GRWM as we catch up!

[@libbynihill9801]

I was 16 when I started watching you. Now I’m 29, married and watching this while I breastfeed my 7 month old. You’ve changed and grown and so has your audience. I’d love a chatty ep about how you manage the division of labour in your house and how you and Jackson communicate about your roles inside the house. Big love, all the way from Australia

[@jenettabarlow3197]

Oh my heck! I’m only 26, but I feel ya 💯. Please do this Carlie I would so watch every week. 🤗

[@janetcho90]

Started watching you when I was in high school and now I’m 29, married, and a new mom. Crazy to hear that you were struggling back then because you were the epitome of everything I wanted to be. Beautiful, well spoken, witty, honest, and carries yourself with so much grace. Thanks for sharing, friend and would love ALL the advice for new moms 😊

[@xocnlx3]

Aww Carlie I’m so happy to see you back on here!! I’m 30 and absolutely loved watching your family’s videos throughout my high school and college years. I’m so glad to see life has been good to you these last several years ❤️

[@cortneylang3881]

So happy you’re back!! I watch you over on Instagram but it all started on KZbin. I remember the mom’s view, I loved that!! I found you thru Shay & just have always loved your personality and realness. Can’t wait for what’s to come!! ❤️💕

[@miraix6493]

awwhh we missed you too ❤so glad to have you back on youtube!

[@hello_danielle]

This was fun! I have watched since the beginning. I loved seeing your own personality and seeing someone who had a more relatable life on the mom’s view. I actually didn’t realize how young you were because I was 18 myself. Now I’m laying here married with my 7 month old. You have come so far and we all have grown up so much!

[@madikam]

Gosh, I got off of social media about a year ago and I have thought about you and your family often! Which is probably strange, as a stranger 😂 but I really just adore you all. I’ve been watching you for so many years and have made a family of my own in that time, I’d love to see you on here as often as you’re willing and able to do as a busy mama!

[@Amipalovestwilight]

Yes, I'm excited for this series! I love listening to peoples stories and unique wisdom. Having gone through hard times and admiting that you're not perfect is not a bad thing. It just makes you more relatable, approachable and human, because everybody experiences hardship at one point or another. I personally would love to know if and how the experiences in your twenties (not following the "traditional path") impacted and shaped your religious beliefs. Did your views on certain things change and if so, how? (Obviously just answer if you're comfortable sharing.) Much ❤ from a viewer from Germany!

[@Donnatize]

I’d love to hear parenting advice within a marriage. My husband and I were raised differently so both have different ideas and expectations for our kids childhoods and our kids behaviour. I would love to hear your thoughts on all growing together as a family and balancing your own hopes and visions with the realities of equal partnership in parenting. Sorry if that’s too Moms View-ey. I used to love watching the Moms View before I became a mother 😊 Also I just wanted to say to your younger self that you were raised in a culture that defines success as married for all eternity with lots of children. That is a crazy HIGH expectation in the world we live in today. And not something you can have full control over achieving. You were brilliant then and brilliant now because you didn’t stay small and cosy, you kept pushing and challenging yourself. It’s stuff that will be inspirational for your 3 daughters to know about one day I’d say ❤

[@katelyn_love]

Love your vulnerability here! So excited to see more x

[@brookbell5466]

What concealer did you use? Loved this!!!

[@REALxSWEETIExXOX]

This is so fun! Been watching you since the beginning and would love to get more content from you and a glimpse into your current and past life!

[@abbiestinnett5792]

Of course I love your family vlogs but its good to see you back on here as yourself having some “private girl time.” I started watching your videos in probably 2013 when I found the shaytards and I always admired your beauty and personality and how you didn’t care to be goofy and “immature” I alwys thought to myself that I want to continue to have fun and be playful as an adult. I looked up to you and wanted to be that when I grow up and I am both scared and excited to see what I will be like when I am 36 and looking back to now seeing how much I have changed and its crazy to comprehend that who I am right now and who I am trying to be is most likely not who I’m gonna be by then, I am so excited for this new chapter of your channel and thanks for the girls chat!

[@naylaleifson9022]

How do I get that mascara❤❤ so glad your back & love your other channel to

[@c4arla]

To me Carlie has always been the same just really genuine and fun and not to concern and if anything really confident and actually for me its you who made the whole Butler clan so relatable and nice

[@bezzziek]

So excited!! 🎉

[@SumayaAhmed-j4r]

how it felt being a young mom+teen pregnancy, teen pregnancy compared to now, shaytards and being part of all that, previous relationships then finding Jackson all that would be so interesting

[@CaitlinDunbar]

Is what’s up woods coming back?? I loved your vlogs! Excited for new beginnings ❤

[@amandaryan2122]

Ahhhhh so excited!!!!

[@katelynkeck]

Ahhhh so excited you’re back!!!

[@hello_danielle]

As a new mom I would love to hear your advice on how to not lose yourself and how to still feel like you and take care of yourself. Also any advice or wisdom you can share on boundaries with family especially husband’s family and how to not be a people pleaser. It’s so hard to not get caught up in everyone requests to see my baby when life is crazy and busy. I want to give them opportunities to build that relationship of course but she is 7 months old and my husband and I have been going through a lot of changes and it’s challenging to be figuring out how to be parents and also running around meeting up family or having people over often. Hope this makes sense it’s my bed time lol

[@devonparker9211]

Yay!!! I’ve missed you on here!!

[@annefraser6908]

Sounds good ,great ur back uk

[@tristaburns4236]

Could you have Kayli on one day? Maybe talk about if you ever felt like you would never find the love of your life, and that you’re behind the game compared to everyone your age. I’m 20

[@ljke]

What are the first 3 products that you used???

[@TWOCRAZZIE]

What foundation did you use?

[@heartsndots]

Please don't "come back" and then not do any videos afterall. I'm too excited for this now! 😅❤

[@HorsePrints]

having first baby in august PLZ do a newborn must haves / what to expect as a first time mom.

[@cherylhall8975]

Love this❤

[@Sassygrannyvlogs]

💙

[@ambolyne17]

I would love for you to talk more about your first marriage and was it with a member of the church and maybe why it didn’t work. Also, I grew up Mormon and decided many many years ago it wasn’t for me (and I believe there are lots of lies, cult like behavior and many more reasons). You have always been so “normal” yet still active and proud of being Mormon. Do you 100% believe in it or is it just part of how you grew up so you feel obligated to be a Mormon. Not throwing shade just curious. I know there is a lot of info out there that disproves the churches history, but at the end of the day it doesn’t matter if being a Mormon makes you happy. Hope you know this all came from love. Just curious. Have loved watching you for years. Also you’re hella funny and I love when you’re brutally honest. And let’s be real. I love that Copper and Lenny are so unafraid to be “naughty” like flipping you off. Shows you’re a cool mom just doing life with a fun spirit and yet making sure they always feel like they can be themselves. K that’s all! ❤❤❤

[@jackieturley4775]

❤

[@jovialthinker]

Yay!!! 🎉

[@Haleybluebarry7]

😮

[@Lilbro2018]

🎉❤🎉

[@Kkimmey]

❤❤😊😊

[@user-vf9qe3oq4y]

saving money advice

[@eringilfoy5891]

Postpartum body positive vids pls 😭

[@thomasmontella6481]

It only took 3 days to coment! I owe u the biggest apology. That mankind can give you! Sometimes stupidity runs my life and runs head on with others needs wants and desires and for the first time I feel like a honeymooner once again! Not a good place to be especially when only one instead of two have been on an 16:53 journey

[@mariaalejandragomezgiglian4886]

Hi carlie! I Wonder if you do this full Face of make up everyday... and then Take it off at night? Love3 your videos!