國外聲樂老師點評 周深 騰格爾《大魚的天堂》Vocal Coach Reaction to Charlie Zhou Shen x Tengri「Big Fish's Paradise」

[@SYTCgogo]

Let's the real show ,❤What u see and what u hear from.....

[@jolu7297]

老師請繼續保持您真誠的評論，那樣的評論才是有鮮活生命的。透過您的評論也讓我更懂得歌手唱的出彩的技術和用心及努力，進而更加懂的欣賞，謝謝老師！ 缺的是您這樣真誠而專業的點評，不被外力干擾。很享受和您聽一首歌的時光，謝謝您!

[@Audrey0428tube]

節省我的打字時間，完全同意。 Just be yourself, do whatever you feel like doing and suit your heart.

[@liijwutyng]

非常認同

[@kimkit7014]

＋1

[@tyenh4191]

+1

[@深雪-r4d]

認同,而且老師的點評很具建設性,表達方式又很令人舒服

[@李幸枝-v8w]

最欣賞的就是杰諾老師真誠的分析，這是我一直關注這個平台的原因，誰要去看假惺惺的追捧。而且深信周深長此以來堅持真唱，這可以從一些與他合作過的老師、工作夥伴的視頻證實，他連拍MV都是不厭其煩的一遍遍唱從不偷懶。❤❤❤❤

[@Truth2011sg]

Most important now is when will be the next ZS's reaction? The platform is lifted alived whenever ZS's performance is reacted. Thank you for your reaction, Coach Rozette.

[@cchhiinn929]

去年央視中秋户外錄製，周深穿白色西裝外套，頂高溫配合舞團，唱了九遍I see us，他每次的彩排也都是真槍實彈，即便發燒、生病上場也是盡全力真實演出，我就是愛他這種對舞台認真的態度。

[@Alex.chen_m]

老师，请你继续保持你的坦白和真诚，这才是你频道的真正价值所在，我非常爱看，不论是好的评价或者是揭穿一些现代工业的包装。我们需要真相，一个内行人的指引，谢谢老师

[@samadhi408]

+1

[@kimkit7014]

老师的解说对我们这些行外人来说是一件好事。

[@tyenh4191]

+1

[@yunjaone]

真實是老師以及這個頻道最重要的品質之一，請繼續保持~~

[@jn3t454]

请老师保持真诚和真实的自己😊当初喜欢老师是因为老师的专业点评，就算是真正的歌手也会喜欢听见他们的能力去到哪里...而不是粉丝们的捧杀，只要听他们爱听的...这是在扼杀自己喜欢的歌手。

[@jp.yan0126]

我在b站看完過來的，評論也在那裡發過，但感覺這裡比較容易被看到所以再發一次： 實話實說，保持禮貌的情況下keep real keep honest 就好了，這是老師的特色啊，說實話我看了很多周深的reaction視頻，很多都是說好聽好厲害，卻沒有說哪裡厲害，老師是我看過那麼多影片里，僅有會說這些的，個人認為是老師的特色。倘若為了那小部分 見不得人說一點不好的人無理取鬧，便是隨波逐流不夠真實。既然是好歌手，個人更希望能瞭解到他運用的技巧，後期做了什麼變化，他有什麼微瑕可以精進的，他有什麼巧思花了心血的，這樣無論對粉絲和歌手都是好的，老師加油！ PS：B站彈幕真的很精彩很吸引，建議有空看看

[@HUIBINTAN-d1n]

be honest, be yourself... appreciate and love your sharing..

[@lilychen7580]

這個世界需要真實的聲音及真相，請繼續真誠的專業分享，謝謝您。❤🎉

[@sweejunechai4791]

＋1

[@emmalay100]

完全支持老師的"想要"，我喜歡坦誠真誠自然，所以我才會這麼喜歡周深！

[@小白熊-v8q]

我希望老師能說自己想說的話，對我來說真實的點評才是我期望看到的。

[@美華-k2e]

請Rozette老師繼續真實，暢所欲言，沒水準的留言請直接刪除拉黑，其他點評節目我只看周深，這是我唯一每個點評都看的節目，因為我真的太喜歡❤❤❤Rozette老師的專業點評跟歌聲

[@TheMeowmeowlee]

Please continue being honest with what you see! I really enjoy your genuine and professional comments!

[@maychan298]

现在我祗听周深!他已超越一般歌手的能力和技巧!懂声乐的一听就惊艳!这根本不是一般人能唱到的！🥰💙💙👍👍👍

[@ringowong1439]

老師請妳務必保持現有的風格，我們看妳的點評視頻，就是欣賞妳夠專業、夠客觀、夠真誠，請不要理會這些麻木崇拜不懂客觀的歌迷或粉絲們，他們這樣做只會害了他們喜歡的偶像。 懇請老師保持初心，繼續做妳的專業點評，我相信有很多很多很多人與我同樣想法的。🙏❤❤❤

[@emmaus7498]

Yes absolutely to be yourself, say what you want and enjoy to do. You are a true professional, you have all my respect. Be frank and honest.

[@penciltip8853]

We all know magic shows aren’t real and still enjoy them. The same for these music industry tricks. We have the right to know the truth so as to enjoy the music. Otherwise we’re just cheated. Thank you Rozettee, say whatever you want to say in the reactions and we love it.

[@peichifan9190]

其實我還挺喜歡老師說出關於行業中所使用的一些 “工具”，毕竟对于一般观众确实不了解，很感激老师的真诚以及專業，希望能繼續保持，就像老師說的，不論預錄或是修音，在現在這個時代屬於正常，並不表示歌手本身沒有能力現場演唱，更多時候可能是為求完美。

[@spark-vison1801]

说得好，特别是最后一句，正是我想说的。虽然使用这些“工具”但并不能抹杀歌手的的能力和努力。现场演出会有很多状况，有时可能导致歌手违背自己意愿被迫使用“工具”

[@TSENG666]

欣賞老師不吹不黑真實評點，請老師做自己，以自己自在、喜歡的方式，及專業的學識、學術；敏銳的眼睛、耳朵、音感、直覺繼續講評👍 老師專業的領域，無庸置疑👍💯⬆️🔼🔺 超❤老師講評方式生動自然獨樹一格👍，老師的個性超可愛的😉😌🙂 支持老師以自己的方式繼續評點👍 簽到影片下方給你們點個讚👍 遇廣告看完看🈵支持

[@helenwong8973]

還可以付費支持 That’s what I have done to their channel.

[@wu4240]

希望老師 暢所欲言！❤❤❤❤

[@continentzero7572]

As an anti-fan, I prefer honesty and frankness. I am 100% in favor of revelation that Santa doesn't exist. So, speak freely. And, of course, I really liked your reaction to this mix of theme songs between Tengger (60 years old) and our young Shenshen.

[@hyang802]

首先，当然希望听到真实的声音。所以只要对老师没有不好的影响，希望她继续保持现在的坦诚风格，而不是假装没有听出来（从老师发言里可以推测，一些粉丝评论显然困扰到你们了）。 其次，已经好几次听到老师谈到转音了，想听她评论周深在时光音乐会上演唱的胡彦斌作品《月光》。这首说是有超多转音，极为难唱。我不懂，但是个人非常喜欢这首歌，也喜欢周深的演绎。

[@dorishuang7813]

請繼續您們的真實～ 😊

[@wongman4585]

周深.... 實在太多好歌，數之不盡😂

[@草莓吐司]

喜歡老師的真實，這是期待這個reaction的核心價值所在。 請繼續保持初心不被外界干擾，期待每一次的更新。😊❤

[@stephenkong8552]

YES!! Please keep on telling the truth and give professional comment

[@nataliechang]

期待老師在929一起聽深深的寵粉演唱會

[@hkvintak]

Please keep your honest of your opinion. I really support and respect your opinion.

[@yjw3851]

有人喜欢就会有人不喜欢 希望老师保持真实 想说什么 就说什么 不需要为了酸民做出什么改变 不喜欢就别看 我也相信喜欢老师真实点评的人更多

[@CSB-pu9mc]

Yes, pls be honest with your observations. Many are watching your channel because you are real and to the point. 🙂I personally enjoy every review you gave.

[@peggypao6705]

當初這個舞台演出我很喜歡，可以欣賞倆個歌手以不同聲線演譯兩首名曲，給人耳目一新的感受！ 老師的 reaction style 是絕大多數人愛看的，因爲專業、真實！做為海米，我們是有底氣的，這底氣是來自於對周深的了解！

[@msmshappy1180]

Awesome Awesome Zhou Shen Amazing amazing as always ❤️ ♥️ 💖 😍 💕 💙 ❤️ ♥️ 💖 😍 💕 💙 ❤️ ♥️ 💖 😍 💕 with Teacher Tengir ❤️ 💙

[@chongkm8941]

Appreciate your honest comment. Please keep on.

[@homepeace]

The more honest the better. Its why I like u.

[@bluem3zs]

周深珍惜每一次舞台演唱，要求自己極高，不對嘴型

[@qyrmq9642]

11:54 的尾音，话筒拿开了依然有尾音，感觉两个都是假唱，不过像老师说的，不是什么大问题

[@莞吟]

@@qyrmq9642造謠張嘴就來啊？那是拉麥+聲音延遲效果，周深唱高音的聲壓和氣息之強大眾所皆知，還有這場就是周深真唱+騰格爾假唱，up質疑的只有騰格爾那部分，為什麼？因為有周深的真唱作對比所以變得極明顯！ 下場預告周深《燈火裡的中國》在北京國家大劇院音樂廳～配制交響樂團+85人大合唱團+無修音無擴音設備，目前市面上唱流行樂的歌手沒有幾個有能力有資格能像他這樣唱，他是受過專業美聲訓練的學院派歌手，別用你那井蛙的見識來看他，互聯網也不是讓你丟臉的地方！

[@金艾莉絲]

@@莞吟 😂😂好好溝通~好好說即可!別激動!!至少深深是各專業人都在稱讚的优秀歌唱家~這己是不爭的事實!👍

[@莞吟]

@@金艾莉絲 對一個勤勤懇懇好好唱歌的歌手隨口造謠的我為何要好好說啥？你怎不去跟那個隨口造鬼謠的讓他好好說人話？

[@金艾莉絲]

@@莞吟 所以你喜欢用別人的錯懲罰自己?氣pu pu対你有比較好嗎?深深應該更喜欢粉絲理性些~喜欢他就别过激言論為他招黒不是嗎?我們喜欢他的勤懇、謙虚、貼心、和善~為他打拚努力感動~為他天籟的聲線、天使般的吟唱、神仙般的歌唱技巧所征服~他的粉絲就是被他一個又-個的舞台唱出来的不是吗？

[@ft4352]

喜歡老師真誠用你專業講解周深的歌曲，我對他的演唱有信心，其實他要求很高，都希望有人可評價他的歌藝，老師是適合的人選😊

[@kellylian8236]

Pls keep being frank & honest! That's the reason why i love watching your review.

[@凱議-u8m]

老師想聽聽歌手真實的現場演唱 如同我也想聽老師的真實評論一樣 老師評論拿捏得宜，保持初心 一同開心的享用歌手們的演唱

[@liijwutyng]

+1

[@阿芙-f7p]

超期待下期的深深❤❤

[@jimmyzhang4095]

真实和客观的评价，喜欢！超级喜欢！！！世间本无完美，真实的，可能就是完美的一种。

[@thou168]

老師，他們二個在互唱彼此的成名曲，騰格爾老師用他慣用的唱法詮釋周深的這首大魚，之前周深很皮常常模仿藤老師的唱腔，這首曲子是周深跟一個大前輩老師的合作，非常的特別！又很有意思，就像老師說的是一個非常好看的舞台表演！

[@xuecalvin284]

Of course we can have different ideas, but only when the truth can become the basis of communication, and there is room for each other to make mistakes, it is an interesting place to comment or discuss. Keep on, teacher Rozette!

[@joeyzhao3925]

老师对周深是真爱😂

[@Jasperhsiao]

我希望老師可以繼續想到什麼說什麼，真實的評論才是最好看的❤ 但其實也不必問觀眾們意見啦，做自己開心的事最重要了！

[@amazingtnshmwu2982]

100%being honest is the soul of music and singing🎉❤ Please be what you are and continue to react to more zhou shen’s performances🙏👍🥰😍😘

[@cherylkwan6317]

謝謝老師的精準真誠點評!

[@michaelxu7026]

I watch your professional comments because your honesty, keep your honesty it’s priceless ❤

[@georgechrome4735]

Love your honesty, please continue, you are doing a great job... Don't gloss it over!!! I understand your hesitation, but can't avoid it, some fans can't accept objective comments.. I continue to watch your clip because you are honest and give professional coaching, not just talking for 15 mins or so but is going nowhere...

[@李幸枝-v8w]

終於又等到周深的Reaction了❤❤❤❤❤滿心期待😊😊😊

[@wongman4585]

等了很久，才到今天 聽深寶 的歌，下期 不知 又要等多久😂

[@CP-go3oj]

Yes! We need honesty.

[@洪于絜-e6q]

老師，做自己就好❤

[@haohao-kb8ze]

Just do what you want. and talk what you want. That's why we like you and your reaction.

[@o0jay0o]

老師的真城是我最喜愛的 希望可一路保持初心 永遠不變 點評的人有太多 但能像你說實話的絕無僅有

[@aslanz4188]

Honesty, yes, yes, yes, is what we need and details and That's the point, madam

[@ching19800]

Being real is a great virtue, please keep it that way. Solute!

[@kkwong1215]

真實的評論才是這個頻道寶貴的地方，請老師繼續保持❤ 另外，終於等到周深的燈火裏的中國排上了，讚！❤😊

[@善-o1k7r]

當然實話實說了(從專業性看)😇如果為了某些粉絲喜好說假話🙄那這種點評節目就不需要看了😎

[@liijwutyng]

+1

[@kennethgan78]

Like no.888, yes please follow your heart on your content.

[@ceceliakrieg5824]

We love it, Roxette. Just keep doing what you are doing..... and keep loving Zhou Shen, that special little person with the special voice.

[@maioyulujiawu6285]

老师厉害啊，请继续你的真诚。

[@swen1216]

非常喜歡周深，真誠又誠懇的個性深深吸引我！ 會追老師的視頻，是因為老師評論深深，超級吸引我！（而且全部都「追」完了！） 也喜歡老師的真誠和誠懇，有什麼就說什麼，真的很好！（跟深深一樣） 對於我這個音樂大外行，經由老師的講評，才能一窺究竟，深深的技術到底好在什麼地方！ （第一次聽深深的歌，很不協調，但又說不出來那裡怪怪的！聲音美，唱的也好，太吸引我了！（男生唱出這種歌聲，是自己少見多怪，我是這樣認知的。）結果老師在周深的初體驗那集視頻中，完完全全是我的「臉替」，老師把我的感覺都表達出來了！ 在講評「灣」的那首歌，說深深有兩個地方跑調了，真是太強了，因為有另外一個視頻用機器測，有四個音不準！看的我哈哈大笑！更喜歡老師說，因為這樣才是「人性」） 老師講評深深的視頻，我是可以重複看的，有時翻到，又再看一遍！ 最後想說，謝謝老師珍貴的意見，（深深如果看到，他應該也會開心；獨孤求敗其實心裡不好過，已經天下無敵手了，多寂寞）無論妳要怎麼評論，如何評論，我都是抱持吸收的態度，因為我真的不懂！ 看到上次某個深深視頻下面，吵成一團，因為有人認為深深的視頻太多；我只關注自家，我也不會跑到別家去講這種話；如同深深說的，不喜歡的，就划過去！ 做一個視頻不容易，無論是做那個歌手都應該尊重視頻主的言論自由！

[@raineylee1317]

Thank you for being honest and also objective. Thanks for being real ❤

[@dadamuimuiable]

Looking forward to see more ZhouShan's reaction❤ No type of song he can't carry so far. He graduated from Lviv State Conservatory of Music, Ukraine Countertenor.

[@laulau7203]

您說錯了他的名字，他是周深！在大學跟老師學習的是男高音，假聲男高音是因為喜歡而自學的。您可以關注另一檔音綜聲入人心中和廖昌永老師的對話。

[@莞吟]

他專業是美聲男高音！不要搞錯了！

[@Fang_0608]

喜歡的就是您真實的分析，作為粉絲也非常能夠接受瑕疵，正因為不是機器，唱得多好多差其實都心知肚明，很多的反應視頻也只會說多好聽，而有專業評論卻很稀少，所以請繼續保持最真誠的點評，非常感謝老師帶來不同的觀點，提供我們欣賞。

[@bearbear8529]

Zhou shen 😘😘😘👏👏👏

[@李湘儒-w5d]

保持就好~加油

[@weijayfan4413]

Teacher, your comments are very true and let me learn a lot of things that I don’t understand

[@auntiegangmi5508]

Appreciate the sensitivity expressed so well by Rosette. I watched this channel mainly for her professionalism but also for her honesty and openness. I learned so much from watching this channel. Please try to speak what you really heard and saw.

[@brandonapple942]

The way you paused before you want to comment something that you think the audience or fans might not like to hear, and yet you still stick with the honest opinion but try not to hurt anyone's feelings, that's beautiful, and we appreciate that, so please stick with what you've been doing so far, we love you.

[@benwong2246]

Im your follower from hk Charie Chow is my favorite singer His. BLOODY LOVE STORY is good If teacher have opportunity to reacted i will so 😊appreciate

[@chiangbernard2888]

Stay honest, amazing channel

[@johnniewalkers]

Follow your heart ❤ 我們懂妳就夠了😊

[@mattakubodimasen10]

The teacher explained really well her thoughts and feelings! I don't think anyone could misunderstand her viewpoint after such a well-put speech unless they have no intention to see things objectively. For me, the charm in the teacher's reaction videos isn't only in her professional capabilities in showing us the vocal skills and techniques we don't know, but also the sincerity and frankness! I think we can enjoy things at a higher level as we gain more knowledge about it. So it's extremely enjoying for me personally, as someone who doesn't have experiences in music, to have the teacher point out more of the beauties that my unprofessional ears missed. I think the subject of editing in live stages should be an equally important thing for normal people like myself to learn as well. At least the basics of how to recognise the most common editing should be something more people have. It would pose a great injustice for singers who have worked hard to train their vocals if those with lesser skills can perform just as well thanks to the power of technology. Moreover, if singers rely on post editing too much, the overall quality of the industry will undoubtedly starts to fall, which is something that can be witnessed more and more nowadays. I hope the teachers wouldn't have to shy away from the topic because of any dispute. Please have no worries that the general public can hold their own rational judgements! There are many audio editors in china who makes professional videos specifically on whether a stage was editted or not. They were undoubtedly faced with dissatisfaction from certain fans, but rational and sensible people can trust professionals to know what they are doing and judge things objectively. Should the teachers encounter too much negativity, perhaps bypassing stages that might be more controversial and avoiding the larger disputes could be an option. After all, this channel is very precious!! The teachers are very precious!! Thank you for your work!!!

[@helenwong8973]

So nice to have lovely Rozette let us know what techniques Zhou Shen has used to build up his singing so beautifully that is completely out of my knowledge as I am not in music profession. Dear Coach Rozette is really amazing and versatile, definitely the most outstanding and unique among all other reactions to Zhou Shen’s performances. Thanks Coach Rozette.

[@fiona108fox]

我喜歡這樣真實賞析的老師，也許一開始是真的不太習慣，但是看了幾部就喜歡上老師的真誠以及感受到老師對音樂的熱愛。不希望因為一些不開心的事情讓老師失去當初分享這些影片的初衷，不論老師作何決定只希望您能繼續快樂的愛音樂❤

[@cdanny5060]

Yes, we need your honest, and we need that too, we will still respect those singer after your professional comments. Thank you!

[@huichen3561]

Nice to know that, thanks very good

[@mariatachi8398]

Please continue to comment with honest review. I find your review are genuine. We cannot please everyone in this world as it was indeed speaking the fact.

[@Rosie-vy4nl]

As a person who has no background in music, I love hearing about the different techniques that you point out. I also find the stuff about the production/post production interesting. It's amazing to me that you can tell when the sounds have been edited!

[@boboyue8976]

我爱老师真实的评论❤

[@msmshappy1180]

Thank you so much for this 💖 💗 💓 ❤️ Just listen to your Heart.. Say what you honestly and sincerely feel!

[@lulumtl7783]

Yes, please keep frank and honest. This is one of the main reason I like your reviewing channel. this world is missing honesty and sincerity now. So please keep your genuine opinion 🙏👍

[@rachelduan8642]

please please just be yourself. I have been feeling reaction vedios boring until i saw this channel. Your comments are real, nutral and also informative. Can't wait to see more of them!

[@emilychung9216]

All of your reactions so far so good. Just do what you feel is good😊

[@teresalau86]

One thing for sure Zhou Shen always insisting to sings live every single performance 👍

[@yickwachung8930]

Just commence what you hear and what you see , to be honest to youself , keep going teacher !

[@sxyline4807]

Great review, truly appreciated your observation and honest opinions! Keep it up and be yourself to say what it is!

[@lincristian8090]

hi miss Rosette please just keep your honest , real review as usual ,that is your difference from otheres reviewers , and please do review MY ONLY song from Zhou Shen i am sure you will love it

[@maggiec8193]

Your sharp ear and honesty are the most attractive parts to me. You bring a lot of value to this channel's audience. Be your self. We love you.

[@tsai2217]

Love Zhou Shen ❤❤❤❤❤

[@irwinng9665]

you do very well ,that's why we love to watch on you ❤❤❤💪💪💪

[@mannie692002]

+ 1 Thailand

[@Lisa-leeks73]

老师点评很真挚，请老师继续做点评的job ❤

[@aliceli110]

I have watched all your reviews on KZbin and never once left a message. But since Rozette wants to what the audience want to hear, here is one vote for, I really enjoy your honest responses and reactions, continue to be true to yourself is my vote.

[@pearbear8]

Please respond to what you and hear , stay honest and comment from your heart ❤️ , that’s why I like your reactions videos. Thanks

[@陸風雲]

真实就好

[@homeycow1628]

@Rozette - Pls continue with your honest reviews on the vocals, staging, all you hear and see in the videos! Totally enjoy your reaction videos😘

[@Raystonebox515]

Keep going for your reality; showing us the secret of magic

[@貞胡-k6x]

I sincerely hope teacher Rossetti will and be willing to react ZS more. ZS, for me, is credit and trust ; and most of all, always nice to be listening to; I just hope to listen to true feelings.

[@irischan1110]

Be true! Be yourself! That’s the reason why I am here! Continue with your good work!

[@熊比]

老師只要保持自己想說什麼就說什麼就好不需要在意跟考慮這麼多，人生已經很難了，為何不能講自己想講的呢？我喜歡老師你的真誠❤繼續加油！

[@taoyang3244]

please continue to be real..that is why i follow you. I have seen many reactions，your reaction is the best. There.are many crazy fans. Please ighore them. I really like you🎉🎉🎉