Grandson’s Totaled Car

[@MeriV]

Why the hell isn’t the police that caused the accident paying this young man’s car?? Use their insurance!

[@jayj.6146]

My thoughts exactly! Either the police should pay for it, or the person the police was chasing can be sued.

[@shortcake2204]

Now you know the police will get out of doing anything...I bet their reasoning was because he was driving illegally without insurance.

[@relliej386]

Grandma is a beauty❤

[@JacksQueen.]

I don’t believe granny is going to fool with her grandson’s mom anymore.

[@robinaaayyeee]

I was wondering because they cut it off before she responded. Lol

[@hellofriend760]

I myself think granny's more mad at herself then anyone else,she just salty as a peanut right now..😂

[@maciawilliams9760]

I’m wondering why if her son agreed to get it then why did the mom have to take over? It seems to me like the grandmother should be mad at her son. If he got the insurance initially, then a month hasn’t passed yet unless it was insured while it was getting worked on.

[@tjneverdefeated4394]

@@maciawilliams9760these mothers never like to hold their precious sons accountable 🤦🏾‍♀️

[@infinitig37x84]

After watching the grandma is heated 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@imissmayberry12]

Grandma laid everything out except insurance.

[@adrianknight1406]

I get why Mathis ruled as he did but It's unfortunate that the plaintiff's grandson is out a car and she out 5 grand. But it was a gift so there's no way she was going to recoup the money she put in either way..

[@1980tiffani]

But if she gave it to the grandson as a gift… she’s not owed anything, right? If your mom bought you some sneakers or an expensive suit, if you ripped the suit or someone stole the shoes from the gym locker room.. why would your mom ask you to give her the money the suit or shoes cost? If grandma said he could use the car and had to return it when he got a new one, then yes, this situation would make sense. But if it’s a gift, and it’s gone… the grandson just doesn’t have a car now.

[@jays.5978]

She hit a nerve with JM at the beginning… he got in defense mode real quick!! 😂

[@BREEZYM6015]

It doesn't take much to hit a nerve with him. 😂

[@sjont]

She really didn’t do anything wrong. He expects people to answer his random ass questions when he knows she’s already upset at the incoming verdict

[@mrshappilymarried1]

Yep he hates being corrected.

[@dawnlee866]

I noticed that as well. Then he hit her with “what are u doing for the community in drug rehabilitation process, since u know about what I did.”😂😂 Then she hit him back with all the stuff she actually is doing in the community! 👍🏽

[@tjneverdefeated4394]

And all she was saying is that some crackheads do truly recover. Why that rubbed him the wrong way Idk….

[@jenn_x.]

I love what the audience member who sits behind the plaintiff post-2020 did with her hair. I see you! 😊

[@jsmith2609]

I thought I was the only one paying attention to the staff members/audience. Her hair is beautiful.

[@jenn_x.]

@@jsmith2609 nope - you're not alone. 😁 I even caught it one day when JM singled out one of them by name, so I know that "fade guy with glasses" is actually called Anthony.

[@coreycalloway3268]

Car wasn't insured before leaving the mechanic for pickup, then got hit 20 min later? The car shouldn't have never been MOVED/picked up from the mechanic period without insurance.

[@Sheherhis]

I know I was wondering why plaintiff was making this so complicated. Why did he move an uninsured car?

[@nettejones8276]

It sounds like the grandmother didn't know the car did not have insurance.

[@beauphomasterpiece3795]

@@nettejones8276right meaning that granny son didn’t pay it and she should be suing him . She even said she didn’t know the insurance lasped .

[@mizzmz7051]

Her story brought tears to my eyes prayers to all domestic violence victims 🩵

[@1980tiffani]

I’m over here like 🫢… that’s some tv stuff and I’m glad she made it out safely, but so sad for her and the 3 kids.

[@Nurse_Nash]

🙏🏽🙏🏽🫢

[@AuthenticJoShow]

I wish JM would have spoken to the mother about accountability though...😢

[@FalaqX]

Google her, she wrote a book & everything

[@PrettyEyesz]

Wow that's wonderful.

[@Jason_T0203]

I just read the news article about this smh

[@Toriab]

That’s so sad. I’m praying for her because I couldn’t imagine going through this

[@bing7play]

You can explain stuff 1000 times to some people and they will just never get it 🤷🏿

[@KayB-l5h]

I don't think the plaintiff thought through what she was doing. I thought she was gonna be suing for payments or something she loaned them for the car. But I can understand her being mad at money wasted. He totaled it 25 minutes after she gave it to him. Sounds like she should be suing the police department.

[@shaydaslays]

Probably can't sense they were driving illegally with no insurance

[@Prettythompkins242]

You cannot scare or humiliate anyone into recovery. If addicts don’t care about their kids and families wtf makes JM think that they care about his opinion?

[@jgwphilly1969]

That actually doesn’t work. Humiliating people is not effective. Motivational interviewing not confrontation.

[@jenn_x.]

I was thinking the same thing when he bragged about shaming people to set them straight. Shame and humiliation usually makes people double down in most cases. In fact, about the he only time I ever see it work is when a male is called out on disrespecting his mother.

[@velmalathan3402]

God bless you queen that's very traumatic sending healing energy your way 🙏🏽 ❤

[@nopenallnull]

What does her being kidnapped have to do with this case????

[@mcharle01]

She looking for sympathy and it worked!

[@bettywilliams9633]

It sure did

[@virginiamelanin0510]

Not a damn thing That was over 20 years ago but her Son was out of a car at age 17 because of her negligence

[@bludiva27]

Ratings.

[@yeahthatslaki9877]

@@mcharle01whether she told her story or not, the plaintiff still had no standing

[@meeksluvspink9047]

Mom needs to use her tax refund or something, to get her son a car. He sounds like a good kids and deserves it

[@setteam9337]

Nanna got a voice like velcro

[@tracym4175]

😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@PrettyEyesz]

Funny I imagined her voice the moment I saw your comment. You described it quite accurately. Her voice sounded just like I imagined it would.

[@jays.5978]

She smokes

[@cassandra6710]

Omg you so wrong. 😂😂

[@33Tiffny]

😂😂LOL huhhhhhhhhh

[@cupofchi_]

both of them are so beautiful. sending healing to mom

[@lilmai2616]

I really like the grandmother's personality.

[@MrLenroc82]

How were they supposed to have insurance on the car if he only had for 25 minutes??? If she cared sooooo much, she would have insured the car until he could afford it.

[@beauphomasterpiece3795]

At least until he made it home . 😂😂

[@papalegbasson2447]

She loves her grandson. She's very proud 👏 🥲 🥰

[@tracym4175]

Where is her son? This storyline is getting old.

[@deetheefoodie]

I don’t think he needed to be there. She spoke to her husband about gifting the grandson the car. Seems like her son was and still is involved in his son life.

[@jayj.6146]

@@deetheefoodieI think the OP is asking why isn’t the grandmother suing her son as well because the parents should be equally responsible to cover the insurance for their minor son. But she’s only suing the mother.

[@deandraallen6679]

Because the agreement was with the mother, not dad 🤷🏾‍♀️

[@tracym4175]

@deandraalle6679 well now that mom isn't on the hook, dad should help his mom out 😐

[@donte53moore]

If mom was like grandma the kid would probably be an actor already .Mom’s choices in men explains a lot.😢 GOOD LUCK kid fr

[@salenachannel769]

So nobody told him he didn't have insurance? The insurance probably wouldn't have covered his lost

[@BlackShogun]

Uninsured motorist coverage would apply in case of hit and run.

[@shostoppah111]

Sue the police dept.. oh wait no insurance 🤦🏾‍♀️ insurance for a 17 yr old is high ah

[@jayj.6146]

Yeah! To add my son to our insurance policy as a new driver it would’ve been an extra $250 a month.

[@tjneverdefeated4394]

Oh yeah it’s definitely going to affect their relationship.

[@susiesolangesimpson2828]

We didn’t need to know about her ex being killed by the police.

[@fundifferent1]

The producers be telling them to get their "stories" together for the show. All reality show "actors" these days have a "story". You can't watch American Idol or Survivor without each contestant telling their 5 min sob story.

[@ShesFromVenus]

“And I guess I’m saying, you have no standing…” 🤣😂

[@RacieRain]

How is she suing for the cost of the car she gifted to her grandson?

[@deetheefoodie]

That’s what I’m saying too.

[@virginiamelanin0510]

Because the grandson is a minor

[@yeahthatslaki9877]

He could have took that car and spray painted if he wanted it’s his car

[@victoriabradford6156]

Sometimes the judge can be a ass hole

[@deetheefoodie]

I hope her grandson goes into nursing or the medical field in general…we need more caring black men in the field

[@ki9206]

1. It’s a gift 2. It’s a promise not contracted agreement 3. You are not the parent to the minor 4. A car for a child is a luxury not necessity 5. A car doesn’t get you out of trouble 6. Grandma thinks she can raise him better (at least I get those vibes) 7. Why didn’t she sue her son/the father too?!

[@beauphomasterpiece3795]

Right . Your #7 .. her own son didn’t pay the insurance and let it lasp in coverage. Cause remember she said she called to ask the grandsons mom to cover the insurance but she would had to pay more too since it’s lasped in coverage . Granny doesn’t seem to know what she doing here

[@TheToyBox333]

Granny You KNOW better… and how can you hold her responsible…? She wasn’t driving… and insurance should have been in the person name driving IT…!! 🤦🏾‍♀️

[@sha1genesis]

Lesson Learned make children or anyone for that matter pay for items that you desire to still have control over. Contracts signed with understanding for both parties work mostly.

[@LorraineGross-s7w]

I understand why grandmother is upset with the mother. The mother definitely should have had insurance on the car for a teenager. Judge Mathias should have said something to the mother to make her accountable and the grandson should had been in court. Mother spoke more about her abusive relationship than the car. The mother should have been accountable and I feel grandmother is going to put distance between her and grandson mother.

[@LorraineGross-s7w]

We said the same thing and I didn’t see your comment until after I posted. I agree with you

[@fundifferent1]

Just ask the mother to buy the replacement car....Or...that's what she tried to do, the mom said no and so now she thinks she can take her to court and basically make her buy the car.

[@nothx512]

If her abduction has to do with the car being totaled....then I would want to hear it...pls stick to incidents ONLY involving the case please

[@33Tiffny]

Right lmao

[@lildevil872]

The thing is the producers often ask the litigants to air their dirty laundry prior to the case. They are asked to say interesting things about their lives and relationship.

[@gt43025]

Defendants sad story dragged on too long. Had to cut off. Who won? 😂

[@ieshaanderson1317]

😂

[@bovinityleak2066]

Nobody

[@fundifferent1]

She did.

[@lillian4404]

God bless you Judge Mathis.🖤👑💯.

[@Tigersniper99]

That’s a wild story!

[@virgo_hershey_kisses2990]

He should’ve sued the person that hit. And if she only paid $3000 for the car he would’ve been lucky to even get $500 for the car from the insurance company anyway.

[@marshallelliott8894]

Grandma a baritone.....

[@saturnladee110]

I want her voice while I am in public to scare the predators away. 😂😂😂

[@TheAdot8808]

Rip detective Wally 😢

[@leyahruizdeloreto6420]

Why did the defendant have to tell her story too?? Write a book if you have a story.

[@alexishart3623]

She did

[@mtuck1993]

Why couldn’t the grandson pay for his own insurance if he really wanted the car ? He already had a job and was working. & Where is the dad ?

[@jimmcdonald9490]

Wait did I miss something? Where is dad in all this? Agreement with mom or not, I’m surprised Mathis didn’t ask the million dollar question lol... maybe I need to run this one back a few times 😂. And how is no car automatically mean grandson is gonna end up on the corner if hes such a good boy lol. I mean I get it but I don’t ... guess dad is serving time or a deadbeat since not even SHE brought him up . Sad

[@jarronwilliams7227]

isnt that what the lady explained in the beginning? i thought the dad was the abusive guy

[@fundifferent1]

@@jarronwilliams7227 No that was the dad of the other 3 kids. This is the son of the plaintiff's son. But this doesn't involve him. The Grandmom seems to think the mom owes her since she said she'd pay the insurance.

[@Bolobei]

Its Thursday, I'm here

[@juniorstarks7494]

I’m here too

[@cassandra6710]

Here as well.

[@kirkmo1666]

God is so amazing. Even in a total mess He still sent his only son to pay our penalty for sin. And now all we have to do is accept Jesus Christ as our personal Savior to have everlasting life after this one.

[@codiestrauss8132]

What does this have to do with the Case love

[@kirkmo1666]

@codiestrauss8132 He's a God of a second chance. Getting off drugs and escaping an abusive potentially deadly relationship doesn't even scratch the surface of what God wants to do in our lives. Accepting Christ as a personal Savior has benefits beyond my explanation. Not to mention everlasting life. This has everything to do with this case. My opinion...

[@locafly]

HALLELUJAH 🎉🎉🙏🏽🙏🏽💜💜💜 Thank you Jesus!

[@charismamartin1545]

Amen

[@badseedent4827]

Ive heard mathis lie alot especially about his "thuggin" but him not caring about feelings is the biggest lie ever left his mouth... He literally rules on his feelings... Not law😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@SSMarie]

The Mother should have been held accountable for not putting insurance on the car. Who receives a free car and don’t pay insurance for their child to drive around

[@ISayToMyself]

Both these ladies need to write a book. 😮

[@bing7play]

How many packs of cigs a day yall think this lady smokes 😂

[@fundifferent1]

She said she was the female Pookie

[@naterriebracynebblett4435]

I'm here My Beloved Favorite Judge***ASHAY***

[@Ginaaaa555]

Grandma you need to stop. You act like she drove it

[@skorwolf2719]

Who's name was the insurance

[@kianaCAB]

You can't humiliate someone into recovery, a lot of times that pushes them more toward the drug in choice

[@KoriCalciano-yw1fz]

I bet u that’s the last time she watched maths

[@kennethbrown6141]

Mom was not engaged with the car arrangements. This family was not on the same page before purchasing the car. Granny was moving too fast on her own...

[@brenttucker3933]

I know she shouldn’t but a little lie at the end about him going to college for something might’ve swayed Judge to reach in his pockets for this one 😏. A’s and B’s! Come on people😅😅

[@marcusford809]

You can tell she’s a single grandma

[@frankrice9520]

This is why grandparents must never have any rights to grandchildren! They are old, stubborn, stuck in the past, confused, disrespectful and often interfere as if the grandchildren are THEIRS !

[@carolharris5455]

Momma should be ashamed of what she did just horrible

[@bludiva27]

What did that long story have to do with the case?

[@cheikhsarr5176]

Violence is never a solution. Get down and talk your problems through. Otherwise, go to your séparate ways

[@gonegirldiaries]

wow, prayers to her🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾

[@beauphomasterpiece3795]

Just started but why sue the mom and not your son ? Edit: Your son had the insurance placed on the car and it lasped in 25 minutes after the your grandson picks it up. The insurance had lasped before the purchase it sounds like and you should be suing your son .

[@khartford62]

If the kid has feet, he has transportation.

[@deetheefoodie]

My dad gifted my 16 year old a charger. I was livid cuz whyyyyy sir. So I got the title in my name and sold the car. I got my son another smaller car, that I felt was good for a first car. After we got the car, we found it need a transmission (I definitely take the blame cuz I didn’t take anyone with me)….I didn’t call my dad about it. My husband and I paid for it. My parents did find out till last year. If something is a gift, u can’t dictate it after it’s given.

[@jarronwilliams7227]

i know yo son was PISSED.

[@virgo_hershey_kisses2990]

So now grandma bout to blame his future degenerate behavior on an uninsured car 🙄 lady stop it! She’s about to cause an unnecessary rift between her grandson and his mother. And even if the car was insured they weren’t paying out a claim for a car that he only had for 25 minutes 😂

[@nothgir]

Judge was kinda rude to the grandmother. She’s been good to her grandson in the absence of his father. The mother needs to meet the grandmother half way considering all that she’s done for him/her thus far.

[@nettejones8276]

This entire case went over the plaintiff's head. Once you make a gift of something it's no longer your concern. Her logic is flawed

[@akilahabell75]

Poor Hanna

[@karendorsey4780]

That’s part of being a grandparent! You spoil them! You can’t blame the parents when you give their child something ! The parents couldn’t afford to give! Judge Mathis made the correct ruling.

[@dance4life1208]

Damn she had 3 kids at 25

[@Alphonse72]

If the police caused the loss, why aren’t they paying for it????

[@hiphop3sree3]

So this a real life pokisha

[@Maya-lv5ed]

She tried to guilt trip talking about her grandson gonna be on the street because he don’t have a car

[@CrackHead-iy5vt]

She wanted the bad guy from the beginning

[@toya1374]

Maybe he wasnt ready to drive if he totaled the car within the 1st 30 minutes

[@lavidaloca2344]

He was hit during a police chase 🤷🏽‍♀️

[@KayB-l5h]

Judge so prissy and such a bragging fool.

[@yeahthatslaki9877]

That man was ready to die that day, he definitely would have murdered her that day if the police didn’t come. He had his mind made up

[@suzieque5989]

She sounds like a female Morgan freeman! Not talking down on granny at all, ijs

[@prose6827]

Im sorry but what does the younger ladies story has to do with this case? She didnt even tell the story in an interesting way

[@raymondbennettjr.8845]

William Wolly rolniak jr is the guy to look up to find the tragic story Natasha mentioned blessings to all

[@brendahudson8578]

Where's the daddy??

[@robert123461]

I don’t think it’s registering to the grandma want the law is

[@jew-el1]

Fast little girls 8:15 this is the penalty- trauma‼️

[@just_here30]

And get on the fast little boys who cause the trauma

[@crmm1004]

okay ! they love blaming the females tf them lil boys just as fass @@just_here30

[@TrulyOutrageous]

parents not doing their hob

[@keeshamcmillon4282]

This was hard to watch

[@burgerbish]

This doesn't seem right

[@xxxx2935]

.( DEUTERONOMY ) 28 : 15 - 68.. 100%. It's not a discussion !

[@khrisi9410]

People in the comments triggered by the Defendants story 😂 and the Plaintiffs grandson is a bum at his young age.

[@earlisanorman3709]

😢😢😢

[@kimthomas6044]

I don't like granny she still got crackish ways

[@MrsB320]

Can he sue his MOMMA ???😮😮😮 WHAT ???? 17:42 SOOOOOO SAD! He don’t need to work or have a car … he crashed it make him pay in yard work… so sad

[@TROLLzenbergRAW]

Grandson is doomed… grandma need to let that man be a man he 17 the real world not gon hold his hand …

[@Ladylegree21]

Present 🎉🎉🎉

[@rashen24]

First🎉🎉🎉🎉