PHLCoffeeSnob]

It's hard to tell because of the capo on the 2nd fret

[@russbentley7677]

I have a lot of respect and understanding for all sides of this bad old history. And ths video is apparently from 6 years ago if I am reading it right. But the object of the song is gone now as of January 2023, and I feel it's time to bury this tune as well. No point in kicking a man who is down and who made his amends quite a while ago.

[@MinstrelOnTheRun]

While I appreciate the sentiment, this song was the closest there was to a proper epilogue for CSN(Y). Certainly more so than the “Silent Night” debacle.

[@garyhorsfield442]

.You are an Englishman Mr Nash...Chin up, old sausage. You still are the Mr Pastry of rock n roll

[@albertson2327]

Are there any good tabs that follow this performance? I can only seem to find simplified versions, without the capo.

[@erintaylor5856]

I am reading his book. A very complex man, but in Crosby's defense, even though Crosby has been proven to be a jerk, Graham has stepped away from his fair share of relationships. Takes two you know :)

[@rogermckamey8299]

There comes a point a person has too walk away from a toxic relationship so they can stay true to themselves.

[@rogermckamey8299]

@@ralphczukay1390 I just listened to the song again and realized that I am old enough now to look at my life and wonder what I will do when I have to admit i can't do the job anymore and i have to "play my last song" and what will i do. Not a comfortable place to be

[@patrickreilly9192]

now that's a fucking song - damn - where did that come from

[@glennkrzeminski7539]

Come on, gang! They've been a nostalgia group since the early '70s.

[@barnabyaprobert5159]

I had no idea that Teller of Penn & Teller was such a good guitarist. ;-)

[@oudwater58]

If i must choose between CSN&Y? It is Nash!

[@LABLOSSE]

convaincant !

[@databirds]

larmes

[@Zimmy907]

Still got it in spades.

[@keithcaldwell1970]

Great song very Pink Floydesq

[@blackmore4]

How funny! He's finally caught on to prog ;)

[@keithcaldwell1970]

For sure. At least he is going out with style.

[@tessjones5987]

Graham has so many muscian best friends from Joni MItchell on and on. If you can't find a friend in him that says something.

[@thomas5714]

DYK: Crosby is descendant from a particular bloodline - and Melissa Ethridge choose Crosby to be the in-vitro donor for her child, Beckett Cypher, who died of opioids in May, 2020.

[@bauld101]

what guitar is fontayne using

[@MSUSpartanFootball]

Appears to be a Gibson.

[@bauld101]

+MSUSpartanFootball yes i meant specifically but cheers

[@Klimwriter]

Gibson Hummingbird

[@bauld101]

+Jasper Klimbie ahh yes! thanks (:

[@shaundeane]

Are you guys sure? I cannot find a Hummingbird without a very ornate pickguard....thanks

[@stefankalscheid3818]

Who's the guy on guitar?

[@Buddhamaniac]

"...Graham Nash interprète en live le titre "Encore" accompagné de Shane Fontayne..."

[@rogerdodger8415]

If you sang like this in a bar, they'd toss you out.

[@rogerdodger8415]

@Stavis Maples Nnnnyep.

[@rogerdodger8415]

@Stavis Maples Shhhhh

[@DeanHaasJr]

Written for David Crosby. I hope they both find peace.

[@javiermoraguncay6102]

guitar tuning?

[@myguitardetective5961]

Open D, Capo 2.....very easy to play....

[@timothycornell3032]

i have former friends like that!

[@janscott602]

Nash has range. Crosby can’t touch him.

[@jesussantisteban3446]

I can see by the comments, that Mr. Nash is being successful in using his music to inspire bad feelings against Mr. Croz. When CSNY first split in the 1970s, you know what the gentleman did? And when he published his last book bashing the Croz memories, the gentleman didn't ask for any permission to publish it. It seems to me that he needs to pose indignated to justify himself. Could he also play some Song for Susan?

[@justgivemethetruth]

What is up with reading the lyrics off a paper ?

[@rjb7569]

Bruce uses a teleprompter, as do others. When you get a little older (like Graham and I) the short term ain't what it used to be.

[@garyoldham4449]

I believe the point of having the lyrics handy is so that the performance goes smoothly the first take. Who f****** cares!

[@ptownscribe1254]

Nice song, but sounds to me like it could be about almost any aging performer/person. If it's directed at Crosby, it's pretty oblique and vague.

[@13magic74]

this song was originally called "David Crosby is a Dick"

[@VitoAnthonyD.-ow7oo]

Took the election of Donald Trump to light a fire under this hippy's arse and get back into the studio to spread his Liberal bullcrap that doesn't work for anybody but entitled elites like Graham Nash, David Crosby and Neil Young. Chuck them. Give me Ted Nugent and his love of country over these Obama ass kissing whiners any day.

[@ryetim32]

F Crosby

[@TheJukeboxhero15]

I was surprised that David will vote for Trump. I guess the 60's are over.

[@janesteward9915]

TheJukeboxhero15 Do we really have a choice on who to vote for? We are in a double bind and have corruption all around us. I don't say this to argue your comment. I say it as a person who feels like he cannot trust a system broken. Take care.

[@justgivemethetruth]

Did Crosby really vote for Trump ? Ugh !

[@rogerdodger8415]

@@justgivemethetruth You can't handle the truth!!

[@garyoldham4449]

We can't afford the changes that need to happen. Every household knows you don't go on a spending spree when you're deep in debt. That's why Trump was supported. Because every single thing he did was concerned with creating a strong economy. The rest is up to us to stop blowing money on entertainment, to stop buying s*** we don't even need, to stop wasting time on anything else including analyzing politics for hours into the night. Our part to play in turning things around for this country was to focus, allow no detours, purchase nothing except those things which will make you money, the necessary equipment for your business dreams and make them happen so that you can become a higher tax bracket contributor to society. That is the only way a strong economy and the rest is up to us to leverage it and become successful. That is the only way to pay off our debt and until it is paid off we cannot afford the changes that need to happen. That's why the Democrats in power are not fixing anything. Because we cannot afford it from a position of weakness deep in debt. the ultimate goal of trump was to see the national debt paid off so that we could afford the changes that need to happen because _there is no other way._

[@garyoldham4449]

@@myguitardetective5961 I'll just take your first lines. "Huh? Trump cut revenues..." Since when does any president "cut" revenues. It's a free market system. You know this and yet you spin it as though he "did" something "deliberately" and "cut" revenues. You word it like the propagandist a hole you are. No president cuts revenue. Your word choice says it all. A president tweaks the system either to create a strong economy or to push for a change of the form of government such as paths toward higher levels of socialism. Just the fact that you try to spin and spread misinformation that "he cut revenues" tells me that you are no one to be taken seriously. What I said stands... before the pandemic we had a strong economy and the highest employment numbers which means tax revenue. The pandemic comes along and shuts the economy down. Leading up to the shutdowns we had a very strong economy because of the tax cuts and incentives. Because of streamlining, trying to create a smaller government and eliminating unnecessary expenditure. For example he eliminated Obama's pandemic preparedness team. Then we had to endure the mainstream media bashing him for "undermining our preparedness!" Really?! The fact is they were nothing more than pencil pushers. They wrote reports advising the president that is all they did. They did not deliver supplies, they were not truck drivers bringing ventilators to hospitals, they were not first responders for Christ's sake! They did nothing except push pencils and write reports. They were advisors for Christ's sake and yet Trump haters use that as though that was the only source. As though he had to use Obama's advisors instead of creating his own. He got the same pencil pushing advice, from other departments. Obama's preparedness team offices were eliminated and recreated in NHS offices. Besides the fact that in fact did have it key pandemic preparedness advisors he also had, and any president has many options dispersed all around the world and only a phone call away, from any source he is comfortable with not the ones that you dictate he must use. Access to every expert in the world not only his own advisors or his own cabinet members but any experts in business circles, experts in science communities, astronomers, economists, or even paleontologists if there was a dinosaur threat. Anyone in all of the world any source that he chooses. Not the ones you or CNN insists that he has to use. And especially not the ones Obama chose specifically because of their loyalty. And the cost of the pandemic preparedness team was b*******. Because it was a bunch of b******* people pencil pushers who were against Trump. If the whole point is to streamline and reduce the cost of government then he did what he did to contribute tothat. One of thousands of ways where his sensibility and business sense was to cut costs and streamline and stop wasting money on foreign involvement, and the list is huge. And largely ignored because of hatred. No other reason. Besides keeping money here instead of throwing it away overseas. Building a strong economy, generating tax revenue, and every measure known to stimulate job creation. All of these things as I said it was his main purpose so everything he did revolved around making America great again which means one thing. We must pay off the national debt before we will ever be able to afford the changes that we all hope to see. 8 years of his policies would have done it. No. The Democrats and the pandemic stopped it. It is one thing out of many in the list of his accomplishments which you should have read at the .gov website. Every watcher of CNN and every Trump basher should have went to the.gov website and read the list of his accomplishments then you would have seen a common thread of saving money and creating money. And you would have questioned the authenticity of CNN's reporting. You obviously swallowed the Kool-Aid and are still drinking it. Trump haters never went there. They never read the list. They watched only news that never reported the list. The longest list of any president. Yes very busy making changes. All for one purpose Because they were biased. And so are you because you only watched the news that hated him. If you had read the list you would have seen a common thread. Reducing the size and cost of government. Stopping billions of dollars in foreign aid. Billions of dollars in NATO and W.H.O. He simply said sorry to the rest of the world but we cannot help you as we used to right now. We have to make America first and you'll have to deal with your own troubles. We are deep in debt. And the only way we're going to get the changes we need to see is if we get the debt paid off so we can afford the changes that need to happen. That was temporary. Just like loosening environmental regulations was temporary. Environmental concerns are real. Of course it doesn't sound logical to remove environmental restrictions. But it was only for a season. Maybe for 8 years. Then with the debt paid off and able to afford the changes we need the environmental regulations could have gone back in place including becoming stricter and moving toward The changes that need to happen cannot be afforded therefore the best thing to do is to do everything possible to create a strong economy to get the national debt paid off. I don't know what the numbers are you're talking about. I do know the stock market was record highs. That is a strong indicator of a strong economy. Employment numbers were higher than ever that is a strong indicator. And high employment numbers means tax revenue flowing in instead of going out. It means that people who were pulling money out of the tax revenue in welfare were now leaving that welfare money in the tax revenues. Plus paying in taxes. That is two chunks of money. Conversely in a weak economy they may be pulling money out of the tax revenues while simultaneously not paying money in that is also two chunks of money. Not one. Everything I said was correct. I said everything he did was an attempt to do something about this nation's financial disaster. An attempt is an attempt. And it's like any investment, it might pay off or it might not. We never found out because the pandemic didn't allow the payoff.. if the pandemic had not stopped the economy Trump's last year in office would have made up for all of the investment he did initially to get things jump started. That would not have been enough to pay off the national debt but if it had proceeded for another 4 years at the end of the entire 8 years it would have been paid off. And then we could afford the changes that truly need to happen. The changes that both sides want. Initially you invest money.. yes he created debt yes.. you are correct so what you are correct. Anyone with a brain knows the first step. It takes money to make money. It's called investment. It's no different than a local flower shop startup. They both worked full-time jobs. They invested money. A building, coolers, countertop, cash register, windows, flooring, bathroom fixtures, lighting, decor. Even when they start selling flowers they're not making any profit because it has to go back into the business. It's called investment. Now that flower shop was just about to become profitable when the pandemic shut them down. That's the same thing with Trump. You aren't going to listen because you're trying to spin the truth against everything I say. But what I say will bring more truth than anything you got. I said everything he did was an attempt. And you talk about how it didn't work out so well. But you don't admit that the strong economy that preceded the shutdowns put us in a much better position of strength going into the shutdowns. The actions the took were paying off. You won't admit that the strong economy preceding the shutdowns helped us a tremendously because you hate him and you will twist the truth Any Which Way You Can. But no one is buying it except your fellow Trump haters who are also blind by their hatred. Because love sees the good in someone and cannot see their flaws. But hatred is also blind in a much more insidious way. Because it can only see someone's flaws which everyone has including Trump. And hatred cannot see. I don't save refuses to see. I'm saying cannot see or acknowledge accomplishments. Which were in a list at .gov which you refused to go read, which CNN refuse to report. Because it's a psychological impossibility to hate someone and simultaneously acknowledge their accomplishments. Therefore you will never admit that his strong economy... For a fairly long period of time before the shutdowns... Meant that we entered the shutdowns from a better position of strength. You will never admit that unless you ever achieve the sublimation of hate. Then you will be able psychologically to acknowledge accomplishments that now your brain does not allow you to ever see. Once again it's not that you refuse to acknowledge them. It's because when you hate someone you cannot see them. Not trying to see that! Not willing to hear that! No no no! He undid the preparedness team!!!!! And every other BS that's ever been thrown at Trump except the things that apply to actual flaws which he has some. But do you haters that's the only thing that exists is the flaws.

[@TRICK-OR-TREAT236]

HIS LOVE SONG FOR HIS BITCH DAVID NOW THAT THE DIVORCE IS FINAL. THE REMAINING QUESTION IS WHO GETS CUSTODY OF STEVEN ? L.O.L.

[@sandmtnirishred]

TRICK-OR TREAT oh, you didn't catch it, did you? Not that Nash intended many to be able to do so. He's talking to David. Nash has always been very gifted at almost undetectable manipulation of words and the use of musicians being in the public EAR to make points. According to the other 3 initials: Nash was very professional, everything in its place, time, pocket, etc. Which is essential for musicians. Crosby is very emotionally charged and can find a way to link issues and performers. Neil is a brilliant songwriter and performer of any genre and he's going to blow in and out of every genre and performer he connects with. Stephen is a blindingly brilliant instrumentalist on several instruments, writer, singer, performer, intellectual(it's not everyone in their time who made a double 800 on the SAT for college, speaks 3 languages fluently, etc), and without Stephen's talent for taking everything handed to him from anyone and creating the music for it, none of the rest would be possible. "How you gonna feel when the music dies How you gonna feel soul sadly searching For the wind that is our life..." Steven is dying, honey. No one gets custody.

[@jefflindeman]

Always liked CSN and CSNY. As far as this goes, I gotta say that Nash may very well have a fire in his belly again, but I can only hope that this isn’t representative of what to expect from him in the future. Sorry, but this has absolutely no musical appeal whatsoever. Of course, it’s now 2020 and 4 years after the fact, so I’d say the people’s vote has pretty much been tallied and come up way short.

[@JJohnson1340]

That was dreadful. He was always the weak link, but fuck me , if he got up at the worst open mic in the country he'd be thrown off before the first verse was over .. that was painful..

[@JohnDoe-gk7ok]

opiumpillowcase I think this song is beautiful. Plus, it’s sincere and yet avoids sounding cliche.

[@alt2584]

This song is a tribute to David Crosby. Man Nash really thinks a lot a Crosby to write a song.

[@Stevo_Drums]

A "tribute?" It's really a cleverly disguised criticism of Crosby's lack of integrity, apparently.

[@Buddhamaniac]

NOT a tribute, he is disgusted with Crosby.

[@pietrozignani9667]

che cazzo è?

[@rupertmcnaughtdavis7302]

Not up to CSN standard ,that`s for sure!

[@eoinmurphy210]

ok,i guess its just me ,but i think this is crap.

[@trismegistus7758]

There doesn't exist a word in the OED to accurately describe how bloody awful this tripe truly is.

[@RickStaffordcartunes]

if you ever find a soul you may understand...until then. Doubtful.

[@lanes58]

DM. I assume you are referring to yourself, when you said "this tripe".

[@Stevo_Drums]

Guys... he likes Justin Bieber. Give him a break.

[@trismegistus7758]

Regrettably, some people have a fetish for brandishing their lack of taste and musical acuity in a public forum. Go figure.

[@adrianpeterspeters6149]

Trismegistus now you work hard there you know you will get on, but you have no notion on what on, ha ha, can you really be alive and liveing, no, just existing, oh what a waste of food and water,.....

[@heatsavers]

crap

[@daevidintonti7081]

You need to have something beautiful inside yourself to appreciate The beauty of his music

[@TheNaturalust]

Cliche, mindless drivel with a forgettable melody. Good lyrics though. Needs Crosby to spice it up and Stills to add some musical excitement.

[@perry801]

Since the lyrics are about Crosby, and how he has alienated all the other members by being such an asshole, I would say it's unlikely that he would be invited to "spice this song up". :-)

[@algrand52]

I heard the Biebs and Lady Gaga has some really upbeat and lively tunes. You must have strolled in here quite by mistake. So pls, GTFOH lol