國外聲樂老師點評 C AllStar & 馮允謙 Jay Fung《銀河修理員》

[@ttcatherine2328]

5:02 "He looks shiny like a guy we would like" 5:43 "Actually I like that guy's tone" 釗峰把聲好正

[@jy8010]

more c all star pls!!!! they are really The best singing group in HK currently！

[@carmenchan2193]

我都鍾意釗峰音色! I like Chiu Fung's tone too~🤩

[@htng]

"C" in "C AllStar" means "Kingdom C", which is the name of their company. All the 4 members of this group joined the same singing contest organized by Kingdom C, and awarded 1st to 4th place respectively. Although the company aimed to sign only the winner originally, eventually the producer thought all the 4 guys are talented thus decided to sign them all and form this singing group - "C AllStar". The group is well known for the harmonic singing while each of them is capable of taking lead role. They were also famous for busking on street in a capella style. Hope to see more reviews for C AllStar with their own songs.

[@tang3272]

C AllStar is underrated

[@tungtungx2]

oh my god!! C AllStar!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!the last album is fantastic, highly recommend!!!!!!!

[@jeclngng1085]

我係香港人，但最近十年廿年都好少聽廣東歌，多謝flo仲有留意香港樂壇😘🤗😊

[@RickyChow510]

你都好慘

[@tinlokchan7314]

must listen their famous song 天梯

[@iceyfung]

Please do a video with C AllStar 's live 🤟🤟

[@RB-zk2vo]

超愛JayFung❤

[@chunsingko4160]

6 號嘅 Let us go then you and i 超正 希望可以做一集

[@Tsj7473]

6:32 聽到佢指出和聲嘅時候，我放心了

[@YAUBELLEBELLE]

More C Allstar please ❤

[@isroying]

Jay is among the best vocalists in current canto pop scene. C All Star may perhaps be the best harmonized vocal group HK has. Another great singer in harmonizing is Yoyo Shum.

[@garry527]

Should have explained the lyrics! “Other than pain everything would be okay!” That’s why he used a tone that is like comforting a baby!

[@rickylau1595]

I always agree with Jay opinions 😂

[@lairanky5760]

作為香港人，要勇於接受批評；一板一眼的表現還未夠好，更多自由度的即興表演，才可以經得起高水平的點評。

[@opf1995]

留下來的人 PLZ

[@ww2200]

嗰個查查真係好嘈😂😂😂

[@hayleyyung3]

Pleaseeeee do a reaction video for Anita Mui like any songs please!!!❤ her whole stage presence and charisma is OUT OF THIS WORLD ! My personally favourite is her concert performance in 1991🥹 but she passed away 21 years ago so there will not be a very up to date performance from her that you could react to but I really hope that you would do a reaction for her and putting that aside please 🙏 ❤️❤️

[@hinson-y6t]

推Call Star 時日如飛

[@pandayy8865]

Haha the first guy On jai is my favorite from CAllStar. But I understand what the guy meant bc if you try to sing like the girl sing ppl in Cantonese might criticize you singing without emotion. Bc singing like the girl is kinda what you would do in a choir?

[@echeung2087]

3:05 我讚成JKAI 講法 "咁唱有感情D喎" 😁

[@可米仔-g9l]

@@echeung2087 唔用柔情唱法，而用硬朗方式去演繹，因為呢隻歌本身就唔係抒情歌！而係一隻香港勵志歌！ 大家都明！

[@FunGwoSiuMai]

as a cantonese speaker, i totally agree with Rozette...i don't resonate with that old school jacky cheung thing and cantonese doesn't always have to be like that

[@gingerboy1333]

I definitely disagree you saying that the beginning of the song / that first letter sounds like a style~ As a Cantonese, I definitely agree with Jay! It’s how the word sounds like even when i speak! 😂😂😂

[@AK-ce6zv]

They form the band “C all star” because they want to become artist and they will have chance to “See” all the famous “stars” in Hong Kong.

[@hayyamlina7532]

please react to Dionela’s Marilag live at the cozy cove

[@trevorswang]

我鼓手 對我快被那個高頻攻擊到死亡了 十分需要deesser

[@hohoho._.]

Im curious, is that Flo cant read chinese? Since every time Rozette ask sth about the singer, she cant answer. I guess she has checked out wikipedia but eng version? Cos the Chinese vesrion one usually has the answer. Maybe next time can check out the chinese version first ( if she can read ~ )

[@loklok6076]

很少聽廣東歌，C All-star 是少有會聽。因為他們很多都不屬商業創作，而是生活中情感與社會面對的狀況令大眾有共鳴。他們撲實無華沒特別技巧去粉飾演釋，但又能獲取聽眾支持。在香港是很難得的清流. 鼓手kb是LMF前成員，好像有一邊耳有點問題，所以沒控制好音量。當年LMF的創作團隊也是一絕，但太多歌不能放出來😅

[@zebraimage]

这期应该上不了B站

[@echeung2087]

是的話挺可惜 畢竟是首好歌

[@Sum_sum_berry]

為什麼？

[@echeung2087]

​@Sum_sum_berry 來來去去咪又係得嗰幾個原因😂 你懂的

[@Sum_sum_berry]

@@echeung2087 大概估到咩原因，但唔知問題出喺人定首歌度，不過我估係c all star?

[@BONFA4EVA]

Can you please do a reaction of Jay Fung and Janice’s performance of song called 一格格 kzbin.info/www/bejne/qmKQpGqPmsd0Z80si=hyjqmcqya0GHLVbx

[@shetatong5264]

「C」代表他們的經理人公司Kingdom C的簡稱，而「AllStar」是他們都喜愛的鞋子品牌。 資料來源：維基

[@realchaopeng]

Trash can lid is actually fit the song, the song is about fixing the trash world

[@sigmatsang]

C AllStar這個名字源於他們的經理人公司，「C」代表 Kingdom C，即 C AllStar所屬經理人公司的簡稱，而「AllStar」是他們都喜愛的鞋子品牌。 from wiki

[@ykiku1366]

@@sigmatsang 呢個解釋Wiki唔係好啱，C 係公司Kingdom C冇錯，但AllStar係因為佢哋四個係Kingdom C搞嘅歌唱比賽頭四名，好似NBA All Star藍球賽入面嘅All Star咁解

[@sigmatsang]

@@ykiku1366 謝謝補充

[@Tommy-vr2vz]

試下聽 至少做了一件離譜的事 黑玻璃

[@manchan9815]

This is what we Hongkongers gotta recommend to the others, not the overrated boy band starting with M.

[@kalun888]

解釋錯晒。如果生在香港，講的說話同識講廣東話都吾同。吾咬字，個音就變abc,廣東話就係咁，一個字其實有幾個音，像個你字，咬字吾咬字都吾同，可以講到「理」香港長大既香港人唱歌都會係咁

[@可米仔-g9l]

如果明呢隻歌本身嘅意義，就會明白點解一開始會一種硬朗，但又帶有悲傷嘅方式去唱！ 大家都明，香港加油💪🏼

[@athomenotavailable]

Terrible cymbals

[@LCR-f1s]

I think chiu fung is doing too much to his voice, like as a group, that may be nice to hear some lines from him. but when he’s doing solo, it’s so tiring to hear the whole song from him

[@htng]

Yes, ever since he started doing solo project, he has been singing in sort of exaggerated tone and got a number of reviews/comments saying that's "overacting". However, he seems to be aware of this recently, and his latest songs have fine tuned the style. Suggest you can listen to《離合的藝術》and see if that sounds more acceptable to you.

[@SC-fv6tl]

老師第一句就get到劍chiu fung嘅作撞🤣

[@kj8866]

@@SC-fv6tl 第一句安仔嚟㗎喎😂