國外聲樂老師點評

[@alexc3309]

我觉得这首歌，就是袁娅维的巅峰了。 在流行和小众之间，达到了最完美的平衡点

[@Kansou67]

還有歌手2017第一期的阿楚姑娘 這兩首都是巔峰

[@snoope.snoope]

沒錯沒錯 近年都好油好漂（也許剛好都看到這樣的 害我好想念她😢 也許她到了撞牆期了吧

[@DennisJ16]

@@snoope.snoope 不如听听早年乐队时期的袁娅维，看看是不是“好油好漂” 她自己的审美可能没怎么变过，只是你能接受的一直都是一部分的她罢了

[@snoope.snoope]

@@DennisJ16 她那時的氣息還沒那麼穩，參賽這時候技巧真的成熟很多

[@小提琴-k3c]

​@@Kansou67那期好像是最後一名，差一點淘汰😂😂

[@Zachary8848]

Tia 最神級的live之ㄧ!!!

[@鍾承軒-p6j]

這一場不是live

[@egg1080]

+1，太強

[@egg1080]

​@use老師都說了這場連修音部分都很少，你說這場演出不是現場...真的不懂不要亂說r-ps1cs2xc5w

[@shikin7963]

@@egg1080live是直播的意思，歌手除了最后的一集都是录播的，音轨肯定是tia当时唱的，但这个音频一听就知道是后期过的，所以说不是live一点毛病没有

[@mana15951]

只要看到袁婭維就會想起這首,當初聽到真的超級驚豔

[@Love-df8ji]

袁婭維參加過很多次節目歌手，都留下代表作，挑戰不同曲風 2017歌手，除了開往春天的地鐵外，其他像是愛是懷疑、golden都讓人驚艷 2020歌手～淒美地、I love you 3000, 以及突圍賽開大絕的盛夏光年 希望橘老師也能評論以上這幾首～

[@ph0086744]

老師終於評了我看歌手多年最愛的表演了，真的好愛Tia這首的演繹，非常動聽精彩！

[@jiachenyu5698]

哇哇哇哇 我之前留言过想评价这首的，终于等到了！！！我觉得这首超级绝，当年比赛的时候当下第一遍我只是觉得厉害，但是又过了一两年的以后某天我突然被震撼到反复听 越听越觉得绝 就那种被blown away的感觉。你们有没有同感啊！就非常完美的现场诶没什么缺点的那种！

[@櫻太郎-k8k]

這真的是很神的 live，2017從年頭聽到年尾還聽不膩，現在聽依然神

[@viviensiu9352]

終於等到Tia泥首開往春天，真係好好聽，幾年前睇左泥個performance真係好聽到癲，自己時不時都會去翻聽，係神級之作！

[@塑膠是吃貨]

期待這首歌曲很久了!!!!

[@hsieheden]

終於等到了！下次聽聽“存不存在”！

[@staceshei5225]

我也在等！！！！！！

[@jacky710812]

希望可以解析韓國歌手鄭恩地視頻😊

[@vivian7247]

Finally! This is my favourite performance from her! That transition to “kiss from a rose” was so unexpected yet perfect to me and really push the whole song to an exciting climax!

[@maigiopang6882]

@@vivian7247 absolutely , the best of Tia

[@zhpan342]

終於等到這首～🎉 但還是私心敲碗拉拉😭😭

[@kcmann8708]

Tia's "Love can fly" was even better on the 2020 Singer show.

[@edwardk8477]

这个D6非常神奇。一开始入耳的感觉是D5的belting有很好的共鸣并且携带了D6的泛音（我相信这就是老师讲的像Celine Dion飙高音的音色），然后D5和D6的比例就非常丝滑地转换直到变成D6的哨音，蛮奇妙的

[@跟喝]

沒有吧, D5切D6而且還是混轉哨,你說胸混轉頭混還有一點可能,哨音跟混聲是完全不一樣的東西,除非你是外星人,不然不可能絲滑的轉換,應該是celine dion的高音都有泛音聽著像六組,導致聽到六組以為是五組

[@跟喝]

by the way我喜歡 tia + celine dion (雖然比較喜歡celine dion)但我不是想踩tia或你

[@Jacindalau25]

She does best when she uses her techniques just right but also keep the melody of the songs. When she does too much sometimes we can’t appreciate the song 😅 I always love watching her because I see the potential but she does a bit too much sometimes. But when she finds the balance, she’s flawless 💖

[@张张-q8s]

Golden

[@hong-zhenwu8799]

Please also do reaction videos of “Golden” from 歌手2017；”存不存在”、”我愛” from 歌手 2020 and “愛” from 中國之星

[@Simon-bu7ld]

She reviewed 愛 already in a comparison video

[@hong-zhenwu8799]

She did a 愛 comparison but Tia was not in it.

[@Simon-bu7ld]

@@hong-zhenwu8799 Wow really?my bad

[@holohulolo]

Yeah that lasts long is also one of several performance I wanted to see her review. But that particular version in that show, is probably one of the best cover of that karen mok song. She did a high not but ita so fitting to the arrangement and so good. Although I remember there being a very tiny hiccup somewhere in that song either on the high not or leading to it but it was still so satisfying.

[@holohulolo]

​@@Simon-bu7ldyeah I remember watching that video and commented why tias version isnt included. I thinn at the time this was not in their radar yet, i keep commenting to review more tia and they eventually did, but probably not because of my comments

[@沈毓秋-y5l]

Tia的Love can fly 是她的必聽曲！

[@P877883225]

終於等到這首歌 超愛

[@Iasbeyl]

我的愛歌😍😍😍

[@黃愷輝]

其實我覺得tia不是不知道怎麼比賽， 而是她想要在舞台上用自己喜歡的方式表演。 她是有這個實力的。 我認為她是少數超脫競技、放下排名的歌手。 如果該死的芒果有歌手2025的話，希望她當首發歌手，不要再搞個和好姐妹廝殺的劇本。

[@陳泓尹-m3k]

袁很敬業，總是配合導演節目組的安排! 無論是不是現場有沒有修音 她都是強大的演唱+技術型歌手

[@BoggyYen]

總算有這首了……從老師有聽Tia之後就一直敲碗這首……絕對是Tia最強的舞台沒有之一 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@egg1080]

其實Tia在另一個節目翻唱莫文蔚的愛也使用過很高超的海豚音，還有翻唱林志炫的蒙娜麗莎，結尾也有使用非常驚人的海豚音，而且她的海豚音我覺得聽起來更有瑪莉亞凱莉的感覺，比較尖銳那種。 張靚穎的海豚音就比較偏頭聲的女高音，比較沒有那種海豚音穿出雲端那種感覺，是比較柔和的美聲那種。 黃霄雲的海豚音也是非常高超而且很優美。

[@RB-zk2vo]

袁婭維❤希望她更加厲害進步

[@vl7up]

Vintage TIA. This is hands-down the best performance from her in my opinion.

[@egg1080]

好棒喔.搭配音樂更讚.感謝

[@jiachenyu5698]

the song really showed her optimum state and skill of singing. flawless performance.

[@jiachenyu5698]

I have watched many countries' music talent shows since I was a child, and my taste for music has been improved through listening. My ears are also very sensitive.

[@adrianteoh93]

终于等到这首歌的reflection了！！

[@dimetosansu]

Reaction 😅

[@YeYing-i3u]

阿楚姑娘也好好听

[@Bisazu]

敲碗「存不存在」這才是真的封神🙌

[@imissu0812]

從這首歌開始算迷上了袁娅维的歌聲 比較耐聽的還有阿楚姑娘、靠近 她其他歌老實說 並沒到很吸引我 開往春天的地鐵真的是很讚!!

[@jackyzhu8627]

Recommed Tia [ I love you 3000 + 我想]❤

[@lin_k2673]

我很期待後面有阿楚姑娘

[@某人-v4e]

希望老師可以點評一下周深在《音樂緣計劃》中唱的《沉默的羔羊》，這首歌真的很好聽🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@carrieyou620]

It would be soooooo great if you guys would do reaction videos of l'm Not Good 如果你聽見(from tttv05), 刻在我心底的名字(from tttv01), 風情萬種(from tttv 03) and I Love You 3000+我想(from 歌手當打之年) I think these songs are showing the real her and that why I love her so much❤

[@haydenpak6355]

阿楚姑娘❤❤❤

[@xuansvlog]

any more A-Lin reaction videos?

[@jiachenyu5698]

同好同好 😊

[@星星-v4k]

推阿楚姑娘

[@tianlouis8793]

真的是tia的巅峰

[@aaaa0939688811]

tia太棒了👏🌟👏🌟🌟

[@tedchen191]

很期待老師如果有評價Tia的另一個舞台 翻唱莫文蔚的愛!! 這兩首是我最喜歡Tia的兩個表演

[@holohulolo]

Before Tia was under your radar, I've been suggesting her videos. You guys even did a comparison of multiple artists singing the song "爱" but missed her cover. She's a really good singer, and if she weren't going for that rnb and soul route, shell probably be even more successful. I wish you guys would get a pole or survey on which song to react and get people to vote them.

[@李奥-v6o]

也是这首歌路转粉，听到有直击灵魂的感觉，一直在好奇为何没说到这首歌，说到了。

[@trcgodllo]

Recommend 【LIVE映像】Aishite Aishite Aishite 愛して愛して愛して PEACOCK THEATER Los Angeles, CA 2024.3.29【Ado】

[@danieltao7509]

哨音是Tia的招牌沒錯啊，張靚穎的“海豚音”大部分時間是頭聲

[@振祥薛]

只能说之前是招牌，但是tia自从上次严重倒嗓之后，为了稳妥，tia彻底放弃了哨音改练混强了吧

[@athomenotavailable]

When Tia's Golden?

[@EvanDelilan]

恳请老师看一下Tia的 ：存，不存在！！！！ 期待！！！

[@yuanlv4493]

蒙娜丽莎是让Tia得到关注的第一个翻唱，请老师听一下

[@Thomas-freedom]

希望老师可以评一下李安的逝去的爱

[@ponneyma4163]

这个片子里有袁娅维在台湾录音棚唱这首歌的live。kzbin.info/www/bejne/fIDXamyjibZneZIsi=W-Ib_WZ7MAqERNHo

[@leohuang5991]

想看老师评论Tia的Golden！！

[@yiutowai6063]

老師應該要看JJ演唱會，請周深做嘉賓個集

[@ashsh222]

推一下 芒果的樂在其中 聚集各地的民族音樂 覺得比歌手2024的歌精彩太多 私心推薦alexia evellyn🙋🏾‍♂️

[@masterran248]

Please react to Gigi cover of She's Gone on a Wish date Obscure concert

[@RyanEstrada-q3q]

Hi coach please react to Katrina Velarde WHITNEY HOUSTON MEDLEY (MusicHall Metrowalk2018) And try also react of cover "SOMEWHERE OVER THE RAIN" at music hall metrowalk... thanks and more power to you!!!

[@BadassMasonMa]

the only only only problem i have with Rozette is her timing of pausing, and sometimes would miss the good spots

[@腻儿]

老师还没听过张韶涵吗

[@raytseng4986]

想請問老師對一些名詞的看法，很常看到super head voice, whistle note, whistle register, falsetto…通常在歌手用出這些技巧，底下就會有人說他是用A不是B，搞得我很亂，希望能幫忙解答，感謝

[@BadassMasonMa]

can you do a Jackie Chan singing reaction?

[@etoe1813]

Please react angela chang (singer 2018)

[@trcgodllo]

許願老師講評澤野弘之製作的進擊的巨人經典神組曲 , Hiroyuki Sawano / Project【emU】 “Attack on Titan” suite

[@hhui81]

什麼時候才有徐佳瑩

[@Simon-bu7ld]

老師什麼時候要review李佳薇的煎熬？已經等了好幾個月...

[@bigchief1210]

其實有 有一集jj 參加李演唱會當嘉賓 翻車那集

[@Simon-bu7ld]

@@bigchief1210 不是那一集，之前死了都要愛那集後面有預告李佳薇在歌手唱的煎熬

[@FullmoonArc]

也可以Re 齐豫 费玉清 蔡琴😂

[@lisalin4511]

这个字幕不是Jkai做的吧？好像有的地方翻译不对哦，比如2:10 compliment译成抱怨😂

[@hendroheng9336]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/jaLOpZ99lLmIpZI kzbin.info/www/bejne/pYbUd3utq9eXsJI kzbin.info/www/bejne/fIOZgWqIrMmJfLc Are the above imitation videos funny, everyone?

[@andyxi5360]

非常牛逼的翻唱，我一直存在歌单里

[@andyxi5360]

蝙蝠侠的歌曲融在里面毫不违和

[@jiachenyu5698]

我也是 听一次震撼一次

[@ruoshulian4343]

Compliment 字幕翻译错了

[@Clementine-q1i]

徐佳瑩 不痛 🙏

[@jiachenyu5698]

能不能再评一下alin的爱上你等于爱上寂寞 在我心里可以pk这首

[@jiachenyu5698]

A-lin’s many performances really showed her stability. her ability to control sound and taste fascinated me！and now she got variety of styles and still good at convey feelings through voice. she is an one-take singer.In her concert，her beautiful voice is just like cd quality .

[@Estrelaxxx]

🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉 please please please review her performances in Singer 2020 (当打之年) too!!! You will love her more! She was more relaxed in Singer 2020. BUT her performances in this season of Singer were also great! Thank you for revisiting her performance again! She will supervise you more ❤

[@冷眼观潮]

应该反应一下郭顶的《水星记》《凄美地》